SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Challenge:
Over an extended period of time, Sponsor X had been investing in a large and diverse range of partnership
programs including community initiatives, individual athletes, national sporting teams, venues and media
sponsorships. A new corporate strategy, requirement for greater accountability and austerity measures
required the portfolio to be objectively assessed to ensure it met the ongoing needs/ challenges of the
organisation, and objectives of the brand.
Action:
To achieve these requirements, Sponsorium applied PerforMind:
1. Created a set of weighted criteria in order to assess the performance of all partnerships against the new
corporate strategy.
2. Designed an online partnership audit and assessment process based upon this new criteria.
3. A link to the online audit and assessment form was then sent to the relevant partnership managers and
store managers with instructions to submit their programs, events or projects.
4. The online form asked for key information (property contract details, expenditure, etc), but also, asked
questions relevant to the new criteria of which the weightings sit behind the question.
5. The recipient filled out the form and submitted the partnership to the PerforMind database. An
automated notification of a new record was then sent to HQ.
PerforMind Audit Example; European based Retailer
6. Sponsorium project managed this process, advised on the form design and content and provided local
support to those who needed help with form filling.
7. The audit was given a deadline for all submissions to be made, after which all partnership records were
centralised in a consistent format.
8. PerforMind then generated automatic summary reports on every partnership and a custom macro report
on issues such as number and type of partnerships by sector, region, date, length, expiry date, expenditure
(in cash and value in kind).
9. PerforMind had also automatically assessed each partnership on three dimensions – score (against
weighted criteria) – cost per point (dividing score by budget), and a grid comparing each partnership to the
average.
10.With all partnerships centralised the next step was to use PerforMind as an approval process for renewals
and any future partnership deals. The evaluation process also ensured that all new partnerships were
aligned to the corporate objectives and the scoring and cost per point system was used to help negotiate
deals.
11.Now PerforMind provides the process, transparency and governance for all future decision making and
expenditure.
Result:
• The entire portfolio was ranked in accordance to the brand’s partnership & corporate objectives
• The brand team and management received objective information as to how the existing portfolio (and
properties) could be improved to meet business objectives via either/ or rights enhancement, fee
negotiation or property removal.
• The re-balanced and prioritised portfolio was then more aligned with the objectives and requirements of
the brand and organisation.
• Local partnership and store managers engaged the process and found the results fed back to them helpful
in terms of assessing new proposals.
• The overall portfolio rights expenditure decreased by 60%, with both rights fees and leverage costs either
placed back into the marcomms budget to optimise key properties or accrued with overall budget. The rights of
the existing (new) portfolio now improved its delivery of the Return on Objectives (ROO) by 40%
• The company also aligned their buying model on the Cost Per Point. Whereas previously their sponsorships
ranged from 500 to 150 Cost Per Point they now work off a lower average of 100 Cost Per Point and have
introduced this as a Group policy.
pts
1000 ● ●
● ●
800 ● ● ●
● ●
600 ● ●
● ●
400 ● ●
200
0 €/pt
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800
pts
1000
800 ●
● ● ● ●
600 ● ●
400 ● ● ● ●
● ● ●
200 ● ●
● ●
0 €/pt
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800
Portfolio Pre Audit Portfolio Post Audit

More Related Content

What's hot

Role of Auditors in Punjab National Bank Scam
Role of Auditors in Punjab National Bank ScamRole of Auditors in Punjab National Bank Scam
Role of Auditors in Punjab National Bank Scam
GurbaniLuthra
 
Punjab National Bank- Nirav Modi Fraud
Punjab National Bank- Nirav Modi Fraud Punjab National Bank- Nirav Modi Fraud
Punjab National Bank- Nirav Modi Fraud
21rahul1999
 
PNB SCAM (NIRAV MODI)
PNB SCAM (NIRAV MODI)PNB SCAM (NIRAV MODI)
PNB SCAM (NIRAV MODI)
Nitin Pandey
 
Auditing Standard and Practice
Auditing Standard and Practice Auditing Standard and Practice
Auditing Standard and Practice
Bikash Kumar
 
Forensic Accounting
Forensic AccountingForensic Accounting
Forensic Accounting
Nabendu Maji
 
Fraud Management ppt.pptx
Fraud Management ppt.pptxFraud Management ppt.pptx
Fraud Management ppt.pptx
jaramulat
 
“NIRAV MODI & THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK FRAUD”
“NIRAV MODI & THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK FRAUD”“NIRAV MODI & THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK FRAUD”
“NIRAV MODI & THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK FRAUD”
Vatsal Patel
 
Punjab National Bank (PNB) Scam
Punjab National Bank (PNB) Scam Punjab National Bank (PNB) Scam
Punjab National Bank (PNB) Scam
Subrata Sarkar
 
History of Accounting Thought
History of Accounting ThoughtHistory of Accounting Thought
History of Accounting Thought
Abu Hasan Al-Nahiyan
 
Fraud Detection presentation
Fraud Detection presentationFraud Detection presentation
Fraud Detection presentation
Hernan Huwyler
 
Presentation on corporate frauds
Presentation on corporate fraudsPresentation on corporate frauds
Presentation on corporate frauds
Muti ur Rahman Khan Lodhi
 
Audit process model
Audit process  modelAudit process  model
Audit process model
Armaghan khan
 
LAPORAN INTERNAL AUDIT DAN KETERAMPILAN AUDIT PPT.pptx
LAPORAN INTERNAL AUDIT DAN KETERAMPILAN AUDIT PPT.pptxLAPORAN INTERNAL AUDIT DAN KETERAMPILAN AUDIT PPT.pptx
LAPORAN INTERNAL AUDIT DAN KETERAMPILAN AUDIT PPT.pptx
LuviaHusna
 
Fraud Cases in Auditing
Fraud Cases in AuditingFraud Cases in Auditing
Fraud Cases in Auditing
Raymond Kulzick
 
AUDIT CASE
AUDIT CASEAUDIT CASE
AUDIT CASE
ZarfARIE ARON
 
PNB SCAM.pptx
PNB SCAM.pptxPNB SCAM.pptx
PNB SCAM.pptx
SabyasachiSahu16
 
Accounting Fraud At WorldCom
Accounting Fraud At WorldComAccounting Fraud At WorldCom
Accounting Fraud At WorldCom
Nadeem Hazari
 
Chapter 11, Tests of Controls
Chapter 11, Tests of ControlsChapter 11, Tests of Controls
Chapter 11, Tests of Controls
Sazzad Hossain, ITP, MBA, CSCA™
 
A Report on the Punjab National Bank Scam (Nirav Modi)
A Report on the Punjab National Bank Scam (Nirav Modi)A Report on the Punjab National Bank Scam (Nirav Modi)
A Report on the Punjab National Bank Scam (Nirav Modi)
Yohan DSouza
 
Auditing activities of microfinance institutions
Auditing activities of microfinance institutionsAuditing activities of microfinance institutions
Auditing activities of microfinance institutions
Frank Kabuye, CPA
 

What's hot (20)

Role of Auditors in Punjab National Bank Scam
Role of Auditors in Punjab National Bank ScamRole of Auditors in Punjab National Bank Scam
Role of Auditors in Punjab National Bank Scam
 
Punjab National Bank- Nirav Modi Fraud
Punjab National Bank- Nirav Modi Fraud Punjab National Bank- Nirav Modi Fraud
Punjab National Bank- Nirav Modi Fraud
 
PNB SCAM (NIRAV MODI)
PNB SCAM (NIRAV MODI)PNB SCAM (NIRAV MODI)
PNB SCAM (NIRAV MODI)
 
Auditing Standard and Practice
Auditing Standard and Practice Auditing Standard and Practice
Auditing Standard and Practice
 
Forensic Accounting
Forensic AccountingForensic Accounting
Forensic Accounting
 
Fraud Management ppt.pptx
Fraud Management ppt.pptxFraud Management ppt.pptx
Fraud Management ppt.pptx
 
“NIRAV MODI & THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK FRAUD”
“NIRAV MODI & THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK FRAUD”“NIRAV MODI & THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK FRAUD”
“NIRAV MODI & THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK FRAUD”
 
Punjab National Bank (PNB) Scam
Punjab National Bank (PNB) Scam Punjab National Bank (PNB) Scam
Punjab National Bank (PNB) Scam
 
History of Accounting Thought
History of Accounting ThoughtHistory of Accounting Thought
History of Accounting Thought
 
Fraud Detection presentation
Fraud Detection presentationFraud Detection presentation
Fraud Detection presentation
 
Presentation on corporate frauds
Presentation on corporate fraudsPresentation on corporate frauds
Presentation on corporate frauds
 
Audit process model
Audit process  modelAudit process  model
Audit process model
 
LAPORAN INTERNAL AUDIT DAN KETERAMPILAN AUDIT PPT.pptx
LAPORAN INTERNAL AUDIT DAN KETERAMPILAN AUDIT PPT.pptxLAPORAN INTERNAL AUDIT DAN KETERAMPILAN AUDIT PPT.pptx
LAPORAN INTERNAL AUDIT DAN KETERAMPILAN AUDIT PPT.pptx
 
Fraud Cases in Auditing
Fraud Cases in AuditingFraud Cases in Auditing
Fraud Cases in Auditing
 
AUDIT CASE
AUDIT CASEAUDIT CASE
AUDIT CASE
 
PNB SCAM.pptx
PNB SCAM.pptxPNB SCAM.pptx
PNB SCAM.pptx
 
Accounting Fraud At WorldCom
Accounting Fraud At WorldComAccounting Fraud At WorldCom
Accounting Fraud At WorldCom
 
Chapter 11, Tests of Controls
Chapter 11, Tests of ControlsChapter 11, Tests of Controls
Chapter 11, Tests of Controls
 
A Report on the Punjab National Bank Scam (Nirav Modi)
A Report on the Punjab National Bank Scam (Nirav Modi)A Report on the Punjab National Bank Scam (Nirav Modi)
A Report on the Punjab National Bank Scam (Nirav Modi)
 
Auditing activities of microfinance institutions
Auditing activities of microfinance institutionsAuditing activities of microfinance institutions
Auditing activities of microfinance institutions
 

Viewers also liked

Reebok scam 2012 fraud
Reebok scam 2012 fraudReebok scam 2012 fraud
Reebok scam 2012 fraud
Karan Kukreja
 
The Internal Audit Framework
The Internal Audit FrameworkThe Internal Audit Framework
The Internal Audit Framework
Ahmad Tariq Bhatti
 
Auditing (Introduction to Auditing)
Auditing (Introduction to Auditing) Auditing (Introduction to Auditing)
Auditing (Introduction to Auditing)
Noorulhadi Qureshi
 
Project audit & review checklist
Project audit & review checklistProject audit & review checklist
Project audit & review checklist
Ram Srivastava
 
Audit presentation
Audit presentationAudit presentation
Audit presentation
Metafrique group
 
Basic Internal Auditing Presentation
Basic Internal Auditing PresentationBasic Internal Auditing Presentation
Basic Internal Auditing Presentation
Vernon Benjamin
 
Basic Internal Auditing Presentation
Basic Internal Auditing PresentationBasic Internal Auditing Presentation
Basic Internal Auditing Presentation
Vernon Benjamin
 
Audit Process, Audit Procedures, Audit Planning, Auditing
Audit Process, Audit Procedures, Audit Planning, AuditingAudit Process, Audit Procedures, Audit Planning, Auditing
Audit Process, Audit Procedures, Audit Planning, Auditing
Advance Business Consulting
 
Introduction to auditing
Introduction to auditingIntroduction to auditing
Introduction to auditing
WINNERbd.it
 

Viewers also liked (9)

Reebok scam 2012 fraud
Reebok scam 2012 fraudReebok scam 2012 fraud
Reebok scam 2012 fraud
 
The Internal Audit Framework
The Internal Audit FrameworkThe Internal Audit Framework
The Internal Audit Framework
 
Auditing (Introduction to Auditing)
Auditing (Introduction to Auditing) Auditing (Introduction to Auditing)
Auditing (Introduction to Auditing)
 
Project audit & review checklist
Project audit & review checklistProject audit & review checklist
Project audit & review checklist
 
Audit presentation
Audit presentationAudit presentation
Audit presentation
 
Basic Internal Auditing Presentation
Basic Internal Auditing PresentationBasic Internal Auditing Presentation
Basic Internal Auditing Presentation
 
Basic Internal Auditing Presentation
Basic Internal Auditing PresentationBasic Internal Auditing Presentation
Basic Internal Auditing Presentation
 
Audit Process, Audit Procedures, Audit Planning, Auditing
Audit Process, Audit Procedures, Audit Planning, AuditingAudit Process, Audit Procedures, Audit Planning, Auditing
Audit Process, Audit Procedures, Audit Planning, Auditing
 
Introduction to auditing
Introduction to auditingIntroduction to auditing
Introduction to auditing
 

Similar to Audit case study

supply-chain-finance-jul17.pdf
supply-chain-finance-jul17.pdfsupply-chain-finance-jul17.pdf
ISC Brochure
ISC BrochureISC Brochure
ISC Brochure
Mark Tully
 
Presentation on uniform costing
Presentation on uniform costingPresentation on uniform costing
Presentation on uniform costing
Jatin Goyal
 
CHANNEL MANAGEMENT CHECKLIST
CHANNEL MANAGEMENT CHECKLISTCHANNEL MANAGEMENT CHECKLIST
CHANNEL MANAGEMENT CHECKLIST
Pradeep Banerjee
 
The Age of Alignment Part III: Moving From Theory to Practice
The Age of Alignment Part III: Moving From Theory to PracticeThe Age of Alignment Part III: Moving From Theory to Practice
The Age of Alignment Part III: Moving From Theory to Practice
Pearl Meyer
 
Whitepaper - Developing a Productive Partner Ecosystem.2014
Whitepaper - Developing a Productive Partner Ecosystem.2014Whitepaper - Developing a Productive Partner Ecosystem.2014
Whitepaper - Developing a Productive Partner Ecosystem.2014
Peter Bricknell
 
Channel marketing fund overview (MDF/Co-Op)
Channel marketing fund overview (MDF/Co-Op)Channel marketing fund overview (MDF/Co-Op)
Channel marketing fund overview (MDF/Co-Op)
Ashish Saxena
 
The role of finance in the strategic planning and decision-making process
The role of finance in the strategic planning and decision-making processThe role of finance in the strategic planning and decision-making process
The role of finance in the strategic planning and decision-making process
yashikagupta48
 
Pricing , lisencing and portfolios in tech transfer
Pricing , lisencing and portfolios in tech transferPricing , lisencing and portfolios in tech transfer
Pricing , lisencing and portfolios in tech transfer
RakshaSharma26
 
Morgan motor car company
Morgan motor car companyMorgan motor car company
Morgan motor car company
Feroza Khatun
 
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing PlatformForrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Donna Chang
 
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing PlatformForrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Paul Enriquez
 
Application sourcing focused on value, not cost alone
Application sourcing focused on value, not cost aloneApplication sourcing focused on value, not cost alone
Application sourcing focused on value, not cost alone
WGroup
 
kalafsky Resume 032315
kalafsky Resume 032315 kalafsky Resume 032315
kalafsky Resume 032315
Mark Kalafsky
 
RESUME James Gilchrist MAR 2015
RESUME James Gilchrist MAR 2015RESUME James Gilchrist MAR 2015
RESUME James Gilchrist MAR 2015
James Gilchrist
 
FTE outsourcing_PharmaNetwork_sep2014
FTE outsourcing_PharmaNetwork_sep2014FTE outsourcing_PharmaNetwork_sep2014
FTE outsourcing_PharmaNetwork_sep2014
Frédéric Gaussens
 
Blackstone Synergy Consulting Group - MOA
Blackstone Synergy Consulting Group - MOABlackstone Synergy Consulting Group - MOA
Blackstone Synergy Consulting Group - MOA
Debashish Banerjee
 
Channel Marketing Automation Can Increase Channel Management Maturity
Channel Marketing Automation Can Increase Channel Management MaturityChannel Marketing Automation Can Increase Channel Management Maturity
Channel Marketing Automation Can Increase Channel Management Maturity
ZINFI Technologies, Inc.
 
Operations in Source to Pay (S2P) Cycle
Operations in Source to Pay (S2P) CycleOperations in Source to Pay (S2P) Cycle
Operations in Source to Pay (S2P) Cycle
IRJET Journal
 
10 Key Steps to Law Firm Transition Planning
10 Key Steps to Law Firm Transition Planning 10 Key Steps to Law Firm Transition Planning
10 Key Steps to Law Firm Transition Planning
PerformLaw
 

Similar to Audit case study (20)

supply-chain-finance-jul17.pdf
supply-chain-finance-jul17.pdfsupply-chain-finance-jul17.pdf
supply-chain-finance-jul17.pdf
 
ISC Brochure
ISC BrochureISC Brochure
ISC Brochure
 
Presentation on uniform costing
Presentation on uniform costingPresentation on uniform costing
Presentation on uniform costing
 
CHANNEL MANAGEMENT CHECKLIST
CHANNEL MANAGEMENT CHECKLISTCHANNEL MANAGEMENT CHECKLIST
CHANNEL MANAGEMENT CHECKLIST
 
The Age of Alignment Part III: Moving From Theory to Practice
The Age of Alignment Part III: Moving From Theory to PracticeThe Age of Alignment Part III: Moving From Theory to Practice
The Age of Alignment Part III: Moving From Theory to Practice
 
Whitepaper - Developing a Productive Partner Ecosystem.2014
Whitepaper - Developing a Productive Partner Ecosystem.2014Whitepaper - Developing a Productive Partner Ecosystem.2014
Whitepaper - Developing a Productive Partner Ecosystem.2014
 
Channel marketing fund overview (MDF/Co-Op)
Channel marketing fund overview (MDF/Co-Op)Channel marketing fund overview (MDF/Co-Op)
Channel marketing fund overview (MDF/Co-Op)
 
The role of finance in the strategic planning and decision-making process
The role of finance in the strategic planning and decision-making processThe role of finance in the strategic planning and decision-making process
The role of finance in the strategic planning and decision-making process
 
Pricing , lisencing and portfolios in tech transfer
Pricing , lisencing and portfolios in tech transferPricing , lisencing and portfolios in tech transfer
Pricing , lisencing and portfolios in tech transfer
 
Morgan motor car company
Morgan motor car companyMorgan motor car company
Morgan motor car company
 
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing PlatformForrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
 
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing PlatformForrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
Forrester Consultiung - TEI of Rocket Fuel Programmatic Marketing Platform
 
Application sourcing focused on value, not cost alone
Application sourcing focused on value, not cost aloneApplication sourcing focused on value, not cost alone
Application sourcing focused on value, not cost alone
 
kalafsky Resume 032315
kalafsky Resume 032315 kalafsky Resume 032315
kalafsky Resume 032315
 
RESUME James Gilchrist MAR 2015
RESUME James Gilchrist MAR 2015RESUME James Gilchrist MAR 2015
RESUME James Gilchrist MAR 2015
 
FTE outsourcing_PharmaNetwork_sep2014
FTE outsourcing_PharmaNetwork_sep2014FTE outsourcing_PharmaNetwork_sep2014
FTE outsourcing_PharmaNetwork_sep2014
 
Blackstone Synergy Consulting Group - MOA
Blackstone Synergy Consulting Group - MOABlackstone Synergy Consulting Group - MOA
Blackstone Synergy Consulting Group - MOA
 
Channel Marketing Automation Can Increase Channel Management Maturity
Channel Marketing Automation Can Increase Channel Management MaturityChannel Marketing Automation Can Increase Channel Management Maturity
Channel Marketing Automation Can Increase Channel Management Maturity
 
Operations in Source to Pay (S2P) Cycle
Operations in Source to Pay (S2P) CycleOperations in Source to Pay (S2P) Cycle
Operations in Source to Pay (S2P) Cycle
 
10 Key Steps to Law Firm Transition Planning
10 Key Steps to Law Firm Transition Planning 10 Key Steps to Law Firm Transition Planning
10 Key Steps to Law Firm Transition Planning
 

Audit case study

  • 1. Challenge: Over an extended period of time, Sponsor X had been investing in a large and diverse range of partnership programs including community initiatives, individual athletes, national sporting teams, venues and media sponsorships. A new corporate strategy, requirement for greater accountability and austerity measures required the portfolio to be objectively assessed to ensure it met the ongoing needs/ challenges of the organisation, and objectives of the brand. Action: To achieve these requirements, Sponsorium applied PerforMind: 1. Created a set of weighted criteria in order to assess the performance of all partnerships against the new corporate strategy. 2. Designed an online partnership audit and assessment process based upon this new criteria. 3. A link to the online audit and assessment form was then sent to the relevant partnership managers and store managers with instructions to submit their programs, events or projects. 4. The online form asked for key information (property contract details, expenditure, etc), but also, asked questions relevant to the new criteria of which the weightings sit behind the question. 5. The recipient filled out the form and submitted the partnership to the PerforMind database. An automated notification of a new record was then sent to HQ. PerforMind Audit Example; European based Retailer
  • 2. 6. Sponsorium project managed this process, advised on the form design and content and provided local support to those who needed help with form filling. 7. The audit was given a deadline for all submissions to be made, after which all partnership records were centralised in a consistent format. 8. PerforMind then generated automatic summary reports on every partnership and a custom macro report on issues such as number and type of partnerships by sector, region, date, length, expiry date, expenditure (in cash and value in kind). 9. PerforMind had also automatically assessed each partnership on three dimensions – score (against weighted criteria) – cost per point (dividing score by budget), and a grid comparing each partnership to the average. 10.With all partnerships centralised the next step was to use PerforMind as an approval process for renewals and any future partnership deals. The evaluation process also ensured that all new partnerships were aligned to the corporate objectives and the scoring and cost per point system was used to help negotiate deals. 11.Now PerforMind provides the process, transparency and governance for all future decision making and expenditure.
  • 3. Result: • The entire portfolio was ranked in accordance to the brand’s partnership & corporate objectives • The brand team and management received objective information as to how the existing portfolio (and properties) could be improved to meet business objectives via either/ or rights enhancement, fee negotiation or property removal. • The re-balanced and prioritised portfolio was then more aligned with the objectives and requirements of the brand and organisation. • Local partnership and store managers engaged the process and found the results fed back to them helpful in terms of assessing new proposals.
  • 4. • The overall portfolio rights expenditure decreased by 60%, with both rights fees and leverage costs either placed back into the marcomms budget to optimise key properties or accrued with overall budget. The rights of the existing (new) portfolio now improved its delivery of the Return on Objectives (ROO) by 40% • The company also aligned their buying model on the Cost Per Point. Whereas previously their sponsorships ranged from 500 to 150 Cost Per Point they now work off a lower average of 100 Cost Per Point and have introduced this as a Group policy. pts 1000 ● ● ● ● 800 ● ● ● ● ● 600 ● ● ● ● 400 ● ● 200 0 €/pt 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 pts 1000 800 ● ● ● ● ● 600 ● ● 400 ● ● ● ● ● ● ● 200 ● ● ● ● 0 €/pt 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 Portfolio Pre Audit Portfolio Post Audit