This article compares three-dimensional alterations following the use of autogenous versus allogeneic onlay grafts for augmentation at single tooth sites. Autogenous bone grafts from the chin or ramus were compared to freeze-dried allogeneic bone grafts. Cone beam computed tomography scans were used to evaluate changes in graft and defect volumes at 6 months. Both graft types resulted in significant bone fill, with autogenous grafts showing slightly more volume gain. Allogeneic grafts require less surgery time and morbidity compared to autogenous grafts.