Food beyond the farm gate: environmental change, adaptation and mitigation - Sonja Vermeulen
1. Food
beyond
the
farm
gate:
environmental
change,
adapta7on
and
mi7ga7on
Sonja
Vermeulen
CGIAR
Research
Program
on
Climate
Change,
Agriculture
and
Food
Security
IARU
Congress,
24
October
2014
7. Which
post-‐farmgate
acOons
maTer
most?
KeaOng
et
al.,
Global
Food
Security
2014
Refrigera7on
Supply
chain
disrup7on
Interna7onal
trade
20%
(diets
and
waste)
46%
34%
8. Food
safety,
refrigeraOon
and
human
health
energy
367
t
CO2eq
waste
578
t
CO2eq
Should
domesOc
fridges
be
colder
or
warmer?
Brown
et
al.,
2014
Int
Journal
of
RefrigeraOon
9. Extreme
weather
events
and
supply
chain
disrupOons
Survey
of
559
companies
in
62
countries,
Zurich
Financial
Services
Group
2011
Ø Most
highly
cited
cause
of
supply
chain
disrupOon
was
extreme
weather
events
-‐
51%
of
respondents
Ø A
third
said
disrupOon
caused
a
loss
in
revenue
and
17%
said
the
biggest
incident
cost
over
1
million
euros
Ø Only
8%
thought
their
supply
chain
had
strategies
to
deal
with
disrupOons
Ø Also
weather-‐related
peaks
in
consumer
demand
Ø Low
inventory
/
rapid
response
strategies
(“just-‐in
Ome”)
versus
high
inventory
cost-‐saving
strategies
10. InternaOonal
trade
A
valuable
adaptaOon
measure?
Liu
et
al.,
Global
Environmental
Change
2014
11. But
more
trade,
more
emissions?
Schmitz
et
al.,
Global
Environmental
Change
2012
deforesta7on
12. Problems
and
soluOons
are
highly
specific
home-‐cooked
meal
versus
ready
meal
Schmidt
Rivera
et
al
2014,
Journal
of
Cleaner
Prodn.
14. Developing
country
food
supply
chains
seen
as:
Ø Geographically
short
Ø Many
“middlemen”
–
long
in
terms
of
intermediaries
Ø Highly
fragmented
–
mainly
small
players
Ø Few
technological
advances
Ø Tied
credit
15. Reardon
et
al.
2012.
The
Quiet
RevoluOon
in
Staple
Food
Value
Chains.
ADB
and
IFPRI
The
modern
reality?
Example
of
staple
markets
in
China
&
India
–
but
other
countries
close
behind
Peri-‐urbanisa7on
Photo:
Mint
Cold
storage
Photo:
CFP
Retail
revolu7on
Photo:
Reuters
Fewer
market
players
LiOle
7ed
credit
A
“tresformed
middle”
18. Private
sector
sustainability:
from
operaOons
to
whole
supply
chains
• “A
new
green
wave”
(The
Economist,
August
2014)
• “How
strange
bedfellows
are
transforming
a
trillion-‐dollar
Industry”
(CLUA,
September
2014)
19. Research
programs:
with
honourable
excepOons,
agriculture
dominates
publicly
funded
research
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
crop
yield
access
to
food
Ingram,
Food
Security
2011
ASTI,
2012
20. Concluding
conundrum:
why
do
post-‐farmgate
acOviOes,
strategies
and
drivers
remain
so
under-‐researched?
• Difficult
to
study?
– Geographic
dispersion
and
many
food
chain
actors
– Corporate
privacy
– Inter-‐disciplinarity
• Power
of
“producOonist”
agendas?
– Food-‐insecure
countries
have
agricultural
economies
– Knee-‐jerk
simplicity
of
“need
more
food”
• Complex
relaOonships
between
environmental
change
and
food
system
outcomes
(e.g.
nutriOon)