Leading the continuous school renewal process - wlb
1. Achievement Centered Leadership
Crystal Mountain Resort
Thompsonville, MI
29 July 2014
Lead the Continuous School Renewal
by:
Walter L. Burt, Ph.D.
Facilitator
2. ACL TRAINING SCHEDULE
• Time Schedule
•
• Session 1: 8:15 – 10:05 Open Discussion (110 Minutes or 1.83 hrs.)
•
• 10:05 - 10:30 Activity #1: Moral Purpose (25 Minutes)
•
• 10:30 - 10:45 BREAK (15 Minutes)
•
• Session 2: 10:45 – 11:05 Open Discussion (20 Minutes)
•
• 11:05 - 11:30 Activity #2: To Lead one Must First Lead (25
• Minutes)
•
• Session 3: 11:30 – 11:55 School Renewal Activity (25 Minutes)
•
•
• TOTAL MINUTES: 220 MINUTES (3.78 Hours)
•
3. A SALUTE TO PRINCIPALS AND
TEACHER LEADERS
• Educators, and
particularly school
principals have one of the
most challenging and
beneficial role in
education today
(Hallinger & Heck, 1996;
Leithwood, 2003).
• A key for student success
is a great school, and the
key to a great school is a
great principal (Hallinger
& Leithwood, 1996;
Leithwood, 2003).
4. Learning Objectives
• Highlight the relevant research
associated with selected
leadership dispositions and their
indirect effect upon student
achievement.
• Conduct an assessment of
participants’ leadership attributes
and reflect upon their motivation,
dedication and commitment to
doing this important work.
• Brainstorm “best practices” for
infusing continuous school
renewal activities in the building’s
school improvement plan for the
2014-15 School Year.
4
5. INTRODUCTION
• So far, you have
received training on
five of the six
dimensions
associated with ACL.
6. 6
Manage Safe and
Orderly School
Operations
Establish a
Coherent and
Rigorous
Instructional
Program
Develop Teacher
Leaders
Lead the
Continuous
School
Renewal
Engage in Data-
Informed
Decision-
Making
Achievement
Centered
Leadership
THE ACL LEADERSHIP MODEL
7. 7
Manage Safe and
Orderly School
Operation
Engage in
Data-
informed
Decision-
Making
Develop Teacher
Leaders
Establish a
Coherent and
Rigorous
Instructional
Program
Redesign the
Organization
Lead the
Continuous
School Renewal
THE ACL LEADERSHIP MODEL - PROPOSED
REVISION
8. INTRODUCTION
• Humans are intensely
spiritual creatures
and requires a sense
of belonging,
development and
maintenance of a
sense of purpose and
calling (Graseck,
2005).
10. INTRODUCTION
• People that have a
sense of passion
about their work and
the workplace
encourage creativity
and risk-taking by
having supportive
programs to foster
outside commitment
(Groen, 2001).
11. INTRODUCTION
• This final training session
on leading the
continuous school
renewal process, in my
opinion, tends to bind the
other dimensions into
one encompassing model
that enables one to do
this important work.
12. INTRODUCTION
• The research reports
of the failure of the
publics schools in the
1980s served as the
served as the
harbinger for
policymakers to
institute change in
public schools
(Hallinger & Heck,
1996).
13. INTRODUCTION
• The decline in state and
national economies
during the 1980s brought
a wave of reform in
educational policy,
structure, and training
(Hallinger & Heck, 1996,
Marks & Printy, 2003;
Leithwood & Jantzi,
1999).
14. INTRODUCTION
• The research community
provided policymakers
with the venue to view
principals. We have seen
evidence of this in recent
policy decisions
pertaining to principal
evaluation, principal
preparation programs,
and principal
professional training
(Hallinger & Heck,
1996;Leithwood & Jantzi,
1999).
15. THE CHALLENGES OF PRINCIPAL
LEADERSHIP
• NCLB and RTTT legislative
fiats have placed
tremendous pressure on
school staff to improved
student achievement
(Hallinger & Heck, 1996;
Leithwood & Seashore-
Louis, 2012; Shen, Cooley,
Mia, Reeves, Burt, Rainey,
Yuan, 2012).
16. THE CHALLENGES OF PRINCIPAL
LEADERSHIP
• The goal of becoming a
teacher or principal
does not have the allure
it once had.
Consequently, fewer
candidates are moving
into teaching and
school administrative
positions (Burt &
McCrumb, 2011; Heitin,
2013; Tillman, 2009).
17. THE CHALLENGES OF PRINCIPAL
LEADERSHIP
• People with a high level
of personal mastery have
a special sense of vision
and goals for their
organization. It becomes
a calling, rather than
simply a good idea
(Allison, 2012; Bolman &
Deal, 2001; Senge, 1999,
2000).
18. • The extant research show
principals have an
indirect influence on
improving student
achievement (Hallinger &
Leithwood, 1996;
Leithwood, Seashore-
Louis, Anderson, &
Wahlstrom, 2010 ; The
Wallace Foundation,
2013).
19. • Developing leadership
capacity to improve
school conditions is
difficult work – few
people have the
background and
experience to do this
important work
(Fullan, 2001, 2005;
Wayman, Midgley &
Stringfield, 2006).
20. • Principals must not only
focus on student
performance, they must
also support the
intellectual and emotional
work of teachers
(Hargraves, Moore, &
Manning, 2001).
21. Activity #1: WHY I CHOSE TO DO THIS
IMPORTANT WORK? MY STORY
• Identify a person that you do
not know and/or have had
little to no prior conversation.
• Find a convenient place to talk.
• Share your experience about
what compelled you to do and
sustain your desire to lead in
this area.
• Take 25 minutes to share your
story.
22. THE VISION
• “We hold these truths to be
self-evident that all men are
created equal and that they
are endowed by their
Creator with certain
unalienable rights, that
among these are life, liberty
and the pursuit of
happiness” (The United
States Declaration of
Independence, 1776).
22
24. PURPOSE, VISION, AND GOALS
• Purpose, vision, and
goals helps to bring
focus to the individual
and collective work of
staff members. They
articulate a compelling
and challenging target
for one’s personal
practices (Cotton, 2003;
Fritz, 1999; Fullan,
2001, Kouzes & Posner,
2002; Leithwood &
Jantzi, 1999).
25. LEADERSHIP ATTRIBUTES THAT HAVE AN
INDIRECT INFLUENCE ON STUDENT
ACHIEVEMENT
• Passion
• Commitment
• Motivation
• Rituals, Ceremonies, and
other Symbolic Actions
• Encouraging Risk-Taking
• Self Confidence,
Responsibility, and
Perservance
• High Expectations
• Charismatic Leadership
• Transformational
Leadership
26. PASSION
• Passion is a compelling
emotion. It conveys a sense of
conviction of responsibility to
others (Kouzes & Posner,
2002).
• Exemplary leaders model the
expectations they have for
others and are willing to make
personal sacrifices to
demonstrate their willingness
and conviction to make
improvements (Burns, 1978;
Marion, 2002; Northouse,
2010).
• Youtube.com – Remember the
Titans – Coach Boone Speech.
26
27. PASSION
• In high achieving
schools, principals hold
themselves accountable
for student
achievement (Cotton,
2003).
• Principals’ strong focus
on academics is essential
to improving student
achievement (Leithwood
& Jantzi, 1999; Cotton,
2003).
28. PASSION
• In high achieving
schools, principals
spend their time in
classrooms, hallways,
lunchroom, and
meeting with
instructional leadership
teams, rather than
being cloistered in their
offices (Cotton, 2003;
Witziers, et al., 2003).
29. COMMITMENT
• Making an effort to
embrace the
organization’s aim and
values as a member of
the organization.
Committed employees
feel the need to go
beyond normal job
expectations (Cerit,
2010).
29
30. COMMITMENT
• Principals’ strong
focus on academics is
essential to improving
student achievement
(Cotton, 2003;
Edmonds, 1979;
Leithwood & Jantzi,
1999).
31. COMMITMENT
• We can improve our
leadership by focusing
on a small number of
key dimensions – core
aspects of leadership.
It creates a new mind-
set about the leader’s
responsibility to him or
herself and to those
with whom s/he works
(Fullan, 2001).
32. COMMITMENT
• School and district
effectiveness studies
show that high levels of
student achievement are
possible when schools
and the district act as
coordinated units of
change (Chrispeels,
Burke, Johnson, & Daly
(2008).
33. COMMITMENT
• When implementing
school initiatives, school
leaders should recognize
that change is slow (Ma,
Shen, Kavanaugh, Lu,
Brandi, Goodman, Till, &
Watson (in press) and that
the commitment of the
principal and a core
group is critical to change
(Lee, Levin, & Soler, 2005;
Rogers, 1995).
34. COMMITMENT
• New school initiatives are
often seen to be
distractions. These
measures may distance
staff from the “real” work
and distance teachers and
principals’ emotions to do
well. In this sense,
commitment often
produced counterintuitive
impulses (Blackmore,
2004)
35. MOTIVATION
• School reform
initiatives depend on
the motivations and
capacities of local
leadership, including
teachers and
administrators,
(Leithwood,
Seashore-Louis,
Anderson, &
Wahlstrom, 2010).
36. MOTIVATION
• People are motivated
by goals which they
find personally
compelling, as well as
challenging, but
achievable
(Leithwood &
Seashore-Louis, 2011;
Leithwood, Seashore-
Louis, Anderson, &
Wahlstrom, (2004).
37. COLLABORATION
• Schools are
deprivatized and
there is a norm where
principals, teachers,
and others are
planning and
working together to
upgrade their skills
and knowledge
(Cotton, 2003).
38. MORAL PURPOSE
• Transformation of the
individual to become
committed to making a
difference in the lives
of children. It means,
– Raising the bar for all
children
– Treating people with
respect
– Altering the social
environment for other
schools and districts
(Fullan, 2001, 2005;
Goodlad, 1994).
39. RITUALS, CEREMONIES, AND OTHER
SYMBOLIC ACTIONS
• Effective schools
utilize ceremonies
and rituals intended
to honor tradition,
instill pride,
recognize excellence,
and stimulate
proprietary interest in
the school than
ineffective schools
(Cotton, 2003).
40. ENCOURAGING RISK-TAKING
• Principals in
productive
elementary schools
skillfully used a
number of strategies
to promote the efforts
of both parents and
teachers who work
directly with children
(Sebring & Bryk,
2000).
41. SELF-CONFIDENCE, RESPONSIBILITY,
AND PERSERVANCE
• In high achieving schools,
the administrator holds
him/herself accountable
for the success of the
whole school. They have
confidence in their ability
to influence situations.
They offer no excuses
about student
performance (Cotton,
2003; Smith, Guarino,
Strom, & Adams, 2006).
42. HIGH EXPECTATIONS
• Researchers from Edmonds
(1979) to the present have
consistently found that
high-achieving schools,
including poor and
minority schools, are
successful in part because
the principals communicate
to everyone in the school
their expectations of high
performance (Cotton, 2003;
Goodlad, 1994; Leithwood
& Jantzi, 1999).
43. Activity #2 : AN ASSESSMENT OF MY LEADERSHIP
QUALITIES:
• The purpose of this learning
activity is designed to assess
school leaders’ commitment
and motivation for doing this
work.
• Principals and aspiring
principals will use Activity
Sheet #2 to discuss their
leadership qualities. Take 25
minutes for this activity
• Be prepared to discuss your
“take-away” from this activity.
43
44. CHARISMATIC LEADERSHIP
• Theories of leadership almost
always involve theories of
change (Knight, 2001).
• Leaders with a great degree of
passion are also individuals
imbued with a high level of
charisma (Crawford, 2002).
• Many people think charisma is
vital to leadership (Burns,
1978; Marion, 2002; Northouse,
2010).
44
45. The Dilemma of the Charismatic
Leader
• Charismatic leaders are
often described in ways
that make it similar to
transformational leadership
(Northouse, 2010).
• Charismatic leaders have
exceptional powers of
persuasion and are able to
overcome resistance and
opposition to the chosen
course of action.
45
46. Personality Characteristics, Behaviors, and Effects on
Followers of Charismatic Leadership
46
Personality Characteristics Behaviors Effects on Followers
Dominant
Desire to influence
Self-confident
Strong moral values
Sets strong role model
Shows competence
Articulates goals
Communicates high
expectations
Trust in leader’s ideology
Belief similarity between leader and follower
Unquestioning acceptance
Affection toward leader
Obedience
Identification with leader
Emotional involvement
Heightened goals
Increased confidence
Northouse, P. G. (2010). Leadership: Theory and practice (5th Edition).
San Francisco:, CA: Sage
47. TRANSFORMATIONAL LEADERSHIP
• Strong transformational
leadership by the
principal is essential in
getting teachers involved
in the implementation of
various instructional and
support initiatives (Marks
& Printy, 2003). These
principals create a sense
of urgency for doing this
work (Kotter, 1996).
48. CONCLUDING REMARKS
• People that have
passion & commitment
have discovered work
that excites them.
• Passionate and
committed people are
willing to take risk.
• Passionate and
committed people
believe they have the
ability to make a
difference.
48
49. CHILDREN ARE OUR FUTURE
• Whitney Houston –
Children are our
Future
49
50. Activity #3: SCHOOL RENEWAL
ACTIVITY
• Principal and Aspiring
principals will take 25
minutes to begin the
planning process for
demonstrating their
commitment and
willingness to lead
continuous school
renewal activities for the
2014-15 School Year.
50
Editor's Notes
Consider using Dalton Sherman’s opening speech to DISD.
All to often, you are not recognized for the work that you do. You are an underrepresented group when in comes to recognition.
Your work is to recognize the work of others. So, let’s take a few minutes and recognize the people who provide a lot of leadership, support, and commitment at the building level.
You were first introduced to the ACL Leadership Model in February. You see five dimensions and data informed decision-making circling the dimensions. Why do you think this is so?
I would argue that the model should look like this.
This dimension serves as the spiritual foundation that helps to coalesce the remaining disciplines into a framework for doing this important work.
[Review the statements below]
Spirituality is not synonymous with religion. Spirituality is a way of living that promotes an awareness of meaning in life, love, relationships and a priority of values while religion is a particular belief and faith characterized by a social institution in which a group of people participate and are concerned about systems of practices and beliefs.
There is a great degree of spiritual leadership traits that is associated with leading school renewal and it is beginning to gain recognition as an effective leadership style for correcting what is wrong with the nation’s schools. According to Thompson, “personal observations as well as research has shown that there defined patterns of behavior among certain district and school leaders that indicates their successful use of spiritual leadership traits and attributes in their daily actions and decisions.”
Bolman & Deal (2001) reminds us that while the job of a leader can be overwhelming, they set the tone for entire building -leading by example. If a leader wants teachers to instruct their students with love and a genuine concern for their well-being, they have to lead with the same qualities. This does not mean that you cannot hold people accountable, it means that it is done with respect, dignity and with love –not vengeance, malice, or negativity.
Even the word “administrator” has a spiritual connotation – one who serves, comfort others, etc. (See Taylor’s work.)
Add commentary about this word. See Taylor
Review the thoughts of Kline & Saunders.
The research conducted by Hallinger & Heck, along with Leithwood and others, clearly demonstrate that school principals have an indirect influence on student achievement. In other words, good principals enhance the instructional, organizational, and culture that supports the climate for effective schools.
The 29th Annual MetLife Survey of the American Teacher finds that tree out of four K-12 public school principals believe the job has become “too complex” anmd about a third say they are likely to go into a different occupation within the next five years (Heitin, 2003)
Allison says resilient leaders take action with speed and elegance that responds to new and ever-changing realities, even as they maintain the essential of the organizations they lead.
There are many signs that many organizations are at a critical juncture because of a crisis of meaning and faith. Managers wonder how to build team spirit when turnover is high, resources are low, and people worry about losing their jobs.
Fullan (2005) believes that high-quality leaders help make working conditions energizing and make school improvement exciting. Principals who do not possess these qualities do not improve the working lives of teachers.
When the job of the building principal is characterized by a lack of excitement and not being able to see issues from other people’s perspectives, the job become tiresome and claustrophobic and there is no joy in the work being done
Fullan (2003), in referencing Palmer, ask his colleagues to revisit their moral purpose by asking the following questions (Provide Handout):
Why did I become a teacher/principal in the first place?
What do I stand for as a teacher/principal?
What are the gifts I bring to my work?
What do I want my legacy to be?
What can I do to “keep track of myself” – to remember my own heart? (p. 11.)
“We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal. And that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights. Among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.” - The Declaration to the United States Constitution, 1776.
Passion that the Founding Fathers had about creating a world that they could not envision. Many who had a vision did not even live up to these expectations. Some had slaves, and the majority of the men felt that women could not vote, own property, and could be bought on the price of tobacco. While these individuals held these debilitating beliefs, I have to believe that they had a vision for a world that they could not even envision.
Their legacy to us who work in many different fields
Important principles about structural tension: This is the role of the building principal and that is to create structural tension in the workplace. To create tension so that the organization improves, rather than accepting the status quo (rubber band).
Tension is formed by a discrepancy, or difference, between two elements – goal and reality;
Tension creates a tendency for movement by forming a path of least resistance;
Tension resolves when the discrepancy ends (Fritz, 1999).
Proverbs 29:18.
School Improvement Plan – What is the vision? (Can you recall it?) Does it have meaning? Whose purpose, vision, and goals does it represent?
The word passion has a strong biblical connection. Its origin stems around the years of 1125-1175 in Medieval England and it comes from the word “passio” which represents Christ’s sufferings on the cross. Now the word passio serves as a representation of sufferings and submission.
Exemplary leaders have a greater passion and commitment for their staffs, students, parents, their building and district. Caring for others and their well-being convey a sense of conviction and responsibility to others. Exemplary leaders model the expectations they have for others and are willing to make personal sacrifices to demonstrate their willingness and convictions to make improvements within their organization. (Think of King & Ghandi and their personal sacrifices.)
Michael Fullan’s framework for leadership. This framework contains six themes. They are: (1) moral purpose, (2) understanding change, (3) relationship building, (4) knowledge creation and sharing, and (5) coherence making.
Committed people are willing to go the extra mile.
Refer to Everett Rogers’ book, Diffusion of Innovation.
Teachers may see the school renewal as a distraction from the work.
Teachers may be sensitive to not being successful in the new initiative. They may feel their competence may come into question.
What does this mean for administrators & teacher leaders? (Resources, time, leader involvement.)
Fullan (2001) argues that many aspects of the current principalship do not pertain to moral purpose at all. Being a competent manager, engaging in good public relations, and even getting higher test scores do not constitute moral purpose. The driver should be moral purpose and that all other capacities (e.g., knowledge of the change process, building professional learning communities) should be in the service of moral purpose.
There were three major trends:
Leadership styles – facilitative orientation, an institutional focus on student learning, efficient management , and a reliance on a combination of pressure and support to motivate others;
Principals tended to address problems that can be solved quickly, they keep their long-term focus on improving student achievement, they follow a school improvement plan, and they attack incoherence.
With the Chicago Reform initiative, promoting stronger ties between the school and parents and other community members, developing teachers’ knowledge and skills, and creating a viable professional learning community within the school.
Principals working with higher proportions of free/reduced lunch populations reported significantly higher self-efficacy beliefs for instructional leadership. Schools with high percentages of free lunch students would benefit from principals with higher levels of self-efficacy for instructional leadership.
If we are to lead, we must first be able to demonstrate the capacity to lead . . . .
Relate the cabin pressure instance on departing airlines.
Reference Life Magazine that shows the 100 most influential people that changed the world.
Transformational and pseudotransformational leaders.
If your company is heading in the right direction, a charismatic leader will get you there faster. Unfortunately, if you’re heading in the wrong direction, charisma will also get you there faster.
By articulating the mission, the transformational leader “sets the agenda.”
The mission statement is by far very powerful. When advanced by a transformative leader who is charismatic, convincing, and inspirational, they can have an even stronger impact. This suggestion is anchored in Ma Weber’s (1947) now classical argument that charisma matters; this notion- that charisma matters- is highly evident in transformational leadership. Not only does a a mission statement paint a picture about the future of the organization for the organizational members, but TL theorists argue that it can be done in a way that makes others want to assist in the painting of that picture- to color within the lines of the picture and take it up as their very own project.
Charismatic leadership inadvertently often do more harm than good because, at best, they provide episodic improvement followed by frustrated or despondent dependency. Superhuman leaders also do us another disservice: they are role models who can never be emulated by large numbers. Deep and sustained reform depends on many of us, not just on the very few who are destined to be extraordinary (Fullan, 2001).