ACJ Revision Surgery
Lennard Funk
Functional Anatomy
3
1.5mm
Beardon
! Superior AC Lig = 56% Posterior Translation
! Posterior AC Lig = 25% Posterior Translation
! Klimkiewikcz
! Superior AC Lig = Rotational Stability
! Branch et al.
4
AC Ligaments
Urist, JBJSA. 1946
AC Ligaments
5
! Attaches over 2.6cm of clavicle in men, 2.3cm in
women
! Renfree & Wright
! (1.5cm - Hearnden 2012)
! No difference if superior or inferior AC lig. cut
(horizontal, vertical & rotatory)
! Branch et al. AJSM 1996
! Superior & Posterior not capable of stabilising
clavicle - 32% incr. of posterior translation after
Ant & Inf capsular resection
! Corteen & Teitge
Failed ACJ Excision (Basmania, 1995)
1. Diagnostic Error
2. Inadequate resection
3. Joint Instability
4. Weakness
5. Miscellaneous
6
Failed ACJ Excision (Strauss et al. 2010)
7
Common Causes Less Common Causes
Instability Distal Clavicle Fracture
Under Resection Suprascapular neuropathy
Over Resection Other Cause
- Neck pain, SLAP, etc.
Stiffness (29%)
Bony regrowth
Untreated Concomitant
Pathology
Infection
Failed ACJ Excision (Funk, 2014)
8
Common Causes Less Common Causes
Instability - 22% Distal Clavicle Fracture
Under Resection - 3% Suprascapular neuropathy
Over Resection - 8% Other Cause
- Neck pain, SLAP, etc.
Stiffness - 12%
Bony regrowth
Untreated Concomitant
Pathology - 4%
Infection - 0.8%
Also:
! Post-op pain correlates with Translation,
but not amount of bone resected
! Blazar et al. CORR. 1998
! No difference if superior or inferior AC lig.
cut (horizontal, vertical & rotatory instability)
! Branch et al. AJSM 1996
9
Unstable ACJ
10
ACJ Reconstructions
11
>100 PUBLISHED!!
Harris et al. AJSM 2000
“None of the reconstruction techniques
analyzed in the present study were able to
restore the normal mechanical function of
the intact coracoclavicular ligament
complex”
12
Our Data
Desais, Robinson, Phandis, Funk
In print, 2016
• 23 revisions betw. 2008 - 2015
• Mean Age = 32yrs (20-57)
• M:F = 18:5
13
14
Original Procedure N/23
Tightrope or equivalent 6
Lockdown / Surgilig 6
LARS 4
Weaver-Dunn 3
Hook Plate 3
Bosworth Screw 1
Our Data
Desais, Robinson, Phandis, Funk
In print, 2016
Revision Technique
! Anatomical Reconstruction
! Very strong, but flexible
! Allows early Rehab.
! Biological
! Avoid donor site
! Allows variable options
15
LARS Ligament (Corin)
! Braided Polyethylenetraphthalate
! 1500N tensile strength (30 LAC)
! No reduction in mechanical resilience after
over 10 million wear cycles loaded in
torsion, traction and flexion [Fialka et al. 2005;
! Vascularisation & Fibrous ingrowth -
Collagen Type 1 [Trieb et al. Eur Surg Res. 2004; Yu et al. 2005;
Pelletier & Durand]
16
Incision
17
Shoulderdoc.co.uk
Nottingham Approach
18
Shoulderdoc.co.uk
Procedure(s)
19
"# Remove all previous fix & Scar tissue
$# Micro samples
%# CC Ligs - LARS anatomical + ‘Biceps Flip’
&# AC Ligs - LARS + Reverse CAL Transfer
'# Delto-trapezial Reefing
20
Procedure(s)
Results (failed Reconstructions)
Desais, Robinson, Phandis, Funk
In print, 2016
! 23 cases over 7 years
! Follow-up = 37 months (24-48)
! Constant Score = 51.8 pre to 85.2 post
! 10% re-displaced radiologically
! 13% superficial infections
! No further revisions
21
Results (failed Excisions)
Desais, Robinson, Phandis, Funk
In print, 2016
! 13 cases over 5 years
! Follow-up = 34 months (24-48)
! Constant Score = 26 pre to 73 post
! 1 re-displaced radiologically
! 1 chronic pain
! No further revisions
Summary
! Awareness
! Test for Horizontal & Vertical Instability
! Ultrasound
! CT Scan
! Revise if Symptomatic
! Strong
! Anatomical
! Biological
23
THANK YOU

ACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisions

  • 1.
  • 3.
  • 4.
    ! Superior ACLig = 56% Posterior Translation ! Posterior AC Lig = 25% Posterior Translation ! Klimkiewikcz ! Superior AC Lig = Rotational Stability ! Branch et al. 4 AC Ligaments Urist, JBJSA. 1946
  • 5.
    AC Ligaments 5 ! Attachesover 2.6cm of clavicle in men, 2.3cm in women ! Renfree & Wright ! (1.5cm - Hearnden 2012) ! No difference if superior or inferior AC lig. cut (horizontal, vertical & rotatory) ! Branch et al. AJSM 1996 ! Superior & Posterior not capable of stabilising clavicle - 32% incr. of posterior translation after Ant & Inf capsular resection ! Corteen & Teitge
  • 6.
    Failed ACJ Excision(Basmania, 1995) 1. Diagnostic Error 2. Inadequate resection 3. Joint Instability 4. Weakness 5. Miscellaneous 6
  • 7.
    Failed ACJ Excision(Strauss et al. 2010) 7 Common Causes Less Common Causes Instability Distal Clavicle Fracture Under Resection Suprascapular neuropathy Over Resection Other Cause - Neck pain, SLAP, etc. Stiffness (29%) Bony regrowth Untreated Concomitant Pathology Infection
  • 8.
    Failed ACJ Excision(Funk, 2014) 8 Common Causes Less Common Causes Instability - 22% Distal Clavicle Fracture Under Resection - 3% Suprascapular neuropathy Over Resection - 8% Other Cause - Neck pain, SLAP, etc. Stiffness - 12% Bony regrowth Untreated Concomitant Pathology - 4% Infection - 0.8%
  • 9.
    Also: ! Post-op paincorrelates with Translation, but not amount of bone resected ! Blazar et al. CORR. 1998 ! No difference if superior or inferior AC lig. cut (horizontal, vertical & rotatory instability) ! Branch et al. AJSM 1996 9
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    Harris et al.AJSM 2000 “None of the reconstruction techniques analyzed in the present study were able to restore the normal mechanical function of the intact coracoclavicular ligament complex” 12
  • 13.
    Our Data Desais, Robinson,Phandis, Funk In print, 2016 • 23 revisions betw. 2008 - 2015 • Mean Age = 32yrs (20-57) • M:F = 18:5 13
  • 14.
    14 Original Procedure N/23 Tightropeor equivalent 6 Lockdown / Surgilig 6 LARS 4 Weaver-Dunn 3 Hook Plate 3 Bosworth Screw 1 Our Data Desais, Robinson, Phandis, Funk In print, 2016
  • 15.
    Revision Technique ! AnatomicalReconstruction ! Very strong, but flexible ! Allows early Rehab. ! Biological ! Avoid donor site ! Allows variable options 15
  • 16.
    LARS Ligament (Corin) !Braided Polyethylenetraphthalate ! 1500N tensile strength (30 LAC) ! No reduction in mechanical resilience after over 10 million wear cycles loaded in torsion, traction and flexion [Fialka et al. 2005; ! Vascularisation & Fibrous ingrowth - Collagen Type 1 [Trieb et al. Eur Surg Res. 2004; Yu et al. 2005; Pelletier & Durand] 16
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Procedure(s) 19 "# Remove allprevious fix & Scar tissue $# Micro samples %# CC Ligs - LARS anatomical + ‘Biceps Flip’ &# AC Ligs - LARS + Reverse CAL Transfer '# Delto-trapezial Reefing
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Results (failed Reconstructions) Desais,Robinson, Phandis, Funk In print, 2016 ! 23 cases over 7 years ! Follow-up = 37 months (24-48) ! Constant Score = 51.8 pre to 85.2 post ! 10% re-displaced radiologically ! 13% superficial infections ! No further revisions 21
  • 22.
    Results (failed Excisions) Desais,Robinson, Phandis, Funk In print, 2016 ! 13 cases over 5 years ! Follow-up = 34 months (24-48) ! Constant Score = 26 pre to 73 post ! 1 re-displaced radiologically ! 1 chronic pain ! No further revisions
  • 23.
    Summary ! Awareness ! Testfor Horizontal & Vertical Instability ! Ultrasound ! CT Scan ! Revise if Symptomatic ! Strong ! Anatomical ! Biological 23
  • 24.