A Different Perspective on Disability

         Laura (Mole) Chapman
Welcome




Without certain groups represented in the room, we miss out
  on the voices we need to hear in order to change.
Ground Rules

Agreed understandings or social
contract?



  What do you need to participate?
Shared Outcomes:
• Hopes and fears:
Respectful language
Disability... the disadvantage or restriction
  of activity caused by contemporary social
  organisation which takes little or no
  account of people who have physical
  impairments and thus excludes them
  from the mainstream of social activities.

   (the Union for of Physically Impaired Segregation1976)
Respectful language
Impairment, disabled people use this
 term to talk about their medical
 condition or diagnosis or description
 of their functioning—if there is
 nothing more formal.
         Quadriplegia
    Examples of   Polio
    Impairment    Cerebral palsy
                  Blindness
                  Deafness


                  Buildings without
    Examples of   ramps
     Disability   Poor health provision
                  Bullying, name-calling
                  Segregated education
                  Workplaces without lifts
Respectful language
•   The person—their name.
•    Impairment = Functioning
•    Disability = barriers in society
Respectful
                language
Fred Brown (the person) is a man with
  cerebral palsy (the impairment). When the
  barriers    and      discrimination     (the
  oppression) that restrict Fred have been
  removed from society, Fred will no longer
  be disabled, but he will still have cerebral
  palsy and be called Fred.
Eastenders
             Corrie
CSI




Shrek
Disability Today?
Richard Hawkes, Scope, said the figures were
"alarming".
•Hundreds of thousands of disabled people
will be forced into a cycle of long-term
unemployment, poverty and social exclusion.
•Disabled people must not be pushed
 even further backwards in our society
 by the pursuit of deficit reduction.
Culture Change
 Welcome                         Invitation
 Tolerance                       Acceptance
 Single /other                   Diverse
 Deficit                         Assets
 Barriers                        Boundaries
 Rigid rules                     Flexible Principles
 Compliance                      Commitment
 Improvement                     Transformation

Chapman, L. 2010 pg. 26
Disabilism

The disadvantage or restriction of activity
  caused     by    contemporary     social
  organisation which takes little or no
  account of people who have impairments
  and thus excludes them from the
  mainstream of social activities.
Articulating Disablism

Fred Brown (the person) is a man with
  cerebral palsy (the impairment). When the
  barriers and disablism (the oppression) that
  restrict Fred have been removed from
  society, Fred will no longer be disabled, but
  he will still have cerebral palsy and be called
  Fred.
Disabling Assumptions

  The characteristics of disablism
Outcomes
Feeling       Action
The Facts
• Visually impaired people are four times more likely
  to be verbally and physically abused than sighted
  people

• People with mental health issues are 11 times
  more likely to be victimised

• 90% of adults with a learning difficulty report being
  'bullied'.



                                 Scope 2008
Compared with non-disabled people,
      disabled people are:
• more likely to be economically inactive – only one in
  two disabled people of working age are currently in
  employment, compared with four out of five non-
  disabled people;

• more likely to experience problems with hate crime
  or harassment – a quarter of all disabled people say
  that they have experienced hate crime or
  harassment, and this number rises to 47% of people
  with mental health conditions;
"on the experience of disability, history is
largely silent, and when it is discussed at all, it
 is within the context of the history of medical
   advances. Just as women and black people
   have discovered that they must write their
  own histories, so too with disabled people.”

              Oliver and Campbell 1996
The Medical Model of disability
          the personal domain

• Medical approach to the problem.
• Defined by non-disabled professionals
• Equated to illness in terms of research and
  findings.
• Care and benefits have been awarded to
  compensate for personal tragedy.
The Social Model of Disability
           the public domain

• The problem owned by the whole community.
• It defines the problem in terms barriers:
  attitudinal, structural and systemic.
• Acknowledges the oppression and a requirement
for action.
• It recognises disabled people’s voice in
  distributed or shared leadership.
Social Justice
As stated by Prof. West-Burnham:
The principle of equality has to be reinforced and extended by the
   practice of equity.
Equality: every human being has an absolute and equal right to common
   dignity and parity of esteem and entitlement to access the benefits of
   society on equal terms.
Equity: every human being has a right to benefit from the outcomes of
   society on the basis of fairness and according to need.
Social justice: justice requires deliberate and specific intervention to
   secure equality and equity.


                            (Chapman, L. and West-Burnham, J. 2010, pg.26)
Inclusive practice:
Inclusion is a process of identifying and breaking down barriers
   which can be environmental, attitudinal and institutional. This
   process eliminates discrimination thus providing all participants
   with equal access.



Is an ongoing process of reviewing and developing practice in order
    to adjust and celebrate diversity. It is the journey not the
    destination!


(Chapman, L. 2006, pg 4. Unpublished)
Growth and Capacity building
Barriers
attitudinal
structural
 systemic
Equalities Act
• Eliminate unlawful discrimination,
harassment and victimisation and
other conduct prohibited by the Act.
• Advance equality of opportunity
between people who share a protected
characteristic and those who do not.
• Foster good relations between people
who share a protected characteristic
and those who do not.
Co-Production
On a societal level, Co-Production entails
a simple but profound shift in
relationships... Co-Production may mean
the active process of remedying or
preventing whatever would violate our
sense of social justice. A social justice
perspective elevates the principle to an
Imperative’
          (Cahn, 2000, p 34-35).
Practice
Gather evidence

What does your community look like?
What evidence are you basing this on?
What evidence do you need to gather?


The change from ‘impact assessment’ to ‘analysis of the effects’ to
focus attention on the quality of the analysis and how it is used in
decision-making, and less on the production of a document.
Practice
Enable ‘engagement’
Or co-production?

How do you demonstrate participation?



This can assist with development of evidence base…
Practice
Set objectives

Challenging and achievable


Issues regarding inequality are deep-seated and difficult, and it
   may take time to fully address these.
Practice
Innovate:

Design delivery and service
Practice
Evaluate the difference made?

What works?
Who is better off?
Shared ownership???
Vision and Ethical commitment

• To address inequality the approach will
  need to value everyone’s experience.

• Rather than one-off and costly changes, it
  requires a shift in organisational culture so
  that people are universally entitled to
  contribution.

A Different Perspective on Equality, pg. 31
Positive and Possible
• Everyone can do something to contribute towards
  greater fairness, while not everyone will do the
  same thing in the same way.
• The challenge then is to accept that the change is
  possible if people are able to appreciate a whole
  diversity of positive actions.
• Rather than a step-by-step approach or a scale of
  difficulty, an acceptance of diverse routes to a
  more human experience.
A Different Perspective on Equality, pg. 35
Good bye!

   …on Facebook
      or Twitter
 For free materials:
www.equalitytraining.co.uk

Disability Equality

  • 1.
    A Different Perspectiveon Disability Laura (Mole) Chapman
  • 2.
    Welcome Without certain groupsrepresented in the room, we miss out on the voices we need to hear in order to change.
  • 3.
    Ground Rules Agreed understandingsor social contract? What do you need to participate?
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Respectful language Disability... thedisadvantage or restriction of activity caused by contemporary social organisation which takes little or no account of people who have physical impairments and thus excludes them from the mainstream of social activities. (the Union for of Physically Impaired Segregation1976)
  • 6.
    Respectful language Impairment, disabledpeople use this term to talk about their medical condition or diagnosis or description of their functioning—if there is nothing more formal.
  • 7.
      Quadriplegia Examples of Polio Impairment Cerebral palsy Blindness Deafness   Buildings without Examples of ramps Disability Poor health provision Bullying, name-calling Segregated education Workplaces without lifts
  • 8.
    Respectful language • The person—their name. • Impairment = Functioning • Disability = barriers in society
  • 9.
    Respectful language Fred Brown (the person) is a man with cerebral palsy (the impairment). When the barriers and discrimination (the oppression) that restrict Fred have been removed from society, Fred will no longer be disabled, but he will still have cerebral palsy and be called Fred.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    Disability Today? Richard Hawkes,Scope, said the figures were "alarming". •Hundreds of thousands of disabled people will be forced into a cycle of long-term unemployment, poverty and social exclusion. •Disabled people must not be pushed even further backwards in our society by the pursuit of deficit reduction.
  • 13.
    Culture Change Welcome Invitation Tolerance Acceptance Single /other Diverse Deficit Assets Barriers Boundaries Rigid rules Flexible Principles Compliance Commitment Improvement Transformation Chapman, L. 2010 pg. 26
  • 14.
    Disabilism The disadvantage orrestriction of activity caused by contemporary social organisation which takes little or no account of people who have impairments and thus excludes them from the mainstream of social activities.
  • 15.
    Articulating Disablism Fred Brown(the person) is a man with cerebral palsy (the impairment). When the barriers and disablism (the oppression) that restrict Fred have been removed from society, Fred will no longer be disabled, but he will still have cerebral palsy and be called Fred.
  • 16.
    Disabling Assumptions The characteristics of disablism
  • 17.
  • 18.
    The Facts • Visuallyimpaired people are four times more likely to be verbally and physically abused than sighted people • People with mental health issues are 11 times more likely to be victimised • 90% of adults with a learning difficulty report being 'bullied'. Scope 2008
  • 19.
    Compared with non-disabledpeople, disabled people are: • more likely to be economically inactive – only one in two disabled people of working age are currently in employment, compared with four out of five non- disabled people; • more likely to experience problems with hate crime or harassment – a quarter of all disabled people say that they have experienced hate crime or harassment, and this number rises to 47% of people with mental health conditions;
  • 20.
    "on the experienceof disability, history is largely silent, and when it is discussed at all, it is within the context of the history of medical advances. Just as women and black people have discovered that they must write their own histories, so too with disabled people.” Oliver and Campbell 1996
  • 21.
    The Medical Modelof disability the personal domain • Medical approach to the problem. • Defined by non-disabled professionals • Equated to illness in terms of research and findings. • Care and benefits have been awarded to compensate for personal tragedy.
  • 23.
    The Social Modelof Disability the public domain • The problem owned by the whole community. • It defines the problem in terms barriers: attitudinal, structural and systemic. • Acknowledges the oppression and a requirement for action. • It recognises disabled people’s voice in distributed or shared leadership.
  • 26.
    Social Justice As statedby Prof. West-Burnham: The principle of equality has to be reinforced and extended by the practice of equity. Equality: every human being has an absolute and equal right to common dignity and parity of esteem and entitlement to access the benefits of society on equal terms. Equity: every human being has a right to benefit from the outcomes of society on the basis of fairness and according to need. Social justice: justice requires deliberate and specific intervention to secure equality and equity. (Chapman, L. and West-Burnham, J. 2010, pg.26)
  • 27.
    Inclusive practice: Inclusion isa process of identifying and breaking down barriers which can be environmental, attitudinal and institutional. This process eliminates discrimination thus providing all participants with equal access. Is an ongoing process of reviewing and developing practice in order to adjust and celebrate diversity. It is the journey not the destination! (Chapman, L. 2006, pg 4. Unpublished)
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Equalities Act • Eliminateunlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation and other conduct prohibited by the Act. • Advance equality of opportunity between people who share a protected characteristic and those who do not. • Foster good relations between people who share a protected characteristic and those who do not.
  • 31.
    Co-Production On a societallevel, Co-Production entails a simple but profound shift in relationships... Co-Production may mean the active process of remedying or preventing whatever would violate our sense of social justice. A social justice perspective elevates the principle to an Imperative’ (Cahn, 2000, p 34-35).
  • 32.
    Practice Gather evidence What doesyour community look like? What evidence are you basing this on? What evidence do you need to gather? The change from ‘impact assessment’ to ‘analysis of the effects’ to focus attention on the quality of the analysis and how it is used in decision-making, and less on the production of a document.
  • 33.
    Practice Enable ‘engagement’ Or co-production? Howdo you demonstrate participation? This can assist with development of evidence base…
  • 34.
    Practice Set objectives Challenging andachievable Issues regarding inequality are deep-seated and difficult, and it may take time to fully address these.
  • 35.
  • 36.
    Practice Evaluate the differencemade? What works? Who is better off? Shared ownership???
  • 37.
    Vision and Ethicalcommitment • To address inequality the approach will need to value everyone’s experience. • Rather than one-off and costly changes, it requires a shift in organisational culture so that people are universally entitled to contribution. A Different Perspective on Equality, pg. 31
  • 38.
    Positive and Possible •Everyone can do something to contribute towards greater fairness, while not everyone will do the same thing in the same way. • The challenge then is to accept that the change is possible if people are able to appreciate a whole diversity of positive actions. • Rather than a step-by-step approach or a scale of difficulty, an acceptance of diverse routes to a more human experience. A Different Perspective on Equality, pg. 35
  • 39.
    Good bye! …on Facebook or Twitter For free materials: www.equalitytraining.co.uk