The Alignment Factor, Leveraging Total Stakeholder
                            Support, Routlege, 2012




Prof.dr Cees B.M. van Riel RSM/Erasmus University Rotterdam
Alignment:

“A mutual rewarding relationship between a company
 and its key stakeholders, which enables the firm to
    meet its objectives and realize its purpose.”




This book focuses on internal and external alignment
Key Points Illustrated in THE ALIGNMENT FACTOR
• 1 Alignment is the process of building and maintaining a mutually rewarding
  relationship (MRR) with stakeholders, resulting in a better reputation as a stepping stone
  in increasing (financial) performance: 10% increase in employee alignment, evokes, 2%
  higher financial performance!


• 2 This implies a shift in attitude for most companies, respecting the necessity to balance
  its own interests with the demands of stakeholders that they depend upon


• 3 Getting employees aligned and involved around strategy implies implementing four
  managerial efforts:
      • Gather relevant intelligence before launching the strategy
      • Reveal support and/or resistance among key stakeholders
      • Implement the strategy by balancing hard and soft wired intitiatives, incl. communications
      • Track progress by KPI’s assessing progress in building MRR with key stakeholders



        Phase I:              Phase II:                                  Phase IV:
                             Revealing              Phase III:
   Know Before You Go                              Action Plan       Tracking Progress
                         Support & Resistance
Phase II:                    Phase III:                Phase IV:
                                     Phase I:
Building aligned Organization
                                                               Revealing                    Action Plan            Tracking Progress
                                Know Before You Go
                                                           Support & Resistance



                                  Alignment with what?
                                                                                                                      Tracking progress in
                                                                                                                      supportive employee
                                                                                                                           behavior
                                                             Tracking progress in
                                                                                       Hard wired and soft wired
                                                             supportive employee
                                                                                               initiatives
                                                                  behavior
                                Who needs to be aligned?
                                                                                                                    Introducing KPIs targets
                                                            Inventory of bottlenecks
                                                              and opportunities in
                                                                                       Communication support
                                                               achieving aligned
                                   Desired behavior?               behavior
                                                                                                                   Linking Alignment KPI’s to
                                                                                                                          performance




                                  Benefits employees?




                                                                      Increase performance
Alignment with what?


•   What is the core of the corporate strategy?
•   Which four building blocks matter most?
•   For Telefonica this implies:
Who needs to be aligned?


 •   Who has to be aligned first? Everybody? Only the Top? One division
     specifically?
 •   To be determined based on nature business problem: which employees
      matter most in solving the business challenge?
What is the desired behavior?
     Firm Perspective and Employee Perspective
What does FedEx want couriers to do?                   What drives a courier?
• What does the Access strategy mean for them?
   • Making every FedEx experience outstanding          • I receive respect for what I am doing
• How many packages a day?             The purple promise from my firm
   • 10 instead of 12 if you have to spent              • Customers love FedEx and that
     extra time“I justified by service FedEx experience outstanding” too
                   will make every                        increases respect for me
• What is acceptable when delivering extra service? • I have career opportunties within
   • Explaining mistakes, solving problems caused         FedEx if I encourage customer
     by the firm, etc.                                    satisfaction
• What is not acceptable?
   • Reducing the amount of deliveries and still
     not providing added value in service
Desired behavior at a Utility company?
• What are employees supposed to do? Be specific as a firm.
• Plus, do take into consideration what will be beneficial for the employee.
• The more you stress the added value of the new strategy for the
  employee in internal messaging, the more aligned they will be.
       A non-aligned mechanic:                        An aligned mechanic
-   Considers sustainability to be just    -   Believes in the Sustainability
    another catch phrase                       strategy
-   Is not willing to take any extra       -   Acknowledges that (s)he needs
    training                                   training to keep up-to-date with the
-   Continuous working based on                latest technologies and ensures
    demanded output by his manager             his/her own future by doing so
    (e.g. number of customer visits per    -   Explains sustainable energy to
    day)                                       customers
                                           -   Is motivated by customer
                                               satisfaction
Step 1: Know Before You Go

                                    How to assess
  Alignment with   Alignment with
                                       desired
      what?            whom?
                                      behavior?
Step 2 Revealing Support & Resistance

In general…. employees will show three types of
 reactions towards a new strategy….
   10% has a positive                                         20% has a negative
                               70% is indecisive whether
perception of the strategy,                                perception of the strategy,
                                to support the strategy,
  they fully support the                                   they will never support the
                              they need to be persuaded
         strategy                                                    strategy
….. however, you have to know who is in which group?
So, measure the facts by using the RepTrak™ Alignment Monitor



 1


                                      -   Intranet-based survey among a
                                          stratified sample in the firm.
                                      -   Aimed at (1) revealing the degree of
 2                                        employee support for the strategy.
                                      -   Aimed at (2) showcasing what works
                                          and what doesn’t work regarding
                                          informing, motivating and capability
                                          development.
 3
Step 3: ACTION PLAN
Implementing the right tools at the right moment



                                             Implementing
                                               Soft tools
                              Implementing
                                Hard tools
  Alignment




              Launching the
                Strategy
                                     Time
Step 3: Balancing hard and soft wired initiatives


          Assessing strategic options using the gathered intelligence

 Negotiation                                      Confrontation
 Consulting                                       Mirroring
 •  Presentations and negotiations with Unions    •   Unavoidable exposure by internal messaging
 •  Presentations and negotiations with Working   •   Using Corporate Adds to persuade internal
    Council(s)                                        audiences
                                                  •   Allocating Coaches to key managers aimed at
                                                      adjusting role behavior
 Consensus                                        Power Play
 •  Town Hall meetings                            •   New organizational structures and decision
 •  Management Meetings                               making procedures
 •  Jam Sessions                                  •   Appointing new managers in key roles
                                                  •   Capability development in Internal Training
                                                      Programs
                                                  •   New appraisal rules
Step 3: Who does what?


                                                     Sell their vision it to the rest of the
                                  Top Management
                                                     organization



         Communication & HR                              Marketing
                                   Who does
  Internal communication                           Expose employees to external
                                    what?          campaigns


                  Accounting                  Information Technology

Use reporting & appraisals format forcing    Facilitate vertical and
alignment                                    horizontal communication
Step 4: Key Performance Indicators
         Introducing KPI’s using RepTrak™Alignment Monitor


                                                                Examination of historical performance,
                                                                using RepTrak Alignment Monitor over
                                                         1
                                                                two to three years (past)




                                Extrapolating key drivers of                                   Extrapolating KPI’s on aligned
                      2         alignment for next years (future)                       3      behavior for the next years (future)

                                 KPIs INFORMING
                                   Realized                                                 KPI EMPLOYEE ALIGNMENT
                                            Goal 2012 Goal 2013 Goal 2014
                                                                 2012 2013     2014
                                     2011
                                                                                                      Realized
Manager leads by example             55.3     56.9      58.5      60.0                                         Goal 2012 Goal 2013 Goal 2014
                                KPIs MOTIVATING                                                         2011
                                   Realized
                                     2011
                                            Goal 2012 Goal 2013 Goal 2014   Alignment                   55.2     56.8      58.4      60.0
Regular conversations manager        49.6     51.1      52.6      54.1
                           KPIs CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT
                                   Realized                      2012 2013     2014
                                            Goal 2012 Goal 2013 Goal 2014
                                     2011
Sufficient authorization             51.3     52.9      54.5      56.1
Sufficient recognition               55.3      56.9      58.5       60.1
Sufficient rewarded                  47.3      48.9      50.5       52.1
Wrap up


  • Aligned employees increase performance substantially
  • Building and maintaining an aligned workforce requires a four
    step approach:
     Phase I:             Phase II:          Phase III:       Phase IV:
Know Before You Go       Revealing          Action Plan   Tracking Progress
                     Support & Resistance

Presentatie Cees van Riel; Het Communicatie Congres 2012

  • 1.
    The Alignment Factor,Leveraging Total Stakeholder Support, Routlege, 2012 Prof.dr Cees B.M. van Riel RSM/Erasmus University Rotterdam
  • 2.
    Alignment: “A mutual rewardingrelationship between a company and its key stakeholders, which enables the firm to meet its objectives and realize its purpose.” This book focuses on internal and external alignment
  • 3.
    Key Points Illustratedin THE ALIGNMENT FACTOR • 1 Alignment is the process of building and maintaining a mutually rewarding relationship (MRR) with stakeholders, resulting in a better reputation as a stepping stone in increasing (financial) performance: 10% increase in employee alignment, evokes, 2% higher financial performance! • 2 This implies a shift in attitude for most companies, respecting the necessity to balance its own interests with the demands of stakeholders that they depend upon • 3 Getting employees aligned and involved around strategy implies implementing four managerial efforts: • Gather relevant intelligence before launching the strategy • Reveal support and/or resistance among key stakeholders • Implement the strategy by balancing hard and soft wired intitiatives, incl. communications • Track progress by KPI’s assessing progress in building MRR with key stakeholders Phase I: Phase II: Phase IV: Revealing Phase III: Know Before You Go Action Plan Tracking Progress Support & Resistance
  • 4.
    Phase II: Phase III: Phase IV: Phase I: Building aligned Organization Revealing Action Plan Tracking Progress Know Before You Go Support & Resistance Alignment with what? Tracking progress in supportive employee behavior Tracking progress in Hard wired and soft wired supportive employee initiatives behavior Who needs to be aligned? Introducing KPIs targets Inventory of bottlenecks and opportunities in Communication support achieving aligned Desired behavior? behavior Linking Alignment KPI’s to performance Benefits employees? Increase performance
  • 5.
    Alignment with what? • What is the core of the corporate strategy? • Which four building blocks matter most? • For Telefonica this implies:
  • 6.
    Who needs tobe aligned? • Who has to be aligned first? Everybody? Only the Top? One division specifically? • To be determined based on nature business problem: which employees matter most in solving the business challenge?
  • 7.
    What is thedesired behavior? Firm Perspective and Employee Perspective What does FedEx want couriers to do? What drives a courier? • What does the Access strategy mean for them? • Making every FedEx experience outstanding • I receive respect for what I am doing • How many packages a day? The purple promise from my firm • 10 instead of 12 if you have to spent • Customers love FedEx and that extra time“I justified by service FedEx experience outstanding” too will make every increases respect for me • What is acceptable when delivering extra service? • I have career opportunties within • Explaining mistakes, solving problems caused FedEx if I encourage customer by the firm, etc. satisfaction • What is not acceptable? • Reducing the amount of deliveries and still not providing added value in service
  • 8.
    Desired behavior ata Utility company? • What are employees supposed to do? Be specific as a firm. • Plus, do take into consideration what will be beneficial for the employee. • The more you stress the added value of the new strategy for the employee in internal messaging, the more aligned they will be. A non-aligned mechanic: An aligned mechanic - Considers sustainability to be just - Believes in the Sustainability another catch phrase strategy - Is not willing to take any extra - Acknowledges that (s)he needs training training to keep up-to-date with the - Continuous working based on latest technologies and ensures demanded output by his manager his/her own future by doing so (e.g. number of customer visits per - Explains sustainable energy to day) customers - Is motivated by customer satisfaction
  • 9.
    Step 1: KnowBefore You Go How to assess Alignment with Alignment with desired what? whom? behavior?
  • 10.
    Step 2 RevealingSupport & Resistance In general…. employees will show three types of reactions towards a new strategy…. 10% has a positive 20% has a negative 70% is indecisive whether perception of the strategy, perception of the strategy, to support the strategy, they fully support the they will never support the they need to be persuaded strategy strategy
  • 11.
    ….. however, youhave to know who is in which group? So, measure the facts by using the RepTrak™ Alignment Monitor 1 - Intranet-based survey among a stratified sample in the firm. - Aimed at (1) revealing the degree of 2 employee support for the strategy. - Aimed at (2) showcasing what works and what doesn’t work regarding informing, motivating and capability development. 3
  • 12.
    Step 3: ACTIONPLAN Implementing the right tools at the right moment Implementing Soft tools Implementing Hard tools Alignment Launching the Strategy Time
  • 13.
    Step 3: Balancinghard and soft wired initiatives Assessing strategic options using the gathered intelligence Negotiation Confrontation Consulting Mirroring • Presentations and negotiations with Unions • Unavoidable exposure by internal messaging • Presentations and negotiations with Working • Using Corporate Adds to persuade internal Council(s) audiences • Allocating Coaches to key managers aimed at adjusting role behavior Consensus Power Play • Town Hall meetings • New organizational structures and decision • Management Meetings making procedures • Jam Sessions • Appointing new managers in key roles • Capability development in Internal Training Programs • New appraisal rules
  • 14.
    Step 3: Whodoes what? Sell their vision it to the rest of the Top Management organization Communication & HR Marketing Who does Internal communication Expose employees to external what? campaigns Accounting Information Technology Use reporting & appraisals format forcing Facilitate vertical and alignment horizontal communication
  • 15.
    Step 4: KeyPerformance Indicators Introducing KPI’s using RepTrak™Alignment Monitor Examination of historical performance, using RepTrak Alignment Monitor over 1 two to three years (past) Extrapolating key drivers of Extrapolating KPI’s on aligned 2 alignment for next years (future) 3 behavior for the next years (future) KPIs INFORMING Realized KPI EMPLOYEE ALIGNMENT Goal 2012 Goal 2013 Goal 2014 2012 2013 2014 2011 Realized Manager leads by example 55.3 56.9 58.5 60.0 Goal 2012 Goal 2013 Goal 2014 KPIs MOTIVATING 2011 Realized 2011 Goal 2012 Goal 2013 Goal 2014 Alignment 55.2 56.8 58.4 60.0 Regular conversations manager 49.6 51.1 52.6 54.1 KPIs CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT Realized 2012 2013 2014 Goal 2012 Goal 2013 Goal 2014 2011 Sufficient authorization 51.3 52.9 54.5 56.1 Sufficient recognition 55.3 56.9 58.5 60.1 Sufficient rewarded 47.3 48.9 50.5 52.1
  • 16.
    Wrap up • Aligned employees increase performance substantially • Building and maintaining an aligned workforce requires a four step approach: Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Phase IV: Know Before You Go Revealing Action Plan Tracking Progress Support & Resistance