Die Deutschen im
amerikanischen Bürgerkriege
als Gettysburg
Stephen T. Frezza
Electrical & Computer Engr
Gannon University
frezza@gannon.edu
ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 1
Sezessionskrieg 1861-1865
The Story of Germans in
The War...
The Story of The War
– 216,000 German-born
Union Soldiers
– Nearly every Union Army
Corps
– Every Major Campaign &
Battle
Pvt. Alexander Zang, c. 1862

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 2
German Americans in ACW
• Most marked events in the history of
German-Americans
• Loyal to the Union
• Virtually no German...
– promoters of succession
– slaveholders

• Provided significantly more volunteers than
other ethnic groups
– double the rate of other groups

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 3
German-Born Americans
10% of Union Army:
– 2,150,000 Union Soldiers (White)
– 216,000 German-born (vs. 144,000 Irish)
~ 300,000 American-born
~ 250,000 ‘Old Germans’

High volunteer rate:
Northern population of 1.6 million (1860-64)
~ 72,000 in rebellious states
ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 5
German Enlistees
• Considered / emigrated from
then-nations of:
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–

Denmark
Austria
Switzerland
Belgium
Luxembourg
Alsace
Holland
Canada

ECWR

Pvt. Conrad Holtzhaur
Co A 2nd MI Inf
DOW Malvern Hill

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 6
14%
20%
9.2%
8.4%
6.5%

7.7%

6.3%
11%

36%

6.2%

12%
6.2%

Where they Enlisted
ECWR

Gannon
German Regiments
• New York:
7th Steuben Rifles
von Schack
9.2%
8th
Blenker, Stahel, Wutschel
20th Turner Regiment Webber
37,000
th
29 Astor Rifles
von Steinwehr
41st DeKalb Regiment von Gilsa
45th
von Amsberg
46th
von Rosa, Gerhard
52nd Sigel Rifles
Freudenberg
54th
Gellmann
103rd von Egloffstein, Ringgold, Heine
4th Cav
Dickel
Numerous batteries
Schirmer, Dilger, Wiedrich, Sturmfels...

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 10
German Regiments
• Pennsylvania:
–
–
–
–

6.3%

• Ohio
–
–
–
–
–

27th Infantry
73rd Infantry
74th Infantry
75th Infantry

• New Jersey
– 3rd Cavalry
12%
– A, 1st NJ Light Artillery

ECWR

7.7%

9th (Turner) Infantry
28th Infantry
37th Infantry
107th Infantry
3rd Cavalry

• Wisconsin

Gannon

–
–
–
–

9th Infantry
26th Infantry
45th Infantry
2nd Artillery

20%

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 11
German Regiments
• Missouri:
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–

• Illinois

1 Infantry
36%
2nd Infantry
3rd Infantry
4th Infantry
5th Infantry
12th Infantry
15th Infantry (Swiss)
17th Infantry (Turner)

ECWR

– 43 Infantry
– 82nd Infantry

st

rd

8.4%

• Indiana

Gannon

– 32nd Infantry

4.6%

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 12
Half-German Regiments
• New York: 39th, 58th, 68th, 119th
• Pennsylvania: 4th, 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 14th, 15th, 16th, 48th,
50th, 51st, 56th, 65th, 79th, 88th, 96th, 98th

• Ohio: 7th, 47th, 58th, 74th, 106th, 108th, 165th, 20th Battery
• Missouri: 1st,39th, 40th, 41st, 4th Cav
• Illinois: 9th, 24th, 27th, 36th, 44th, 45th, 57th, 58th, 13th Cav,
16th Cav

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 13
Half-German Regiments
• Indiana: 24th, 136th
• Minnesota: 1st, 2nd, 4th, 6th,
• Texas: 1st (Loyal)
• Kansas: 1st, 2nd
• Nebraska: 1st Cav
• Kentucky: 5th, 6th, 2nd Cav
• Maryland: 5th

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 14
Why they enlisted
• Strongly influenced by the ideals of the
1848 revolution
Union
• Value and importance of Republican
Ideals
Slavery
“All für Lincoln und Sie Freiheit”

• Freedom
ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 15
Camp Jackson

1st Bull Run

Wilson’s Creek
Pea Ridge

Franz Sigel

The War - 1861
ECWR

Gannon
Early Blows
• May: Saving St. Louis
–
–

German Loyalist rush to flag
Armory Held, Camp Jackson taken

• July: 1st Bull Run
– Blenker’s German Division
• held in reserve
• mistaken For U.S. Regulars

• Wilson’s Creek
• Pea Ridge
ECWR

Gannon

Louis Blenker
©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 17
South-West Texas:
Little Germany

• 1/5 of all whites - over 22,000 German-born
• Pro-Union, anti-slave, German-speaking
communities
• February - Twiggs surrenders, Commanches attack
• August - Banishment Law, Law of Confiscation
– Moved, or Pro-Union property confiscated

Four years of Murder, Man-hunts, Imprisonments,
Lynching

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 18
Antietam
Bull Run
Cross Keys
Fredricksburg
Seven Days
Henry & Donelson
August Willich

Stones River
Shiloh
Corinth

The War - 1862
ECWR

Gannon
Gettysburg

Peter Osterhaus

Chancellorsville

Chattanooga

Chickamauga

Vicksburg

The War - 1863
ECWR

Gannon
The Turning Points
West

•
•
•
•

East

Vicksburg
Tullahoma
Chickamauga
Chattanooga

•
•
•
•

Chancellorsville
Brandy Station
Gettysburg
Mine Run

Chancellorsville
Carl Schurz
ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 22
From Chancellorsville to
Gettysburg
Oliver O. Howard
Unjustified Criticism
• Disliked 11th Corps
• “Measureless Abuse”
Commander
• Coverup of German
• New commanders (e.g.,
heroics
Barlow in 3rd Division) • Marched north to shed
• Questionable
their dishonorable
assignments of Smith &
reputation.
Coster as Brigade
Commanders

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 23
The First Day
•
•
•
•
•

ECWR

July 1, 1863: 9:30 AM
St. Joseph’s College, Emmitsburg Maryland
Buford’s Cavalry & 1st Corps stop Heth
Reynolds (wing commander) Killed
10:45 AM: Howard takes Army Command, Schurz
11th Corps
2:30 PM: Schurz ordered to take 5,100 Men of 1st &
3rd Division north to protect 1st Corp’s flank
3:00 PM: 5,600 men of Early’s and Rodes’ divisions
concentrate on Union right

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 24
Threats to the Union Right
Schurz’s Intent:

so
’d
seR
s
iiv
o
niD

s’s
no edoR
i si
vD
i

’s
rly n
Ea isio
Di v

ts
s pr o C
1

&h e H
t
w r g tt e P
e i

ECWR

Gannon

Barlow

Devin’s
Devin’s
Cavalry
Cavalry

Schimmelfenning

To
Gettysburg
&
©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 25
Cemetery Hill
2:45 PM: July 1st

Barlow & Schimmelfennig Deploy

s’s
no s edo R
ii
v
iD

so
’d
seR
s
iiv
o
niD

107 OH
68th NY
4th US

74 PA
th

Batt. G

von Gilsa

61st OH

75th OH
1st OH 13th NY

45th NY
157th NY

Dilger

25th OH

th

Light

68th NY
’s
rly n
Ea isio
153rd PA iv
D
54th NY

17th CON

Ames

Barlow

82nd ILL

von Amsberg
ECWR

Schimmelfennig
Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 26
3:15 PM

Barlow Falls on
Blocher Knoll

Hays

Doles

(Early)

(Rodes)

25 OH
th

107th OH
4th US

74 PA

Batt. G

von Gilsa

61st OH

75th OH
1st OH 13th NY

45th NY
157th NY

Dilger

(Early)

68th NY

68th NY
th

Gordon

153rd PA

17th CON

54th NY

Ames

Barlow

Light

82nd ILL

von Amsberg
Krzyzanowski
ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 27
3:30-4PM: Forlorn Hopes

Krzyanowski’s Brigade
157th New York
Doles
(Rodes)

Hays
(Early)

1st OH 13th NYKrzyzanowski
45 NY
th

157th NY

Dilger

Gordon
(Early)

Light

Avery
(Early)

3rd Division

82nd ILL

von Gilsa

von Amsberg
ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 28
Germans on
The First Day
• Ordered into an impossible situation
• Position untenable from the start (Barlow’s
deployment)
• Fought bravely until overwhelmed
• Horrendous Casualties
– Krzyzanowski’s Brigade – every regiment engaged took
over 50% casualties
– 127th New York collapsed after taking 75% casualties

• 82nd Illinois – last out of Gettysburg
• Posted to defend North- and East Cemetery Hill

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 29
Sunset: 2nd July 1863

Cemetery Ridge

Wilcox

1st MN

Barksdale

21st Miss

126th NY
111th NY
125th NY
39th NY
Watson’s
Weikert’s
Woods

ECWR

d
f f or
Wo

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 30
Bias Against Germans
The Second Day’s Record
• 1st Minnesota loses 170 of 250 engaged
– Staves the advance of 1000 rebels

• Fassitt asks Hildebrand to advance
– Gets Medal of Honor for initiative

• 39th New York retakes Watson’s Battery
– 75+ Casualties (25%) in 15 Minutes
– Never recognized for recapturing four guns

• 21st Mississippi retreats, gives up guns
– claim they exchanged only “long range” volleys
ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 31
Hoke

Dusk: 2nd July 1863
6

th

NC

21st NC 57 th N
C

East Cemetery Hill
Hays

w
yto

Ba
l t im
ore

Pik

e

33 rd

d
nR

ECWR

Culp’s
Hill

M
ass

s

Ri
ck
et t

ne
Ta

W

ie d
r ic

h

7
10

OH

ro
ll

th

15
3r
68 th d PA
54 th NY
41 st NY
NY
Ca
r

Br
i ck
La yard
ne

25 th
O
Kr SchuH
75 th y
r
17 th O zana tz &
Co H ows
nn
ki

Du Sollst est…!

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 32
Gettysburg
German Participation

• Significant
– 1st Day – North of
Gettysburg
– 1st Day – On Cemetery
Hill
– 2nd Day – East Cemetery
Hill

Wadsworth Knoll

– Overlooking East
Cemetery Hill

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 33
Wilderness
Spottsylvania
Petersburg
Nashville
Kennesaw

March to the Sea
Atlanta

The War - 1864
ECWR

Gannon
The Long Year
West

East

•
•
•
•

Reseca
Kennesaw Mountain
Atlanta
March to the Sea

•
•

Franklin
Nashville

ECWR

Gannon

•
•
•
•
•
•

Wilderness
Spottsylvania
Cold Harbor
Monocacy
Petersburg
Valley Campaign

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 35
1865: The End
South

East

• Goldsboro
• Bentonville

ECWR

•
•
•

Gannon

Petersburg
Saylors Creek
Appomatox

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 36
Summary
• Germans
–
–
–
–

Played a significant role
Helped train the Union Army
Received little recognition
Suffered for their Union Sentiments

ECWR

Gannon

©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 37

Germans at Gettysburg

  • 1.
    Die Deutschen im amerikanischenBürgerkriege als Gettysburg Stephen T. Frezza Electrical & Computer Engr Gannon University frezza@gannon.edu ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 1
  • 2.
    Sezessionskrieg 1861-1865 The Storyof Germans in The War... The Story of The War – 216,000 German-born Union Soldiers – Nearly every Union Army Corps – Every Major Campaign & Battle Pvt. Alexander Zang, c. 1862 ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 2
  • 3.
    German Americans inACW • Most marked events in the history of German-Americans • Loyal to the Union • Virtually no German... – promoters of succession – slaveholders • Provided significantly more volunteers than other ethnic groups – double the rate of other groups ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 3
  • 4.
    German-Born Americans 10% ofUnion Army: – 2,150,000 Union Soldiers (White) – 216,000 German-born (vs. 144,000 Irish) ~ 300,000 American-born ~ 250,000 ‘Old Germans’ High volunteer rate: Northern population of 1.6 million (1860-64) ~ 72,000 in rebellious states ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 5
  • 5.
    German Enlistees • Considered/ emigrated from then-nations of: – – – – – – – – Denmark Austria Switzerland Belgium Luxembourg Alsace Holland Canada ECWR Pvt. Conrad Holtzhaur Co A 2nd MI Inf DOW Malvern Hill Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 6
  • 6.
  • 7.
    German Regiments • NewYork: 7th Steuben Rifles von Schack 9.2% 8th Blenker, Stahel, Wutschel 20th Turner Regiment Webber 37,000 th 29 Astor Rifles von Steinwehr 41st DeKalb Regiment von Gilsa 45th von Amsberg 46th von Rosa, Gerhard 52nd Sigel Rifles Freudenberg 54th Gellmann 103rd von Egloffstein, Ringgold, Heine 4th Cav Dickel Numerous batteries Schirmer, Dilger, Wiedrich, Sturmfels... ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 10
  • 8.
    German Regiments • Pennsylvania: – – – – 6.3% •Ohio – – – – – 27th Infantry 73rd Infantry 74th Infantry 75th Infantry • New Jersey – 3rd Cavalry 12% – A, 1st NJ Light Artillery ECWR 7.7% 9th (Turner) Infantry 28th Infantry 37th Infantry 107th Infantry 3rd Cavalry • Wisconsin Gannon – – – – 9th Infantry 26th Infantry 45th Infantry 2nd Artillery 20% ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 11
  • 9.
    German Regiments • Missouri: – – – – – – – – •Illinois 1 Infantry 36% 2nd Infantry 3rd Infantry 4th Infantry 5th Infantry 12th Infantry 15th Infantry (Swiss) 17th Infantry (Turner) ECWR – 43 Infantry – 82nd Infantry st rd 8.4% • Indiana Gannon – 32nd Infantry 4.6% ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 12
  • 10.
    Half-German Regiments • NewYork: 39th, 58th, 68th, 119th • Pennsylvania: 4th, 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 14th, 15th, 16th, 48th, 50th, 51st, 56th, 65th, 79th, 88th, 96th, 98th • Ohio: 7th, 47th, 58th, 74th, 106th, 108th, 165th, 20th Battery • Missouri: 1st,39th, 40th, 41st, 4th Cav • Illinois: 9th, 24th, 27th, 36th, 44th, 45th, 57th, 58th, 13th Cav, 16th Cav ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 13
  • 11.
    Half-German Regiments • Indiana:24th, 136th • Minnesota: 1st, 2nd, 4th, 6th, • Texas: 1st (Loyal) • Kansas: 1st, 2nd • Nebraska: 1st Cav • Kentucky: 5th, 6th, 2nd Cav • Maryland: 5th ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 14
  • 12.
    Why they enlisted •Strongly influenced by the ideals of the 1848 revolution Union • Value and importance of Republican Ideals Slavery “All für Lincoln und Sie Freiheit” • Freedom ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 15
  • 13.
    Camp Jackson 1st BullRun Wilson’s Creek Pea Ridge Franz Sigel The War - 1861 ECWR Gannon
  • 14.
    Early Blows • May:Saving St. Louis – – German Loyalist rush to flag Armory Held, Camp Jackson taken • July: 1st Bull Run – Blenker’s German Division • held in reserve • mistaken For U.S. Regulars • Wilson’s Creek • Pea Ridge ECWR Gannon Louis Blenker ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 17
  • 15.
    South-West Texas: Little Germany •1/5 of all whites - over 22,000 German-born • Pro-Union, anti-slave, German-speaking communities • February - Twiggs surrenders, Commanches attack • August - Banishment Law, Law of Confiscation – Moved, or Pro-Union property confiscated Four years of Murder, Man-hunts, Imprisonments, Lynching ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 18
  • 16.
    Antietam Bull Run Cross Keys Fredricksburg SevenDays Henry & Donelson August Willich Stones River Shiloh Corinth The War - 1862 ECWR Gannon
  • 17.
  • 18.
    The Turning Points West • • • • East Vicksburg Tullahoma Chickamauga Chattanooga • • • • Chancellorsville BrandyStation Gettysburg Mine Run Chancellorsville Carl Schurz ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 22
  • 19.
    From Chancellorsville to Gettysburg OliverO. Howard Unjustified Criticism • Disliked 11th Corps • “Measureless Abuse” Commander • Coverup of German • New commanders (e.g., heroics Barlow in 3rd Division) • Marched north to shed • Questionable their dishonorable assignments of Smith & reputation. Coster as Brigade Commanders ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 23
  • 20.
    The First Day • • • • • ECWR July1, 1863: 9:30 AM St. Joseph’s College, Emmitsburg Maryland Buford’s Cavalry & 1st Corps stop Heth Reynolds (wing commander) Killed 10:45 AM: Howard takes Army Command, Schurz 11th Corps 2:30 PM: Schurz ordered to take 5,100 Men of 1st & 3rd Division north to protect 1st Corp’s flank 3:00 PM: 5,600 men of Early’s and Rodes’ divisions concentrate on Union right Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 24
  • 21.
    Threats to theUnion Right Schurz’s Intent: so ’d seR s iiv o niD s’s no edoR i si vD i ’s rly n Ea isio Di v ts s pr o C 1 &h e H t w r g tt e P e i ECWR Gannon Barlow Devin’s Devin’s Cavalry Cavalry Schimmelfenning To Gettysburg & ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 25 Cemetery Hill
  • 22.
    2:45 PM: July1st Barlow & Schimmelfennig Deploy s’s no s edo R ii v iD so ’d seR s iiv o niD 107 OH 68th NY 4th US 74 PA th Batt. G von Gilsa 61st OH 75th OH 1st OH 13th NY 45th NY 157th NY Dilger 25th OH th Light 68th NY ’s rly n Ea isio 153rd PA iv D 54th NY 17th CON Ames Barlow 82nd ILL von Amsberg ECWR Schimmelfennig Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 26
  • 23.
    3:15 PM Barlow Fallson Blocher Knoll Hays Doles (Early) (Rodes) 25 OH th 107th OH 4th US 74 PA Batt. G von Gilsa 61st OH 75th OH 1st OH 13th NY 45th NY 157th NY Dilger (Early) 68th NY 68th NY th Gordon 153rd PA 17th CON 54th NY Ames Barlow Light 82nd ILL von Amsberg Krzyzanowski ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 27
  • 24.
    3:30-4PM: Forlorn Hopes Krzyanowski’sBrigade 157th New York Doles (Rodes) Hays (Early) 1st OH 13th NYKrzyzanowski 45 NY th 157th NY Dilger Gordon (Early) Light Avery (Early) 3rd Division 82nd ILL von Gilsa von Amsberg ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 28
  • 25.
    Germans on The FirstDay • Ordered into an impossible situation • Position untenable from the start (Barlow’s deployment) • Fought bravely until overwhelmed • Horrendous Casualties – Krzyzanowski’s Brigade – every regiment engaged took over 50% casualties – 127th New York collapsed after taking 75% casualties • 82nd Illinois – last out of Gettysburg • Posted to defend North- and East Cemetery Hill ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 29
  • 26.
    Sunset: 2nd July1863 Cemetery Ridge Wilcox 1st MN Barksdale 21st Miss 126th NY 111th NY 125th NY 39th NY Watson’s Weikert’s Woods ECWR d f f or Wo Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 30
  • 27.
    Bias Against Germans TheSecond Day’s Record • 1st Minnesota loses 170 of 250 engaged – Staves the advance of 1000 rebels • Fassitt asks Hildebrand to advance – Gets Medal of Honor for initiative • 39th New York retakes Watson’s Battery – 75+ Casualties (25%) in 15 Minutes – Never recognized for recapturing four guns • 21st Mississippi retreats, gives up guns – claim they exchanged only “long range” volleys ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 31
  • 28.
    Hoke Dusk: 2nd July1863 6 th NC 21st NC 57 th N C East Cemetery Hill Hays w yto Ba l t im ore Pik e 33 rd d nR ECWR Culp’s Hill M ass s Ri ck et t ne Ta W ie d r ic h 7 10 OH ro ll th 15 3r 68 th d PA 54 th NY 41 st NY NY Ca r Br i ck La yard ne 25 th O Kr SchuH 75 th y r 17 th O zana tz & Co H ows nn ki Du Sollst est…! Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 32
  • 29.
    Gettysburg German Participation • Significant –1st Day – North of Gettysburg – 1st Day – On Cemetery Hill – 2nd Day – East Cemetery Hill Wadsworth Knoll – Overlooking East Cemetery Hill ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 33
  • 30.
  • 31.
    The Long Year West East • • • • Reseca KennesawMountain Atlanta March to the Sea • • Franklin Nashville ECWR Gannon • • • • • • Wilderness Spottsylvania Cold Harbor Monocacy Petersburg Valley Campaign ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 35
  • 32.
    1865: The End South East •Goldsboro • Bentonville ECWR • • • Gannon Petersburg Saylors Creek Appomatox ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 36
  • 33.
    Summary • Germans – – – – Played asignificant role Helped train the Union Army Received little recognition Suffered for their Union Sentiments ECWR Gannon ©2004 Stephen T. Frezza 37

Editor's Notes

  • #3 The history of the Gemans in the Civil War is territory as yet completely unexplored