SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Download to read offline
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing
Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev
Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
Ragima N Ramachandran
University of Nagpur
Email: ragima.nr@gmail.com
Proportion and measurements have been the guiding tools for the construction of Indian temples
from the 5th century AD onwards to till date. Through-out the history, Proportion dominated as a
tool, which determined the monuments spatial arrangements as well as their forms. The ancient
texts, therefore, insist on a high degree of precision in their measurements. The standard text
Mayamata mentions – “Only if the temple is constructed correctly according to a mathematical
system, can it be expected to function in harmony with the universe. Only if the measurement of
the temple is in every way perfect, there will be perfection in the universe as well.” In this paper,
Mandapas in Indian temples are studied with respect to various parameters like expression,
function, proportion, orientation, chronology, etc. This study analyzes the proportion of mandapa
in the Indian temple architecture, especially focusing on Nagara style. The evolution of Mandapa
and other parameters are discussed in general. These factors are studied with respect to a
selected sample. Temples ascribed to the time period between 8th
C AD to 15th
C AD are taken for
the study, as Mandapas were added proportionately from 8th
C AD onwards. This comprises the
literature part, and is depicted through drawings and diagrams. Selected temples of the Ashapuri
complex are also studied through the same perspective and focus. The study will end by
examining whether the proportions and design of mandapa in Ashapuri follows Nagara Style.
Key words: Ashapuri Temples, Indian Temple Architecture, Mandapa, Proportions
INTRODUCTION
Indian Temple Architecture
India “Land of Temples” (brown Percy) - A land of intense
spirituality and religious faith reflected in the profusion of
temples present in this subcontinent. Temples are found
everywhere in India from large monumental structures to
small shrines, each having certain significance and greatly
influencing the lives of the people who regard the temple
as a place where they could be close to god. The Hindu
temple architecture developed over two thousand years.
The architectural evolution took place within the rigid
frameworks derived entirely from religious thoughtfulness.
Architect was bound to adhere to the ancient proportioning
systems and configurations, which remained unaltered
over the period of time. The ideology behind the designing
of Hindu temples is to link, man with the gods. The
architect and the sculptor were allowed a great deal of
freedom in the embellishment of the structure prescribed
as per the underlying principles and formulae. It evolved
from simple rock cut architecture in Lomas Rishi Cave (300
BC) to complex temples as Kandariya Mahadeo Temple,
Khajuraho and Meenakshi Amman Temple, Madurai in
11th & 16th C AD respectively. Distinctive architectural
styles of Hindu temples have so developed due to broad
geographical, climatic, cultural, racial, historical and
linguistic differences between the northern plains and the
southern peninsula of India. Broadly based on geography,
Hindu temples have been classified into three different
styles; the Nagara or ’northern’ style, the Dravidian or
’southern’ style, and the Vesara or hybrid style. There are
also other distinct styles in Bengal, Kerala and the
Himalayan valleys.
Research Article
Vol. 4(2), pp. 089-096, August, 2019. © www.premierpublishers.org. ISSN: 1530-9931
International Research Journal of Architecture and Planning
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
Ragima NR. 090
Proportion in Temples
Proportion being an important tool in analyzing individual
buildings, also plays an important tool in the study of
temple Architecture. Like in Greek Architecture the Orders
of pillars served as a tool for proportioning based on
column diameter, here in India also, we possessed a
proportionate arrangement for Temple Architecture. All of
them receive a character of harmony, leading to aesthetic
beauty, and peace of our inner soul due to the proportional
relationship. The perspective effects in the visual frames
and their strategic alignment often pro- vides a basis for
the proportioning of spaces. (Pandya Yatin 2013). Indian
architecture is considered as true style by Fergusson in his
book History of Indian & Eastern Architecture in 1876.
Mandapa- the gathering space in temples, evolved later
and became sacred as well. They initially developed as a
porch, became large mandapas later, and eventually
became an integral part of the temple plan and affected
the temple form as well. From 8th C AD onwards mandapa
also possessed mandala character as that of shrine.
(Hardy Adam 2007). Mandapa became a part of the temple
entity, affected its plan and form. According to Mayamata,
Mandapas should be positioned in front of the shrine and
they should follow the same orientation as that of temple
shrine. (Table 1) Mandapas are placed on elevated plinth
and even if they might be detached as in South Indian
temples they are connected together by visual
juxtaposition, adjacency, organizational axis and implied
route of movement (Pandya Yatin 2013).
In this paper, study mainly focuses on Mandapa - its
features like orientation, expression, function etc. how it
affects the proportion of mandapa or vice versa which
determines the proportion of that temple. This is examined
through the literature study of a temple - Kandaria
Mahadeo temple in Khajuraho. This temple is selected
since Khajuraho temples are considered as culmination of
Indian art & architecture. A major reason for selection was
also the availability of proper data and drawings. The study
finally ends with examining of the mandapa proportions of
the case study temples at -Ashapuri.
Mandapa
Mandapa - a general overview
The regional classification of Indian Temple Architecture
into three major distinct style is the base for the
comparison of mandapas. Till 6th C AD North and South
styles were of the same kind; after that they evolved.
Nagara style is most prominently seen in Orissan temples.
Addition of mandapa to temple started in 8th C AD; till then
there was only Garbhagriha, ambulatory path and portico,
with its width of central bay corresponding to that of
sanctum and antarala. In Nagara Mandapa were added
along the linear axis, whether detached or attached, with a
proportion same as that of Garbhagriha in plan,
irrespective of their function; and in elevation the
Sukhanasa determined the height of Mandapa giving it a
mountain appearance. Later Nagara style developed over
time into Latina, Valabhi, Shikhari and Bhumija. In the
South of India before the development of great temple
complexes of later centuries, Mandapas were unimportant.
It was only by 11th C AD, that large, rectangular, flat roofed
halls began to appear including open ones. (Hardy Adam
2007). There was a more detached Open Mandapa, larger
in proportion to that of Garbhagriha indicating the function
they were to perform. In South India, the Open Mandapa
gradually got more and more enclosed nearing the
sanctum reducing the light and giving a sacred feeling.
Mandapas in shrine compound are arranged in front of the
shrine and are flat roofed giving emphasis on linearity. In
the Deccan region, a temple may have several shrines
adjoining a single Mandapa or several interlinked
Mandapas. 2 to 5 shrines could be arranged around a
Mandapa or even more. Here also, Mandapa seems to be
larger and rectangular but the basic square in Mandapa is
aligned to the size of Garbhagriha and in elevation the roof
of Mandapa is flat.
Figure 1: Evolution of mandapa from a) porch to b)
Mandapa c) closed mandapa d), e), f), g) one to three
porchs attached to a mandapa. (Source: Hardy Adam
(2007))
Evolution & Features
Mandapa- audience hall of God’s palace (Hardy Adam
2007). They are sacred pillared hall or pavilion for
assembly of those paying their devotions. Mandapa
established a separate hall, preparatory and subservient
to the purpose of Prasada. Ancient temples consisted of a
square cella with a small porch in front of it especially
temples before 6th C AD as seen in Tigawa temple of
Gupta period. They were entrance porches constituting
one, two or three entries to the temple shrine. In most of
the temples these porches were added separately after the
construction of temples. Later they evolved into
mandapas- may be enclosed by thick walls, or open like
an extended porch (Fig. 1), but still they were not in rhythm
to that of their Prasada. Wooden halls of post and beam
construction were prototypes for the mandapa
construction. By 7th and 8th C AD mandapa had massive
roof slabs as in early Chalukyan temples in Karnataka &
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
Int. Res. J. Archit. Planning 091
Andhra Pradesh. A century or more had to pass before the
Sthapati arrived at the perfect solution showing the
Prasada as the main building and temple proper, with
mandapa as the lesser part of the sacred structure,
following its rhythm in the particularities of its own form.
(Kramrisch Stella 1946). From 8th C AD Mandapa had
mandala like character reflecting that of shrine. They were
added in proportion; whose proportion was regulated by
the proportion of Prasada. This integrity is clearly visible in
Orissan temples where it is more strongly retained than
elsewhere and only indicates their distinction by a deeper
recess produced by the buttresses of the wall of two
structures. With-in this lies the porch (antarala) of the
Prasada or garbhagriha, fulfills the function of
Mukhamandapa of more ancient temples. This small porch
is marked on the outside of the Prasada by a buttress
carried on to the Sukanasa at the prescribed height which
regulates the height of the Mandapa. (Kramrisch Stella
1946).
Later as the temple developed into a complex structure,
the number of Mandapas also increased. They were added
for different purposes and functions like dance, offerings,
habitation, upanayanam, marriage, festivals etc. In
Orissan temples one could see the gradual development
in temple plan and form. The Mandapa started as
gathering space i.e. Jagmohan as in Parasurameshwar
temple and Muktheswar temple, in the former one the
pillared hall was added later after the construction of
Garbhagriha but in the latter one the Mandapa structure
was constructed along with the Garbhagriha in proportion
to it. In later Orissan temples one could see that Mandapas
increased in number; they were added according to
different functions like a hall for dance called Nat mandir
and, a hall for offerings called Bhog mandir. Open
mandapas of a scale greater than that of simple porch
were known in western India by the end of 8th C AD and
were widespread in most regions by 11th C AD. (Hardy
Adam 2007). They were added especially for recitations
and dance performance, a central platform will be
provided, either attached, closed or free-standing. Later
the Mandapa got detached as in Sun temple Konark,
marking a transition from exterior to interior. In south Indian
temples like Madurai Meenakshi and Vitthala temple at
Hampi also one could see detached Mandpas added for
various functions. According to Benjamin Roland, the
culmination of Indo Aryan style is seen in the Khajuraho
temples with properly developed temple plan and form. In
that also, one could see series of Mandapa starting from
Mukhamandapa- the porch to Mandapa and
Mahamandapa (larger hall with transepts) which seems to
be the part of a same mass externally but separated
internally by construction of wall planes. Storied open
mandapa appeared by the end of 11th C AD.
Mandapa - Proportion in Nagara Style
In Indian Temple Architecture, temples are represented in
a symbolic language. Hindu philosophy views cosmos to
be self- similar in nature. According to ancient architecture
tradition, Hindu temples are symbols of models of the
cosmos. To maintain harmony with cosmos, all temples are
fashioned with the same principles and measurements
with which cosmos is made. According to myth, Mount
Meru is considered as axis of Cosmos. To resemble this
above the central zone of wall proper, rises the roof
consisting of series of graded peaks. To express this
symbolically in diagrammatic forms basic geometrical
figures were used. The Square represents manifest world
and the circle the Universe. ‘Mandala’ is a Sanskrit word
signifying wholeness. (Trivedi Kirti 1989). Proportion also
plays a greater role in this. Till 9th C AD Varahamihira’s
Brahtsamhita was the standard text followed for temple
construction; by early 11th C AD Nagara temple proportions
began to follow a new text Samaranganasutradara.
Modification was made in the proportionate measurement
of Prasada.
Figure 2: Proportionate arrangement of Mandapa to
Garbhagriha
In plan Mandapa proportion was regulated by
Garbhagriha. The center of Mandapa is in a fixed
proportion to the garbhagriha, its center square has the
same area. The central space is marked by four pillars
forming catuski. (Table 2) The superstructure of the
Mandapa must not exceed in height the Sukanasa of the
Prasada. (Samaranganasutradara). Thus the height of
Mandapa will depend upon the height of temple and its
sukhanasa which varies always according to temple, thus
it is not a fixed one.
Proportions of Mandapa to Garbagriha
Another method is for example the distance from the
square of garbhgriha to Catuskika is the diagonal of these
Squares. Here the Center of garbhagriha is the corner of
the Square on edge, formed by connecting the angles of
the offsets of the wall of Mandapa; Fig. 3 (Kramrisch Stella
1946). In case of Mandapa separated from the temple
same theme is applied but varied in their proportionate
application, link the Mandapa, built in one other of the 8 to
27 possible varieties, to the Prasada.
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
Ragima NR. 092
Table 1: Mandapa Parameter
Mandapa ParametersRelation with mandapa Influence on Proportion or vise versa
Orientation Follows same orientation as
temple
Doesn’t have any influence
Location In front of the temple
Being located in front of the sanctum
its follows the same proportion of Garbhagriha or Prasada or
its proportion is determined by that of Garbhagriha or
Prasada.
Function Mainly for gathering, dance, offerings
etc.
Proportion is not influenced by func-
tion but it proportionately decrease in size from
Mahamandapa to Mukhap- mandapa guided by the
dimension of Garbhagriha
Expression
Mandapa affects the temple form as
well as plan gives an expression of
cosmos
Its self similar nature(Fractal) both in
plan and elevation achieved through the proportionate
arrangement of each Mandpa.
Table 2: Proportions of Mandapa to Garbhagrih
SamaranganaSutradara Mayamata Manasara Matsyapurana Agnipurana
For Nirandhara
(prasada(P) 4x4)
Pillard porch W=3 parts of P
D= 2 parts of P
W= W of Prasada
Or
W= or W of P
Small temples
Whole L = 4 parts
Or 4 1/2 or 6 parts
G.G = 2or2 1/2
or 3 parts
Antarala = 1 or
1 1/2 or 2 parts
Ardha mandapa = 1
or 1 1/2 parts
X = side of Q
Area of P = 16Q
Mandapa W 4X = W
Depth 3X = 3W/4
Mukhamandapa
2X = W/2
”Do”
For Sandhara
C Q of Mandapa = C Q of G.G
W= P or ht of P or
diagonal of P (most perfect)
L= redoubled the L of P
W= 2W of P
Or
L= 1 W of P
Large temples
3 to 4 porticos
W= 1 1/2or2
W of G.G
Kramrisch,
Stella. 1946.
The Hindu Temple (Vol 1).
Montilal banarsidas:
New Delhi
Kramrisch,
Stella. 1946.
The Hindu Temple (Vol
1).
Montilal banarsidas:
New Delhi
Kramrisch,
Stella. 1946.
The Hindu Temple
(Vol 1).
Montilal banarsidas:
New Delhi
Figure 3: Proportionate arrangement of Mandapa to
Garbhagriha
Kandariya Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho 1030 AD
Kandariya Mahadev temple at Khajuraho sets the
benchmark of Hindu art and Architecture in India. This
temple was constructed when Indian temples had attained
the highest point of matured design in the middle of 11th C
AD. Kandariya.
Mahadev temple has a height of 31m. It is elevated above
a lofty plinth which makes the temple structure sanctity and
monumental. The temple is faced to the east to welcome
the first rays of sun and the structure is 30.5 m long and
20 m wide. It consists of four major parts.
1. Garbhagriha, i.e., sanctuary where the main deity has
been kept.
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
Int. Res. J. Archit. Planning 093
2. Pradakshina path, i.e., circumambulatory path having
three sides balcony bringing ventilation and light to the
interior.
3. Mandapa, i.e., columned assembly hall having two
sides balcony.
4. Ardha mandapa, i.e., entrance porch.
In Kandariya Mahadev Temple starting from Ardha
Mandapa, Mandapa and Maha mandapa one could see
three Mandapas in an axis both in plan as well as in
elevation, internally they are divided by intermittent walls
whereas externally they seem to be the part of the same
mass. The Maha Mandapa, largest of the three mandapa
is linked to the Garbhagriha through antarala inside and
outside its height is determined by the Sukhanasa over
antarala. It is pillared hall in front of the Garbhagriha fo the
assembly of devotees, used by them to sit, pray, chant and
meditate. Like the Prasada, the Mandapas are also
oriented in the East West axis and are located in front of
the Prasada expressing themselves as a development in
temple plan from the simple small temple to a complex
one.
Self-similarity or fractal geometry is another feature of
Indian temples to represent an evolving cosmos. Fractal
geometry is the technique of repeating similar shapes in
varied scales but in same proportion. In Kandariya
mahadev temple it is visible in plan, elevation as well as in
decorations. (fig 4) In plan the basic square of Garbhagriha
is used for all the Mandapas with their overall sizes varying
in proportion to it. In Elevation self- similar repeating
structures are the roofs over Mandapas. Even the smallest
Mandapa has a roof in decreased size of the largest one
in proportion to its which is in overall proportionate the
Shikhara. They resemble series of graded peaks that
resemble a mountain range to which a Hindu temple is
frequently compared. These peaks, arranged along the
axial line, rise and fall alternately while maintaining the
overall upward accent and culminating in the tallest spire
(shikhara). (Trivedi Kirti 1989). Even the minute
decorations on shikhara and mandapa roofs are examples
for fractal geometry.
Figure 4: Left: plan of Kandariya Mahadev temple (11th
century): (1) Garbhagriha, (2) Pradakshinapth, (3)
Mandapa, and (4) Arthamandapa. Right: EastâA˘S¸West
section of Kandariya Mahadev temple. (Source: Rian. Isef
(2007))
Analysis of Kandariya Mahadev Temple
Floor Plan
In the foundation of any Hindu temple, the center of
mandala is the source of cosmos which is embodied by
laying down the diagram of Vastupurusha mandala on a
selected ground which grasp cosmic energies beneath the
structure, which are radiated outwards to the physical
world. The image of cosmos is reflected, through this
divine diagram by its fractal qualities. The square shape
maintains the energy equilibrium. (Rian Iasef, 2007). In
early stages temple plans were a direct copy of
Vastupurusha mandala later they became complex by
rotating the sides of square sideways depicting cosmic
energy radiation. Thus, temple plan has become a visual
expression of energy radiation before it was only a
symbolic expression. Lastly, during the 11th century, the
plan of Hindu temple had attained its final shape as the
result of third fractal iteration of mandala. This modified
and matured plan was widely adopted in the North Indian
temples; among those Kandaraiya Mahadev temple at
Kahjuraho is the most remarkable. The plan of Kandariya
Mahadev temple is the result of third iteration of Pitah
mandala (36-squares grid). (Rian Iasef, 2007). Analyzing
the plan considering the Mandapa proportion, inner
square of Garbhagriha is in accordance with the inner
square of Mahamandapa, Mandapa and Ardhamandapa.
Width of Mandapa platform is same as the width of
Prasada and it is the limiting factor for the smallest
Mandpa irrespective of the function they were supposed
to handle. The center of Garbhagriha is formed by the
corner edge of the square of Mandapa’s offset wall.
Length of Mandapa is also redoubled considering the
length of Bhahyabhitti of Garbhagriha (Fig. 5).
Figure 5: Proportion analysis of the Plan-Kandariya
mahadev Temple
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
Ragima NR. 094
Figure 6: whole form of shikhara is repeated in a part
within another part (marked by red color). Repetitions of
tower above the mandapas (marked by green color) create
angle for upward eye movement to the summit of main
shikhara. (Source: Rian. Isef (2007)
Elevation
Hindu cosmology, manifested in the plan of Hindu temple
two dimensionally, was also manifested in its elevation but
three dimensionally and more symbolically. Here the
Sthapati has employed this with the help of Fractal
geometry which is a proportionate arrangement of self-
similar structure i.e. the roofs of Mandapa with that of
Shikhara. The Stapati has taken the model of mountain for
the fractal object where self-similar mounts are repeated
and recurred pointing towards the sky. They resemble
series of graded peaks that resemble a mountain range to
which a Hindu temple is frequently compared.
Figure 7: Proportion analysis of the Elevation- Kandariya
mahadev Temple
These peaks, arranged along the axial line, rise and fall
alternately while maintaining the over- all upward accent,
and culminating in the tallest spire (shikhara). (Trivedi Kirti
1989). In the case of Kandariya mahadev temple it
resembles Mount Kailash being aboded to lord Siva.
Above the assembly hall, i.e., mandapa the main tower is
repeated within its own body and at the same time its
whole body is repeated along the axis of mandapa to the
entrance. This arrangement of repetitive towers above the
mandapa (assembly hall) and ardhamandapa (entrance
porch) is such that it makes to move up one’s eyes
automatically to the main tower above sanctuary and from
that travel up through the summit of finial to the axis of
cosmos (Fig. 6). (Rian Iasef, 2007). They follow a
proportion of 1: 1.6: 2.6. (Fig. 7) Thus, the highest point of
the Shikhara above the sanctuary is believed as the
ultimate point of liberation from the physical world. Thus,
the proportionate arrangement of Mandapas provide an
expression of cosmos to the whole temple form.
Ashapuri temple complex
The village of Ashapuri is about 32 km south of Bhopal,
and 6 km from the famous, unfinished Shiva temple of
Bhojpur. It is now under the protection of the Directorate of
Archaeology, Archives and Museums (DAAM),
Government of Madhya Pradesh. Ashapuri seems to be an
urban settlement near Bhojpur when Bhoja the king of
Bhojpur started the construction of Shiva temple, bhojpur.
The site Ashapuri has now discovered with 26 temple
reminisces. Now the site is known as Bhuthnath named
after the name given locally to temple no:21. (Hardy Adam
2007) The temples where constructed between 9th to 11th
C AD. Out of the remains only two temples could be
reconstructed, Temple no: 17 Surya temple and temple
no:5 both from Prathihara period. So, these two temples
where only selected for proportion study. They follow post
Gupta Nagara tradition.
Analysis of Temple no: 17
Temple no:17 is the earliest of the group, built in first half
of 9th C AD also known as Surya temple. It is oriented
towards east. It has a Mukhamandapa leading to the
anatrala then to Garbhagriha. It was said that it belongs to
Latina mode of Nagara temple construction and is
Pancharatha plan by Adam Hardy in Ashapuri:
Resurrecting a Medieval Temple Site. The deity and its
disposition are unusual for a Surya temple.
Floor Plan
In plan it consists a Mukhamandapa, antarala leading to
Garbhagriha. By early 9th C Mandapa started to be added
in proportion. Mandapa is connected to Garbhagriha
through antarala which acts a separation between the two
or may like the projections on the three sides of
Garbhagriha mandapa is added after the fourth projection
towards the entrance. Ashapuri temples were constructed
before the text Samarangana sutradhara was written but
they seem to follow the proportion as mentioned in the text.
Width of Mukhamandapa is 3 parts the width of Prasada
and its depth is 2 Parts of its width. (fig 8) Masons might
have had their proportion in mind and it coincides with the
proportion as said in the ancient text.
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
Int. Res. J. Archit. Planning 095
Elevation
Just like complex temple now a day they also resemble to
a mountain by their proportionate arrangement allowing
the spectator’s eyes to move upwards. The decorations
over the roof of Mandapa and shikhara is again an
example for fractal geometry which symbolize cosmos in
3D. Externally they seem to be a single mass where the
height of mandapa restricted by Sukhanasa over antarala
which is half the height of Shikhara as mentioned in
ancient texts. (fig 9) From the analysis it is clear that the
temple 17 have followed the proportion as mention in
ancient texts.
Figure 8: Proportion analysis of the Plan temple 17
Figure 9: Proportion analysis of the Elevation temple 17
Analysis of Temple no: 5
Temple no:5 built by the end of 9th C or in the early
beginning of 10th C. Its oriented facing West. It has a
Mukhamandapa leading to the antarala then to
Garbhagriha like temple no:17. The exact size were not
known but can be estimated with accuracy from available
studies. This temple is a composite temple of Nagara
tradition developing into Shekhari form used in Khajuraho
temples. It exhibits a beautiful precursor of Shekhari
concept. (Adam Hardy 2007)
Floor Plan
In plan it consists a Mukhamandapa, antarala leading to
Garbhagriha. Mandapa is connected to Garbhagriha
through antrala which acts a separation between the two
like in the previous temple. Ashapuri temples were
constructed before the text Samarangana sutradhara was
written but they seem to follow the proportion as mentioned
in the text. Here the inner square of Mandapa seem to
have the same proportion as that of Garbhagriha (fig 10)
as in a fully developed temple or it is similar to that in
Kandariya mahadev even if it’s a Nirandhara plan. Which
again proves it be shekahari form.
Figure 10: Proportion analysis of the Plan temple 5
Figure 11: Proportion analysis of the Elevation temple 5
The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India
Ragima NR. 096
Elevation
This temple also resembles to a mountain by their
proportionate arrangement allowing the spectator’s eyes
to move upwards. Fractal geometry is visible in the
decorations over mandapa as well as shikhara resembling
cosmos. Externally they seem to be a single mass joined
by Sukhanasa outside and divided by anatrala inside. (fig
11) From the analysis it is clear that the temple 5 have also
followed the proportion as mention in ancient texts.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
Indian temples are microcosm of Cosmos, acting as a
connecting bridge between physical world and divine
world through their proportional arrangement. Mandapa,
which were entrance porches in the beginning became an
integral part of the temple plan in providing additional
functions and in form providing an expression of cosmos
especially in elevation.
Ashapuri temples analyzed here, corresponds to Nagara
temple proportions varying in proportions they belong to
two different styles of Nagara Architecture.From the study
of Adam Hardy, it can be inferred that they possessed
temples of different styles in Nagara other than these two.
The site of Ashapuri seems to be a place for the
development of Nagara school of Architecture.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
To Dr. Ujwala Chakradeo, Principal Smt .Manoramabai
Mundel college Of Architecture, Seminary Hills, Nagpur for
giving her valuable guidance, constant encouragement
and support to carry out the research.
REFERENCES
Brown, Percy. Indian Architecture (Buddhist and Hindu
Period). Kiran book agency: New Delhi P.P 62-66
Dagens. Bruno (2007). Mayamatam (Vol II). Motilal
Banarsidass publishers Pvt Ltd: New Delhi P.P 451-501
Fergusson James (1876) History of Indian and Eastern
Architecture; Saraswati press
Hardy, Adam. (2007). The Temple Architecture of India.
Chichester: Wiley P. P 90-123
Hardy, Adam. 2015. Theory and practice of Temple
Architecture in Medivial India. Indira gandhi national
center for Arts, Deve publishers & distributors: New
Delhi
Kramrisch, Stella. 1946. The Hindu Temple (Vol 1).
Montilal banarsidas : New Delhi P.P 227-260
Meister.W. Micheal. (1985). Measurement and proportion
In Hindu Temple Ar- chitecture. Departments of the
History of Art and South Asia Regional Studies.
University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, USA
Pandya Yatin (2007) Concepts of space in traditional
Indian Architecture; Grantha Corporation
Parimo. Rathan (1995). Studies in Jaina Art and
Iconography and Allied subjects in honour of Dr. U P
Shah. Abhinav Publications: Vadodhara P.P 91- 101
Raz Ram (1834) Essay on the architecture of the
HindÞs. J. L Cox & Son: London
Rian. Iasef (2007) Fractal geometry as the synthesis of
Hindu cosmology in Kan- dariya Mahadev temple,
Khajuraho. De- partment of Architecture, Inha
University, South Korea
Samarangana sutradhara of Bhojadev (Vol II) (2015).
Parimal publications: New Delhi P.P 274-284
Trivedi. Kirti (1989) Hindu Temples: Models of Fractal
Universe. Industrial Design Center. Indian Institute of
Technology, Powai, Bombay
Accepted 15 August 2019
Citation: Ragima NR (2019). The Proportioning System of
the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple
Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev
Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India.
International Research Journal of Architecture and
Planning. 4(2): 089-096.
Copyright: © 2019. Ragima NR. This is an open-access
article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
provided the original author and source are cited.

More Related Content

What's hot

Brihadeshwara Temple, Tanjaur, Tamilnadu, India (Chola Temple)
Brihadeshwara Temple, Tanjaur, Tamilnadu, India (Chola Temple)Brihadeshwara Temple, Tanjaur, Tamilnadu, India (Chola Temple)
Brihadeshwara Temple, Tanjaur, Tamilnadu, India (Chola Temple)Banaras Hindu University
 
Indo saracenic architecture
Indo saracenic architectureIndo saracenic architecture
Indo saracenic architectureShivika Gulati
 
Ancient temples Geometry - conference paper prepared on 28th Feb. 2021
Ancient temples Geometry - conference paper prepared on 28th Feb. 2021 Ancient temples Geometry - conference paper prepared on 28th Feb. 2021
Ancient temples Geometry - conference paper prepared on 28th Feb. 2021 Samirsinh Parmar
 
Uttarakhand Architecture: Sarais of Haridwar
Uttarakhand Architecture: Sarais of HaridwarUttarakhand Architecture: Sarais of Haridwar
Uttarakhand Architecture: Sarais of HaridwarSneha Nagarajan
 
vedic civilization
vedic civilizationvedic civilization
vedic civilizationapoorva jain
 
Bharat Bhavan, Bhopal
Bharat Bhavan, BhopalBharat Bhavan, Bhopal
Bharat Bhavan, BhopalDivya Suresh
 
Bengal Provincial style
Bengal Provincial styleBengal Provincial style
Bengal Provincial styleMahak Gupta
 
report of dance, drama and music academy and auditorium
report of dance, drama and music academy and auditoriumreport of dance, drama and music academy and auditorium
report of dance, drama and music academy and auditoriumShourya Puri
 
Surya temple osian
Surya temple  osianSurya temple  osian
Surya temple osianMonica Raghu
 
Madhurai meenakshi temple
Madhurai meenakshi templeMadhurai meenakshi temple
Madhurai meenakshi templeRoopa Chikkalgi
 
HISTORY: Indian Architecture
HISTORY: Indian ArchitectureHISTORY: Indian Architecture
HISTORY: Indian ArchitectureArchiEducPH
 
Lecture vi indo aryan temples
Lecture vi indo aryan templesLecture vi indo aryan temples
Lecture vi indo aryan templesHena Dutt
 
Evolution of Hindu Temple Architecture
Evolution of Hindu Temple ArchitectureEvolution of Hindu Temple Architecture
Evolution of Hindu Temple ArchitectureSumathi Mariappan
 
Islamic architecture of India
Islamic architecture of IndiaIslamic architecture of India
Islamic architecture of IndiaAr. TANIA BERA
 

What's hot (20)

Shore temple
Shore templeShore temple
Shore temple
 
Brihadeshwara Temple, Tanjaur, Tamilnadu, India (Chola Temple)
Brihadeshwara Temple, Tanjaur, Tamilnadu, India (Chola Temple)Brihadeshwara Temple, Tanjaur, Tamilnadu, India (Chola Temple)
Brihadeshwara Temple, Tanjaur, Tamilnadu, India (Chola Temple)
 
Indo saracenic architecture
Indo saracenic architectureIndo saracenic architecture
Indo saracenic architecture
 
Humayun's tomb
Humayun's tombHumayun's tomb
Humayun's tomb
 
Ancient temples Geometry - conference paper prepared on 28th Feb. 2021
Ancient temples Geometry - conference paper prepared on 28th Feb. 2021 Ancient temples Geometry - conference paper prepared on 28th Feb. 2021
Ancient temples Geometry - conference paper prepared on 28th Feb. 2021
 
Uttarakhand Architecture: Sarais of Haridwar
Uttarakhand Architecture: Sarais of HaridwarUttarakhand Architecture: Sarais of Haridwar
Uttarakhand Architecture: Sarais of Haridwar
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
vedic civilization
vedic civilizationvedic civilization
vedic civilization
 
Haridwar
HaridwarHaridwar
Haridwar
 
Bharat Bhavan, Bhopal
Bharat Bhavan, BhopalBharat Bhavan, Bhopal
Bharat Bhavan, Bhopal
 
Temple case study
Temple case studyTemple case study
Temple case study
 
Bengal Provincial style
Bengal Provincial styleBengal Provincial style
Bengal Provincial style
 
report of dance, drama and music academy and auditorium
report of dance, drama and music academy and auditoriumreport of dance, drama and music academy and auditorium
report of dance, drama and music academy and auditorium
 
Surya temple osian
Surya temple  osianSurya temple  osian
Surya temple osian
 
Madhurai meenakshi temple
Madhurai meenakshi templeMadhurai meenakshi temple
Madhurai meenakshi temple
 
Dissertation _ Museum
Dissertation _ MuseumDissertation _ Museum
Dissertation _ Museum
 
HISTORY: Indian Architecture
HISTORY: Indian ArchitectureHISTORY: Indian Architecture
HISTORY: Indian Architecture
 
Lecture vi indo aryan temples
Lecture vi indo aryan templesLecture vi indo aryan temples
Lecture vi indo aryan temples
 
Evolution of Hindu Temple Architecture
Evolution of Hindu Temple ArchitectureEvolution of Hindu Temple Architecture
Evolution of Hindu Temple Architecture
 
Islamic architecture of India
Islamic architecture of IndiaIslamic architecture of India
Islamic architecture of India
 

Similar to The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India

GEOMETRICAL DESIGN PHILOSOPHY OF ANCIENT INDIAN TEMPLE AND ITS CONSTRUCTION M...
GEOMETRICAL DESIGN PHILOSOPHY OF ANCIENT INDIAN TEMPLE AND ITS CONSTRUCTION M...GEOMETRICAL DESIGN PHILOSOPHY OF ANCIENT INDIAN TEMPLE AND ITS CONSTRUCTION M...
GEOMETRICAL DESIGN PHILOSOPHY OF ANCIENT INDIAN TEMPLE AND ITS CONSTRUCTION M...Samirsinh Parmar
 
Mathematical aspect of all the geometrical shapes used in the architecture of...
Mathematical aspect of all the geometrical shapes used in the architecture of...Mathematical aspect of all the geometrical shapes used in the architecture of...
Mathematical aspect of all the geometrical shapes used in the architecture of...shamila53
 
Spiritual Splendor_ Exploring the Symbolism and Marvels of Hindu Temple Archi...
Spiritual Splendor_ Exploring the Symbolism and Marvels of Hindu Temple Archi...Spiritual Splendor_ Exploring the Symbolism and Marvels of Hindu Temple Archi...
Spiritual Splendor_ Exploring the Symbolism and Marvels of Hindu Temple Archi...Abir Pothi
 
2133138-A REVIEW STUDY ON ARCHITECTURE OF HINDU TEMPLE (1).pdf
2133138-A REVIEW STUDY ON ARCHITECTURE OF HINDU TEMPLE (1).pdf2133138-A REVIEW STUDY ON ARCHITECTURE OF HINDU TEMPLE (1).pdf
2133138-A REVIEW STUDY ON ARCHITECTURE OF HINDU TEMPLE (1).pdfKanakYadav27
 
A railing in hindu temples
A railing in hindu templesA railing in hindu temples
A railing in hindu templesuday lokras
 
A railing of Hindu temples
A railing of Hindu templesA railing of Hindu temples
A railing of Hindu templesUdayDokras2
 
Human body and hindu temple 11
Human body and hindu temple 11Human body and hindu temple 11
Human body and hindu temple 11Betsy Booboo
 
temple technique literature study A0 SIZE
temple technique literature study A0 SIZEtemple technique literature study A0 SIZE
temple technique literature study A0 SIZEajay maurya
 
Architecture of the Temple Of Vishnu
Architecture of the Temple Of VishnuArchitecture of the Temple Of Vishnu
Architecture of the Temple Of Vishnuinventionjournals
 
Minorprojectreport 121211061936-phpapp02
Minorprojectreport 121211061936-phpapp02Minorprojectreport 121211061936-phpapp02
Minorprojectreport 121211061936-phpapp02mnrao62
 
2013 - Indian Temple Typologies
2013 - Indian Temple Typologies2013 - Indian Temple Typologies
2013 - Indian Temple TypologiesJill Brown
 
Through the Lens of Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS)-Ancient Indian.pdf
Through the Lens of Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS)-Ancient Indian.pdfThrough the Lens of Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS)-Ancient Indian.pdf
Through the Lens of Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS)-Ancient Indian.pdfdrningthouchronicle
 
Hindu architecture and art
Hindu architecture and artHindu architecture and art
Hindu architecture and artDhruva Methi
 
Hindu temples - ARCH 203
Hindu temples - ARCH 203Hindu temples - ARCH 203
Hindu temples - ARCH 203LipikaPandey
 
Jain architecture final 1
Jain architecture final 1Jain architecture final 1
Jain architecture final 1aziz khan
 

Similar to The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India (20)

GEOMETRICAL DESIGN PHILOSOPHY OF ANCIENT INDIAN TEMPLE AND ITS CONSTRUCTION M...
GEOMETRICAL DESIGN PHILOSOPHY OF ANCIENT INDIAN TEMPLE AND ITS CONSTRUCTION M...GEOMETRICAL DESIGN PHILOSOPHY OF ANCIENT INDIAN TEMPLE AND ITS CONSTRUCTION M...
GEOMETRICAL DESIGN PHILOSOPHY OF ANCIENT INDIAN TEMPLE AND ITS CONSTRUCTION M...
 
Mathematical aspect of all the geometrical shapes used in the architecture of...
Mathematical aspect of all the geometrical shapes used in the architecture of...Mathematical aspect of all the geometrical shapes used in the architecture of...
Mathematical aspect of all the geometrical shapes used in the architecture of...
 
Spiritual Splendor_ Exploring the Symbolism and Marvels of Hindu Temple Archi...
Spiritual Splendor_ Exploring the Symbolism and Marvels of Hindu Temple Archi...Spiritual Splendor_ Exploring the Symbolism and Marvels of Hindu Temple Archi...
Spiritual Splendor_ Exploring the Symbolism and Marvels of Hindu Temple Archi...
 
2133138-A REVIEW STUDY ON ARCHITECTURE OF HINDU TEMPLE (1).pdf
2133138-A REVIEW STUDY ON ARCHITECTURE OF HINDU TEMPLE (1).pdf2133138-A REVIEW STUDY ON ARCHITECTURE OF HINDU TEMPLE (1).pdf
2133138-A REVIEW STUDY ON ARCHITECTURE OF HINDU TEMPLE (1).pdf
 
A railing in hindu temples
A railing in hindu templesA railing in hindu temples
A railing in hindu temples
 
A railing of Hindu temples
A railing of Hindu templesA railing of Hindu temples
A railing of Hindu temples
 
Human body and hindu temple 11
Human body and hindu temple 11Human body and hindu temple 11
Human body and hindu temple 11
 
Vastu Shastra.ppt
Vastu Shastra.pptVastu Shastra.ppt
Vastu Shastra.ppt
 
temple technique literature study A0 SIZE
temple technique literature study A0 SIZEtemple technique literature study A0 SIZE
temple technique literature study A0 SIZE
 
Architecture of the Temple Of Vishnu
Architecture of the Temple Of VishnuArchitecture of the Temple Of Vishnu
Architecture of the Temple Of Vishnu
 
Temple geometry
Temple geometryTemple geometry
Temple geometry
 
Indian Design Idenity
Indian Design IdenityIndian Design Idenity
Indian Design Idenity
 
Minorprojectreport 121211061936-phpapp02
Minorprojectreport 121211061936-phpapp02Minorprojectreport 121211061936-phpapp02
Minorprojectreport 121211061936-phpapp02
 
2013 - Indian Temple Typologies
2013 - Indian Temple Typologies2013 - Indian Temple Typologies
2013 - Indian Temple Typologies
 
Through the Lens of Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS)-Ancient Indian.pdf
Through the Lens of Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS)-Ancient Indian.pdfThrough the Lens of Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS)-Ancient Indian.pdf
Through the Lens of Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS)-Ancient Indian.pdf
 
Budhhist Architecture
Budhhist ArchitectureBudhhist Architecture
Budhhist Architecture
 
Hindu architecture and art
Hindu architecture and artHindu architecture and art
Hindu architecture and art
 
Hindu temples - ARCH 203
Hindu temples - ARCH 203Hindu temples - ARCH 203
Hindu temples - ARCH 203
 
Jain architecture final 1
Jain architecture final 1Jain architecture final 1
Jain architecture final 1
 
Dravidian Architecture
Dravidian ArchitectureDravidian Architecture
Dravidian Architecture
 

More from Premier Publishers

Evaluation of Agro-morphological Performances of Hybrid Varieties of Chili Pe...
Evaluation of Agro-morphological Performances of Hybrid Varieties of Chili Pe...Evaluation of Agro-morphological Performances of Hybrid Varieties of Chili Pe...
Evaluation of Agro-morphological Performances of Hybrid Varieties of Chili Pe...Premier Publishers
 
An Empirical Approach for the Variation in Capital Market Price Changes
An Empirical Approach for the Variation in Capital Market Price Changes An Empirical Approach for the Variation in Capital Market Price Changes
An Empirical Approach for the Variation in Capital Market Price Changes Premier Publishers
 
Influence of Nitrogen and Spacing on Growth and Yield of Chia (Salvia hispani...
Influence of Nitrogen and Spacing on Growth and Yield of Chia (Salvia hispani...Influence of Nitrogen and Spacing on Growth and Yield of Chia (Salvia hispani...
Influence of Nitrogen and Spacing on Growth and Yield of Chia (Salvia hispani...Premier Publishers
 
Enhancing Social Capital During the Pandemic: A Case of the Rural Women in Bu...
Enhancing Social Capital During the Pandemic: A Case of the Rural Women in Bu...Enhancing Social Capital During the Pandemic: A Case of the Rural Women in Bu...
Enhancing Social Capital During the Pandemic: A Case of the Rural Women in Bu...Premier Publishers
 
Impact of Provision of Litigation Supports through Forensic Investigations on...
Impact of Provision of Litigation Supports through Forensic Investigations on...Impact of Provision of Litigation Supports through Forensic Investigations on...
Impact of Provision of Litigation Supports through Forensic Investigations on...Premier Publishers
 
Improving the Efficiency of Ratio Estimators by Calibration Weightings
Improving the Efficiency of Ratio Estimators by Calibration WeightingsImproving the Efficiency of Ratio Estimators by Calibration Weightings
Improving the Efficiency of Ratio Estimators by Calibration WeightingsPremier Publishers
 
Urban Liveability in the Context of Sustainable Development: A Perspective fr...
Urban Liveability in the Context of Sustainable Development: A Perspective fr...Urban Liveability in the Context of Sustainable Development: A Perspective fr...
Urban Liveability in the Context of Sustainable Development: A Perspective fr...Premier Publishers
 
Transcript Level of Genes Involved in “Rebaudioside A” Biosynthesis Pathway u...
Transcript Level of Genes Involved in “Rebaudioside A” Biosynthesis Pathway u...Transcript Level of Genes Involved in “Rebaudioside A” Biosynthesis Pathway u...
Transcript Level of Genes Involved in “Rebaudioside A” Biosynthesis Pathway u...Premier Publishers
 
Multivariate Analysis of Tea (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze) Clones on Mor...
Multivariate Analysis of Tea (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze) Clones on Mor...Multivariate Analysis of Tea (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze) Clones on Mor...
Multivariate Analysis of Tea (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze) Clones on Mor...Premier Publishers
 
Causes, Consequences and Remedies of Juvenile Delinquency in the Context of S...
Causes, Consequences and Remedies of Juvenile Delinquency in the Context of S...Causes, Consequences and Remedies of Juvenile Delinquency in the Context of S...
Causes, Consequences and Remedies of Juvenile Delinquency in the Context of S...Premier Publishers
 
The Knowledge of and Attitude to and Beliefs about Causes and Treatments of M...
The Knowledge of and Attitude to and Beliefs about Causes and Treatments of M...The Knowledge of and Attitude to and Beliefs about Causes and Treatments of M...
The Knowledge of and Attitude to and Beliefs about Causes and Treatments of M...Premier Publishers
 
Effect of Phosphorus and Zinc on the Growth, Nodulation and Yield of Soybean ...
Effect of Phosphorus and Zinc on the Growth, Nodulation and Yield of Soybean ...Effect of Phosphorus and Zinc on the Growth, Nodulation and Yield of Soybean ...
Effect of Phosphorus and Zinc on the Growth, Nodulation and Yield of Soybean ...Premier Publishers
 
Influence of Harvest Stage on Yield and Yield Components of Orange Fleshed Sw...
Influence of Harvest Stage on Yield and Yield Components of Orange Fleshed Sw...Influence of Harvest Stage on Yield and Yield Components of Orange Fleshed Sw...
Influence of Harvest Stage on Yield and Yield Components of Orange Fleshed Sw...Premier Publishers
 
Performance evaluation of upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and variability study...
Performance evaluation of upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and variability study...Performance evaluation of upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and variability study...
Performance evaluation of upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and variability study...Premier Publishers
 
Response of Hot Pepper (Capsicum Annuum L.) to Deficit Irrigation in Bennatse...
Response of Hot Pepper (Capsicum Annuum L.) to Deficit Irrigation in Bennatse...Response of Hot Pepper (Capsicum Annuum L.) to Deficit Irrigation in Bennatse...
Response of Hot Pepper (Capsicum Annuum L.) to Deficit Irrigation in Bennatse...Premier Publishers
 
Harnessing the Power of Agricultural Waste: A Study of Sabo Market, Ikorodu, ...
Harnessing the Power of Agricultural Waste: A Study of Sabo Market, Ikorodu, ...Harnessing the Power of Agricultural Waste: A Study of Sabo Market, Ikorodu, ...
Harnessing the Power of Agricultural Waste: A Study of Sabo Market, Ikorodu, ...Premier Publishers
 
Influence of Conferences and Job Rotation on Job Productivity of Library Staf...
Influence of Conferences and Job Rotation on Job Productivity of Library Staf...Influence of Conferences and Job Rotation on Job Productivity of Library Staf...
Influence of Conferences and Job Rotation on Job Productivity of Library Staf...Premier Publishers
 
Scanning Electron Microscopic Structure and Composition of Urinary Calculi of...
Scanning Electron Microscopic Structure and Composition of Urinary Calculi of...Scanning Electron Microscopic Structure and Composition of Urinary Calculi of...
Scanning Electron Microscopic Structure and Composition of Urinary Calculi of...Premier Publishers
 
Gentrification and its Effects on Minority Communities – A Comparative Case S...
Gentrification and its Effects on Minority Communities – A Comparative Case S...Gentrification and its Effects on Minority Communities – A Comparative Case S...
Gentrification and its Effects on Minority Communities – A Comparative Case S...Premier Publishers
 
Oil and Fatty Acid Composition Analysis of Ethiopian Mustard (Brasicacarinata...
Oil and Fatty Acid Composition Analysis of Ethiopian Mustard (Brasicacarinata...Oil and Fatty Acid Composition Analysis of Ethiopian Mustard (Brasicacarinata...
Oil and Fatty Acid Composition Analysis of Ethiopian Mustard (Brasicacarinata...Premier Publishers
 

More from Premier Publishers (20)

Evaluation of Agro-morphological Performances of Hybrid Varieties of Chili Pe...
Evaluation of Agro-morphological Performances of Hybrid Varieties of Chili Pe...Evaluation of Agro-morphological Performances of Hybrid Varieties of Chili Pe...
Evaluation of Agro-morphological Performances of Hybrid Varieties of Chili Pe...
 
An Empirical Approach for the Variation in Capital Market Price Changes
An Empirical Approach for the Variation in Capital Market Price Changes An Empirical Approach for the Variation in Capital Market Price Changes
An Empirical Approach for the Variation in Capital Market Price Changes
 
Influence of Nitrogen and Spacing on Growth and Yield of Chia (Salvia hispani...
Influence of Nitrogen and Spacing on Growth and Yield of Chia (Salvia hispani...Influence of Nitrogen and Spacing on Growth and Yield of Chia (Salvia hispani...
Influence of Nitrogen and Spacing on Growth and Yield of Chia (Salvia hispani...
 
Enhancing Social Capital During the Pandemic: A Case of the Rural Women in Bu...
Enhancing Social Capital During the Pandemic: A Case of the Rural Women in Bu...Enhancing Social Capital During the Pandemic: A Case of the Rural Women in Bu...
Enhancing Social Capital During the Pandemic: A Case of the Rural Women in Bu...
 
Impact of Provision of Litigation Supports through Forensic Investigations on...
Impact of Provision of Litigation Supports through Forensic Investigations on...Impact of Provision of Litigation Supports through Forensic Investigations on...
Impact of Provision of Litigation Supports through Forensic Investigations on...
 
Improving the Efficiency of Ratio Estimators by Calibration Weightings
Improving the Efficiency of Ratio Estimators by Calibration WeightingsImproving the Efficiency of Ratio Estimators by Calibration Weightings
Improving the Efficiency of Ratio Estimators by Calibration Weightings
 
Urban Liveability in the Context of Sustainable Development: A Perspective fr...
Urban Liveability in the Context of Sustainable Development: A Perspective fr...Urban Liveability in the Context of Sustainable Development: A Perspective fr...
Urban Liveability in the Context of Sustainable Development: A Perspective fr...
 
Transcript Level of Genes Involved in “Rebaudioside A” Biosynthesis Pathway u...
Transcript Level of Genes Involved in “Rebaudioside A” Biosynthesis Pathway u...Transcript Level of Genes Involved in “Rebaudioside A” Biosynthesis Pathway u...
Transcript Level of Genes Involved in “Rebaudioside A” Biosynthesis Pathway u...
 
Multivariate Analysis of Tea (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze) Clones on Mor...
Multivariate Analysis of Tea (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze) Clones on Mor...Multivariate Analysis of Tea (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze) Clones on Mor...
Multivariate Analysis of Tea (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze) Clones on Mor...
 
Causes, Consequences and Remedies of Juvenile Delinquency in the Context of S...
Causes, Consequences and Remedies of Juvenile Delinquency in the Context of S...Causes, Consequences and Remedies of Juvenile Delinquency in the Context of S...
Causes, Consequences and Remedies of Juvenile Delinquency in the Context of S...
 
The Knowledge of and Attitude to and Beliefs about Causes and Treatments of M...
The Knowledge of and Attitude to and Beliefs about Causes and Treatments of M...The Knowledge of and Attitude to and Beliefs about Causes and Treatments of M...
The Knowledge of and Attitude to and Beliefs about Causes and Treatments of M...
 
Effect of Phosphorus and Zinc on the Growth, Nodulation and Yield of Soybean ...
Effect of Phosphorus and Zinc on the Growth, Nodulation and Yield of Soybean ...Effect of Phosphorus and Zinc on the Growth, Nodulation and Yield of Soybean ...
Effect of Phosphorus and Zinc on the Growth, Nodulation and Yield of Soybean ...
 
Influence of Harvest Stage on Yield and Yield Components of Orange Fleshed Sw...
Influence of Harvest Stage on Yield and Yield Components of Orange Fleshed Sw...Influence of Harvest Stage on Yield and Yield Components of Orange Fleshed Sw...
Influence of Harvest Stage on Yield and Yield Components of Orange Fleshed Sw...
 
Performance evaluation of upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and variability study...
Performance evaluation of upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and variability study...Performance evaluation of upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and variability study...
Performance evaluation of upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and variability study...
 
Response of Hot Pepper (Capsicum Annuum L.) to Deficit Irrigation in Bennatse...
Response of Hot Pepper (Capsicum Annuum L.) to Deficit Irrigation in Bennatse...Response of Hot Pepper (Capsicum Annuum L.) to Deficit Irrigation in Bennatse...
Response of Hot Pepper (Capsicum Annuum L.) to Deficit Irrigation in Bennatse...
 
Harnessing the Power of Agricultural Waste: A Study of Sabo Market, Ikorodu, ...
Harnessing the Power of Agricultural Waste: A Study of Sabo Market, Ikorodu, ...Harnessing the Power of Agricultural Waste: A Study of Sabo Market, Ikorodu, ...
Harnessing the Power of Agricultural Waste: A Study of Sabo Market, Ikorodu, ...
 
Influence of Conferences and Job Rotation on Job Productivity of Library Staf...
Influence of Conferences and Job Rotation on Job Productivity of Library Staf...Influence of Conferences and Job Rotation on Job Productivity of Library Staf...
Influence of Conferences and Job Rotation on Job Productivity of Library Staf...
 
Scanning Electron Microscopic Structure and Composition of Urinary Calculi of...
Scanning Electron Microscopic Structure and Composition of Urinary Calculi of...Scanning Electron Microscopic Structure and Composition of Urinary Calculi of...
Scanning Electron Microscopic Structure and Composition of Urinary Calculi of...
 
Gentrification and its Effects on Minority Communities – A Comparative Case S...
Gentrification and its Effects on Minority Communities – A Comparative Case S...Gentrification and its Effects on Minority Communities – A Comparative Case S...
Gentrification and its Effects on Minority Communities – A Comparative Case S...
 
Oil and Fatty Acid Composition Analysis of Ethiopian Mustard (Brasicacarinata...
Oil and Fatty Acid Composition Analysis of Ethiopian Mustard (Brasicacarinata...Oil and Fatty Acid Composition Analysis of Ethiopian Mustard (Brasicacarinata...
Oil and Fatty Acid Composition Analysis of Ethiopian Mustard (Brasicacarinata...
 

Recently uploaded

Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsanshu789521
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionMaksud Ahmed
 
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesSeparation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesFatimaKhan178732
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Educationpboyjonauth
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfchloefrazer622
 
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Krashi Coaching
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformChameera Dedduwage
 
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxContemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxRoyAbrique
 
Hybridoma Technology ( Production , Purification , and Application )
Hybridoma Technology  ( Production , Purification , and Application  ) Hybridoma Technology  ( Production , Purification , and Application  )
Hybridoma Technology ( Production , Purification , and Application ) Sakshi Ghasle
 
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website AppURLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website AppCeline George
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxMENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxPoojaSen20
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3JemimahLaneBuaron
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfSoniaTolstoy
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionSafetyChain Software
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesSeparation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
 
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdfTataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
 
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
 
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxContemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
 
Hybridoma Technology ( Production , Purification , and Application )
Hybridoma Technology  ( Production , Purification , and Application  ) Hybridoma Technology  ( Production , Purification , and Application  )
Hybridoma Technology ( Production , Purification , and Application )
 
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website AppURLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
 
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxMENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
 
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
 

The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India

  • 1. The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India Ragima N Ramachandran University of Nagpur Email: ragima.nr@gmail.com Proportion and measurements have been the guiding tools for the construction of Indian temples from the 5th century AD onwards to till date. Through-out the history, Proportion dominated as a tool, which determined the monuments spatial arrangements as well as their forms. The ancient texts, therefore, insist on a high degree of precision in their measurements. The standard text Mayamata mentions – “Only if the temple is constructed correctly according to a mathematical system, can it be expected to function in harmony with the universe. Only if the measurement of the temple is in every way perfect, there will be perfection in the universe as well.” In this paper, Mandapas in Indian temples are studied with respect to various parameters like expression, function, proportion, orientation, chronology, etc. This study analyzes the proportion of mandapa in the Indian temple architecture, especially focusing on Nagara style. The evolution of Mandapa and other parameters are discussed in general. These factors are studied with respect to a selected sample. Temples ascribed to the time period between 8th C AD to 15th C AD are taken for the study, as Mandapas were added proportionately from 8th C AD onwards. This comprises the literature part, and is depicted through drawings and diagrams. Selected temples of the Ashapuri complex are also studied through the same perspective and focus. The study will end by examining whether the proportions and design of mandapa in Ashapuri follows Nagara Style. Key words: Ashapuri Temples, Indian Temple Architecture, Mandapa, Proportions INTRODUCTION Indian Temple Architecture India “Land of Temples” (brown Percy) - A land of intense spirituality and religious faith reflected in the profusion of temples present in this subcontinent. Temples are found everywhere in India from large monumental structures to small shrines, each having certain significance and greatly influencing the lives of the people who regard the temple as a place where they could be close to god. The Hindu temple architecture developed over two thousand years. The architectural evolution took place within the rigid frameworks derived entirely from religious thoughtfulness. Architect was bound to adhere to the ancient proportioning systems and configurations, which remained unaltered over the period of time. The ideology behind the designing of Hindu temples is to link, man with the gods. The architect and the sculptor were allowed a great deal of freedom in the embellishment of the structure prescribed as per the underlying principles and formulae. It evolved from simple rock cut architecture in Lomas Rishi Cave (300 BC) to complex temples as Kandariya Mahadeo Temple, Khajuraho and Meenakshi Amman Temple, Madurai in 11th & 16th C AD respectively. Distinctive architectural styles of Hindu temples have so developed due to broad geographical, climatic, cultural, racial, historical and linguistic differences between the northern plains and the southern peninsula of India. Broadly based on geography, Hindu temples have been classified into three different styles; the Nagara or ’northern’ style, the Dravidian or ’southern’ style, and the Vesara or hybrid style. There are also other distinct styles in Bengal, Kerala and the Himalayan valleys. Research Article Vol. 4(2), pp. 089-096, August, 2019. © www.premierpublishers.org. ISSN: 1530-9931 International Research Journal of Architecture and Planning
  • 2. The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India Ragima NR. 090 Proportion in Temples Proportion being an important tool in analyzing individual buildings, also plays an important tool in the study of temple Architecture. Like in Greek Architecture the Orders of pillars served as a tool for proportioning based on column diameter, here in India also, we possessed a proportionate arrangement for Temple Architecture. All of them receive a character of harmony, leading to aesthetic beauty, and peace of our inner soul due to the proportional relationship. The perspective effects in the visual frames and their strategic alignment often pro- vides a basis for the proportioning of spaces. (Pandya Yatin 2013). Indian architecture is considered as true style by Fergusson in his book History of Indian & Eastern Architecture in 1876. Mandapa- the gathering space in temples, evolved later and became sacred as well. They initially developed as a porch, became large mandapas later, and eventually became an integral part of the temple plan and affected the temple form as well. From 8th C AD onwards mandapa also possessed mandala character as that of shrine. (Hardy Adam 2007). Mandapa became a part of the temple entity, affected its plan and form. According to Mayamata, Mandapas should be positioned in front of the shrine and they should follow the same orientation as that of temple shrine. (Table 1) Mandapas are placed on elevated plinth and even if they might be detached as in South Indian temples they are connected together by visual juxtaposition, adjacency, organizational axis and implied route of movement (Pandya Yatin 2013). In this paper, study mainly focuses on Mandapa - its features like orientation, expression, function etc. how it affects the proportion of mandapa or vice versa which determines the proportion of that temple. This is examined through the literature study of a temple - Kandaria Mahadeo temple in Khajuraho. This temple is selected since Khajuraho temples are considered as culmination of Indian art & architecture. A major reason for selection was also the availability of proper data and drawings. The study finally ends with examining of the mandapa proportions of the case study temples at -Ashapuri. Mandapa Mandapa - a general overview The regional classification of Indian Temple Architecture into three major distinct style is the base for the comparison of mandapas. Till 6th C AD North and South styles were of the same kind; after that they evolved. Nagara style is most prominently seen in Orissan temples. Addition of mandapa to temple started in 8th C AD; till then there was only Garbhagriha, ambulatory path and portico, with its width of central bay corresponding to that of sanctum and antarala. In Nagara Mandapa were added along the linear axis, whether detached or attached, with a proportion same as that of Garbhagriha in plan, irrespective of their function; and in elevation the Sukhanasa determined the height of Mandapa giving it a mountain appearance. Later Nagara style developed over time into Latina, Valabhi, Shikhari and Bhumija. In the South of India before the development of great temple complexes of later centuries, Mandapas were unimportant. It was only by 11th C AD, that large, rectangular, flat roofed halls began to appear including open ones. (Hardy Adam 2007). There was a more detached Open Mandapa, larger in proportion to that of Garbhagriha indicating the function they were to perform. In South India, the Open Mandapa gradually got more and more enclosed nearing the sanctum reducing the light and giving a sacred feeling. Mandapas in shrine compound are arranged in front of the shrine and are flat roofed giving emphasis on linearity. In the Deccan region, a temple may have several shrines adjoining a single Mandapa or several interlinked Mandapas. 2 to 5 shrines could be arranged around a Mandapa or even more. Here also, Mandapa seems to be larger and rectangular but the basic square in Mandapa is aligned to the size of Garbhagriha and in elevation the roof of Mandapa is flat. Figure 1: Evolution of mandapa from a) porch to b) Mandapa c) closed mandapa d), e), f), g) one to three porchs attached to a mandapa. (Source: Hardy Adam (2007)) Evolution & Features Mandapa- audience hall of God’s palace (Hardy Adam 2007). They are sacred pillared hall or pavilion for assembly of those paying their devotions. Mandapa established a separate hall, preparatory and subservient to the purpose of Prasada. Ancient temples consisted of a square cella with a small porch in front of it especially temples before 6th C AD as seen in Tigawa temple of Gupta period. They were entrance porches constituting one, two or three entries to the temple shrine. In most of the temples these porches were added separately after the construction of temples. Later they evolved into mandapas- may be enclosed by thick walls, or open like an extended porch (Fig. 1), but still they were not in rhythm to that of their Prasada. Wooden halls of post and beam construction were prototypes for the mandapa construction. By 7th and 8th C AD mandapa had massive roof slabs as in early Chalukyan temples in Karnataka &
  • 3. The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India Int. Res. J. Archit. Planning 091 Andhra Pradesh. A century or more had to pass before the Sthapati arrived at the perfect solution showing the Prasada as the main building and temple proper, with mandapa as the lesser part of the sacred structure, following its rhythm in the particularities of its own form. (Kramrisch Stella 1946). From 8th C AD Mandapa had mandala like character reflecting that of shrine. They were added in proportion; whose proportion was regulated by the proportion of Prasada. This integrity is clearly visible in Orissan temples where it is more strongly retained than elsewhere and only indicates their distinction by a deeper recess produced by the buttresses of the wall of two structures. With-in this lies the porch (antarala) of the Prasada or garbhagriha, fulfills the function of Mukhamandapa of more ancient temples. This small porch is marked on the outside of the Prasada by a buttress carried on to the Sukanasa at the prescribed height which regulates the height of the Mandapa. (Kramrisch Stella 1946). Later as the temple developed into a complex structure, the number of Mandapas also increased. They were added for different purposes and functions like dance, offerings, habitation, upanayanam, marriage, festivals etc. In Orissan temples one could see the gradual development in temple plan and form. The Mandapa started as gathering space i.e. Jagmohan as in Parasurameshwar temple and Muktheswar temple, in the former one the pillared hall was added later after the construction of Garbhagriha but in the latter one the Mandapa structure was constructed along with the Garbhagriha in proportion to it. In later Orissan temples one could see that Mandapas increased in number; they were added according to different functions like a hall for dance called Nat mandir and, a hall for offerings called Bhog mandir. Open mandapas of a scale greater than that of simple porch were known in western India by the end of 8th C AD and were widespread in most regions by 11th C AD. (Hardy Adam 2007). They were added especially for recitations and dance performance, a central platform will be provided, either attached, closed or free-standing. Later the Mandapa got detached as in Sun temple Konark, marking a transition from exterior to interior. In south Indian temples like Madurai Meenakshi and Vitthala temple at Hampi also one could see detached Mandpas added for various functions. According to Benjamin Roland, the culmination of Indo Aryan style is seen in the Khajuraho temples with properly developed temple plan and form. In that also, one could see series of Mandapa starting from Mukhamandapa- the porch to Mandapa and Mahamandapa (larger hall with transepts) which seems to be the part of a same mass externally but separated internally by construction of wall planes. Storied open mandapa appeared by the end of 11th C AD. Mandapa - Proportion in Nagara Style In Indian Temple Architecture, temples are represented in a symbolic language. Hindu philosophy views cosmos to be self- similar in nature. According to ancient architecture tradition, Hindu temples are symbols of models of the cosmos. To maintain harmony with cosmos, all temples are fashioned with the same principles and measurements with which cosmos is made. According to myth, Mount Meru is considered as axis of Cosmos. To resemble this above the central zone of wall proper, rises the roof consisting of series of graded peaks. To express this symbolically in diagrammatic forms basic geometrical figures were used. The Square represents manifest world and the circle the Universe. ‘Mandala’ is a Sanskrit word signifying wholeness. (Trivedi Kirti 1989). Proportion also plays a greater role in this. Till 9th C AD Varahamihira’s Brahtsamhita was the standard text followed for temple construction; by early 11th C AD Nagara temple proportions began to follow a new text Samaranganasutradara. Modification was made in the proportionate measurement of Prasada. Figure 2: Proportionate arrangement of Mandapa to Garbhagriha In plan Mandapa proportion was regulated by Garbhagriha. The center of Mandapa is in a fixed proportion to the garbhagriha, its center square has the same area. The central space is marked by four pillars forming catuski. (Table 2) The superstructure of the Mandapa must not exceed in height the Sukanasa of the Prasada. (Samaranganasutradara). Thus the height of Mandapa will depend upon the height of temple and its sukhanasa which varies always according to temple, thus it is not a fixed one. Proportions of Mandapa to Garbagriha Another method is for example the distance from the square of garbhgriha to Catuskika is the diagonal of these Squares. Here the Center of garbhagriha is the corner of the Square on edge, formed by connecting the angles of the offsets of the wall of Mandapa; Fig. 3 (Kramrisch Stella 1946). In case of Mandapa separated from the temple same theme is applied but varied in their proportionate application, link the Mandapa, built in one other of the 8 to 27 possible varieties, to the Prasada.
  • 4. The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India Ragima NR. 092 Table 1: Mandapa Parameter Mandapa ParametersRelation with mandapa Influence on Proportion or vise versa Orientation Follows same orientation as temple Doesn’t have any influence Location In front of the temple Being located in front of the sanctum its follows the same proportion of Garbhagriha or Prasada or its proportion is determined by that of Garbhagriha or Prasada. Function Mainly for gathering, dance, offerings etc. Proportion is not influenced by func- tion but it proportionately decrease in size from Mahamandapa to Mukhap- mandapa guided by the dimension of Garbhagriha Expression Mandapa affects the temple form as well as plan gives an expression of cosmos Its self similar nature(Fractal) both in plan and elevation achieved through the proportionate arrangement of each Mandpa. Table 2: Proportions of Mandapa to Garbhagrih SamaranganaSutradara Mayamata Manasara Matsyapurana Agnipurana For Nirandhara (prasada(P) 4x4) Pillard porch W=3 parts of P D= 2 parts of P W= W of Prasada Or W= or W of P Small temples Whole L = 4 parts Or 4 1/2 or 6 parts G.G = 2or2 1/2 or 3 parts Antarala = 1 or 1 1/2 or 2 parts Ardha mandapa = 1 or 1 1/2 parts X = side of Q Area of P = 16Q Mandapa W 4X = W Depth 3X = 3W/4 Mukhamandapa 2X = W/2 ”Do” For Sandhara C Q of Mandapa = C Q of G.G W= P or ht of P or diagonal of P (most perfect) L= redoubled the L of P W= 2W of P Or L= 1 W of P Large temples 3 to 4 porticos W= 1 1/2or2 W of G.G Kramrisch, Stella. 1946. The Hindu Temple (Vol 1). Montilal banarsidas: New Delhi Kramrisch, Stella. 1946. The Hindu Temple (Vol 1). Montilal banarsidas: New Delhi Kramrisch, Stella. 1946. The Hindu Temple (Vol 1). Montilal banarsidas: New Delhi Figure 3: Proportionate arrangement of Mandapa to Garbhagriha Kandariya Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho 1030 AD Kandariya Mahadev temple at Khajuraho sets the benchmark of Hindu art and Architecture in India. This temple was constructed when Indian temples had attained the highest point of matured design in the middle of 11th C AD. Kandariya. Mahadev temple has a height of 31m. It is elevated above a lofty plinth which makes the temple structure sanctity and monumental. The temple is faced to the east to welcome the first rays of sun and the structure is 30.5 m long and 20 m wide. It consists of four major parts. 1. Garbhagriha, i.e., sanctuary where the main deity has been kept.
  • 5. The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India Int. Res. J. Archit. Planning 093 2. Pradakshina path, i.e., circumambulatory path having three sides balcony bringing ventilation and light to the interior. 3. Mandapa, i.e., columned assembly hall having two sides balcony. 4. Ardha mandapa, i.e., entrance porch. In Kandariya Mahadev Temple starting from Ardha Mandapa, Mandapa and Maha mandapa one could see three Mandapas in an axis both in plan as well as in elevation, internally they are divided by intermittent walls whereas externally they seem to be the part of the same mass. The Maha Mandapa, largest of the three mandapa is linked to the Garbhagriha through antarala inside and outside its height is determined by the Sukhanasa over antarala. It is pillared hall in front of the Garbhagriha fo the assembly of devotees, used by them to sit, pray, chant and meditate. Like the Prasada, the Mandapas are also oriented in the East West axis and are located in front of the Prasada expressing themselves as a development in temple plan from the simple small temple to a complex one. Self-similarity or fractal geometry is another feature of Indian temples to represent an evolving cosmos. Fractal geometry is the technique of repeating similar shapes in varied scales but in same proportion. In Kandariya mahadev temple it is visible in plan, elevation as well as in decorations. (fig 4) In plan the basic square of Garbhagriha is used for all the Mandapas with their overall sizes varying in proportion to it. In Elevation self- similar repeating structures are the roofs over Mandapas. Even the smallest Mandapa has a roof in decreased size of the largest one in proportion to its which is in overall proportionate the Shikhara. They resemble series of graded peaks that resemble a mountain range to which a Hindu temple is frequently compared. These peaks, arranged along the axial line, rise and fall alternately while maintaining the overall upward accent and culminating in the tallest spire (shikhara). (Trivedi Kirti 1989). Even the minute decorations on shikhara and mandapa roofs are examples for fractal geometry. Figure 4: Left: plan of Kandariya Mahadev temple (11th century): (1) Garbhagriha, (2) Pradakshinapth, (3) Mandapa, and (4) Arthamandapa. Right: EastâA˘S¸West section of Kandariya Mahadev temple. (Source: Rian. Isef (2007)) Analysis of Kandariya Mahadev Temple Floor Plan In the foundation of any Hindu temple, the center of mandala is the source of cosmos which is embodied by laying down the diagram of Vastupurusha mandala on a selected ground which grasp cosmic energies beneath the structure, which are radiated outwards to the physical world. The image of cosmos is reflected, through this divine diagram by its fractal qualities. The square shape maintains the energy equilibrium. (Rian Iasef, 2007). In early stages temple plans were a direct copy of Vastupurusha mandala later they became complex by rotating the sides of square sideways depicting cosmic energy radiation. Thus, temple plan has become a visual expression of energy radiation before it was only a symbolic expression. Lastly, during the 11th century, the plan of Hindu temple had attained its final shape as the result of third fractal iteration of mandala. This modified and matured plan was widely adopted in the North Indian temples; among those Kandaraiya Mahadev temple at Kahjuraho is the most remarkable. The plan of Kandariya Mahadev temple is the result of third iteration of Pitah mandala (36-squares grid). (Rian Iasef, 2007). Analyzing the plan considering the Mandapa proportion, inner square of Garbhagriha is in accordance with the inner square of Mahamandapa, Mandapa and Ardhamandapa. Width of Mandapa platform is same as the width of Prasada and it is the limiting factor for the smallest Mandpa irrespective of the function they were supposed to handle. The center of Garbhagriha is formed by the corner edge of the square of Mandapa’s offset wall. Length of Mandapa is also redoubled considering the length of Bhahyabhitti of Garbhagriha (Fig. 5). Figure 5: Proportion analysis of the Plan-Kandariya mahadev Temple
  • 6. The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India Ragima NR. 094 Figure 6: whole form of shikhara is repeated in a part within another part (marked by red color). Repetitions of tower above the mandapas (marked by green color) create angle for upward eye movement to the summit of main shikhara. (Source: Rian. Isef (2007) Elevation Hindu cosmology, manifested in the plan of Hindu temple two dimensionally, was also manifested in its elevation but three dimensionally and more symbolically. Here the Sthapati has employed this with the help of Fractal geometry which is a proportionate arrangement of self- similar structure i.e. the roofs of Mandapa with that of Shikhara. The Stapati has taken the model of mountain for the fractal object where self-similar mounts are repeated and recurred pointing towards the sky. They resemble series of graded peaks that resemble a mountain range to which a Hindu temple is frequently compared. Figure 7: Proportion analysis of the Elevation- Kandariya mahadev Temple These peaks, arranged along the axial line, rise and fall alternately while maintaining the over- all upward accent, and culminating in the tallest spire (shikhara). (Trivedi Kirti 1989). In the case of Kandariya mahadev temple it resembles Mount Kailash being aboded to lord Siva. Above the assembly hall, i.e., mandapa the main tower is repeated within its own body and at the same time its whole body is repeated along the axis of mandapa to the entrance. This arrangement of repetitive towers above the mandapa (assembly hall) and ardhamandapa (entrance porch) is such that it makes to move up one’s eyes automatically to the main tower above sanctuary and from that travel up through the summit of finial to the axis of cosmos (Fig. 6). (Rian Iasef, 2007). They follow a proportion of 1: 1.6: 2.6. (Fig. 7) Thus, the highest point of the Shikhara above the sanctuary is believed as the ultimate point of liberation from the physical world. Thus, the proportionate arrangement of Mandapas provide an expression of cosmos to the whole temple form. Ashapuri temple complex The village of Ashapuri is about 32 km south of Bhopal, and 6 km from the famous, unfinished Shiva temple of Bhojpur. It is now under the protection of the Directorate of Archaeology, Archives and Museums (DAAM), Government of Madhya Pradesh. Ashapuri seems to be an urban settlement near Bhojpur when Bhoja the king of Bhojpur started the construction of Shiva temple, bhojpur. The site Ashapuri has now discovered with 26 temple reminisces. Now the site is known as Bhuthnath named after the name given locally to temple no:21. (Hardy Adam 2007) The temples where constructed between 9th to 11th C AD. Out of the remains only two temples could be reconstructed, Temple no: 17 Surya temple and temple no:5 both from Prathihara period. So, these two temples where only selected for proportion study. They follow post Gupta Nagara tradition. Analysis of Temple no: 17 Temple no:17 is the earliest of the group, built in first half of 9th C AD also known as Surya temple. It is oriented towards east. It has a Mukhamandapa leading to the anatrala then to Garbhagriha. It was said that it belongs to Latina mode of Nagara temple construction and is Pancharatha plan by Adam Hardy in Ashapuri: Resurrecting a Medieval Temple Site. The deity and its disposition are unusual for a Surya temple. Floor Plan In plan it consists a Mukhamandapa, antarala leading to Garbhagriha. By early 9th C Mandapa started to be added in proportion. Mandapa is connected to Garbhagriha through antarala which acts a separation between the two or may like the projections on the three sides of Garbhagriha mandapa is added after the fourth projection towards the entrance. Ashapuri temples were constructed before the text Samarangana sutradhara was written but they seem to follow the proportion as mentioned in the text. Width of Mukhamandapa is 3 parts the width of Prasada and its depth is 2 Parts of its width. (fig 8) Masons might have had their proportion in mind and it coincides with the proportion as said in the ancient text.
  • 7. The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India Int. Res. J. Archit. Planning 095 Elevation Just like complex temple now a day they also resemble to a mountain by their proportionate arrangement allowing the spectator’s eyes to move upwards. The decorations over the roof of Mandapa and shikhara is again an example for fractal geometry which symbolize cosmos in 3D. Externally they seem to be a single mass where the height of mandapa restricted by Sukhanasa over antarala which is half the height of Shikhara as mentioned in ancient texts. (fig 9) From the analysis it is clear that the temple 17 have followed the proportion as mention in ancient texts. Figure 8: Proportion analysis of the Plan temple 17 Figure 9: Proportion analysis of the Elevation temple 17 Analysis of Temple no: 5 Temple no:5 built by the end of 9th C or in the early beginning of 10th C. Its oriented facing West. It has a Mukhamandapa leading to the antarala then to Garbhagriha like temple no:17. The exact size were not known but can be estimated with accuracy from available studies. This temple is a composite temple of Nagara tradition developing into Shekhari form used in Khajuraho temples. It exhibits a beautiful precursor of Shekhari concept. (Adam Hardy 2007) Floor Plan In plan it consists a Mukhamandapa, antarala leading to Garbhagriha. Mandapa is connected to Garbhagriha through antrala which acts a separation between the two like in the previous temple. Ashapuri temples were constructed before the text Samarangana sutradhara was written but they seem to follow the proportion as mentioned in the text. Here the inner square of Mandapa seem to have the same proportion as that of Garbhagriha (fig 10) as in a fully developed temple or it is similar to that in Kandariya mahadev even if it’s a Nirandhara plan. Which again proves it be shekahari form. Figure 10: Proportion analysis of the Plan temple 5 Figure 11: Proportion analysis of the Elevation temple 5
  • 8. The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India Ragima NR. 096 Elevation This temple also resembles to a mountain by their proportionate arrangement allowing the spectator’s eyes to move upwards. Fractal geometry is visible in the decorations over mandapa as well as shikhara resembling cosmos. Externally they seem to be a single mass joined by Sukhanasa outside and divided by anatrala inside. (fig 11) From the analysis it is clear that the temple 5 have also followed the proportion as mention in ancient texts. CONCLUDING REMARKS Indian temples are microcosm of Cosmos, acting as a connecting bridge between physical world and divine world through their proportional arrangement. Mandapa, which were entrance porches in the beginning became an integral part of the temple plan in providing additional functions and in form providing an expression of cosmos especially in elevation. Ashapuri temples analyzed here, corresponds to Nagara temple proportions varying in proportions they belong to two different styles of Nagara Architecture.From the study of Adam Hardy, it can be inferred that they possessed temples of different styles in Nagara other than these two. The site of Ashapuri seems to be a place for the development of Nagara school of Architecture. ACKNOWLEDGMENT To Dr. Ujwala Chakradeo, Principal Smt .Manoramabai Mundel college Of Architecture, Seminary Hills, Nagpur for giving her valuable guidance, constant encouragement and support to carry out the research. REFERENCES Brown, Percy. Indian Architecture (Buddhist and Hindu Period). Kiran book agency: New Delhi P.P 62-66 Dagens. Bruno (2007). Mayamatam (Vol II). Motilal Banarsidass publishers Pvt Ltd: New Delhi P.P 451-501 Fergusson James (1876) History of Indian and Eastern Architecture; Saraswati press Hardy, Adam. (2007). The Temple Architecture of India. Chichester: Wiley P. P 90-123 Hardy, Adam. 2015. Theory and practice of Temple Architecture in Medivial India. Indira gandhi national center for Arts, Deve publishers & distributors: New Delhi Kramrisch, Stella. 1946. The Hindu Temple (Vol 1). Montilal banarsidas : New Delhi P.P 227-260 Meister.W. Micheal. (1985). Measurement and proportion In Hindu Temple Ar- chitecture. Departments of the History of Art and South Asia Regional Studies. University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, USA Pandya Yatin (2007) Concepts of space in traditional Indian Architecture; Grantha Corporation Parimo. Rathan (1995). Studies in Jaina Art and Iconography and Allied subjects in honour of Dr. U P Shah. Abhinav Publications: Vadodhara P.P 91- 101 Raz Ram (1834) Essay on the architecture of the HindÞs. J. L Cox & Son: London Rian. Iasef (2007) Fractal geometry as the synthesis of Hindu cosmology in Kan- dariya Mahadev temple, Khajuraho. De- partment of Architecture, Inha University, South Korea Samarangana sutradhara of Bhojadev (Vol II) (2015). Parimal publications: New Delhi P.P 274-284 Trivedi. Kirti (1989) Hindu Temples: Models of Fractal Universe. Industrial Design Center. Indian Institute of Technology, Powai, Bombay Accepted 15 August 2019 Citation: Ragima NR (2019). The Proportioning System of the Mandapas as a Tool for Analyzing Indian Temple Architecture: The Case Study of Kandaria Mahadev Temple, Khajuraho & Ashapuri Temples of India. International Research Journal of Architecture and Planning. 4(2): 089-096. Copyright: © 2019. Ragima NR. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are cited.