Guideline Summary:
When to Start ART

             Guidelines for the Use of
                 Antiretroviral Agents
            in Adults and Adolescents
                 Andy Catanzaro, MD
                  Infectious Diseases
      acatanzaro@unityhealthcare.org

                          March 2012
Outline

     Overview of HIV therapy
     Initiation of Therapy
     Special Issues




2                               October 2011   www.aidsetc.org
HIV Terms/Acronyms
    Terms

ART: Antiretroviral Therapy
HIV Viral Load: amount of virus in the blood
Undetectable Viral Load: Goal of Therapy
CD4 Count: Immune Marker
Genotype: Sensitivity of the Virus to
 Medications



3                              October 2011   www.aidsetc.org
Goal of HIV Therapy: Stop the Virus!
What are ‘The Guidelines’ for HIV Therapy

Independent panel of experts
Review Current Literature on HIV
Make Recommendations
Strength of Evidence given for each
  guidance



              (www.aidsinfo.nih.gov)

                                       October 2011   www.aidsetc.org
What the Guidelines Address

       Baseline evaluation
       Laboratory testing
       When to initiate & change therapy
       Therapeutic options
       ART-associated adverse effects




6
What the Guidelines Address

     Treatment of acute HIV infection
     Special considerations (pregnant,
      injection drug users, coinfected with
      HBV, HCV, or TB)
     Preventing secondary transmission




7
Websites to Access the Guidelines

     http://aidsinfo.nih.gov
     http://www.aidsetc.org




8
Goals of Treatment

 Improve quality of life
 Reduce HIV-related morbidity and
  mortality
 Restore and/or preserve immunologic
  function
 Suppress HIV viral load
 Prevent HIV transmission


9
Use of CD4 Cell Levels to Guide
     Therapy Decisions
 CD4 count
          The major indicator of immune function
          Most recent CD4 count is best predictor of
           disease progression
          A key factor in decision to start prophylaxis
          Important in determining response to ART
              Adequate response: CD4 increase 50-150 cells/µL per year




     *




10
Studies in patients CD4>500

 Favor Treatment    Neutral on Treatment
      NA-ACCORD       ART-CC
                       CASCADE




11
ART in Treatment Recommended for
All Patients

CD4 count   Strength of the   Evidence for the
            Recommendation    Recommendation
<350        Strong            Data from randomized clinical trials
350-500     Strong            Data from non-randomized clinical
                              trials
>500        Moderate          Expert Opinion




12
Use of HIV RNA Levels to Guide
      Therapy Decisions

      HIV RNA
        May influence choice of ART
        Critical in monitoring response to ART
          Goal of ART: HIV RNA below limit of detection
           (ie, <20-75 copies/mL, depending on assay)




13
Use of HIV RNA Levels to Guide
      Therapy Decisions (2)
      RNA monitoring
        Check at baseline
        Before initiating ART
        2-4 weeks (not more than 8 weeks) after start or change of
         ART, then every 4-8 weeks until suppressed to <200
         copies/mL
        Every 3-4 months with stable patients; may consider every 6
         months for stable adherent patients with VL suppression >2-3
         years
        Isolated “blips” may occur (transient low-level RNA, typically
         <400 copies/mL), are not thought to predict virologic failure
            ACTG defines virologic failure as confirmed HIV RNA >200 copies/
             mL




14
When to Start ART
 Potent ART may improve and preserve immune
  function in most patients with virologic suppression,
  regardless of baseline CD4 count
      ART indicated for all with low CD4 count or symptoms
      Earlier ART may result in better immunologic responses
       and better clinical outcomes
         Reduction in AIDS- and non-AIDS-associated morbidity and
          mortality
            Reduction in HIV-associated inflammation and associated
             complications
         Reduction in HIV transmission
      Recommended ARV combinations are considered to be
       durable and tolerable

15
When to Start ART
 Exact CD4 count at which to initiate therapy not known,
  but evidence points to starting at higher counts
 Current recommendation: ART for all patients with CD4
      Randomized control trial (RTC) data support benefit of ART if
       CD4 count ≤350 cells/µL
      No RTC data on benefit of ART at CD4 counts of >350 cells/µL,
       but observational cohort data exist
 Currently available ARVs are effective and well tolerated




16
Potential Benefits of Early Therapy
     (CD4 count >500 cells/µL)

 Cohort study data show survival benefit if ART
  initiated at CD4 count >500 cells/µL
 Earlier ART may prevent HIV-related end organ
  damage; deferred ART may not reliably repair
  damage acquired earlier
      Increasing evidence of direct HIV effects on various
       end organs and indirect effects via HIV-associated
       inflammation
      End organ damage occurs at all stages of infection



17
Potential Benefits of Early Therapy
     (CD4 count >500 cells/µL) (2)

 Potential decrease in risk of many
  complications, including:
      HIV-associated nephropathy
      Liver disease progression from hepatitis B or
       hepatitis C
      Cardiovascular disease
      Malignancies (AIDS defining and non-AIDS defining)
      Neurocognitive decline
      Blunted immunological response owing to ART
       initiation at older age
      Persistent T-cell activation and inflammation

18
Potential Benefits of Early Therapy
     (CD4 count >500 cells/µL) (3)



 Prevention of sexual and blood borne
  transmission of HIV
 Prevention of mother-to-child
  transmission of HIV
 Prevention of transmission to a sexual
  partner



19
Potential Limitations of Early Therapy
 (CD4 count >500 cells/µL)


    ARV-related toxicities
    Drug resistance
    Non-adherence to ART
    Cost




20
Recommendations for Initiating ART (3)

 Patients may choose to postpone ART
 Providers may elect to defer ART, based on
  patients’ clinical or psychosocial factors
      caveat: do we really know who is ready?




21
Consider More Rapid Initiation of ART
(e.g. before the genotype is available)
    Pregnancy
    Acute opportunistic infection
    Lower CD4 count (eg, <200 cells/µL)
    Rapid decline in CD4
    Higher viral load
    HIV Associated Nephropathy
    HBV coinfection when HBV treatment is indicated


22
Consider Deferral of ART

 Clinical or personal factors may support deferral
  of ART
      If CD4 count is low, deferral should be considered
       only in unusual situations, and with close follow-up
 When there are significant barriers to adherence
 If comorbidities complicate or prohibit ART
 “Elite controllers” and long-term nonprogressors




23
Initial ART Regimens: DHHS Categories
 Preferred
      Randomized controlled trials show optimal efficacy and
       durability
      Favorable tolerability and toxicity profiles




24
Initial Treatment: Choosing Regimens
       3 main categories:
          1 Non-nucleoside Reductase Inhibitor + 2 Nucleside
           Reductase Inhibitor (NRTI)
          1 Protease Inhibitor + 2 NRTIs
          1 Integrase Inhibitor + 2 NRTIs
       Combinations preferred for most patients
       (Bias: Once Daily Preferred by patients)




25
Initial Therapy: Fixed Dose Combinations

Preferred:        Once-daily dosing
                  High virologic efficacy
TDF/FTC           Active against HBV
(Truvada)         Potential for renal toxicity

Alternative:    Once-daily dosing
                Risk of hypersensitivity reaction if positive for
ABC/3TC          HLA-B*5701
(Epzicom)       Possible inferior efficacy if baseline HIV RNA
                 >100,000 copies/mL
                Active against HBV


Acceptable:        Twice-daily dosing
                   Preferred for pregnant women
ZDV/3TC            More toxicities than TDF/FTC or ABC/3TC
(Combivir)

26
Initial Regimens: Preferred

NNRTI based                     EFV/TDF/FTC (Atripla) 1,
Protease        ATV/r (Reyataz/Norvir) + TDF/
Inhibitor       FTC (Truvada)
 based          DRV/r (Prezista/Norvir) + TDF/
                FTC (Truvada)²
Integrase       RAL (Isentress BID) +
Inhibitor based TDF/FTC (Truvada)
Pregnant women LPV/r (Kaletra BID) +
                ZDV/3TC (Combivir)²
   1. EFV should not be used during the first trimester of pregnancy or in
   women trying to conceive or not using effective and consistent
27 contraception.
Drug-Drug Interactions

Too Common
Always check new medications
Resources: Guidelines, Uptodate,
  Epocrates




                             October 2011   www.aidsetc.org
Websites to Access the Guidelines

        http://www.aidsetc.org
        http://aidsinfo.nih.gov




29

SYNCing Guidelines- Catanzaro

  • 1.
    Guideline Summary: When toStart ART Guidelines for the Use of Antiretroviral Agents in Adults and Adolescents Andy Catanzaro, MD Infectious Diseases acatanzaro@unityhealthcare.org March 2012
  • 2.
    Outline  Overview of HIV therapy  Initiation of Therapy  Special Issues 2 October 2011 www.aidsetc.org
  • 3.
    HIV Terms/Acronyms Terms ART: Antiretroviral Therapy HIV Viral Load: amount of virus in the blood Undetectable Viral Load: Goal of Therapy CD4 Count: Immune Marker Genotype: Sensitivity of the Virus to Medications 3 October 2011 www.aidsetc.org
  • 4.
    Goal of HIVTherapy: Stop the Virus!
  • 5.
    What are ‘TheGuidelines’ for HIV Therapy Independent panel of experts Review Current Literature on HIV Make Recommendations Strength of Evidence given for each guidance (www.aidsinfo.nih.gov) October 2011 www.aidsetc.org
  • 6.
    What the GuidelinesAddress  Baseline evaluation  Laboratory testing  When to initiate & change therapy  Therapeutic options  ART-associated adverse effects 6
  • 7.
    What the GuidelinesAddress  Treatment of acute HIV infection  Special considerations (pregnant, injection drug users, coinfected with HBV, HCV, or TB)  Preventing secondary transmission 7
  • 8.
    Websites to Accessthe Guidelines  http://aidsinfo.nih.gov  http://www.aidsetc.org 8
  • 9.
    Goals of Treatment Improve quality of life  Reduce HIV-related morbidity and mortality  Restore and/or preserve immunologic function  Suppress HIV viral load  Prevent HIV transmission 9
  • 10.
    Use of CD4Cell Levels to Guide Therapy Decisions  CD4 count  The major indicator of immune function  Most recent CD4 count is best predictor of disease progression  A key factor in decision to start prophylaxis  Important in determining response to ART  Adequate response: CD4 increase 50-150 cells/µL per year * 10
  • 11.
    Studies in patientsCD4>500  Favor Treatment  Neutral on Treatment  NA-ACCORD  ART-CC  CASCADE 11
  • 12.
    ART in TreatmentRecommended for All Patients CD4 count Strength of the Evidence for the Recommendation Recommendation <350 Strong Data from randomized clinical trials 350-500 Strong Data from non-randomized clinical trials >500 Moderate Expert Opinion 12
  • 13.
    Use of HIVRNA Levels to Guide Therapy Decisions  HIV RNA  May influence choice of ART  Critical in monitoring response to ART  Goal of ART: HIV RNA below limit of detection (ie, <20-75 copies/mL, depending on assay) 13
  • 14.
    Use of HIVRNA Levels to Guide Therapy Decisions (2)  RNA monitoring  Check at baseline  Before initiating ART  2-4 weeks (not more than 8 weeks) after start or change of ART, then every 4-8 weeks until suppressed to <200 copies/mL  Every 3-4 months with stable patients; may consider every 6 months for stable adherent patients with VL suppression >2-3 years  Isolated “blips” may occur (transient low-level RNA, typically <400 copies/mL), are not thought to predict virologic failure  ACTG defines virologic failure as confirmed HIV RNA >200 copies/ mL 14
  • 15.
    When to StartART  Potent ART may improve and preserve immune function in most patients with virologic suppression, regardless of baseline CD4 count  ART indicated for all with low CD4 count or symptoms  Earlier ART may result in better immunologic responses and better clinical outcomes  Reduction in AIDS- and non-AIDS-associated morbidity and mortality  Reduction in HIV-associated inflammation and associated complications  Reduction in HIV transmission  Recommended ARV combinations are considered to be durable and tolerable 15
  • 16.
    When to StartART  Exact CD4 count at which to initiate therapy not known, but evidence points to starting at higher counts  Current recommendation: ART for all patients with CD4  Randomized control trial (RTC) data support benefit of ART if CD4 count ≤350 cells/µL  No RTC data on benefit of ART at CD4 counts of >350 cells/µL, but observational cohort data exist  Currently available ARVs are effective and well tolerated 16
  • 17.
    Potential Benefits ofEarly Therapy (CD4 count >500 cells/µL)  Cohort study data show survival benefit if ART initiated at CD4 count >500 cells/µL  Earlier ART may prevent HIV-related end organ damage; deferred ART may not reliably repair damage acquired earlier  Increasing evidence of direct HIV effects on various end organs and indirect effects via HIV-associated inflammation  End organ damage occurs at all stages of infection 17
  • 18.
    Potential Benefits ofEarly Therapy (CD4 count >500 cells/µL) (2)  Potential decrease in risk of many complications, including:  HIV-associated nephropathy  Liver disease progression from hepatitis B or hepatitis C  Cardiovascular disease  Malignancies (AIDS defining and non-AIDS defining)  Neurocognitive decline  Blunted immunological response owing to ART initiation at older age  Persistent T-cell activation and inflammation 18
  • 19.
    Potential Benefits ofEarly Therapy (CD4 count >500 cells/µL) (3)  Prevention of sexual and blood borne transmission of HIV  Prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV  Prevention of transmission to a sexual partner 19
  • 20.
    Potential Limitations ofEarly Therapy (CD4 count >500 cells/µL)  ARV-related toxicities  Drug resistance  Non-adherence to ART  Cost 20
  • 21.
    Recommendations for InitiatingART (3)  Patients may choose to postpone ART  Providers may elect to defer ART, based on patients’ clinical or psychosocial factors  caveat: do we really know who is ready? 21
  • 22.
    Consider More RapidInitiation of ART (e.g. before the genotype is available)  Pregnancy  Acute opportunistic infection  Lower CD4 count (eg, <200 cells/µL)  Rapid decline in CD4  Higher viral load  HIV Associated Nephropathy  HBV coinfection when HBV treatment is indicated 22
  • 23.
    Consider Deferral ofART  Clinical or personal factors may support deferral of ART  If CD4 count is low, deferral should be considered only in unusual situations, and with close follow-up  When there are significant barriers to adherence  If comorbidities complicate or prohibit ART  “Elite controllers” and long-term nonprogressors 23
  • 24.
    Initial ART Regimens:DHHS Categories  Preferred  Randomized controlled trials show optimal efficacy and durability  Favorable tolerability and toxicity profiles 24
  • 25.
    Initial Treatment: ChoosingRegimens  3 main categories:  1 Non-nucleoside Reductase Inhibitor + 2 Nucleside Reductase Inhibitor (NRTI)  1 Protease Inhibitor + 2 NRTIs  1 Integrase Inhibitor + 2 NRTIs  Combinations preferred for most patients  (Bias: Once Daily Preferred by patients) 25
  • 26.
    Initial Therapy: FixedDose Combinations Preferred:  Once-daily dosing  High virologic efficacy TDF/FTC  Active against HBV (Truvada)  Potential for renal toxicity Alternative:  Once-daily dosing  Risk of hypersensitivity reaction if positive for ABC/3TC HLA-B*5701 (Epzicom)  Possible inferior efficacy if baseline HIV RNA >100,000 copies/mL  Active against HBV Acceptable:  Twice-daily dosing  Preferred for pregnant women ZDV/3TC  More toxicities than TDF/FTC or ABC/3TC (Combivir) 26
  • 27.
    Initial Regimens: Preferred NNRTIbased EFV/TDF/FTC (Atripla) 1, Protease ATV/r (Reyataz/Norvir) + TDF/ Inhibitor FTC (Truvada) based DRV/r (Prezista/Norvir) + TDF/ FTC (Truvada)² Integrase RAL (Isentress BID) + Inhibitor based TDF/FTC (Truvada) Pregnant women LPV/r (Kaletra BID) + ZDV/3TC (Combivir)² 1. EFV should not be used during the first trimester of pregnancy or in women trying to conceive or not using effective and consistent 27 contraception.
  • 28.
    Drug-Drug Interactions Too Common Alwayscheck new medications Resources: Guidelines, Uptodate, Epocrates October 2011 www.aidsetc.org
  • 29.
    Websites to Accessthe Guidelines  http://www.aidsetc.org  http://aidsinfo.nih.gov 29

Editor's Notes

  • #26 Summary of Recommended Regimens The most extensively studied combination antiretroviral regimens for treatment-naïve patients generally consist of two NRTIs plus either one NNRTI or a PI (with or without ritonavir boosting). A list of Panel-recommended components for initial therapy in treatment-naïve patients can be found in Table 6 . Potential advantages and disadvantages of the components recommended as initial therapy for treatment-naïve patients are listed in Table 7 to guide prescribers in choosing the regimen best suited for an individual patient. A list of agents or components not recommended for initial treatment can be found in Table 8 . Some agents or components that are not recommended for use because of lack of potency or potential serious safety concerns are listed in Table 9