Sustainable Neighborhood Design
Criteria for Afghan Cities
Osama HIDAYAT
24 May 2016
Overview
Background
Current
Research Conclusion
Necessity of Research
 Dysfunctional pattern of urban growth;
 Increasing pollution and cost of land and resources.
Jaada-e-Maiwand (Source: Noori, 2009)
Chronological Timeline
ARG (Presidential Palace)
built in 1880 by king Abdur
Rahman Khan in capital Kabul.
Ambitus urban programmes
of modernization were
launched in major cities.
The deepening conflict
between the soviet-
supported government and
Mujahidin factions impact
on urban development
Focused on the spatial
development of the city, including
new capital in Darulaman
Modernization and urban
development efforts
continued, including ministry
buildings and public facilities.
1880 1920 1950 1970 1985 2016
Kabul New City Master plan
Research Question
 what might constitute a sustainable neighborhood or
community.
 How can we define sustainability principles and criteria in
neighborhoods for various periods of time and different spatial
circumstances?
Current Problems
 The Dispersal of Population and Activities
 Centralization of Services and Facilities
Desire line of year 2008 over existing urban areas in Kabul city
Internally Displaced People (IDP’s)
and Squatter Settlements
Kabul City squatter settlement updated 06/2013, 63 Settlements mapped.
Source: IMMAP/USAID, Kabul.
Improving Current Land Use Trends
 Development Density
• Less land is required for
development,
• The potential to use energy more
efficiently.
 Accessibility to Public Transport
• Reduce reliance on car.
 Provision Local Employment,
Services and Facilities
Work
21%
School
20%
Business
4%Private
7%
Home
48%
Trip Composition by Purpose
Source: JICA- KMA Report 2008
Administration and Management
 Neighborhood Sustainability Assessment Standard
• Evaluate and rate the performance of a given neighborhood;
• Specify the extent of the neighborhood’s success in approaching
sustainability goals.
 Enlist public participation regularly in decision making
Design Guidelines for Neighborhood
Sustainability
Land Use
Conservation
Energy Use and
Conservation
Walkability and
Cycling
Network
Land Use Conservation
 Different choices of
housing;
• Reduce dwelling lot size;
• Neighborhood variations
 Include mix-use area;
 Street pattern and type.
Land use plan for the proposed neighborhood
Passive Architectural Strategies
for Energy Use and Conservation
 In sustainable development, the built environment
should be designed in response to the site
microclimatic conditions;
 Some aspects of importance that need to be
considered in the planning process
Sun
 Considering and incorporating
the effects of the sun on
buildings into a design may
reduce energy consumption by
as much as 30% (Brooks 1988).
 Developing the Passive House
Standards (PHS) that provides
sustainable solutions to energy
needs can be a good starting
point.
Psychrometric chart showing daily temperature ranges per year in
Kabul. The range indicates that passive solar heating is the most
effective climate responsive design strategy
Source: IHFD, Feasibility study for a housing complex in Kabul. 2012
Passive Solar Heating
Thermal Mass Effects
Natural Ventilation
Direct Evaporative Cooling
Thermal Insulation of Buildings
Indoor temperature hours with internal gains in Kabul
Source: IHFD, Feasibility study for a housing complex in Kabul. 2012
 Install shading devices and employ night ventilation
 Can drop the indoor temperature by 3-4 Co
 Use better glazing windows to maximize the use of solar gain.
Wind
 Wind direction is another element that must be integrated into
neighborhood design.
Wind direction over the entire year
Source: IHFD, Feasibility study for a housing complex in Kabul. 2012
 Streets should be gently curving and houses should be closer to street’s
edge,
 Setback should vary slightly from house to house to avoid aligning front
facades
Walkability & Cycling Network
 The key motivation behind this
interest is that travel by non-
motorized modes constitutes an
environmentally sustainable and a
physically active transportation
choice;
Walk
33%
Bike
11%Microbus
18%
Minibus
6%
Large Bus
14%
Taxi
12%
Car
4%
Truck
2%
Trip Composition by Main Transport Mode
Source: JICA- KMA Report 2008
Commercial and Civic amenities can be placed in close proximity to each other to foster walkability
A
Offices above stores
B
Apartments above stores
C
Shopping strip
D
Homes
Walkable Neighborhood
Conceptual Movement structure along with cycling route
Movement Structure (Appendix)
Preliminary Findings
Characteristic Traditional Neighborhood
Design
Sustainable Neighborhood
Design
Land-use diversity Single use: predominantly
residential, with designated
areas of clustered retail;
segregated use base
Integrated mix-use:
neighborhood based with
integrated residential, retail,
commercial and institutional
Street pattern & type Straight-linear and hierarchical;
Traffic dispersed
Inter-connected network; flatter
hierarchy of types;
Traffic dispersed
Residential lot size
and housing density
Average lot size: 600m2
Typical density: 11 lots/ha
Average lot size: 500m2
Typical density: 14 lot/ha
Dominant retail type Regional, serving shopping
centers, chai stores
Neighborhood, serving
Independent retailers
Dominant planning Create comfortable housing Create community; affordable
housing; jobs containment
Comparison of design for Kabul: Traditional vs Sustainable neighborhoods
Conclusion
 The microclimate consideration in buildings and
preserving green spaces in neighborhoods are making
our cities more energy efficient;
 Neighborhood Sustainability Assessment needs to be
customized for being applied to Afghan cities;
 Promoting mon-motorized modes of transport means
lower emission and lower emission can mean cleaner
environment;
 adopting the recommendations systematically will be a
significant long-term resource, bring monetary savings,
and preserve the historical and cultural heritage of cities.
Thank you from your attention

Sustainable Neighborhood Design

  • 1.
    Sustainable Neighborhood Design Criteriafor Afghan Cities Osama HIDAYAT 24 May 2016
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Necessity of Research Dysfunctional pattern of urban growth;  Increasing pollution and cost of land and resources. Jaada-e-Maiwand (Source: Noori, 2009)
  • 4.
    Chronological Timeline ARG (PresidentialPalace) built in 1880 by king Abdur Rahman Khan in capital Kabul. Ambitus urban programmes of modernization were launched in major cities. The deepening conflict between the soviet- supported government and Mujahidin factions impact on urban development Focused on the spatial development of the city, including new capital in Darulaman Modernization and urban development efforts continued, including ministry buildings and public facilities. 1880 1920 1950 1970 1985 2016 Kabul New City Master plan
  • 5.
    Research Question  whatmight constitute a sustainable neighborhood or community.  How can we define sustainability principles and criteria in neighborhoods for various periods of time and different spatial circumstances?
  • 6.
    Current Problems  TheDispersal of Population and Activities  Centralization of Services and Facilities Desire line of year 2008 over existing urban areas in Kabul city
  • 7.
    Internally Displaced People(IDP’s) and Squatter Settlements Kabul City squatter settlement updated 06/2013, 63 Settlements mapped. Source: IMMAP/USAID, Kabul.
  • 8.
    Improving Current LandUse Trends  Development Density • Less land is required for development, • The potential to use energy more efficiently.  Accessibility to Public Transport • Reduce reliance on car.  Provision Local Employment, Services and Facilities Work 21% School 20% Business 4%Private 7% Home 48% Trip Composition by Purpose Source: JICA- KMA Report 2008
  • 9.
    Administration and Management Neighborhood Sustainability Assessment Standard • Evaluate and rate the performance of a given neighborhood; • Specify the extent of the neighborhood’s success in approaching sustainability goals.  Enlist public participation regularly in decision making
  • 10.
    Design Guidelines forNeighborhood Sustainability Land Use Conservation Energy Use and Conservation Walkability and Cycling Network
  • 11.
    Land Use Conservation Different choices of housing; • Reduce dwelling lot size; • Neighborhood variations  Include mix-use area;  Street pattern and type. Land use plan for the proposed neighborhood
  • 12.
    Passive Architectural Strategies forEnergy Use and Conservation  In sustainable development, the built environment should be designed in response to the site microclimatic conditions;  Some aspects of importance that need to be considered in the planning process
  • 13.
    Sun  Considering andincorporating the effects of the sun on buildings into a design may reduce energy consumption by as much as 30% (Brooks 1988).  Developing the Passive House Standards (PHS) that provides sustainable solutions to energy needs can be a good starting point. Psychrometric chart showing daily temperature ranges per year in Kabul. The range indicates that passive solar heating is the most effective climate responsive design strategy Source: IHFD, Feasibility study for a housing complex in Kabul. 2012 Passive Solar Heating Thermal Mass Effects Natural Ventilation Direct Evaporative Cooling
  • 14.
    Thermal Insulation ofBuildings Indoor temperature hours with internal gains in Kabul Source: IHFD, Feasibility study for a housing complex in Kabul. 2012  Install shading devices and employ night ventilation  Can drop the indoor temperature by 3-4 Co  Use better glazing windows to maximize the use of solar gain.
  • 15.
    Wind  Wind directionis another element that must be integrated into neighborhood design. Wind direction over the entire year Source: IHFD, Feasibility study for a housing complex in Kabul. 2012  Streets should be gently curving and houses should be closer to street’s edge,  Setback should vary slightly from house to house to avoid aligning front facades
  • 16.
    Walkability & CyclingNetwork  The key motivation behind this interest is that travel by non- motorized modes constitutes an environmentally sustainable and a physically active transportation choice; Walk 33% Bike 11%Microbus 18% Minibus 6% Large Bus 14% Taxi 12% Car 4% Truck 2% Trip Composition by Main Transport Mode Source: JICA- KMA Report 2008
  • 17.
    Commercial and Civicamenities can be placed in close proximity to each other to foster walkability A Offices above stores B Apartments above stores C Shopping strip D Homes Walkable Neighborhood
  • 18.
    Conceptual Movement structurealong with cycling route Movement Structure (Appendix)
  • 19.
    Preliminary Findings Characteristic TraditionalNeighborhood Design Sustainable Neighborhood Design Land-use diversity Single use: predominantly residential, with designated areas of clustered retail; segregated use base Integrated mix-use: neighborhood based with integrated residential, retail, commercial and institutional Street pattern & type Straight-linear and hierarchical; Traffic dispersed Inter-connected network; flatter hierarchy of types; Traffic dispersed Residential lot size and housing density Average lot size: 600m2 Typical density: 11 lots/ha Average lot size: 500m2 Typical density: 14 lot/ha Dominant retail type Regional, serving shopping centers, chai stores Neighborhood, serving Independent retailers Dominant planning Create comfortable housing Create community; affordable housing; jobs containment Comparison of design for Kabul: Traditional vs Sustainable neighborhoods
  • 20.
    Conclusion  The microclimateconsideration in buildings and preserving green spaces in neighborhoods are making our cities more energy efficient;  Neighborhood Sustainability Assessment needs to be customized for being applied to Afghan cities;  Promoting mon-motorized modes of transport means lower emission and lower emission can mean cleaner environment;  adopting the recommendations systematically will be a significant long-term resource, bring monetary savings, and preserve the historical and cultural heritage of cities.
  • 21.
    Thank you fromyour attention