SlideShare a Scribd company logo
TOPIC                                    CONTENT AREA

Use of social forms                              LT, LLP, PE, LC

Learning in a group                              LA, LC

Function of the Common European Framework LA, LC, LLP, LT, PE
of Reference

Which are the different learner types            LLP, LC

The four skills                                  LA, LLP, LT

Speaking activities                              LT, LA, LLP

How do we draw up a lesson plan?                 LLP, PE

How do I present a grammar structure?            LT, PE

Micro-peer teaching                              LT, PE, SA

Different types of exercises in language         LA, LT, LLP
classrooms

Using pictures in a language classroom           LT, PE, LLP

Feedback rules                                   PE, SA

Pronunciation training                           LA, LT, PE

Learning strategies and learner autonomy         LLP

Difficult classroom situations                   LT, PE, SA

Progress tests                                   LT, LLP, PE, SA

The use of media e-learning / blended learning   LT, PE


Intercultural learning                           LC, LA
TOPIC ONE
                                SUBJECT: TEACHING ENGLISH LESSONS WITH SONGS.




                                          LESSON PLAN
       Performance Objective: By the end of the lesson students will be able to understand the
                             use of songs, video and movies for ESL.

COURSE: ENGLISH 3             Level: LOW INTERMEDIATE                      GROUP: 3 B



Segment                           Description of Activities          Didactic            Materials
                                                                     resources

1.- Ice breakers.

Using ice breakers in class

                                  Differences between child and
                                  adult foreign language learning.
2. Introduction                                                      teaching            Printed material
                                  The brain process

3. pronunciation                  Understanding differences          Ppt presentation.   Projector
                                  between child and adult
                                  pronunciation process                                  computer
4. sounds                                Understanding how sounds are      Team work        Video
                                         perceived by adults
                                                                                            Printed material

                                          Main concerns for adult          Pair work        Board
                                         learners
5. words and intonation                                                                     printed material

                                                                                            notepads

                                         Understanding motivations,        video
                                         acquisitions and learning.
6. adult learners and their                                                                 Projector
characteristics and learning abilities
                                                                                            worksheets

                                                                           Songs. Lyrics.
                                                                           Videos.
7. listening                             Listening levels.                                  workbook

                                         Listening skills

                                         Listening principles

                                         music and songs                   Team work        Notebooks.

8. Listening materials.                  types of rhythms



9. activities                            Some activities to apply in the
                                         classroom.
TOPIC TWO: READING SKILLS



                                                      SUBJECT: PRESENT CONTINUOUS



                                                                 LESSON PLAN



Performance Objective: By the end of the lesson students will be able to apply effective reading techniques.



COURSE: ENGLISH 3                       Level: LOW INTERMEDIATE                         GROUP: 3 B



Segment                                       Description of Activities          Didactic               Materials           Time
                                                                                 resources


1.- Ice breakers.

Using ice breakers in class                                                                                                 45 min



2. Warm up and /or preview                                                       Short readings(2)      Printed materials

a) uses previously learned content to         Reading short stories                                                         1 hr
   begin a new lesson,
3. Preview.                                     Read titles. Look at pictures (if                      Printed materials   1hr.
                                                there is any). Read a few of the
 Focusing students attention to English         first sentences the first           Ppt presentation   Projector
language structures.                            paragraph. Read first line of
                                                                                    Short readings     speakers
                                                other paragraphs. Read the
                                                sentences of the last paragraph.




4. Predicting                                   Predicting the contents of the      Team work          Notebooks,
                                                reading by using pictures. With                        notepads
Focusing student attention on the lesson-       the above information, students                                            45 min
asking questions, using visual. Stating the     will predict what happens next.
objective, relating the objective to previous
learning.




3. Scanning                                      Students practice scanning         Pair work          board               1 hr
                                                important data (numbers, dates,
Practice is guided through materials and        etc) and then write them board                         notepads
may be whole group, small group, pairs, or      and in their workbook.
individuals. Instructor models each activity,
monitors progress and provides feed back.



4. Looking for unknown words and new            Students will underline the         Team work          Notepads            90 min
meanings for sentences                          unknown words, find their
                                                meaning and try to understand                          Notebooks
Opportunity to see the application of new
knowledge. Practice is guided by material     their application on the context.               dictionary




5.- Skimming for patterns or                  Students will look for patterns     Team work   Workbook     45 min
organization.                                 like cause-effect, comparison
                                              and contrasts, etc.                             notepad
Opportunity to see the application of
patterns, that will help students with
reading and writing skills.



6. Application/Closure                        Conduct a classroom discussion      Team work
                                              on what the short reading was
An activity that requires students to apply   about.                                                       30 min
new knowledge to their own lives or a new
situation.
TIME TABLE FOR TWO WEEK COURSE

SUBJECT: TEACHING ENGLISH WITH SONGS.

         WEEK 1           9-10:30                    10:35 -12:00                 1:00- 2:30
Monday            Using ice breakers.           Differences between        The brain process:
                  Introduction                  child and adult foreign    lateralization
                                                language learning.
Tuesday           Understanding                 Examples of strong         Adults as a specific ESL
                  differences between           accents, broken English    learning group.
                  child and adult               and other issues.          Pronunciation techniques
                  pronunciation process
Wednesday         sounds                        Understanding how          Learning sounds
                                                sounds are perceived by    different from the native
                                                adults                     language
Thursday          Words and intonation.         Language learning          Understanding adult
                  Main concerns for adult       abilities for adult        motivations, acquisitions
                  learners                      learners. Intonation       and learning.
                                                patterns
Friday            Listening levels.             Listening materials        Some activities to apply
                  Listening skills                                         in the classroom



         WEEK 1           9-10:30                    10:35 -12:00                 1:00- 2:30
Monday            Using ice breakers.            Reading short stories      Understanding the
                  Introduction                  (2)                        contents.
Tuesday           Read titles. Look at           Predicting the contents   . With the above
                  pictures (if there is any).   of the reading by using    information, students will
                  Read a few of the first       pictures                   predict what happens
                  sentences the first                                      next
                  paragraph. Read first line
                  of other paragraphs.
                  Read the sentences of
                  the last paragraph.
Wednesday          Reading another kind of      Students practice          Discussion about the
printed material:           scanning important data    importance of scanning
           Magazine                    (numbers, dates, etc)      for reading
           Newspaper                   and then write them        comprehension
           An article with             board and in their
           technological information   workbook.
Thursday    Reading another short       Students will underline   Students will write
           story                       the unknown words, find    sentences extracted form
                                       their meaning and try to   the story in order to
                                       understand their           understand the meaning.
                                       application on the         Then they´ll use the
                                       context                    same sentences to write
                                                                  a short text.
Friday
           Students will look for      Students will change the   Group discussion about
           patterns like cause-        pattern of the reading     the impact of the pattern
           effect, comparison and                                 in a short story.
           contrasts, etc.

More Related Content

What's hot

Flipping fantastic character
Flipping fantastic characterFlipping fantastic character
Flipping fantastic characterArvindan Nayar
 
Ultversion modulo7 act3 unid3
Ultversion modulo7 act3 unid3Ultversion modulo7 act3 unid3
Ultversion modulo7 act3 unid3
OLGA TORRES SED SEC. EDUCACIÓN DE BOGOTA
 
Weekly plan 3rd week march 12 16
Weekly plan 3rd week march 12 16Weekly plan 3rd week march 12 16
Weekly plan 3rd week march 12 16
Eva Ramos
 
Assignment1 fabiola perez_palma
Assignment1 fabiola perez_palmaAssignment1 fabiola perez_palma
Assignment1 fabiola perez_palmaFabiola Perez
 
Lesson Plan 5- Direct Speech
Lesson  Plan 5-  Direct SpeechLesson  Plan 5-  Direct Speech
Lesson Plan 5- Direct Speech
oceangrean
 
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103cesmyra
 
Reading Lesson Plan
Reading Lesson PlanReading Lesson Plan
Reading Lesson Plan
Zack Rosman
 
Lesson plan for teaching of symbolism (wuthering Heights)
Lesson plan for teaching of symbolism (wuthering Heights) Lesson plan for teaching of symbolism (wuthering Heights)
Lesson plan for teaching of symbolism (wuthering Heights) Mugilan Manokaran
 

What's hot (13)

Flipping fantastic character
Flipping fantastic characterFlipping fantastic character
Flipping fantastic character
 
Ultversion modulo7 act3 unid3
Ultversion modulo7 act3 unid3Ultversion modulo7 act3 unid3
Ultversion modulo7 act3 unid3
 
Form 1 hospitality
Form 1 hospitalityForm 1 hospitality
Form 1 hospitality
 
Weekly plan 3rd week march 12 16
Weekly plan 3rd week march 12 16Weekly plan 3rd week march 12 16
Weekly plan 3rd week march 12 16
 
Form 1 essey 1
Form 1 essey 1Form 1 essey 1
Form 1 essey 1
 
Assignment1 fabiola perez_palma
Assignment1 fabiola perez_palmaAssignment1 fabiola perez_palma
Assignment1 fabiola perez_palma
 
Lesson Plan 5- Direct Speech
Lesson  Plan 5-  Direct SpeechLesson  Plan 5-  Direct Speech
Lesson Plan 5- Direct Speech
 
Sarjin Enp7
Sarjin Enp7Sarjin Enp7
Sarjin Enp7
 
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
 
M4全
M4全M4全
M4全
 
18 8-11
18 8-1118 8-11
18 8-11
 
Reading Lesson Plan
Reading Lesson PlanReading Lesson Plan
Reading Lesson Plan
 
Lesson plan for teaching of symbolism (wuthering Heights)
Lesson plan for teaching of symbolism (wuthering Heights) Lesson plan for teaching of symbolism (wuthering Heights)
Lesson plan for teaching of symbolism (wuthering Heights)
 

Viewers also liked

Analisis pekan efektif
Analisis pekan efektifAnalisis pekan efektif
Analisis pekan efektif
Annis Afifah, S.Pd
 
telaah SLTP
telaah SLTPtelaah SLTP
telaah SLTP
Annis Afifah, S.Pd
 
Manual for a teaching dossier
Manual for a teaching dossierManual for a teaching dossier
Manual for a teaching dossierLourdes Pescador
 
Kmd 3
Kmd 3Kmd 3
Tactics and strategies (1)
Tactics and strategies (1)Tactics and strategies (1)
Tactics and strategies (1)brianphamm
 
Sejarah fisika kel 1
Sejarah fisika kel 1Sejarah fisika kel 1
Sejarah fisika kel 1
Annis Afifah, S.Pd
 
Struktur dan energi atom
Struktur dan energi atomStruktur dan energi atom
Struktur dan energi atom
Annis Afifah, S.Pd
 
Poligami dan Monogami
Poligami dan Monogami Poligami dan Monogami
Poligami dan Monogami
Annis Afifah, S.Pd
 
Origins of WW1
Origins of WW1Origins of WW1
Origins of WW1brianphamm
 
Osiloskop
OsiloskopOsiloskop
Causes of wwii pacific war
Causes of wwii pacific warCauses of wwii pacific war
Causes of wwii pacific warbrianphamm
 
Strategi Pembelajaran Inkuiri
Strategi Pembelajaran InkuiriStrategi Pembelajaran Inkuiri
Strategi Pembelajaran Inkuiri
Annis Afifah, S.Pd
 
Energi dan Daya Listrik
Energi dan Daya ListrikEnergi dan Daya Listrik
Energi dan Daya Listrik
Annis Afifah, S.Pd
 
Sifat Koligatif
Sifat KoligatifSifat Koligatif
Sifat Koligatif
Annis Afifah, S.Pd
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Analisis pekan efektif
Analisis pekan efektifAnalisis pekan efektif
Analisis pekan efektif
 
telaah SLTP
telaah SLTPtelaah SLTP
telaah SLTP
 
Manual for a teaching dossier
Manual for a teaching dossierManual for a teaching dossier
Manual for a teaching dossier
 
Test
TestTest
Test
 
Kmd 3
Kmd 3Kmd 3
Kmd 3
 
Tactics and strategies (1)
Tactics and strategies (1)Tactics and strategies (1)
Tactics and strategies (1)
 
Sejarah fisika kel 1
Sejarah fisika kel 1Sejarah fisika kel 1
Sejarah fisika kel 1
 
Struktur dan energi atom
Struktur dan energi atomStruktur dan energi atom
Struktur dan energi atom
 
Poligami dan Monogami
Poligami dan Monogami Poligami dan Monogami
Poligami dan Monogami
 
Ley28693 ley general snt
Ley28693 ley general sntLey28693 ley general snt
Ley28693 ley general snt
 
Origins of WW1
Origins of WW1Origins of WW1
Origins of WW1
 
4.6 part 1
4.6 part 14.6 part 1
4.6 part 1
 
Osiloskop
OsiloskopOsiloskop
Osiloskop
 
Causes of wwii pacific war
Causes of wwii pacific warCauses of wwii pacific war
Causes of wwii pacific war
 
Strategi Pembelajaran Inkuiri
Strategi Pembelajaran InkuiriStrategi Pembelajaran Inkuiri
Strategi Pembelajaran Inkuiri
 
Energi dan Daya Listrik
Energi dan Daya ListrikEnergi dan Daya Listrik
Energi dan Daya Listrik
 
Sifat Koligatif
Sifat KoligatifSifat Koligatif
Sifat Koligatif
 

Similar to Topic lesson 1

4 6 1_fabiola_pérez_palma
4 6 1_fabiola_pérez_palma4 6 1_fabiola_pérez_palma
4 6 1_fabiola_pérez_palma
Fabiola Perez
 
Sample of writing lesson plan
Sample of writing lesson planSample of writing lesson plan
Sample of writing lesson planAkmal Ariffin
 
HOW TO TEACH GRAMMAR
HOW TO TEACH GRAMMARHOW TO TEACH GRAMMAR
HOW TO TEACH GRAMMARJim DeLarge
 
11.%20 listening%20comprehension[1]
11.%20 listening%20comprehension[1]11.%20 listening%20comprehension[1]
11.%20 listening%20comprehension[1]Amira Mahmoud
 
B1 t1 anavela
B1 t1 anavelaB1 t1 anavela
B1 t1 anavela
aniitita
 
Reading Process From Understanding To Teaching
Reading Process From Understanding To TeachingReading Process From Understanding To Teaching
Reading Process From Understanding To TeachingBrent Daigle, Ph.D.
 
New lesson plans
New lesson plansNew lesson plans
New lesson plansKVelez12
 
Pa final project(1)Lana Davis
Pa final project(1)Lana DavisPa final project(1)Lana Davis
Pa final project(1)Lana Davislanaforecast
 
Norma patricia martinez caamaño
Norma patricia martinez caamañoNorma patricia martinez caamaño
Norma patricia martinez caamañomtzcaamano13
 
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103cesmyra
 
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103cesmyra
 

Similar to Topic lesson 1 (20)

4 6 1_fabiola_pérez_palma
4 6 1_fabiola_pérez_palma4 6 1_fabiola_pérez_palma
4 6 1_fabiola_pérez_palma
 
Lp 7 30
Lp 7 30Lp 7 30
Lp 7 30
 
Sample of writing lesson plan
Sample of writing lesson planSample of writing lesson plan
Sample of writing lesson plan
 
HOW TO TEACH GRAMMAR
HOW TO TEACH GRAMMARHOW TO TEACH GRAMMAR
HOW TO TEACH GRAMMAR
 
11.%20 listening%20comprehension[1]
11.%20 listening%20comprehension[1]11.%20 listening%20comprehension[1]
11.%20 listening%20comprehension[1]
 
B1 t1 anavela
B1 t1 anavelaB1 t1 anavela
B1 t1 anavela
 
Flipping fantastic
Flipping fantasticFlipping fantastic
Flipping fantastic
 
M4全
M4全M4全
M4全
 
Reading Process From Understanding To Teaching
Reading Process From Understanding To TeachingReading Process From Understanding To Teaching
Reading Process From Understanding To Teaching
 
New lesson plans
New lesson plansNew lesson plans
New lesson plans
 
Unit plan
Unit planUnit plan
Unit plan
 
Lessonplan
Lessonplan Lessonplan
Lessonplan
 
Daily lesson plan
Daily lesson planDaily lesson plan
Daily lesson plan
 
Pa final project(1)Lana Davis
Pa final project(1)Lana DavisPa final project(1)Lana Davis
Pa final project(1)Lana Davis
 
Lesson plan
Lesson planLesson plan
Lesson plan
 
16 8-11
16 8-1116 8-11
16 8-11
 
Norma patricia martinez caamaño
Norma patricia martinez caamañoNorma patricia martinez caamaño
Norma patricia martinez caamaño
 
Rph skm
Rph skmRph skm
Rph skm
 
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
 
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
Seminar Workshop Course Guide For Eng 103
 

More from Lourdes Pescador (20)

Task 2.6
Task 2.6Task 2.6
Task 2.6
 
2 2 task_format[1]
2 2 task_format[1]2 2 task_format[1]
2 2 task_format[1]
 
Assignment 3
Assignment 3Assignment 3
Assignment 3
 
Assignment 3
Assignment 3Assignment 3
Assignment 3
 
Task 4.6 part 3
Task 4.6 part 3Task 4.6 part 3
Task 4.6 part 3
 
Task 4.3
Task 4.3Task 4.3
Task 4.3
 
Task 4.2
Task 4.2Task 4.2
Task 4.2
 
Task 2.6
Task 2.6Task 2.6
Task 2.6
 
2 5 task_format[1]
2 5 task_format[1]2 5 task_format[1]
2 5 task_format[1]
 
2 3 task_format[1]
2 3 task_format[1]2 3 task_format[1]
2 3 task_format[1]
 
2 4 task_format[1]
2 4 task_format[1]2 4 task_format[1]
2 4 task_format[1]
 
2 2 task_format[1]
2 2 task_format[1]2 2 task_format[1]
2 2 task_format[1]
 
2 1 task_format[1]
2 1 task_format[1]2 1 task_format[1]
2 1 task_format[1]
 
Task 3.3
Task 3.3Task 3.3
Task 3.3
 
Task 3.3
Task 3.3Task 3.3
Task 3.3
 
Task 3
Task 3Task 3
Task 3
 
Assignment 3
Assignment 3Assignment 3
Assignment 3
 
Assignment 2. unit1
Assignment 2. unit1Assignment 2. unit1
Assignment 2. unit1
 
Esl lesson format
Esl lesson formatEsl lesson format
Esl lesson format
 
Eurosys. a1
Eurosys. a1Eurosys. a1
Eurosys. a1
 

Topic lesson 1

  • 1. TOPIC CONTENT AREA Use of social forms LT, LLP, PE, LC Learning in a group LA, LC Function of the Common European Framework LA, LC, LLP, LT, PE of Reference Which are the different learner types LLP, LC The four skills LA, LLP, LT Speaking activities LT, LA, LLP How do we draw up a lesson plan? LLP, PE How do I present a grammar structure? LT, PE Micro-peer teaching LT, PE, SA Different types of exercises in language LA, LT, LLP classrooms Using pictures in a language classroom LT, PE, LLP Feedback rules PE, SA Pronunciation training LA, LT, PE Learning strategies and learner autonomy LLP Difficult classroom situations LT, PE, SA Progress tests LT, LLP, PE, SA The use of media e-learning / blended learning LT, PE Intercultural learning LC, LA
  • 2. TOPIC ONE SUBJECT: TEACHING ENGLISH LESSONS WITH SONGS. LESSON PLAN Performance Objective: By the end of the lesson students will be able to understand the use of songs, video and movies for ESL. COURSE: ENGLISH 3 Level: LOW INTERMEDIATE GROUP: 3 B Segment Description of Activities Didactic Materials resources 1.- Ice breakers. Using ice breakers in class Differences between child and adult foreign language learning. 2. Introduction teaching Printed material The brain process 3. pronunciation Understanding differences Ppt presentation. Projector between child and adult pronunciation process computer
  • 3. 4. sounds Understanding how sounds are Team work Video perceived by adults Printed material Main concerns for adult Pair work Board learners 5. words and intonation printed material notepads Understanding motivations, video acquisitions and learning. 6. adult learners and their Projector characteristics and learning abilities worksheets Songs. Lyrics. Videos. 7. listening Listening levels. workbook Listening skills Listening principles music and songs Team work Notebooks. 8. Listening materials. types of rhythms 9. activities Some activities to apply in the classroom.
  • 4. TOPIC TWO: READING SKILLS SUBJECT: PRESENT CONTINUOUS LESSON PLAN Performance Objective: By the end of the lesson students will be able to apply effective reading techniques. COURSE: ENGLISH 3 Level: LOW INTERMEDIATE GROUP: 3 B Segment Description of Activities Didactic Materials Time resources 1.- Ice breakers. Using ice breakers in class 45 min 2. Warm up and /or preview Short readings(2) Printed materials a) uses previously learned content to Reading short stories 1 hr begin a new lesson,
  • 5. 3. Preview. Read titles. Look at pictures (if Printed materials 1hr. there is any). Read a few of the Focusing students attention to English first sentences the first Ppt presentation Projector language structures. paragraph. Read first line of Short readings speakers other paragraphs. Read the sentences of the last paragraph. 4. Predicting Predicting the contents of the Team work Notebooks, reading by using pictures. With notepads Focusing student attention on the lesson- the above information, students 45 min asking questions, using visual. Stating the will predict what happens next. objective, relating the objective to previous learning. 3. Scanning Students practice scanning Pair work board 1 hr important data (numbers, dates, Practice is guided through materials and etc) and then write them board notepads may be whole group, small group, pairs, or and in their workbook. individuals. Instructor models each activity, monitors progress and provides feed back. 4. Looking for unknown words and new Students will underline the Team work Notepads 90 min meanings for sentences unknown words, find their meaning and try to understand Notebooks Opportunity to see the application of new
  • 6. knowledge. Practice is guided by material their application on the context. dictionary 5.- Skimming for patterns or Students will look for patterns Team work Workbook 45 min organization. like cause-effect, comparison and contrasts, etc. notepad Opportunity to see the application of patterns, that will help students with reading and writing skills. 6. Application/Closure Conduct a classroom discussion Team work on what the short reading was An activity that requires students to apply about. 30 min new knowledge to their own lives or a new situation.
  • 7. TIME TABLE FOR TWO WEEK COURSE SUBJECT: TEACHING ENGLISH WITH SONGS. WEEK 1 9-10:30 10:35 -12:00 1:00- 2:30 Monday Using ice breakers. Differences between The brain process: Introduction child and adult foreign lateralization language learning. Tuesday Understanding Examples of strong Adults as a specific ESL differences between accents, broken English learning group. child and adult and other issues. Pronunciation techniques pronunciation process Wednesday sounds Understanding how Learning sounds sounds are perceived by different from the native adults language Thursday Words and intonation. Language learning Understanding adult Main concerns for adult abilities for adult motivations, acquisitions learners learners. Intonation and learning. patterns Friday Listening levels. Listening materials Some activities to apply Listening skills in the classroom WEEK 1 9-10:30 10:35 -12:00 1:00- 2:30 Monday Using ice breakers. Reading short stories Understanding the Introduction (2) contents. Tuesday Read titles. Look at Predicting the contents . With the above pictures (if there is any). of the reading by using information, students will Read a few of the first pictures predict what happens sentences the first next paragraph. Read first line of other paragraphs. Read the sentences of the last paragraph. Wednesday Reading another kind of Students practice Discussion about the
  • 8. printed material: scanning important data importance of scanning Magazine (numbers, dates, etc) for reading Newspaper and then write them comprehension An article with board and in their technological information workbook. Thursday Reading another short Students will underline Students will write story the unknown words, find sentences extracted form their meaning and try to the story in order to understand their understand the meaning. application on the Then they´ll use the context same sentences to write a short text. Friday Students will look for Students will change the Group discussion about patterns like cause- pattern of the reading the impact of the pattern effect, comparison and in a short story. contrasts, etc.