Dr. Pradeep Kumar Jena
Assoc. Prof. of Paediatrics
S.V.P.P.G.I.P.,Sishubhaban,Cuttack
2
Objectives:
1.Differentiate competencies from objectives.
2.Develop objectives from different competencies.
3.Explain the relationship between objectives, learning
and assessment.
3
GOALS =COMPETENCY = OBJECTIVES?
Aims & Goals are vague
have wider perspective
► Teacher or Institute oriented
►  May be Social, Financial, Political etc.
e.g.: - to train Doctors, Nurses for society
to run the hospital at profit etc.
Goal:
• A projected state of affairs that a person or
system plans to achieve
Where do you want to go? or What do you want
to become?
8
5
Learning objectives describe what the learner
should be able to achieve at the end of a learning
period.
Learning objectives are specific to a course of
instruction.
Objective
Competency
The habitual and judicious use of
communication,knowledge, technical skills,
clinical reasoning, emotions, values,and reflection
in daily practice for the benefit of the
individualand community being served.
What should you be able to perform at course
completion in relation to your role, job
responsibility and capability ?
9
Preamble
• The competency document is the work of subject
experts.
• The expanse and depth of competencies identified
may vary from subject to subject.
• This is broad Framework and not regulation –
• A guideline for institutions to develop a similar document
that addresses their curricular needs.
6
8
• Clinician
• Leader
• Communicator
• Lifelong learner
• Professional
9
GENERAL
OBJECTIVES
INTERMEDIATE
OBJECTIVES
SPECIFIC
INSTRUCTINOAL
OBJECTIVES
[SIOs]
Knowledge
(HEAD)
Cognitive
Domain
Affective
domain
Attitudes
(HEART)
Skills
(HANDS)
Psychomotor
Domain
10
Communication
(HEART)
Affective
Domain
Characteristics (qualities) of Objectives ?
S
M
A
R
T
Specific
Measurable
Attainable
Relevant
Time-bound
12
13
Sources
o health needs, demands & resources of the
society
o national health policies
o services to the community
o scientific progress
o prevalent culture & value system
o student characteristics
14
The Educational Spiral
Planning
evaluation
Implementing
evaluation
Defining Educational
Objectives
Preparing & Implementing
Educational programme
15
SPECIFIC INSTRUCTIONAL OBJECTIVES
16
e.g. - a lecture, a course of lectures
- a practical
- a tutorial
- a group discussion
- a clinical session / term …..
SIOs-
What the teacher expects from the students to learn
as a result of his/her teaching efforts at the end of
an instructional unit
17
A meaningfully stated objective
should be
CLEAR & UNAMBIGUOUS
so that
it successfully communicates to the reader,
what the writer intends
18
1. Activity : Appropriate action verb
2. Content : what is to be implemented (performed)
3. Condition: e.g. with / without help of equipment,
specimen, reports, books etc.
 Condition of learner (Student) not of patient !
4. Criteria : minimum standard of performance.
19
1. START WITH ACTION VERB
Specific activity / behavior of the learner
 Name
 Enlist
 Perform
 Respond
[From the list of action verbs according to the domain]
20
2. Follow with CONTENT REFERENCE – describing
the subject being treated.
• ASK WHAT IS TO BE IMPLEMENTED
 Name the bones in the human hand
 Enlist the steps in cell division
 Perform lumbar puncture
 Respond to a patient’s concern over his illness
21
3. Specify the main CONDITIONS under which the
action is to take place – e.g.
By memory
Under observation / guidance of the teacher or
independently
Given the data
With the help of a microscope
22
4.Followed by Performance Standard [CRITERIA]
-indicating minimum acceptable achievement in
measurable terms.
Enlist the bones in the human hand with an accuracy of at least
90%
Perform a lumbar puncture in five consecutive cases, obtaining
the necessary amount (3cc) of cerebrospinal fluid with
minimum discomfort to the patient.
Respond to a patient’s concern over his illness to the patient’s
satisfaction, as measured by his response to a questionnaire or
his interview afterwards.
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Action verb ?
24
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Action verb
25
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Content ?
26
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Content
27
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Condition ?
28
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Condition
29
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Criteria ?
30
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Criteria
31
SLO
The learner should be able to prepare a
thin blood smear for differential count
with the provided blood sample in two
attempts.
Action verb ?
Present complete clinical history of a
patient without referring to notes, missing
not more than two important points
32
Action verb
Present complete clinical history of a
patient without referring to notes, missing
not more than two important points
33
Content ?
Present complete clinical history of a
patient without referring to notes, missing
not more than two important points
34
Content
Present complete clinical history of a
patient without referring to notes, missing
not more than two important points
35
Condition ?
Present complete clinical history of a
patient without referring to notes, missing
not more than two important points
36
Condition
Present complete clinical history of a
patient without referring to notes, missing
not more than two important points
37
Criteria ?
Present complete clinical history of a
patient without referring to notes, missing
not more than two important points
38
Criteria
Present complete clinical history of a
patient without referring to notes, missing
not more than two important points
39
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ counsel the mother for 6
months exclusive breast feeding with the
help of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5
cases as confirmed by mother’s interview
afterwards.
40
Action verb ?
At the end of the session the student should be
able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for
6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help
of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as
confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards.
41
Action verb
At the end of the session the student should be
able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for
6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help
of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as
confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards.
42
Content ?
At the end of the session the student should be
able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for
6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help
of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as
confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards.
43
Content
At the end of the session the student should be
able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for
6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help
of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as
confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards.
44
Condition ?
At the end of the session the student should be
able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for
6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help
of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as
confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards.
45
Condition
At the end of the session the student should be
able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for
6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help
of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as
confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards.
46
Criteria ?
At the end of the session the student should be
able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for
6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help
of flip cards successfully in 3 out of 5 cases as
confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards.
47
Criteria
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ define various types of shock,
its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and
management without missing the important
points.”
48
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ define various types of shock,
its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and
management without missing the important
points.”
49
Action verb ?
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ define various types of shock,
its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and
management without missing the important
points.”
50
Action verb
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ define various types of shock,
its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and
management without missing the important
points.”
51
Content ?
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ define various types of shock,
its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and
management without missing the important
points.”
52
Content
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ define various types of shock,
its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and
management without missing the important
points.”
53
Condition ?
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ define various types of shock,
its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and
management without missing the important
points.”
54
Criteria ?
At the end of the session the student should
be able TO “ define various types of shock,
its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and
management without missing the important
points.”
55
Criteria
56
Competency:
Utilizes appropriate methods for interacting sensitively,
effectively, and professionally with persons from diverse
cultural, socioeconomic, educational, racial, ethnic and
professional backgrounds, and persons of all ages and
lifestyle preferences
57
Learning objectives relating to the above
competency:
1. Describe the demographic trends and epidemiological
trends related to diverse populations of India.
2. Compare and contrast diversity and cultural background
in the public health context.
3. Identify a framework to design culturally competent
public health care services for diverse populations.
Slide # 58
OBJECTIVES
STUDENT
QUESTION
PAPER
SETTER
TEACHER
59
60
FORMULATING SIOs OF TAXONOMIC DOMAINS
• In a group each participant will formulate one SIO related to
his / her discipline belonging to each domain.
• Present SIOs in her / his group.
• Each group will select one objective for presentation in the
plenary session
GROUP I Clinical competency
GROUP II
GROUP III
Leadership competency
GROUP IV
GROUP V Professional competency
Communicator competency
Lifelong learner competency

Competency and objectives in medical education technology

  • 1.
    Dr. Pradeep KumarJena Assoc. Prof. of Paediatrics S.V.P.P.G.I.P.,Sishubhaban,Cuttack
  • 2.
    2 Objectives: 1.Differentiate competencies fromobjectives. 2.Develop objectives from different competencies. 3.Explain the relationship between objectives, learning and assessment.
  • 3.
    3 GOALS =COMPETENCY =OBJECTIVES? Aims & Goals are vague have wider perspective ► Teacher or Institute oriented ►  May be Social, Financial, Political etc. e.g.: - to train Doctors, Nurses for society to run the hospital at profit etc.
  • 4.
    Goal: • A projectedstate of affairs that a person or system plans to achieve Where do you want to go? or What do you want to become? 8
  • 5.
    5 Learning objectives describewhat the learner should be able to achieve at the end of a learning period. Learning objectives are specific to a course of instruction. Objective
  • 6.
    Competency The habitual andjudicious use of communication,knowledge, technical skills, clinical reasoning, emotions, values,and reflection in daily practice for the benefit of the individualand community being served. What should you be able to perform at course completion in relation to your role, job responsibility and capability ? 9
  • 7.
    Preamble • The competencydocument is the work of subject experts. • The expanse and depth of competencies identified may vary from subject to subject. • This is broad Framework and not regulation – • A guideline for institutions to develop a similar document that addresses their curricular needs. 6
  • 8.
    8 • Clinician • Leader •Communicator • Lifelong learner • Professional
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Characteristics (qualities) ofObjectives ? S M A R T Specific Measurable Attainable Relevant Time-bound
  • 12.
  • 13.
    13 Sources o health needs,demands & resources of the society o national health policies o services to the community o scientific progress o prevalent culture & value system o student characteristics
  • 14.
    14 The Educational Spiral Planning evaluation Implementing evaluation DefiningEducational Objectives Preparing & Implementing Educational programme
  • 15.
  • 16.
    16 e.g. - alecture, a course of lectures - a practical - a tutorial - a group discussion - a clinical session / term ….. SIOs- What the teacher expects from the students to learn as a result of his/her teaching efforts at the end of an instructional unit
  • 17.
    17 A meaningfully statedobjective should be CLEAR & UNAMBIGUOUS so that it successfully communicates to the reader, what the writer intends
  • 18.
    18 1. Activity :Appropriate action verb 2. Content : what is to be implemented (performed) 3. Condition: e.g. with / without help of equipment, specimen, reports, books etc.  Condition of learner (Student) not of patient ! 4. Criteria : minimum standard of performance.
  • 19.
    19 1. START WITHACTION VERB Specific activity / behavior of the learner  Name  Enlist  Perform  Respond [From the list of action verbs according to the domain]
  • 20.
    20 2. Follow withCONTENT REFERENCE – describing the subject being treated. • ASK WHAT IS TO BE IMPLEMENTED  Name the bones in the human hand  Enlist the steps in cell division  Perform lumbar puncture  Respond to a patient’s concern over his illness
  • 21.
    21 3. Specify themain CONDITIONS under which the action is to take place – e.g. By memory Under observation / guidance of the teacher or independently Given the data With the help of a microscope
  • 22.
    22 4.Followed by PerformanceStandard [CRITERIA] -indicating minimum acceptable achievement in measurable terms. Enlist the bones in the human hand with an accuracy of at least 90% Perform a lumbar puncture in five consecutive cases, obtaining the necessary amount (3cc) of cerebrospinal fluid with minimum discomfort to the patient. Respond to a patient’s concern over his illness to the patient’s satisfaction, as measured by his response to a questionnaire or his interview afterwards.
  • 23.
    SLO The learner shouldbe able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 24.
    Action verb ? 24 SLO Thelearner should be able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 25.
    Action verb 25 SLO The learnershould be able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 26.
    Content ? 26 SLO The learnershould be able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 27.
    Content 27 SLO The learner shouldbe able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 28.
    Condition ? 28 SLO The learnershould be able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 29.
    Condition 29 SLO The learner shouldbe able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 30.
    Criteria ? 30 SLO The learnershould be able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 31.
    Criteria 31 SLO The learner shouldbe able to prepare a thin blood smear for differential count with the provided blood sample in two attempts.
  • 32.
    Action verb ? Presentcomplete clinical history of a patient without referring to notes, missing not more than two important points 32
  • 33.
    Action verb Present completeclinical history of a patient without referring to notes, missing not more than two important points 33
  • 34.
    Content ? Present completeclinical history of a patient without referring to notes, missing not more than two important points 34
  • 35.
    Content Present complete clinicalhistory of a patient without referring to notes, missing not more than two important points 35
  • 36.
    Condition ? Present completeclinical history of a patient without referring to notes, missing not more than two important points 36
  • 37.
    Condition Present complete clinicalhistory of a patient without referring to notes, missing not more than two important points 37
  • 38.
    Criteria ? Present completeclinical history of a patient without referring to notes, missing not more than two important points 38
  • 39.
    Criteria Present complete clinicalhistory of a patient without referring to notes, missing not more than two important points 39
  • 40.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ counsel the mother for 6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards. 40 Action verb ?
  • 41.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for 6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards. 41 Action verb
  • 42.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for 6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards. 42 Content ?
  • 43.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for 6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards. 43 Content
  • 44.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for 6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards. 44 Condition ?
  • 45.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for 6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards. 45 Condition
  • 46.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for 6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help of flip cards successfully in 2 out of 5 cases as confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards. 46 Criteria ?
  • 47.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ counsel the mother of a neonate for 6 months exclusive breast feeding with the help of flip cards successfully in 3 out of 5 cases as confirmed by mother’s interview afterwards. 47 Criteria
  • 48.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ define various types of shock, its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and management without missing the important points.” 48
  • 49.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ define various types of shock, its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and management without missing the important points.” 49 Action verb ?
  • 50.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ define various types of shock, its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and management without missing the important points.” 50 Action verb
  • 51.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ define various types of shock, its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and management without missing the important points.” 51 Content ?
  • 52.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ define various types of shock, its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and management without missing the important points.” 52 Content
  • 53.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ define various types of shock, its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and management without missing the important points.” 53 Condition ?
  • 54.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ define various types of shock, its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and management without missing the important points.” 54 Criteria ?
  • 55.
    At the endof the session the student should be able TO “ define various types of shock, its etiology, pathogenesis, complication and management without missing the important points.” 55 Criteria
  • 56.
    56 Competency: Utilizes appropriate methodsfor interacting sensitively, effectively, and professionally with persons from diverse cultural, socioeconomic, educational, racial, ethnic and professional backgrounds, and persons of all ages and lifestyle preferences
  • 57.
    57 Learning objectives relatingto the above competency: 1. Describe the demographic trends and epidemiological trends related to diverse populations of India. 2. Compare and contrast diversity and cultural background in the public health context. 3. Identify a framework to design culturally competent public health care services for diverse populations.
  • 58.
  • 59.
  • 60.
    60 FORMULATING SIOs OFTAXONOMIC DOMAINS • In a group each participant will formulate one SIO related to his / her discipline belonging to each domain. • Present SIOs in her / his group. • Each group will select one objective for presentation in the plenary session GROUP I Clinical competency GROUP II GROUP III Leadership competency GROUP IV GROUP V Professional competency Communicator competency Lifelong learner competency