CAN HR STANDARDS MITIGATE RISK?
Xolani Mawande, COO: SABPP
3rd Annual HR Conference
2 June 2016
@xolani_mawande
@SABPP1
The role of HR …
Global HR trends
• Strategic HR as foundation for HR success
• HR business partner role
• Talent management
• HR Governance – making better and ethican
decisions about people
• HR Risk Management
• HR Technology + social media
• Innovating the HR function and business
• OD focus in HR work – employee engagement
• HR measurement – big data & metrics
• HR competencies and standards
HR Risk Management: It is all about
people factors
Top facts about HR
• Human Capital is the biggest concern for
CEOs (PwC).
• Only 18% of CEOs feel confident that they
have the right people in place to execute
strategy (CEB).
• Human Capital is the biggest risk in
business (HCI Africa).
• Skills crisis is the top obstacle to economic
growth.
• Strikes cost SA R 200 million+ per day.
More facts about HR
• SA losing R12 billion a year due to absenteeism.
• Only 19% auditors feel they use HR optimally (CG
Index – Institute of Internal Auditors)
• Only 5% employees understand business strategy.
• World-wide 13% of employees actively engaged.
• Companies with engaged employees outperform
others by 202% (Dale Carnegie).
• Companies with good HR Practices outperform
others by treating HR as critical business function,
these companies are 105% more profitable.
• Average ROI on wellness programmes: 300%.
HR Professionalism Priorities
What are standards really?
• A level of acceptable quality
• Good enough in terms of professionalism
• What is good or normal or usual
• A guideline for practice
• A foundation for reasonable expectations
and sound judgement
• A framework for managing risk
• A basis for measurement (M&E)
468 HR Leaders developing
HR Standards for South Africa
BUSINESS STRATEGY – HR BUSINESS ALIGNMENT
Strategic
HRM
Talent
Management
HR Risk
Management
HR ARCHITECTURE
I
HR VALUE &
DELIVERY PLATFORM
Work-
force
planning
Learning
&
Deve-
lopment
Perfor-
mance
Mana-
gement
Reward
Well-
ness
ERM OD
HR Service
Delivery
HR Technology
(HRIS)
Prepare
Imple-
ment
Review ImproveHR MEASUREMENT
HR Audit: Standards & Metrics
HRCOMPETENCIES
SABPP HRM SYSTEM STANDARDS MODEL
Risk / Readiness Profile
HR RISK MANAGEMENT
STANDARD
DEFINITION
HR Risk Management is a systematic
approach of identifying and addressing people
risks (uncertainties and opportunities) that can
either have a positive or negative effect on the
realisation of the objectives of an
organisation.
SABPP (2013)
Do you manage HR risk?
HR Risk Management
OBJECTIVES
3.2.1 To increase the probability and impact of positive events and decrease the
probability and impact of negative events caused by people factors on the
achievement of organisational objectives.
3.2.2 To align HR and people management practices within the governance, risk
and compliance framework and integrated reporting model of the organisation.
3.2.3 To ensure appropriate risk assessment practices and procedures relating to
people factors are embedded within the organisation.
3.2.4 To ensure appropriate risk controls are designed and applied to HR activities
and interventions.
3.2.5 To contribute in creating and sustaining a risk culture in an organisation
which also encourages innovation and creativity.
SABPP (2013)
 181 babies died in state hospitals last year.
 Human errors, faulty equipment
& cover-up by senior medical staff were key
factors.
 Infection-control nurse retired, and her post not
filled.
 Critical shortage of nurses & clinical engineers
who are responsible for maintaining ventilators.
 Senior doctors presented inaccurate stats to their
bosses to cover up poor management practices.
 Doctors failed to alert DoH to the crisis, even
though a few nurses had raised the alarm to
management.
Public sector case study
HR RISK MANAGEMENT PROCESS
Assessment of
risk tolerance
for each risk
Identify and
evaluate impact of
HR risks
HR practices,
programmes, metrics to
manage risks
HR Risk Map
HR Risk
Register
Organisation’s risk
management
structures and
processes
HR Risk
Register
HR Risk
Management
Plan
HR Risk Map
MONITOR &
EVALUATE
H R R I S K S – 8 African countries
• Safety - accidents
• Skills shortages/gaps
• Incompetence
• Employee
disengagement
• Strikes & poor
employment
relationships
• Fraud/corruption
• Stress
• Staff turnover
• Low staff satisfaction –
impact on customer
satisfaction
• Cyber security
• Conflict/disputes
• Diversity problems
• Sexual harassment
• Expatriate issues
• Non-compliance
HR Risk?
HR Standards Files
13 standards (2013) 19 standards (2014)
HR Professional Practice Standards
• Absenteeism management
• Career management
• Coaching & mentoring
• Collective bargaining
• Disciplinary procedure
• Dispute resolution
• Diversity management
• Grievance procedure
• Leadership development
• Learning design
• Learning evaluation
• Learning needs analysis
• On-boarding
• Organisation design
• Performance appraisals
• Recruitment
• Remuneration benchmarking
• Selection
• Succession planning
BUSINESS STRATEGY – HR BUSINESS ALIGNMENT
Strategic
HRM
5.0
Talent
Management
4.3
HR Risk
Management
4.1
FUNCTIONAL & CROSS FUNCTIONAL HR VALUE CHAIN
HR VALUE &
DELIVERY PLATFORM
Work-
force
Planning
4.4
Learning
5.7
Perfor-
mance
5.3
Reward
4.7
Well-
ness 5.5
ERM
5.8
OD
4.7
HR Service
Delivery
5.6
HR Technology
(HRIS) 4.6
Prepare
Imple-
ment
Review ImproveMEASURING HR SUCCESS 3.8
HR Audit: Standards & Metrics
HRCOMPETENCIES
SELF RATINGS – OVERALL AVERAGE MAY 2016
400
responses
BUSINESS STRATEGY – HR BUSINESS ALIGNMENT
Strategic
HRM
6.0
Talent
Management
4.8
HR Risk
Management
6.5
FUNCTIONAL & CROSS FUNCTIONAL HR VALUE CHAIN
HR VALUE &
DELIVERY PLATFORM
Work-
force
Planning
5.8
Learning
6.5
Perfor-
mance
6.3
Reward
6.3
Well-
ness
6.6
ERM
6.6
OD
5.7
HR Service
Delivery
5.6
HR Technology
(HRIS) 5.6
Prepare
Imple-
ment
Review ImproveMEASURING HR SUCCESS 4.9
HR Audit: Standards & Metrics
HRCOMPETENCIES
AUDIT SCORES – OVERALL AVERAGE MAY 2016
17 audits
Link to risk
• The HR Risk Standard provides you with the
methodology and steps to identify and
manage people risks.
• Any standard scoring less than 60% in an
audit puts the organisation at risk.
• Build robust risk mitigation strategies in all
underperforming areas.
• Create a culture of continuous improvement.
Value of HR Audits
HR Audits as valuable instrument to mitigate
HR risks and to improve HR impact
Email: hraudit@sabpp.co.za
Tel: (011) 045 5400
2015 was our first year of HR
Audits
HR Audit - Certification
What the Auditors are looking for?
Positive trend in
results?
Sustainable?
Targets met?
External benchmarks?
Approach vs results?
Quality of
results
Across whole
organisation?
Up and down the
organisation?
Extent of
application
Sound?
Systematic?
Integrated?
Reviewed & updated?
Quality
approach
RATING SCALE TO ASSESS HR
PROBLEMATIC MEDIOCRE EXCELLENT
High Risk Medium Risk Low/no Risk
HR practice is non-existent,
has a low uptake or is applied
poorly. Little, no or poor
results are evident. Requires
urgent attention to move to
medium risk over short or
medium term.
Some pockets of excellence,
but they are isolated, and
applied inconsistently in
certain parts of company.
Some occasional positive
results comparable to typical
average HR standards. Should
be addressed before it
becomes problematic.
HR leading practice is well
infused, aligned and integra-
ted across the company and
applied consistently with clear
results. Comparable to world-
class standards. Should be
maintained, reinforced or used
as a model for other
companies.
SUSTAINABLE PERFORMANCE
“Whether a company sustains exceptional performance
depends first and foremost on whether it continues to
have the right people in power.”
Can HR Standards mitigate risk?
• The 13 HR standards are positioned as a
risk-based framework to manage your
people risk in organisations.
• The HR Risk standard provides specific
focus on people risks.
• Identify and mitigate your HR risks.
• HR audits can be used as part of the 5 lines
of assurance in accordance with King IV.™
• Apply the HR standards (and HR Risk) and
get your HR function audited.
Conclusion
HR Standards usher in a new period of
institutionalising people management as a
best practice for sound HR professionalism in
organisations. As HR practitioners you are the
specialists who can make this change
successful. Let us build great organisations
with great people and HR functions in driving
our business strategies, while mitigating HR
risks in the process.
We set HR standards!
professional@sabpp.co.za or registrations@sabpp.co.za
(Professional Registration)
executiveoffice@sabpp.co.za (CEO office)
marius@sabpp.co.za (CEO & Strategy inputs)
xolani@sabpp.co.za (COO)
hraudit@sabpp.co.za (HR Audits)
lathasha@sabpp.co.za (Knowledge & Innovation)
naren@sabpp.co.za (Learning & Quality)
events@sabpp.co.za (Events & HR Standards files)
Website: www.sabpp.co.za Blog: hrtoday.me
Office: 8 Sherborne Str, Parktown
Tel: 011 045-5400 Fax: 011 482-4830

Can HR Standards Mitigate Risk?

  • 1.
    CAN HR STANDARDSMITIGATE RISK? Xolani Mawande, COO: SABPP 3rd Annual HR Conference 2 June 2016 @xolani_mawande @SABPP1
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Global HR trends •Strategic HR as foundation for HR success • HR business partner role • Talent management • HR Governance – making better and ethican decisions about people • HR Risk Management • HR Technology + social media • Innovating the HR function and business • OD focus in HR work – employee engagement • HR measurement – big data & metrics • HR competencies and standards
  • 4.
    HR Risk Management:It is all about people factors
  • 5.
    Top facts aboutHR • Human Capital is the biggest concern for CEOs (PwC). • Only 18% of CEOs feel confident that they have the right people in place to execute strategy (CEB). • Human Capital is the biggest risk in business (HCI Africa). • Skills crisis is the top obstacle to economic growth. • Strikes cost SA R 200 million+ per day.
  • 6.
    More facts aboutHR • SA losing R12 billion a year due to absenteeism. • Only 19% auditors feel they use HR optimally (CG Index – Institute of Internal Auditors) • Only 5% employees understand business strategy. • World-wide 13% of employees actively engaged. • Companies with engaged employees outperform others by 202% (Dale Carnegie). • Companies with good HR Practices outperform others by treating HR as critical business function, these companies are 105% more profitable. • Average ROI on wellness programmes: 300%.
  • 7.
  • 8.
    What are standardsreally? • A level of acceptable quality • Good enough in terms of professionalism • What is good or normal or usual • A guideline for practice • A foundation for reasonable expectations and sound judgement • A framework for managing risk • A basis for measurement (M&E)
  • 9.
    468 HR Leadersdeveloping HR Standards for South Africa
  • 10.
    BUSINESS STRATEGY –HR BUSINESS ALIGNMENT Strategic HRM Talent Management HR Risk Management HR ARCHITECTURE I HR VALUE & DELIVERY PLATFORM Work- force planning Learning & Deve- lopment Perfor- mance Mana- gement Reward Well- ness ERM OD HR Service Delivery HR Technology (HRIS) Prepare Imple- ment Review ImproveHR MEASUREMENT HR Audit: Standards & Metrics HRCOMPETENCIES SABPP HRM SYSTEM STANDARDS MODEL
  • 11.
  • 12.
    HR RISK MANAGEMENT STANDARD DEFINITION HRRisk Management is a systematic approach of identifying and addressing people risks (uncertainties and opportunities) that can either have a positive or negative effect on the realisation of the objectives of an organisation. SABPP (2013)
  • 13.
    Do you manageHR risk?
  • 14.
    HR Risk Management OBJECTIVES 3.2.1To increase the probability and impact of positive events and decrease the probability and impact of negative events caused by people factors on the achievement of organisational objectives. 3.2.2 To align HR and people management practices within the governance, risk and compliance framework and integrated reporting model of the organisation. 3.2.3 To ensure appropriate risk assessment practices and procedures relating to people factors are embedded within the organisation. 3.2.4 To ensure appropriate risk controls are designed and applied to HR activities and interventions. 3.2.5 To contribute in creating and sustaining a risk culture in an organisation which also encourages innovation and creativity. SABPP (2013)
  • 15.
     181 babiesdied in state hospitals last year.  Human errors, faulty equipment & cover-up by senior medical staff were key factors.  Infection-control nurse retired, and her post not filled.  Critical shortage of nurses & clinical engineers who are responsible for maintaining ventilators.  Senior doctors presented inaccurate stats to their bosses to cover up poor management practices.  Doctors failed to alert DoH to the crisis, even though a few nurses had raised the alarm to management. Public sector case study
  • 16.
    HR RISK MANAGEMENTPROCESS Assessment of risk tolerance for each risk Identify and evaluate impact of HR risks HR practices, programmes, metrics to manage risks HR Risk Map HR Risk Register Organisation’s risk management structures and processes HR Risk Register HR Risk Management Plan HR Risk Map MONITOR & EVALUATE
  • 17.
    H R RI S K S – 8 African countries • Safety - accidents • Skills shortages/gaps • Incompetence • Employee disengagement • Strikes & poor employment relationships • Fraud/corruption • Stress • Staff turnover • Low staff satisfaction – impact on customer satisfaction • Cyber security • Conflict/disputes • Diversity problems • Sexual harassment • Expatriate issues • Non-compliance
  • 18.
  • 19.
    HR Standards Files 13standards (2013) 19 standards (2014)
  • 20.
    HR Professional PracticeStandards • Absenteeism management • Career management • Coaching & mentoring • Collective bargaining • Disciplinary procedure • Dispute resolution • Diversity management • Grievance procedure • Leadership development • Learning design • Learning evaluation • Learning needs analysis • On-boarding • Organisation design • Performance appraisals • Recruitment • Remuneration benchmarking • Selection • Succession planning
  • 21.
    BUSINESS STRATEGY –HR BUSINESS ALIGNMENT Strategic HRM 5.0 Talent Management 4.3 HR Risk Management 4.1 FUNCTIONAL & CROSS FUNCTIONAL HR VALUE CHAIN HR VALUE & DELIVERY PLATFORM Work- force Planning 4.4 Learning 5.7 Perfor- mance 5.3 Reward 4.7 Well- ness 5.5 ERM 5.8 OD 4.7 HR Service Delivery 5.6 HR Technology (HRIS) 4.6 Prepare Imple- ment Review ImproveMEASURING HR SUCCESS 3.8 HR Audit: Standards & Metrics HRCOMPETENCIES SELF RATINGS – OVERALL AVERAGE MAY 2016 400 responses
  • 22.
    BUSINESS STRATEGY –HR BUSINESS ALIGNMENT Strategic HRM 6.0 Talent Management 4.8 HR Risk Management 6.5 FUNCTIONAL & CROSS FUNCTIONAL HR VALUE CHAIN HR VALUE & DELIVERY PLATFORM Work- force Planning 5.8 Learning 6.5 Perfor- mance 6.3 Reward 6.3 Well- ness 6.6 ERM 6.6 OD 5.7 HR Service Delivery 5.6 HR Technology (HRIS) 5.6 Prepare Imple- ment Review ImproveMEASURING HR SUCCESS 4.9 HR Audit: Standards & Metrics HRCOMPETENCIES AUDIT SCORES – OVERALL AVERAGE MAY 2016 17 audits
  • 23.
    Link to risk •The HR Risk Standard provides you with the methodology and steps to identify and manage people risks. • Any standard scoring less than 60% in an audit puts the organisation at risk. • Build robust risk mitigation strategies in all underperforming areas. • Create a culture of continuous improvement.
  • 24.
    Value of HRAudits HR Audits as valuable instrument to mitigate HR risks and to improve HR impact Email: hraudit@sabpp.co.za Tel: (011) 045 5400
  • 25.
    2015 was ourfirst year of HR Audits
  • 26.
    HR Audit -Certification
  • 27.
    What the Auditorsare looking for? Positive trend in results? Sustainable? Targets met? External benchmarks? Approach vs results? Quality of results Across whole organisation? Up and down the organisation? Extent of application Sound? Systematic? Integrated? Reviewed & updated? Quality approach
  • 28.
    RATING SCALE TOASSESS HR PROBLEMATIC MEDIOCRE EXCELLENT High Risk Medium Risk Low/no Risk HR practice is non-existent, has a low uptake or is applied poorly. Little, no or poor results are evident. Requires urgent attention to move to medium risk over short or medium term. Some pockets of excellence, but they are isolated, and applied inconsistently in certain parts of company. Some occasional positive results comparable to typical average HR standards. Should be addressed before it becomes problematic. HR leading practice is well infused, aligned and integra- ted across the company and applied consistently with clear results. Comparable to world- class standards. Should be maintained, reinforced or used as a model for other companies.
  • 29.
    SUSTAINABLE PERFORMANCE “Whether acompany sustains exceptional performance depends first and foremost on whether it continues to have the right people in power.”
  • 31.
    Can HR Standardsmitigate risk? • The 13 HR standards are positioned as a risk-based framework to manage your people risk in organisations. • The HR Risk standard provides specific focus on people risks. • Identify and mitigate your HR risks. • HR audits can be used as part of the 5 lines of assurance in accordance with King IV.™ • Apply the HR standards (and HR Risk) and get your HR function audited.
  • 32.
    Conclusion HR Standards usherin a new period of institutionalising people management as a best practice for sound HR professionalism in organisations. As HR practitioners you are the specialists who can make this change successful. Let us build great organisations with great people and HR functions in driving our business strategies, while mitigating HR risks in the process.
  • 33.
    We set HRstandards! professional@sabpp.co.za or registrations@sabpp.co.za (Professional Registration) executiveoffice@sabpp.co.za (CEO office) marius@sabpp.co.za (CEO & Strategy inputs) xolani@sabpp.co.za (COO) hraudit@sabpp.co.za (HR Audits) lathasha@sabpp.co.za (Knowledge & Innovation) naren@sabpp.co.za (Learning & Quality) events@sabpp.co.za (Events & HR Standards files) Website: www.sabpp.co.za Blog: hrtoday.me Office: 8 Sherborne Str, Parktown Tel: 011 045-5400 Fax: 011 482-4830