presentation by Colin Price part of the Phytothreats project

1. USING CARBBROD TO
ESTIMATE THE COST OF
PHYTOPHTHORAS
Colin Price, free-lance academic
90 Farrar Road, Bangor, Gwynedd LL57 2DU
United Kingdom

3.  Origins in early 1990s (cost–benefit analysis of
farm woodlands – MAFF funding);
 based on yield models (Forestry Commission);
 used social cost of carbon and single discount
rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;

4.  Origins in early 1990s (cost–benefit analysis of
farm woodlands – MAFF funding);
 based on yield models (Forestry Commission);
 used social cost of carbon and single discount
rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;

5. THINNED JAPANESE LARCH YC12: CROP VOLUME
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
0 20 40 60 80 100
Maincropvolume(cu.m.)
Lapse of time (years)

6. 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
0 20 40 60 80 100
Maincropvolume(cu.m.)
Lapse of time (years)
REPLACEMENT: THINNED SCOTS PINE YC10

7.  Origins in early 1990s (cost–benefit analysis of
farm woodlands – MAFF funding);
 based on yield models (Forestry Commission);
 used social cost of carbon and single discount
rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;

8. 0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
0 100 200 300 400 500
Proportionoforiginalvalue
Lapse of time (years)
Remnant
atmosph-
eric CO 2
Present
temper-
ature
change
2

9. 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
0 100 200 300 400
Discountrate(%)
Lapse of time (years)
Get out there and
use them!

10. Year Low Central High Low Central High
2008 20 20 20 27 55 82
2009 12 12 12 28 56 84
2010 12 12 12 28 57 85
2011 11 11 11 29 57 86
2012 6 6 6 29 58 87
2013 0 3 16 30 59 89
2014 0 4 17 30 60 90
2015 0 4 18 30 61 91
2016 0 4 19 31 62 93
2017 0 4 21 31 63 94
2018 0 4 22 32 64 96
2019 0 5 24 32 65 97
2020 0 5 26 33 66 99
2021 4 12 35 33 67 100
2022 8 19 44 34 68 102
Traded Non-traded
Traded and non-traded (for forestry etc)
differ.
Not all changes are monotonic.
But they converge after 2030.
They go on rising thereafter.
Traded and non-traded (for forestry etc)
differ.
Not all changes are monotonic.
But they converge after 2030.
They go on rising thereafter.
Traded and non-traded (for forestry etc)
differ.
Not all changes are monotonic.
But they converge after 2030.
They go on rising thereafter.
Traded and non-traded (for forestry etc)
differ.
Not all changes are monotonic.
But they converge after 2030.
They go on rising thereafter.

11. DECC prices are:
 per tonne carbon dioxide equivalent;
 not per tonne carbon.
 Multiply by 3.67 for per tonne carbon.
 They are very high compared with those used
by Stern etc.

12. DECC prices are:
 per tonne carbon dioxide equivalent;
 not per tonne carbon.
 Multiply by 3.67 for per tonne carbon.
 They are very high compared with those used
by Stern etc.

13. DECC prices are:
 per tonne carbon dioxide equivalent;
 not per tonne carbon.
 Multiply by 3.67 for per tonne carbon.
 They are very high compared with those used
by Stern etc.

14. DECC prices are:
 per tonne carbon dioxide equivalent;
 not per tonne carbon.
 Multiply by 3.67 for per tonne carbon.
 They are very high compared with those used
by Stern etc.

15. “These long-term carbon values reflect the costs
required to achieve the internationally agreed
UNFCCC long term goal of limiting global
temperature increases to not greater than 2 degrees
centigrade above pre-industrial levels.” (UK DECC,
2013)
Get out there and
use them!

16. Summed
effects of
carbon flux
during t = 2
Carbon flux
during t = 2
Effect during
t = 2
Effect during
t = 3
Effect during
t = 4
…
Effect in t = 
Summed
effects of
carbon flux
during t = 1
Carbon flux
during t = 1
Effect during
t = 1
Effect during
t = 2
Effect during
t = 3
…
Effect in t = 
Summed
effects of
carbon flux
during t = T
Carbon flux
during t = T
Effect during
t = T
Effect during
t = T + 1
Effect during
t = T + 2
…
Effect in t = 
 Algebraic 
integration
 Algebraic 
integration
 Algebraic 
integration
. . . Numerical
summation
Summed
effects of
carbon flux
during t = 1T


  Tρ
e1
1
Summed
effects of
carbon flux
during t = 1
None of this is possible with irregular
discount and carbon prices. So …

17. Forest
increment
during the
year t
Harvesting
at t added
to give ...
SRW
pool (t-1)
Biomass
pool (t-1)
decay
Net carbon
change in
atmosph-
ere during
the year t
LRW
pool (t-1)
decay
decay
Biomass
pool (t)
 price 
discount
factor for t
= C value
SRW
pool (t)
LRW
pool (t)
Increment
during the
year t+1 decay
Net carbon
change in
atmosph-
ere during
year t+1
decay
decay
 price 
Biomass
pool (t+1)
Harvesting
at t+1 add-
ed to give
SRW
pool (t+1)
LRW
pool (t+1)
LRW
pool (t)
SRW
pool (t)
Biomass
pool (t)
And so on …
Strictly, to be integrated over year t…

18. THINNED JAPANESE LARCH YC12: CO2 FLUXES
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 20 40 60 80 100
CO2fluxes(tonnes)
Lapse of time (years)
Into trees
From
products

19. 0.083271
%).(%)(%).(





 54530
521
1
31
1
531
1
 
Tρ
eT











1
rotationoneofPV
yearsofrotations
ofseriesperpetual
ofvalueDiscounted

20. Repeat after me! OR
replace if diseased.

21. Carbon Price
2008 20
2009 12
2010 12
2011 11
2012 6
2013 0
2014 0
2015 0
2016 0
2017 0
2018 0
2019 0
2020 0
2021 4
2022 8
2023 11
16 3.50%
17 3.50%
18 3.50%
19 3.50%
20 3.50%
21 3.50%
22 3.50%
23 3.50%
24 3.50%
25 3.50%
26 3.50%
27 3.50%
28 3.50%
29 3.50%
30 3.50%
31 3%
32 3%
Age MeanVol TotalVol
0 0 0
1 0 5.117647
2 0 10.23529
3 0 15.35294
4 0 20.47059
5 0 25.58824
6 0 30.70588
7 0 35.82353
8 0 40.94118
9 0 46.05882
10 0 51.17647
11 0 56.29412
12 0 61.41176
13 0 66.52941
14 0 71.64706
Year
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028

22. THIS SHEET TAKES THE CURRENT CROP AND REGIME WITHOUT INFECTION AND REPEATS IT Add to accumulated carbon the accumulated DCF values
It constructs the physical and cash flows from the present yield model and cash flows. Rotation 102
It compiles the regime, from the sequence of crops, starting with the defined present age of the present crop up to the defined rotation. MaxPrice MargTree SizeofHalfValue Partition SRW/LRW Sum disc carb to 2514
This is then followed by as many replanted crops of the existing one as it take to get a completion beyond any changes in discount or carbon price (500 years).Parameters of present PSR 35 0.08 0.25 SRWmin 0 DiffDisc for carbon done by
In the final format, there will be an infinite series of the replacement crop after the time when all prices stabilise, but this won't much affect the numbers. Parameters of replacement PSR 35 0.08 0.25 expo trend for price
Rotation is set at 102 Size at this age 3.769912 All it needs is for the amount of decay to be reduced by the subst proportion Biomass addition present crop 0.77822 SRWconst 2.3 Carbon column used 6
Replacement rotation 102 Rows are filled in for each year up to the time DCF SumCost SumRev NPV Biomass addition replacement 0.77822 CarbPrice Uc SumCarb SumDiscCarb Test columns
Year starts from current. Infection time is defined for the facsimiles of this sheet which look at infection and treatments. £595 -£3,366 £3,961 £50,336 Stem Non-stem Decay Biomass Sawmill Boards £519,350 £49,741
The rows start from the current crop age. Maincrop before thinning Thinning VoltoCO2 0.751667 0.584962 coeffs 0.06 0.033 0.06 Discounted?
Year Crop Rotation Age MeanVol TotalVol FellRev MeanVol TotalVol ThinRev CostNameAmount£ DiscFact DCF DCF for replac 0.751667 0.584962 Decaying pools (CO2 equiv) Yes! Switch 2034
(P)resent/(R)eplace Fallow Yr at RotEnd Do via a table in Master and lookup a/c "R" and rotation? T (cost) (revenue) Condit CO2Fix VoltoCO2 LRW CO2 SRW CO2 Biomass Sawmill Boards Biofuel Displace't Year's Year's CarbPrice @ Priced CarbDiscFacDiscCarbValue Lapsed age
R Crop age VoltoCO2 in trees for stem harvestedharvestedC (dead) Conditionals not needed perman't decay net flux mid-period flux for year to t Last year Accumulated carbon value Discounted price Undiscounted revenue
-£3,366 Decay rates and assortments need to go conditional when replacement switches con to blf or vice versa. for crop None of these need Q9 conditionally to Q9 or Q10, as BAU doesn't change species. from of CO2 Check to see what Carbbrod27's columns are Not sure what this is
?Should be here a "story so far" for the CO2 already fixed, which is what decays? Or only the biomass? Redundant! 0 pools Check first row: is story so far, not year's change. So delete flux? AccCarbP AccDCF AccNPV Felling Thinning
2017 P 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Estab -1725 1 -1725 0 1.336629 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 62.834964 0 1 0 2017 0 -1725 -1725 62.83496 62.83496 0 0 0
2018 P 1 1 0.002747 4.166667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.966184 -24.15459 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 63.7774885 352.5705 0.9829464 346.55789 2018 346.5579 -1749.15 -1402.6 61.62076 124.4557 1 -53.9937 0
2019 P 1 2 0.005493 8.333333 0 0 0 0 Estab -325 0.933511 -303.391 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 64.7341508 357.85905 0.9497066 339.86112 2019 686.419 -2052.55 -1366.13 60.43002 184.8857 2 -103.537 0
2020 P 1 3 0.00824 12.5 0 0 0 0 Estab -325 0.901943 -293.1314 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 65.7051631 363.22694 0.917591 333.29375 2020 1019.713 -2345.68 -1325.96 59.26229 244.148 3 -148.703 0
2021 P 1 4 0.010987 16.66667 0 0 0 0 Estab -175 0.871442 -152.5024 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 66.8002491 368.98029 0.8865613 327.12365 2021 1346.836 -2498.18 -1151.34 58.21256 302.3606 4 -189.567 0
2022 P 1 5 0.013733 20.83333 0 0 0 0 Estab -75 0.841973 -63.14799 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 67.8953352 375.07913 0.856581 321.28565 2022 1668.122 -2561.33 -893.205 57.16605 359.5266 5 -226.199 0
2023 P 1 6 0.01648 25 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.813501 -20.33752 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 68.9904212 381.17798 0.8276145 315.46841 2023 1983.59 -2581.66 -598.074 56.12375 415.6504 6 -258.671 0
2024 P 1 7 0.019227 29.16667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.785991 -19.64977 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 70.0855073 387.27683 0.7996275 309.67721 2024 2293.268 -2601.31 -308.047 55.08658 470.737 7 -287.054 0
2025 P 1 8 0.021973 33.33333 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.759412 -18.98529 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 71.1805933 393.37568 0.772587 303.91692 2025 2597.185 -2620.3 -23.1153 54.05537 524.7923 8 -311.416 0
2026 P 1 9 0.02472 37.5 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.733731 -18.34327 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 72.2756794 399.47452 0.7464608 298.19209 2026 2895.377 -2638.64 256.7335 53.0309 577.8232 9 -331.824 0
2027 P 1 10 0.027466 41.66667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.708919 -17.72297 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 73.3707654 405.57337 0.7212182 292.5069 2027 3187.884 -2656.37 531.5174 52.01392 629.8372 10 -348.347 0
2028 P 1 11 0.030213 45.83333 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.684946 -17.12364 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 74.4658515 411.67222 0.6968292 286.86521 2028 3474.749 -2673.49 801.259 51.00507 680.8422 11 -361.049 0
2029 P 1 12 0.03296 50 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.661783 -16.54458 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.569286 75.5609375 417.77107 0.6732649 281.2706 2029 3756.019 -2690.03 1065.985 50.00497 730.8472 12 -369.997 0
2030 P 1 13 0.04087 62 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.639404 -15.9851 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 16.03954 76.2299233 1217.3281 0.6504975 791.8689 2030 4547.888 -2706.02 1841.869 48.74173 779.5889 13 -375.362 0
2031 P 1 14 0.050234 75 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.617782 -15.44454 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17.37617 83.7740829 1390.1287 0.6285 873.69585 2031 5421.584 -2721.46 2700.12 51.7541 831.343 14 -338.72 0
2032 P 1 15 0.059905 88 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.596891 -14.92227 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17.37617 90.8921422 1517.5153 0.6072464 921.50565 2032 6343.09 -2736.39 3606.703 54.25267 885.5957 15 -262.988 0
2033 P 1 16 0.069848 101 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.576706 -14.41765 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17.37617 98.0102016 1641.1999 0.5867115 962.91081 2033 7306.001 -2750.8 4555.197 56.52306 942.1188 16 -149.397 0
2034 P 1 17 0.080169 114 0 0.078799 42 -7.21457 Estab -25 0.557204 -13.93009 -4.01998 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 5.233152 26.33685 24.56841 2.878234 10.15986 18.5319 17.87279 18.5319 16.71706 105.128261 1697.9393 0.566871 962.51251 2034 8268.513 -2768.75 5499.759 58.57786 1000.697 17 2.744806 1.011244
2035 P 1 18 0.102771 89 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.538361 -13.45903 0 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 0 0 23.0943 2.783252 9.550272 0 0 2.178678 20.54401 112.24632 2232.8728 0.5477014 1222.9476 2035 9491.461 -2782.21 6709.248 60.42906 1061.126 18 276.1965 0
2036 P 1 19 0.121247 105 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.520156 -13.00389 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 21.70864 2.691405 8.977256 0 0 2.050522 19.33554 119.36438 2239.1587 0.5291801 1184.9183 2036 10676.38 -2795.22 7881.162 62.08806 1123.214 19 568.8787 0
2037 P 1 20 0.140878 122 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.502566 -12.56415 0 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 0 0 20.40612 2.602588 8.438621 0 0 1.92997 20.79272 126.482439 2555.9117 0.5112851 1306.7997 2037 11983.18 -2807.78 9175.398 63.56576 1059.648 20 938.5908 0
2038 P 1 21 0.159353 138 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.485571 -12.13927 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 19.18176 2.516703 7.932303 0 0 1.81657 19.56949 133.600498 2544.8451 0.4939953 1257.1416 2038 13240.32 -2819.92 10420.4 64.87251 997.9393 21 1335.13 0
2039 P 1 22 0.178984 155 0 0.157303 42 397.4161 Estab -25 0.469151 -11.72877 186.448 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 9.583919 21.98608 42.59926 7.704807 16.8766 16.87861 16.83474 18.58851 20.96892 140.718558 2876.0874 0.4772902 1372.7282 2039 14613.05 -2645.2 11967.85 66.0182 938.2036 22 1801.547 488.161
2040 P 1 23 0.215 129 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.453286 -11.33214 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 40.0433 7.450549 15.864 0 0 3.82281 17.56325 147.836617 2533.9832 0.4611499 1168.5461 2040 15781.59 -2656.53 13125.06 67.01221 880.5257 23 1911.219 0
2041 P 1 24 0.243333 146 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.437957 -10.94893 0 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 0 0 37.6407 7.204681 14.91216 0 0 3.600306 19.12238 154.954676 2895.0453 0.4455555 1289.9033 2041 17071.5 -2667.48 14404.02 67.86351 824.9637 24 2484.597 0
2042 P 1 25 0.27 162 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.423147 -10.57867 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 35.38226 6.966926 14.01743 0 0 3.390926 17.99513 162.072736 2852.4752 0.4304884 1227.9574 2042 18299.46 -2678.06 15621.39 68.58059 771.5531 25 3057.01 0
2043 P 1 26 0.298333 179 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.408838 -10.22094 0 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 0 0 33.25933 6.737018 13.17639 0 0 3.19389 19.5288 169.190795 3234.5892 0.4159308 1345.3653 2043 19644.82 -2688.28 16956.54 69.17157 720.3095 26 3692.804 0
2044 P 1 27 0.325 195 0 0.3 42 870.5553 Estab -25 0.395012 -9.875306 343.88 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 15.73524 15.83476 55.83217 15.16908 20.76031 14.54111 15.36709 17.54957 19.20358 176.308854 3317.4144 0.4018655 1333.1544 2044 20977.98 -2354.28 18623.7 69.64416 671.2321 27 4311.579 928.6477
2045 P 1 28 0.367391 169 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.381654 -9.541359 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 52.48224 14.6685 19.51469 0 0 5.096129 16.28993 183.426914 2930.0353 0.3882759 1137.662 2045 22115.64 -2363.82 19751.82 70.00568 624.3059 28 4082.465 0
2046 P 1 29 0.4 184 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.368748 -9.218704 0 1.336629 20.04943 0.751667 0 0 49.33331 14.18444 18.34381 0 0 4.803877 15.24555 190.544973 2850.7043 0.3751458 1069.4296 2046 23185.07 -2373.04 20812.03 70.26311 579.5042 29 4693.208 0
2047 P 1 30 0.432609 199 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.356278 -8.90696 0 1.336629 20.04943 0.751667 0 0 46.37331 13.71635 17.24318 0 0 4.528714 15.52072 197.663032 3012.6333 0.3624597 1091.958 2047 24277.02 -2381.94 21895.08 70.42307 536.7904 30 5311.005 0
2048 P 1 31 0.467391 215 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.345901 -8.647534 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 43.59091 13.26371 16.20859 0 0 4.269629 17.11643 204.781092 3444.2033 0.3510515 1209.0929 2048 25486.12 -2390.59 23095.53 70.83406 495.9227 31 5974.3 0
2049 P 1 32 0.5 230 0 0.461538 42 1159.757 Estab -25 0.335827 -8.395664 389.4771 1.336629 20.04943 0.751667 20.6492 10.9208 65.54386 24.18307 22.77521 12.6738 14.19466 16.69948 17.54462 211.899151 3655.2478 0.3408267 1245.8062 2049 26731.92 -2009.51 24722.41 71.16137 456.8685 32 6597.639 1204.786
2050 P 1 33 0.547425 202 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.326045 -8.15113 0 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 0 0 61.61123 23.38503 21.4087 0 0 6.097186 12.61562 219.01721 2718.1377 0.3308998 899.43109 2050 27631.35 -2017.66 25613.69 71.40951 419.5895 33 6018.719 0
2051 P 1 34 0.585366 216 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.316549 -7.913719 0 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 0 0 57.91456 22.61333 20.12418 0 0 5.752902 12.9599 226.76253 2888.6304 0.3212619 928.00689 2051 28559.36 -2025.58 26533.79 71.7814 383.9439 34 6596.974 0
2052 P 1 35 0.623306 230 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.307329 -7.683222 0 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 0 0 54.43968 21.86709 18.91673 0 0 5.428564 13.28424 234.265814 3062.2051 0.3119048 955.11634 2924762 2052 29514.48 -2033.26 27481.22 71.99665 349.9351 35 7171.527 0
2053 P 1 36 0.661247 244 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.298378 -7.459439 0 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 0 0 51.1733 21.14547 17.78172 0 0 5.122998 13.5898 241.805596 3234.8584 0.3028202 979.58032 3168804 2053 30494.06 -2040.72 28453.34 72.14936 317.5163 36 7741.625 0
2054 P 1 37 0.699187 258 0 0.646154 42 1323.852 Estab -25 0.289687 -7.242174 383.5027 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 24.42757 7.142433 72.67131 33.88283 23.61163 11.23802 13.29318 16.07313 15.93285 249.348012 3912.7396 0.2940001 1150.346 4501004 2054 31644.4 -1664.46 29979.95 72.23287 286.6429 37 8306.809 1352.271
2055 P 1 38 0.75 228 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.281249 -7.031237 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 68.31103 32.7647 22.19494 0 0 6.89511 9.144434 256.650013 2313.5329 0.285437 660.36796 1527783 2055 32304.77 -1671.49 30633.28 72.18268 257.2956 38 7460.494 0
2056 P 1 39 0.792763 241 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.273058 -6.826443 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 64.21237 31.68346 20.86324 0 0 6.511593 10.86458 263.995346 2828.2966 0.2771233 783.78698 2216782 2056 33088.56 -1678.31 31410.24 72.08597 229.417 39 7973.736 0
2057 P 1 40 0.832237 253 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.265105 -6.627615 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 60.35963 30.63791 19.61144 0 0 6.150091 9.889454 271.073309 2645.7683 0.2690518 711.84868 1883387 2057 33800.41 -1684.94 32115.47 71.86278 202.9802 40 8442.756 0
2058 P 1 41 0.875 266 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.257383 -6.434578 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 56.73805 29.62686 18.43476 0 0 5.809315 11.56686 277.982933 3175.4277 0.2612153 829.47038 2633923 2058 34629.88 -1691.38 32938.5 71.54811 177.9428 41 8945.924 0
2059 P 1 42 0.914474 278 0 0.880952 37 1245.572 Estab -25 0.249887 -6.247163 311.2517 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 24.14507 3.666601 74.97736 41.92896 22.95809 8.902458 11.08423 14.39051 12.73326 284.776616 3582.8815 0.2536071 908.64422 3255565 2059 35538.52 -1386.37 34152.15 71.16183 154.2551 42 9406.066 1251.887
2060 P 1 43 0.965649 253 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.242608 -6.065207 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 70.47872 40.5453 21.58061 0 0 7.259783 8.779761 291.399473 2529.3443 0.2462205 622.7764 1575216 2060 36161.3 -1392.44 34768.86 70.69592 131.8702 43 8615.716 0
2061 P 1 44 1.01145 265 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.235542 -5.88855 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 66.25 39.20731 20.28577 0 0 6.861555 9.17799 296.655968 2698.5834 0.239049 645.09372 1740839 2061 36806.39 -1398.33 35408.07 69.87494 110.8242 44 9067.062 0
2062 P 1 45 1.053435 276 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.228682 -5.717039 0 1.336629 14.70292 0.751667 0 0 62.275 37.91347 19.06863 0 0 6.485987 8.216928 301.880719 2459.0666 0.2320864 570.71598 1403429 2062 37377.11 -1404.04 35973.07 69.03455 91.0455 45 9477.504 0
2063 P 1 46 1.099237 288 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.222021 -5.550523 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 58.5385 36.66232 17.92451 0 0 6.131762 9.907783 306.576193 3014.2294 0.2253266 679.18616 2047223 2063 38056.29 -1409.59 36646.7 68.06633 72.49526 46 9922.009 0
2064 P 1 47 1.145038 300 0 1.1 33 1136.953 Estab -25 0.215554 -5.388857 245.0751 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 22.82906 1.975942 74.32993 48.00845 21.64985 7.448208 9.577132 13.24584 12.37083 311.019815 3820.088 0.2187637 835.69666 3192435 2064 38891.99 -1169.91 37722.08 67.04166 55.11536 47 10363.46 1139.981
2065 P 1 48 1.188841 277 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.209276 -5.2319 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 69.87014 46.42417 20.35086 0 0 7.343066 6.023221 314.927986 1885.1111 0.212392 400.38243 754765.4 2065 39292.37 -1175.14 38117.23 65.90687 38.86292 48 9589.549 0
2066 P 1 49 1.236052 288 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.203181 -5.079515 0 1.336629 14.70292 0.751667 0 0 65.67793 44.89217 19.12981 0 0 6.945257 7.757658 318.782331 2458.0541 0.2062058 506.86498 1245902 2066 39799.24 -1180.22 38619.02 64.77039 23.66972 49 9989.559 0
2067 P 1 50 1.283262 299 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.197263 -4.931568 0 1.336629 14.70292 0.751667 0 0 61.73725 43.41073 17.98202 0 0 6.569906 8.13301 322.000352 2605.746 0.2001998 521.6698 1359339 2067 40320.91 -1185.15 39135.76 63.51866 9.496787 50 10387.55 0
2068 P 1 51 1.32618 309 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.191517 -4.78793 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 58.03302 41.97818 16.9031 0 0 6.21571 7.150577 324.943181 2313.0097 0.1943687 449.57675 1039875 2068 40770.49 -1189.94 39580.55 62.23221 -3.71187 51 10747.81 0
2069 P 1 52 1.373391 320 0 1.304348 30 1042.869 Estab -25 0.185939 -4.648476 193.91 1.336629 14.70292 0.751667 21.4273 1.122698 72.0999 52.37791 20.13877 6.515125 8.545766 12.39657 10.85211 327.439378 3539.8634 0.1887075 667.99879 2364624 2069 41438.48 -1000.68 40437.81 60.88376 -16.0041 52 11142.6 1044.619
2070 P 1 53 1.428571 300 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.180523 -4.513083 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 67.7739 50.64944 18.93044 0 0 7.262791 6.103496 329.592224 2005.0948 0.1832112 367.35577 736583.2 2070 41805.84 -1005.19 40800.65 59.49909 -27.4309 53 10457.03 0
2071 P 1 54 1.47619 310 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.175265 -4.381634 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 63.70747 48.97801 17.79462 0 0 6.873692 6.492595 331.730607 2146.8505 0.1778749 381.87087 819819.7 2071 42187.71 -1009.57 41178.14 58.14089 -38.0523 54 10813.43 0
2072 P 1 55 1.52381 320 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.170161 -4.254014 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 59.88502 47.36174 16.72694 0 0 6.5064 6.859887 333.502866 2281.7134 0.1726941 394.03844 899082.8 2072 42581.75 -1013.83 41567.92 56.74903 -47.9138 55 11168.91 0
2073 P 1 56 1.571429 330 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.165204 -4.130111 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 56.29192 45.7988 15.72332 0 0 6.159655 7.206632 335.007871 2408.8554 0.1676642 403.87876 972885.6 2073 42985.63 -1017.96 41967.67 55.34478 -57.0622 56 11523.6 0
2074 P 1 57 1.619048 340 0 1.555556 28 977.6102 Estab -25 0.160393 -4.009816 156.8015 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 20.45867 0.587996 69.29334 55.53971 18.66828 5.906038 7.86633 11.73831 9.494304 335.910239 3184.9503 0.1627808 518.4486 1651233 2074 43504.08 -865.164 42638.91 53.87753 -65.5338 57 11877.6 978.1553
2075 P 1 58 1.671875 321 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.155721 -3.893025 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 65.13574 53.7069 17.54819 0 0 7.110508 4.91915 336.857849 1654.7237 0.1580396 261.51182 432729.8 2075 43765.59 -869.057 42896.53 52.45584 -73.3795 58 11217.95 0
2076 P 1 59 1.71875 330 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.151185 -3.779636 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 61.2276 51.93457 16.4953 0 0 6.733363 5.296295 336.938891 1784.3132 0.1534365 273.77872 488507 2076 44039.37 -872.837 43166.53 50.94026 -80.627 59 11535.52 0
2077 P 1 60 1.765625 339 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.146782 -3.66955 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 57.55394 50.22073 15.50558 0 0 6.377214 5.652444 337.060094 1904.8708 0.1489674 283.76374 540533.2 2077 44323.13 -876.506 43446.62 49.47435 -87.3226 60 11852.71 0
2078 P 1 61 1.8125 348 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.142507 -3.56267 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 54.1007 48.56344 14.57524 0 0 6.040855 5.988803 336.640303 2017.3295 0.1446286 291.76353 588583.2 2078 44614.89 -880.069 43734.83 47.97353 -93.4985 61 12169.58 0
2079 P 1 62 1.859375 357 0 1.8 27 944.1494 Estab -25 0.138356 -3.458903 130.6288 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 19.97185 0.323154 66.64864 57.94537 17.40876 5.602449 7.527212 11.3256 8.231271 336.018826 2768.4197 0.1404161 388.73072 1076170 2079 45003.63 -752.899 44250.73 46.49025 -99.1915 62 12486.17 944.3323
2080 P 1 63 1.904494 339 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.134326 -3.358158 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 62.64972 56.03317 16.36424 0 0 6.955641 5.074017 334.790735 1701.8496 0.1363263 232.00689 394840.8 2080 45235.63 -756.257 44479.37 44.9712 -104.43 63 11858.03 0
2081 P 1 64 1.949438 347 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.130414 -3.260347 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 58.89074 54.18407 15.38238 0 0 6.589932 4.103098 334.621349 1373.3315 0.1323556 181.76819 249628 2081 45417.4 -759.518 44657.88 43.63927 -109.265 64 12139.06 0
2082 P 1 65 2 356 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.126615 -3.165386 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 55.35729 52.396 14.45944 0 0 6.244462 5.785197 333.864177 1933.6601 0.1285006 248.47654 480469.2 2082 45665.88 -762.683 44903.19 42.27236 -113.721 65 12455.04 0
2083 P 1 66 2.044944 364 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.122928 -3.07319 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 52.03585 50.66693 13.59187 0 0 5.918072 4.774958 332.853361 1591.774 0.1247579 198.58637 316104.6 2083 45864.46 -765.756 45098.71 40.91687 -117.823 66 12735.78 0
2084 P 1 67 2.089888 372 0 2 26 909.6376 Estab -25 0.119347 -2.98368 108.5627 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 19.34689 0.196446 64.12272 59.63571 16.32756 5.35135 7.22105 10.96102 6.953058 331.6318 2310.1019 0.1211242 279.80917 646387.7 2084 46144.27 -660.177 45484.1 39.57932 -121.598 67 13016.41 909.7488
2085 P 1 68 2.145455 354 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.115871 -2.896776 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 60.27535 57.66773 15.3479 0 0 6.794995 3.898035 330.557227 1290.6179 0.1175963 151.77186 195879.5 2085 46296.04 -663.074 45632.97 38.30202 -125.072 68 12387.27 0
2086 P 1 69 2.193939 362 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.112496 -2.812404 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 56.65883 55.7647 14.42703 0 0 6.440431 4.252599 328.840451 1402.0769 0.1141711 160.07673 224439.9 2086 46456.12 -665.886 45790.23 36.99329 -128.265 69 12667.71 0
2087 P 1 70 2.242424 370 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.10922 -2.73049 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 53.2593 53.92446 13.56141 0 0 6.105387 4.587643 326.863113 1504.0669 0.1108458 166.71945 250757.2 2087 46622.84 -668.617 45954.22 35.69985 -131.195 70 12948.08 0
2088 P 1 71 2.290909 378 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.106038 -2.650961 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 50.06374 52.14495 12.74772 0 0 5.78875 4.90428 324.834261 1598.0531 0.1076173 171.97809 274830.1 2088 46794.82 -671.268 46123.55 34.44492 -133.885 71 13228.39 0
2089 P 1 72 2.339394 386 0 2.363636 26 909.9177 Estab -25 0.10295 -2.573748 93.67597 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 19.45822 0.085117 62.26893 61.12619 15.51513 5.309044 7.194488 10.79852 7.089002 322.496095 2294.463 0.1044828 239.73185 550055.9 2089 47034.55 -580.166 46454.38 33.20095 -136.351 72 13508.65 909.9092
2090 P 1 73 2.383117 367 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.099951 -2.498785 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 58.5328 59.10903 14.58422 0 0 6.684208 2.672193 320.135584 858.6179 0.1014396 87.097841 74783.77 2090 47121.65 -582.664 46538.98 31.998 -138.611 73 12843.93 0
2091 P 1 74 2.435065 375 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.09704 -2.426005 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 55.02083 57.15843 13.70917 0 0 6.337619 4.355411 318.140753 1389.9778 0.098485 136.89201 190276.8 2091 47258.54 -585.09 46673.45 30.87244 -140.686 74 13124.11 0
2092 P 1 75 2.480519 382 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.094214 -2.355344 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 51.71958 55.2722 12.88662 0 0 6.010028 3.346373 316.0913 1061.1885 0.0956165 101.46717 107675.8 2092 47360.01 -587.446 46772.56 29.78015 -142.59 75 13369.25 0
2093 P 1 76 2.532468 390 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.091916 -2.297897 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 48.6164 53.44822 12.11342 0 0 5.700354 4.992675 313.529731 1571.7466 0.0930577 146.26318 229888.7 2093 47506.27 -589.744 46916.53 28.81836 -144.342 76 13649.38 0
2094 P 1 77 2.577922 397 0 2.6 26 909.9686 Estab -25 0.089674 -2.241851 81.60055 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 19.49391 0.049422 60.90843 62.40608 14.91282 5.29548 7.185972 10.70306 5.839311 310.905423 1823.1357 0.090788 165.5189 301763.4 2094 47671.79 -510.385 47161.4 27.88014 -145.955 77 13894.48 909.9657
2095 P 1 78 2.631944 379 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.087487 -2.187171 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 57.25393 60.34668 14.01805 0 0 6.608676 4.084354 308.17188 1264.2654 0.0885737 111.98065 141573.3 2095 47783.77 -512.572 47271.2 26.96099 -147.438 78 13264.6 0
2096 P 1 79 2.673611 385 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.085353 -2.133826 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 53.81869 58.35524 13.17697 0 0 6.267759 1.752013 305.366494 537.4637 0.0864134 46.444041 24961.99 2096 47830.21 -514.706 47315.51 26.06395 -148.803 79 13474.66 0
2097 P 1 80 2.722222 392 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.083271 -2.081781 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 50.58957 56.42951 12.38635 0 0 5.945462 3.410939 302.679571 1037.0039 0.0843057 87.425353 90660.43 2097 47917.64 -516.788 47400.85 25.20451 -150.058 80 13719.71 0
2098 P 1 81 2.770833 399 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.08124 -2.031006 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 47.5542 54.56734 11.64317 0 0 5.640729 3.715672 299.506081 1118.7621 0.0822495 92.017599 102945.8 2098 48009.66 -518.819 47490.84 24.33195 -151.21 81 13964.76 0
2099 P 1 82 2.839161 406 0 2.777778 25 874.9854 Estab -25 0.079259 -1.981469 69.35027 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 18.76009 0.031572 59.32499 63.08467 14.33244 5.085747 6.905783 10.43831 5.823872 296.630077 1735.9104 0.0802434 139.29534 241804.2 2099 48148.95 -451.45 47697.5 23.51054 -152.269 82 14209.82 874.9886
2100 P 1 83 2.895522 388 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.077326 -1.933141 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 55.76549 61.00288 13.4725 0 0 6.50124 2.85516 293.453071 842.39103 0.0782862 65.947622 55553.69 2100 48214.9 -453.383 47761.52 22.69144 -153.241 83 13579.86 0
2101 P 1 84 2.940299 394 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.07544 -1.885991 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 52.41957 58.98978 12.66415 0 0 6.167374 1.852398 293.453071 543.59181 0.0763768 41.51781 22568.74 2101 48256.42 -455.269 47801.15 22.13799 -154.144 84 13789.88 0
2102 P 1 85 2.992537 401 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.0736 -1.839991 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 49.27439 57.04312 11.9043 0 0 5.851686 3.504715 293.453071 1028.4695 0.074514 76.635339 78817.11 2102 48333.05 -457.109 47875.94 21.59804 -154.981 85 14034.9 0
2103 P 1 86 3.037313 407 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.071805 -1.795113 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 46.31793 55.16069 11.19004 0 0 5.553144 2.466628 293.453071 723.83953 0.0726966 52.620637 38088.9 2103 48385.67 -458.904 47926.77 21.07126 -155.758 86 14244.92 0
2104 P 1 87 3.08209 413 0 3 24 839.9943 Estab -25 0.070053 -1.75133 58.84429 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 18.02182 0.01818 57.57794 63.25239 13.76893 4.877709 6.626658 10.14849 4.49794 293.453071 1319.9344 0.0709235 93.614319 123564.8 2104 48479.29 -401.811 48077.48 20.55733 -156.48 87 14454.93 839.9959
2105 P 1 88 3.134921 395 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.068345 -1.708615 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 54.12326 61.16506 12.94279 0 0 6.368141 1.651631 293.453071 484.67619 0.0691936 33.536502 16254.34 2105 48512.82 -403.52 48109.3 20.05593 -157.149 88 13824.95 0
2106 P 1 89 3.18254 401 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.066678 -1.666941 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 50.87587 59.14662 12.16623 0 0 6.042411 1.977362 293.453071 580.26284 0.067506 39.171208 22729.6 2106 48552 -405.187 48146.81 19.56676 -157.77 89 14034.95 0
2107 P 1 90 3.230159 407 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.065051 -1.626284 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 47.82332 57.19478 11.43625 0 0 5.734364 2.285408 293.453071 670.66005 0.0658595 44.169327 29622.6 2107 48596.17 -406.813 48189.35 19.08952 -158.347 90 14244.96 0
2108 P 1 91 3.277778 413 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.063465 -1.586619 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 44.95392 55.30735 10.75008 0 0 5.443002 2.57677 293.453071 756.16118 0.0642532 48.585744 36738.65 2108 48644.75 -408.4 48236.35 18.62392 -158.882 91 14454.97 0
2109 P 1 92 3.325397 419 0 3.285714 23 804.9983 Estab -25 0.061917 -1.547921 49.84294 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 17.2793 0.009031 55.71081 62.98582 13.21851 4.671282 6.348545 9.838664 4.529653 293.453071 1329.2406 0.062686 83.324784 110758.7 2109 48728.08 -360.105 48367.97 18.16968 -159.378 92 14664.97 804.9986
2110 P 1 93 3.369748 401 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.060407 -1.510166 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 52.36816 60.90729 12.4254 0 0 6.214291 0.468852 293.453071 137.58614 0.0611571 8.4143665 1157.7 2110 48736.49 -361.615 48374.88 17.72652 -159.839 93 14034.98 0
2111 P 1 94 3.411765 406 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.058933 -1.473333 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 49.22607 58.89735 11.67987 0 0 5.897554 0.785589 293.453071 230.53361 0.0596654 13.754891 3170.965 2111 48750.25 -363.088 48387.16 17.29417 -160.266 94 14209.98 0
2112 P 1 95 3.462185 412 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.057496 -1.437398 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 46.27251 56.95374 10.97908 0 0 5.597969 2.421803 293.453071 710.6855 0.0582102 41.369138 29400.45 2112 48791.61 -364.525 48427.09 16.87236 -160.663 95 14419.99 0
2113 P 1 96 3.504202 417 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.056094 -1.40234 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 43.49616 55.07427 10.32034 0 0 5.314569 1.368575 293.453071 401.61249 0.0567904 22.807746 9159.876 2113 48814.42 -365.928 48448.49 16.46084 -161.031 96 14594.99 0
2114 P 1 97 3.554622 423 0 3.285714 23 804.9983 Estab -25 0.054725 -1.368136 44.0539 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 17.2793 0.009031 54.34051 62.76043 12.81455 4.671282 6.348545 9.717722 4.650595 293.453071 1364.7313 0.0554053 75.613345 103191.9 2114 48890.04 -323.242 48566.79 16.05935 -161.373 97 14804.99 804.9994
2115 P 1 98 3.584071 405 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.053391 -1.334767 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 51.08008 60.68934 12.04568 0 0 6.100398 0.582745 293.453071 171.00842 0.0540539 9.2436801 1580.747 2115 48899.28 -324.577 48574.7 15.66766 -161.69 98 14174.99 0
2116 P 1 99 3.628319 410 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.052088 -1.302212 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 48.01528 58.68659 11.32294 0 0 5.790294 0.89285 293.453071 262.00949 0.0527356 13.817217 3620.242 2116 48913.1 -325.879 48587.22 15.28552 -161.985 99 14349.99 0
2117 P 1 100 3.672566 415 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.050818 -1.270451 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 45.13436 56.74993 10.64356 0 0 5.49695 1.186193 293.453071 348.09202 0.0514493 17.9091 6234.015 2117 48931.01 -327.149 48603.86 14.9127 -162.258 100 14524.99 0
2118 P 1 101 3.725664 421 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.049579 -1.239464 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 42.4263 54.87718 10.00495 0 0 5.219423 2.800349 293.453071 821.77104 0.0501945 41.248358 33896.71 2118 48972.25 -328.389 48643.86 14.54898 -162.511 101 14734.99 0
2119 P 1 102 3.769912 426 14910 3.666667 22 0 Estab -25 0.048369 -1.209233 721.1864 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 320.1551 0.054923 289.0745 229.1515 67.05179 86.47757 117.5593 91.43439 32.80803 293.453071 9627.6186 0.0489702 471.4665 4539100 2119 49443.72 391.5883 49835.31 14.19413 -162.746 102 14910 769.9998
2120 P 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Estab -1725 0.04719 -81.40204 0 1.336629 0 0.751667 0 0 271.7301 221.5895 63.02868 0 0 28.92958 -28.9296 293.453071 -8489.474 0.0477758 -405.5915 3443259 2120 49038.13 310.1862 49348.31 13.84793 -162.965 103 0 0
2121 P 2 1 0.002747 4.166667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.046039 -1.150966 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 255.4263 214.2771 59.24696 0 0 27.39798 -21.8287 293.453071 -6405.697 0.0466106 -298.5731 1912569 2121 48739.56 309.0353 49048.59 13.51017 -163.167 104 -53.9937 0
2122 P 2 2 0.005493 8.333333 0 0 0 0 Estab -325 0.044916 -14.59761 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 240.1007 207.2059 55.69214 0 0 25.95154 -20.3823 293.453071 -5981.234 0.0454737 -271.9889 1626829 2122 48467.57 294.4377 48762 13.18066 -163.355 105 -103.537 0
2123 P 2 3 0.00824 12.5 0 0 0 0 Estab -325 0.04382 -14.24157 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 225.6947 200.3681 52.35061 0 0 24.58537 -19.0161 293.453071 -5580.327 0.0443646 -247.5689 1381516 2123 48220 280.1961 48500.19 12.85918 -163.53 106 -148.703 0
2124 P 2 4 0.010987 16.66667 0 0 0 0 Estab -175 0.042751 -7.481501 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 212.153 193.756 49.20958 0 0 23.29486 -17.7256 293.453071 -5201.625 0.0432825 -225.1395 1171091 2124 47994.86 272.7146 48267.57 12.54554 -163.692 107 -189.567 0
2125 P 2 5 0.013733 20.83333 0 0 0 0 Estab -75 0.041709 -3.128154 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 199.4238 187.362 46.257 0 0 22.0757 -16.5064 293.453071 -4843.858 0.0422269 -204.5409 990767.1 2125 47790.32 269.5864 48059.9 12.23955 -163.842 108 -226.199 0
2126 P 2 6 0.01648 25 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.040691 -1.017286 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 187.4584 181.1791 43.48158 0 0 20.9238 -15.3545 293.453071 -4505.828 0.0411969 -185.6263 836400.1 2126 47604.69 268.5692 47873.26 11.94103 -163.981 109 -258.671 0
2127 P 2 7 0.019227 29.16667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.039699 -0.992474 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 176.2109 175.2002 40.87269 0 0 19.83531 -14.266 293.453071 -4186.408 0.0401921 -168.2606 704407.6 2127 47436.43 267.5767 47704.01 11.64978 -164.111 110 -287.054 0
2128 P 2 8 0.021973 33.33333 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.038731 -0.968267 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 165.6382 169.4186 38.42033 0 0 18.80662 -13.2373 293.453071 -3884.536 0.0392118 -152.3198 591691.7 2128 47284.11 266.6084 47550.72 11.36564 -164.231 111 -311.416 0
2129 P 2 9 0.02472 37.5 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.037786 -0.944651 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 155.6999 163.8278 36.11511 0 0 17.83433 -12.265 293.453071 -3599.213 0.0382554 -137.6895 495574 2129 47146.42 265.6638 47412.08 11.08843 -164.342 112 -331.824 0
2130 P 2 10 0.027466 41.66667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.036864 -0.921611 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 146.3579 158.4214 33.9482 0 0 16.91522 -11.3459 293.453071 -3329.498 0.0373224 -124.2648 413739.6 2130 47022.16 264.7421 47286.9 10.81798 -164.446 113 -348.347 0
2131 P 2 11 0.030213 45.83333 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.035965 -0.899132 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 137.5764 153.1935 31.91131 0 0 16.04628 -10.477 293.453071 -3074.505 0.0364121 -111.9491 344188.1 2131 46910.21 263.843 47174.05 10.55413 -164.542 114 -361.049 0
2132 P 2 12 0.03296 50 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.035088 -0.877202 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 129.3219 148.1382 29.99663 0 0 15.22465 -9.65537 293.453071 -2833.397 0.035524 -100.6536 285191.5 2132 46809.55 262.9658 47072.52 10.29671 -164.631 115 -369.997 0
2133 P 2 13 0.04087 62 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.034232 -0.855807 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 121.5626 143.2496 28.19683 0 0 14.44767 1.591876 293.453071 467.14086 0.0346575 16.189957 7562.99 2133 46825.74 262.11 47087.85 10.04557 -164.714 116 -375.362 0
2134 P 2 14 0.050234 75 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.033397 -0.834934 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 114.2688 138.5224 26.50502 0 0 13.7128 3.663374 293.453071 1075.0282 0.0338122 36.349115 39076.33 2134 46862.09 261.2751 47123.37 9.800556 -164.79 117 -338.72 0
2135 P 2 15 0.059905 88 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.032583 -0.81457 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 107.4127 133.9511 24.91472 0 0 13.01767 4.358506 293.453071 1279.017 0.0329876 42.191643 53963.83 2135 46904.28 260.4605 47164.74 9.561518 -164.862 118 -262.988 0
2136 P 2 16 0.069848 101 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.031788 -0.794702 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 100.9679 129.5307 23.41984 0 0 12.36003 5.016143 293.453071 1472.0025 0.032183 47.373426 69733.8 2136 46951.66 259.6658 47211.32 9.32831 -164.928 119 -149.397 0
2137 P 2 17 0.080169 114 0 0.078799 42 -7.21457 Estab -25 0.031013 -0.775319 -0.22374 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 5.233152 26.33685 119.4782 128.1345 32.17451 18.5319 17.87279 30.26968 4.979284 293.453071 1461.1863 0.031398 45.878369 67036.84 2137 46997.54 258.6667 47256.2 9.10079 -164.989 120 2.744806 1.011244
2138 P 2 18 0.102771 89 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.030405 -0.760117 0 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 0 0 112.3095 123.906 30.24404 0 0 13.3276 9.395086 293.453071 2757.0168 0.0307072 84.660295 233409.9 2138 47082.2 257.9066 47340.1 8.922343 -165.046 121 276.1965 0
2139 P 2 19 0.121247 105 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.029808 -0.745212 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 105.571 119.8171 28.4294 0 0 12.64211 8.743946 293.453071 2565.9377 0.0301051 77.247831 198213.1 2139 47159.44 257.1614 47416.61 8.747396 -165.099 122 568.8787 0
2140 P 2 20 0.140878 122 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.029224 -0.7306 0 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 0 0 99.23672 115.8632 26.72363 0 0 11.99399 10.7287 293.453071 3148.3702 0.0295148 92.923555 292557.7 2140 47252.37 256.4308 47508.8 8.575878 -165.149 123 938.5908 0
2141 P 2 21 0.159353 138 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.028651 -0.716275 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 93.28251 112.0397 25.12022 0 0 11.3811 10.00495 293.453071 2935.9846 0.0289361 84.955914 249429.3 2141 47337.32 255.7145 47593.04 8.407724 -165.196 124 1335.13 0
2142 P 2 22 0.178984 155 0 0.157303 42 397.4161 Estab -25 0.028089 -0.70223 11.16311 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 9.583919 21.98608 112.254 113.6135 33.03324 16.87861 16.83474 27.68008 11.87734 293.453071 3485.4429 0.0283687 98.877541 344632 2142 47436.2 266.1754 47702.38 8.242866 -165.239 125 1801.547 488.161
2143 P 2 23 0.215 129 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.027538 -0.688461 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 105.5187 109.8643 31.05124 0 0 12.46648 8.919581 293.453071 2617.4784 0.0278125 72.798532 190548.6 2143 47509 265.487 47774.49 8.081241 -165.279 126 1911.219 0
2144 P 2 24 0.243333 146 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.026998 -0.674962 0 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 0 0 99.18761 106.2387 29.18817 0 0 11.81972 10.90297 293.453071 3199.5097 0.0272671 87.241427 279129.8 2144 47596.24 264.812 47861.05 7.922786 -165.317 127 2484.597 0
2145 P 2 25 0.27 162 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.026469 -0.661727 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 93.23635 102.7329 27.43688 0 0 11.20843 10.17763 293.453071 2986.658 0.0267325 79.840759 238457 2145 47676.08 264.1503 47940.23 7.767437 -165.352 128 3057.01 0
2146 P 2 26 0.298333 179 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.02595 -0.648752 0 1.336629 22.72269 0.751667 0 0 87.64217 99.34268 25.79067 0 0 10.63058 12.09211 293.453071 3548.4667 0.0262083 92.99931 330005 2146 47769.08 263.5015 48032.58 7.615134 -165.385 129 3692.804 0
2147 P 2 27 0.325 195 0 0.3 42 870.5553 Estab -25 0.025441 -0.636032 22.14803 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 15.73524 15.83476 106.952 104.7188 32.61773 14.54111 15.36709 24.62539 12.12776 293.453071 3558.929 0.0256944 91.444618 325444.9 2147 47860.53 285.0135 48145.54 7.465818 -165.415 130 4311.579 928.6477
2148 P 2 28 0.367391 169 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.024942 -0.62356 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 100.5349 101.263 30.66067 0 0 11.82991 9.556154 293.453071 2804.2826 0.0251906 70.641583 198099 2148 47931.17 284.3899 48215.56 7.319429 -165.444 131 4082.465 0
2149 P 2 29 0.4 184 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.024453 -0.611334 0 1.336629 20.04943 0.751667 0 0 94.50283 97.92136 28.82103 0 0 11.21342 8.836015 293.453071 2592.9557 0.0246967 64.037382 166046.1 2149 47995.2 283.7786 48278.98 7.175911 -165.47 132 4693.208 0
2150 P 2 30 0.432609 199 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.023974 -0.599347 0 1.336629 20.04943 0.751667 0 0 88.83266 94.68995 27.09177 0 0 10.63084 9.418594 293.453071 2763.9154 0.0242124 66.921098 184964.3 2150 48062.13 283.1793 48345.31 7.035207 -165.495 133 5311.005 0
2151 P 2 31 0.467391 215 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.023504 -0.587595 0 1.336629 21.38606 0.751667 0 0 83.5027 91.56519 25.46626 0 0 10.08023 11.30583 293.453071 3317.7291 0.0237377 78.755168 261288.3 2151 48140.88 282.5917 48423.47 6.897262 -165.518 134 5974.3 0
2152 P 2 32 0.5 230 0 0.461538 42 1159.757 Estab -25 0.023043 -0.576073 26.7242 1.336629 20.04943 0.751667 20.6492 10.9208 103.0609 99.9006 31.47742 12.6738 14.19466 22.23359 12.0105 293.453071 3524.5187 0.0232722 82.023403 289093 2152 48222.9 308.7398 48531.64 6.762021 -165.539 135 6597.639 1204.786
2153 P 2 33 0.547425 202 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.022591 -0.564778 0 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 0 0 96.87728 96.60388 29.58878 0 0 11.36902 7.34378 293.453071 2155.0549 0.0228159 49.169538 105963.1 2153 48272.07 308.175 48580.25 6.629433 -165.559 136 6018.719 0
2154 P 2 34 0.585366 216 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.022148 -0.553704 0 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 0 0 91.06465 93.41595 27.81345 0 0 10.77589 7.93691 293.453071 2329.1107 0.0223685 52.098803 121343.9 2154 48324.17 307.6213 48631.79 6.499444 -165.578 137 6596.974 0
2155 P 2 35 0.623306 230 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.021714 -0.542847 0 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 0 0 85.60077 90.33322 26.14464 0 0 10.21541 8.49739 293.453071 2493.5851 0.0219299 54.684172 136359.6 2155 48378.86 307.0785 48685.94 6.372004 -165.596 138 7171.527 0
2156 P 2 36 0.661247 244 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.021288 -0.532203 0 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 0 0 80.46472 87.35223 24.57596 0 0 9.685721 9.027081 293.453071 2649.0246 0.0214999 56.953873 150872.2 2156 48435.81 306.5463 48742.36 6.247062 -165.612 139 7741.625 0
2157 P 2 37 0.699187 258 0 0.646154 42 1323.852 Estab -25 0.020871 -0.521768 27.62972 1.336629 18.7128 0.751667 24.42757 7.142433 100.2052 97.90477 29.99822 11.23802 13.29318 20.42309 11.58289 293.453071 3399.0353 0.0210784 71.646137 243527.7 2157 48507.46 333.6542 48841.11 6.124571 -165.627 140 8306.809 1352.271
2158 P 2 38 0.75 228 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.020461 -0.511537 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 94.19293 94.67391 28.19833 0 0 11.04307 4.996479 293.453071 1466.2322 0.0206651 30.299795 44426.53 2158 48537.76 333.1427 48870.9 6.004481 -165.641 141 7460.494 0
2159 P 2 39 0.792763 241 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.02006 -0.501507 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 88.54135 91.54967 26.50643 0 0 10.46771 6.908459 293.453071 2027.3084 0.0202599 41.073015 83267.67 2159 48578.83 332.6412 48911.47 5.886746 -165.654 142 7973.736 0
2160 P 2 40 0.832237 253 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.019667 -0.491673 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 83.22887 88.52853 24.91604 0 0 9.924006 6.115538 293.453071 1794.6235 0.0198626 35.64593 63971.03 2160 48614.48 332.1495 48946.63 5.77132 -165.667 143 8442.756 0
2161 P 2 41 0.875 266 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.019281 -0.482033 0 1.336629 17.37617 0.751667 0 0 78.23514 85.60709 23.42108 0 0 9.410136 7.966037 293.453071 2337.658 0.0194732 45.521586 106413.9 2161 48660 331.6675 48991.66 5.658157 -165.678 144 8945.924 0
2162 P 2 42 0.914474 278 0 0.880952 37 1245.572 Estab -25 0.018903 -0.472581 23.54534 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 24.14507 3.666601 95.18463 96.06184 27.64524 8.902458 11.08423 17.82687 9.296907 293.453071 2728.2058 0.0190913 52.085084 142098.8 2162 48712.08 354.7402 49066.82 5.547213 -165.689 145 9406.066 1251.887
2163 P 2 43 0.965649 253 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.018533 -0.463315 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 89.47355 92.8918 25.98652 0 0 10.53983 5.499712 293.453071 1613.9073 0.018717 30.207492 48752.09 2163 48742.29 354.2769 49096.57 5.438444 -165.699 146 8615.716 0
2164 P 2 44 1.01145 265 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.018169 -0.45423 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 84.10514 89.82637 24.42733 0 0 9.993034 6.046511 293.453071 1774.3671 0.01835 32.559624 57772.73 2164 48774.85 353.8227 49128.67 5.331808 -165.708 147 9067.062 0
2165 P 2 45 1.053435 276 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.017813 -0.445324 0 1.336629 14.70292 0.751667 0 0 79.05883 86.8621 22.96169 0 0 9.476218 5.226697 293.453071 1533.7904 0.0179902 27.59318 42322.15 2165 48802.44 353.3774 49155.82 5.227262 -165.717 148 9477.504 0
2166 P 2 46 1.099237 288 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.017464 -0.436592 0 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 0 0 74.3153 83.99565 21.58399 0 0 8.98768 7.051864 293.453071 2069.3911 0.0176374 36.498763 75530.22 2166 48838.94 352.9408 49191.88 5.124767 -165.725 149 9922.009 0
2167 P 2 47 1.145038 300 0 1.1 33 1136.953 Estab -25 0.017121 -0.428031 19.46605 1.336629 16.03954 0.751667 22.82906 1.975942 89.16013 93.77978 25.08976 7.448208 9.577132 15.97402 9.642654 293.453071 2829.6666 0.0172916 48.929485 138454.1 2167 48887.87 371.9788 49259.85 5.024281 -165.733 150 10363.46 1139.981
2168 P 2 48 1.188841 277 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.016786 -0.419638 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 83.81052 90.68504 23.58437 0 0 9.949726 3.416561 293.453071 1002.6003 0.0169526 16.99664 17040.84 2168 48904.87 371.5592 49276.43 4.925766 -165.74 151 9589.549 0
2169 P 2 49 1.236052 288 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.016456 -0.41141 0 1.336629 14.70292 0.751667 0 0 78.78189 87.69244 22.16931 0 0 9.4363 5.266616 293.453071 1545.5045 0.0166202 25.686523 39698.64 2169 48930.55 371.1478 49301.7 4.829182 -165.746 152 9989.559 0
2170 P 2 50 1.283262 299 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.016134 -0.403343 0 1.336629 14.70292 0.751667 0 0 74.05498 84.79859 20.83915 0 0 8.950922 5.751993 293.453071 1687.9401 0.0162943 27.503749 46424.68 2170 48958.06 370.7444 49328.8 4.734493 -165.752 153 10387.55 0
2171 P 2 51 1.32618 309 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.015817 -0.395435 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 69.61168 82.00023 19.5888 0 0 8.492001 4.874286 293.453071 1430.3742 0.0159748 22.849903 32683.91 2171 48980.91 370.349 49351.26 4.641659 -165.758 154 10747.81 0
2172 P 2 52 1.373391 320 0 1.304348 30 1042.869 Estab -25 0.015507 -0.387681 16.17202 1.336629 14.70292 0.751667 21.4273 1.122698 82.98384 91.07924 22.66333 6.515125 8.545766 14.57316 8.675519 293.453071 2545.8578 0.0156615 39.872059 101508.6 2172 49020.78 386.1333 49406.91 4.550646 -165.763 155 11142.6 1044.619
2173 P 2 53 1.428571 300 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.015203 -0.380079 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 78.00481 88.07363 21.30353 0 0 9.344445 4.021842 293.453071 1180.2218 0.0153545 18.12166 21387.58 2173 49038.9 385.7532 49424.65 4.461418 -165.768 156 10457.03 0
2174 P 2 54 1.47619 310 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.014905 -0.372627 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 73.32452 85.1672 20.02532 0 0 8.86493 4.501357 293.453071 1320.937 0.0150534 19.884574 26266.27 2174 49058.79 385.3806 49444.17 4.373939 -165.773 157 10813.43 0
2175 P 2 55 1.52381 320 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.014613 -0.36532 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 68.92505 82.35668 18.8238 0 0 8.411508 4.954779 293.453071 1453.9951 0.0147582 21.458381 31200.38 2175 49080.24 385.0153 49465.26 4.288176 -165.777 158 11168.91 0
2176 P 2 56 1.571429 330 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.014326 -0.358157 0 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 0 0 64.78954 79.63891 17.69438 0 0 7.982701 5.383586 293.453071 1579.8297 0.0144688 22.85831 36112.24 2176 49103.1 384.6571 49487.76 4.204094 -165.781 159 11523.6 0
2177 P 2 57 1.619048 340 0 1.555556 28 977.6102 Estab -25 0.014045 -0.351135 13.73091 1.336629 13.36629 0.751667 20.45867 0.587996 77.28111 88.26309 20.52107 5.906038 7.86633 13.48316 7.74946 293.453071 2274.1028 0.0141851 32.25847 73359.08 2177 49135.36 398.0369 49533.4 4.121661 -165.785 160 11877.6 978.1553
2178 P 2 58 1.671875 321 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.01377 -0.34425 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 72.64424 85.35041 19.28981 0 0 8.780813 3.248845 293.453071 953.38364 0.013907 13.258708 12640.63 2178 49148.62 397.6926 49546.31 4.040844 -165.789 161 11217.95 0
2179 P 2 59 1.71875 330 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.0135 -0.3375 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 68.28559 82.53385 18.13242 0 0 8.332607 3.697052 293.453071 1084.9112 0.0136343 14.792021 16048.03 2179 49163.41 397.3551 49560.77 3.961612 -165.792 162 11535.52 0
2180 P 2 60 1.765625 339 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.013235 -0.330882 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 64.18845 79.81023 17.04447 0 0 7.908697 4.120961 293.453071 1209.3086 0.013367 16.164799 19548.23 2180 49179.58 397.0243 49576.6 3.883933 -165.795 163 11852.71 0
2181 P 2 61 1.8125 348 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.012976 -0.324394 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 60.33715 77.17649 16.02181 0 0 7.507713 4.521945 293.453071 1326.9787 0.0131049 17.389893 23076.02 2181 49196.97 396.6999 49593.67 3.807777 -165.798 164 12169.58 0
2182 P 2 62 1.859375 357 0 1.8 27 944.1494 Estab -25 0.012721 -0.318033 12.01084 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 19.97185 0.323154 72.51089 85.61418 18.76853 5.602449 7.527212 12.73081 6.82606 293.453071 2003.1283 0.0128479 25.736031 51552.57 2182 49222.7 408.3927 49631.1 3.733115 -165.8 165 12486.17 944.3323
2183 P 2 63 1.904494 339 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.012472 -0.311797 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 68.16024 82.78892 17.64242 0 0 8.302034 3.727625 293.453071 1093.8829 0.012596 13.778549 15072.12 2183 49236.48 408.0809 49644.56 3.659917 -165.803 166 11858.03 0
2184 P 2 64 1.949438 347 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.012227 -0.305684 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 64.07062 80.05688 16.58388 0 0 7.880194 2.812836 293.453071 825.4353 0.012349 10.193316 8413.923 2184 49246.67 407.7752 49654.45 3.588154 -165.805 167 12139.06 0
2185 P 2 65 2 356 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.011988 -0.29969 0 1.336629 12.02966 0.751667 0 0 60.22639 77.41501 15.58884 0 0 7.481147 4.548511 293.453071 1334.7746 0.0121069 16.159958 21569.9 2185 49262.83 407.4755 49670.31 3.517798 -165.807 168 12455.04 0
2186 P 2 66 2.044944 364 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.011753 -0.293814 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 56.6128 74.86031 14.65351 0 0 7.103609 3.589421 293.453071 1053.3265 0.0118695 12.50245 13169.16 2186 49275.34 407.1817 49682.52 3.448821 -165.809 169 12735.78 0
2187 P 2 67 2.089888 372 0 2 26 909.6376 Estab -25 0.011522 -0.288053 10.48094 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 19.34689 0.196446 68.42505 83.03071 17.3255 5.35135 7.22105 12.09772 5.816361 293.453071 1706.829 0.0116368 19.861954 33900.96 2187 49295.2 417.3746 49712.57 3.381197 -165.811 170 13016.41 909.7488
2188 P 2 68 2.145455 354 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.011296 -0.282405 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 64.31954 80.29069 16.28597 0 0 7.885046 2.807983 293.453071 824.01138 0.0114086 9.4008038 7746.369 2188 49304.6 417.0922 49721.69 3.314899 -165.813 171 12387.27 0
2189 P 2 69 2.193939 362 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.011075 -0.276867 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 60.46037 77.6411 15.30881 0 0 7.485924 3.207106 293.453071 941.13508 0.0111849 10.52649 9906.849 2189 49315.13 416.8153 49731.94 3.249901 -165.815 172 12667.71 0
2190 P 2 70 2.242424 370 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.010858 -0.271438 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 56.83275 75.07895 14.39028 0 0 7.108307 3.584722 293.453071 1051.9478 0.0109656 11.535213 12134.44 2190 49326.66 416.5439 49743.21 3.186178 -165.816 173 12948.08 0
2191 P 2 71 2.290909 378 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.010645 -0.266116 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 53.42278 72.60134 13.52686 0 0 6.750987 3.942043 293.453071 1156.8045 0.0107506 12.436301 14386.37 2191 49339.1 416.2778 49755.38 3.123704 -165.818 174 13228.39 0
2192 P 2 72 2.339394 386 0 2.363636 26 909.9177 Estab -25 0.010436 -0.260898 9.495834 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 19.45822 0.085117 65.42643 80.90751 16.24752 5.309044 7.194488 11.72187 6.16565 293.453071 1809.329 0.0105398 19.069909 34503.74 2192 49358.17 425.5127 49783.68 3.062455 -165.819 175 13508.65 909.9092
2193 P 2 73 2.383117 367 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.010231 -0.255783 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 61.50084 78.23757 15.27267 0 0 7.570385 1.786016 293.453071 524.1118 0.0103331 5.4157032 2838.434 2193 49363.58 425.2569 49788.84 3.002407 -165.82 176 12843.93 0
2194 P 2 74 2.435065 375 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.010031 -0.250767 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 57.81079 75.65573 14.35631 0 0 7.188251 3.504779 293.453071 1028.4881 0.0101305 10.419096 10715.92 2194 49374 425.0061 49799.01 2.943536 -165.821 177 13124.11 0
2195 P 2 75 2.480519 382 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.009834 -0.24585 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 54.34215 73.15909 13.49493 0 0 6.826665 2.529736 293.453071 742.35868 0.0099319 7.3730023 5473.412 2195 49381.38 424.7603 49806.14 2.885819 -165.822 178 13369.25 0
2196 P 2 76 2.532468 390 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.009641 -0.24103 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 51.08162 70.74484 12.68524 0 0 6.484475 4.208555 293.453071 1235.0134 0.0097371 12.02547 14851.62 2196 49393.4 424.5193 49817.92 2.829235 -165.823 179 13649.38 0
2197 P 2 77 2.577922 397 0 2.6 26 909.9686 Estab -25 0.009452 -0.236304 8.601151 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 19.49391 0.049422 63.22573 79.13191 15.45032 5.29548 7.185972 11.45607 5.086301 293.453071 1492.5907 0.0095462 14.24856 21267.27 2197 49407.65 432.8841 49840.53 2.77376 -165.824 180 13894.48 909.9657
2198 P 2 78 2.631944 379 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.009267 -0.23167 0 1.336629 10.69303 0.751667 0 0 59.43219 76.52056 14.5233 0 0 7.331916 3.361113 293.453071 986.32897 0.009359 9.2310659 9104.868 2198 49416.88 432.6524 49849.53 2.719372 -165.825 181 13264.6 0
2199 P 2 79 2.673611 385 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.009085 -0.227128 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 55.86626 73.99538 13.65191 0 0 6.962508 1.057264 293.453071 310.25742 0.0091755 2.846768 883.2309 2199 49419.73 432.4253 49852.15 2.666051 -165.826 182 13474.66 0
2200 P 2 80 2.722222 392 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.008907 -0.222674 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 52.51428 71.55353 12.83279 0 0 6.612937 2.743464 293.453071 805.0778 0.0089956 7.2421509 5830.495 2200 49426.97 432.2026 49859.17 2.613776 -165.827 183 13719.71 0
2201 P 2 81 2.770833 399 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.008732 -0.218308 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 49.36343 69.19226 12.06282 0 0 6.282091 3.07431 293.453071 902.16568 0.0088192 7.9563861 7177.978 2201 49434.93 431.9843 49866.91 2.562525 -165.827 184 13964.76 0
2202 P 2 82 2.839161 406 0 2.777778 25 874.9854 Estab -25 0.008561 -0.214027 7.490832 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 18.76009 0.031572 61.02567 77.22697 14.72692 5.085747 6.905783 11.05467 5.207517 293.453071 1528.1617 0.0086463 13.212917 20191.47 2202 49448.14 439.2611 49887.4 2.512279 -165.828 185 14209.82 874.9886
2203 P 2 83 2.895522 388 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.008393 -0.209831 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 57.36413 74.67848 13.84331 0 0 7.093646 2.262755 293.453071 664.01248 0.0084767 5.6286655 3737.504 2203 49453.77 439.0513 49892.82 2.463019 -165.829 186 13579.86 0
2204 P 2 84 2.940299 394 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.008229 -0.205716 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 53.92228 72.21409 13.01271 0 0 6.736836 1.282936 293.453071 376.48153 0.0083105 3.1287632 1177.922 2204 49456.9 438.8456 49895.74 2.414725 -165.829 187 13789.88 0
2205 P 2 85 2.992537 401 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.008067 -0.201683 0 1.336629 9.356401 0.751667 0 0 50.68695 69.83103 12.23195 0 0 6.399165 2.957236 293.453071 867.8101 0.0081476 7.0705559 6135.9 2205 49463.97 438.6439 49902.61 2.367377 -165.83 188 14034.9 0
2206 P 2 86 3.037313 407 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.007909 -0.197728 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 47.64573 67.5266 11.49803 0 0 6.079557 1.940215 293.453071 569.362 0.0079878 4.5479655 2589.439 2206 49468.51 438.4462 49906.96 2.320958 -165.83 189 14244.92 0
2207 P 2 87 3.08209 413 0 3 24 839.9943 Estab -25 0.007754 -0.193851 6.513355 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 18.02182 0.01818 58.82607 75.21023 14.05844 4.877709 6.626658 10.65471 3.991718 293.453071 1171.3819 0.0078312 9.17333 10745.47 2207 49477.69 444.7657 49922.45 2.275449 -165.831 190 14454.93 839.9959
2208 P 2 88 3.134921 395 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.007602 -0.19005 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 55.29651 72.72829 13.21493 0 0 6.855008 1.164764 293.453071 341.80358 0.0076777 2.6242484 896.9775 2208 49480.31 444.5756 49924.89 2.230832 -165.831 191 13824.95 0
2209 P 2 89 3.18254 401 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.007453 -0.186324 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 51.97872 70.32825 12.42204 0 0 6.51072 1.509052 293.453071 442.836 0.0075271 3.3332746 1476.094 2209 49483.65 444.3893 49928.03 2.18709 -165.832 192 14034.95 0
2210 P 2 90 3.230159 407 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.007307 -0.18267 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 48.86 68.00742 11.67671 0 0 6.184878 1.834894 293.453071 538.45542 0.0073795 3.9735415 2139.575 2210 49487.62 444.2066 49931.83 2.144206 -165.832 193 14244.96 0
2211 P 2 91 3.277778 413 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.007164 -0.179089 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 45.9284 65.76318 10.97611 0 0 5.876448 2.143325 293.453071 628.96521 0.0072348 4.5504511 2862.075 2211 49492.17 444.0276 49936.2 2.102163 -165.832 194 14454.97 0
2212 P 2 92 3.325397 419 0 3.285714 23 804.9983 Estab -25 0.007023 -0.175577 5.653567 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 17.2793 0.009031 56.62682 73.09661 13.43098 4.671282 6.348545 10.25574 4.11258 293.453071 1206.8492 0.007093 8.5601359 10330.79 2212 49500.73 449.5055 49950.24 2.060944 -165.833 195 14664.97 804.9986
2213 P 2 93 3.369748 401 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.006885 -0.172134 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 53.22921 70.68442 12.62512 0 0 6.615656 0.067487 293.453071 19.80441 0.0069539 0.1377176 2.727415 2213 49500.87 449.3334 49950.2 2.020534 -165.833 196 14034.98 0
2214 P 2 94 3.411765 406 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.00675 -0.168759 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 50.03546 68.35183 11.86761 0 0 6.283846 0.399298 293.453071 117.17516 0.0068175 0.7988456 93.60486 2214 49501.67 449.1646 49950.83 1.980915 -165.833 197 14209.98 0
2215 P 2 95 3.462185 412 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.006618 -0.16545 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 47.03333 66.09622 11.15556 0 0 5.969795 2.049977 293.453071 601.57216 0.0066839 4.0208222 2418.815 2215 49505.69 448.9992 49954.69 1.942074 -165.833 198 14419.99 0
2216 P 2 96 3.504202 417 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.006488 -0.162206 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 44.21133 63.91505 10.48622 0 0 5.672509 1.010635 293.453071 296.57391 0.0065528 1.9433898 576.3587 2216 49507.63 448.837 49956.47 1.903994 -165.834 199 14594.99 0
2217 P 2 97 3.554622 423 0 3.285714 23 804.9983 Estab -25 0.006361 -0.159025 5.12061 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 17.2793 0.009031 55.01278 71.30947 12.97049 4.671282 6.348545 10.06233 4.305985 293.453071 1263.6046 0.0064243 8.1177935 10257.68 2217 49515.75 453.7986 49969.55 1.866661 -165.834 200 14804.99 804.9994
2218 P 2 98 3.584071 405 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.006267 -0.156675 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 51.71201 68.95626 12.19226 0 0 6.432208 0.250935 293.453071 73.637733 0.0063138 0.464937 34.23691 2218 49516.21 453.6419 49969.86 1.839075 -165.834 201 14174.99 0
2219 P 2 99 3.628319 410 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.006174 -0.15436 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 48.60929 66.6807 11.46072 0 0 6.109812 0.573331 293.453071 168.24576 0.0062205 1.0465784 176.0824 2219 49517.26 453.4875 49970.75 1.811896 -165.834 202 14349.99 0
2220 P 2 100 3.672566 415 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.006083 -0.152079 0 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 0 0 45.69273 64.48024 10.77308 0 0 5.804664 0.87848 293.453071 257.79259 0.0061286 1.5799088 407.2888 2220 49518.84 453.3355 49972.18 1.785119 -165.835 203 14524.99 0
2221 P 2 101 3.725664 421 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.005993 -0.149831 0 1.336629 8.019772 0.751667 0 0 42.95117 62.35239 10.12669 0 0 5.515796 2.503976 293.453071 734.79939 0.006038 4.4367438 3260.117 2221 49523.28 453.1856 49976.46 1.758738 -165.835 204 14734.99 0
2222 P 2 102 3.769912 426 14910 3.666667 22 0 Estab -25 0.005905 -0.147617 88.03878 1.336629 6.683144 0.751667 320.1551 0.054923 289.5679 236.3801 67.16623 86.47757 117.5593 91.71987 32.52256 293.453071 9543.844 0.0059488 56.774439 541846.4 2222 49580.05 541.0768 50121.13 1.732747 -165.835 205 14910 769.9998
2223 P 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Estab -1725 0.005817 -10.03505 0 1.336629 0 0.751667 0 0 272.1938 228.5795 63.13625 0 0 29.20459 -29.2046 293.453071 -8570.177 0.0058609 -50.22885 430470.2 2223 49529.82 531.0417 50060.86 1.70714 -165.835 206 0 0
2224 P 3 1 0.002747 4.166667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.005731 -0.143286 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 255.8622 221.0364 59.34808 0 0 27.66293 -22.0936 293.453071 -6483.448 0.0057743 -37.43721 242722.2 2224 49492.38 530.8985 50023.28 1.681911 -165.835 207 -53.9937 0
2225 P 3 2 0.005493 8.333333 0 0 0 0 Estab -325 0.005647 -1.835193 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 240.5105 213.7422 55.78719 0 0 26.20682 -20.6375 293.453071 -6056.147 0.0056889 -34.45306 208652.8 2225 49457.93 529.0633 49986.99 1.657055 -165.835 208 -103.537 0
2226 P 3 3 0.00824 12.5 0 0 0 0 Estab -325 0.005563 -1.808072 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 226.0799 206.6887 52.43996 0 0 24.83135 -19.2621 293.453071 -5652.513 0.0056049 -31.68158 179080.6 2226 49426.25 527.2552 49953.51 1.632567 -165.835 209 -148.703 0
2227 P 3 4 0.010987 16.66667 0 0 0 0 Estab -175 0.005481 -0.959189 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 212.5151 199.868 49.29356 0 0 23.53192 -17.9626 293.453071 -5271.189 0.005522 -29.1077 153432.2 2227 49397.14 526.296 49923.44 1.60844 -165.836 210 -189.567 0
2228 P 3 5 0.013733 20.83333 0 0 0 0 Estab -75 0.0054 -0.405006 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 199.7642 193.2723 46.33595 0 0 22.30416 -16.7349 293.453071 -4910.9 0.0054404 -26.71741 131206.5 2228 49370.42 525.891 49896.32 1.58467 -165.836 211 -226.199 0
2229 P 3 6 0.01648 25 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.00532 -0.133007 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 187.7783 186.8943 43.55579 0 0 21.14399 -15.5747 293.453071 -4570.446 0.00536 -24.49773 111965.5 2229 49345.93 525.758 49871.69 1.561251 -165.836 212 -258.671 0
2230 P 3 7 0.019227 29.16667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.005242 -0.131041 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 176.5116 180.7268 40.94245 0 0 20.04756 -14.4783 293.453071 -4248.694 0.0052808 -22.43658 95326.15 2230 49323.49 525.6269 49849.12 1.538179 -165.836 213 -287.054 0
2231 P 3 8 0.021973 33.33333 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.005164 -0.129105 0 1.336629 5.569286 0.751667 0 0 165.9209 174.7628 38.4859 0 0 19.01123 -13.4419 293.453071 -3944.579 0.0052028 -20.52276 80953.67 2231 49302.97 525.4978 49828.47 1.515447 -165.836 214 -311.416 0
2232 P
THIS SHEETTAKES THECURRENTCROP ANDREGIMEWITHOUTINFECTION ANDREPEATS IT
It constructs the physical and cash flows from the present yield model and cash flows.
It compiles the regime, from the sequence of crops, starting with the defined present age of the present crop up to the defined rotatio
This is then followed by as many replanted crops of the existing one as it take to get a completion beyond any changes in discount orca
In the final format, there will be an infinite series of the replacement crop afterthe time when all prices stabilise, but this won t much
Rotation is set at 102 Size at this age 3.769912 All it needs is forthe amount of decay to be reduce
Replacement rotation 102 Rows are filled in foreach yearup to the time DCF
Yearstarts from current. Infection time is defined forthe facsimiles of this sheet which look at infection and treatments. £595
The rows start from the current crop age. Maincrop before thinning Thinning
Year Crop Rotation Age MeanVol TotalVol FellRev MeanVol TotalVol ThinRev CostNameAmount£ DiscFact
(P)resent/(R)eplace Fallow Yrat RotEnd Do via a table in Masterand lookup a/c"R" and rotation? T
R Crop age
-£3,366 Decay rates and assortments need to go conditional when replacement switches con to blf orvice versa
?Should be here a "story so far" forthe CO2already fixed, which is what decays? Oronly the biomass? Redundant!
2017 P 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Estab -1725 1
2018 P 1 1 0.002747 4.166667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.966184
2019 P 1 2 0.005493 8.333333 0 0 0 0 Estab -325 0.933511
2020 P 1 3 0.00824 12.5 0 0 0 0 Estab -325 0.901943
2021 P 1 4 0.010987 16.66667 0 0 0 0 Estab -175 0.871442
2022 P 1 5 0.013733 20.83333 0 0 0 0 Estab -75 0.841973
2023 P 1 6 0.01648 25 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.813501
2024 P 1 7 0.019227 29.16667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.785991
2025 P 1 8 0.021973 33.33333 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.759412
2026 P 1 9 0.02472 37.5 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.733731
2027 P 1 10 0.027466 41.66667 0 0 0 0 Estab -25 0.708919
Go to Home Go to Master

23.  Origins in early 1990s (cost–benefit analysis of
farm woodlands – MAFF funding);
 based on yield models (Forestry Commission);
 used social cost of carbon and single discount
rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;

24.  Origins in early 1990s (cost–benefit analysis of
farm woodlands – MAFF funding);
 based on yield models (Forestry Commission);
 used social cost of carbon and single discount
rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;

25. -10,000
-8,000
-6,000
-4,000
-2,000
0
2,000
4,000
0 25 50 75 100 125 150
NPVofmanyrotations(£/ha)
Rotation (years)
Thinned Japanese larch
YC12, zero carbon values
Optimal rotation = 50 years

26. -10,000
-8,000
-6,000
-4,000
-2,000
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
0 25 50 75 100 125 150
NPVofmanyrotations(£/ha)
Rotation (years)
Thinned Japanese larch
YC12, NEA carbon values
Optimal rotation = 54 years

27. -10,000
-5,000
0
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
0 25 50 75 100 125 150
NPVofmanyrotations(£/ha)
Rotation (years)
Thinned Japanese larch
YC12, Stern carbon values
Optimal rotation = 71 years

28. -10,000
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
0 25 50 75 100 125 150
NPVofmanyrotations(£/ha)
Rotation (years)
Thinned Japanese larch
YC12, DECC carbon values
Optimal rotation = 102 years

29. No
carbon
price
NEA
carbon
prices
Stern
carbon
price
DECC
carbon
prices
Optimal
rotation
50 years 54 years 71 years
102
years
DCF (no
carbon)
£1 488 £1 472 £1 146 £595
NPV
(with
carbon)
£1 488 £4 658 £20 925 £50 336
NB Treasury discount schedule throughout

30.  Origins in early 1990s (cost–benefit analysis of
farm woodlands – MAFF funding);
 based on yield models (Forestry Commission);
 used social cost of carbon and single discount
rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;

31. Replace by Scots pine YC10, various infection ages
-20000
-15000
-10000
-5000
0
5000
10000
0 20 40 60 80 100
Costofloss(£NPV500)
Current age (years)
vs business as
usual
Infection

32. Replace by Douglas fir YC12, various infection ages
-30000
-25000
-20000
-15000
-10000
-5000
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Costofloss(£NPV500)
Current age (years)
vs business as
usual
Infection

33. 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
2000 2100 2200 2300 2400 2500 2600
Discountedprice(£)
Date AD
DECC untraded values, Treasury discount rates

34. Replace by Scots pine YC10, various infection ages;
Stern CO2 price
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
18000
20000
0 20 40 60 80 100
Costofloss(£NPV500)
Current age (years)
vs business as
usual
Infection

35. 0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
0 20 40 60 80 100
Costofloss(£NPV500)
Current age (years)
vs business as
usual
Infection
NO replacement, various infection ages; DECC CO2
prices

38. -80000
-60000
-40000
-20000
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
140000
0 100 200
NPV500(£)
Rotation (years)
Business as
usual
Modified
baseline
Infected
Replanted
Underplanted

39. Infection age is set manually Reduced growth rate
Working start date 2017 (for death, rate=0)
User-set rotation 102 102 30
150 150 0
N/A 147 147
102 147 147
N/A 30 30
N/A 0% 0%
N/A N/A 0.5
N/A N/A 0
Age of first treatment
Treatment interval (years)
Cost per application
Treat replacement crop? Y/N Note: only treat replacement crop if it is susceptible, e.g. same spe
NPV500 (set rotn) £84,800 £83,303 £46,601
NPV500 (optimal rotn) £85,766 £85,657 £59,060
Baseline (business as
usual)
Modified baseline:
changing silviculture
Post-infection growth rate
Growth rate recovery
Optimal rotation
Replacement rotn
Age of extra thinning
% extra thinning
Replacement rotation used

40. rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;
 no account yet of costs of rescheduling other
felling.
 possible extension to other environmental
objectives.

42. rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;
 no account yet of costs of rescheduling other
felling.
 possible extension to other environmental
objectives.

43. rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;
 no account yet of costs of rescheduling other
felling;
 possible extension to other environmental
objectives.

44. rate;
 reconstructed (massively) to use any discount
schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;
 no account yet of costs of rescheduling other
felling;
 possible extension to other environmental
objectives.

47. schedule or carbon price (Defra, FERA);
 numerous spin-off papers and reports – no
substantive criticisms so far;
 revised for improved user friendliness;
 application to rapid evaluation of scenarios with-
and without change in nursery practice;
 done per hectare, not on landscape scale;
 no account yet of impacts on markets;
 no account yet of costs of rescheduling other
felling;
 possible extension to other environmental
objectives;
 AND what else?