This document discusses two papers about measuring and accounting for in-kind government benefits (social transfers in kind or STIK) at micro and macro levels. The OECD paper presents illustrative calculations of STIK distribution across income quintiles for 10 countries. The ABS paper focuses on how the Australian Bureau of Statistics constructs official statistics on STIK and reconciles micro and macro measures. Both papers use an "insurance approach" to allocate STIK by characteristics like age, education level, and health status. The discussant comments on strengths and limitations of the methods and calls for more work to improve cross-country comparisons and understand what drives differences in STIK distribution.
Olli Kangas: Can Universal Basic Income solve future Income Security Challenges? Some tentative answers from the Finnish Basic Income (BI) experiment. Presentation at 5th Conference of the Regulating for Decent Work Network, Geneva, 4.7.2017.
Jurgen de Wispelaere (Tampereen yliopisto): Game On! Is Basic Income Experiencing a Global Window of Opportunity? Esitys seminaarissa "Perustulo globaalissa maailmassa" 13.4.2016 Helsinki, Kelan päätalo. / Presentation in the seminar "Basic income in a global world" held in Helsinki 13 April 2016. More info: http://www.kela.fi/perustulo-globaalissa-maailmassa
Kotamäki M, Mattila J, Tervola J. Turning static pessimism to dynamic optimism. An ex-ante evaluation of unemployment insurance reform in Finland. Working papers 124, Kela. http://hdl.handle.net/10138/212599
Joe Chrisp: Policy, mirror, or metaphor? The political economy of ubi. Presentation at seminar Reforming social security – What can we learn from basic income experiments? 17.12.2021.
A working group of researchers from a range of organisations under the project leadership of Kela is exploring ways in which to carry out an experimental study focusing on the implementation of a universal basic income scheme. The project is part of the Finnish Government's analysis, assessment and research plan for 2015. This presentation collects information and data on the project.
More information: http://www.kela.fi/web/en/experimental-study-on-a-universal-basic-income
Olli Kangas: Can Universal Basic Income solve future Income Security Challenges? Some tentative answers from the Finnish Basic Income (BI) experiment. Presentation at 5th Conference of the Regulating for Decent Work Network, Geneva, 4.7.2017.
Jurgen de Wispelaere (Tampereen yliopisto): Game On! Is Basic Income Experiencing a Global Window of Opportunity? Esitys seminaarissa "Perustulo globaalissa maailmassa" 13.4.2016 Helsinki, Kelan päätalo. / Presentation in the seminar "Basic income in a global world" held in Helsinki 13 April 2016. More info: http://www.kela.fi/perustulo-globaalissa-maailmassa
Kotamäki M, Mattila J, Tervola J. Turning static pessimism to dynamic optimism. An ex-ante evaluation of unemployment insurance reform in Finland. Working papers 124, Kela. http://hdl.handle.net/10138/212599
Joe Chrisp: Policy, mirror, or metaphor? The political economy of ubi. Presentation at seminar Reforming social security – What can we learn from basic income experiments? 17.12.2021.
A working group of researchers from a range of organisations under the project leadership of Kela is exploring ways in which to carry out an experimental study focusing on the implementation of a universal basic income scheme. The project is part of the Finnish Government's analysis, assessment and research plan for 2015. This presentation collects information and data on the project.
More information: http://www.kela.fi/web/en/experimental-study-on-a-universal-basic-income
Nick Pearce: Growth regimes, statecraft and incremental change. Presentation at seminar Reforming social security – What can we learn from basic income experiments? 17.12.2021.
Marjukka Turunen: How the basic income experiment works in practice. Presentation at the event ”Socially Innovative Finland - Spotlight on the basic income experiment and the Finnish maternity package”, Kela, Helsinki, 12.1.2017.
A basic income experiment was conducted in Finland in 2017–2018 to find ways to reshape the social security system. Evaluation study of the basic income experiment is underway.
Professor of Practice Olavi Kangas, University of Turku, Finland, and Program Director, Strategic Research at the Academy of Finland, at INVEST – Towards the Next Welfare State? EU side event, 4 Oct 2019, THL, Helsinki
Miska Simanainen: Benefit take up in the finnish basic income experiment. Presentation at seminar Reforming social security – What can we learn from basic income experiments? 17.12.2021.
In many countries inequality is growing as the benefits of economic growth go to the richest members of society. Inclusive Growth is all about changing the rules so that more people can contribute to and benefit from economic growth. For more information see www.oecd.org/gov/inclusive-growth-and-public-governance.htm
Minna Ylikännö: Ubi and ongoing social security reform. Presentation at seminar Reforming social security – What can we learn from basic income experiments? 17.12.2021.
Ageing: Fiscal implications and policy responses -- Mirko Lichetta, United Ki...OECD Governance
This presentation was made by Mirko Lichetta, United Kingdom, at the 6th Meeting of the Joint OECD DELSA-GOV Network on Fiscal Sustainability of Health Systems, held at the OECD Conference Centre, Paris, on 18-19 September 2017
Women's participation in the labour market is dependent on a number of factors. The policies and the budget has to be gender sensitive to create an enabling environment for the women workers. We need to shift from the gender neutral approach to the gender sensitive approach.by asking the right questions during budget preparation.
Indicators for Municipal Financial AnalysisRavikant Joshi
This PPT delivered to Students of Nirma University explains indicator as a tool of performance measurent and then provides various indicators useful for municipal financial analysis
Basic Income Ireland introductory presentationJohn Baker
Basic Income is an idea whose time has come. This presentation offers a general introduction to basic income with specific reference to Ireland. More information is available on our website basicincomeireland.com. Please contact us through our site if you would like us to come and talk about basic income.
This 2014 edition of the OECD Pensions Outlook examines the ever-changing pensions landscape. It looks at pension reform, the role of private pensions and retirement savings. Population ageing and longevity risk is examined as are the means of increasing coverage and providing automatic enrolment. This presentation by Pablo Antolin contains the highlights of main findings.
Find the book and more information about OECD work in this domain at http://oe.cd/Ov
Nick Pearce: Growth regimes, statecraft and incremental change. Presentation at seminar Reforming social security – What can we learn from basic income experiments? 17.12.2021.
Marjukka Turunen: How the basic income experiment works in practice. Presentation at the event ”Socially Innovative Finland - Spotlight on the basic income experiment and the Finnish maternity package”, Kela, Helsinki, 12.1.2017.
A basic income experiment was conducted in Finland in 2017–2018 to find ways to reshape the social security system. Evaluation study of the basic income experiment is underway.
Professor of Practice Olavi Kangas, University of Turku, Finland, and Program Director, Strategic Research at the Academy of Finland, at INVEST – Towards the Next Welfare State? EU side event, 4 Oct 2019, THL, Helsinki
Miska Simanainen: Benefit take up in the finnish basic income experiment. Presentation at seminar Reforming social security – What can we learn from basic income experiments? 17.12.2021.
In many countries inequality is growing as the benefits of economic growth go to the richest members of society. Inclusive Growth is all about changing the rules so that more people can contribute to and benefit from economic growth. For more information see www.oecd.org/gov/inclusive-growth-and-public-governance.htm
Minna Ylikännö: Ubi and ongoing social security reform. Presentation at seminar Reforming social security – What can we learn from basic income experiments? 17.12.2021.
Ageing: Fiscal implications and policy responses -- Mirko Lichetta, United Ki...OECD Governance
This presentation was made by Mirko Lichetta, United Kingdom, at the 6th Meeting of the Joint OECD DELSA-GOV Network on Fiscal Sustainability of Health Systems, held at the OECD Conference Centre, Paris, on 18-19 September 2017
Women's participation in the labour market is dependent on a number of factors. The policies and the budget has to be gender sensitive to create an enabling environment for the women workers. We need to shift from the gender neutral approach to the gender sensitive approach.by asking the right questions during budget preparation.
Indicators for Municipal Financial AnalysisRavikant Joshi
This PPT delivered to Students of Nirma University explains indicator as a tool of performance measurent and then provides various indicators useful for municipal financial analysis
Basic Income Ireland introductory presentationJohn Baker
Basic Income is an idea whose time has come. This presentation offers a general introduction to basic income with specific reference to Ireland. More information is available on our website basicincomeireland.com. Please contact us through our site if you would like us to come and talk about basic income.
This 2014 edition of the OECD Pensions Outlook examines the ever-changing pensions landscape. It looks at pension reform, the role of private pensions and retirement savings. Population ageing and longevity risk is examined as are the means of increasing coverage and providing automatic enrolment. This presentation by Pablo Antolin contains the highlights of main findings.
Find the book and more information about OECD work in this domain at http://oe.cd/Ov
Skate's Art Investment Handbook: The Comprehensive Guide to Investing in the ...McGraw-Hill Professional
The most comprehensive how-to guide of its kind, Skate’s Art Investment Handbook demystifies art investing. It provides a detailed, dispassionate look at the global art market and outlines an original analytical model and rational strategies for profiting from this alternative asset class.
Uma boa apresentação, além de mostrar empenho profissional em desenvolver um bom trabalho também pode ser o diferencial que faça o cliente escolher você, e não seu concorrente.
Uma apresentação bem feita demanda de tempo e certo planejamento. Tentar fazer uma apresentação no PowerPoint 30 minutos antes da reunião com o cliente é certeza de fracasso e trabalho perdido. Tente montar a apresentação com a maior antecedência possível, para poder revisá-la e se preparar adequadamente para a reunião
Por isso que a Agência Carcará encurta esse caminho para você! Aplicando assim conceitos de estética, design e semiótica para alcançar resultados positivos para sua apresentação empresarial.
Acesse nosso site e saiba mais http://agenciacarcara.com.br
HLEG thematic workshop on Measuring Inequalities of Income and Wealth, Marco ...StatsCommunications
Presentation at the HLEG thematic workshop on Measuring Inequalities of Income and Wealth, 15-16 September 2015, Berlin, Germany, http://oe.cd/hleg-workshop-inequalities-income-and-wealth
HLEG thematic workshop on Economic Insecurity, Andrea Brandolini, presenterStatsCommunications
HLEG thematic workshop on Economic Insecurity, 4 March 2016, New York, United States. More information at: http://oecd/hleg-workshop-on-economic-insecurity-2016
OECD Framework for Statistics on the Distribution of Household Income, Consum...StatsCommunications
This publication presents an internationally agreed framework to support the joint analysis of micro-level statistics on household income, consumption and wealth. Its aim is to extend the existing international frameworks for measuring household income and consumption at the micro level to include wealth, and describes income, consumption and wealth as three separate but interrelated dimensions of people’s economic well-being.
The framework, prepared by an international expert group working under the auspices of the OECD, is intended to assist national statistical offices and other data producers to develop data sets at the household level that are suitable for integrated analysis, and for facilitating comparisons between countries. The Framework is widely applicable, with relevance to countries that are at different stages of statistical development, that have different statistical infrastructures, and that operate in different economic and social environments.
The dynamics of social assistance benefit receiptOECD
Comparative evidence on the receipt of minimum-income benefits discussion of empirical assessment of state dependence / "scarring effects" in benefit receipt
Presentation by Xiaotong Niu, an analyst in CBO's Health, Retirement, and Long-Term Analysis Division, at the Biennial Conference of the American Society of Health Economists.
The consequences of any change to Medicare for different socioeconomic groups depend on the distribution of taxes paid to and benefits received from the current system by each group. However, only a few studies have estimated that distribution, and they offer conflicting views. This presentation describes an analysis of the distribution of Medicare taxes and spending using a unique dataset with information on beneficiaries’ lifetime earnings and Medicare spending. The dataset includes more recent cohorts of beneficiaries than earlier studies, and the distribution of Medicare taxes and spending is projected based on demographic and economic projections from CBO’s long-term microsimulation model.
The Medicare system is progressive. For people born in the 1950s, lifetime Medicare spending net of both premiums and dedicated Medicare taxes, as a share of lifetime earnings, tends to be lower for beneficiaries with higher lifetime household earnings. Almost all of the variation in lifetime Medicare spending net of premiums by lifetime household earnings can be explained by the variation in life expectancy. Medicare is projected to become more progressive for later cohorts because lifetime earnings are expected to grow faster for those with higher earnings.
Beyond GDP: Measuring well-being and progress of NationsKübra Bayram
Everyone aspires to a good life. But what does a "good" (or better) life mean? In recent years, concerns have emerged that standard macro-economic statistics, such as GDP, which for a long time had been used as proxies to measure well-being, failed to give a true account of people’s current and future living conditions. The ongoing financial and economic crisis has reinforced this perception and it is now widely recognized that data on GDP provide only a partial perspective on the broad range of factors that matter to people’s lives.
Joseph E. Stiglitz - HLEG event "Beyond GDP: What counts for economic & socia...StatsCommunications
Keynote by Joseph E. Stiglitz at HLEG event "Beyond GDP: What counts for economic & social performance? Understanding different daily life challenges of Europeans", Jointly organised by Bertelsmann Stiftung & the OECD-hosted HLEG
Presentation by OECD Chief Economist, Laurence Boone, on Inclusive Growth at the farewell conference in honor of Governor Karnit Flug, The Van Leer Institute in Jerusalem, 4 November 2018
** 'Cold Society? Improving the UK's strategy for coping with the cold' **
Date(s) - 04/03/2013
5:30 pm - 7:00 pm
Location:
British Library Conference Centre
A British Library and Strategic Society Centre public debate about excess winter deaths and the cost of cold-related illness.
As winter draws to a close, the countdown begins until the Office for National Statistics publishes its annual estimate of ‘excess winter deaths’ – usually around 25,000 pensioners each year.
These deaths, and the cost of cold-related illness to the NHS – estimated to be £1.36 billion a year in England – are widely acknowledged to be unnecessary and preventable, particularly given the outcomes achieved in countries much colder than the UK.
Four government departments deploy policies directed at the effect of cold weather on the population: DH, DECC, DCLG and – spending by far the most – DWP.
However, it is still far from clear that the UK has an effective, adequate and joined up strategy for dealing with the effects of cold.
This event will therefore explore:
Are excess winter deaths and cold-related illness a problem of public health, low incomes, fuel poverty, poor home insulation or human behaviour?
Is government policy in this area effective or targeted?
As the biggest item of public spending in this area, what proportion of Winter Fuel Payments is spent on keeping warm? What would be the effect of scrapping Winter Fuel Payments on household fuel spending?
What is the scope for more joined-up policy interventions and choices?
Speakers at this event include:
Reg Platt, Research Fellow, Institute for Public Policy Research
Cormac O’Dea, Senior Research Economist, Institute for Fiscal Studies
James Lloyd, Director, Strategic Society Centre
Labor Policy Analysis for Jobs Expansion and DevelopmentFEF Philippines
Study conducted and presented by FEF Fellow Vicente Paqueo, Aniceto Orbeta, Leonardo Lanzona and Dean Dulay for the PIDS Economic Policy Monitor Seminar, April 3, 2014. The study concludes that minimum wages and labor security have negative effects for poverty alleviation and income growth.
Similar to Plenary session 3 4 holly sutherland (20)
STREETONOMICS: Exploring the Uncharted Territories of Informal Markets throug...sameer shah
Delve into the world of STREETONOMICS, where a team of 7 enthusiasts embarks on a journey to understand unorganized markets. By engaging with a coffee street vendor and crafting questionnaires, this project uncovers valuable insights into consumer behavior and market dynamics in informal settings."
how to swap pi coins to foreign currency withdrawable.DOT TECH
As of my last update, Pi is still in the testing phase and is not tradable on any exchanges.
However, Pi Network has announced plans to launch its Testnet and Mainnet in the future, which may include listing Pi on exchanges.
The current method for selling pi coins involves exchanging them with a pi vendor who purchases pi coins for investment reasons.
If you want to sell your pi coins, reach out to a pi vendor and sell them to anyone looking to sell pi coins from any country around the globe.
Below is the what'sapp information for my personal pi vendor.
+12349014282
The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.DOT TECH
Well as we all know pi isn't launched yet. But you can still sell your pi coins effortlessly because some whales in China are interested in holding massive pi coins. And they are willing to pay good money for it. If you are interested in selling I will leave a contact for you. Just what'sapp this number below. I sold about 3000 pi coins to him and he paid me immediately.
+12349014282
Abhay Bhutada Leads Poonawalla Fincorp To Record Low NPA And Unprecedented Gr...Vighnesh Shashtri
Under the leadership of Abhay Bhutada, Poonawalla Fincorp has achieved record-low Non-Performing Assets (NPA) and witnessed unprecedented growth. Bhutada's strategic vision and effective management have significantly enhanced the company's financial health, showcasing a robust performance in the financial sector. This achievement underscores the company's resilience and ability to thrive in a competitive market, setting a new benchmark for operational excellence in the industry.
Seminar: Gender Board Diversity through Ownership NetworksGRAPE
Seminar on gender diversity spillovers through ownership networks at FAME|GRAPE. Presenting novel research. Studies in economics and management using econometrics methods.
where can I find a legit pi merchant onlineDOT TECH
Yes. This is very easy what you need is a recommendation from someone who has successfully traded pi coins before with a merchant.
Who is a pi merchant?
A pi merchant is someone who buys pi network coins and resell them to Investors looking forward to hold thousands of pi coins before the open mainnet.
I will leave the what'sapp contact of my personal pi merchant to trade with
+12349014282
BONKMILLON Unleashes Its Bonkers Potential on Solana.pdfcoingabbar
Introducing BONKMILLON - The Most Bonkers Meme Coin Yet
Let's be real for a second – the world of meme coins can feel like a bit of a circus at times. Every other day, there's a new token promising to take you "to the moon" or offering some groundbreaking utility that'll change the game forever. But how many of them actually deliver on that hype?
What website can I sell pi coins securely.DOT TECH
Currently there are no website or exchange that allow buying or selling of pi coins..
But you can still easily sell pi coins, by reselling it to exchanges/crypto whales interested in holding thousands of pi coins before the mainnet launch.
Who is a pi merchant?
A pi merchant is someone who buys pi coins from miners and resell to these crypto whales and holders of pi..
This is because pi network is not doing any pre-sale. The only way exchanges can get pi is by buying from miners and pi merchants stands in between the miners and the exchanges.
How can I sell my pi coins?
Selling pi coins is really easy, but first you need to migrate to mainnet wallet before you can do that. I will leave the what'sapp contact of my personal pi merchant to trade with.
+12349014282
1. What About STIK: How to Treat In-kind
Government Benefits at Micro- and Macro-
Levels
Discussant: Holly Sutherland, ISER, University of Essex
Session 3 IARIW General Conference 2014
Rotterdam, the Netherlands August 25th
2. 1. Household Income Disparity Comparisons Among
Countries with Various Levels of Redistribution,
Gyorgy Gyomai & Jennifer Ribarsky (OECD)
– “OECD paper”
2. Social Transfers in Kind (STIK) – Methodologies for
their Imputation, Impact on Economic Well-being
and a Comparison of the Treatment in Macro versus
Micro Data, Heather Burgess, Michael Smedes,
Andrew Tomadini & David Zago (Australian Bureau of
Statistics)
– “ABS paper”
3. Outline
• Introductory/contextual comments
• Common elements and differences
• OECD paper
– Summary
– Comments
• ABS paper
– Summary
– Comments
• Broader questions and reflections
4. Introduction/context
• From a micro (academic/policy) perspective
• AIM-AP project
– Cross-country comparisons of the distributional effects of
STiK (7 EU countries)
– Countries make different choices in the balance between
cash and non cash policies
• substitutes to some extent
• distributional consequences
• STiK in the context of cash redistribution
– Paulus, Sutherland and Tsakloglou (2010) JPAM
5. Common elements
• Concern with consistency between micro and macro
measures of STiK; (mostly) starting from the macro side
• Concepts and starting point from Canberra
• “Insurance approach” (modified) to measuring the incidence
of education, healthcare and “other” STiK, allocating producer
costs to relevant households in micro data
• STiK by income quintiles; effect on income inequality
• Reports of official studies
– OECD – Eurostat-OECD joint Expert Group on Disparities in
National Accounts (EG-DNA) → experimental calculations
– ABS – following from their contribution to EG-DNA;
ongoing work
6. Differences
• Geographical scope:
– OECD: calculations for 10 diverse countries - Australia, France, Italy, Korea,
Mexico, New Zealand, Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland & the US
– ABS: Australia only
• Content
– OECD: Illustrative/experimental calculations from the EG-DNA; further
simulation work to show that measurement issues should not prevent
conclusions being drawn
– ABS: An account of how official statistics are constructed and
reconciled (micro-macro); effect of including STiK on measures of Low
Economic Resource (LER) headcounts
• Income ranking for quintiles:
– OECD: Equivalised cash disposable income, counting households
– ABS: Equivalised private income including IR, counting persons
7. OECD paper - methods
• National inputs into EG study, so not always fully comparable (or
documented?)
• STiK elements: Health, Education and “Other”
• Macro quantities adjusted for population scope of micro-data
– People in institutions/overseas, not in private households
– By cash income and STiK sub-component
• Benchmark sum of micro-level cash income variables to macro totals
(range of methods)
• Allocate macro quantity of STiK to households according to socio-demographic
characteristics (insurance approach, modified in places)
– Heath: age and a varying range of other characteristics (gender, region,
deprivation, long term disabled/in need of care)
– Education: for those participating in education by level (mostly not
distinguishing public/private)
– “Other” varies and may include social protection services, elderly or child-care
services, recreational and cultural services; methods vary
• Households ranked by equivalised cash household disposable income
(using the modified OECD scale) and divided into quintiles on this basis
– Nice discussion of the choice of ranking regime
8. OECD paper – selected results
• STiK distribution across income quintiles
• (Comparison for healthcare in Sweden with “actual use”
method)
• Impact on income distribution of net transfers as a whole
(cash benefits and taxes, plus STiK)
• Effect on Gini coefficient
9. Share of STiK by income quintile: health
– Differences across countries in distribution reflect differences in
• Household composition of quintiles
• Types of population targeted by STiK
• Content of what is classified as STiK by national accountants
15. OECD paper – extension
• STiK distribution is difficult to measure precisely so reliability
of estimates and comparisons across countries might easily be
questioned.
• What would happen if we allocated STiK randomly across
households?
• The simulation exercise shows that on this basis including STiK
would still reduce income inequality but by less than when
using the detailed methods of allocation.
16. OECD paper – conclusion
• The larger the starting levels of inequality the more likely any
random allocation of STiK will improve the Gini-coefficient.
• The larger the share of total STiK in adjusted disposable income the
greater impact STiK may have on the Gini coefficient.
• An imperfect allocation of STiK is better than not accounting for
STiK at all.
• A uniform allocation – corresponding to a situation where no
information is available to the NSO to model STiK allocation at a
micro level – already captures at least 2/3 of the “true” impact of
STiK on the value of the Gini-coefficient.
17. OECD paper – comments (1/2)
• On the simulation exercise and the conclusion
– Almost axiomatic;
– Not clear that random allocation (equal shares) is the natural or only
appropriate counterfactual for STiK (or public spending generally):
proportional to voting power or cash income?
– STiK is created through political decision making. There are policy
implications of assuming random or equal shares.
• On the EG-DNA method: broadly standard/fine but
– Treatment of those who opt out of public provision?
– Treatment of non-compulsory (e.g. tertiary) education?
– Appropriateness of the equivalence scale for all income concepts?
– The “other” category is large/variable enough to be problematic
– Demonstrates the challenges of cross-country comparability and
suggests that an analysis based on collection of national studies may
not be fully adequate
18. OECD paper – comments (2/2)
• On the analysis of results
– It looks like the inequality results are calculated on quintile averages (5
numbers) rather than the micro-level distributions (e.g. Fig 3): if so a
huge and unnecessary loss of information.
– “Differences across countries in distribution reflect differences in
• Household composition of quintiles
• Types of population targeted by STiK
• Content of what is classified as STiK by national accountants”
• (Actual resources going into STiK)
– Suggestion: why not try and distinguish these effects?
19. ABS paper - methods
• Similar method to the OECD paper, more detail about Australian specifics
provided, including the “other” category, which is disaggregated
– Rent subsidies, electricity concessions, child care and other care
• STiK by equivalised “private income quintile” incl IR. [Before taxes and
cash transfers? What e-scale?]
• Small un-reconciled differences in SNA and micro-data based (Survey of
Income and Housing- SIH) estimates of total STiK due to difficulties in
aligning the transactions that are included, and reduced population scope
in micro-data.
– E.g. SNA includes spending on national parks, wildlife and cultural facilities
and services; micro-data based estimates do not
• Confronting micro- and macro- estimates usefully reveals different
(“subjective”) treatments by context especially in relation to
– Deciding which expenditures are individual and which collective
– Omission of the return on capital in non-market production, leading to STiK
being under-valued.
20. ABS paper – selected results
• STiK (3 main components) by private income
quintile
• Income shares by quintile + Gini coefficients
using 3 income concepts:
21. STiK in $ (3 main components) by private
income quintile
1 2 3 4 5
300
200
100
Source: ABS publications 6523.0 and 6537.0.
Equivilised private income (incl. IR) quintile
Average weekly benefit ($)
0
Education benefits
Health benefits
Social security and welfare benefits
22. Shares of income by income concept, by quintile
+ Gini coefficients
23. ABS paper – low economic resource
(LER) households/people
• LER – in the bottom 40% of equivalised disposable
income including IR and in the bottom 40% by
equivalised net worth
• Adding STiK to the former changes the composition
of those considered to be with LER
– Fewer couples/singles over age 65, those with children,
those with a disability
– More couples/singles below age 65 without children
• BUT LER is an indicator of economic hardship, not
the level of resources received: so STiK not
necessarily relevant.
24. ABS paper - conclusions
• STiK are a key mechanism for redistribution; the appropriate
measurement is vital in order that statistics (both micro and
macro) correctly reflect the economic circumstances of
households
• Contribution to quality assurance
• Contribution to developing international standards
25. ABS paper - comments
• On the method:
– Health benefit STiK is allocated to households on the basis of age, sex
and state/territory of residence taking the “insurance approach”
– But those with a disability or a long term health condition have a
higher utilisation rate applied, based on data on doctor visits.
– This would seem fine if it were balanced by an adjustment to the
equivalence scale to take account of the greater needs of these
people.
– But it is not, meaning that these people appear to be better resourced
than their equivalents without disability or long term health problems.
– The evidence in the OECD paper on Sweden suggests that this may not
have a big effect on quintile means. But …
• It might in Australia
• It probably would at the individual level
• On the analysis of results:
– We need to know how people are ranked
26. General reflections (1/2)
• Details matter. These papers are generally pretty good at providing the
necessary ones – but some are still missing (What is the ranking variable?
Who is being counted? What is the equivalence scale?)
• Results could be sensitivity tested to key assumptions to provide bounds
around the true value
• This could also aid country comparisons; these are very challenging using
OECD-style national inputs; better done centrally, in dialogue with national
experts?
• What drives cross-country differences? Can they be decomposed?
• More thought needs to be given to the appropriate equivalence scale to
use (unclear that there are economies of scale associated with most STiK)
– cf. Section 2B yesterday
• STiK in the context of cash redistribution (taxes and benefits); they are
partial substitutes
27. General reflections (2/2)
• The distribution of STiK is a policy/political issue; a key question we need
to be able to address is if public spending is cut, how are the losses
distributed across the population? Can our methods address that
robustly?
• (No?)
• That is why we need to keep working on improving concepts, precision
of measurement, comparability across countries and through time and
making sure the implications of our assumptions are transparent.