This document discusses measuring the effectiveness of integrated cross-media campaigns. It outlines challenges in aligning research with client needs, measuring campaign integration and media duplication, obtaining basic campaign effectiveness measures, and modeling the entire communication flow. The document then provides examples of research conducted by Millward Brown and Dynamic Logic to evaluate how different media interact and affect brand metrics. It shows that magazines are generally the strongest driver of persuasion while maintaining awareness, and that combining magazines with online media can strengthen impact through synergy and increased exposure frequency. The document concludes by discussing opportunities for more advanced modeling and ongoing in-market cross-media measurement.
The Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown DigitalSanoma Belgium
The Print Campaign Analysis, a “meta-analysis “ conducted by Millward Brown, an authority in the assessment
of advertising impact, examined nearly 100 ad effectiveness studies that the advertisers themselves had
originally commissioned. Millward Brown’s report finds that print advertising results in the greatest increases
in persuasion metrics—brand favorability and purchase intent—compared to other platforms. These
advertiser-generated data also reveal that when advertisers used print magazine in combination with other
platforms, they were most successful in raising outcome metrics, leading to the conclusion that digital
platforms work best when they are connected to powerful traditional media, such as print.
2014 - A year of transformation,
consolidation and disruption.
New brand tops the rankings
Top 100 brand values increase
Surprising top riser
A first for sector growth
First time a retailer makes the coveted Top 10
more : http://www.wpp.com/wpp/marketing/brandz/brandz-2014/
The Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown DigitalSanoma Belgium
The Print Campaign Analysis, a “meta-analysis “ conducted by Millward Brown, an authority in the assessment
of advertising impact, examined nearly 100 ad effectiveness studies that the advertisers themselves had
originally commissioned. Millward Brown’s report finds that print advertising results in the greatest increases
in persuasion metrics—brand favorability and purchase intent—compared to other platforms. These
advertiser-generated data also reveal that when advertisers used print magazine in combination with other
platforms, they were most successful in raising outcome metrics, leading to the conclusion that digital
platforms work best when they are connected to powerful traditional media, such as print.
2014 - A year of transformation,
consolidation and disruption.
New brand tops the rankings
Top 100 brand values increase
Surprising top riser
A first for sector growth
First time a retailer makes the coveted Top 10
more : http://www.wpp.com/wpp/marketing/brandz/brandz-2014/
Earned Media Amplification - Personal Care BrandMasood Akhtar
Our social media measurement approach applied to a popular personal care brand. Here we assess the degree to which PAID media is AMPLIFIED by EARNED media conversations.
Peter Field analysed 108 UK cases from the IPA effectiveness awards databank 2012-2016, to understand the business effectiveness of UK newsbrands. This work builds on his previous analysis of 2012 and 2014 cases.
Shows approach which expands the breadth of what marketing-mix models cMichael Wolfe
Much criticism has been levied towards marketing-mix modeling recently. This article shows innovations and proposes solutions for reinventing this powerful marketing measurement tool
Modeling the Customer Journey insights using Structural Equation Modelling. This provides a battery of insights into the causal relationships that exist for Brand X's marketing eco-system.
This is a case showing how Structural Equation Modeling (SEM0 can be applied to common consumer tracking surveys, media data, web traffic info.,and social media metrics to develop a mapping and quantification of the "customer journey" from awareness to purchase and brand loyalty.
Using the results from over 500 econometric models over the last five years, Benchmarketing has proved that newsbrands continue to play a very important part in the modern media mix. As a result, advertising spend should return to 2013 levels for optimum effectiveness
A case study marketing mix model for major department store retailer. The. data source is credit-card transactions, segmented among Millennial (18-24), Gen XZ (25-54) and Boomer (55+)age groups. This measures short & long-term advertjsing plus the impact of media creative. The work examines and evaluates this retailer's "Millennial's only" media targeting strategy.
Analysis of the IPA Effectiveness Awards – a bank of campaigns with proven commercial success – shows that including newsbrands in the media mix improves business performance and boosts the business effectiveness of other media.
What's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant ResearchConversant, Inc.
A major Conversant research study evaluating
attitudes, plans and actions of both brand
marketers and agencies reveals a shift in focus
among marketers in 2014. As pressure for driving
results becomes stronger, marketers are moving
away from piecemeal tactics and experimentation
and doubling down budgets on those strategies
and tactics that they can count on to deliver a
higher return in the coming year.
10,856 readers, five big brand campaigns and 700,000+ individual brand measurements demonstrate that newsbrands have a significant impact on brand health.
Marketing ROI Measurement for RestaurantsMichael Wolfe
Case study of how a QSR restaurant used marketing ROI models to identify opportunities to expand growth of their business. In this case, showing how spending more on a new item launch will accelerate business growth.
Customer Journey Insights using Structural Equation Modelling_BLA GLOBAL 2014Masood Akhtar
This analysis sheds light into the connectedness of one brands' insight ecosystem. Using Structural Equation Modelling we have been able to provide a multitude of insights from; some of the causal relationships that exists, the transmission of offline and digital media to sales, the role of social display versus true social consumer engagement and salient concepts that can help steer content generation
Earned Media Amplification - Personal Care BrandMasood Akhtar
Our social media measurement approach applied to a popular personal care brand. Here we assess the degree to which PAID media is AMPLIFIED by EARNED media conversations.
Peter Field analysed 108 UK cases from the IPA effectiveness awards databank 2012-2016, to understand the business effectiveness of UK newsbrands. This work builds on his previous analysis of 2012 and 2014 cases.
Shows approach which expands the breadth of what marketing-mix models cMichael Wolfe
Much criticism has been levied towards marketing-mix modeling recently. This article shows innovations and proposes solutions for reinventing this powerful marketing measurement tool
Modeling the Customer Journey insights using Structural Equation Modelling. This provides a battery of insights into the causal relationships that exist for Brand X's marketing eco-system.
This is a case showing how Structural Equation Modeling (SEM0 can be applied to common consumer tracking surveys, media data, web traffic info.,and social media metrics to develop a mapping and quantification of the "customer journey" from awareness to purchase and brand loyalty.
Using the results from over 500 econometric models over the last five years, Benchmarketing has proved that newsbrands continue to play a very important part in the modern media mix. As a result, advertising spend should return to 2013 levels for optimum effectiveness
A case study marketing mix model for major department store retailer. The. data source is credit-card transactions, segmented among Millennial (18-24), Gen XZ (25-54) and Boomer (55+)age groups. This measures short & long-term advertjsing plus the impact of media creative. The work examines and evaluates this retailer's "Millennial's only" media targeting strategy.
Analysis of the IPA Effectiveness Awards – a bank of campaigns with proven commercial success – shows that including newsbrands in the media mix improves business performance and boosts the business effectiveness of other media.
What's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant ResearchConversant, Inc.
A major Conversant research study evaluating
attitudes, plans and actions of both brand
marketers and agencies reveals a shift in focus
among marketers in 2014. As pressure for driving
results becomes stronger, marketers are moving
away from piecemeal tactics and experimentation
and doubling down budgets on those strategies
and tactics that they can count on to deliver a
higher return in the coming year.
10,856 readers, five big brand campaigns and 700,000+ individual brand measurements demonstrate that newsbrands have a significant impact on brand health.
Marketing ROI Measurement for RestaurantsMichael Wolfe
Case study of how a QSR restaurant used marketing ROI models to identify opportunities to expand growth of their business. In this case, showing how spending more on a new item launch will accelerate business growth.
Customer Journey Insights using Structural Equation Modelling_BLA GLOBAL 2014Masood Akhtar
This analysis sheds light into the connectedness of one brands' insight ecosystem. Using Structural Equation Modelling we have been able to provide a multitude of insights from; some of the causal relationships that exists, the transmission of offline and digital media to sales, the role of social display versus true social consumer engagement and salient concepts that can help steer content generation
Hi, I'm Colin, a hugely experienced Strategy Director with a proven track record in shaping and executing award-winning brand, communications and digital strategies. freelance UX & Strategy.
I have a diverse background, spanning client-side, creative and media agency roles, which enables a consultative approach, joined-up strategic thinking and ensures the customer is placed at the heart of the solution. I have specialisms in Automotive, B2B, Financial Services, Behavioural Economics, CRM and integrated marketing strategies
Amazon Marketing Cloud is a holistic measurement and analytics solution, and can be a treasure trove of data that can be converted into insights to drive your Amazon business.
Learning how AMC works can give you a robust understanding of your audience and your performance on Amazon – but knowing where to begin is the tricky part.
In this webinar, our Amazon Marketing Cloud expert will dive into how to utilize AMC to get the answers to your most pressing business questions on Amazon.
Advertising media selection is the process of choosing the most efficient media for an advertising campaign. To evaluate media efficiency, planners consider ...
New Zealand: GfK for the Radio Broadcasters .
UNIT-9-MANAGING MASS AND PERSONAL COMMUNICATION.pptetebarkhmichale
Invoice Finance
In Ethiopia, Ethio Lease is the first privately owned equipment leasing company with a license from the National Bank of Ethiopia. Ethio Lease provides its customers with carefully selected equipment on the basis of a lease contract, whereby the customer is the Lessee, who has a conditional right to use the equipment, and Ethio Lease is the Lessor, who buys and owns the equipment. If the equipment needs to be imported, Ethio Lease will buy the equipment abroad, using foreign currency from its parent company, AAFC. Ethio Lease customers can pay the lease fee in Ethiopian Birr. While leasing comes in many forms and shapes, for now the only form of leasing that the NBE will allow is a capital lease (aka “financial lease” or “full pay-out” lease). This Ethio Lease can be an alternative foe very few startups, it cannot be considered as a significant alternative for startups since most of them couldn’t fit it and it couldn’t be accessible enough.
The Always-On Approach: How to Continually Improve Your Streaming Advertising...Tinuiti
Take the guesswork out of driving results from your Streaming campaigns, and discover how the always-on approach can deliver the metrics needed for a full picture across your entire campaign.
In this webinar, our experts at Tinuiti and our Streaming agency, Bliss Point Media, with guest global market research company, Forrester, explore Streaming advertising marketing trends and the importance of incrementality testing in driving sales.
Insights from Coalition for Innovative Media Measurement (CIMM) were presented at Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference, held in 2011. Through the use of eDiaries and the example of moms, a presentation was given on the value of USA touchpoints to increase ROI. Presenters included Jane Clarke-Managing Director of Coalition for Innovative Media Measurement & Jim Spaeth-Partner at Media Behavior Institute.
As part of the emerging new topics series, a presentation entitled UX: The User Experience Cross-Screen, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. A research study including questions, methods, and findings on cross-screen users was presented. The presentation was given by, Richard Zackon-Facilitator for Council for Research Excellence & Rick Ducey- Chief Strategy Officer at BIA/Kelsey.
A presentation on new ad models, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. Dr. Duane Varan-Executive Director at Audience Research Labs Murdoch University gave the presentation. Varan presented studies done by the Beyond 30 research program.
At the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011, a Keynote presentation was given entitled Meeting the Challenges of Cross Media Research. Google presented three initiatives and how they are trying to help meet the challenges of cross media research. Keynote presenters from Google were Owen Charlebois-Global Manager, Advertising, Marketing and Media Research & ElissaLee, Ph.D.-Group Manager,Quantitative Measurement.
A presentation entitled Impact of Online and Television Advertising on Consumer Behavior, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. The presentation includes, the challenges to measuring cross-platform media impacts, comscore methods, case studies and results. Presenters included Joan FitzGerald-Vice President of comScore & Alan Vaughn- Statistical Analyst at comScore.
A presentation entitled Following the Sports Fan with Arbitron’s PPM, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. A study using Arbitron Portable People Meter™ (PPM™) service was presented. The presentation was given by Glenn Enoch- VP, Integrated Media Research at ESPN Inc., Kelly Johnson- Director, Media and Promotion Research at ESPN Inc., & Lung Huang- VP, National Account Services at Arbitron Inc.
A presentation entitled BrandLife – Showing the Client What to Do Visually and What to Avoid was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. The Interpretation of visual Semiotic “Answers” is presented. The presentation is given by Steve Wolf- Commercial Director, Global Qualitative & SVP/Division Director at Synovate Qualitative.
At the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011, a presentation was given on Facebook’s information platform. The job of research team at Facebook along with the topic of making research interesting to users is discussed. The presentation is given by Brad Smallwood-Head of Measurement and Insights at Facebook
A presentation entitled The Television Audience Redefined: An Update, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. Insights into the profiles of various consumers across a variety of media platforms, was presented. The presentation was given by David Poltrack-Chief Research Officer of CBS Corporation & President of CBS Vision.
A presentation entitled Measuring the Moving Screen: The Future of Tablet Measurement, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. A presentation was given on the profile tablet users as well as the findings regarding ad effectiveness on iPads vs iPhones and other devices. The presentation was given by Matt O’Grady- EVP, Media Audience Measurement at The Nielsen Company.
A presentation entitled MAXIMIZING MOMENTUM: Insights from Verizon, SMG & Cisco, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference. Insights on Brand building were presented. Presenters included Patrick McLean-Executive Director at Verizon Interactive, Helen Katz-SVP/Research Director at Starcom MediaVest Group, & Charlie Treadwell-Marketing Strategy Manager Corporate Affairs Marketing at Cisco.
A presentation entitled Integrated Social Media: Business Impact Study 2011, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference. The presentation explores the impact that social media has on sales. Presenters included Irfan Kamal- SVP, Digital/Social at Ogilvy & Dr. Walter Carl- Founder and Chief Research Officer at ChatThreads.
A presentation entitled Global Perspectives on Measurement Issues, was given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. Presenters included Horst Stipp-EVP, Global Business Strategy at the Advertising Research Foundation & LuizG. Duarte, Ph.D.-Corporate Research at DIRECTV Latin America.
A presentation entitled Insights for the Future of Online Video Commercialization given at the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) AM 6.0 conference held in 2011. Test on online commercial viewing done by TBS was presented. The presentation included the research design and methods used as well as the findings. The presentation was given by Stacey Lynn Schulman-SVP, Ad Sales & Sports Research at Turner Broadcasting Sales, Inc.
At the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) 2011 annual re:think convention, a key issues forum presentation was held entitled New Shopper Journeys: The Influence of Digital Touchpoints. The presentation explores how digital has an effect on shopper’s behaviors. Presentation is given by Alex Charlton- Director at essential research, Mike Hess- EVP of Research at Carat N.A., & Beth Uyenco- Global Research Director at Microsoft.
At the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) 2011 annual re:think convention, a key issues forum presentation was held entitled Supercharging the Path to Purchase: Using Word-of-Mouth to Drive More Consumers to Buy. The presentation looks at the effects of Word of Mouth advertising as it relates to female consumers. Presenters include Ed Keller-CEO of Keller Fay Group & Tony Cardinale-EVP, Brand Planning & Strategic Insights at NBC Universal.
At the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) 2011 annual re:think convention, a key issues forum presentation was held entitled SHOPPER INSIGHTS. Ashmeed Ali-Senior Manager at Yahoo! & David Gill-Vice President at The Nielsen Company discussed when Mobile Goes Shopping. This presentation explored how consumers use their mobiles to research products and advertising on mobile devices. Manila Austin-Director of Research at Communispace Corporation moderated the discussion.
At the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) 2011 annual re:think convention, a key issues forum presentation was held entitled The Power of Relevancy The Biometric Impact of Online Advertising. The presentation includes topics such as measuring the biological impact, and the contextual and personal relevancy of ads. The presenters include Tony Marlow-Strategic Insights at YAHOO! & Brian Levine-President of Innerscope Research.
At the Advertising Research Foundation’s (ARF) 2011 annual re:think convention, a key issues forum presentation was held entitled Understanding the Relationship Between Social Media and TV Viewership. The presentation used a case study on the World cup to present findings. Presenters included, Jon Gibs-SVP at The Nielsen Company & David Coletti-VP at ESPN.
More from The Advertising Research Foundation (20)
Business Valuation Principles for EntrepreneursBen Wann
This insightful presentation is designed to equip entrepreneurs with the essential knowledge and tools needed to accurately value their businesses. Understanding business valuation is crucial for making informed decisions, whether you're seeking investment, planning to sell, or simply want to gauge your company's worth.
[Note: This is a partial preview. To download this presentation, visit:
https://www.oeconsulting.com.sg/training-presentations]
Sustainability has become an increasingly critical topic as the world recognizes the need to protect our planet and its resources for future generations. Sustainability means meeting our current needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet theirs. It involves long-term planning and consideration of the consequences of our actions. The goal is to create strategies that ensure the long-term viability of People, Planet, and Profit.
Leading companies such as Nike, Toyota, and Siemens are prioritizing sustainable innovation in their business models, setting an example for others to follow. In this Sustainability training presentation, you will learn key concepts, principles, and practices of sustainability applicable across industries. This training aims to create awareness and educate employees, senior executives, consultants, and other key stakeholders, including investors, policymakers, and supply chain partners, on the importance and implementation of sustainability.
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
1. Develop a comprehensive understanding of the fundamental principles and concepts that form the foundation of sustainability within corporate environments.
2. Explore the sustainability implementation model, focusing on effective measures and reporting strategies to track and communicate sustainability efforts.
3. Identify and define best practices and critical success factors essential for achieving sustainability goals within organizations.
CONTENTS
1. Introduction and Key Concepts of Sustainability
2. Principles and Practices of Sustainability
3. Measures and Reporting in Sustainability
4. Sustainability Implementation & Best Practices
To download the complete presentation, visit: https://www.oeconsulting.com.sg/training-presentations
Event Report - SAP Sapphire 2024 Orlando - lots of innovation and old challengesHolger Mueller
Holger Mueller of Constellation Research shares his key takeaways from SAP's Sapphire confernece, held in Orlando, June 3rd till 5th 2024, in the Orange Convention Center.
Discover the innovative and creative projects that highlight my journey throu...dylandmeas
Discover the innovative and creative projects that highlight my journey through Full Sail University. Below, you’ll find a collection of my work showcasing my skills and expertise in digital marketing, event planning, and media production.
Digital Transformation and IT Strategy Toolkit and TemplatesAurelien Domont, MBA
This Digital Transformation and IT Strategy Toolkit was created by ex-McKinsey, Deloitte and BCG Management Consultants, after more than 5,000 hours of work. It is considered the world's best & most comprehensive Digital Transformation and IT Strategy Toolkit. It includes all the Frameworks, Best Practices & Templates required to successfully undertake the Digital Transformation of your organization and define a robust IT Strategy.
Editable Toolkit to help you reuse our content: 700 Powerpoint slides | 35 Excel sheets | 84 minutes of Video training
This PowerPoint presentation is only a small preview of our Toolkits. For more details, visit www.domontconsulting.com
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern BusinessesSynapseIndia
Stay ahead of the curve with our premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions. Our expert developers utilize MongoDB, Express.js, AngularJS, and Node.js to create modern and responsive web applications. Trust us for cutting-edge solutions that drive your business growth and success.
Know more: https://www.synapseindia.com/technology/mean-stack-development-company.html
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media MasterclassLuanWise
In this masterclass, presented at the Global HR Summit on 5th June 2024, Luan Wise explored the essential features of social media platforms that support talent acquisition, including LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, X (formerly Twitter) and TikTok.
B2B payments are rapidly changing. Find out the 5 key questions you need to be asking yourself to be sure you are mastering B2B payments today. Learn more at www.BlueSnap.com.
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.Any kyc Account
Learn how to use Binance Savings to expand your bitcoin holdings. Discover how to maximize your earnings on one of the most reliable cryptocurrency exchange platforms, as well as how to earn interest on your cryptocurrency holdings and the various savings choices available.
Personal Brand Statement:
As an Army veteran dedicated to lifelong learning, I bring a disciplined, strategic mindset to my pursuits. I am constantly expanding my knowledge to innovate and lead effectively. My journey is driven by a commitment to excellence, and to make a meaningful impact in the world.
Kseniya Leshchenko: Shared development support service model as the way to ma...Lviv Startup Club
Kseniya Leshchenko: Shared development support service model as the way to make small projects with small budgets profitable for the company (UA)
Kyiv PMDay 2024 Summer
Website – www.pmday.org
Youtube – https://www.youtube.com/startuplviv
FB – https://www.facebook.com/pmdayconference
Kseniya Leshchenko: Shared development support service model as the way to ma...
Measuring the Effectiveness of Cross Media Campaigns
1. Measuring the Effectiveness of Cross Media
Campaigns
Doron Wesly, Millward Brown
Kara Manatt, Dynamic Logic
Print Council
Advertising Research Foundation
March 19, 2008
3. 3
Challenge: measure campaign integration
• Copy testing can help advertisers, agencies, and publishers
understand campaign creative strengths and weaknesses
• Holistic copy testing can provide insight about
● Campaign creative integration
● Media audience
Campaigns with integrated creative show a boost on key measures as
media are added to the campaign, while campaigns without integrated
creative may decrease in effectiveness
Case 1:
Integrated creative
Case 2:
Unintegrated creative
One medium Two media One medium Two media
Favorability 50% 67% 37% 29%
Consideration 16% 28% 30% 24%
4. 4
Challenge: measure media duplication
Blended sample from online panel and web intercept
● Panel
> nationally representative magazine and offline media audience
● Intercept
> booster sample for online site(s)
> Targets online and joint print/online audiences
AdScout tracking and survey questions are used to
assess respondent opportunity to see (OTS)
advertising in each medium
● OTS provides measure of media effectiveness tied to media
planning
Panel sample can be used together with OTS to
measure media duplication
5. 5
Challenge: measure magazine OTS & frequency fairly
Magazine OTS determined by:
● frequency of readership for titles where advertising appears
> 3-month screener and frequency are asked for each magazine
OR
● showing magazine issue covers
> Convergent validity has been tested for both approaches
—Cardarelli, Havlena, and Campbell 2005
> Campaign-specific approach is recommended based on media
plan and analytical framework
Account for:
● audience accumulation
● advertising decay accounted for in frequency estimation
6. 6
Challenge: obtain basic campaign effectiveness
measures
• Magazine Publishers of America selected Dynamic Logic to quantify
the attitudinal impact of the Jeep Compass integrated marketing
campaign across TV, magazine, and online
• Magazine OTS was determined by specific-issue readership for titles
where advertising appeared
● 3-month screener and specific issues read were asked for each magazine
7. 7
Opportunity to see advertising in multiple media
increased brand awareness
100
133 136
145
158 164 161
176
0
50
100
150
200
Control TVonly Magazine only Online only TV+Online Mag+Online TV+Mag TV+Mag+On
Aided Brand Awareness
8. 8
Campaign memorability, driven by magazines and
online, was associated with purchase consideration
Purchase Consideration
100
109
122
78
117
165
143
170
0
50
100
150
200
Control TV only Magazine only Online only TV+Online Mag+Online TV+Mag TV+Mag+Online
9. 9
Awareness of Jeep Compass advertising continued to
increase with magazine exposure frequency
Note: TV & online consumption levels, including time periods,
were controlled for between magazine exposure frequency groups
Aided Advertising Awareness
163 156
219
250 256
288
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Control 1-2 Magazines 3-4 Magazines 5+ Magazines
Number of magazine issues read
Magazine Only Magazine+TV+Online
10. 10
Favorability continued to increase with magazine
frequency among consumers exposed to 3 media
Note: TV & online consumption levels, including time periods,
were controlled for between magazine exposure frequency groups
Brand Favorability
135
165 165
150
185
225
0
50
100
150
200
250
Control 1-2 Magazines 3-4 Magazines 5+ Magazines
Number of magazine issues read
Magazine Only Magazine+TV+Online
11. 11
Magazines alone or in combination with online were
most cost-efficient
TV Magazine Online TV + Online
Mag +
Online
TV + Mag
TV + Mag +
Online
Aided Brand Awareness 236 100 131 282 133 314 207
Aided Ad Awareness 434 100 167 1666 147 380 212
Message Association 186 113 115 644 100 239 322
Brand Imagery
Attribute A ** ** ** ** 100 461 301
Attribute B ** 183 ** ** 100 238 199
Attribute C ** 156 ** ** 100 204 215
Attribute D 1914 ** ** ** 100 553 232
Attribute E ** 163 ** ** 100 646 242
Attribute F ** ** ** ** 100 500 586
Brand Favorability 594 112 ** 2496 100 330 317
Purchase Consideration ** ** ** ** 100 1887 960
Calculated Cost-Per-Person (CPP) by Metric and Exposure Cell
Note: Costs are indexed to most efficient media combination (CPP = 100) for each metric
12. 12
Challenge: general conclusion about integrated
campaigns
• Dynamic Logic has conducted 200+ cross-media
campaign evaluations
• 32 were identified for analysis in 2007
● Studies contained unique measurements consisting of
television, magazine, and "standard display" internet
advertising placements
● Comparable in terms of target audience composition, reach
& frequency, seasonality, flight time, and type of magazine
● Over 300,000 respondents across the studies
14. 14
CPG campaigns exhibit larger increase in awareness; TV is
particularly strong at increasing Message Association
• Magazines are a memorable medium for this category and
demonstrate consistent results with the aggregated dataset
Source: Dynamic Logic CrossMedia Research N=14 2007
Delta = Exposed - control
7.2
11.0
2.6 3.5
3.5
2.0
2.5
4.3
8.6
7.1
6.6
6.3
4.8
1.8
3.8
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Aided Brand
Awareness
Advertising
Awareness
Message
Association
Brand
Favorability
Purchase
Intent/
Consideration
TV Online Magazine
*Consumer magazines were used in this test across various categories. Trade
publications were excluded from this analysis
AverageDelta
Incremental Effect of Medium on Brand Metrics: CPG Studies
Average Percentage Point Increase over Unexposed (Control) Baseline
15.0
24.4
11.9
11.7 12.6
15. 15
• Millward Brown implemented a cutting edge research design to
evaluate media interactions (print, online) and the effect on targets
for a major pharmaceutical brand
Challenge: model entire communication flow
Total
Communication
Online
Consideration
Magazines
Awareness
Online
Magazines
Exposure
16. 16
Media reached the majority of the target consumer
population – primarily through print
Duplicated Mag-Online
Reach: 8.2%
Frequency: 4.5
Magazines Only
Reach: 49%
Frequency: 1.2
Online Only
Reach: 8%
Frequency: 2.6
• Most of the reach for the campaign
was achieved via magazines.
• Online extended the campaign
beyond the print audience.
• The average frequency achieved for
those reached only by magazines
was quite low, at 1.2.
• Given the positive synergistic effect
of online and magazines, working
to achieve a higher frequency in
the print campaign would have a
positive impact on the key metrics.
• Given the low average frequency
for magazines, wear-out was not
an issue.
17. 17
Print advertising had good impact on awareness,
but synergy was evident
Note: Magazine R/F as planned for Nov 2006: 54%/2.2
34%
0%
20%
Unaided
Awareness
Aided Brand
Awareness
Measured
Reach/Average
Frequency of
Exposure
0 1.2 2.6 4.5
No Media
Exposure Magazine Only Online Only
Magazine
& Online
28%
44%
49%
19%
37%
8%
43%
62%
8%
18. 18
Campaign media implications
1. Magazines & online
● higher frequency of exposure would lead to more positive
impact in terms of awareness, especially among prospects.
2. Online
● adds unique reach to the media plan
● frequency levels may be too low, on average, to achieve
an impact on its own.
3. Modeling
● Suggest high frequency levels (over 5) are needed to drive
a change in awareness for magazines alone.
4. Duplication
● increasing exposure to both print and online media
strengthens the positive impact of the advertising because
of synergy and frequency of exposure.
19. 19
Challenge: What’s next?
• Modeling of media and creative effectiveness to
improve campaign optimization
• Volume of cross media studies makes more
advanced normative analysis possible
● Multivariate analysis of campaign effectiveness drivers
● Quantifying media synergy
● Understanding frequency effects across media at the
consumer level
● Ongoing in market cross media measurement
> intra media
> inter media
20. 20
Final thoughts
● Campaign objective
> brand, media, agency
● Creative impact
> on campaign
● Media impact
> individually & synergistically
● Analyze media delivery
> reach
● Scenario planning
● Normative analysis
21. 21
Thank you
● Doron Wesly, doron.wesly@us.millwardbrown.com
● Kara Manatt, karam@dynamiclogic.com