This document provides an overview of different approaches to cultural criticism. It discusses criticism versus cynicism, explaining that critics carefully examine media through evidence-based analysis rather than making unsupported judgments. Several theories of cultural criticism are then outlined, including reader response, formalism, and biographic, Marxist, deconstructionist, psychoanalytic, and archetypal approaches. The document notes criticism in the 1990s predominantly involved white male critics from Western nations. It argues for more diverse perspectives to achieve richer understanding. Finally, it briefly introduces feminist, critical race theory, and ecocriticism as alternative approaches.

1. Cultural criticism
A practice in which you look for the way-deeper meaning
in a cultural text, from road sign to commercial to viral
video.
Then you look for the meaning of the meaning. And you
try to figure out what that means, how it means, why it
means.

2. Criticism versus cynicism
 A media cynic decides a bit of media sucks or that
news is "fake” or “biased” without careful examination.
 A media critic makes a hypothesis about media's
value, tests the hypothesis through careful
observation, crafts a detailed analysis and comes to
an informed conclusion. The critic might decide that
a film sucks or that news is fake. But they will be able
to back up that conclusion with supportive evidence.
 In this class, we will strive to be critics, not cynics.

3. Many theories and critical modes
 A reader response mode of criticism allowed for
individual ways of thinking about a text. Remember
the English-class maxim that “there is no right
answer”? This is that way of thinking.
 But reader response criticism was too mushy for folks
who preferred a more structured, almost scientific
approach to the cultural text.
 Formalists suggested that a text contained within it all
the needed clues to an exact interpretation.

4. More theories
 Other critics and scholars tried to ascertain what the
media maker intended to say with her or his work by
putting it in historic context.
 Scholars tried to tie works to the media maker’s own
life, using a biographic criticism.
 Marxist critics looked at economics, critiquing the
capitalist forces that drive the narrative (and sales of
the media).

5. And even more!
 Deconstructionists studied how meaning could be
derived only from contextual oppositions, always in flux.
 Psychoanalysts studied the text as a revelation of our
inner psyches.
 Archetypal critics read a text like it was a deck of tarot
cards.
 Phenomenologists looked for the epiphanous moments
and barbaric yawps.
 (Many critics would now accuse me of being reductive, with
regards to their sophisticated and complex theories.)

6. A 1990s list of influential critics
(What do you notice?)

7. Critics = white guys from Western nations.
Except for British anthropologist Mary
Douglas, of course, of course.

8. The problem with Eurocentrism
 Eurocentrism as the term for an ideology was coined
by Samir Amin in the 1970s.
 A Eurocentric view privileges Western culture
(European and Euro-based U.S. and Canadian
cultures).
 Critics develop analytical systems from their cultural
perspectives.
 More perspectives = a richer, more inclusive criticism
– for us, a wider, more useful understanding of the
role of mass media messages and their influence on
our thinking and our actions.

9. A fresher list
of theories for
cultural
criticism
From Purdue’s
Online Writing Lab

10. Feminist criticism
 Feminist critics look at how texts – mass
media messages, included, reinforce the
economic, political, social, and psychological
oppression of women" (Tyson 83).
 For cultural criticism, feminist criticism
examines patriarchal (male dominated) media
messages and aims to expose misogyny.
(From Perdue’s OWL.)

11. Sexist 1950s coffee ad

12. December 2019 Peloton ad
 Peloton ad:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ijof8uw4OHs
 Washington Post video describes controversy:
https://youtu.be/Ey2_O_VdBA0
 Ryan Reynolds’ vodka ad:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H2t7lknrK28
 Reaction to vodka ad: https://youtu.be/H2DoapmVFU8
 What do you think? (Reply in your post.)

13. Critical Race Theory
 “Critical Race Theory, or CRT, examines
the appearance of race and racism
across cultural expressions including
mass media messages.
 “CRT scholars attempt to understand
how victims of systemic racism are
affected by cultural perceptions of race
and how they are able to represent
themselves to counter prejudice.”

14. Derrick Bell (1995)
From “Who’s Afraid of Critical Race Theory?”

15. Ecocriticism
 Ecocriticism embraces a principle of “relevance” in
literature, which can began looking at texts as stored
energy – renewable, sustainable
 “The problem now, as most ecologists agree, is to find
ways of keeping the human community from
destroying the natural community, and with it the
human community.”
 “Energy comes from the creative imagination.”

16. Branches of ecocriticism
Ecocriticism, criticism via literary ecology, sprawled out
into its own sub-fields of criticism, including:
 Ecofeminism
 Ecocriticism and social justice
 Eco-phenomenology
 Eco-psychology