SlideShare a Scribd company logo
QUESTIONS OF
CHARACTER
27th January 2015:
Survey results
What were the concerns?
• Victorian
• Value laden
• Preconceptions of Character Education
• Time spent ‘away’ from curriculum study
• There is a specific focus on Character Education built into
Curriculum for Excellence
• Character Education should be informed by underlying
philosophy or values approach
Which values should we focus on?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Moral Performance Civic Intellectual
Series 1
Column1
Column2
Workings
• Moral (46): Kindness x 2, empathy x 12, honesty x 6, courage/strength x 2,
fairness, integrity x 8, personal responsibility x 6, compassion x 5, trust x 2, grace,
morality
• Performance (27): resilience x 6, confidence x 3, perseverance x 3, targets/goals
x 2, resourcefulness, self-reliance, solution-focussed, ambition, motivation,
commitment x 2, enthusiasm, initiative, fulfil potential, communication x 2,
flexibility
• Civic (49): Mutually supportive x 2, cooperation, committed to greater good,
respect x 8, tolerance x 2, freedom to express opinions, acceptance x
2/treatment/celebration of others, diversity x 3, equality, harmony, agreement,
dialogue, opportunities to do good, reciprocity, shared/mutual responsibility x 2,
caring x 2, inclusive, supportive, positive interdependence, selflessness, person-
centered, giving x 2, ownership, service, outgoing, family x 2, shared values,
participation, wider world, community, fairness (others)
• Intellectual (21): Reflection x 6, love of learning, intellectual rigour, curiosity x 2,
scepticism, open-mindedness, debate, constructive criticism, learning/thinking
dispositions, understanding x 2, forthcoming, ethical judgement, fairness (self)
Character Education as pedagogy
Boyd’s report A Common Weal Education (2014) asks us to examine
“…the role of schooling in creating a civilised society. It looks at the aims
of education and emphasises the importance of ‘the New Basics’ like the
ability to think – critically and creatively - empathy, working with others,
problem-solving and resilience in a modern economy and society.”
Kelly (2004) argues that a ‘process curriculum’ starts from “…a concern
with the nature of the child and with his or her development as a human
being” and should be “an overtly value-laden and ideological model”.
Questions & Issues raised from pre-event
survey
Terminology
• What is a ‘positive moral ethos’?
Community approach
• Links with other influences in young people’s lives
• Teachers being asked to do work previously done by families, communities,
churches etc
• Schools should support this work and expect wider communities to do the same
• Responsibility lies with many people
• Diversity of belief
• Schools adding value to communities – young people having pride in school
because of this – data linking this with improved behaviours
• Shared understanding of how we live and work together
Professionalism
• CE and values provide a key lever for school improvement
• Tension between engaging in areas of ‘right and wrong’ and teachers putting
across own moral position
Questions & Issues
Character Education principles
• What is the ultimate good?
• ‘Good character’ – who decides?
• Focus on the moral is simplistic
• Character Education is about the capacity to make choices of ‘right’ and ‘wrong’
• How do we account for cultural bias?
• What is Character Education? Is it a subject or an approach to curriculum?
• What to do in terms of assessment and measurement?
• How prescriptive should it be? How much emphasis?
• Partnership working e.g. CLD – schools shaping communities – we are missing this opportunity
• Values-based or principle centred?
• Recognition of Wider Achievement
• Keep integrity of RME intact
• Danger of assuming moral superiority
• Values approach shouldn’t be separated from morality
• Character Education as development, not a new ‘initiative’
• Approaches to character & ethics without didactic/proselytising approach
• In what ways can CE be an academic enabler AS WELL AS building character? Is that a false distinction?
• Character of organisation vs character of individuals
• Nature vs nurture
• CE as another blot on or passing fad with short shelf life
• What are schools currently doing? Existing models from other countries?
• CE given a ‘Scottish’ slant?
• “There are so many approaches to achieve the same ends- is it useful to have another one and if so what is it's particular
contribution?”
• Inspiration AND aspiration
• Get values ‘off the wall’
Challenges in schools where character &
values could play a role
Pupils & teachers
• Lack of confidence: perseverance, confidence, courage
• Senior School students do not feel their views are taken into account, they don’t
feel valued
• Pupils under huge pressure of exams, tend to be critical about everything
• Learned helplessness, working with others, lack of ambition & intrinsic motivation,
pupils ‘trained out of creativity’
• Number and scale of competing challenges facing teachers
• Acting with integrity, ‘doing the right thing’ rather than ‘doing things right’
• Self-regulation in education and work settings
• Respect, integrity, giving people a chance, putting personal opinions to one side,
gratitude, equality
• Low aspirations, limiting beliefs
• Enthusiasm, moral background, integrity
• Development mindset, seeing mistakes as learning opportunity, conflict resolution
• Encouraging commitment & consistency with young volunteers
• Exploring own values vs agreeing school values? Shared values/conduct between
staff and pupils? Pupil ownership?
• YP desperate to do good? Unconditional positive regard?
Challenges
Health & Wellbeing
• Developing wellbeing curriculum – resilience model – can this be linked with CE?
• Behaviour: ‘foul’ language, litter, bullying, lack of empathy for diversity
• Stress
Culture
• We live in a compliance culture, more concern about what we are seen to do than what we
actually do
• Achievement: Extrinsic motivation ‘winning’ over intrinsic
• Growth mindset vs fixed ‘cultural’ mindset
• Financial constraints
• Opportunities for challenge
• Ethics to negotiate the moral/social questions of modern world
• Moving from vision to measurable steps towards it
• Engagement of those who feel let down by the system
• Home environment not encouraging good character vs doing good as part of school
curriculum
• Getting parents on board
• Competing priorities, CE seen as another pressure, convincing headteachers
• Role of parents/families?
Questions of Character Survey Results

More Related Content

What's hot

Integrating ethics into your school community
Integrating ethics into your school communityIntegrating ethics into your school community
Integrating ethics into your school community
The Institute for Global Ethics
 
A student centered approach to ethical literacy
A student centered approach to ethical literacyA student centered approach to ethical literacy
A student centered approach to ethical literacy
The Institute for Global Ethics
 
School culture healthy toxicchange
School culture healthy toxicchangeSchool culture healthy toxicchange
School culture healthy toxicchange
betseykenn
 
Transforming school culture
Transforming school cultureTransforming school culture
Transforming school culture
PJ Caposey
 
Understanding School Culture
Understanding School CultureUnderstanding School Culture
Understanding School Culture
Matt Scully
 
School Culture and Climate-BBPSTC
School Culture and Climate-BBPSTCSchool Culture and Climate-BBPSTC
School Culture and Climate-BBPSTC
bbpstc
 
Brochure
BrochureBrochure
Brochure
angyoung
 
Leading Learning 1
Leading Learning 1Leading Learning 1
Leading Learning 1
Anthony Kilcoyne
 
Mentoring in schools mrs. lalitha kandaswamy
Mentoring in schools   mrs. lalitha kandaswamyMentoring in schools   mrs. lalitha kandaswamy
Mentoring in schools mrs. lalitha kandaswamyEduMedia India
 
CEESSA Governance Workshop 2014
CEESSA Governance Workshop 2014CEESSA Governance Workshop 2014
CEESSA Governance Workshop 2014Jon Zurfluh
 
2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins
2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins
2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins
Mid-America Transportation Center
 
School & Society PowerPoint - Sep 5
School & Society PowerPoint - Sep 5School & Society PowerPoint - Sep 5
School & Society PowerPoint - Sep 5
Scott McLeod
 
Value Based Technical Education
Value Based Technical EducationValue Based Technical Education
Value Based Technical Education
Dr. S.N. Sridhara
 
Project Based Learning Framework
Project Based Learning FrameworkProject Based Learning Framework
Sustaining the leader
Sustaining the leaderSustaining the leader
Sustaining the leaderMartin Brown
 
N richardson sharing re practitioner session 2013
N richardson sharing re   practitioner session 2013N richardson sharing re   practitioner session 2013
N richardson sharing re practitioner session 2013jneducator
 

What's hot (16)

Integrating ethics into your school community
Integrating ethics into your school communityIntegrating ethics into your school community
Integrating ethics into your school community
 
A student centered approach to ethical literacy
A student centered approach to ethical literacyA student centered approach to ethical literacy
A student centered approach to ethical literacy
 
School culture healthy toxicchange
School culture healthy toxicchangeSchool culture healthy toxicchange
School culture healthy toxicchange
 
Transforming school culture
Transforming school cultureTransforming school culture
Transforming school culture
 
Understanding School Culture
Understanding School CultureUnderstanding School Culture
Understanding School Culture
 
School Culture and Climate-BBPSTC
School Culture and Climate-BBPSTCSchool Culture and Climate-BBPSTC
School Culture and Climate-BBPSTC
 
Brochure
BrochureBrochure
Brochure
 
Leading Learning 1
Leading Learning 1Leading Learning 1
Leading Learning 1
 
Mentoring in schools mrs. lalitha kandaswamy
Mentoring in schools   mrs. lalitha kandaswamyMentoring in schools   mrs. lalitha kandaswamy
Mentoring in schools mrs. lalitha kandaswamy
 
CEESSA Governance Workshop 2014
CEESSA Governance Workshop 2014CEESSA Governance Workshop 2014
CEESSA Governance Workshop 2014
 
2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins
2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins
2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins
 
School & Society PowerPoint - Sep 5
School & Society PowerPoint - Sep 5School & Society PowerPoint - Sep 5
School & Society PowerPoint - Sep 5
 
Value Based Technical Education
Value Based Technical EducationValue Based Technical Education
Value Based Technical Education
 
Project Based Learning Framework
Project Based Learning FrameworkProject Based Learning Framework
Project Based Learning Framework
 
Sustaining the leader
Sustaining the leaderSustaining the leader
Sustaining the leader
 
N richardson sharing re practitioner session 2013
N richardson sharing re   practitioner session 2013N richardson sharing re   practitioner session 2013
N richardson sharing re practitioner session 2013
 

Viewers also liked

Performance character mini forum n florida
Performance character mini forum n floridaPerformance character mini forum n florida
Performance character mini forum n florida
Stephaniasherman
 
Suggested strategies and approaches in teaching values education
Suggested strategies and approaches in teaching values educationSuggested strategies and approaches in teaching values education
Suggested strategies and approaches in teaching values education
vien_xzquell
 
57191541 edukasyong-an-at-pangkabuhayan
57191541 edukasyong-an-at-pangkabuhayan57191541 edukasyong-an-at-pangkabuhayan
57191541 edukasyong-an-at-pangkabuhayanEDITHA HONRADEZ
 
Deped Values Education Program
Deped Values Education ProgramDeped Values Education Program
Deped Values Education Program
Jennifer De Julio
 
Mga Uri ng Pagtatanong
Mga Uri ng PagtatanongMga Uri ng Pagtatanong
Mga Uri ng PagtatanongMckoi M
 
Core Values and Related Values in the DepEd Framework of Values Education
Core Values and Related Values in the DepEd Framework of Values EducationCore Values and Related Values in the DepEd Framework of Values Education
Core Values and Related Values in the DepEd Framework of Values Education
Ramil Gallardo
 
K TO 12 GRADE 7 LEARNING MODULE IN EDUKASYON SA PAGPAPAKATAO (Q3-Q4)
K TO 12 GRADE 7 LEARNING MODULE IN EDUKASYON SA PAGPAPAKATAO (Q3-Q4)K TO 12 GRADE 7 LEARNING MODULE IN EDUKASYON SA PAGPAPAKATAO (Q3-Q4)
K TO 12 GRADE 7 LEARNING MODULE IN EDUKASYON SA PAGPAPAKATAO (Q3-Q4)
LiGhT ArOhL
 
GRADE 10 - EsP Yunit 3
GRADE 10 - EsP Yunit 3GRADE 10 - EsP Yunit 3
GRADE 10 - EsP Yunit 3
khikox
 
THESIS - WIKANG FILIPINO, SA MAKABAGONG PANAHON
THESIS - WIKANG FILIPINO, SA MAKABAGONG PANAHONTHESIS - WIKANG FILIPINO, SA MAKABAGONG PANAHON
THESIS - WIKANG FILIPINO, SA MAKABAGONG PANAHON
Mi L
 
Ang guro sa paglinang ng edukasyon
Ang guro sa paglinang ng edukasyonAng guro sa paglinang ng edukasyon
Ang guro sa paglinang ng edukasyon
Olutanga National High School
 
Strengths and Weaknesses of the Filipino Character
Strengths and Weaknesses of the Filipino CharacterStrengths and Weaknesses of the Filipino Character
Strengths and Weaknesses of the Filipino Character
San Pedro College
 
Values Education for Future Educators
Values Education for Future EducatorsValues Education for Future Educators
Values Education for Future Educators
bernadette enriquez
 
Values education
Values educationValues education
The DECS Values Education Framework
The DECS Values Education FrameworkThe DECS Values Education Framework
The DECS Values Education Framework
Sharmaine Joyce Hayawon
 

Viewers also liked (15)

Performance character mini forum n florida
Performance character mini forum n floridaPerformance character mini forum n florida
Performance character mini forum n florida
 
Suggested strategies and approaches in teaching values education
Suggested strategies and approaches in teaching values educationSuggested strategies and approaches in teaching values education
Suggested strategies and approaches in teaching values education
 
57191541 edukasyong-an-at-pangkabuhayan
57191541 edukasyong-an-at-pangkabuhayan57191541 edukasyong-an-at-pangkabuhayan
57191541 edukasyong-an-at-pangkabuhayan
 
Deped Values Education Program
Deped Values Education ProgramDeped Values Education Program
Deped Values Education Program
 
Mga Uri ng Pagtatanong
Mga Uri ng PagtatanongMga Uri ng Pagtatanong
Mga Uri ng Pagtatanong
 
Core Values and Related Values in the DepEd Framework of Values Education
Core Values and Related Values in the DepEd Framework of Values EducationCore Values and Related Values in the DepEd Framework of Values Education
Core Values and Related Values in the DepEd Framework of Values Education
 
K TO 12 GRADE 7 LEARNING MODULE IN EDUKASYON SA PAGPAPAKATAO (Q3-Q4)
K TO 12 GRADE 7 LEARNING MODULE IN EDUKASYON SA PAGPAPAKATAO (Q3-Q4)K TO 12 GRADE 7 LEARNING MODULE IN EDUKASYON SA PAGPAPAKATAO (Q3-Q4)
K TO 12 GRADE 7 LEARNING MODULE IN EDUKASYON SA PAGPAPAKATAO (Q3-Q4)
 
GRADE 10 - EsP Yunit 3
GRADE 10 - EsP Yunit 3GRADE 10 - EsP Yunit 3
GRADE 10 - EsP Yunit 3
 
THESIS - WIKANG FILIPINO, SA MAKABAGONG PANAHON
THESIS - WIKANG FILIPINO, SA MAKABAGONG PANAHONTHESIS - WIKANG FILIPINO, SA MAKABAGONG PANAHON
THESIS - WIKANG FILIPINO, SA MAKABAGONG PANAHON
 
Ang guro sa paglinang ng edukasyon
Ang guro sa paglinang ng edukasyonAng guro sa paglinang ng edukasyon
Ang guro sa paglinang ng edukasyon
 
Strengths and Weaknesses of the Filipino Character
Strengths and Weaknesses of the Filipino CharacterStrengths and Weaknesses of the Filipino Character
Strengths and Weaknesses of the Filipino Character
 
Values Education for Future Educators
Values Education for Future EducatorsValues Education for Future Educators
Values Education for Future Educators
 
Values education
Values educationValues education
Values education
 
The DECS Values Education Framework
The DECS Values Education FrameworkThe DECS Values Education Framework
The DECS Values Education Framework
 
Values education
Values educationValues education
Values education
 

Similar to Questions of Character Survey Results

A questions of fundamentals
A questions of fundamentalsA questions of fundamentals
A questions of fundamentals
Hunter Institute of Mental Health
 
Charter Review 2012
Charter Review 2012Charter Review 2012
Charter Review 2012gerry21
 
NCF 2023-VALUES & INCLUSION.ppt
NCF 2023-VALUES & INCLUSION.pptNCF 2023-VALUES & INCLUSION.ppt
NCF 2023-VALUES & INCLUSION.ppt
Rosea Sidhu
 
Towards a Holistic View of Teacher Growth
Towards a Holistic View of Teacher GrowthTowards a Holistic View of Teacher Growth
Towards a Holistic View of Teacher GrowthPhilwood
 
Julie Coiro Reflecting On PDI Culture
Julie Coiro Reflecting On PDI CultureJulie Coiro Reflecting On PDI Culture
Julie Coiro Reflecting On PDI Culture
Julie Coiro
 
Best schools principles
Best schools principlesBest schools principles
Bc 8 p15 session 5 2019
Bc 8 p15 session 5 2019Bc 8 p15 session 5 2019
Bc 8 p15 session 5 2019
Beth Carey
 
adult edu.pptx
adult edu.pptxadult edu.pptx
adult edu.pptx
ARPITADUTTA48
 
Developing values at secondary level.pptx
Developing values at secondary level.pptxDeveloping values at secondary level.pptx
Developing values at secondary level.pptx
YukthaKarthikeyan
 
C. Max Roach- Personal Philosophy and Favorite Quote
C. Max Roach- Personal Philosophy and Favorite QuoteC. Max Roach- Personal Philosophy and Favorite Quote
C. Max Roach- Personal Philosophy and Favorite QuoteMax Roach
 
(May 31) CREATING SCHOOLS OF CHARACTER: 11 Principles for Accreditation
(May 31) CREATING SCHOOLS OF CHARACTER: 11 Principles for Accreditation(May 31) CREATING SCHOOLS OF CHARACTER: 11 Principles for Accreditation
(May 31) CREATING SCHOOLS OF CHARACTER: 11 Principles for Accreditation
Mann Rentoy
 
SD48 CUPE+ Pathways Presentation
SD48 CUPE+ Pathways PresentationSD48 CUPE+ Pathways Presentation
SD48 CUPE+ Pathways Presentation
sd48seatosky
 
8 p15 session 4 winter 2018
8 p15 session 4 winter 2018 8 p15 session 4 winter 2018
8 p15 session 4 winter 2018
Beth Carey
 
moral values
moral valuesmoral values
moral values
apoorvkumar9277
 
character_education_final.pptx
character_education_final.pptxcharacter_education_final.pptx
character_education_final.pptx
AnuragKumar60835
 
Curriculum
CurriculumCurriculum
Curriculum
Priyanka Bhatia
 
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
NortheasternSAIL
 
Ed 713: Foundation of curriculum planning
Ed 713: Foundation of curriculum planningEd 713: Foundation of curriculum planning
Ed 713: Foundation of curriculum planning
ChristineCatyong
 
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
NortheasternSAIL
 
CREATING A SCHOOL CULTURE THAT WORKS FOR STUDENT SUCCESS
CREATING A SCHOOL CULTURE THAT WORKS FOR STUDENT SUCCESSCREATING A SCHOOL CULTURE THAT WORKS FOR STUDENT SUCCESS
CREATING A SCHOOL CULTURE THAT WORKS FOR STUDENT SUCCESS
Mann Rentoy
 

Similar to Questions of Character Survey Results (20)

A questions of fundamentals
A questions of fundamentalsA questions of fundamentals
A questions of fundamentals
 
Charter Review 2012
Charter Review 2012Charter Review 2012
Charter Review 2012
 
NCF 2023-VALUES & INCLUSION.ppt
NCF 2023-VALUES & INCLUSION.pptNCF 2023-VALUES & INCLUSION.ppt
NCF 2023-VALUES & INCLUSION.ppt
 
Towards a Holistic View of Teacher Growth
Towards a Holistic View of Teacher GrowthTowards a Holistic View of Teacher Growth
Towards a Holistic View of Teacher Growth
 
Julie Coiro Reflecting On PDI Culture
Julie Coiro Reflecting On PDI CultureJulie Coiro Reflecting On PDI Culture
Julie Coiro Reflecting On PDI Culture
 
Best schools principles
Best schools principlesBest schools principles
Best schools principles
 
Bc 8 p15 session 5 2019
Bc 8 p15 session 5 2019Bc 8 p15 session 5 2019
Bc 8 p15 session 5 2019
 
adult edu.pptx
adult edu.pptxadult edu.pptx
adult edu.pptx
 
Developing values at secondary level.pptx
Developing values at secondary level.pptxDeveloping values at secondary level.pptx
Developing values at secondary level.pptx
 
C. Max Roach- Personal Philosophy and Favorite Quote
C. Max Roach- Personal Philosophy and Favorite QuoteC. Max Roach- Personal Philosophy and Favorite Quote
C. Max Roach- Personal Philosophy and Favorite Quote
 
(May 31) CREATING SCHOOLS OF CHARACTER: 11 Principles for Accreditation
(May 31) CREATING SCHOOLS OF CHARACTER: 11 Principles for Accreditation(May 31) CREATING SCHOOLS OF CHARACTER: 11 Principles for Accreditation
(May 31) CREATING SCHOOLS OF CHARACTER: 11 Principles for Accreditation
 
SD48 CUPE+ Pathways Presentation
SD48 CUPE+ Pathways PresentationSD48 CUPE+ Pathways Presentation
SD48 CUPE+ Pathways Presentation
 
8 p15 session 4 winter 2018
8 p15 session 4 winter 2018 8 p15 session 4 winter 2018
8 p15 session 4 winter 2018
 
moral values
moral valuesmoral values
moral values
 
character_education_final.pptx
character_education_final.pptxcharacter_education_final.pptx
character_education_final.pptx
 
Curriculum
CurriculumCurriculum
Curriculum
 
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
 
Ed 713: Foundation of curriculum planning
Ed 713: Foundation of curriculum planningEd 713: Foundation of curriculum planning
Ed 713: Foundation of curriculum planning
 
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
Intersections Between Your Domain and SAIL - May 1, 2018 "Learning Everywhere...
 
CREATING A SCHOOL CULTURE THAT WORKS FOR STUDENT SUCCESS
CREATING A SCHOOL CULTURE THAT WORKS FOR STUDENT SUCCESSCREATING A SCHOOL CULTURE THAT WORKS FOR STUDENT SUCCESS
CREATING A SCHOOL CULTURE THAT WORKS FOR STUDENT SUCCESS
 

Recently uploaded

EXPERIENCE MONSTER BITES STREETWEAR APPAREL
EXPERIENCE MONSTER BITES STREETWEAR APPARELEXPERIENCE MONSTER BITES STREETWEAR APPAREL
EXPERIENCE MONSTER BITES STREETWEAR APPAREL
6ctbkfpdxz
 
What Makes Candle Making The Ultimate Bachelorette Celebration
What Makes Candle Making The Ultimate Bachelorette CelebrationWhat Makes Candle Making The Ultimate Bachelorette Celebration
What Makes Candle Making The Ultimate Bachelorette Celebration
Wick & Pour
 
Unique Wedding Bands For Women Who Want To Stand Out.pptx
Unique Wedding Bands For Women Who Want To Stand Out.pptxUnique Wedding Bands For Women Who Want To Stand Out.pptx
Unique Wedding Bands For Women Who Want To Stand Out.pptx
Andrews Jewelers
 
Gujarat Details in Hindi for children's for presentation in school
Gujarat Details in Hindi for children's for presentation in schoolGujarat Details in Hindi for children's for presentation in school
Gujarat Details in Hindi for children's for presentation in school
shouryajoshi5
 
30 Manipulation Techniques to be a smart person in society (1).pdf
30 Manipulation Techniques to be a smart person in society (1).pdf30 Manipulation Techniques to be a smart person in society (1).pdf
30 Manipulation Techniques to be a smart person in society (1).pdf
minaserver6679
 
Johnny Depp Long Hair: A Signature Look Through the Years
Johnny Depp Long Hair: A Signature Look Through the YearsJohnny Depp Long Hair: A Signature Look Through the Years
Johnny Depp Long Hair: A Signature Look Through the Years
greendigital
 
From Stress to Success How Oakland's Corporate Wellness Programs are Cultivat...
From Stress to Success How Oakland's Corporate Wellness Programs are Cultivat...From Stress to Success How Oakland's Corporate Wellness Programs are Cultivat...
From Stress to Success How Oakland's Corporate Wellness Programs are Cultivat...
Kitchen on Fire
 
erevna-influencers-social-media-stin-ellada
erevna-influencers-social-media-stin-elladaerevna-influencers-social-media-stin-ellada
erevna-influencers-social-media-stin-ellada
rvlassopoulou
 
What To Do If Your Ring Is Too Big? Must Read
What To Do If Your Ring Is Too Big? Must ReadWhat To Do If Your Ring Is Too Big? Must Read
What To Do If Your Ring Is Too Big? Must Read
Andrews Jewelers
 
La transidentité, un sujet qui fractionne les Français
La transidentité, un sujet qui fractionne les FrançaisLa transidentité, un sujet qui fractionne les Français
La transidentité, un sujet qui fractionne les Français
Ipsos France
 

Recently uploaded (10)

EXPERIENCE MONSTER BITES STREETWEAR APPAREL
EXPERIENCE MONSTER BITES STREETWEAR APPARELEXPERIENCE MONSTER BITES STREETWEAR APPAREL
EXPERIENCE MONSTER BITES STREETWEAR APPAREL
 
What Makes Candle Making The Ultimate Bachelorette Celebration
What Makes Candle Making The Ultimate Bachelorette CelebrationWhat Makes Candle Making The Ultimate Bachelorette Celebration
What Makes Candle Making The Ultimate Bachelorette Celebration
 
Unique Wedding Bands For Women Who Want To Stand Out.pptx
Unique Wedding Bands For Women Who Want To Stand Out.pptxUnique Wedding Bands For Women Who Want To Stand Out.pptx
Unique Wedding Bands For Women Who Want To Stand Out.pptx
 
Gujarat Details in Hindi for children's for presentation in school
Gujarat Details in Hindi for children's for presentation in schoolGujarat Details in Hindi for children's for presentation in school
Gujarat Details in Hindi for children's for presentation in school
 
30 Manipulation Techniques to be a smart person in society (1).pdf
30 Manipulation Techniques to be a smart person in society (1).pdf30 Manipulation Techniques to be a smart person in society (1).pdf
30 Manipulation Techniques to be a smart person in society (1).pdf
 
Johnny Depp Long Hair: A Signature Look Through the Years
Johnny Depp Long Hair: A Signature Look Through the YearsJohnny Depp Long Hair: A Signature Look Through the Years
Johnny Depp Long Hair: A Signature Look Through the Years
 
From Stress to Success How Oakland's Corporate Wellness Programs are Cultivat...
From Stress to Success How Oakland's Corporate Wellness Programs are Cultivat...From Stress to Success How Oakland's Corporate Wellness Programs are Cultivat...
From Stress to Success How Oakland's Corporate Wellness Programs are Cultivat...
 
erevna-influencers-social-media-stin-ellada
erevna-influencers-social-media-stin-elladaerevna-influencers-social-media-stin-ellada
erevna-influencers-social-media-stin-ellada
 
What To Do If Your Ring Is Too Big? Must Read
What To Do If Your Ring Is Too Big? Must ReadWhat To Do If Your Ring Is Too Big? Must Read
What To Do If Your Ring Is Too Big? Must Read
 
La transidentité, un sujet qui fractionne les Français
La transidentité, un sujet qui fractionne les FrançaisLa transidentité, un sujet qui fractionne les Français
La transidentité, un sujet qui fractionne les Français
 

Questions of Character Survey Results

  • 1. QUESTIONS OF CHARACTER 27th January 2015: Survey results
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5. What were the concerns? • Victorian • Value laden • Preconceptions of Character Education • Time spent ‘away’ from curriculum study • There is a specific focus on Character Education built into Curriculum for Excellence • Character Education should be informed by underlying philosophy or values approach
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10. Which values should we focus on? 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Moral Performance Civic Intellectual Series 1 Column1 Column2
  • 11. Workings • Moral (46): Kindness x 2, empathy x 12, honesty x 6, courage/strength x 2, fairness, integrity x 8, personal responsibility x 6, compassion x 5, trust x 2, grace, morality • Performance (27): resilience x 6, confidence x 3, perseverance x 3, targets/goals x 2, resourcefulness, self-reliance, solution-focussed, ambition, motivation, commitment x 2, enthusiasm, initiative, fulfil potential, communication x 2, flexibility • Civic (49): Mutually supportive x 2, cooperation, committed to greater good, respect x 8, tolerance x 2, freedom to express opinions, acceptance x 2/treatment/celebration of others, diversity x 3, equality, harmony, agreement, dialogue, opportunities to do good, reciprocity, shared/mutual responsibility x 2, caring x 2, inclusive, supportive, positive interdependence, selflessness, person- centered, giving x 2, ownership, service, outgoing, family x 2, shared values, participation, wider world, community, fairness (others) • Intellectual (21): Reflection x 6, love of learning, intellectual rigour, curiosity x 2, scepticism, open-mindedness, debate, constructive criticism, learning/thinking dispositions, understanding x 2, forthcoming, ethical judgement, fairness (self)
  • 12. Character Education as pedagogy Boyd’s report A Common Weal Education (2014) asks us to examine “…the role of schooling in creating a civilised society. It looks at the aims of education and emphasises the importance of ‘the New Basics’ like the ability to think – critically and creatively - empathy, working with others, problem-solving and resilience in a modern economy and society.” Kelly (2004) argues that a ‘process curriculum’ starts from “…a concern with the nature of the child and with his or her development as a human being” and should be “an overtly value-laden and ideological model”.
  • 13. Questions & Issues raised from pre-event survey Terminology • What is a ‘positive moral ethos’? Community approach • Links with other influences in young people’s lives • Teachers being asked to do work previously done by families, communities, churches etc • Schools should support this work and expect wider communities to do the same • Responsibility lies with many people • Diversity of belief • Schools adding value to communities – young people having pride in school because of this – data linking this with improved behaviours • Shared understanding of how we live and work together Professionalism • CE and values provide a key lever for school improvement • Tension between engaging in areas of ‘right and wrong’ and teachers putting across own moral position
  • 14. Questions & Issues Character Education principles • What is the ultimate good? • ‘Good character’ – who decides? • Focus on the moral is simplistic • Character Education is about the capacity to make choices of ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ • How do we account for cultural bias? • What is Character Education? Is it a subject or an approach to curriculum? • What to do in terms of assessment and measurement? • How prescriptive should it be? How much emphasis? • Partnership working e.g. CLD – schools shaping communities – we are missing this opportunity • Values-based or principle centred? • Recognition of Wider Achievement • Keep integrity of RME intact • Danger of assuming moral superiority • Values approach shouldn’t be separated from morality • Character Education as development, not a new ‘initiative’ • Approaches to character & ethics without didactic/proselytising approach • In what ways can CE be an academic enabler AS WELL AS building character? Is that a false distinction? • Character of organisation vs character of individuals • Nature vs nurture • CE as another blot on or passing fad with short shelf life • What are schools currently doing? Existing models from other countries? • CE given a ‘Scottish’ slant? • “There are so many approaches to achieve the same ends- is it useful to have another one and if so what is it's particular contribution?” • Inspiration AND aspiration • Get values ‘off the wall’
  • 15. Challenges in schools where character & values could play a role Pupils & teachers • Lack of confidence: perseverance, confidence, courage • Senior School students do not feel their views are taken into account, they don’t feel valued • Pupils under huge pressure of exams, tend to be critical about everything • Learned helplessness, working with others, lack of ambition & intrinsic motivation, pupils ‘trained out of creativity’ • Number and scale of competing challenges facing teachers • Acting with integrity, ‘doing the right thing’ rather than ‘doing things right’ • Self-regulation in education and work settings • Respect, integrity, giving people a chance, putting personal opinions to one side, gratitude, equality • Low aspirations, limiting beliefs • Enthusiasm, moral background, integrity • Development mindset, seeing mistakes as learning opportunity, conflict resolution • Encouraging commitment & consistency with young volunteers • Exploring own values vs agreeing school values? Shared values/conduct between staff and pupils? Pupil ownership? • YP desperate to do good? Unconditional positive regard?
  • 16. Challenges Health & Wellbeing • Developing wellbeing curriculum – resilience model – can this be linked with CE? • Behaviour: ‘foul’ language, litter, bullying, lack of empathy for diversity • Stress Culture • We live in a compliance culture, more concern about what we are seen to do than what we actually do • Achievement: Extrinsic motivation ‘winning’ over intrinsic • Growth mindset vs fixed ‘cultural’ mindset • Financial constraints • Opportunities for challenge • Ethics to negotiate the moral/social questions of modern world • Moving from vision to measurable steps towards it • Engagement of those who feel let down by the system • Home environment not encouraging good character vs doing good as part of school curriculum • Getting parents on board • Competing priorities, CE seen as another pressure, convincing headteachers • Role of parents/families?