GAME THEORY
Game Theory
• What is Game Theory?
• What is strategic environment?
• What are the main assumptions in Game
  Theory?
• How are games represented?
• What are the elements of Games ?
Game representations
                                                     Matrix form
          Extensive form                             (aka normal form
                                                     aka strategic form)

                                                                 player 2’s strategy
                           Up     1, 2
                                                      Up, Up Up,  Down D, D
                                                             Down , Up
         Up    Coca Cola

                           Down   3, 4              Up    1, 2    1, 2     3, 4    3, 4
                                         player 1’s
Pepsi                                    strategy
                           Up     5, 6
                                                   Down   5, 6    7, 8     5, 6    7, 8

        Down   Coca Cola

                           Down   7, 8
Dominated Strategy
• What is a dominated strategy?
Rules of the Game
• The strategic environment
   – Players
   – Strategies
   – Payoffs


• The assumptions
   – Rationality
   – Common knowledge

• The rules
   – Timing of moves
   – Informational conditions
Formal definition

Definitions

• Let Ai be the set of actions available for player I

• a = (a1, a2, …, ai,…) be an action profile: An action for
each player in the game.

• write (ai', a-i) if i chooses ai', other players according to a

• ui (ai , a-i ): payoff for player i from playing action ai and
others playing a-i
Prisoner’s Dilemma
Prisoner’s Dilemma
                 Not Confess   Confess


Not Confess      -2, -2        -5, -1


Confess          -1, -5        -3,-3
Comments
• Simultaneous actions does not imply taking
  actions at the same time.
• Rationality implies knowing the structure of
  the game.
• It does not mean that there is coordination on
  beliefs / cooperation
• Rationality is an assumption not necessary in
  reality.
Comments
• (Not Confess, Not Confess) is a pareto optimal
  outcome
• This is common knowledge
• Will Not Confess be chosen by both?
• Depends upon their beliefs about the actions
  of other players
Prisoner’s Dilemma
                 Not Confess   Confess


Not Confess      -2, -2        -5, -1


Confess          -1, -5        -3,-3
NASH EQUILIBRIUM
Nash Equilibrium
Nash Equilibrium:
• A set of strategies, one for each player, such
  that each player’s strategy is a best response
  to others’ strategies

Everybody is playing a best response
• No incentive to unilaterally change my strategy
Nash Equilibrium

• a* =( a* 1 , a* 2 , ……) = =( a* i , a* -i)
is a Nash equilibrium if for every player i and every
action, ai that is element of Ai:

              ui(a*) ≥ ui (ai , a-i*)

where ui is the payoff function representing the
preferences of player I
L         C           R


U   8, 3       0, 4        4,4


M   8,5        1,5       5,3


D   3,7        0,1       2,0
L             R



L   1,-1    -1, 1



R   -1, 1    1,-1
Coordination Games
            Opera     Movie



Opera       2,1       0,0



Movie       0,0       1,2
SUV Price Wars
               Discount   No Discount


Discount       3,3        8, 0


No Discount    0, 8       5,5
Games of Chicken

• Entry into small markets


                         Firm 2
                        Stay       Swerve
            Stay     -50 , -50    100 , 0
   Firm 1
            Swerve     0 , 100    50 , 50
Stag Hunt Game
• Each can individually hunt a stag or hunt a
  hare together.
• You can hunt a stag alone.
• You can only hunt a hare when you hunt it
  together.
• Hunting a hare alone means no dinner!
Stag Hunt Game
         Hare      Stag


Hare     3,3       -1, 0


Stag     0, -1     0,0
Games of Assurance
Joint research ventures
   –   Each firm may invest $50,000 into an R&D project
   –   Project succeeds only if both invest
   –   If successful, each nets $75,000
   –   Stag Hunt                     Firm 2
                                   $50K           $0
                      $50K       75 , 75      -50 , 0
           Firm 1
                      $0          0 , -50       0 , 0
Nash Equilibrium
• May or may not have to exist in pure
  strategies.




• Can be multiple in a single game.

Game theory 2

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Game Theory • Whatis Game Theory? • What is strategic environment? • What are the main assumptions in Game Theory? • How are games represented? • What are the elements of Games ?
  • 3.
    Game representations Matrix form Extensive form (aka normal form aka strategic form) player 2’s strategy Up 1, 2 Up, Up Up, Down D, D Down , Up Up Coca Cola Down 3, 4 Up 1, 2 1, 2 3, 4 3, 4 player 1’s Pepsi strategy Up 5, 6 Down 5, 6 7, 8 5, 6 7, 8 Down Coca Cola Down 7, 8
  • 4.
    Dominated Strategy • Whatis a dominated strategy?
  • 5.
    Rules of theGame • The strategic environment – Players – Strategies – Payoffs • The assumptions – Rationality – Common knowledge • The rules – Timing of moves – Informational conditions
  • 6.
    Formal definition Definitions • LetAi be the set of actions available for player I • a = (a1, a2, …, ai,…) be an action profile: An action for each player in the game. • write (ai', a-i) if i chooses ai', other players according to a • ui (ai , a-i ): payoff for player i from playing action ai and others playing a-i
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Prisoner’s Dilemma Not Confess Confess Not Confess -2, -2 -5, -1 Confess -1, -5 -3,-3
  • 9.
    Comments • Simultaneous actionsdoes not imply taking actions at the same time. • Rationality implies knowing the structure of the game. • It does not mean that there is coordination on beliefs / cooperation • Rationality is an assumption not necessary in reality.
  • 10.
    Comments • (Not Confess,Not Confess) is a pareto optimal outcome • This is common knowledge • Will Not Confess be chosen by both? • Depends upon their beliefs about the actions of other players
  • 11.
    Prisoner’s Dilemma Not Confess Confess Not Confess -2, -2 -5, -1 Confess -1, -5 -3,-3
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Nash Equilibrium Nash Equilibrium: •A set of strategies, one for each player, such that each player’s strategy is a best response to others’ strategies Everybody is playing a best response • No incentive to unilaterally change my strategy
  • 14.
    Nash Equilibrium • a*=( a* 1 , a* 2 , ……) = =( a* i , a* -i) is a Nash equilibrium if for every player i and every action, ai that is element of Ai: ui(a*) ≥ ui (ai , a-i*) where ui is the payoff function representing the preferences of player I
  • 15.
    L C R U 8, 3 0, 4 4,4 M 8,5 1,5 5,3 D 3,7 0,1 2,0
  • 16.
    L R L 1,-1 -1, 1 R -1, 1 1,-1
  • 17.
    Coordination Games Opera Movie Opera 2,1 0,0 Movie 0,0 1,2
  • 18.
    SUV Price Wars Discount No Discount Discount 3,3 8, 0 No Discount 0, 8 5,5
  • 19.
    Games of Chicken •Entry into small markets Firm 2 Stay Swerve Stay -50 , -50 100 , 0 Firm 1 Swerve 0 , 100 50 , 50
  • 20.
    Stag Hunt Game •Each can individually hunt a stag or hunt a hare together. • You can hunt a stag alone. • You can only hunt a hare when you hunt it together. • Hunting a hare alone means no dinner!
  • 21.
    Stag Hunt Game Hare Stag Hare 3,3 -1, 0 Stag 0, -1 0,0
  • 22.
    Games of Assurance Jointresearch ventures – Each firm may invest $50,000 into an R&D project – Project succeeds only if both invest – If successful, each nets $75,000 – Stag Hunt Firm 2 $50K $0 $50K 75 , 75 -50 , 0 Firm 1 $0 0 , -50 0 , 0
  • 23.
    Nash Equilibrium • Mayor may not have to exist in pure strategies. • Can be multiple in a single game.

Editor's Notes

  • #10 In PD you know that Not confessing is a pareto optimal scenario, you know that everyone knows that Not Confessing is a pareto optimal scenario. However, this does not mean that Not Confessing will be chosen or is the best strategy to choose. Your optimal strategy depends upon your belief about the other players action. You could believe that the other player will choose Not Confess in which case it still will never be optimal for you to Not Confess.
  • #19 Market worth of 10 which is split between the two players
  • #22 Market worth of 10 which is split between the two players