2. Challenge
To collect and record and analyze and respond to
information, queries, and concerns from the affected
population.
When you are limited in terms of time, human resources, and financial
resources, what are non-traditional ways to do surveys, collect and
respond to feedback?
3. Our goals
To provide more ways to
provide input into a
humanitarian response-
throughout the duration of a
response
To receive feedback or
information about services in
a timely and comprehensive
manner
To respond more quickly to
feedback
To scale
feedback/engagement
mechanisms
To more quickly receive
information about the affected
population’s needs
For the affected
population:
For the humanitarian
actor:
4. Traditional methods
Hotline
HR intensive
Requires reliable
network coverage
Satisfaction box
Require literacy
Often go and unchecked
One-on-one surveys
or interviews
HR intensive
May require additional
data entry, translation
and analysis
Focus group
discussions or
community meetings
HR intensive
Infrequent
Require data entry,
transcription, translation, and
analysis
Comment cards
Require literacy
Require data entry and
translation
5. Why the need for alternatives to traditional
methods?
Traditional methods for ongoing community engagement can be
human resource intensive
Heavy dependence on literacy, phone ownership and network
coverage
Considerable time is needed for data entry, translation and/or
transcription, and analysis
The affected population may be geographically dispersed –
reaching them in-person may not be an option.
7. Key features of a functional solution
Must offer anonymity to users
Must be simple enough to “learn” in a day or two (from
the NGO side)
Must work for multiple languages and/or dialects
Must be inclusive of or accessible by multiple “types” of
people (women, low literacy, etc.)
8. Possible solution: Natural Language
Processing
What is NLP? What could it do for us?
Automatic transcription
Automatic or machine translation
Sentiment analysis
Topic segmentation and recognition
.
Speech recognition
Suggestions Needs
Comments
Complaints
Clean, usable, data
This is about having a continuous conversation with emergency affected people. This cycle should include assessments, unsolicited feedback, post-assistance monitoring, etc. For the IRC – this ongoing engagement, not just one piece of it, is a struggle. This is, due to a lack of dedicated resources/easy methods. ... we are crap at it more than 50% of the time. Donors won’t fund humans to focus on this, and without the humans/funding, our team on the ground focuses on the service provision, not the ongoing engagement that is required to ensure that service provision is acceptable. There currently are not dedicated resources or funding for this side of the work- so having alternative solutions are key.
Surveys- needs assessment, satisfaction surveys
FGDs, KIIs, HHs (Needs assessment)
Provision of information about services
Feedback information collection and processing
Cameroon: Cameroon is Franco and Anglophone. The IRC recently started a new response in the Anglophone region of the country. A phone line already existed in the Francophone region. The team is considering different options for feedback mechanisms. If they want to implement a hotline, the hotline will need to be separate from the existing phone line in order to make sure
Also, currently, there are not sufficient funds to hire a full-time employee to answer the phone and record and respond to questions and inquiries.
There is also a need to provide information about services offered. The response in Cameroon will be doing distributions soon and registering those who qualify for assistance. Many will not receive assistance and will want to know why they were not chosen. There needs to be an easy/wide-reaching way to share the selection criteria information and a way to field inquiries about the distributions.
Yemen- is doing cash distributions. There is a need to have constant communication with the community, including those who are not selected to receive cash, to be transparent and to keep our staff safe.
IRC is interested in supporting partners responding to the current economic and food/health crisis in Venezuela- we need to conduct periodic remote surveys with affected people to do so, to ensure the services we support are meeting needs and not causing harm.
Surveys- needs assessment, satisfaction surveys
FGDs, KIIs, HHs (Needs assessment)
Provision of information about services
Feedback information collection and processing
Must offer anonymity
Respond to/work with multiple languages or dialects
Must be simple enough so that key staff can learn how to use it in a day or two
Machine translation
Automatically translate text from one (non-computer) language to another.
Sentiment analysis
Topic segmentation and recognition
Separate text into segments each of which is devoted to a topic, and identify the topic of the segment.
Speech recognition
Given a sound clip of a person or people speaking, determine the textual representation of the speech
Respond to/work with multiple languages or dialects
Impersonality and fear of technology – will people trust tech?
Lack of phone network in some contexts
Phone ownership coverage
Need to figure out tracking to follow up with people