Introduction to VANET
                   Scenarios
      Security Requirements
       Privacy Requirements
                Bibliography




  The Security and Privacy
    Requirements in VANET

             Ankit Singh
mailto:ankit.singh@sit.fraunhofer.de


                   June 24, 2011




                Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                 Scenarios
                    Security Requirements
                     Privacy Requirements
                              Bibliography




1   Introduction to VANET
       History
       Overview
       Overview of Basic Components in VANETs

2   Scenarios
      Vehicle to Vehicle Communication
      Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication

3   Security Requirements

4   Privacy Requirements

5   Bibliography


                              Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                              Scenarios   History
                 Security Requirements    Overview
                  Privacy Requirements    Overview of Basic Components in VANETs
                           Bibliography


History of Vehicles I




             Figure: Cars were Pure Mechanical Devices

                           Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                 Scenarios   History
                    Security Requirements    Overview
                     Privacy Requirements    Overview of Basic Components in VANETs
                              Bibliography


History of Vehicles II




     Figure: Todays cars with almost fully controlled Software devices



                              Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                  Scenarios   History
                     Security Requirements    Overview
                      Privacy Requirements    Overview of Basic Components in VANETs
                               Bibliography


History of Vehicles III




  Figure: Future smart cars fully controlled by softwares (Concept model of
  Audi A9 will repairs itself)



                               Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                               Scenarios   History
                  Security Requirements    Overview
                   Privacy Requirements    Overview of Basic Components in VANETs
                            Bibliography


What is VANET? I

     Vehicles Transformed into “Computers on the Wheels” or
     “Networks on the Wheel”
     Vehicular Communication System (VCS):- Two main type of
     communications
         Vehicle to Vehicle (V2V) Communication:-
         Vehicle to Infrastructure (V2I) communication:-
     Advantage and Usage of VCS:-
         Information sharing
         Co-operative driving
         Other value added services like Navigation, internet access etc.
     Communication between C2C adn C2I are “ad-hoc” in nature.
     This special kind of communication network is known as
     “Vehicular Ad-hoc Network (VANET)”

                            Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                              Scenarios   History
                 Security Requirements    Overview
                  Privacy Requirements    Overview of Basic Components in VANETs
                           Bibliography


What is VANET? II
     VANET will become Worlds largest ad-hoc network




                           Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                           Scenarios   History
              Security Requirements    Overview
               Privacy Requirements    Overview of Basic Components in VANETs
                        Bibliography


Why we need VANET? I




                        Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                            Scenarios   History
               Security Requirements    Overview
                Privacy Requirements    Overview of Basic Components in VANETs
                         Bibliography


Overview of Basic Components in VANETs I




             Figure: Basic Component of VANET

                         Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                               Scenarios   History
                  Security Requirements    Overview
                   Privacy Requirements    Overview of Basic Components in VANETs
                            Bibliography


Overview of Basic Components in VANETs II
     Communication:- Wireless Access in Vehicular Environment
     (WAVE): IEEE 1609.2 Standard also Known DSRC 802.11p .
     Supports Multi-Hop communication for vehicles out of range
     (Max. Range DSRC is 1000m)
     On-Board Unit (OBU):- A device which is inside the vehicle
     which -
         processes the data collected from various sensors fitted inside
         the cars and gives conditions of the vehicles
         is responsible for communication with outside network i.e with
         other vehicles and infrastructure.
     Road Side Unit (RSU): Infrastructure for communication
     between the cars for sharing and information from various
     vehicles.

                            Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                Scenarios
                                            Vehicle to Vehicle Communication
                   Security Requirements
                                            Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication
                    Privacy Requirements
                             Bibliography


Vehicle to Vehicle Communication I




                         Figure: Scenarios in V2V


  Possible Threat Scenarios in V2V above:-
      Pre-crash warning:- trust on the warning message, Denial of
      Service, Jamming
      Traffic condition warning:- Linkablity of Private Credentials
      (Tracking/profiling), Message fabrication/tamper
                             Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                               Scenarios
                                           Vehicle to Vehicle Communication
                  Security Requirements
                                           Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication
                   Privacy Requirements
                            Bibliography


Vehicle to Vehicle Communication II
      Vehicle Status Warning:- Drops/Tamper Message




                            Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                             Scenarios
                                         Vehicle to Vehicle Communication
                Security Requirements
                                         Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication
                 Privacy Requirements
                          Bibliography


Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication I




                       Figure: Scenarios in V2I



                          Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                 Scenarios
                                             Vehicle to Vehicle Communication
                    Security Requirements
                                             Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication
                     Privacy Requirements
                              Bibliography


Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication II
  Possible Threat in Scenarios of V2I above:-
      Electronic Toll collection/Automatic access control/parking
      access:- Privacy Violation, Impersonation,
      Infotainment:- Penetration attack, Privacy violation
      Remote Fleet Management:- Tracking/Profiling
      Tax payment: The authority can link or indentify using
      previous transaction or other vehicle can hack transaction
      information and reveal the identity of the sender.




                              Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                   Scenarios
                      Security Requirements
                       Privacy Requirements
                                Bibliography


Security Requirements I

  Various Security Requirements for VANET’s:-
      Authentication
      Accountability
      Verification of Data Consistency
      Availability
      Non-Repudiation
      Credential revocation




                                Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                 Scenarios
                    Security Requirements
                     Privacy Requirements
                              Bibliography


Privacy Requirements I

  Various Privacy Requirements for VANET’s:-
      Anonymity
      Unlinkablility
      Restricted credential usage
      Perfect forward Privacy




                              Ankit Singh    The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                         Scenarios
                            Security Requirements
                             Privacy Requirements
                                      Bibliography


Bibliography I
     Security Engineering for Vehicular IT Systems, Improving the Trustworthiness and Dependability of
     Automotive IT Applications, Marko Wolf

     How much does software add to the cost of today’s vehicles? How about tomorrow’s electric cars? by
     Sebastian Blanco on Jun 8th 2010, at Auto Blog Green: autobloggreen.com

     Design of 5.9GHz DSRC-based Vehicular Safety Communication, Daniel Jiang1 , Vikas Taliwal1 , Andreas
     Meier1 , Wieland Holfelder1 , Ralf Herrtwich2 , 1 DaimlerChrysler Research and Technology North America,
     Inc., 2 DaimlerChrysler AG, Vehicle IT and Services Research and Advanced Engineering

     DSRC range comparison with FM Radio, cellular Phone, Satellite, Check FAQs

     Security in Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks, Xiaodong Lin, Rongxing Lu, Chenxi Zhang, Haojin Zhu, Pin-Han
     Ho, and Xuemin (Sherman) Shen, University of Waterloo

     Privacy Requirements in Vehicular Communications Systems, Florian Schaub, Zhendong Ma, and Frank
     Kargl, Institute of Media Informatics, Ulm University, Germany

     The Security of Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks, Maxim Raya and Jean-Pierre Hubaux, Laboratory of computer
     Communications and Applications (LCA), School of Computer and Communication Sciences, EPFL,
     Switzerland




                                       Ankit Singh       The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
Introduction to VANET
                                          Scenarios
                             Security Requirements
                              Privacy Requirements
                                       Bibliography


Bibliography II
      Securing Vehicular Communications, Maxim Raya, Panos Papadimitratos, Jean-Pierre Hubaux, Laboratory
      of computer Communications and Applications (LCA), School of Computer and Communication Sciences,
      EPFL, Switzerland

      Security Engineering for VANETs, Frank Kargl, Zhendong Ma, and Elmar Schoch, Ulm University, Institute
      of Media Informatics
      Privacy in VANETs using Changing Pseudonyms - Ideal and Real, Matthias Gerlach and Felix G¨ttler
                                                                                                u

      Adaptive Privacy-Preserving Authentication in Vehicular Networks (Invited Paper) Kewi Sha1 , Yong Xi1 ,
      Weisong Shi1 , Loren Schwiebert1 , and Tao Zhang2 , 1 Department of computer Science, Wayne state
      University, 2 Telcordia Technologies, Inc.

      Strong and Affordable Location Privacy in VANETs: Identity Diffusion Using Time-Slots and Swapping,
      David Eckhoff , Christoph Sommer , Tobias Gansen† , Reinhard German and Falko Dressler∗ ,
      ∗
       Computer Networks and Communication Systems, Dept. of Computer Science, University of Erlangen,
      Germany, † Audi Electronics Venture GmbH, Gaimersheim, Germany

      Current Trends in Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks, Ghassan M. T. Abdalla∗ , Mosa Ali Abu-Rgheff∗ and Sidi
      Mohammad Senouci∗∗ , ∗ University of Plymouth - School of Computing, Communications & Electronics,
      UK, ∗∗ France T´l´com - Recherche et D´veloppment CORE, France
                     ee                     e




                                        Ankit Singh       The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET

The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET

  • 1.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Security Requirements Privacy Requirements Bibliography The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET Ankit Singh mailto:ankit.singh@sit.fraunhofer.de June 24, 2011 Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 2.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Security Requirements Privacy Requirements Bibliography 1 Introduction to VANET History Overview Overview of Basic Components in VANETs 2 Scenarios Vehicle to Vehicle Communication Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication 3 Security Requirements 4 Privacy Requirements 5 Bibliography Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 3.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios History Security Requirements Overview Privacy Requirements Overview of Basic Components in VANETs Bibliography History of Vehicles I Figure: Cars were Pure Mechanical Devices Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 4.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios History Security Requirements Overview Privacy Requirements Overview of Basic Components in VANETs Bibliography History of Vehicles II Figure: Todays cars with almost fully controlled Software devices Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 5.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios History Security Requirements Overview Privacy Requirements Overview of Basic Components in VANETs Bibliography History of Vehicles III Figure: Future smart cars fully controlled by softwares (Concept model of Audi A9 will repairs itself) Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 6.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios History Security Requirements Overview Privacy Requirements Overview of Basic Components in VANETs Bibliography What is VANET? I Vehicles Transformed into “Computers on the Wheels” or “Networks on the Wheel” Vehicular Communication System (VCS):- Two main type of communications Vehicle to Vehicle (V2V) Communication:- Vehicle to Infrastructure (V2I) communication:- Advantage and Usage of VCS:- Information sharing Co-operative driving Other value added services like Navigation, internet access etc. Communication between C2C adn C2I are “ad-hoc” in nature. This special kind of communication network is known as “Vehicular Ad-hoc Network (VANET)” Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 7.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios History Security Requirements Overview Privacy Requirements Overview of Basic Components in VANETs Bibliography What is VANET? II VANET will become Worlds largest ad-hoc network Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 8.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios History Security Requirements Overview Privacy Requirements Overview of Basic Components in VANETs Bibliography Why we need VANET? I Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 9.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios History Security Requirements Overview Privacy Requirements Overview of Basic Components in VANETs Bibliography Overview of Basic Components in VANETs I Figure: Basic Component of VANET Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 10.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios History Security Requirements Overview Privacy Requirements Overview of Basic Components in VANETs Bibliography Overview of Basic Components in VANETs II Communication:- Wireless Access in Vehicular Environment (WAVE): IEEE 1609.2 Standard also Known DSRC 802.11p . Supports Multi-Hop communication for vehicles out of range (Max. Range DSRC is 1000m) On-Board Unit (OBU):- A device which is inside the vehicle which - processes the data collected from various sensors fitted inside the cars and gives conditions of the vehicles is responsible for communication with outside network i.e with other vehicles and infrastructure. Road Side Unit (RSU): Infrastructure for communication between the cars for sharing and information from various vehicles. Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 11.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Vehicle to Vehicle Communication Security Requirements Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication Privacy Requirements Bibliography Vehicle to Vehicle Communication I Figure: Scenarios in V2V Possible Threat Scenarios in V2V above:- Pre-crash warning:- trust on the warning message, Denial of Service, Jamming Traffic condition warning:- Linkablity of Private Credentials (Tracking/profiling), Message fabrication/tamper Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 12.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Vehicle to Vehicle Communication Security Requirements Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication Privacy Requirements Bibliography Vehicle to Vehicle Communication II Vehicle Status Warning:- Drops/Tamper Message Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 13.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Vehicle to Vehicle Communication Security Requirements Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication Privacy Requirements Bibliography Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication I Figure: Scenarios in V2I Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 14.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Vehicle to Vehicle Communication Security Requirements Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication Privacy Requirements Bibliography Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication II Possible Threat in Scenarios of V2I above:- Electronic Toll collection/Automatic access control/parking access:- Privacy Violation, Impersonation, Infotainment:- Penetration attack, Privacy violation Remote Fleet Management:- Tracking/Profiling Tax payment: The authority can link or indentify using previous transaction or other vehicle can hack transaction information and reveal the identity of the sender. Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 15.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Security Requirements Privacy Requirements Bibliography Security Requirements I Various Security Requirements for VANET’s:- Authentication Accountability Verification of Data Consistency Availability Non-Repudiation Credential revocation Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 16.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Security Requirements Privacy Requirements Bibliography Privacy Requirements I Various Privacy Requirements for VANET’s:- Anonymity Unlinkablility Restricted credential usage Perfect forward Privacy Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 17.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Security Requirements Privacy Requirements Bibliography Bibliography I Security Engineering for Vehicular IT Systems, Improving the Trustworthiness and Dependability of Automotive IT Applications, Marko Wolf How much does software add to the cost of today’s vehicles? How about tomorrow’s electric cars? by Sebastian Blanco on Jun 8th 2010, at Auto Blog Green: autobloggreen.com Design of 5.9GHz DSRC-based Vehicular Safety Communication, Daniel Jiang1 , Vikas Taliwal1 , Andreas Meier1 , Wieland Holfelder1 , Ralf Herrtwich2 , 1 DaimlerChrysler Research and Technology North America, Inc., 2 DaimlerChrysler AG, Vehicle IT and Services Research and Advanced Engineering DSRC range comparison with FM Radio, cellular Phone, Satellite, Check FAQs Security in Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks, Xiaodong Lin, Rongxing Lu, Chenxi Zhang, Haojin Zhu, Pin-Han Ho, and Xuemin (Sherman) Shen, University of Waterloo Privacy Requirements in Vehicular Communications Systems, Florian Schaub, Zhendong Ma, and Frank Kargl, Institute of Media Informatics, Ulm University, Germany The Security of Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks, Maxim Raya and Jean-Pierre Hubaux, Laboratory of computer Communications and Applications (LCA), School of Computer and Communication Sciences, EPFL, Switzerland Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET
  • 18.
    Introduction to VANET Scenarios Security Requirements Privacy Requirements Bibliography Bibliography II Securing Vehicular Communications, Maxim Raya, Panos Papadimitratos, Jean-Pierre Hubaux, Laboratory of computer Communications and Applications (LCA), School of Computer and Communication Sciences, EPFL, Switzerland Security Engineering for VANETs, Frank Kargl, Zhendong Ma, and Elmar Schoch, Ulm University, Institute of Media Informatics Privacy in VANETs using Changing Pseudonyms - Ideal and Real, Matthias Gerlach and Felix G¨ttler u Adaptive Privacy-Preserving Authentication in Vehicular Networks (Invited Paper) Kewi Sha1 , Yong Xi1 , Weisong Shi1 , Loren Schwiebert1 , and Tao Zhang2 , 1 Department of computer Science, Wayne state University, 2 Telcordia Technologies, Inc. Strong and Affordable Location Privacy in VANETs: Identity Diffusion Using Time-Slots and Swapping, David Eckhoff , Christoph Sommer , Tobias Gansen† , Reinhard German and Falko Dressler∗ , ∗ Computer Networks and Communication Systems, Dept. of Computer Science, University of Erlangen, Germany, † Audi Electronics Venture GmbH, Gaimersheim, Germany Current Trends in Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks, Ghassan M. T. Abdalla∗ , Mosa Ali Abu-Rgheff∗ and Sidi Mohammad Senouci∗∗ , ∗ University of Plymouth - School of Computing, Communications & Electronics, UK, ∗∗ France T´l´com - Recherche et D´veloppment CORE, France ee e Ankit Singh The Security and Privacy Requirements in VANET