9. Project Selection Methods
• Problem analysis
• Idea generation methods
• Stakeholders analysis
• Decision models
• Benefit measurement methods
• Analyze of assumptions and limitations
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
10. Problem Analysis
• Problem finding methods
• Grouping and ordering
• Define triggers and outcomes
• Problem tree
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
11. E.g.: School Motivation Day Problem Tree
Activities are poorly
organised
Low participation level
Atenders are not satisfied
Teachers are not satisfied
Too much free time
Problematic behaviour
(drinking, fighting, …)
Parents are not satisfied
Activities are boring
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
16. Analytic Hierarchy Process
• Design goal-criteria-alternatives
structure
• Set wages or priorities to criteria
• Compare alternatives pairwise per
every criteria
• Synthesize judgments
• Check consistency
• Final decision
17. Logical Framework Analysis
• Problem
• Alternatives
• Deliverables
• Indicators (cost)
• Other issues (risks)
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
18. Example of LFA
Objective Alternatives Deliverables Cost Other
Decrease
response time to
client requests
from 5 to 2 days
Call center Room 5 000 …
Software 25 000 …
Hardware 5 000 …
Recruiting 50 000 …
Training 10 000 …
Online self
service
Software 50 000 …
Hardware 5 000 …
Training 10 000 …
… … …
… … … …
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
19. Multi Criteria Analysis
• Family of algorithms for selecting alternatives
• Criteria and their weights
• Multidimensional characteristics instead of quantitative
economic calculus
• Used if the costs end benefits are difficult to measure
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
20. MCA Process
• Define (alternative) objectives in measurable variables
• Assign weight (priorities) to the objectives
• Define thresholds (criteria)
• Analyze impact of each criteria
• Forecast the effect of each alternative
• Identify preferences
• Calculate scores
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
26. Purpose of the Project Charter
• Document that formally authorizes the project
• Provides authority to the project manager to use
organizational resources
• Starts project planning
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
27. Project Charter Contains
• Project manager name
• Organization (team)
• Requirements and Business needs
• Description of the end result
• Main deliverables
• Stakeholders influence
• Business case
• Summary milestones (estimated deadline)
• Summary budget (estimated price)
• Assumptions and constrains
www.projektor.ee/pm/#initiation
narrative description of the project outcome
Business needs – needed training, market demand, technological progress, legal requirements, governmental policy
Product or service characteristics, connections between business needs and product requirements
One problem different solutions
Piirangud:
Org, struktuur
Standardid
Infrastruktuur
Ressursid
Turutingimused
Riskitundlikus
IS
Forced Choice – Question and specific answers: Yes; No. “not sure,” “no opinion,” or “not applicable” are not included
Tree – …
AHP – selecting most suitable (not correct) solution among alternatives
Assignment:
Idea – alternatives – alternative selection justification.
Tree structure
Cost of available choices
Probability of events
Reward of selection
Makes suggestions
Calculates proce and reward of the selection in a current point
Project logical inner structure
AKA Log Frame
Benefit / Cost ratio -
Economic models (added value)
Scoring models – criteria listed, wages, evaluations
Comparative approaches
Payback period
Net Present Value (NPV)
Discounted Cash Flow
Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
Return on Investment – ROI
Opportunity cost
https://www.simplilearn.com/project-selection-methods-article
Constrained Optimization Methods: Linear, nonlinear, …
Business case - the linkage of the project with high-level strategic goals of the organization
Piirangud:
Org, struktuur
Standardid
Infrastruktuur
Ressursid
Turutingimused
Riskitundlikus
IS