#ELTchat summary of 20/05/2015

1. ERROR CORRECTION-
CAN IT BE MADE FUN?
ELTchat Summary for 20th May 2015

2. What is Error
Correction?
What are errors?
Are we correcting:
something said in the heat of the moment?
something written as part of an exercise or
task?
= Both. But different techniques may be used
in the context of the situation.
 Strictly speaking we should be discussing
mistakes , which are performance errors
and can be corrected. Real errors are
things which have not necessarily been
taught yet, and therefore are not easily
self-corrected. D. Brown

3. Could we call
them something
else?
Tongue –in-cheek from Marisa_C:
 Deviations ?
 Unfortunate episodes?
 Things we can improve on…
 Things we can say in a different
way… (ShaunWilden)

4. DO WE USE DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO
CORRECT WRITTEN AND SPOKEN MISTAKES
?
 Strongminded, talkative students made it
difficult to hear mistakes of the quiet sts.
 Using Screen casts (see links) or Jing short
videos for written error correction works well
(Marisa and Sue)
 Voice recording tools would be good for
peer corrected speaking. Something like
Vocaroo or Voxopop would make good
homework tasks for sts to correct each other
 brokus_a : only outright corrects in writing.
Without a tip it doesn’t stick in conversation
 Students enjoy having writing corrected, so it
is easier than correcting fluency

5. RETHINK THE TEACHER’S ATTITUDE TO
ERRORS
 Don’t think of it as ‘error correction’ but as giving
students feedback (GlenysHanson)
 Errors are to be actually encouraged as part of
learning ( Marisa_C)
 Don’t be judgemental and put sts on the spot
(GlenysHanson)
 We need to take the shame out of making mistakes
(Marisa_C)
 If our students don’t make errors- we don’t have
jobs  (SueAnnan)
 Errors are just part of the learning curve
 Look at Error Gravity; List of errors to mark 0-5 (Marisa)
Would stop Students thinking that every problem is
major.
 Some teachers are as scared of correcting as the
students are of producing errors (Glenys)

6. HOW DO STUDENTS FEEL?
 Sts might arrive in class feeling ashamed of
mistakes.
 Students can feel embarrassed at the
beginning, but they end up enjoying the
guesswork (MigueCorDi)
 Sts have fun if they create their own silly symbols
for marking (Marisa_C)
 In groups they don’t feel stressed (GlenysHanson)
 If Teacher is not hypercritical, they don’t feel put
on the spot
 Some students really ask to be corrected,
especially in the run up to exams (Sunny_EvaS)
(Ven_VVE) But
it could be from habit (ShaunWilden)

7. DO STUDENTS ALWAYS WANT TO ‘GET IT
RIGHT’?
 Sometimes they get to Intermediate
level and stagnate (SueAnnan)
 Errors can be caused by lack of
attention (MigueCorDi)
 When speaking it is more important
to students that others understand
their message,

8. How can we
make error
correction more
fun?
 Take errors from student essays and ask the
class to guess who made them. (MigueCorDi)
 Write up a mix of sentences which are
correct and error-ridden and do a grammar
auction (HanaHainsworth)
 Use colourful markers and give positive
feedback (Sunny_EvaS)
 Colour-code errors- Sts correct in groups
(Marisa_C)
 Put errors on Flipchart on wall for class to
correct (GlenysHanson)
 Take an exercise and turn it into nonsense
works well for LA and amuses students
(Marisa_C)
 The Human Computer technique is fun (see
links)
 Play devil’s advocate. Let them argue
correctness with you (MigueCorDi)

9. And more
ideas….
 Make a student ‘the expert’ on a
mistake they make frequently. Ask
them for help if someone else
makes the same error. (Glenys)
 Make mistakes, pretend you have
forgotten the correct grammar and
ask students to look it up (Sunny_EvaS)
 Come at the error from a different
direction and make the lesson fun
(brockus_a)
 Get the students to teach the class
(brockus_a) ( Marisa)( Glenys)

10. What if the same
students are
making all the
mistakes?
 Do delayed correction and respond
to the content, not the student.
 Take care with sts who have low
affective filters (HanaHainsworth)
 Be selective about what you
correct and don’t over-face the
students
 Remember to respond to the quiet
ones- not the over-talkative
students who monopolise.

11. Does Correction
really work?
If it does- what other
factors might be at
play?

12. LINKS
The Human computer
techniquehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=di8TcpLY47g
(watch from around 10 minutes in)
Does Error Correction really work? Jeremy Harmer
http://203.72.145.166/ELT/files/47-4-6.pdf
Marisa’s Pinterest https://www.pinterest.com/celtathens/errors-
error-correction
Screencasting by Russell Stannard
http://www.teachertrainingvideos.com/screen-
casting/jing.html
http://203.72.145.166/ELT/files/47-4-6.pdf Scholarly article
All images taken from CC licensed ELTpics on Twitter by
@Senicko, @SandyMillin and @Karabetca