Co-Government 
Jordi Graells i Costa 
Barcelona, October 2014 
@jordigraells graells.cat slideshare.net/jordigraells 
1 Thomas Jefferson Memorial: Closed Due to Government Shutdown © NPCA Photos CC BY-ND 2.0
1. Marketing 
2 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 CCCC –– BBYY 33..00
Marketing: 
a new point 
of view with 
Philip Kotler 
3 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 2014 CCCC CC –– – BBYY BY 33..3.0 
00
The customer at the heart of strategy 
http://cliptank.com/history-painting-famous-answers.html 
4 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
All the current series of marketing guidelines... 
1. 1,7 seg = Time that a consumer looks at a product, according to advertisers. 
2. Competition is not the only price. 
3. Sensorial Marketing = visual, auditory, tactile or olfactory stimuli. 
4. Intuition is based on the success or failure of previous purchases. 
? 
5. Brands interact with customers through social networks. 
6. Products have to provide a benefit to the customer or for the planet. 
7. The surprise captures consumers. 
8. Million consumers exposed to TV ads throughout life. 
9. Consumers repeat if shopping means a moment of pleasure. 
10.When buying, emotion is 90% of purchase decisions. 
11.Companies choose to create with customer. Shared experiencies of client + brand. 
12.The company's reputation is the differentiating factor. 
5 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
... which ones are useful for public services? 
6 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
A new marketing model is born: co-creation 
Internet + Social Networks = co-creation 
7 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
8 
Now the technology is more open, 
social and mobile. It’s closer to people, 
and we can do a lot of things with it. 
‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
2. Co-creation 
9 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 CCCC –– BBYY 33..00
Bright people are people outside the company 
«Most of the bright 
people don't work 
for you– no matter 
who you are. You need 
a strategy that allows 
for innovation occurring 
elsewhere». 
Bill Joy (Sun Microsystems) 
10 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Latest marketing trends 
Marketing trends: 
1.Ethnomarketing. It studies consumers in their 
natural habitat. It’s difficult to apply because the 
consumer has become multifaceted and 
chameleonic. 
2.Positive Marketing, Social Marketing or 
Responsible Marketing. The company shows that it 
has customer values and it makes the customer (as 
a partner) feel that if he buys the product, he is 
doing something good. 
3.Neuromarketing. Only 10% of buying decisions 
are neural; other decisions are the result of 
Neuroscience. 
11 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
The goal of marketing 
To establish a regular 
and constant 
relationship 
with the costumer. 
12 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Current Marketing 
What is it? 
1.Shopping experience shared with the client and in his 
own way. 
2.Branding reputation. To reach people by attitude: 
open, ethical, transparent, innovative. 
#brand 
13 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Examples 
In improving the shopping experience, emotions drive consumer 
behavior. 
•KLM: Meet&Seat 
•Illa Diagonal: shopping without music 
•Burger King: aroma of grilled meat 
More examples: 
•Lays. Cash prize and a percentage of sales, 
for the contribution of ideas. 
•Banc Sabadell. Ideas contributed by customers. 
•Starbucks. Website of Ideas. 280 ideas implemented. Customers already 
inspired products of Ikea, Lego, Heineken, BMW, Zara, Procter&Gamble. 
14 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
But the consumers are changing 
Consumers are probably tired 
of corporate marketing 
policies. 
Instead, they appreciate 
responsible pricing policies, 
concern for the environment 
and companies actively 
listening to their problems. 
15 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
What does co-create mean? 
Co-creation is a form of economic strategy 
that emphasizes the generation 
and ongoing realization of mutual 
Company-Customer value. It views 
markets as platforms for firms and 
active customers to share, combine 
and renew each other's resources and 
capabilities to create value through new 
forms of interaction, service and learning mechanisms. 
It differs from the traditional passive consumer market 
of the past. 
And co-production is the phase after co-creation. But here we still 
talking about co-creation, to simplify it. 
16 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Value of co-creation 
• Economic. It is a clear saving model 
• Loyalty. The client feels part of the company. 
• Information / knowledge (the most relevant). The 
company receives information without intermediaries.. 
17 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
3. Co-creation in 
the Government 
18 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 CCCC –– BBYY 33..00
And in the Government? 
Citizens have to live their own User 
Experience in the public services too. 
19 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Action plan for co-creation 
The action plan has to contain the 
technological platform, the governance model 
and operations for developing. 
Common aspects in the projects: 
•Objectives, users, legal, operational, release, 
technology, integration, analysis, 
communication, social networking, other 
channels. 
Other different aspects: 
•Ideas, evaluation, voting, lifecycle, incentives. ! 
20 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
How can they live Citizen Experience as users? 
• They feel part of the services model management. 
• Services have to be more useful for citizens. They are now more 
educated and changing. 
• Citizens perceive the Government as open, ethical, transparent and 
innovative. 
• These values have to improve the brand reputation of Government. 
• Citizens provide information 
to the Government to manage 
public affairs better. 
• All this helps to reduce costs. 
21 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Co-creation in the Government 
1. Internal co-creation. Innovation by collaborative strategies. 
2. External co-creation. The case of open data websites and 
crowdsourcing initiatives. 
3. Internal-External co-creation. Networks of civil servants in society. 
4. Internal co-production. 
5. External co-production. 
22 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
1. Internal co-creation 
CoP Public Health Agency of Catalonia Or CoP Compartim [Let’s Share] program 
Or ‘Aula Virtual’ EAPC 
23 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
2. External co-creation 1/2 
Open data websites 
Government / 
Administration 
Datasets 
Open 
services 
Reusing actors Products / frameworks 
Infomediaries 
Companies 
Governments / 
Administrations 
Social 
entities 
All kinds of 
products and 
services 
Mobile 
services 
Social 
media 
Websites 
24 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
2. External co-creation 2/2 
Other initiatives 
25 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
3. Internal-external co-creation 
Civil servants’ networks, like VOST, XIP. 
26 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
4. Internal co-production 
App gencat to measure the coverage 
of mobile services. 
27 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
5. External co-production 
University of Central Lancashire, UK: saving lives by drones 
www.smartdrones.fr/en/quand-le-drone-le-crowdsourcing-peut-sauver-des-vies/002572 
Street Bump (Boston): Mobile app collects data about the 
smoothness of the ride; that data provides the City with 
real-time information it uses to fix problems 
www.cityofboston.gov/DoIT/apps/streetbump.asp 
Citizen apps (Barcelona, Sant Cugat V, Londres…) 
To identify urban incidents so they can be repaired 
www.fixmystreet.com 
28 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
4. In conclusion 
29 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 CCCC –– BBYY 33..00
Service value 
The key is the value proposition of the service. 
x 
performances emotions 
x x 
cost discomfort insecurity 
30 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Citizen mobile sourcing 
+ = 
Revolution in the innovation 
of public services 
31 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Co-creation and co-production leads 
to Co-Government 
Government can co-create and 
co-produce meanly through: 
1.Open data = 
Open Governments. 
2.Social networks = Government 
in network. 
3.Mobile services = Government 
on the mobile. 
32 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
Thanks! 
Co-Government 
Jordi Graells i Costa 
Barcelona, October 2014 
@jordigraells graells.cat slideshare.net/jordigraells 
33 Thomas Jefferson Memorial: Closed Due to Government Shutdown © NPCA Photos CC BY-ND 2.0

Co-Government

  • 1.
    Co-Government Jordi Graellsi Costa Barcelona, October 2014 @jordigraells graells.cat slideshare.net/jordigraells 1 Thomas Jefferson Memorial: Closed Due to Government Shutdown © NPCA Photos CC BY-ND 2.0
  • 2.
    1. Marketing 2‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 CCCC –– BBYY 33..00
  • 3.
    Marketing: a newpoint of view with Philip Kotler 3 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 2014 CCCC CC –– – BBYY BY 33..3.0 00
  • 4.
    The customer atthe heart of strategy http://cliptank.com/history-painting-famous-answers.html 4 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 5.
    All the currentseries of marketing guidelines... 1. 1,7 seg = Time that a consumer looks at a product, according to advertisers. 2. Competition is not the only price. 3. Sensorial Marketing = visual, auditory, tactile or olfactory stimuli. 4. Intuition is based on the success or failure of previous purchases. ? 5. Brands interact with customers through social networks. 6. Products have to provide a benefit to the customer or for the planet. 7. The surprise captures consumers. 8. Million consumers exposed to TV ads throughout life. 9. Consumers repeat if shopping means a moment of pleasure. 10.When buying, emotion is 90% of purchase decisions. 11.Companies choose to create with customer. Shared experiencies of client + brand. 12.The company's reputation is the differentiating factor. 5 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 6.
    ... which onesare useful for public services? 6 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 7.
    A new marketingmodel is born: co-creation Internet + Social Networks = co-creation 7 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 8.
    8 Now thetechnology is more open, social and mobile. It’s closer to people, and we can do a lot of things with it. ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 9.
    2. Co-creation 9‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 CCCC –– BBYY 33..00
  • 10.
    Bright people arepeople outside the company «Most of the bright people don't work for you– no matter who you are. You need a strategy that allows for innovation occurring elsewhere». Bill Joy (Sun Microsystems) 10 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 11.
    Latest marketing trends Marketing trends: 1.Ethnomarketing. It studies consumers in their natural habitat. It’s difficult to apply because the consumer has become multifaceted and chameleonic. 2.Positive Marketing, Social Marketing or Responsible Marketing. The company shows that it has customer values and it makes the customer (as a partner) feel that if he buys the product, he is doing something good. 3.Neuromarketing. Only 10% of buying decisions are neural; other decisions are the result of Neuroscience. 11 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 12.
    The goal ofmarketing To establish a regular and constant relationship with the costumer. 12 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 13.
    Current Marketing Whatis it? 1.Shopping experience shared with the client and in his own way. 2.Branding reputation. To reach people by attitude: open, ethical, transparent, innovative. #brand 13 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 14.
    Examples In improvingthe shopping experience, emotions drive consumer behavior. •KLM: Meet&Seat •Illa Diagonal: shopping without music •Burger King: aroma of grilled meat More examples: •Lays. Cash prize and a percentage of sales, for the contribution of ideas. •Banc Sabadell. Ideas contributed by customers. •Starbucks. Website of Ideas. 280 ideas implemented. Customers already inspired products of Ikea, Lego, Heineken, BMW, Zara, Procter&Gamble. 14 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 15.
    But the consumersare changing Consumers are probably tired of corporate marketing policies. Instead, they appreciate responsible pricing policies, concern for the environment and companies actively listening to their problems. 15 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 16.
    What does co-createmean? Co-creation is a form of economic strategy that emphasizes the generation and ongoing realization of mutual Company-Customer value. It views markets as platforms for firms and active customers to share, combine and renew each other's resources and capabilities to create value through new forms of interaction, service and learning mechanisms. It differs from the traditional passive consumer market of the past. And co-production is the phase after co-creation. But here we still talking about co-creation, to simplify it. 16 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 17.
    Value of co-creation • Economic. It is a clear saving model • Loyalty. The client feels part of the company. • Information / knowledge (the most relevant). The company receives information without intermediaries.. 17 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 18.
    3. Co-creation in the Government 18 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 CCCC –– BBYY 33..00
  • 19.
    And in theGovernment? Citizens have to live their own User Experience in the public services too. 19 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 20.
    Action plan forco-creation The action plan has to contain the technological platform, the governance model and operations for developing. Common aspects in the projects: •Objectives, users, legal, operational, release, technology, integration, analysis, communication, social networking, other channels. Other different aspects: •Ideas, evaluation, voting, lifecycle, incentives. ! 20 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 21.
    How can theylive Citizen Experience as users? • They feel part of the services model management. • Services have to be more useful for citizens. They are now more educated and changing. • Citizens perceive the Government as open, ethical, transparent and innovative. • These values have to improve the brand reputation of Government. • Citizens provide information to the Government to manage public affairs better. • All this helps to reduce costs. 21 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 22.
    Co-creation in theGovernment 1. Internal co-creation. Innovation by collaborative strategies. 2. External co-creation. The case of open data websites and crowdsourcing initiatives. 3. Internal-External co-creation. Networks of civil servants in society. 4. Internal co-production. 5. External co-production. 22 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 23.
    1. Internal co-creation CoP Public Health Agency of Catalonia Or CoP Compartim [Let’s Share] program Or ‘Aula Virtual’ EAPC 23 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 24.
    2. External co-creation1/2 Open data websites Government / Administration Datasets Open services Reusing actors Products / frameworks Infomediaries Companies Governments / Administrations Social entities All kinds of products and services Mobile services Social media Websites 24 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 25.
    2. External co-creation2/2 Other initiatives 25 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 26.
    3. Internal-external co-creation Civil servants’ networks, like VOST, XIP. 26 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 27.
    4. Internal co-production App gencat to measure the coverage of mobile services. 27 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 28.
    5. External co-production University of Central Lancashire, UK: saving lives by drones www.smartdrones.fr/en/quand-le-drone-le-crowdsourcing-peut-sauver-des-vies/002572 Street Bump (Boston): Mobile app collects data about the smoothness of the ride; that data provides the City with real-time information it uses to fix problems www.cityofboston.gov/DoIT/apps/streetbump.asp Citizen apps (Barcelona, Sant Cugat V, Londres…) To identify urban incidents so they can be repaired www.fixmystreet.com 28 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 29.
    4. In conclusion 29 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 22001144 CCCC –– BBYY 33..00
  • 30.
    Service value Thekey is the value proposition of the service. x performances emotions x x cost discomfort insecurity 30 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 31.
    Citizen mobile sourcing + = Revolution in the innovation of public services 31 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 32.
    Co-creation and co-productionleads to Co-Government Government can co-create and co-produce meanly through: 1.Open data = Open Governments. 2.Social networks = Government in network. 3.Mobile services = Government on the mobile. 32 ‘Co-government’. Jordi Graells i Costa. Barcelona, october 2014 CC – BY 3.0
  • 33.
    Thanks! Co-Government JordiGraells i Costa Barcelona, October 2014 @jordigraells graells.cat slideshare.net/jordigraells 33 Thomas Jefferson Memorial: Closed Due to Government Shutdown © NPCA Photos CC BY-ND 2.0