Flouting and Violating Maxims
Source: Khosravizadeh, P and Sadehvandi, N. 2011. Some instances of Violation and
Flouting of the Maxim of Quality by Main Characters (Barry & Tim) in Dinner for
Schmucks. Conference: International Conference of Literature, and Linguistics.
Flouting vs violating maxim
Flouting
• Speaker fails to observe a
maxim with deliberate
intention on generating
implicature
Violating
• People may quietly and
unostentatiously violate a
maxim with intention to
mislead
Maxim of …………..
Violating
The boy has been playing
games for hours when her
mother asks.
Mother : Did you study all day
long?
Son : Yes, I’ve been
studying till now!
Flouting
Teacher to a student who
arrives late more than ten
minutes to the class meeting
T: Wow! You’re such a
punctual fellow! Welcome to
the class.
S: Sorry Sir! It won’t happen
again.
Maxim of …………….
……………..
Ali: Where are you, Majid?
Majid: I’m in my clothes.
Ali: That I know. I mean
seriously, where are you man?
Majid: Well, at work, but I’ll be
finished in two hours
…………….
John: Where have you been?
I searched everywhere
for you during the past
three months!
Mike: I wasn’t around. So,
what’s the big deal?
Maxim of …………….
……………..
Bob: What were you and Anna
talking about? You were looking
at me all the time.
Marry: Oh, well….why don’t we
get something to drink?
Bob: Are you avoiding this
conversation? There has to be
something going on about me!
Why aren’t you brave enough to
tell me?
Marry: Well, you know…they
think that you are the one who
stole that money
…………….
Teacher: Why didn’t you do
your homework?
Student: May I go and get
some water? I’m so thirsty.
Maxim of……………
…………………………
Sarah: Did you enjoy the party
last night?
Anna: There was plenty of
oriental food on the table, lots
of flowers all over the place,
people hanging around
chatting with each other.
…………………………..
Wife: Darling….what’s the
story with that new watch on
your wrist?
Husband: Oh, this watch
you’re talking about! I knew
it….I told my boss that my wife
would be curious when she
sees it. Oh, honey you have no
idea how much they’re
satisfied with my performance
lately.

Flouting and violating maxims

  • 1.
    Flouting and ViolatingMaxims Source: Khosravizadeh, P and Sadehvandi, N. 2011. Some instances of Violation and Flouting of the Maxim of Quality by Main Characters (Barry & Tim) in Dinner for Schmucks. Conference: International Conference of Literature, and Linguistics.
  • 2.
    Flouting vs violatingmaxim Flouting • Speaker fails to observe a maxim with deliberate intention on generating implicature Violating • People may quietly and unostentatiously violate a maxim with intention to mislead
  • 3.
    Maxim of ………….. Violating Theboy has been playing games for hours when her mother asks. Mother : Did you study all day long? Son : Yes, I’ve been studying till now! Flouting Teacher to a student who arrives late more than ten minutes to the class meeting T: Wow! You’re such a punctual fellow! Welcome to the class. S: Sorry Sir! It won’t happen again.
  • 4.
    Maxim of ……………. …………….. Ali:Where are you, Majid? Majid: I’m in my clothes. Ali: That I know. I mean seriously, where are you man? Majid: Well, at work, but I’ll be finished in two hours ……………. John: Where have you been? I searched everywhere for you during the past three months! Mike: I wasn’t around. So, what’s the big deal?
  • 5.
    Maxim of ……………. …………….. Bob:What were you and Anna talking about? You were looking at me all the time. Marry: Oh, well….why don’t we get something to drink? Bob: Are you avoiding this conversation? There has to be something going on about me! Why aren’t you brave enough to tell me? Marry: Well, you know…they think that you are the one who stole that money ……………. Teacher: Why didn’t you do your homework? Student: May I go and get some water? I’m so thirsty.
  • 6.
    Maxim of…………… ………………………… Sarah: Didyou enjoy the party last night? Anna: There was plenty of oriental food on the table, lots of flowers all over the place, people hanging around chatting with each other. ………………………….. Wife: Darling….what’s the story with that new watch on your wrist? Husband: Oh, this watch you’re talking about! I knew it….I told my boss that my wife would be curious when she sees it. Oh, honey you have no idea how much they’re satisfied with my performance lately.