SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
Download to read offline
Rong Huang is International Students Tutor at the University of Plymouth. Her research interests
focus on a number of aspects of the tourism phenomenon. In particular, she has published on rural
tourism, public-sector tourism and student travel. Specific research locations include Britain and
China.
Vol. 6, No. 1.
ISSN: 1473-8376
www.hlst.heacademy.ac.uk/johlste
ACADEMIC PAPER
‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Learning Experience!’
Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a
Dissertation in the UK
Rong Huang (rong.huang@plymouth.ac.uk)
Plymouth Business School, University of Plymouth, Cookworthy,
Drake Circus, Plymouth, Devon PL4 8AA
DOI:10.3794/johlste.61.130



 Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education
Abstract
Over the past decade international student enrolment at British higher education institutions has
grown significantly. The majority of international students that study for a British qualification
originate from Asia and especially from China. In Britain a dissertation is a significant form of
assessment in the postgraduate curriculum. This paper aims to explore the international students’
perspective of undertaking dissertations in tourism and hospitality management in the UK. Through
personal interviews with 40 international students from Asian countries from April to May 2005, the
experience of undertaking a dissertation was examined. Microanalysis was adopted to understand
their experience. Empirical results indicated that there were three main reasons for choosing a
research topic. For the students the positive experiences gained from writing their dissertations were
generated from learning useful information and peer support. Their negative experiences were related
to difficulties in meeting the demands of writing critically, the relationships with their supervisors
because of cultural barriers, and also access to data.
Keywords: Dissertation, Research Methods, International Students
Introduction
The provision of education and training services for people from overseas has become an increasingly
important source of income for certain countries, including the UK (Mazzarol, 1998; Mazzarol and
Soutar, 1999, 2002). The term ‘international’, ‘overseas’ and ‘foreign’ are used interchangeably in
literature to refer to students studying in another country. Okorocha (1997) observed that there is
some controversy about whether the appropriate term is ‘international’ or ‘foreign’. The argument
being that the word ‘foreign’ has a negative connotation and the word ‘international’ does not
(Okorocha, 1997). In American literature the term ‘international’ is often used, while in British
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 30
literature ‘overseas’ is used. The term ‘foreign’ appears mainly in literature from Australia and other
countries. However, for the purposes of this paper, the term ‘international’ is used to refer to students
from countries outside the United Kingdom, especially those coming from different cultural, language
and religious backgrounds, some of which are very different from the host culture. The implications
are that they see things differently from their hosts in many areas. Some of the issues they value very
highly may not be valued in this society and vice versa (Okorocha, 1997). They are people in
transition who have come to accomplish an education goal with a view to returning home (McLaren,
1998).
The majority of the international students that study for a British qualification originate from Asia and
especially from China. Britain’s popularity amongst Chinese students has grown since America
tightened visa regulations after the terrorist attacks in 2001. Britain has become the most popular
destination for Chinese students, ahead of America, the previous most favourite, and Germany, where
higher education is virtually free (Bird and Owen, 2004). British universities, facing deepening
financial difficulties, have seized on the economic potential of the Chinese market. However, it
should be noted that a sharp drop in total students from China (Kingston, 2005) sent a signal that the
students from this market are getting more discerning when they decide where to attend university.
At a British educational institution, a dissertation is a significant form of assessment in the curriculum
of a masters’ degree. In order to successfully complete a masters’ degree, many tourism and
hospitality programmes require research to be undertaken and then the submission of a dissertation.
However, many studies suggest that international students might have preferred a different learning
approach to the one used in their host country (Barron and Arcodia, 2002; Huang, 2005). Whilst there
are many texts on research methods and also guides to the design, development and writing of
dissertations (e.g. Fitzpatrick, et al, 1999; Mauch and Birch, 1998; Philips and Pugh, 2000), much less
attention has been given to the actual writing and structure of the dissertations. Although a focus on
postgraduate dissertations is evident in educational research (e.g. Kangis, 2001; Abel, 2002; Paltridge,
2002), there is a lack of voice from international students about their own experiences. Therefore, the
aim of this paper is to explore Asian international student perspectives on undertaking a dissertation
by drawing on qualitative research with postgraduate tourism and hospitality management students in
the UK. In order to achieve this research aim, two research objectives are established as follows:
1) To assess the motivations for topic choices by the Asian international students
2) To discuss the positive and negative experiences of Asian international students have in the
research process.
The Role of the Dissertation in the Masters’ Degree
The terms ‘dissertation’ and ‘project’ are used interchangeably within many educational institutions.
However, the author agrees with Clewes’ (1996) classification that ‘project’ refers to first-degree
research, ‘dissertation’ to masters’ degrees, and ‘thesis’ being reserved for higher research-only
degrees. In turn, the dissertation is defined as a substantial piece of work, of about 15,000 – 20,000
words, written with a view to proving or disproving something, and thus adding to, or creating new
knowledge.
Kangis and Carman (2002) identify that commonly encountered (written or unwritten) expectations of
dissertations are to:
1) add to knowledge by creating new ways of looking at what is around us;
2) test existing knowledge as it might apply to new situations;
3) familiarise a student with the literature in a given area of discourse;
4) provide a critical structuring of what is known with a view to addressing a problem;
5) help develop analytical skills; and
6) be an integrating piece of work, demonstrating that the student has competently addressed a
management problem.
Thus, a dissertation requires the candidate to demonstrate a mastery of the subject area being
researched, as well as a comprehensive understanding of the research methodology being used. It
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 31
encompasses both intellectual and skills development. For the vast majority of students, the
dissertation is by far the most challenging piece of academic work that they have attempted or are
ever likely to attempt in the future.
However, there is a strong trend for masters degrees to be based largely on coursework. According to
Remenyi, et al., (1998) the rationale for this is that coursework for a masters’ degree is intended to
prepare individuals to take a more specialist, or in some cases a more distinguished, role in their
profession. Therefore, masters’ degrees are sometimes referred to as mid-career development
degrees. Thus the research component, although still present, is relatively small when compared to
doctoral degrees, but it is still an important component of the curriculum.
The dissertation is a key feature of masters’ degrees in tourism and hospitality subjects in the UK. In
his recent evaluation of dissertation practice in hospitality, leisure, sport and tourism in the UK,
Buswell (2004) identifies that in the majority of courses (90%), the dissertation is a compulsory
element of the programme, a limited number of courses offer an alternative, and others are
considering further options such as a case study, or a project (eg. Enterprise-related). He noted that
all courses (except one) provide some form of research methods instruction prior to the dissertation
process, and only 10% of departments do not assess research methods modules.
As a significant component of the curriculum, assessment of student research has been studied and
evaluated by reflective Higher Education (HE) practitioners in the UK (Buswell, 2004; I’Anson and
Smith, 2004; Dutton et al., 2005). The focus on postgraduate dissertations is evident. Based on the
analysis of 100 dissertations from one British business school and on simulations with random
numbers, Kangis and Carman (2002) concluded that rigid adherence to the conventional scientific
model should be toned down, and that the potential benefits of several alternative models of research
and knowledge creation should be given greater prominence. Woolhouse (2002) explores the
relationship between a supervisor and a dissertation student, and identifies the similarities and
differences in their expectations. In terms of the similarities, supervisors and students agree that:
1) writing a dissertation will enhance knowledge of the topic;
2) students need to commit to their project;
3) students need to be alerted by supervisors about time scales of their projects; and
4) supervisors are advisors for the student projects.
The students noticed more similarities than differences, but in contrast their supervisors saw more
differences than similarities.
The Learning Experience of Asian Students in the UK
International students come to Britain with expectations that come from their past experience in their
own countries and, whether they realise it or not, they must learn to adapt to new circumstances in
order to succeed academically. This includes incorporating priorities formulated by the British
education system and often adapting to new ways of studying and preparing assignments (Lowes,
Peters and Turner, 2004). Problems arise for British academics when they are confronted with what
appear to be differences between the academic standards and expectations of the lecturer and those of
the Asian international students, and this may have an impact on the potential success of those
students. The ability to think critically is required to do well at university in Britain, but Asian
students are often criticised for their lack of critical thinking skills (Egege and Kutieleh, 2004).
Casanave and Hubbard (1992) found that such international students often have difficulty in meeting
the demands of the kind of writing required of them at masters’ degree level. This is especially the
case for students who come from a context where the conventions and expectations of academic
writing may be quite different to the situation they now find themselves in (Ballard and Clanchy,
1997).
One of the most common issues for international students (and also domestic students) is
unintentional plagiarism (CSHE, 2002). Many researchers note that in some educational settings
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 32
outside British higher education, the more closely a student can replicate the work or words of an
expert, the greater the student’s learning or mastery of the subject is considered to be. The students
are unaware that this is not the case in British higher education and that, in sharp contrast to their
previous experience, they may be penalised for such replication.
Aboutorabi (1997) argues that although the student-supervisor relationship should normally develop
into a co-operative working relationship, which could ideally include some personal friendship, the
relationship between international students and their supervisors could be ruined because of cultural
differences. As Dudley-Evans (1995, 1999) and Thompson (1999) argue, given the increasing
numbers of international students undertaking masters/research degrees in English, much more work
needs to be done to establish the particular characteristics of this group. While there is growing
literature exposing difficulties that Asian international students encountered while they were studying
in the UK, there is seldom research on the positive learning experience they had, especially from
writing dissertations.
Methodology
This research adopted a qualitative approach to investigate the experience of Asian international
students who were doing their dissertation in tourism and hospitality subjects. After detailed
secondary research, a three-part semi-structured questionnaire was developed for in-depth interviews.
The first part related to personal information such as their gender and country origin, the second to
their motivations for topic choices, and the third was concerned with their positive and negative
experiences of the process of writing a dissertation.
This research was not designed to present a statistical representation of all Asian international
students’ experience on writing dissertations. Rather, its emphasis was on the richness of information
being gathered and the meaningful comparisons possible. In this sense, the research worked on the
principle of theoretical sampling. Using this sampling strategy, new cases were consciously added to
extend data comparison. Working through the process, the researcher was theoretically sensitive to
new insights developed. New research participants were invited after the preceding interviews were
recorded and analysed. In doing so, the information gaps between the previous and successive
interviews were filled. The research did not stop sampling until no new information emerged from
the latest interview. In total, the researcher interviewed 40 international students from three different
countries about their experience. In-depth interviews were carried out in April and May 2005.
In terms of data analysis, this overlapped with data collection to build a coherent interpretation of the
data. Using a manual process, the researcher made interview transcriptions immediately after each
interview and conducted analysis simultaneously. The analytic procedure referred to Strauss and
Corbin’s microanalysis (1998). This is a line-by-line analysis that is used to generate initial
categories and to discover relationships among concepts (Strauss and Corbin, 1998). The rigour of
the analytical procedure depends on its adequacy and transparency.
Analysis went further than microanalysis, comparisons between categories were also conducted. At
this stage, the relationship between categories was judged at the level of internal convergence and
external divergence (Patton, 2002). Comparisons were made not only within the individual cases but
also cross the individual cases. Concepts discovered from every previous interview were aggregated
immediately. As the insights emerged, they were compared in successive interviews. In this sense,
theoretical sampling was also directed by the data analysis so as to “extend, test, and fill in
information” (Lincoln and Guba, 1985: 201). By doing so, patterns of data were found. At that point,
provisional frameworks were produced. Thus, the analytical process moved from an inductive
approach towards “a more deductive approach to data collection and analysis” (Patton, 2002: 67),
which focused on verification and interpretation (Lincoln and Guba, 1985; Strauss and Corbin, 1998).
On the one hand, the researcher compared similarities and differences among categories within the
empirical study. On the other, she compared the emerged categories with previous literature that, to a
certain extent, provided a set of guiding hypotheses to this research. Constructed in this way, the
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 33
results of this research were built. The completion of this signalled the final stage of the analytic
process.
Findings
Profiles of the interviewees
All of the 40 interviewees were full-time students taking their masters degree in tourism and
hospitality related subjects. In terms of their country origin, 25 of them were from China (19 from
Mainland China, 4 from Hong Kong and 2 from Taiwan), 6 were from Malaysia, and 9 were from
India. In terms of gender, there were 25 female students and 15 male students.
Motivations for topic choices
From the interviews, it was very clear that there were three main motivations for the students in their
choice of research topic and these are now discussed below.
Link to career development
This was the most common motivation for choosing the topic. Most of the interviewees used the
dissertation to understand deeply and thoroughly a topic related to their jobs or possible job prospects.
The following quotations from the interviewees illustrate this motivation:
“I worked in a big travel agency in China. I intend to go back to work there. Doing a project
on travel agencies in China would benefit me later.”
“I have always wanted to work in the hotel industry in Beijing, especially during 2008 Beijing
Olympic Games. Nowadays there are many international hotel chains in Beijing. I thought
that doing a dissertation related to international hotel issues in China would afterwards help
me to get a job in Beijing.”
These concur with Clewes’ research (1996), which identified that skills development and the practical
value of the project in terms of improving job prospects were important.
Personal interest in the subject area
A personal desire to learn about a specific area in their research was the second most important
motivation for the interviewees. This was illustrated by statements from two interviewees:
“I came from the very northern part of China. I like skiing. I really want to go skiing in
Europe. So I did my project about a ski resort in Switzerland. Although it was very difficult
for me to find information, I enjoyed finding the information I had for this resort. I have
planned to go there this winter.”
“It was definitely because of my personal interest! I am a tour guide in Malaysia. I enjoy
traveling. I have never been to Africa. But Africa is so mysterious for me. So I did my
project on tourism development in Egypt.”
The concept that personal interest is a motive for choosing a research topic has been supported by
many researchers (e.g. I’Anson and Smith, 2004; Cadman, 1997).
Perceived ease of access to secondary and primary data
The interviewees also reported that perceived ease of access to sources of data is an important factor
in decision-making and topic choice. They reported an ease of access to primary data through
established contacts with individuals or organisations, either through their current or previous jobs, or
through their family connections. For example:
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 34
“Although I was keen to write something related to travel behaviour of disabled people in
China, I just could not find many data. So I changed my attention to Chinese outbound travel
since I found a lot of articles in English journals.”
“I am an international student in the UK. I have met a lot of international students here. So
when I thought about my dissertation, I decided to write something relating to international
students. This was because of my own experiences and also my network of other
international students here. From a practical point of view, it would be easy to do my survey
and interviews.”
The positive experiences of writing a dissertation
Although writing a dissertation in their non-native language was very hard, many students reported
gaining benefits from their writing up of the dissertation, which an interviewee summarised as “a
challenging but worthwhile learning experience for me”. The students who gave positive experience
statements agreed that writing a long piece of work in English was very beneficial to them. The
following statements illustrate this:
“It’s the first time that I have written such a long piece of work in English. I developed my
writing skills and also I gained some confidence in my language skills.”
“I learned a lot about skiing destinations in Europe. I enjoyed reading articles about the
destination I researched. I really look forward to going there now.”
“Although before studying here I’d wanted to work in the Shanghai conference industry, I had
no real ideas about it. After writing my dissertation, I not only had some knowledge of
conference planning, but I also obtained some first-hand information about its operational
situations.”
The above findings appear to support l’Anson and Smith’s view (2004) that positive experience of
writing a dissertation tended to be reported when research was relatively unproblematic, or if it was a
particularly relevant and interesting research topic. These findings also seem to support Woodhouse’s
(2002) observation that writing a dissertation will enhance knowledge of the topic that the students
research. Several students also reported that during the writing of their dissertation, support from
their classmates was a very positive benefit for them:
“After meeting my supervisors, I had often been very depressed. Then my classmates would
encourage me to carry on. To be honest, without my classmates, I really could not have
finished writing my dissertation.’
“Because we were in the same situation, we understood each other. When I had some
questions about my literature review or methodology, they often tried their best to help me to
solve them.”
“I have limited language skills. I was overjoyed when I knew that I had passed all the
modules. Writing my dissertation was a very big challenge to my level of English. My
classmate helped me a lot by making sure that my sentences were flowing.”
These findings seem to agree with Olsen’s (1998) opinion that peer support was one of the important
factors influencing students’ positive experience in writing dissertations.
The negative experiences of writing a dissertation
Although the interviewees all reported they had a great sense of achievement after finishing writing
their dissertation, they also all told me of their negative experiences. The three most common
negative experiences are summarised below:
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 35
Critical approach/analytical writing
According to Madsen’s (1983) criteria for thesis assessment (which are still widely recognised by the
English language social science academia), writing in this discipline should comprise: a convincing
account, an ordered, critical and reasoned exposition, the testing of ideas, competence in independent
experimentation, ability to make critical use of published work and source materials and originality.
Many interviewees were confused and depressed about their critical analytical skills because of a lack
of knowledge in this area. For example:
“I have been told by my supervisor that my work lacks critical analysis. I really don’t know
what critical analysis means.”
“By beginning the writing of my dissertation without a clear understanding of the critical
approach, I really suffered when I read the feedback from my supervisor with regards to my
literature review. I thought I did a good job, but my supervisor asked me where was my
opinion.”
The above two statements clearly reflected that their lack of experience and clear guidelines from
their lecturers on how to think and write critically made it difficult for the Asian students to know
what the requirement entails in practice. These findings seem to agree with Cadman’s (1997) finding
that international students found it very difficult to write critically. Paltridge (1997) also commented
that students with English as their second language often have difficulty in meeting the demands of
the kind of writing required of them at a critical level.
Other students complained that different suggestions about critical thinking they received from their
lecturers confused them.
“I have been given examples on how to write critically. It seems that I need to criticise
published work from my academic journals. But how dare I be critical? The authors in those
journals were professors or lecturers!”
“Different lecturers tell me different things when I ask them what critical thinking really
means. These really confuse me when I write my dissertation.”
The above finding reflected that Mingers’ conclusion (2000) that the concept of critical thinking is
vague and different educators have different views on this matter.
The relationship with supervisors
All the interviewees reported that there were many cultural barriers to them having an effective
relationship with their supervisors. As a result of cultural differences, they had incorrect expectations
of, or misunderstandings with, their supervisors. The interviewees said:
“I don’t know what help my supervisor is supposed to give me. But it is not my place to ask
him about it. I just did what he told me to do.”
“In my culture, we will not question what our professors say. So in our meeting, I never gave
any real answers to my supervisor. Most of time, I just said ‘yes’.”
“My supervisor misinterpreted my draft. I didn’t know whether I should explain it to her.
What she said was not what I wanted to do, but she is a professor and I am just a student. So I
completely changed my draft to satisfy her comments.”
These findings appear to support Aboutorabi’s (1995) research, which showed that because of cultural
barriers, international students found it very difficult to develop a proper relationship with their
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 36
supervisors. The interviewees also admitted that insufficient language skills were also a barrier to
proper communication with their supervisors.
Access to research samples
The interviewees identified difficulties in data collection due to uncooperative respondents. Some
interviewees complained that because student research was not highly rated in their own countries,
their requests for information from officials in tourism departments, hotel managers in a hotel chain
etc, had often been refused. For example:
“For my research I tried to find out about the kinds of preparations that international hotels in
Beijing had been doing for the Olympic Games. Therefore I had planned to interview hotel
managers from different international hotels in Beijing. After one month of telephone contact
with them, there was only one hotel that accepted my request. I was very disappointed.”
Some interviewees rebuked themselves because they had a low level of understanding about data
collection methods. Also, because they lacked sufficient time management skills they could not get
enough data for their research.
Conclusions and Recommendations
Although this was a small-scale project, this research does provide international student perspectives
on the writing of dissertations, as a counterbalance to the current dominance of the academic’s
perspective and the focus on students originating from within their own country. This paper
identified that there were three main reasons for the international students choosing a particular topic:
a link to career development, personal interest in the subject area, and perceived ease of access to
primary and secondary data. For international students, the positive experiences gained from writing
their dissertations were those generated by learning useful information and also peer support. Their
negative experiences related to difficulties in meeting the demands of writing critically, relationships
with their supervisors and access to and collection of data. It should be noted that the relationships
with their supervisors were perceived negatively not because of academic understanding, but because
of cultural barriers and lack of English language skills.
The findings from this research have implications for research training given to students and also to
lecturers, in terms of pedagogy. As writing a dissertation is a new experience for international
students, they need to have tutorials on how to prepare a dissertation and how to deal with their
supervisors.
As the students have highlighted, cultural differences influence their learning experience and some
cultural influences on learning, such as referencing, and social practices, such as relationships
between teachers and students, could be discussed by both the students and the lecturers in order to
avoid misunderstandings between them. The ground rules about their respective roles and
expectations could be set out at the beginning of their study. This would help in encouraging the
students to express their personal views about their research material, using both oral and written
methods.
During the early stages of topic selection, the challenges of accessing and collecting data should be
emphasised. This will help highlight the important implications of their decisions on research topic
and also avoid disappointment during data collection. The research results appear to suggest that a
short training session on critical thinking skills would also be beneficial to the international students,
as most of them have no clear idea on what critical thinking is, and how to be critical of the literature
they read and also of their own work. For lecturers, it would be very helpful if they could develop a
model for critically analysing a subject, or give examples to the students of how to do a critical
analysis.
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 37
References
Abel, C. F (2002) Academic success and the international student: research and recommendations,
New Directions for Higher Education, 117, 13-20.
Aboutorabi, M (1995) International research students: problems and expectations, The Journal of
International Education, 6(3), 55-62.
August, O (2004) Why Britain is best for the privileged of Beijing, The Times, Tuesday, February 17
2004, 12-13.
Ballard, B and Clanchy, J (1997) Teaching International Students: a brief guide for lecturers and
supervisors. Deakin, ACT: Education Australia.
Barron, P and Arcodia, C (2002) Linking learning style preferences and ethnicity; international
students studying Hospitality and tourism management in Australia, Journal of Hospitality,
Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education, 1(2), 15-27.
Bird, S and Owen, G. (2004) Class divides Chinese who profit in Britain. The Times, Friday, February
13, 12.
Cadman, K (1997) Thesis writing for international students: a question of identity? English for
Specific Purposes, 16(1), 3-14.
Casanave, C. P and Hubbard, P (1992) The writing assignments and writing problems of doctoral
students: faculty perceptions, pedagogical issues and needed research, English for Specific
Purposes, 11(1), 33-49.
Clewes, D (1996) Multiple perspectives on the undergraduate project experience, Innovations - the
learning and teaching Journal of Nottingham Trent University, 27-35.
CHSE (2002) A new era in assessing student learning. [online]. Melbourne, The University of
Melbourne. Available from: http://www.cshe.unimelb.edu.au/assessinglearning/01/index.html
[Accessed 10 October 2005].
Dudley-Evans, A (1995) Genre models for the teaching of academic writing to second language
speakers: advantages and disadvantages, The Journal of TESOL France, 2(2), 181-192.
Dudley-Evans, A (1999) The dissertation: a case of neglect? In: P. Thompson, Issues in EAP writing
research and instruction, 28-36. Reading: Centre for Applied Language Studies, University of
Reading.
Fitzpatrick, J., Secrist, J. and Wright, D. J (1999) Secrets for a Successful Dissertation. London:
SAGE Publications.
Huang, R (2005) The experience of Mainland Chinese international students in the UK – a tourism
perspective. Unpublished thesis (PhD). University of Derby.
I’Anson, R.A and Smith, K.A (2004) Undergraduate research projects and dissertations: issues of
topic selection, access and data collections amongst tourism management students, Journal of
Hospitality, Leisure, Sport an Tourism Education, 3(1), 19-32.
Egege, S & Kutieleh, S (2004) Critical thinking: teaching foreign notions to foreign students,
International Education Journal, 4(4), 75-85.
Kangis, P and Carman, R (2002) Research, knowledge and method: the purpose and role of MBA
dissertation, The International Journal of Management Education, 1(2), 8-16.
Kingston, P (2005) Chinese whispers. Guardian, 11 January.
Lincoln, Y. S and Guba, E. G (1985) Naturalistic Inquiry. London: SAGE Publications.
Lowes, R; Peters, H and Turner, M (2004) The international student’s guide studying in English at
University. London: SAGE Publishing Ltd.
Madsen, D. (1983) Successful dissertation and theses: a guide to graduation student research from
proposal to completion. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Mauch, J.E and Birch, J. W (1998) Guide to the Successful Thesis and Dissertation, New York:
Marcel Dekker, Inc.
Mazzarol, T (1998) Critical success factors for international education marketing, International
Journal of Educational Management, 12(4), 163-175.
Mazzarol, T and Soutar, G. N (1999) Sustainable competitive advantage for educational institutions: a
suggested model, The International Journal of Educational Management, 13(6), 287-300.
Mazzarol, T and Soutar, G. N (2002) ‘Push-pull’ factors influencing international student destination
choice, The International Journal of Educational Management, 16(2), 82-90.
Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student
Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK
Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 38
Mingers, J (2000) What is it to be critical? Teaching a critical approach to management
undergraduates, Management Learning, 31(2), 219-237.
Olsen, L (1998) Teaching and researching the thesis/dissertation in ESP, Colloquium introduction,
TESOL’98, Seattle.
Paltridge, B (1997) Thesis and dissertation writing: preparing ESL students for research, English for
Specific Purposes, 16(1), 61-70.
Paltridge, B (2002) Thesis and dissertation writing: an examination of published advice and actual
practice, English for Specific Purposes, 21, 125-143.
Patton, M. Q (2002) Qualitative Research & Evaluation Methods, 3rd
ed. London: SAGE
Publications.
Phillips, E. M and Pugh, D. S (2000) How to get a PhD: a handbook for students and their
supervisors, 3rd
edition. Buckingham: Open University Press.
Remenyi, D; Williams, B; Money, A and Swartz, E (1998) Doing Research in Business and
Management: an introduction to process and method, London: SAGE Publications.
Strauss, A and Corbin, J (1998) Basics of Qualitative Research: techniques and procedures for
developing grounded theory, 2nd
ed. London: SAGE Publications.
Thompson, P (1999) Exploring the contexts of writing: interviews with PhD supervisors. In: P.
Thompson, Issues in EAP writing research and instruction, 37-54. Reading: Centre for Applied
Language Studies, University of Reading.

More Related Content

Similar to A Challenging But Worthwhile Learning Experience - Asian International Students Perspective Of Undertaking A Dissertation In The UK

ArticleConceptualizing internationaleducation From inte.docx
ArticleConceptualizing internationaleducation From inte.docxArticleConceptualizing internationaleducation From inte.docx
ArticleConceptualizing internationaleducation From inte.docx
davezstarr61655
 
Reed T. Curtis Research Proposal for Stockholm University
Reed T. Curtis Research Proposal for Stockholm UniversityReed T. Curtis Research Proposal for Stockholm University
Reed T. Curtis Research Proposal for Stockholm University
Reed T. Curtis, M.Ed.
 
Lou_Thesis_Final_Manuscript
Lou_Thesis_Final_ManuscriptLou_Thesis_Final_Manuscript
Lou_Thesis_Final_Manuscript
Louis DiFante
 
Journal of research in international education 2013-phakiti-239-58
Journal of research in international education 2013-phakiti-239-58Journal of research in international education 2013-phakiti-239-58
Journal of research in international education 2013-phakiti-239-58
abnaking
 
Fostering Positive Cross-Cultural Student Experiences in Transnational Educat...
Fostering Positive Cross-Cultural Student Experiences in Transnational Educat...Fostering Positive Cross-Cultural Student Experiences in Transnational Educat...
Fostering Positive Cross-Cultural Student Experiences in Transnational Educat...
Hannah Wilkinson
 
African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Vol. 4 (2).docx
African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Vol. 4 (2).docxAfrican Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Vol. 4 (2).docx
African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Vol. 4 (2).docx
coubroughcosta
 
Entomology_Portfolio_Project
Entomology_Portfolio_Project Entomology_Portfolio_Project
Entomology_Portfolio_Project
Dustin Stockmann
 
Olson & Kohntopp Diversity in Ed
Olson & Kohntopp Diversity in EdOlson & Kohntopp Diversity in Ed
Olson & Kohntopp Diversity in Ed
Tom Kohntopp
 
Proposal Meeting
Proposal MeetingProposal Meeting
Proposal Meeting
york1896
 

Similar to A Challenging But Worthwhile Learning Experience - Asian International Students Perspective Of Undertaking A Dissertation In The UK (20)

EDI23-Diversifying-Doctoral-Education-Enhancing-Equity-Diversity-and-Inclusio...
EDI23-Diversifying-Doctoral-Education-Enhancing-Equity-Diversity-and-Inclusio...EDI23-Diversifying-Doctoral-Education-Enhancing-Equity-Diversity-and-Inclusio...
EDI23-Diversifying-Doctoral-Education-Enhancing-Equity-Diversity-and-Inclusio...
 
Sakurai, et al., competing meanings of international experiences for research...
Sakurai, et al., competing meanings of international experiences for research...Sakurai, et al., competing meanings of international experiences for research...
Sakurai, et al., competing meanings of international experiences for research...
 
ArticleConceptualizing internationaleducation From inte.docx
ArticleConceptualizing internationaleducation From inte.docxArticleConceptualizing internationaleducation From inte.docx
ArticleConceptualizing internationaleducation From inte.docx
 
Reed T. Curtis Research Proposal for Stockholm University
Reed T. Curtis Research Proposal for Stockholm UniversityReed T. Curtis Research Proposal for Stockholm University
Reed T. Curtis Research Proposal for Stockholm University
 
Lou thesis final_manuscript
Lou thesis final_manuscriptLou thesis final_manuscript
Lou thesis final_manuscript
 
Lou_Thesis_Final_Manuscript
Lou_Thesis_Final_ManuscriptLou_Thesis_Final_Manuscript
Lou_Thesis_Final_Manuscript
 
International students support
International students supportInternational students support
International students support
 
Journal of research in international education 2013-phakiti-239-58
Journal of research in international education 2013-phakiti-239-58Journal of research in international education 2013-phakiti-239-58
Journal of research in international education 2013-phakiti-239-58
 
English Language Proficiency and Academic Achievement of Internat.pdf
English Language Proficiency and Academic Achievement of Internat.pdfEnglish Language Proficiency and Academic Achievement of Internat.pdf
English Language Proficiency and Academic Achievement of Internat.pdf
 
An Empirical Research Project In English And Writing Studies
An Empirical Research Project In English And Writing StudiesAn Empirical Research Project In English And Writing Studies
An Empirical Research Project In English And Writing Studies
 
Fostering Positive Cross-Cultural Student Experiences in Transnational Educat...
Fostering Positive Cross-Cultural Student Experiences in Transnational Educat...Fostering Positive Cross-Cultural Student Experiences in Transnational Educat...
Fostering Positive Cross-Cultural Student Experiences in Transnational Educat...
 
• Widening participation and postgraduate research - Nigel Vincent, The Briti...
•	Widening participation and postgraduate research - Nigel Vincent, The Briti...•	Widening participation and postgraduate research - Nigel Vincent, The Briti...
• Widening participation and postgraduate research - Nigel Vincent, The Briti...
 
African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Vol. 4 (2).docx
African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Vol. 4 (2).docxAfrican Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Vol. 4 (2).docx
African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Vol. 4 (2).docx
 
Entomology_Portfolio_Project
Entomology_Portfolio_Project Entomology_Portfolio_Project
Entomology_Portfolio_Project
 
Lucky last chance: A study skills pilot program created for ‘excluded’ ESL/EF...
Lucky last chance: A study skills pilot program created for ‘excluded’ ESL/EF...Lucky last chance: A study skills pilot program created for ‘excluded’ ESL/EF...
Lucky last chance: A study skills pilot program created for ‘excluded’ ESL/EF...
 
An Exploration Of Taught Master S Student Perceptions Of UK Dissertation Supe...
An Exploration Of Taught Master S Student Perceptions Of UK Dissertation Supe...An Exploration Of Taught Master S Student Perceptions Of UK Dissertation Supe...
An Exploration Of Taught Master S Student Perceptions Of UK Dissertation Supe...
 
CV, September 2015
CV, September 2015CV, September 2015
CV, September 2015
 
Olson & Kohntopp Diversity in Ed
Olson & Kohntopp Diversity in EdOlson & Kohntopp Diversity in Ed
Olson & Kohntopp Diversity in Ed
 
Proposal Meeting
Proposal MeetingProposal Meeting
Proposal Meeting
 
Proposal Meeting
Proposal MeetingProposal Meeting
Proposal Meeting
 

More from Sarah Brown

More from Sarah Brown (20)

Sample Hypothesis For Th
Sample Hypothesis For ThSample Hypothesis For Th
Sample Hypothesis For Th
 
How To Write A Conclusion Ful
How To Write A Conclusion FulHow To Write A Conclusion Ful
How To Write A Conclusion Ful
 
Observing Ourselves Essays In Social Research
Observing Ourselves Essays In Social ResearchObserving Ourselves Essays In Social Research
Observing Ourselves Essays In Social Research
 
Narrative Essay. Narrative Essay Examples Parts. 2
Narrative Essay. Narrative Essay Examples Parts. 2Narrative Essay. Narrative Essay Examples Parts. 2
Narrative Essay. Narrative Essay Examples Parts. 2
 
Sample Of Research Proposals. 56 Proposal E
Sample Of Research Proposals. 56 Proposal ESample Of Research Proposals. 56 Proposal E
Sample Of Research Proposals. 56 Proposal E
 
College Essay Double Spaced - Buy College Application Es
College Essay Double Spaced - Buy College Application EsCollege Essay Double Spaced - Buy College Application Es
College Essay Double Spaced - Buy College Application Es
 
Essay On Global Warming- Leverage Edu
Essay On Global Warming- Leverage EduEssay On Global Warming- Leverage Edu
Essay On Global Warming- Leverage Edu
 
How To Write A Philosophy Argument Paper. How To W
How To Write A Philosophy Argument Paper. How To WHow To Write A Philosophy Argument Paper. How To W
How To Write A Philosophy Argument Paper. How To W
 
Research Paper Graphic Organizer Essay Writing,
Research Paper Graphic Organizer Essay Writing,Research Paper Graphic Organizer Essay Writing,
Research Paper Graphic Organizer Essay Writing,
 
College Level Research Paper. 1 College Researc
College Level Research Paper. 1 College ResearcCollege Level Research Paper. 1 College Researc
College Level Research Paper. 1 College Researc
 
Sample Divorce Papers - Free Printable Documents
Sample Divorce Papers - Free Printable DocumentsSample Divorce Papers - Free Printable Documents
Sample Divorce Papers - Free Printable Documents
 
Bad College Essays Mistakes You Must Avoid College Essay, Essay
Bad College Essays Mistakes You Must Avoid College Essay, EssayBad College Essays Mistakes You Must Avoid College Essay, Essay
Bad College Essays Mistakes You Must Avoid College Essay, Essay
 
How To Write A Persuasive Essay (With Free Sample Essay)
How To Write A Persuasive Essay (With Free Sample Essay)How To Write A Persuasive Essay (With Free Sample Essay)
How To Write A Persuasive Essay (With Free Sample Essay)
 
Things Money CanT Buy Pictures, Photos, And Images For Facebo
Things Money CanT Buy Pictures, Photos, And Images For FaceboThings Money CanT Buy Pictures, Photos, And Images For Facebo
Things Money CanT Buy Pictures, Photos, And Images For Facebo
 
Elements Of Writing Online Essay Writer, Essay Writing, Essay
Elements Of Writing Online Essay Writer, Essay Writing, EssayElements Of Writing Online Essay Writer, Essay Writing, Essay
Elements Of Writing Online Essay Writer, Essay Writing, Essay
 
How To Write A Literature Review In 5 Simple Steps - Peachy Essay
How To Write A Literature Review In 5 Simple Steps - Peachy EssayHow To Write A Literature Review In 5 Simple Steps - Peachy Essay
How To Write A Literature Review In 5 Simple Steps - Peachy Essay
 
How To Write Paper In Board Exam 9Th And 10Th Class English Paper
How To Write Paper In Board Exam 9Th And 10Th Class English PaperHow To Write Paper In Board Exam 9Th And 10Th Class English Paper
How To Write Paper In Board Exam 9Th And 10Th Class English Paper
 
Great Writing 5 Aswer Key - Great Writing 5 From Gre
Great Writing 5 Aswer Key - Great Writing 5 From GreGreat Writing 5 Aswer Key - Great Writing 5 From Gre
Great Writing 5 Aswer Key - Great Writing 5 From Gre
 
This Pig Theme Paper Has 2 Different Designs. Each Des
This Pig Theme Paper Has 2 Different Designs. Each DesThis Pig Theme Paper Has 2 Different Designs. Each Des
This Pig Theme Paper Has 2 Different Designs. Each Des
 
What Is A Research Hypothesis And How To Write A Hypothesis
What Is A Research Hypothesis And How To Write A HypothesisWhat Is A Research Hypothesis And How To Write A Hypothesis
What Is A Research Hypothesis And How To Write A Hypothesis
 

Recently uploaded

BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
SoniaTolstoy
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
ciinovamais
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
kauryashika82
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
 
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfKey note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
 
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communicationInteractive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
 
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdfWeb & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
 
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptxINDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
 
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpinStudent login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
 
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
 
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and ModeMeasures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
 
social pharmacy d-pharm 1st year by Pragati K. Mahajan
social pharmacy d-pharm 1st year by Pragati K. Mahajansocial pharmacy d-pharm 1st year by Pragati K. Mahajan
social pharmacy d-pharm 1st year by Pragati K. Mahajan
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
 
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptxUnit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
 
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
 

A Challenging But Worthwhile Learning Experience - Asian International Students Perspective Of Undertaking A Dissertation In The UK

  • 1. Rong Huang is International Students Tutor at the University of Plymouth. Her research interests focus on a number of aspects of the tourism phenomenon. In particular, she has published on rural tourism, public-sector tourism and student travel. Specific research locations include Britain and China. Vol. 6, No. 1. ISSN: 1473-8376 www.hlst.heacademy.ac.uk/johlste ACADEMIC PAPER ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Learning Experience!’ Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Rong Huang (rong.huang@plymouth.ac.uk) Plymouth Business School, University of Plymouth, Cookworthy, Drake Circus, Plymouth, Devon PL4 8AA DOI:10.3794/johlste.61.130     Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education Abstract Over the past decade international student enrolment at British higher education institutions has grown significantly. The majority of international students that study for a British qualification originate from Asia and especially from China. In Britain a dissertation is a significant form of assessment in the postgraduate curriculum. This paper aims to explore the international students’ perspective of undertaking dissertations in tourism and hospitality management in the UK. Through personal interviews with 40 international students from Asian countries from April to May 2005, the experience of undertaking a dissertation was examined. Microanalysis was adopted to understand their experience. Empirical results indicated that there were three main reasons for choosing a research topic. For the students the positive experiences gained from writing their dissertations were generated from learning useful information and peer support. Their negative experiences were related to difficulties in meeting the demands of writing critically, the relationships with their supervisors because of cultural barriers, and also access to data. Keywords: Dissertation, Research Methods, International Students Introduction The provision of education and training services for people from overseas has become an increasingly important source of income for certain countries, including the UK (Mazzarol, 1998; Mazzarol and Soutar, 1999, 2002). The term ‘international’, ‘overseas’ and ‘foreign’ are used interchangeably in literature to refer to students studying in another country. Okorocha (1997) observed that there is some controversy about whether the appropriate term is ‘international’ or ‘foreign’. The argument being that the word ‘foreign’ has a negative connotation and the word ‘international’ does not (Okorocha, 1997). In American literature the term ‘international’ is often used, while in British
  • 2. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 30 literature ‘overseas’ is used. The term ‘foreign’ appears mainly in literature from Australia and other countries. However, for the purposes of this paper, the term ‘international’ is used to refer to students from countries outside the United Kingdom, especially those coming from different cultural, language and religious backgrounds, some of which are very different from the host culture. The implications are that they see things differently from their hosts in many areas. Some of the issues they value very highly may not be valued in this society and vice versa (Okorocha, 1997). They are people in transition who have come to accomplish an education goal with a view to returning home (McLaren, 1998). The majority of the international students that study for a British qualification originate from Asia and especially from China. Britain’s popularity amongst Chinese students has grown since America tightened visa regulations after the terrorist attacks in 2001. Britain has become the most popular destination for Chinese students, ahead of America, the previous most favourite, and Germany, where higher education is virtually free (Bird and Owen, 2004). British universities, facing deepening financial difficulties, have seized on the economic potential of the Chinese market. However, it should be noted that a sharp drop in total students from China (Kingston, 2005) sent a signal that the students from this market are getting more discerning when they decide where to attend university. At a British educational institution, a dissertation is a significant form of assessment in the curriculum of a masters’ degree. In order to successfully complete a masters’ degree, many tourism and hospitality programmes require research to be undertaken and then the submission of a dissertation. However, many studies suggest that international students might have preferred a different learning approach to the one used in their host country (Barron and Arcodia, 2002; Huang, 2005). Whilst there are many texts on research methods and also guides to the design, development and writing of dissertations (e.g. Fitzpatrick, et al, 1999; Mauch and Birch, 1998; Philips and Pugh, 2000), much less attention has been given to the actual writing and structure of the dissertations. Although a focus on postgraduate dissertations is evident in educational research (e.g. Kangis, 2001; Abel, 2002; Paltridge, 2002), there is a lack of voice from international students about their own experiences. Therefore, the aim of this paper is to explore Asian international student perspectives on undertaking a dissertation by drawing on qualitative research with postgraduate tourism and hospitality management students in the UK. In order to achieve this research aim, two research objectives are established as follows: 1) To assess the motivations for topic choices by the Asian international students 2) To discuss the positive and negative experiences of Asian international students have in the research process. The Role of the Dissertation in the Masters’ Degree The terms ‘dissertation’ and ‘project’ are used interchangeably within many educational institutions. However, the author agrees with Clewes’ (1996) classification that ‘project’ refers to first-degree research, ‘dissertation’ to masters’ degrees, and ‘thesis’ being reserved for higher research-only degrees. In turn, the dissertation is defined as a substantial piece of work, of about 15,000 – 20,000 words, written with a view to proving or disproving something, and thus adding to, or creating new knowledge. Kangis and Carman (2002) identify that commonly encountered (written or unwritten) expectations of dissertations are to: 1) add to knowledge by creating new ways of looking at what is around us; 2) test existing knowledge as it might apply to new situations; 3) familiarise a student with the literature in a given area of discourse; 4) provide a critical structuring of what is known with a view to addressing a problem; 5) help develop analytical skills; and 6) be an integrating piece of work, demonstrating that the student has competently addressed a management problem. Thus, a dissertation requires the candidate to demonstrate a mastery of the subject area being researched, as well as a comprehensive understanding of the research methodology being used. It
  • 3. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 31 encompasses both intellectual and skills development. For the vast majority of students, the dissertation is by far the most challenging piece of academic work that they have attempted or are ever likely to attempt in the future. However, there is a strong trend for masters degrees to be based largely on coursework. According to Remenyi, et al., (1998) the rationale for this is that coursework for a masters’ degree is intended to prepare individuals to take a more specialist, or in some cases a more distinguished, role in their profession. Therefore, masters’ degrees are sometimes referred to as mid-career development degrees. Thus the research component, although still present, is relatively small when compared to doctoral degrees, but it is still an important component of the curriculum. The dissertation is a key feature of masters’ degrees in tourism and hospitality subjects in the UK. In his recent evaluation of dissertation practice in hospitality, leisure, sport and tourism in the UK, Buswell (2004) identifies that in the majority of courses (90%), the dissertation is a compulsory element of the programme, a limited number of courses offer an alternative, and others are considering further options such as a case study, or a project (eg. Enterprise-related). He noted that all courses (except one) provide some form of research methods instruction prior to the dissertation process, and only 10% of departments do not assess research methods modules. As a significant component of the curriculum, assessment of student research has been studied and evaluated by reflective Higher Education (HE) practitioners in the UK (Buswell, 2004; I’Anson and Smith, 2004; Dutton et al., 2005). The focus on postgraduate dissertations is evident. Based on the analysis of 100 dissertations from one British business school and on simulations with random numbers, Kangis and Carman (2002) concluded that rigid adherence to the conventional scientific model should be toned down, and that the potential benefits of several alternative models of research and knowledge creation should be given greater prominence. Woolhouse (2002) explores the relationship between a supervisor and a dissertation student, and identifies the similarities and differences in their expectations. In terms of the similarities, supervisors and students agree that: 1) writing a dissertation will enhance knowledge of the topic; 2) students need to commit to their project; 3) students need to be alerted by supervisors about time scales of their projects; and 4) supervisors are advisors for the student projects. The students noticed more similarities than differences, but in contrast their supervisors saw more differences than similarities. The Learning Experience of Asian Students in the UK International students come to Britain with expectations that come from their past experience in their own countries and, whether they realise it or not, they must learn to adapt to new circumstances in order to succeed academically. This includes incorporating priorities formulated by the British education system and often adapting to new ways of studying and preparing assignments (Lowes, Peters and Turner, 2004). Problems arise for British academics when they are confronted with what appear to be differences between the academic standards and expectations of the lecturer and those of the Asian international students, and this may have an impact on the potential success of those students. The ability to think critically is required to do well at university in Britain, but Asian students are often criticised for their lack of critical thinking skills (Egege and Kutieleh, 2004). Casanave and Hubbard (1992) found that such international students often have difficulty in meeting the demands of the kind of writing required of them at masters’ degree level. This is especially the case for students who come from a context where the conventions and expectations of academic writing may be quite different to the situation they now find themselves in (Ballard and Clanchy, 1997). One of the most common issues for international students (and also domestic students) is unintentional plagiarism (CSHE, 2002). Many researchers note that in some educational settings
  • 4. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 32 outside British higher education, the more closely a student can replicate the work or words of an expert, the greater the student’s learning or mastery of the subject is considered to be. The students are unaware that this is not the case in British higher education and that, in sharp contrast to their previous experience, they may be penalised for such replication. Aboutorabi (1997) argues that although the student-supervisor relationship should normally develop into a co-operative working relationship, which could ideally include some personal friendship, the relationship between international students and their supervisors could be ruined because of cultural differences. As Dudley-Evans (1995, 1999) and Thompson (1999) argue, given the increasing numbers of international students undertaking masters/research degrees in English, much more work needs to be done to establish the particular characteristics of this group. While there is growing literature exposing difficulties that Asian international students encountered while they were studying in the UK, there is seldom research on the positive learning experience they had, especially from writing dissertations. Methodology This research adopted a qualitative approach to investigate the experience of Asian international students who were doing their dissertation in tourism and hospitality subjects. After detailed secondary research, a three-part semi-structured questionnaire was developed for in-depth interviews. The first part related to personal information such as their gender and country origin, the second to their motivations for topic choices, and the third was concerned with their positive and negative experiences of the process of writing a dissertation. This research was not designed to present a statistical representation of all Asian international students’ experience on writing dissertations. Rather, its emphasis was on the richness of information being gathered and the meaningful comparisons possible. In this sense, the research worked on the principle of theoretical sampling. Using this sampling strategy, new cases were consciously added to extend data comparison. Working through the process, the researcher was theoretically sensitive to new insights developed. New research participants were invited after the preceding interviews were recorded and analysed. In doing so, the information gaps between the previous and successive interviews were filled. The research did not stop sampling until no new information emerged from the latest interview. In total, the researcher interviewed 40 international students from three different countries about their experience. In-depth interviews were carried out in April and May 2005. In terms of data analysis, this overlapped with data collection to build a coherent interpretation of the data. Using a manual process, the researcher made interview transcriptions immediately after each interview and conducted analysis simultaneously. The analytic procedure referred to Strauss and Corbin’s microanalysis (1998). This is a line-by-line analysis that is used to generate initial categories and to discover relationships among concepts (Strauss and Corbin, 1998). The rigour of the analytical procedure depends on its adequacy and transparency. Analysis went further than microanalysis, comparisons between categories were also conducted. At this stage, the relationship between categories was judged at the level of internal convergence and external divergence (Patton, 2002). Comparisons were made not only within the individual cases but also cross the individual cases. Concepts discovered from every previous interview were aggregated immediately. As the insights emerged, they were compared in successive interviews. In this sense, theoretical sampling was also directed by the data analysis so as to “extend, test, and fill in information” (Lincoln and Guba, 1985: 201). By doing so, patterns of data were found. At that point, provisional frameworks were produced. Thus, the analytical process moved from an inductive approach towards “a more deductive approach to data collection and analysis” (Patton, 2002: 67), which focused on verification and interpretation (Lincoln and Guba, 1985; Strauss and Corbin, 1998). On the one hand, the researcher compared similarities and differences among categories within the empirical study. On the other, she compared the emerged categories with previous literature that, to a certain extent, provided a set of guiding hypotheses to this research. Constructed in this way, the
  • 5. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 33 results of this research were built. The completion of this signalled the final stage of the analytic process. Findings Profiles of the interviewees All of the 40 interviewees were full-time students taking their masters degree in tourism and hospitality related subjects. In terms of their country origin, 25 of them were from China (19 from Mainland China, 4 from Hong Kong and 2 from Taiwan), 6 were from Malaysia, and 9 were from India. In terms of gender, there were 25 female students and 15 male students. Motivations for topic choices From the interviews, it was very clear that there were three main motivations for the students in their choice of research topic and these are now discussed below. Link to career development This was the most common motivation for choosing the topic. Most of the interviewees used the dissertation to understand deeply and thoroughly a topic related to their jobs or possible job prospects. The following quotations from the interviewees illustrate this motivation: “I worked in a big travel agency in China. I intend to go back to work there. Doing a project on travel agencies in China would benefit me later.” “I have always wanted to work in the hotel industry in Beijing, especially during 2008 Beijing Olympic Games. Nowadays there are many international hotel chains in Beijing. I thought that doing a dissertation related to international hotel issues in China would afterwards help me to get a job in Beijing.” These concur with Clewes’ research (1996), which identified that skills development and the practical value of the project in terms of improving job prospects were important. Personal interest in the subject area A personal desire to learn about a specific area in their research was the second most important motivation for the interviewees. This was illustrated by statements from two interviewees: “I came from the very northern part of China. I like skiing. I really want to go skiing in Europe. So I did my project about a ski resort in Switzerland. Although it was very difficult for me to find information, I enjoyed finding the information I had for this resort. I have planned to go there this winter.” “It was definitely because of my personal interest! I am a tour guide in Malaysia. I enjoy traveling. I have never been to Africa. But Africa is so mysterious for me. So I did my project on tourism development in Egypt.” The concept that personal interest is a motive for choosing a research topic has been supported by many researchers (e.g. I’Anson and Smith, 2004; Cadman, 1997). Perceived ease of access to secondary and primary data The interviewees also reported that perceived ease of access to sources of data is an important factor in decision-making and topic choice. They reported an ease of access to primary data through established contacts with individuals or organisations, either through their current or previous jobs, or through their family connections. For example:
  • 6. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 34 “Although I was keen to write something related to travel behaviour of disabled people in China, I just could not find many data. So I changed my attention to Chinese outbound travel since I found a lot of articles in English journals.” “I am an international student in the UK. I have met a lot of international students here. So when I thought about my dissertation, I decided to write something relating to international students. This was because of my own experiences and also my network of other international students here. From a practical point of view, it would be easy to do my survey and interviews.” The positive experiences of writing a dissertation Although writing a dissertation in their non-native language was very hard, many students reported gaining benefits from their writing up of the dissertation, which an interviewee summarised as “a challenging but worthwhile learning experience for me”. The students who gave positive experience statements agreed that writing a long piece of work in English was very beneficial to them. The following statements illustrate this: “It’s the first time that I have written such a long piece of work in English. I developed my writing skills and also I gained some confidence in my language skills.” “I learned a lot about skiing destinations in Europe. I enjoyed reading articles about the destination I researched. I really look forward to going there now.” “Although before studying here I’d wanted to work in the Shanghai conference industry, I had no real ideas about it. After writing my dissertation, I not only had some knowledge of conference planning, but I also obtained some first-hand information about its operational situations.” The above findings appear to support l’Anson and Smith’s view (2004) that positive experience of writing a dissertation tended to be reported when research was relatively unproblematic, or if it was a particularly relevant and interesting research topic. These findings also seem to support Woodhouse’s (2002) observation that writing a dissertation will enhance knowledge of the topic that the students research. Several students also reported that during the writing of their dissertation, support from their classmates was a very positive benefit for them: “After meeting my supervisors, I had often been very depressed. Then my classmates would encourage me to carry on. To be honest, without my classmates, I really could not have finished writing my dissertation.’ “Because we were in the same situation, we understood each other. When I had some questions about my literature review or methodology, they often tried their best to help me to solve them.” “I have limited language skills. I was overjoyed when I knew that I had passed all the modules. Writing my dissertation was a very big challenge to my level of English. My classmate helped me a lot by making sure that my sentences were flowing.” These findings seem to agree with Olsen’s (1998) opinion that peer support was one of the important factors influencing students’ positive experience in writing dissertations. The negative experiences of writing a dissertation Although the interviewees all reported they had a great sense of achievement after finishing writing their dissertation, they also all told me of their negative experiences. The three most common negative experiences are summarised below:
  • 7. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 35 Critical approach/analytical writing According to Madsen’s (1983) criteria for thesis assessment (which are still widely recognised by the English language social science academia), writing in this discipline should comprise: a convincing account, an ordered, critical and reasoned exposition, the testing of ideas, competence in independent experimentation, ability to make critical use of published work and source materials and originality. Many interviewees were confused and depressed about their critical analytical skills because of a lack of knowledge in this area. For example: “I have been told by my supervisor that my work lacks critical analysis. I really don’t know what critical analysis means.” “By beginning the writing of my dissertation without a clear understanding of the critical approach, I really suffered when I read the feedback from my supervisor with regards to my literature review. I thought I did a good job, but my supervisor asked me where was my opinion.” The above two statements clearly reflected that their lack of experience and clear guidelines from their lecturers on how to think and write critically made it difficult for the Asian students to know what the requirement entails in practice. These findings seem to agree with Cadman’s (1997) finding that international students found it very difficult to write critically. Paltridge (1997) also commented that students with English as their second language often have difficulty in meeting the demands of the kind of writing required of them at a critical level. Other students complained that different suggestions about critical thinking they received from their lecturers confused them. “I have been given examples on how to write critically. It seems that I need to criticise published work from my academic journals. But how dare I be critical? The authors in those journals were professors or lecturers!” “Different lecturers tell me different things when I ask them what critical thinking really means. These really confuse me when I write my dissertation.” The above finding reflected that Mingers’ conclusion (2000) that the concept of critical thinking is vague and different educators have different views on this matter. The relationship with supervisors All the interviewees reported that there were many cultural barriers to them having an effective relationship with their supervisors. As a result of cultural differences, they had incorrect expectations of, or misunderstandings with, their supervisors. The interviewees said: “I don’t know what help my supervisor is supposed to give me. But it is not my place to ask him about it. I just did what he told me to do.” “In my culture, we will not question what our professors say. So in our meeting, I never gave any real answers to my supervisor. Most of time, I just said ‘yes’.” “My supervisor misinterpreted my draft. I didn’t know whether I should explain it to her. What she said was not what I wanted to do, but she is a professor and I am just a student. So I completely changed my draft to satisfy her comments.” These findings appear to support Aboutorabi’s (1995) research, which showed that because of cultural barriers, international students found it very difficult to develop a proper relationship with their
  • 8. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 36 supervisors. The interviewees also admitted that insufficient language skills were also a barrier to proper communication with their supervisors. Access to research samples The interviewees identified difficulties in data collection due to uncooperative respondents. Some interviewees complained that because student research was not highly rated in their own countries, their requests for information from officials in tourism departments, hotel managers in a hotel chain etc, had often been refused. For example: “For my research I tried to find out about the kinds of preparations that international hotels in Beijing had been doing for the Olympic Games. Therefore I had planned to interview hotel managers from different international hotels in Beijing. After one month of telephone contact with them, there was only one hotel that accepted my request. I was very disappointed.” Some interviewees rebuked themselves because they had a low level of understanding about data collection methods. Also, because they lacked sufficient time management skills they could not get enough data for their research. Conclusions and Recommendations Although this was a small-scale project, this research does provide international student perspectives on the writing of dissertations, as a counterbalance to the current dominance of the academic’s perspective and the focus on students originating from within their own country. This paper identified that there were three main reasons for the international students choosing a particular topic: a link to career development, personal interest in the subject area, and perceived ease of access to primary and secondary data. For international students, the positive experiences gained from writing their dissertations were those generated by learning useful information and also peer support. Their negative experiences related to difficulties in meeting the demands of writing critically, relationships with their supervisors and access to and collection of data. It should be noted that the relationships with their supervisors were perceived negatively not because of academic understanding, but because of cultural barriers and lack of English language skills. The findings from this research have implications for research training given to students and also to lecturers, in terms of pedagogy. As writing a dissertation is a new experience for international students, they need to have tutorials on how to prepare a dissertation and how to deal with their supervisors. As the students have highlighted, cultural differences influence their learning experience and some cultural influences on learning, such as referencing, and social practices, such as relationships between teachers and students, could be discussed by both the students and the lecturers in order to avoid misunderstandings between them. The ground rules about their respective roles and expectations could be set out at the beginning of their study. This would help in encouraging the students to express their personal views about their research material, using both oral and written methods. During the early stages of topic selection, the challenges of accessing and collecting data should be emphasised. This will help highlight the important implications of their decisions on research topic and also avoid disappointment during data collection. The research results appear to suggest that a short training session on critical thinking skills would also be beneficial to the international students, as most of them have no clear idea on what critical thinking is, and how to be critical of the literature they read and also of their own work. For lecturers, it would be very helpful if they could develop a model for critically analysing a subject, or give examples to the students of how to do a critical analysis.
  • 9. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 37 References Abel, C. F (2002) Academic success and the international student: research and recommendations, New Directions for Higher Education, 117, 13-20. Aboutorabi, M (1995) International research students: problems and expectations, The Journal of International Education, 6(3), 55-62. August, O (2004) Why Britain is best for the privileged of Beijing, The Times, Tuesday, February 17 2004, 12-13. Ballard, B and Clanchy, J (1997) Teaching International Students: a brief guide for lecturers and supervisors. Deakin, ACT: Education Australia. Barron, P and Arcodia, C (2002) Linking learning style preferences and ethnicity; international students studying Hospitality and tourism management in Australia, Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education, 1(2), 15-27. Bird, S and Owen, G. (2004) Class divides Chinese who profit in Britain. The Times, Friday, February 13, 12. Cadman, K (1997) Thesis writing for international students: a question of identity? English for Specific Purposes, 16(1), 3-14. Casanave, C. P and Hubbard, P (1992) The writing assignments and writing problems of doctoral students: faculty perceptions, pedagogical issues and needed research, English for Specific Purposes, 11(1), 33-49. Clewes, D (1996) Multiple perspectives on the undergraduate project experience, Innovations - the learning and teaching Journal of Nottingham Trent University, 27-35. CHSE (2002) A new era in assessing student learning. [online]. Melbourne, The University of Melbourne. Available from: http://www.cshe.unimelb.edu.au/assessinglearning/01/index.html [Accessed 10 October 2005]. Dudley-Evans, A (1995) Genre models for the teaching of academic writing to second language speakers: advantages and disadvantages, The Journal of TESOL France, 2(2), 181-192. Dudley-Evans, A (1999) The dissertation: a case of neglect? In: P. Thompson, Issues in EAP writing research and instruction, 28-36. Reading: Centre for Applied Language Studies, University of Reading. Fitzpatrick, J., Secrist, J. and Wright, D. J (1999) Secrets for a Successful Dissertation. London: SAGE Publications. Huang, R (2005) The experience of Mainland Chinese international students in the UK – a tourism perspective. Unpublished thesis (PhD). University of Derby. I’Anson, R.A and Smith, K.A (2004) Undergraduate research projects and dissertations: issues of topic selection, access and data collections amongst tourism management students, Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport an Tourism Education, 3(1), 19-32. Egege, S & Kutieleh, S (2004) Critical thinking: teaching foreign notions to foreign students, International Education Journal, 4(4), 75-85. Kangis, P and Carman, R (2002) Research, knowledge and method: the purpose and role of MBA dissertation, The International Journal of Management Education, 1(2), 8-16. Kingston, P (2005) Chinese whispers. Guardian, 11 January. Lincoln, Y. S and Guba, E. G (1985) Naturalistic Inquiry. London: SAGE Publications. Lowes, R; Peters, H and Turner, M (2004) The international student’s guide studying in English at University. London: SAGE Publishing Ltd. Madsen, D. (1983) Successful dissertation and theses: a guide to graduation student research from proposal to completion. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Mauch, J.E and Birch, J. W (1998) Guide to the Successful Thesis and Dissertation, New York: Marcel Dekker, Inc. Mazzarol, T (1998) Critical success factors for international education marketing, International Journal of Educational Management, 12(4), 163-175. Mazzarol, T and Soutar, G. N (1999) Sustainable competitive advantage for educational institutions: a suggested model, The International Journal of Educational Management, 13(6), 287-300. Mazzarol, T and Soutar, G. N (2002) ‘Push-pull’ factors influencing international student destination choice, The International Journal of Educational Management, 16(2), 82-90.
  • 10. Huang (2007) ‘A Challenging but Worthwhile Experience!’ – Asian International Student Perspectives of Undertaking a Dissertation in the UK Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education 6(1), 29-38. 38 Mingers, J (2000) What is it to be critical? Teaching a critical approach to management undergraduates, Management Learning, 31(2), 219-237. Olsen, L (1998) Teaching and researching the thesis/dissertation in ESP, Colloquium introduction, TESOL’98, Seattle. Paltridge, B (1997) Thesis and dissertation writing: preparing ESL students for research, English for Specific Purposes, 16(1), 61-70. Paltridge, B (2002) Thesis and dissertation writing: an examination of published advice and actual practice, English for Specific Purposes, 21, 125-143. Patton, M. Q (2002) Qualitative Research & Evaluation Methods, 3rd ed. London: SAGE Publications. Phillips, E. M and Pugh, D. S (2000) How to get a PhD: a handbook for students and their supervisors, 3rd edition. Buckingham: Open University Press. Remenyi, D; Williams, B; Money, A and Swartz, E (1998) Doing Research in Business and Management: an introduction to process and method, London: SAGE Publications. Strauss, A and Corbin, J (1998) Basics of Qualitative Research: techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory, 2nd ed. London: SAGE Publications. Thompson, P (1999) Exploring the contexts of writing: interviews with PhD supervisors. In: P. Thompson, Issues in EAP writing research and instruction, 37-54. Reading: Centre for Applied Language Studies, University of Reading.