ayushida, profile picture
Uploaded byayushida
PPT, PDF59,485 views

Tender evaluation procedure

This document outlines information regarding a course on tender evaluation processes. It discusses the course objectives, which are to understand the tender evaluation process and criteria. It describes the typical evaluation process, which involves 6 stages from issuing the tender to acceptance of bids. It also outlines the criteria used, which differ based on project size. The document provides details on the typical information and documents required for bid submissions and evaluates the bidder. It describes the multi-stage evaluation process used to assess bids for compliance, completeness, financial capacity, and experience.

Embed presentation

Downloaded 2,885 times
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 1 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT TENDER EVALUATION -JKR PROCEDURE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 2 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT COURSE OUTCOME • Enable to understand the tender evaluation process. • Knowledge on tender evaluation stages and the criteria involved. • Enable to know all information needed during tender. • Enable to strategize work during tender stages.
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 3 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT OBJECTIVES • To determine and to recommend to the Board of Procurement a tender which offers the most profit to the GOVERNMENT. Only contractor which has the financial and technical capabilities is eligible for Award and Acceptance.
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 4 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION PROCESS 6. Issuing of tender Acceptance letter 5. Determine budget 4. Treasury (if applicable) 3. Procurement board 2. Processing tender 1. Tender opening committee In validity Tender period Tender evaluation must be done in validity of tender period (minimum 90 days) from tender closing date.
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 5 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION PROCESS FIRST STAGE Tender price adjustment Arrange the tender price (from low to high) Price reasonableness based on budget or “cut-off” Determine the number of tenderers to be evaluated SECOND STAGE Tender compliance Tender compliance analysis Completeness of document analysis Adequacy of minimum capital analsys THIRD STAGE Experience and capability Tenderer experience analysis Technical personnel analysis qualify qualify Rejected Contractor Not Fulfill requirement Not Fulfill requirement Not Fulfill requirement
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 6 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT CRITERIA • PWD practice tender evaluation procedure has been divided into 3 categories, namely: i. Large projects (more than RM10.0 million) ii. Medium projects (RM2.0 million to RM10.0 million) iii. Small projects (less than RM2.0 million)
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 7 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT INFORMATION FORMS a) Borang A – Surat pengakuan kebenaran maklumat dan kesahihan dokumen yang dikemukakan pentender a) Borang B – Maklumat am latarbelakang pentender b) Borang C – Data-data kewangan c) Borang CA – Laporan Bank/Institusi Kewangan d) Borang D – Rekod pengalaman kerja e) Borang E – Kakitangan teknikal f) Borang F – Keempunyaan loji dan peralatan pembinaan asas g) Borang G – Senarai kontrak kerja semasa h) Borang GA-1 – Laporan Jurutera Projek (JKR) i) Borang GA-2 – Laporan Jurutera Projek (Swasta) CRITERIA - INFORMATION REQUIRED
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 8 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT OTHERS DOCUMENT i. Audited account copy for last 2 years ii. Account bank statement copy for last 3 months iii. Bank report / financial institution (sealed) iv. Copy of the certificate / confirmation of completion for each project listed in Form D and G v. EPF statement and a copy of Form A or copy service agreement for contract staff vi. Copy of the certificate of approval of technical staff vii. Copy of Grant / hire-purchase agreement plant / equipment viii. Copies of the final interim payment certificate for the current project ix. Project report (sealed) CRITERIA - INFORMATION REQUIRED
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 9 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Sample of summary of tender submission
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 10 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - FIRST STAGE • Preparation need to be done by evaluator before start any tender evaluation process such as: • Prepare summary of tender in ascending order based on tender table prepared by Tender Opening Committee. . Prepare tender analysis based on cut-off pricing. . Select list of tenderers to be evaluated. . Check and fill up Checklist of Compulsory Documents. . Prepare analysis of percentage (%) of price distribution and obtain agreement from tenderers. . Carry out arithmetic checking.
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 11 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Number of tenderer should be assessed is between 15-20 tenderer to produce between 3- 5 tenderer who will pass. • "Range" of tenderer can be selected is between + / - 20% (+ / - 25% for Civil Engineering) from the Mean Price. • For the tenderers who are below the "cut-off" will be checked the compulsory document first. Select tenderer with special criteria to be evaluated. • For tenderers who are outside the “cut-off” to be referred to tender committee for consideration. EVALUATION STAGES - FIRST STAGE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 12 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • A system of evaluation based on predetermined conditions to ascertain whether tenderers are eligible for further evaluation. • Evaluation Criteria: i. Analysis on Compliance to Tender ii. Analysis on Completeness of tender documents. iii. Analysis on Adequacy of Capital iv. Analysis on performance of current work. • Objectives: To ensure tenders under consideration are reasonable, in compliance, complete, have adequate capital and have good current work performance free from sick project, EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 13 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT i. Analysis on Compliance to Tender EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE • Only Tenderers which comply and free from any imperfection in term of legal and contractual which may jeopardize their qualification based on current practice are to be considered. – To check if form of tender has been signed by tenderers – The signing person has been given the power to sign. – To check if tender price is stated in the form of tender. – Are PKK/CIDB registration still valid. – Has tenderer returned all the basic tender documents, – Check proposed construction period is stated in the form of tender. – Failure to submit any of the forms of tender may effect the ranking of tenderer,
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 14 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Common mistakes during filling of forms of tender EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE FORM OF TENDER NOT SIGNED FORM OF TENDER NOT SIGNED
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 15 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT SIGNED ON WRONG FORM
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 16 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Summary of Tender Price TENDER PRICE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 17 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT SIJIL PKK SIGNING PERSON GIVEN POWER VALIDITY PERIOD AHMAD BIN ABU
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 18 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT CIDB CERTIFICATE VALIDITY PERIOD
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 19 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT TENDER PRICE NOT STATED CONTRACT PERIOD NOT STATED FORM OF TENDER
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 20 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT PRICE IN FIGURES PRICE IN WORDS FORM OF TENDER
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 21 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT ii. Analysis on Completeness of Tender a) Tender which is complete and comply to the requirement of tender/regulation/Authority. b) Mandatory Tender Documents includes: i. Forms of Tender ii. List of Quantity/ Summary of Tender iii. Addendum (if any) iv. Schedule of rates v. Design proposal, specification, pricing by contractor etc. (where applicable) as required to enable design work by tenderer to be evaluated. EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 22 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE OTHERS - Analysis on Construction Period • Ensure the construction period offers by tenderers is analysed such as: a) not exceeding the maximum construction period stated in the tender document. b) Construction period if offerred by tenderer is not too short that it becomes unreasonable
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 23 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE Analysis on Completeness of Tender
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 24 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT ii. Analysis on Completeness of Tender EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE MANDATORY DOCUMENTS a) Audited account copy for last 2 years, or Account bank statement copy for last 3 months, or Bank report / financial institution (sealed) b) Project report by project superintendence officer Without mandatory documents (especially regarding financial) evaluation of tenders can not be made and therefore tender will be rejected.
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 25 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Balance Sheet statement EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 26 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Current Bank Statement EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 27 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE Financial Statement Report
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 28 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE ii. Analysis on Completeness of Tender
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 29 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE iii. Analysis on Adequacy of Minimum Capital Method of calculation i. Rolling capital = asset liability – current liability ii. Bank account = average of latest 3 months iii. Make comparison between rolling capital and bank account. Select the higher amount iv. Include credit facilities report v. Add (+) iii and iv = total liquidated capital (>3%)
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 30 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT MINIMA CAPITAL EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE iii. Analysis on Adequacy of Minimum Capital Sample of calculation for minimum capital 3% from value of construction work. Tender price = RM 1,000,000.00 PC Sum = RM 50,000.00 Provisional Sum = RM 50,000.00 Construction work value = RM 900,000.00 So, 3% = RM 27,000.00
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 31 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE iii. Analysis on Adequacy of Minimum Capital Forms of Capital a) Rolling capital b) Shares, unit trust, fixed deposit, Bond c) Balance of credit facilities For joint venture tender submission, minimum capital is analyse based on combined equity agreed by both parties.
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 32 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Adequacy of Minimum Capital EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 33 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Work still on progress during the tendering process (Form D, G and GA) • No sick project – below 30% of work schedule • No termination record • Checking will carry out through; i. PKK / CIDB / JKR scale ii. Superintendence project report iii. T.K.S. if no project on hand. EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE iii. Analysis on performance of current work
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 34 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Current progress report
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 35 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 36 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE REASONABLE FACTORS Faktor Civil Building Mechancal / Enginering work Electrical ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Financial capability 45% 50% 50% Technical Work experience 35% 35% 35% Technical staffs 15% 10% 15% Machineries / plant 5% 5% 0% ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 100% 100% 100% ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 37 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE FINANCIAL CAPABILITY (Financial Bid Capacity) = Working capital Yearly project value i. Financial Capability
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 38 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Working experiences • Technical staff • Machineries / plant EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE ii. Technical • Working experience Evaluation criteria -. Completed total work value past 5 years - Largest work value done in past 5 years - Type of work is limited to recognized work Comparable or similar (follow by head / sub-head
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 39 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Technical staff Evaluation criteria -. Number and working experience of technical staff compares with Estimate Minimum Requirement EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE CONSTRUCTION WORK VALUECONSTRUCTION WORK VALUE BUILDINGBUILDING CIVIL ENGINEERINGCIVIL ENGINEERING CATCAT AA CATCAT BB CATCAT CC CATCAT AA CATCAT BB CATCAT CC More than RM5.0 m and not moreMore than RM5.0 m and not more than RM 8.0 mthan RM 8.0 m More than RM8.0 m and not moreMore than RM8.0 m and not more than RM 15.0 mthan RM 15.0 m More than RM15.0 m and not moreMore than RM15.0 m and not more than RM 25.0 jutathan RM 25.0 juta More than RM25.0 m and not moreMore than RM25.0 m and not more than RM 50.0 mthan RM 50.0 m More than RM50.0 mMore than RM50.0 m 11 22 33 55 88 33 44 77 1111 1818 33 44 77 1111 1818 22 33 55 88 1313 33 44 77 1111 1919 44 55 99 1414 2323
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 40 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE Staff categories: • Category A (Engineer, architect, quantity surveyor) • Category B (Diploma, Technician / polytechnic) • Category C (assistant technician)) Must be employed by employer during tendering • Certificate and KWSP • For contract staff – Contract agreement • Technical staff
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 41 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Machineries / plants EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE Plant and equipment that could be accounted is limited to: • As listed in the Estimated Minimum Requirement. Plants / machineries can be considered if function equivalently • Owned / hire-purchase before the closing of tender • Useful life not exceeding 150 years • If rent-mortgage, the agreement should cover the contract period.
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 42 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE Minimum Score CriteriaCriteria Minimum ScoreMinimum Score BWBW CECE M&EM&E 1.1. Financial capabilityFinancial capability 2.2. Technical capabilityTechnical capability 3.3. Overall capabilityOverall capability 20.020.0 12.512.5 45.045.0 18.018.0 13.813.8 45.545.5 20.020.0 12.512.5 45.045.0
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 43 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT SPECIAL CRITERIA • Tender submission which is below the “cut- off” price and passes Stage 2 Tender Evaluation can be considered if comply to the following criteria: - Excellent performance for current project and completed project for the last 5 years. - Good quality workmanship - Tender price not less than -20% of the “cut-off” price - Tender price is not too unreasonable (Freak).
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 44 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Examples of low tender price can be considered. - Own factory for main building materials - Currently undertake equivalent construction work at neighboring site - Own scaffolding / formwork for recently completed project - For roadwork / earthwork – own plants and machineries readily available for use - Satisfactorily completed 3 projects of similar nature consecutively prior to this tender SPECIAL CRITERIA
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 45 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT OTHERS ANALYSIS • Arithmetic checking • Table for price comparison - comparison of price for every building category with the estimated price prepared by consultant by each tenderer taking into account the arithmetic checking
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 46 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT OTHERS ANALYSIS
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 47 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT COMMITTEE ENDORSEMENT FOR EVALUATION REPORT • Ensure tenderer is not too occupied with on going project. • If the lowest tender price is too high as compared to estimated mean price, recommendation by committee should be: – Award the tender to the lowest tenderer – Decline all tender offer and re-tender. • Recommendation should list down at least five (5) tenderers in ascending order who had passed each stage of evaluation. • Joint signature by qualified three (3) tender committee members • Prepare Q14A/2005/A form for result of tender together with complete tender evaluation report
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 48 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Step to be undertaken if there is any fake documents are detected. - check all submitted documents, and verify in compulsory document checklist. - Check with the parties which is responsible to supply the document. (if suspicious arise) - Verification of fake document should be in writing. - Ensure the affected tenderer not to be recommended - Lodge a police report and send the report to CIDB and PKK. - Evaluation officer to request show cause letter from tenderer via CIDB and PKK TENDER EVALUATION REPORT
August 29, 2013 NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 49 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Thank You

More Related Content

PPTX
Tendering in Construction
byshillier38
 
PPTX
Tender procedure slide
bypoliteknik malaysia
 
PPTX
Construction tender process
byDr Andrew Kimmance PhD, MSc, BSc, MAPM, CIOB, AHEA
 
PPTX
Tendering process, Bid Evaluation & Award Process
byPrateek Kashyap
 
PPTX
Lecture 4 - selection of contract forms
bykohwenqi
 
PPTX
Tendering Bidding & Award of Contract Final Draft
byMuneesh Methwani
 
PPT
Lecture 2 tender process n documentation
byArchDuty
 
PPTX
TENDER DOCUMENT
bySumaiya Jabin
 
Tendering in Construction
byshillier38
 
Tender procedure slide
bypoliteknik malaysia
 
Construction tender process
byDr Andrew Kimmance PhD, MSc, BSc, MAPM, CIOB, AHEA
 
Tendering process, Bid Evaluation & Award Process
byPrateek Kashyap
 
Lecture 4 - selection of contract forms
bykohwenqi
 
Tendering Bidding & Award of Contract Final Draft
byMuneesh Methwani
 
Lecture 2 tender process n documentation
byArchDuty
 
TENDER DOCUMENT
bySumaiya Jabin
 

What's hot

DOCX
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CONTRACT FORM JKR 203A & PAM
byAnep Botak
 
DOCX
Traditional procurement method
byhiewliming
 
PPTX
Site possession
byAmir Ibrahim
 
PDF
M3 Lecture 11 provisional sum prime cost sum
byEst
 
PPT
Tender calling procedure
byShourya Puri
 
PPTX
Strategies in building procurement (summarized)
byMichael Audu
 
PDF
ECA form
byArissa Loh
 
PPTX
Bayaran Dalam Kontrak.pptx
byEFFENDY3
 
PDF
Construction Contract in Malaysia
byDayat Mohamad
 
PDF
ECA Workshop - Brief
byKai Yun Pang
 
DOCX
Professional Practice 2: Group Assignment
by마 이환
 
PDF
Contract payment and variation
byVj NiroSh
 
PPTX
Eca presentation-compile
byTimun Loh
 
PDF
Conditions Of Contract
byguestdb5e498
 
PPTX
bs:copbs101
byAdiirfan Che-ani
 
PPTX
Spun pile
byWen Crystal
 
PPT
contract procedure
byhasyimah ismail
 
PDF
Elemental Cost Analysis
byPang Khai Shuen
 
PDF
50451783 taking-off-quantity
byhlksd
 
PDF
Provisional sum prime cost sum
byEst
 
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CONTRACT FORM JKR 203A & PAM
byAnep Botak
 
Traditional procurement method
byhiewliming
 
Site possession
byAmir Ibrahim
 
M3 Lecture 11 provisional sum prime cost sum
byEst
 
Tender calling procedure
byShourya Puri
 
Strategies in building procurement (summarized)
byMichael Audu
 
ECA form
byArissa Loh
 
Bayaran Dalam Kontrak.pptx
byEFFENDY3
 
Construction Contract in Malaysia
byDayat Mohamad
 
ECA Workshop - Brief
byKai Yun Pang
 
Professional Practice 2: Group Assignment
by마 이환
 
Contract payment and variation
byVj NiroSh
 
Eca presentation-compile
byTimun Loh
 
Conditions Of Contract
byguestdb5e498
 
bs:copbs101
byAdiirfan Che-ani
 
Spun pile
byWen Crystal
 
contract procedure
byhasyimah ismail
 
Elemental Cost Analysis
byPang Khai Shuen
 
50451783 taking-off-quantity
byhlksd
 
Provisional sum prime cost sum
byEst
 

Viewers also liked

PPTX
Tender Process | A Complete Procurement Guide
byTender Process
 
PPTX
Tender processing
bydnyandev_d
 
PPT
Tendering in construction introduction
byDaniel Ross
 
PDF
Chapter 2 [compatibility mode]
byDelhi Technological University
 
PPTX
RIBA plan of work
bysithirumanamperi
 
PDF
Tender writing – point of difference – important in wining tenders?
byRed Tape Busters
 
PDF
14102008 - Nordic Ppp Forum Presentation Pja Peekel Final
byPJAPeekel
 
PPT
Tendering process cvc_guidelines
byRitesh Kumar Baranwal
 
PPT
Estimating and Tendering methods for Construction Work
byDaniel Ross
 
PPT
Rates Analysis For Calculating Material and Labour for building works
byALI HYDER GADHI
 
PPT
Tender
bycharliesleopanadan
 
Tender Process | A Complete Procurement Guide
byTender Process
 
Tender processing
bydnyandev_d
 
Tendering in construction introduction
byDaniel Ross
 
Chapter 2 [compatibility mode]
byDelhi Technological University
 
RIBA plan of work
bysithirumanamperi
 
Tender writing – point of difference – important in wining tenders?
byRed Tape Busters
 
14102008 - Nordic Ppp Forum Presentation Pja Peekel Final
byPJAPeekel
 
Tendering process cvc_guidelines
byRitesh Kumar Baranwal
 
Estimating and Tendering methods for Construction Work
byDaniel Ross
 
Rates Analysis For Calculating Material and Labour for building works
byALI HYDER GADHI
 
Tender
bycharliesleopanadan
 

Similar to Tender evaluation procedure

PPT
EVALUATON TENDER project planning and management ppt
byPunit Sharnagat
 
PPTX
Contract monitoring & evaluation
byjama osman
 
PPTX
EVALUATION OF BID & AWARDING OF WORK
by9021050570
 
PPSX
T4 ct procurement_training_presentation
byLloyd Sewell
 
PPTX
Procurement workshop training slides - Birmingham session
byBrowne Jacobson LLP
 
PPTX
Projects2016_Franks_PreparingFortheParty-Project Close
byBarbara Franks
 
PPTX
Tendering & Pre Construction Operations in Construction
byssuserb8d45c1
 
PPT
Tips For Solving PMP Exam Questions
bytfhakam
 
PPTX
Procurement part 1.
bySkript
 
PDF
Contractual Steps for Smooth Delivery of Infrastructure Projects
byAM Publications
 
PPTX
METHODS OF EVALUATION OF TENDERS IN PUBLIC ENTITIES.pptx
byshafybendaki928
 
PDF
PMP Chapter 6 of 6 closing process group (1- Process) (Based on PMBOK 6th ed...
byShamil Habet
 
PDF
Software Engineering unit 4 personal notes.pdf
byshaquibrizwan66
 
PPT
Final Class Presentation on Project Audit and Closure.ppt
byGeorgeKabongah2
 
PDF
Strategic Document in request for proporsal
bybahatimosha17
 
PPT
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PROJECT CLOSURE.ppt
bykatushabeHellen
 
PPT
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PROJECT CLOSURE.ppt
bykatushabeHellen
 
DOC
TEA checklist
bySr. Azhar Ahmad
 
PPT
Tenders.ppt
bySampath Sredharran
 
PPTX
Procurement presentation Ace workshop - Cotonou
byAssociation of African Univerisites
 
EVALUATON TENDER project planning and management ppt
byPunit Sharnagat
 
Contract monitoring & evaluation
byjama osman
 
EVALUATION OF BID & AWARDING OF WORK
by9021050570
 
T4 ct procurement_training_presentation
byLloyd Sewell
 
Procurement workshop training slides - Birmingham session
byBrowne Jacobson LLP
 
Projects2016_Franks_PreparingFortheParty-Project Close
byBarbara Franks
 
Tendering & Pre Construction Operations in Construction
byssuserb8d45c1
 
Tips For Solving PMP Exam Questions
bytfhakam
 
Procurement part 1.
bySkript
 
Contractual Steps for Smooth Delivery of Infrastructure Projects
byAM Publications
 
METHODS OF EVALUATION OF TENDERS IN PUBLIC ENTITIES.pptx
byshafybendaki928
 
PMP Chapter 6 of 6 closing process group (1- Process) (Based on PMBOK 6th ed...
byShamil Habet
 
Software Engineering unit 4 personal notes.pdf
byshaquibrizwan66
 
Final Class Presentation on Project Audit and Closure.ppt
byGeorgeKabongah2
 
Strategic Document in request for proporsal
bybahatimosha17
 
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PROJECT CLOSURE.ppt
bykatushabeHellen
 
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PROJECT CLOSURE.ppt
bykatushabeHellen
 
TEA checklist
bySr. Azhar Ahmad
 
Tenders.ppt
bySampath Sredharran
 
Procurement presentation Ace workshop - Cotonou
byAssociation of African Univerisites
 

Recently uploaded

DOCX
Proven Ways to Buy Verified PayPal Accounts in Los Angeles Safely.docx
byUsaservicepoint
 
PDF
IFS state pension.pdf From IFS and Oxford
byHenry Tapper
 
PDF
Using-pension-savings-to-support-home-ownership.pdf
byHenry Tapper
 
DOCX
How to Buy Facebook Verified Accounts_ A Guide.docx
byDigital Marketing in the USA
 
PDF
RI&E Checklist MKB (2026) – Voorbereiding, Toetsing & Plan van Aanpak PDF
byRIEklaar.nl
 
DOCX
Buy Tripadvisor Reviews From $15 Per Review _ 100% Safe.docx
bymarketing
 
DOCX
Legal Status & Safety of Verified Cash App Accounts Explained (Year 2026).docx
byBuy Verified Cash App Accounts
 
DOCX
Best 55 Sites for Buying Verified Venmo Accounts in 2026.docx
bymarketing
 
PDF
Laura Sergio - Specializing In Helping Small Businesses
byLaura Sergio
 
PPTX
Exterior Front Entry Door Design Trends, 2025–2026
bydoornmore
 
PDF
V3Cube On-Demand House Cleaning App Solution
byV3CUBE TECHNOLABS
 
PDF
Kirill Klip GEM Royalty TNR Gold Copper Presentation
byKirill Klip
 
PDF
Where and why Buy Verified Binance Accounts With Full KYC ....pdf
byhttps://propvaservice.com/
 
PPTX
Production and Ops - 1 Unit-I-Foundation to Production and Operations Managem...
byDavies Chacko
 
PDF
Startup 8 - Student's Book - ENGLISH - Advanced 2
byenglishcloudresource
 
DOCX
Top 10 Sites to Buy Aged Snapchat Accounts in 2026.docx
byBuyGmailAccounts10
 
PDF
Top 5 Trusted Places to Buy LinkedIn Accounts in the USA.pdf
byBuy LinkedIn Accounts
 
PDF
First Equity BOD New Copper Licences 26 Jan 2026
byJames AH Campbell
 
PDF
Gmail Accounts and Email Communication Architecture: An Academic Study of Dig...
bythumberjames7
 
DOCX
Why Should I Buy Old Gmail Accounts_losangeless _______________.docx
byjoshuabellc7
 
Proven Ways to Buy Verified PayPal Accounts in Los Angeles Safely.docx
byUsaservicepoint
 
IFS state pension.pdf From IFS and Oxford
byHenry Tapper
 
Using-pension-savings-to-support-home-ownership.pdf
byHenry Tapper
 
How to Buy Facebook Verified Accounts_ A Guide.docx
byDigital Marketing in the USA
 
RI&E Checklist MKB (2026) – Voorbereiding, Toetsing & Plan van Aanpak PDF
byRIEklaar.nl
 
Buy Tripadvisor Reviews From $15 Per Review _ 100% Safe.docx
bymarketing
 
Legal Status & Safety of Verified Cash App Accounts Explained (Year 2026).docx
byBuy Verified Cash App Accounts
 
Best 55 Sites for Buying Verified Venmo Accounts in 2026.docx
bymarketing
 
Laura Sergio - Specializing In Helping Small Businesses
byLaura Sergio
 
Exterior Front Entry Door Design Trends, 2025–2026
bydoornmore
 
V3Cube On-Demand House Cleaning App Solution
byV3CUBE TECHNOLABS
 
Kirill Klip GEM Royalty TNR Gold Copper Presentation
byKirill Klip
 
Where and why Buy Verified Binance Accounts With Full KYC ....pdf
byhttps://propvaservice.com/
 
Production and Ops - 1 Unit-I-Foundation to Production and Operations Managem...
byDavies Chacko
 
Startup 8 - Student's Book - ENGLISH - Advanced 2
byenglishcloudresource
 
Top 10 Sites to Buy Aged Snapchat Accounts in 2026.docx
byBuyGmailAccounts10
 
Top 5 Trusted Places to Buy LinkedIn Accounts in the USA.pdf
byBuy LinkedIn Accounts
 
First Equity BOD New Copper Licences 26 Jan 2026
byJames AH Campbell
 
Gmail Accounts and Email Communication Architecture: An Academic Study of Dig...
bythumberjames7
 
Why Should I Buy Old Gmail Accounts_losangeless _______________.docx
byjoshuabellc7
 

Tender evaluation procedure

  • 1.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 1 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT TENDER EVALUATION -JKR PROCEDURE
  • 2.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 2 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT COURSE OUTCOME • Enable to understand the tender evaluation process. • Knowledge on tender evaluation stages and the criteria involved. • Enable to know all information needed during tender. • Enable to strategize work during tender stages.
  • 3.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 3 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT OBJECTIVES • To determine and to recommend to the Board of Procurement a tender which offers the most profit to the GOVERNMENT. Only contractor which has the financial and technical capabilities is eligible for Award and Acceptance.
  • 4.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 4 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION PROCESS 6. Issuing of tender Acceptance letter 5. Determine budget 4. Treasury (if applicable) 3. Procurement board 2. Processing tender 1. Tender opening committee In validity Tender period Tender evaluation must be done in validity of tender period (minimum 90 days) from tender closing date.
  • 5.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 5 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION PROCESS FIRST STAGE Tender price adjustment Arrange the tender price (from low to high) Price reasonableness based on budget or “cut-off” Determine the number of tenderers to be evaluated SECOND STAGE Tender compliance Tender compliance analysis Completeness of document analysis Adequacy of minimum capital analsys THIRD STAGE Experience and capability Tenderer experience analysis Technical personnel analysis qualify qualify Rejected Contractor Not Fulfill requirement Not Fulfill requirement Not Fulfill requirement
  • 6.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 6 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT CRITERIA • PWD practice tender evaluation procedure has been divided into 3 categories, namely: i. Large projects (more than RM10.0 million) ii. Medium projects (RM2.0 million to RM10.0 million) iii. Small projects (less than RM2.0 million)
  • 7.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 7 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT INFORMATION FORMS a) Borang A – Surat pengakuan kebenaran maklumat dan kesahihan dokumen yang dikemukakan pentender a) Borang B – Maklumat am latarbelakang pentender b) Borang C – Data-data kewangan c) Borang CA – Laporan Bank/Institusi Kewangan d) Borang D – Rekod pengalaman kerja e) Borang E – Kakitangan teknikal f) Borang F – Keempunyaan loji dan peralatan pembinaan asas g) Borang G – Senarai kontrak kerja semasa h) Borang GA-1 – Laporan Jurutera Projek (JKR) i) Borang GA-2 – Laporan Jurutera Projek (Swasta) CRITERIA - INFORMATION REQUIRED
  • 8.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 8 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT OTHERS DOCUMENT i. Audited account copy for last 2 years ii. Account bank statement copy for last 3 months iii. Bank report / financial institution (sealed) iv. Copy of the certificate / confirmation of completion for each project listed in Form D and G v. EPF statement and a copy of Form A or copy service agreement for contract staff vi. Copy of the certificate of approval of technical staff vii. Copy of Grant / hire-purchase agreement plant / equipment viii. Copies of the final interim payment certificate for the current project ix. Project report (sealed) CRITERIA - INFORMATION REQUIRED
  • 9.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 9 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Sample of summary of tender submission
  • 10.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 10 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - FIRST STAGE • Preparation need to be done by evaluator before start any tender evaluation process such as: • Prepare summary of tender in ascending order based on tender table prepared by Tender Opening Committee. . Prepare tender analysis based on cut-off pricing. . Select list of tenderers to be evaluated. . Check and fill up Checklist of Compulsory Documents. . Prepare analysis of percentage (%) of price distribution and obtain agreement from tenderers. . Carry out arithmetic checking.
  • 11.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 11 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Number of tenderer should be assessed is between 15-20 tenderer to produce between 3- 5 tenderer who will pass. • "Range" of tenderer can be selected is between + / - 20% (+ / - 25% for Civil Engineering) from the Mean Price. • For the tenderers who are below the "cut-off" will be checked the compulsory document first. Select tenderer with special criteria to be evaluated. • For tenderers who are outside the “cut-off” to be referred to tender committee for consideration. EVALUATION STAGES - FIRST STAGE
  • 12.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 12 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • A system of evaluation based on predetermined conditions to ascertain whether tenderers are eligible for further evaluation. • Evaluation Criteria: i. Analysis on Compliance to Tender ii. Analysis on Completeness of tender documents. iii. Analysis on Adequacy of Capital iv. Analysis on performance of current work. • Objectives: To ensure tenders under consideration are reasonable, in compliance, complete, have adequate capital and have good current work performance free from sick project, EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
  • 13.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 13 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT i. Analysis on Compliance to Tender EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE • Only Tenderers which comply and free from any imperfection in term of legal and contractual which may jeopardize their qualification based on current practice are to be considered. – To check if form of tender has been signed by tenderers – The signing person has been given the power to sign. – To check if tender price is stated in the form of tender. – Are PKK/CIDB registration still valid. – Has tenderer returned all the basic tender documents, – Check proposed construction period is stated in the form of tender. – Failure to submit any of the forms of tender may effect the ranking of tenderer,
  • 14.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 14 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Common mistakes during filling of forms of tender EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE FORM OF TENDER NOT SIGNED FORM OF TENDER NOT SIGNED
  • 15.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 15 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT SIGNED ON WRONG FORM
  • 16.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 16 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Summary of Tender Price TENDER PRICE
  • 17.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 17 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT SIJIL PKK SIGNING PERSON GIVEN POWER VALIDITY PERIOD AHMAD BIN ABU
  • 18.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 18 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT CIDB CERTIFICATE VALIDITY PERIOD
  • 19.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 19 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT TENDER PRICE NOT STATED CONTRACT PERIOD NOT STATED FORM OF TENDER
  • 20.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 20 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT PRICE IN FIGURES PRICE IN WORDS FORM OF TENDER
  • 21.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 21 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT ii. Analysis on Completeness of Tender a) Tender which is complete and comply to the requirement of tender/regulation/Authority. b) Mandatory Tender Documents includes: i. Forms of Tender ii. List of Quantity/ Summary of Tender iii. Addendum (if any) iv. Schedule of rates v. Design proposal, specification, pricing by contractor etc. (where applicable) as required to enable design work by tenderer to be evaluated. EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
  • 22.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 22 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE OTHERS - Analysis on Construction Period • Ensure the construction period offers by tenderers is analysed such as: a) not exceeding the maximum construction period stated in the tender document. b) Construction period if offerred by tenderer is not too short that it becomes unreasonable
  • 23.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 23 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE Analysis on Completeness of Tender
  • 24.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 24 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT ii. Analysis on Completeness of Tender EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE MANDATORY DOCUMENTS a) Audited account copy for last 2 years, or Account bank statement copy for last 3 months, or Bank report / financial institution (sealed) b) Project report by project superintendence officer Without mandatory documents (especially regarding financial) evaluation of tenders can not be made and therefore tender will be rejected.
  • 25.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 25 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Balance Sheet statement EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
  • 26.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 26 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Current Bank Statement EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
  • 27.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 27 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE Financial Statement Report
  • 28.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 28 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE ii. Analysis on Completeness of Tender
  • 29.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 29 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE iii. Analysis on Adequacy of Minimum Capital Method of calculation i. Rolling capital = asset liability – current liability ii. Bank account = average of latest 3 months iii. Make comparison between rolling capital and bank account. Select the higher amount iv. Include credit facilities report v. Add (+) iii and iv = total liquidated capital (>3%)
  • 30.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 30 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT MINIMA CAPITAL EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE iii. Analysis on Adequacy of Minimum Capital Sample of calculation for minimum capital 3% from value of construction work. Tender price = RM 1,000,000.00 PC Sum = RM 50,000.00 Provisional Sum = RM 50,000.00 Construction work value = RM 900,000.00 So, 3% = RM 27,000.00
  • 31.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 31 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE iii. Analysis on Adequacy of Minimum Capital Forms of Capital a) Rolling capital b) Shares, unit trust, fixed deposit, Bond c) Balance of credit facilities For joint venture tender submission, minimum capital is analyse based on combined equity agreed by both parties.
  • 32.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 32 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Adequacy of Minimum Capital EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
  • 33.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 33 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Work still on progress during the tendering process (Form D, G and GA) • No sick project – below 30% of work schedule • No termination record • Checking will carry out through; i. PKK / CIDB / JKR scale ii. Superintendence project report iii. T.K.S. if no project on hand. EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE iii. Analysis on performance of current work
  • 34.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 34 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Current progress report
  • 35.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 35 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - SECOND STAGE
  • 36.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 36 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE REASONABLE FACTORS Faktor Civil Building Mechancal / Enginering work Electrical ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Financial capability 45% 50% 50% Technical Work experience 35% 35% 35% Technical staffs 15% 10% 15% Machineries / plant 5% 5% 0% ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 100% 100% 100% ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  • 37.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 37 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE FINANCIAL CAPABILITY (Financial Bid Capacity) = Working capital Yearly project value i. Financial Capability
  • 38.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 38 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Working experiences • Technical staff • Machineries / plant EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE ii. Technical • Working experience Evaluation criteria -. Completed total work value past 5 years - Largest work value done in past 5 years - Type of work is limited to recognized work Comparable or similar (follow by head / sub-head
  • 39.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 39 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Technical staff Evaluation criteria -. Number and working experience of technical staff compares with Estimate Minimum Requirement EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE CONSTRUCTION WORK VALUECONSTRUCTION WORK VALUE BUILDINGBUILDING CIVIL ENGINEERINGCIVIL ENGINEERING CATCAT AA CATCAT BB CATCAT CC CATCAT AA CATCAT BB CATCAT CC More than RM5.0 m and not moreMore than RM5.0 m and not more than RM 8.0 mthan RM 8.0 m More than RM8.0 m and not moreMore than RM8.0 m and not more than RM 15.0 mthan RM 15.0 m More than RM15.0 m and not moreMore than RM15.0 m and not more than RM 25.0 jutathan RM 25.0 juta More than RM25.0 m and not moreMore than RM25.0 m and not more than RM 50.0 mthan RM 50.0 m More than RM50.0 mMore than RM50.0 m 11 22 33 55 88 33 44 77 1111 1818 33 44 77 1111 1818 22 33 55 88 1313 33 44 77 1111 1919 44 55 99 1414 2323
  • 40.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 40 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE Staff categories: • Category A (Engineer, architect, quantity surveyor) • Category B (Diploma, Technician / polytechnic) • Category C (assistant technician)) Must be employed by employer during tendering • Certificate and KWSP • For contract staff – Contract agreement • Technical staff
  • 41.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 41 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Machineries / plants EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE Plant and equipment that could be accounted is limited to: • As listed in the Estimated Minimum Requirement. Plants / machineries can be considered if function equivalently • Owned / hire-purchase before the closing of tender • Useful life not exceeding 150 years • If rent-mortgage, the agreement should cover the contract period.
  • 42.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 42 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT EVALUATION STAGES - THIRD STAGE Minimum Score CriteriaCriteria Minimum ScoreMinimum Score BWBW CECE M&EM&E 1.1. Financial capabilityFinancial capability 2.2. Technical capabilityTechnical capability 3.3. Overall capabilityOverall capability 20.020.0 12.512.5 45.045.0 18.018.0 13.813.8 45.545.5 20.020.0 12.512.5 45.045.0
  • 43.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 43 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT SPECIAL CRITERIA • Tender submission which is below the “cut- off” price and passes Stage 2 Tender Evaluation can be considered if comply to the following criteria: - Excellent performance for current project and completed project for the last 5 years. - Good quality workmanship - Tender price not less than -20% of the “cut-off” price - Tender price is not too unreasonable (Freak).
  • 44.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 44 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Examples of low tender price can be considered. - Own factory for main building materials - Currently undertake equivalent construction work at neighboring site - Own scaffolding / formwork for recently completed project - For roadwork / earthwork – own plants and machineries readily available for use - Satisfactorily completed 3 projects of similar nature consecutively prior to this tender SPECIAL CRITERIA
  • 45.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 45 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT OTHERS ANALYSIS • Arithmetic checking • Table for price comparison - comparison of price for every building category with the estimated price prepared by consultant by each tenderer taking into account the arithmetic checking
  • 46.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 46 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT OTHERS ANALYSIS
  • 47.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 47 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT COMMITTEE ENDORSEMENT FOR EVALUATION REPORT • Ensure tenderer is not too occupied with on going project. • If the lowest tender price is too high as compared to estimated mean price, recommendation by committee should be: – Award the tender to the lowest tenderer – Decline all tender offer and re-tender. • Recommendation should list down at least five (5) tenderers in ascending order who had passed each stage of evaluation. • Joint signature by qualified three (3) tender committee members • Prepare Q14A/2005/A form for result of tender together with complete tender evaluation report
  • 48.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 48 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT • Step to be undertaken if there is any fake documents are detected. - check all submitted documents, and verify in compulsory document checklist. - Check with the parties which is responsible to supply the document. (if suspicious arise) - Verification of fake document should be in writing. - Ensure the affected tenderer not to be recommended - Lodge a police report and send the report to CIDB and PKK. - Evaluation officer to request show cause letter from tenderer via CIDB and PKK TENDER EVALUATION REPORT
  • 49.
    August 29, 2013NURUL ASRA ABD RAHMAN 49 COURSE OUTCOME OBJECTIVES EVALUATION PROCESS CRITERIA EVALUATION STAGES SPECIAL CRITERIA OTHERS ANALYSIS ENDORSEMENT TENDER REPORT Thank You