Semantic Web, Linked Data
and Education: A Perfect Fit?
           Mathieu d’Aquin
     Knowledge Media Institute, The Open
               University, UK
                @mdaquin
The evolution of
                  (higher) education




From Local to Global
How do we manage that?
(at the technological level)
Metadata for
education already
  But there are
  metadata standards for
learning resources, aren’t
          there?     Yes, my dear, but I’m not
                      sure this answers the
                           question…
So this talk should finish here?
• IEEE LOM
  –   Standard for Learning Object Metadata
  –   Reuse Dublin Core
  –   XML-based
  –   Final draft in 2002
• SCORM
  – Sharable Content Object Reference
    Model
  – Started in 1996 / last edition 2009
• MIT OCW Metadata
  – Open Courseware
  – Reuse IEEE LOM
• LRMI
  –   Learning Resource Metadata Initiative
  –   Started in June 2011, Spec 1.0 (current)
  –   Plan for integration with Schema.org
  –   Does not reuse any of the other
      standards
Why it still does not work




                               http://xkcd.com/927/

Lack of flexibility, too much ambiguity, creating
news silos… Maybe standards are not the
answer?
The Web…
… is quite a great platform


Why don’t we…
… use it to connect educational resources
to each other?
… use it to express the different ways in
which these can be understood and
reused?
… use it to discover, combine and remix
things with different origins and purposes?
Linked Data
 Open University                                     Person: Mathieu
 Website
                                                                                    Publication: Pub1
                                                                           author



                                                              workFor
                     Open University
                     VLE

                                                                                       Course: M366
                                                                           offers
                                       M366 Course
                                       page
                                                        Organisation:
                                                     The Open University
                   Mathieu’s
                   Homepage                                       availableIn
                                                                                               setBook


 Mathieu’s
  List of                       Mathieu’s
Publications                     Twitter             Country: Belgium

                                                                                       Book: Mechatronics


                   The Web                                   The Web of Linked Data
The Web of Linked Data
What is it good for?


   Accessibility and flexibility!

Example: Application at the Open University
The Open University
 • The largest university in the
   UK: 250K students per
   year, 8000 associate
   lecturers, a big campus in
   Milton Keynes
 • Created in 1969
 • Almost entirely open and
   distance learning
 • 13 regional centers, more
   national centers, courses
   available in a large number
   of countries
Applying linked data to the Open UNiversity


Exposed as linked
              DBPedia                                              RAE

data, our data          OpenLearn
                                                       Data from
                                          ORO          Research
interlink with each      Content
                                                        Outputs

other and the
                             Archive of
external world: it            Course
                                                 Library’s
                                                Catalogue
             geonames         Material
becomes part of the                             Of Digital
                                                 Content           data.gov.uk
“global data space”
on the Web                     A/V Material
                                 Podcasts
                                                    University public
                                 iTunesU            data sit in different
                 BBC                                systems – hard to
                                                            DBLP
                                                    discover, obtain,
                                                    integrate by users.
data.open.ac.uk
The first linked data platform providing open
information from a across a whole university
Linked Data at the Open University
Course information:
     580 modules/ description of the course, information about the levels and
     number of credits associated with it, topics, and conditions of enrolment.
Research publications:
     16,000 academic articles / information about authors, dates, abstract and
     venue of the publication.
Podcasts:
     2220 video podcasts and 1500 audio podcats / short description, topics, link
     to a representative image and to a transscript if available, information about
     the course the podcast might relate to and license information regarding the
     content of the podcast.
Open Educational Resources:
     640 OpenLearn Units / short description, topics, tags used to annotate the
     resource, its language, the course it might relate to, and the license that
     applies to the content.
Youtube videos:
     900 videos / short description of the video, tags that were used to annotate
     the video, collection it might be part of and link to the related course if
     relevant.
University buildings:
     – 100 buildings / address, a picture of the building and the sub-divisions of
         the building into floors and spaces.
Library catalogue:
     12,000 books/ topics, authors, publisher and ISBN, as well as the course
Applications


                                                                                             Social


        Resource
        Discovery




                                                      Research
              Exploration


d'Aquin, M. (2012) Putting Linked Data to Use in a Large Higher-Education Organisation, Interacting with
Linked Data at Extended Semantic Web Conference, ESWC 2012
Example: map of buildings



                 Interactive map of
                 Open University
                 Buildings in the UK
Example: Study at the OU mobile
application




            That’s where linked data is
The Semantic Web
                                  rNews
             Music
            Ontology                               Geo
                                                 Ontology
    SIOC                Media
                       Ontology
                                                     Dublin
                                                     Core
                                  DBPedia
             FOAF
                                  Ontology


 DOAP
                                       FMA              BIBO
                                      Ontology
           LODE


                            Gene
                           Ontology
What is it good for?

  Interoperability, reusability
      and open meaning!

  Examples: For libraries, for universities
   globally, for understanding student’s
                  activities
Mapping Library Catalogues to
Standard Web Vocabularies
 Marimba4lib.com
Used by the
Spanish
National
Library

See
http://datos.bne.e
s
Beyond library resources: A global
    university space
                                            mEducator




                  The Open                                         Data.gov.uk
                  University                                        education
                                                        Research
                               Orgs., Bu                 ouputs
                               idings, Lo
                                 cations

                                                     Learning
                                                    resources               University of
            OrganicEduNet                                                   Muenster, DE




                                   University               University of
                                   of Bristol               Southampton
d'Aquin, M. (2012) Linked Data for Open and Distance Learning, Common Wealth of Learning
See http://linkeduniversities.org
Personal analytics based on log integration
     (see http://uciad.info)
                                                                     A generic personal
                                                                     analytics dashboard
                                                                     from web and
                                                                     application logs.

                                                                      Uses a web activity
                                                                      ontology for
                                                                      integration, and
                                                                      ontological
                                                                      reasoning to
                                                                      aggregate
                                                                      information from
                                                                      multiple systems
                                                                      and sites
d'Aquin, M., Elahi, S. and Motta, E. (2011) Semantic Technologies to Support the User-Centric Analysis of
Activity Data, Workshop: Social Data on the Web Workshop, SDoW 2011 at ISWC 2011
What more is it good for?

  Using Knowledge from the
           Web!

  Examples: For understanding research
 communities, for discovering new content
  for, for research, for analyzing student’s
                   activities
Using links to enrich our own
  data




  Academics in “Arts and Humanities”      Topics most commonly mentioned by
 most often involved with the media (in     news outlets own by the BBC (in
        number of news items)                    number of news items)
From dataset about
                         From news         From dbpedia.org
our researchers
                         clipping data
Discovery of open educational resources
(see http://discou.info)
Resources                       Similarity-
          Interface                URIs +                           Based
                                   common topics                    Search

                                         BBC Programme or iPlayer
                 Resource                page
                 descriptions
                                                                                       Indexes

                         Synopsi
                         s
                       Named Entity      Semantic                           Semantic
                       Recognition       Entities                           Indexing
                                         (Dbpedia)
                               Podcasts, OpenL                               Indexes
                               earn Units and
                               Articles
     data.open.ac.uk                                                                   Semantic Index


d'Aquin, M., Allocca, C. and Collins, T. (2012) DiscOU: A Flexible Discovery Engine for Open Educational Resources
Using Semantic Indexing and Relationship Summaries, Demo at International Semantic Web Conference, ISWC 2012
Enriching data-mining results for
interpretation
What even more is it good for?

       Combining, interpreting and
      using sources of knowledge at
                run time!
                       (but I’m running out of time ;-)



d'Aquin, M. and Motta, E. (2011) Watson, more than a Semantic Web search engine, Semantic Web Journal, 2
d'Aquin, M., Motta, E., Sabou, M., Angeletou, S., Gridinoc, L., Lopez, V. and Guidi, D. (2008) Towards a New
Generation of Semantic Web Applications, IEEE Intelligent Systems, 23, 3, pp. 20-28
Towards global education based on
the Web of Data
The LinkedUp support action (http://linkedup-project.eu): tackling the
challenge of large scale Web Data integration for concrete educational
scenarios
Conclusion – Final message
Linked data and semantic web
technologies make the
promises of educational
metadata truly reachable

More importantly, applying
linked data and semantic web
principles make the promises
of open, global education
feasible

But…
Facing again the same
  challenges… any use case but how do we
Linked Data is about supporting
discover resources in linked data if not described according to
what they can do?
How do we represent metadata about educational purpose?
    LRMI just has “educationalAlignment” which can be anything
    Learning Outcome? Competence acquired? More complex
pedagogical models?
Contradicts the flexibility of Semantic Web / Linked Data
    what is the educational purpose of a painting in a museum?
Generally: How do we interpret metadata about a resource the
context of an education scenario?
Thank
         you!
More info and contacts:
      @mdaquin
m.daquin@open.ac.uk
  http://mdaquin.net

Semantic Web, Linked Data and Education: A Perfect Fit?

  • 1.
    Semantic Web, LinkedData and Education: A Perfect Fit? Mathieu d’Aquin Knowledge Media Institute, The Open University, UK @mdaquin
  • 2.
    The evolution of (higher) education From Local to Global How do we manage that? (at the technological level)
  • 4.
    Metadata for education already But there are metadata standards for learning resources, aren’t there? Yes, my dear, but I’m not sure this answers the question…
  • 5.
    So this talkshould finish here? • IEEE LOM – Standard for Learning Object Metadata – Reuse Dublin Core – XML-based – Final draft in 2002 • SCORM – Sharable Content Object Reference Model – Started in 1996 / last edition 2009 • MIT OCW Metadata – Open Courseware – Reuse IEEE LOM • LRMI – Learning Resource Metadata Initiative – Started in June 2011, Spec 1.0 (current) – Plan for integration with Schema.org – Does not reuse any of the other standards
  • 6.
    Why it stilldoes not work http://xkcd.com/927/ Lack of flexibility, too much ambiguity, creating news silos… Maybe standards are not the answer?
  • 7.
    The Web… … isquite a great platform Why don’t we… … use it to connect educational resources to each other? … use it to express the different ways in which these can be understood and reused? … use it to discover, combine and remix things with different origins and purposes?
  • 8.
    Linked Data OpenUniversity Person: Mathieu Website Publication: Pub1 author workFor Open University VLE Course: M366 offers M366 Course page Organisation: The Open University Mathieu’s Homepage availableIn setBook Mathieu’s List of Mathieu’s Publications Twitter Country: Belgium Book: Mechatronics The Web The Web of Linked Data
  • 9.
    The Web ofLinked Data
  • 10.
    What is itgood for? Accessibility and flexibility! Example: Application at the Open University
  • 11.
    The Open University • The largest university in the UK: 250K students per year, 8000 associate lecturers, a big campus in Milton Keynes • Created in 1969 • Almost entirely open and distance learning • 13 regional centers, more national centers, courses available in a large number of countries
  • 12.
    Applying linked datato the Open UNiversity Exposed as linked DBPedia RAE data, our data OpenLearn Data from ORO Research interlink with each Content Outputs other and the Archive of external world: it Course Library’s Catalogue geonames Material becomes part of the Of Digital Content data.gov.uk “global data space” on the Web A/V Material Podcasts University public iTunesU data sit in different BBC systems – hard to DBLP discover, obtain, integrate by users.
  • 13.
    data.open.ac.uk The first linkeddata platform providing open information from a across a whole university
  • 14.
    Linked Data atthe Open University Course information: 580 modules/ description of the course, information about the levels and number of credits associated with it, topics, and conditions of enrolment. Research publications: 16,000 academic articles / information about authors, dates, abstract and venue of the publication. Podcasts: 2220 video podcasts and 1500 audio podcats / short description, topics, link to a representative image and to a transscript if available, information about the course the podcast might relate to and license information regarding the content of the podcast. Open Educational Resources: 640 OpenLearn Units / short description, topics, tags used to annotate the resource, its language, the course it might relate to, and the license that applies to the content. Youtube videos: 900 videos / short description of the video, tags that were used to annotate the video, collection it might be part of and link to the related course if relevant. University buildings: – 100 buildings / address, a picture of the building and the sub-divisions of the building into floors and spaces. Library catalogue: 12,000 books/ topics, authors, publisher and ISBN, as well as the course
  • 15.
    Applications Social Resource Discovery Research Exploration d'Aquin, M. (2012) Putting Linked Data to Use in a Large Higher-Education Organisation, Interacting with Linked Data at Extended Semantic Web Conference, ESWC 2012
  • 16.
    Example: map ofbuildings Interactive map of Open University Buildings in the UK
  • 17.
    Example: Study atthe OU mobile application That’s where linked data is
  • 18.
    The Semantic Web rNews Music Ontology Geo Ontology SIOC Media Ontology Dublin Core DBPedia FOAF Ontology DOAP FMA BIBO Ontology LODE Gene Ontology
  • 19.
    What is itgood for? Interoperability, reusability and open meaning! Examples: For libraries, for universities globally, for understanding student’s activities
  • 20.
    Mapping Library Cataloguesto Standard Web Vocabularies Marimba4lib.com
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Beyond library resources:A global university space mEducator The Open Data.gov.uk University education Research Orgs., Bu ouputs idings, Lo cations Learning resources University of OrganicEduNet Muenster, DE University University of of Bristol Southampton d'Aquin, M. (2012) Linked Data for Open and Distance Learning, Common Wealth of Learning
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Personal analytics basedon log integration (see http://uciad.info) A generic personal analytics dashboard from web and application logs. Uses a web activity ontology for integration, and ontological reasoning to aggregate information from multiple systems and sites d'Aquin, M., Elahi, S. and Motta, E. (2011) Semantic Technologies to Support the User-Centric Analysis of Activity Data, Workshop: Social Data on the Web Workshop, SDoW 2011 at ISWC 2011
  • 25.
    What more isit good for? Using Knowledge from the Web! Examples: For understanding research communities, for discovering new content for, for research, for analyzing student’s activities
  • 26.
    Using links toenrich our own data Academics in “Arts and Humanities” Topics most commonly mentioned by most often involved with the media (in news outlets own by the BBC (in number of news items) number of news items) From dataset about From news From dbpedia.org our researchers clipping data
  • 27.
    Discovery of openeducational resources (see http://discou.info)
  • 28.
    Resources Similarity- Interface URIs + Based common topics Search BBC Programme or iPlayer Resource page descriptions Indexes Synopsi s Named Entity Semantic Semantic Recognition Entities Indexing (Dbpedia) Podcasts, OpenL Indexes earn Units and Articles data.open.ac.uk Semantic Index d'Aquin, M., Allocca, C. and Collins, T. (2012) DiscOU: A Flexible Discovery Engine for Open Educational Resources Using Semantic Indexing and Relationship Summaries, Demo at International Semantic Web Conference, ISWC 2012
  • 29.
  • 30.
    What even moreis it good for? Combining, interpreting and using sources of knowledge at run time! (but I’m running out of time ;-) d'Aquin, M. and Motta, E. (2011) Watson, more than a Semantic Web search engine, Semantic Web Journal, 2 d'Aquin, M., Motta, E., Sabou, M., Angeletou, S., Gridinoc, L., Lopez, V. and Guidi, D. (2008) Towards a New Generation of Semantic Web Applications, IEEE Intelligent Systems, 23, 3, pp. 20-28
  • 31.
    Towards global educationbased on the Web of Data The LinkedUp support action (http://linkedup-project.eu): tackling the challenge of large scale Web Data integration for concrete educational scenarios
  • 32.
    Conclusion – Finalmessage Linked data and semantic web technologies make the promises of educational metadata truly reachable More importantly, applying linked data and semantic web principles make the promises of open, global education feasible But…
  • 33.
    Facing again thesame challenges… any use case but how do we Linked Data is about supporting discover resources in linked data if not described according to what they can do? How do we represent metadata about educational purpose? LRMI just has “educationalAlignment” which can be anything Learning Outcome? Competence acquired? More complex pedagogical models? Contradicts the flexibility of Semantic Web / Linked Data what is the educational purpose of a painting in a museum? Generally: How do we interpret metadata about a resource the context of an education scenario?
  • 34.
    Thank you! More info and contacts: @mdaquin m.daquin@open.ac.uk http://mdaquin.net

Editor's Notes

  • #5 But… there is a bit of history…LOM! What was the plan, (but when you talk about it people say beeuurgh…) when it went wrong?Parallel story: MARC records…. ??And why to we need LRMI then?Why not used by OCW?What should have been the goal: reusability, recombination, repurposing, discoverability
  • #15 Add images for each bullet point…
  • #16 Add discou