SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Disability is NOT inability:
What disabled people can contribute to
sustainability
Walking Interconnections
RESEARCHING THE LIVED EXPERIENCE OF DISABLED PEOPLE FOR A SUSTAINABLE SOCIETY
Sue Porter
University of Bristol
An argument for consideration
According to the United Nations, over 15% of the
world’s population live with disabilities. They are the
world’s largest minority.
In countries with life expectancies over 70 years,
individuals spend on average about 8 years, or 11.5% of
their life span, living with disabilities.
Previous research into disabled people and climate change
related emergencies identified that:
1. Disabled people were amongst hardest hit by climate change
related disasters: they are starting from a low point
– Poverty
– Poor housing
– Unreliable transport systems
– Attitudes
2. Disabled people were as interested in sustainability as any
other group, but often excluded from participating
3. Disabled people have experience and skills, however were
viewed as ‘only vulnerable’, their knowledge not well used by
agency planners and emergency services. (Abbott and Porter, 2013)
Benilda Caixeta (1954 – 2005)
Despite her best efforts, Benilda
Caixeta was unable to evacuate
before or during hurricane
Katrina… She told me the water
was rushing into her home just
before her phone went dead…
her body and her wheelchair
were found floating inside her
home three days later.
(Marcie Roth, Executive Director,
National Spinal Cord Injury Association)
1. Hardest hit
1. Hardest Hit: attitudes and ethics
“When I inquired about the sheltering needs of
people with disabilities, one Red Cross
operations official told me, “We aren’t
supposed to help these people. The local
health department does that. We can hardly
deal with the intact people”.
(Marcie Roth)
2. As committed to sustainable living
Different life styles
– Should everyone be asked to make the same
changes?
– Different needs in order to live independently
e.g. cooling, lifts
Excluded thoughtlessly
– Feeling judged e.g. use of car not cycling
– Ableist assumptions
3. Experience and skills to offer
What’s so great about independence?
‘…the disability perspective of interdependence is a
practical guide from the margins for making new
choices that may lead to a just and sustainable world—
a concept that reduces the distance between each
other and our environment.’ (Erik Leipoldt )
The experience of being in need and in receipt of care,
which requires an interdependence with others, may also
equip disabled people to contribute to the debates around
sustainability and our relationship with the environment.
3. Experience and skills to offer
Disabled people may have more to offer the debate
around climate change from their different lived
experiences, particularly around the idea of resources
(both external resources and their own internal
resources), which means that they may have a much
more nuanced approach to conceiving of ‘limitedness’.
Environmental/sustainability organisations have pointed
out the problem of ‘mainstream’ views about
‘limitlessness’ – of resources, energy and consumption,
and the need to change attitudes if we are to challenge
this ‘addictive’ behaviour.
Individual/social models
Individual/lifestyle model Structural model
Literature and activists advocate
individual actions for
sustainability.
Focus is on sustainable
consumption
Broader societal changes required in
organisation of social life and
embedded power relations.
Structural issues and inequalities
reproduced in environmental
inequalities
It’s the individual that needs to be
‘fixed’ by treatment, cure or rehab.
Society needs to make structural
changes to include disabled people.
Physical and social barriers to
participation need to be addressed
Medical model
Social model
So why don’t we make common cause
“I was at a meeting recently which included quite a lot of
disabled people including people with sensory support needs.
At the start the Chair told us what would happen in the event of
a fire alarm. We were told that we should look out for people in
blue vests and then listen out for personalised alarm messages
which would tell us what to do. Nobody seemed to think this was
problematic”.
So why don’t we make common cause
“I signed up for a Transition Research Network meeting, and on
checking access was told (very apologetically) that I’d have to use the
public toilet 120 yards down the street”.
“Very interested (although unsurprised) to hear about your experience
regarding the Transition Meeting - I have noticed here in Leeds
meetings arranged in rooms that are "unfortunately not wheelchair
accessible".
“One of the reasons I became interested in this area of research was
from my own experience of developing a chronic illness and finding I
wasn't able to continue with many of my previous pro-environmental
behaviours, whilst at the same time feeling quite judged for using a car
and not cycling etc when I attended environmental events!”
So why don’t we make common cause
“Having been involved in environmental and disability
movements I've been surprised by the lack of crossover - and
had interesting conversations with my disabled friends about
how the more 'environmentally sound' shops etc. tend to be
inaccessible, whereas the bigger chains are more likely to be
accessible”.
“One friend in particular complained of green campaigners
advocating the use of bikes over cars etc, [they] often don't
take different forms of embodiment into account. She worried
that such campaigns can even strengthen the discourse of
disabled people are burdens on society”.
Walking Interconnections: Who, what, why
Participants were people who identify as disabled and people
who identify as interested in sustainability
Walking and talking together in pairs – using a physical activity to
surface things that we know in our bodies, as well as what we
know in our minds
Using arts based methods, including writing, photography,
drawing and mapping to know and voice different things,
differently
In order to see what happens – are there things from our different
perspectives and experiences that we can offer each other, and
might enhance our thinking about sustainability?
We were thinking of the social and economic aspects of
sustainability, as much as the environmental ones.
Walking Interconnections: Insights from the research
• The relationship between resilience and risk taking, deviation,
problem solving, persistence and creativity;
• The absence of the disabled body within spaces typically
coded as ‘environmental’ – e.g. heritage sites and ‘natural’
landscapes’;
• The recognition that the dominant discourse of
‘independence’, belies the reality and necessity
of interdependence – interdependence offering alternative
and useful conceptions of ‘sustainable living’;
• That ‘ability’ is a dynamic definition for all human subjects;
• That the uplift in some sustainability initiatives – for example,
urban cycling routes - has ironically impacted negatively on
disabled people’s experiences of supposedly shared
walking/cycling paths.
Walking Interconnections: Insights from the research
Walking Interconnections has enabled us all, as co-
researchers, to recognise the creative, adaptive,
resourceful dimensions of disability.
Possibly our chief insight has been that disability can
teach us—in the words of Rosemarie Garland-Thomson
“to abide the unexpected, to live with dissonance, to
rein in the impulse to control”.
What next?
Where next?
Please contribute a guest blog post at:
www.walkinginterconnections.com

More Related Content

Similar to Disability is NOT inability: What disabled people can contribute to sustainability- Sue Porter

Dementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this eveningDementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
shibley
 
HM224 Lecture 2.pptx
HM224 Lecture 2.pptxHM224 Lecture 2.pptx
HM224 Lecture 2.pptx
AbdurRehman686638
 
Disability and Capitalism clip
Disability and Capitalism clipDisability and Capitalism clip
Disability and Capitalism clipJared Wood
 
Travel & Disability Address to the Carlo Besta Institute
Travel & Disability Address to the Carlo Besta InstituteTravel & Disability Address to the Carlo Besta Institute
Travel & Disability Address to the Carlo Besta Institute
Scott Rains
 
My Friends Can Call me "A Crip"-Do They?
My Friends Can Call me "A Crip"-Do They? My Friends Can Call me "A Crip"-Do They?
My Friends Can Call me "A Crip"-Do They?
Steve Brown
 
Developing an Effective Eco-Social Art Practice
Developing an Effective Eco-Social Art PracticeDeveloping an Effective Eco-Social Art Practice
Developing an Effective Eco-Social Art Practice
Cathy Fitzgerald - Independent artist | educator | researcher
 
Pay Attention To The Man Behind The Curtain Analysis
Pay Attention To The Man Behind The Curtain AnalysisPay Attention To The Man Behind The Curtain Analysis
Pay Attention To The Man Behind The Curtain Analysis
Stacey Wilson
 
Privileged irresponsibility presentation for Meaningful life in just society ...
Privileged irresponsibility presentation for Meaningful life in just society ...Privileged irresponsibility presentation for Meaningful life in just society ...
Privileged irresponsibility presentation for Meaningful life in just society ...
Vivienne Bozalek
 
Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age. Legal Drinking Age Research Paper Example...
Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age. Legal Drinking Age Research Paper Example...Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age. Legal Drinking Age Research Paper Example...
Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age. Legal Drinking Age Research Paper Example...
Violeta Cressman
 
SNED 4.pdf
SNED 4.pdfSNED 4.pdf
What sustainability means to me
What sustainability means to meWhat sustainability means to me
What sustainability means to me
Cleaner Greener China
 
Creating inclusive communities
Creating inclusive communitiesCreating inclusive communities
Creating inclusive communities
Emily Steel
 
RIWC_ Liz Sayce
RIWC_ Liz SayceRIWC_ Liz Sayce
RIWC_ Liz Sayce
Marco Muscroft
 
Practical Universal Design seminar slides Jan 2020
Practical Universal Design seminar slides Jan 2020 Practical Universal Design seminar slides Jan 2020
Practical Universal Design seminar slides Jan 2020
Karen Dunne
 

Similar to Disability is NOT inability: What disabled people can contribute to sustainability- Sue Porter (17)

Dementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this eveningDementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
 
HM224 Lecture 2.pptx
HM224 Lecture 2.pptxHM224 Lecture 2.pptx
HM224 Lecture 2.pptx
 
Disability and Capitalism clip
Disability and Capitalism clipDisability and Capitalism clip
Disability and Capitalism clip
 
Travel & Disability Address to the Carlo Besta Institute
Travel & Disability Address to the Carlo Besta InstituteTravel & Disability Address to the Carlo Besta Institute
Travel & Disability Address to the Carlo Besta Institute
 
My Friends Can Call me "A Crip"-Do They?
My Friends Can Call me "A Crip"-Do They? My Friends Can Call me "A Crip"-Do They?
My Friends Can Call me "A Crip"-Do They?
 
Capitalism and Impairments
Capitalism and ImpairmentsCapitalism and Impairments
Capitalism and Impairments
 
Developing an Effective Eco-Social Art Practice
Developing an Effective Eco-Social Art PracticeDeveloping an Effective Eco-Social Art Practice
Developing an Effective Eco-Social Art Practice
 
Pay Attention To The Man Behind The Curtain Analysis
Pay Attention To The Man Behind The Curtain AnalysisPay Attention To The Man Behind The Curtain Analysis
Pay Attention To The Man Behind The Curtain Analysis
 
Privileged irresponsibility presentation for Meaningful life in just society ...
Privileged irresponsibility presentation for Meaningful life in just society ...Privileged irresponsibility presentation for Meaningful life in just society ...
Privileged irresponsibility presentation for Meaningful life in just society ...
 
Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age. Legal Drinking Age Research Paper Example...
Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age. Legal Drinking Age Research Paper Example...Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age. Legal Drinking Age Research Paper Example...
Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age. Legal Drinking Age Research Paper Example...
 
Prior comment Service innovation  the things that matter
Prior comment Service innovation  the things that matterPrior comment Service innovation  the things that matter
Prior comment Service innovation  the things that matter
 
SNED 4.pdf
SNED 4.pdfSNED 4.pdf
SNED 4.pdf
 
What sustainability means to me
What sustainability means to meWhat sustainability means to me
What sustainability means to me
 
Creating inclusive communities
Creating inclusive communitiesCreating inclusive communities
Creating inclusive communities
 
RIWC_ Liz Sayce
RIWC_ Liz SayceRIWC_ Liz Sayce
RIWC_ Liz Sayce
 
Sustainability Defined
Sustainability DefinedSustainability Defined
Sustainability Defined
 
Practical Universal Design seminar slides Jan 2020
Practical Universal Design seminar slides Jan 2020 Practical Universal Design seminar slides Jan 2020
Practical Universal Design seminar slides Jan 2020
 

More from TheSchumacherInstitute

Margaret Gardner (Practical Action) - From Intermediate Technology to Technol...
Margaret Gardner (Practical Action) - From Intermediate Technology to Technol...Margaret Gardner (Practical Action) - From Intermediate Technology to Technol...
Margaret Gardner (Practical Action) - From Intermediate Technology to Technol...
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
Helen Browning (Soil Association) - From small acorns…how 5 schools and an am...
Helen Browning (Soil Association) - From small acorns…how 5 schools and an am...Helen Browning (Soil Association) - From small acorns…how 5 schools and an am...
Helen Browning (Soil Association) - From small acorns…how 5 schools and an am...
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
Graham Randles (New Economics Foundation Consulting) - A Powerful Vision
Graham Randles (New Economics Foundation Consulting) - A Powerful VisionGraham Randles (New Economics Foundation Consulting) - A Powerful Vision
Graham Randles (New Economics Foundation Consulting) - A Powerful Vision
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
Adrian Ramsay (Centre for Alternative Technology) - Thinking Globally, Acting...
Adrian Ramsay (Centre for Alternative Technology) - Thinking Globally, Acting...Adrian Ramsay (Centre for Alternative Technology) - Thinking Globally, Acting...
Adrian Ramsay (Centre for Alternative Technology) - Thinking Globally, Acting...
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
Adam Lent (Ashoka) - The Schumacher Contradiction - The battle between small ...
Adam Lent (Ashoka) - The Schumacher Contradiction - The battle between small ...Adam Lent (Ashoka) - The Schumacher Contradiction - The battle between small ...
Adam Lent (Ashoka) - The Schumacher Contradiction - The battle between small ...
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
The Future of Work - global, long term trends
The Future of Work - global, long term trendsThe Future of Work - global, long term trends
The Future of Work - global, long term trends
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
Making things – transforming resources (Chris McMahon)
Making things – transforming resources (Chris McMahon)Making things – transforming resources (Chris McMahon)
Making things – transforming resources (Chris McMahon)
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
Ordering and Delivering (Dr Miriam Ricci)
Ordering and Delivering (Dr Miriam Ricci)Ordering and Delivering (Dr Miriam Ricci)
Ordering and Delivering (Dr Miriam Ricci)
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
Getting there - The Daily Commute (Dr Miriam Ricci)
Getting there - The Daily Commute (Dr Miriam Ricci)Getting there - The Daily Commute (Dr Miriam Ricci)
Getting there - The Daily Commute (Dr Miriam Ricci)
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
P4 c launch 18062014
P4 c launch 18062014P4 c launch 18062014
P4 c launch 18062014
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
West of England Carbon Challenge - Jessica Ferrow, Low Carbon South West
West of England Carbon Challenge - Jessica Ferrow, Low Carbon South WestWest of England Carbon Challenge - Jessica Ferrow, Low Carbon South West
West of England Carbon Challenge - Jessica Ferrow, Low Carbon South West
TheSchumacherInstitute
 
The Real Economy Project (Bristol Pound) - Ciaran Mundy
The Real Economy Project (Bristol Pound) - Ciaran MundyThe Real Economy Project (Bristol Pound) - Ciaran Mundy
The Real Economy Project (Bristol Pound) - Ciaran MundyTheSchumacherInstitute
 
The Tredegar Deep Place Study: An Argument for Place-Based Economic Transitio...
The Tredegar Deep Place Study: An Argument for Place-Based Economic Transitio...The Tredegar Deep Place Study: An Argument for Place-Based Economic Transitio...
The Tredegar Deep Place Study: An Argument for Place-Based Economic Transitio...TheSchumacherInstitute
 

More from TheSchumacherInstitute (13)

Margaret Gardner (Practical Action) - From Intermediate Technology to Technol...
Margaret Gardner (Practical Action) - From Intermediate Technology to Technol...Margaret Gardner (Practical Action) - From Intermediate Technology to Technol...
Margaret Gardner (Practical Action) - From Intermediate Technology to Technol...
 
Helen Browning (Soil Association) - From small acorns…how 5 schools and an am...
Helen Browning (Soil Association) - From small acorns…how 5 schools and an am...Helen Browning (Soil Association) - From small acorns…how 5 schools and an am...
Helen Browning (Soil Association) - From small acorns…how 5 schools and an am...
 
Graham Randles (New Economics Foundation Consulting) - A Powerful Vision
Graham Randles (New Economics Foundation Consulting) - A Powerful VisionGraham Randles (New Economics Foundation Consulting) - A Powerful Vision
Graham Randles (New Economics Foundation Consulting) - A Powerful Vision
 
Adrian Ramsay (Centre for Alternative Technology) - Thinking Globally, Acting...
Adrian Ramsay (Centre for Alternative Technology) - Thinking Globally, Acting...Adrian Ramsay (Centre for Alternative Technology) - Thinking Globally, Acting...
Adrian Ramsay (Centre for Alternative Technology) - Thinking Globally, Acting...
 
Adam Lent (Ashoka) - The Schumacher Contradiction - The battle between small ...
Adam Lent (Ashoka) - The Schumacher Contradiction - The battle between small ...Adam Lent (Ashoka) - The Schumacher Contradiction - The battle between small ...
Adam Lent (Ashoka) - The Schumacher Contradiction - The battle between small ...
 
The Future of Work - global, long term trends
The Future of Work - global, long term trendsThe Future of Work - global, long term trends
The Future of Work - global, long term trends
 
Making things – transforming resources (Chris McMahon)
Making things – transforming resources (Chris McMahon)Making things – transforming resources (Chris McMahon)
Making things – transforming resources (Chris McMahon)
 
Ordering and Delivering (Dr Miriam Ricci)
Ordering and Delivering (Dr Miriam Ricci)Ordering and Delivering (Dr Miriam Ricci)
Ordering and Delivering (Dr Miriam Ricci)
 
Getting there - The Daily Commute (Dr Miriam Ricci)
Getting there - The Daily Commute (Dr Miriam Ricci)Getting there - The Daily Commute (Dr Miriam Ricci)
Getting there - The Daily Commute (Dr Miriam Ricci)
 
P4 c launch 18062014
P4 c launch 18062014P4 c launch 18062014
P4 c launch 18062014
 
West of England Carbon Challenge - Jessica Ferrow, Low Carbon South West
West of England Carbon Challenge - Jessica Ferrow, Low Carbon South WestWest of England Carbon Challenge - Jessica Ferrow, Low Carbon South West
West of England Carbon Challenge - Jessica Ferrow, Low Carbon South West
 
The Real Economy Project (Bristol Pound) - Ciaran Mundy
The Real Economy Project (Bristol Pound) - Ciaran MundyThe Real Economy Project (Bristol Pound) - Ciaran Mundy
The Real Economy Project (Bristol Pound) - Ciaran Mundy
 
The Tredegar Deep Place Study: An Argument for Place-Based Economic Transitio...
The Tredegar Deep Place Study: An Argument for Place-Based Economic Transitio...The Tredegar Deep Place Study: An Argument for Place-Based Economic Transitio...
The Tredegar Deep Place Study: An Argument for Place-Based Economic Transitio...
 

Recently uploaded

Presentación Giulio Quaggiotto-Diálogo improbable .pptx.pdf
Presentación Giulio Quaggiotto-Diálogo improbable .pptx.pdfPresentación Giulio Quaggiotto-Diálogo improbable .pptx.pdf
Presentación Giulio Quaggiotto-Diálogo improbable .pptx.pdf
Innovation and Technology for Development Centre
 
一比一原版(UMTC毕业证书)明尼苏达大学双城分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UMTC毕业证书)明尼苏达大学双城分校毕业证如何办理一比一原版(UMTC毕业证书)明尼苏达大学双城分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UMTC毕业证书)明尼苏达大学双城分校毕业证如何办理
zm9ajxup
 
UNDERSTANDING WHAT GREEN WASHING IS!.pdf
UNDERSTANDING WHAT GREEN WASHING IS!.pdfUNDERSTANDING WHAT GREEN WASHING IS!.pdf
UNDERSTANDING WHAT GREEN WASHING IS!.pdf
JulietMogola
 
growbilliontrees.com-Trees for Granddaughter (1).pdf
growbilliontrees.com-Trees for Granddaughter (1).pdfgrowbilliontrees.com-Trees for Granddaughter (1).pdf
growbilliontrees.com-Trees for Granddaughter (1).pdf
yadavakashagra
 
Environmental Science Book By Dr. Y.K. Singh
Environmental Science Book By Dr. Y.K. SinghEnvironmental Science Book By Dr. Y.K. Singh
Environmental Science Book By Dr. Y.K. Singh
AhmadKhan917612
 
alhambra case study Islamic gardens part-2.pptx
alhambra case study Islamic gardens part-2.pptxalhambra case study Islamic gardens part-2.pptx
alhambra case study Islamic gardens part-2.pptx
CECOS University Peshawar, Pakistan
 
Alert-driven Community-based Forest monitoring: A case of the Peruvian Amazon
Alert-driven Community-based Forest monitoring: A case of the Peruvian AmazonAlert-driven Community-based Forest monitoring: A case of the Peruvian Amazon
Alert-driven Community-based Forest monitoring: A case of the Peruvian Amazon
CIFOR-ICRAF
 
ppt on beauty of the nature by Palak.pptx
ppt on  beauty of the nature by Palak.pptxppt on  beauty of the nature by Palak.pptx
ppt on beauty of the nature by Palak.pptx
RaniJaiswal16
 
Daan Park Hydrangea flower season I like it
Daan Park Hydrangea flower season I like itDaan Park Hydrangea flower season I like it
Daan Park Hydrangea flower season I like it
a0966109726
 
Characterization and the Kinetics of drying at the drying oven and with micro...
Characterization and the Kinetics of drying at the drying oven and with micro...Characterization and the Kinetics of drying at the drying oven and with micro...
Characterization and the Kinetics of drying at the drying oven and with micro...
Open Access Research Paper
 
AGRICULTURE Hydrophonic FERTILISER PPT.pptx
AGRICULTURE Hydrophonic FERTILISER PPT.pptxAGRICULTURE Hydrophonic FERTILISER PPT.pptx
AGRICULTURE Hydrophonic FERTILISER PPT.pptx
BanitaDsouza
 
Q&A with the Experts: The Food Service Playbook
Q&A with the Experts: The Food Service PlaybookQ&A with the Experts: The Food Service Playbook
Q&A with the Experts: The Food Service Playbook
World Resources Institute (WRI)
 
NRW Board Paper - DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy
NRW Board Paper - DRAFT NRW Recreation StrategyNRW Board Paper - DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy
NRW Board Paper - DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy
Robin Grant
 
Celebrating World-environment-day-2024.pdf
Celebrating  World-environment-day-2024.pdfCelebrating  World-environment-day-2024.pdf
Celebrating World-environment-day-2024.pdf
rohankumarsinghrore1
 
Navigating the complex landscape of AI governance
Navigating the complex landscape of AI governanceNavigating the complex landscape of AI governance
Navigating the complex landscape of AI governance
Piermenotti Mauro
 
"Understanding the Carbon Cycle: Processes, Human Impacts, and Strategies for...
"Understanding the Carbon Cycle: Processes, Human Impacts, and Strategies for..."Understanding the Carbon Cycle: Processes, Human Impacts, and Strategies for...
"Understanding the Carbon Cycle: Processes, Human Impacts, and Strategies for...
MMariSelvam4
 
DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy - People and Nature thriving together
DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy - People and Nature thriving togetherDRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy - People and Nature thriving together
DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy - People and Nature thriving together
Robin Grant
 
Sustainable farming practices in India .pptx
Sustainable farming  practices in India .pptxSustainable farming  practices in India .pptx
Sustainable farming practices in India .pptx
chaitaliambole
 
Natural farming @ Dr. Siddhartha S. Jena.pptx
Natural farming @ Dr. Siddhartha S. Jena.pptxNatural farming @ Dr. Siddhartha S. Jena.pptx
Natural farming @ Dr. Siddhartha S. Jena.pptx
sidjena70
 
Summary of the Climate and Energy Policy of Australia
Summary of the Climate and Energy Policy of AustraliaSummary of the Climate and Energy Policy of Australia
Summary of the Climate and Energy Policy of Australia
yasmindemoraes1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Presentación Giulio Quaggiotto-Diálogo improbable .pptx.pdf
Presentación Giulio Quaggiotto-Diálogo improbable .pptx.pdfPresentación Giulio Quaggiotto-Diálogo improbable .pptx.pdf
Presentación Giulio Quaggiotto-Diálogo improbable .pptx.pdf
 
一比一原版(UMTC毕业证书)明尼苏达大学双城分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UMTC毕业证书)明尼苏达大学双城分校毕业证如何办理一比一原版(UMTC毕业证书)明尼苏达大学双城分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UMTC毕业证书)明尼苏达大学双城分校毕业证如何办理
 
UNDERSTANDING WHAT GREEN WASHING IS!.pdf
UNDERSTANDING WHAT GREEN WASHING IS!.pdfUNDERSTANDING WHAT GREEN WASHING IS!.pdf
UNDERSTANDING WHAT GREEN WASHING IS!.pdf
 
growbilliontrees.com-Trees for Granddaughter (1).pdf
growbilliontrees.com-Trees for Granddaughter (1).pdfgrowbilliontrees.com-Trees for Granddaughter (1).pdf
growbilliontrees.com-Trees for Granddaughter (1).pdf
 
Environmental Science Book By Dr. Y.K. Singh
Environmental Science Book By Dr. Y.K. SinghEnvironmental Science Book By Dr. Y.K. Singh
Environmental Science Book By Dr. Y.K. Singh
 
alhambra case study Islamic gardens part-2.pptx
alhambra case study Islamic gardens part-2.pptxalhambra case study Islamic gardens part-2.pptx
alhambra case study Islamic gardens part-2.pptx
 
Alert-driven Community-based Forest monitoring: A case of the Peruvian Amazon
Alert-driven Community-based Forest monitoring: A case of the Peruvian AmazonAlert-driven Community-based Forest monitoring: A case of the Peruvian Amazon
Alert-driven Community-based Forest monitoring: A case of the Peruvian Amazon
 
ppt on beauty of the nature by Palak.pptx
ppt on  beauty of the nature by Palak.pptxppt on  beauty of the nature by Palak.pptx
ppt on beauty of the nature by Palak.pptx
 
Daan Park Hydrangea flower season I like it
Daan Park Hydrangea flower season I like itDaan Park Hydrangea flower season I like it
Daan Park Hydrangea flower season I like it
 
Characterization and the Kinetics of drying at the drying oven and with micro...
Characterization and the Kinetics of drying at the drying oven and with micro...Characterization and the Kinetics of drying at the drying oven and with micro...
Characterization and the Kinetics of drying at the drying oven and with micro...
 
AGRICULTURE Hydrophonic FERTILISER PPT.pptx
AGRICULTURE Hydrophonic FERTILISER PPT.pptxAGRICULTURE Hydrophonic FERTILISER PPT.pptx
AGRICULTURE Hydrophonic FERTILISER PPT.pptx
 
Q&A with the Experts: The Food Service Playbook
Q&A with the Experts: The Food Service PlaybookQ&A with the Experts: The Food Service Playbook
Q&A with the Experts: The Food Service Playbook
 
NRW Board Paper - DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy
NRW Board Paper - DRAFT NRW Recreation StrategyNRW Board Paper - DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy
NRW Board Paper - DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy
 
Celebrating World-environment-day-2024.pdf
Celebrating  World-environment-day-2024.pdfCelebrating  World-environment-day-2024.pdf
Celebrating World-environment-day-2024.pdf
 
Navigating the complex landscape of AI governance
Navigating the complex landscape of AI governanceNavigating the complex landscape of AI governance
Navigating the complex landscape of AI governance
 
"Understanding the Carbon Cycle: Processes, Human Impacts, and Strategies for...
"Understanding the Carbon Cycle: Processes, Human Impacts, and Strategies for..."Understanding the Carbon Cycle: Processes, Human Impacts, and Strategies for...
"Understanding the Carbon Cycle: Processes, Human Impacts, and Strategies for...
 
DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy - People and Nature thriving together
DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy - People and Nature thriving togetherDRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy - People and Nature thriving together
DRAFT NRW Recreation Strategy - People and Nature thriving together
 
Sustainable farming practices in India .pptx
Sustainable farming  practices in India .pptxSustainable farming  practices in India .pptx
Sustainable farming practices in India .pptx
 
Natural farming @ Dr. Siddhartha S. Jena.pptx
Natural farming @ Dr. Siddhartha S. Jena.pptxNatural farming @ Dr. Siddhartha S. Jena.pptx
Natural farming @ Dr. Siddhartha S. Jena.pptx
 
Summary of the Climate and Energy Policy of Australia
Summary of the Climate and Energy Policy of AustraliaSummary of the Climate and Energy Policy of Australia
Summary of the Climate and Energy Policy of Australia
 

Disability is NOT inability: What disabled people can contribute to sustainability- Sue Porter

  • 1. Disability is NOT inability: What disabled people can contribute to sustainability Walking Interconnections RESEARCHING THE LIVED EXPERIENCE OF DISABLED PEOPLE FOR A SUSTAINABLE SOCIETY Sue Porter University of Bristol
  • 2. An argument for consideration According to the United Nations, over 15% of the world’s population live with disabilities. They are the world’s largest minority. In countries with life expectancies over 70 years, individuals spend on average about 8 years, or 11.5% of their life span, living with disabilities.
  • 3. Previous research into disabled people and climate change related emergencies identified that: 1. Disabled people were amongst hardest hit by climate change related disasters: they are starting from a low point – Poverty – Poor housing – Unreliable transport systems – Attitudes 2. Disabled people were as interested in sustainability as any other group, but often excluded from participating 3. Disabled people have experience and skills, however were viewed as ‘only vulnerable’, their knowledge not well used by agency planners and emergency services. (Abbott and Porter, 2013)
  • 4. Benilda Caixeta (1954 – 2005) Despite her best efforts, Benilda Caixeta was unable to evacuate before or during hurricane Katrina… She told me the water was rushing into her home just before her phone went dead… her body and her wheelchair were found floating inside her home three days later. (Marcie Roth, Executive Director, National Spinal Cord Injury Association) 1. Hardest hit
  • 5. 1. Hardest Hit: attitudes and ethics “When I inquired about the sheltering needs of people with disabilities, one Red Cross operations official told me, “We aren’t supposed to help these people. The local health department does that. We can hardly deal with the intact people”. (Marcie Roth)
  • 6. 2. As committed to sustainable living Different life styles – Should everyone be asked to make the same changes? – Different needs in order to live independently e.g. cooling, lifts Excluded thoughtlessly – Feeling judged e.g. use of car not cycling – Ableist assumptions
  • 7. 3. Experience and skills to offer What’s so great about independence? ‘…the disability perspective of interdependence is a practical guide from the margins for making new choices that may lead to a just and sustainable world— a concept that reduces the distance between each other and our environment.’ (Erik Leipoldt ) The experience of being in need and in receipt of care, which requires an interdependence with others, may also equip disabled people to contribute to the debates around sustainability and our relationship with the environment.
  • 8. 3. Experience and skills to offer Disabled people may have more to offer the debate around climate change from their different lived experiences, particularly around the idea of resources (both external resources and their own internal resources), which means that they may have a much more nuanced approach to conceiving of ‘limitedness’. Environmental/sustainability organisations have pointed out the problem of ‘mainstream’ views about ‘limitlessness’ – of resources, energy and consumption, and the need to change attitudes if we are to challenge this ‘addictive’ behaviour.
  • 9. Individual/social models Individual/lifestyle model Structural model Literature and activists advocate individual actions for sustainability. Focus is on sustainable consumption Broader societal changes required in organisation of social life and embedded power relations. Structural issues and inequalities reproduced in environmental inequalities It’s the individual that needs to be ‘fixed’ by treatment, cure or rehab. Society needs to make structural changes to include disabled people. Physical and social barriers to participation need to be addressed Medical model Social model
  • 10. So why don’t we make common cause “I was at a meeting recently which included quite a lot of disabled people including people with sensory support needs. At the start the Chair told us what would happen in the event of a fire alarm. We were told that we should look out for people in blue vests and then listen out for personalised alarm messages which would tell us what to do. Nobody seemed to think this was problematic”.
  • 11. So why don’t we make common cause “I signed up for a Transition Research Network meeting, and on checking access was told (very apologetically) that I’d have to use the public toilet 120 yards down the street”. “Very interested (although unsurprised) to hear about your experience regarding the Transition Meeting - I have noticed here in Leeds meetings arranged in rooms that are "unfortunately not wheelchair accessible". “One of the reasons I became interested in this area of research was from my own experience of developing a chronic illness and finding I wasn't able to continue with many of my previous pro-environmental behaviours, whilst at the same time feeling quite judged for using a car and not cycling etc when I attended environmental events!”
  • 12. So why don’t we make common cause “Having been involved in environmental and disability movements I've been surprised by the lack of crossover - and had interesting conversations with my disabled friends about how the more 'environmentally sound' shops etc. tend to be inaccessible, whereas the bigger chains are more likely to be accessible”. “One friend in particular complained of green campaigners advocating the use of bikes over cars etc, [they] often don't take different forms of embodiment into account. She worried that such campaigns can even strengthen the discourse of disabled people are burdens on society”.
  • 13. Walking Interconnections: Who, what, why Participants were people who identify as disabled and people who identify as interested in sustainability Walking and talking together in pairs – using a physical activity to surface things that we know in our bodies, as well as what we know in our minds Using arts based methods, including writing, photography, drawing and mapping to know and voice different things, differently In order to see what happens – are there things from our different perspectives and experiences that we can offer each other, and might enhance our thinking about sustainability? We were thinking of the social and economic aspects of sustainability, as much as the environmental ones.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18. Walking Interconnections: Insights from the research • The relationship between resilience and risk taking, deviation, problem solving, persistence and creativity; • The absence of the disabled body within spaces typically coded as ‘environmental’ – e.g. heritage sites and ‘natural’ landscapes’; • The recognition that the dominant discourse of ‘independence’, belies the reality and necessity of interdependence – interdependence offering alternative and useful conceptions of ‘sustainable living’; • That ‘ability’ is a dynamic definition for all human subjects; • That the uplift in some sustainability initiatives – for example, urban cycling routes - has ironically impacted negatively on disabled people’s experiences of supposedly shared walking/cycling paths.
  • 19. Walking Interconnections: Insights from the research Walking Interconnections has enabled us all, as co- researchers, to recognise the creative, adaptive, resourceful dimensions of disability. Possibly our chief insight has been that disability can teach us—in the words of Rosemarie Garland-Thomson “to abide the unexpected, to live with dissonance, to rein in the impulse to control”.
  • 21. Please contribute a guest blog post at: www.walkinginterconnections.com

Editor's Notes

  1. Poor; housing; transport; social networks Access; social isolation; poor design e.g. nets on recycling boxes, the bus and the oxygen cylinder ‘Unable’ - Subjugated knowledges not valued
  2. The very same para-transit system that people can’t rely on in good weather is what was being relied on in the evacuation. […] I was on the phone with Benilda when she told me, with panic in her voice “the water is rushing in.” And then her phone went dead. We learned days later that she had been found in her apartment dead, floating next to her wheelchair. […] Benilda did not have to drown.
  3. Disableism
  4. Assumptions are made that everyone can be asked to make the same changes in their lifestyle. These ableist assumptions can lead to disabled people feeling pressured to reduce energy consumption, even when their particular needs require heating or cooling to maintain even temperatures, access to motorised transport, or to lifts etc in order to live independent lives. Some disabled people with acquired impairments have also reported feeling excluded from their previous involvement in environmental campaigns, for example because of their growing dependence on the car rather than cycling.
  5. Our feeling was that a problem common to both groups was that of the troubling of the value of ‘independence’ as an ultimate goal we should aspire towards – Why not interdependence, with each other, and with our environment? The lived experience of disability teaches us to value inter-dependence.
  6.   Individual or structural change?   One way of conceptualising issues for both the environment and disability is to compare the debates around medical / social models of disability with the debate as to whether its changes to individual lifestyles / social structures which are required to protect the environment.   Disability and sustainability share some disputed ground – that of whether we should be thinking of the ‘problem’ lying with the individual - the medical model of disability where the impairment is the problem; and the model of sustainability where all we need to do is to change the actions of individuals - OR taking a social model view, asking what is it that is embedded in our culture and its structures that makes a bodily difference a real disability, that means we only plan and provide for one ‘normal’ type of body, and which keeps us addicted to our cars, consumption and ‘growth’.   The technical fix is a danger to both movements – we need to change society’s structures in line with a philosophy of equal rights and equal responsibilities
  7. We need to develop an awareness of unquestioning, institutionalised ableism (as we did with racism and sexism).
  8. Yet unthinking ableism is getting in the way ...
  9. Lots of shared issues between environmental and disabled activists – not least social justice transport, energy, access to wilderness Mutuality
  10. The Walking Interconnections project harnessed arts-based and narrative inquiry methods to facilitate an exchange of knowledge and insights into different experiences in and of the world. These dialogues have allowed us to understand more about different forms of resilience in support of the transition to a sustainable society.
  11. An example of the data
  12. The Walking Interconnections project harnessed arts-based and narrative inquiry methods to facilitate an exchange of knowledge and insights into different experiences in and of the world. These dialogues have allowed us to understand more about different forms of resilience in support of the transition to a sustainable society The relationship between resilience and risk taking, deviation, problem solving, persistence and creativity; The absence of the disabled body within spaces typically coded as ‘environmental’ – e.g. heritage sites and ‘natural’ landscapes’; The recognition that the dominant discourse of ‘independence’, particularly as this is attached to the field of disability policy and practices, belies the reality and necessity of interdependence – interdependence offering alternative and useful conceptions of ‘sustainable living’ (with the attendant practices of trust, negotiation, reciprocity, mutuality, and co-operation); That ‘ability’ is a dynamic definition for all human subjects (for example, some people feel more energetic in the morning, more vulnerable in the cold, etc.); That the uplift in some sustainability initiatives – for example, urban cycling routes - has ironically impacted negatively on disabled people’s experiences of supposedly shared walking/cycling paths.