This document summarizes a study on the roles and tasks of educators involved in massive open online courses (MOOCs). Interviews were conducted with 28 educators from 7 MOOCs across various subject areas. Educators included professors, learning designers, PhD students, and others. Their roles varied and included course design, content creation, video production, facilitation, and more. Educators often took on new roles and learned tasks through practice or collaboration as training was limited. Challenges included a lack of expertise in some required tasks and working outside of regular hours for facilitation. Support for educators could include encouraging collaboration, expertise sharing, and short trainings on topics such as copyright, video skills, and facilitation.
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...
Who are the mooc educators and what are their job tasks? A multi case study
1. Who are the mooc educators and what
are their job tasks? A multi case study
Tina Papathoma
Work supervised by:
Dr. Doug Clow
Dr. Rebecca Ferguson
Prof. Allison Littlejohn
Institute of Educational Technology
Slideshare:
https://goo.gl/4RhUV7
2. Outline
● Main research question and RQ that came up
● Multiple case study
● Analysis:
Who are the people involved in moocs
What are their job tasks and how they describe
their job tasks in moocs
● Challenges educators found during their mooc
practice, how they acted, what can be done to
support them
● Next steps in the analysis of this study 2
3. Main Research Question
How do educators learn how to teach in massive open online
courses (moocs)?
Educators
People involved in the mooc design, run & facilitation
Learn
from training, in practice, in collaboration with colleagues, self-
regulation (integrative pedagogy)
Teach
design, run and facilitate
Moocs
courses offered via FutureLearn 3
4. 4
Research Question that came up
from the data
Who are the mooc educators and what are their job
tasks?
5. Multiple case study
Data were gathered through a multiple case
study involving interviews with people involved
in moocs
7 courses (4 in history, 3 in politics) lasting from 3-6 weeks
28 interviews in total with:
15 Professors & Lecturers
6 PhD students
1 librarian
5 Learning designers
1 member of staff of a specialist organisation
5
6. Who were the mooc
educators?
Before Data Collection
6
7. 7
Examples of potential participants who
were contacted as educators include:
● People involved in the learning design of the
mooc
● People who develop content or assessment for
the mooc
● People who produce videos for the mooc
● People who facilitate / moderate the learners’
discussions
● People who present mooc videos
8. Who are the mooc
educators in this
study?
After Data Collection
8
9. 9
Case G
From the teams* involved in this mooc, 4 people
were interviewed:
1 Digital learning team manager from digital learning team
30 years experience in face to face IT training
30 moocs experience the last 3 years
3 Professors from the academic team
Over 15 years of experience in face to face teaching/
research in the mooc topic
1st mooc experience for all 3
*learning design, academics, specialist organisation, PhD students
10. 10
Job tasks for Learning Design team- Case G
● Learning objectives
● Choice of content
● Length of the mooc, Assessment
● Course outline
● Decisions about purchasing content
● Decisions about images and music
● Video production, filming, editing decisions
● Training academics(script writing, using autocues)
● Repurposing the mooc for other audiences
(academics were NOT involved in this)
11. 11
Quote on how LD manager describes tasks
‘We would then work with our academics, so our academics would be involved
in every process but they don’t actually get involved in creating the course on
the platform. So we would start off by work with those academics to define what
the learning objectives are for their course, what it is that they wanting students
to learn, we would then look into breaking that down into a number of weeks, so
that will determine how long the mooc was, so then we would take those
learning objectives and divide them up basically over the number of weeks we felt
appropriate and then we would start to build a course outline which we would
then, the academics would sign off that they are happy with that course outline.
We would then look at the content that we had to build that course and look at
how we would best represent that content, whether it should be a video,
whether it should be a written article or a text article that the learner can read,
whether there is a need for the learner to research something or maybe discuss
with other learners on the course, whether we need some kind of a quiz or a self-
test to test understanding but also whether there is any more formal assessment
if there is a formal test which is scored at all. So we look at all those different
elements and we define the course outline’
025, Digital Learning Team Manager, F
12. Job Tasks for Academics – Case G
● Learning objectives
● Choice of content, writing the script and being
filmed presenting the course content
● Length of the mooc, Assessment
● Course outline
● Decisions about editing videos (lead)
● Decisions about purchasing content
● Facilitation, (live) Q&A
● To train PhD students to facilitate the course
12
13. Quotes on how academics describe tasks
Purchasing content
●‘I would think more carefully about the sources that were
available [..] because I think I didn’t know what permissions
were needed and what the cost would be […] because we
couldn’t get the stuff’ 026, Lead Educator, F
Facilitation
●the first one we were quite heavily involved during live web
chats for the 3 weeks, the second one we did some recorded
chats and the third we didn’t have much involvement at that
stage 027, Educator, F
●‘first week which was one of my lectures would run, when I
was expected to be online [..] we were going away so I found
myself in a hostel and 11 at night on my phone, responding
[..]because I couldn’t respond during the day cause I was with
my kids.. 027, Educator, F 13
14. Difference between LD &Academic
‘the mooc was a collaboration between
ourselves, [university of X] and the Z [specialist
organization ]’
025, Digital learning team manager, F
‘so we were kind of commissioned to do this
mooc really’
026, Academic, F
14
15. 15
Educators of all cases come from
different backgrounds and expertise
Academics (Lecturers, Professors)
Learning designers (Project managers, Lead of
digital design team)
PhD students
A Librarian
A communication manager
Educators have different types of expertise such as
Teaching
Training in IT
subject matter expertise
learning design expertise
project management
16. 16
Challenges educators found during
mooc practice and how they acted
●Educators learned tasks in practice as training was
either limited or absent
●Educators collaborated with each other & provided
short training to each other (script writing, autocue
use, online presence, facilitation)
●Educators self-regulated by seeking advice from
experts as well as observing how other moocs have
run
●Educators worked outside working hours to facilitate
the mooc
17. 17
Educators’ Roles
●Educators’ roles were not fixed, they often moved
from one role to another, they found themselves
unprepared for the mooc but learned in practice or
from others
●They were taking different responsibilities for which
they often did not have the expertise to work on
18. 18
What can be done to support
educators
to acquire a range of skills
to collaborate with others
to share each other’s expertise
Institutions, senior management and platforms may
assist in that to encourage collaboration between
experts and novices as well as to provide short
training on: purchasing copyright material, video
presentation, digital pedagogy, facilitation skills/tips
19. 19
Next steps in the analysis of this
study
● to analyse the power among the groups involved
in moocs
● to analyse the differences in the vocabulary
educators are using – academics / learning
designers
After I started exploring how educators learn how to teach in massive open online courses for my PhD study, we found out that we actually need to look on who are the mooc educators and what are their job tasks
Here’s an outline of this presentation. I will start with the main RQ and talk about the rq that came up, give some info about the multi case study approach I took , discuss who are the people involved in 1 of the cases I am studying. I will continue with their job tasks and how they describe them. I will discuss the challenges educators have found during their mooc practice and what can be done to support educators. I will finish with the next steps of this study..
Starting with the main research question, I have looked at how educators learn how to teach in massive open online courses.
In particular, I interviewed people involved in the mooc design, run and facilitation
When I talk about ‘how do educators learn’ I mean the knowledge they get from training on how to design, run and facilitate moocs, the knowledge they get from practice by working on a mooc, the knowledge they acquire from other colleagues and the knowledge they get when they take decisions on their own learning. These types of knowledge are part of the Integrative Pedagogy framework of Paivi Tynjala a professor doing research in professional learning in Finland.
By teach I mean how educators, design, run and facilitate the courses .. The cases that were used relate to history and politics courses offered via FL.
While I was analysing the data in order to answer the main question another question came up ‘– which is … so in order to see how they learn we need to see who they are , what do they understand to be the roles of the educators and also I am looking to this from different perspectives on the same mooc (so from academics, ld, phd students ) as well as on different moocs. So after answering who they are, what their knowledge is , and their background , then we will break them down and see how each of these groups learn. What we see from educators’ reports is that they actually have many roles and that they move from one to the other, so they don’t have just one fixed role. I will talk about this in the next slides.
Before that , I will talk through the methodology I followed …
The reason why I chose this area of history and politics is because it is less rooted to technology and therefore educators from such courses might need to learn new practices in order to teach on MOOCs
15 professors and lecturers that their main role was the academic content ..
Phd : facilitation, writing in external blogs
Librarian ac cont and facilitation
Specialist organisation : facilitation, writing in external blogs
Whom did I consider as mooc educators BEFORE the data Collection ..
So before the data collection I contacted potential participants whom I could Identify that they were people involved in the learning design of the mooc, people who develop content or assessment .. And so on ..
As I concluded in the previous FLAN : The role of educators is changing and what we actually see from the data is that their roles were not fixed and they often had to move from one role to another and that they have several roles
For example in CASE G which was a course that run 3 times and was a collaboration from a uni institution and a specialist organisation …
We see that the LD team has the following job tasks for which they closely collaborate with academics
The ones in bold will be shown in a quote in the next slide
-Academics are involved in every process of the MOOC preparation and run- The work starts off with the digital learning team that works with the academics
Learning objectives (academics and digital team)
Course length
Course outline – to give to the academic to sign off
Content (represented in a video, text, quiz?)
so they take decisions about most processes, they are not subject experts, the digital learning team – and they have power in the mooc process.
Perhaps we wouldn’t have guessed that a learning designer would be in charge of all these tasks. The academics sign off the course outline- power
And the academics have lots of job tasks as well closely related to the LD team
Meeting with other colleagues while running the mooc and facilitate live (1st run), responding questions in writing (2nd), no involvement (3rd)
Purchasing content : This quote talks about a task that the academic had to take a decision (about purchasing material but she didn’t have the expertise to do it
Facilitation : the course as I said run 3 times , in the first one the educators had live q&A – in the second they were again involved and in the third they were not involved. So being a mooc educator does not mean they will be present each time that the course runs. This is not part of their tasks/jobs when it runs multiple times. This would not be expected in a face to face class that a course to run is essential to have a teacher/educator..
In the last quote educator 27 describes what responsibility she had even though she was actually away but a mooc is a 24/7 job ..
So for 025 it was a collaboration and it sounds positive, for 026 it was a commission to do the mooc , WE might make an assumption that she did not take the initiative to do it
The role expectations for educators in moocs may be very demanding
acquire a range of skills that were not required in their past experience