SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 52
Download to read offline
Wheaton College (MA)
Whitworth University
Widener University
Wilkes University
Williams College
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Worcester State College
Wright State University
Xavier University
Yeshiva University
Youngstown State University
Plan More, React Less
Building and Expanding Your Planned
Maintenance Program
Sightlines Webinar w/ Steve Maruszewski of Penn
State University & Paul Armas of Brown University
April 27, 2016
Today’s Presenters
> Kevan Will; Account Manager, Sightlines
> 9+ years of tenure at Sightlines
> Has worked with over 100 campuses in 27 states
> Sightlines Operational Lead for The Pennsylvania State University’s University Park Campus & 20
Commonwealth Campuses
> Graduated from Gettysburg College with a BA in Management
> Paul Armas; Director of Maintenance Operations, Brown University
> 6 years of tenure at Brown University
> Proudest Accomplishments @ Brown:
> Cultivated a culture in Facilities Management of Continuous Improvement
> Aligning facilities operations with capital renewal investments and identifying operational inefficiencies that
improve the effectiveness of service initiatives
> Steve Maruszewski; Associate Vice President for Physical Plant, The Pennsylvania State University
> 20 years of tenure at The Pennsylvania State University
> Proudest Accomplishments @ Penn State:
> Sustainability Efforts including Co-chairing the Development of Penn State’s Sustainability Strategic Plan
and achieving APPA’s national Award for Sustainability in Higher Education.
> Leading a physical plant staff of incredibly talented individuals
2
Introduction to Sightlines and our database
Brown’s story – Paul will share Brown’s PM
implementation/execution strategy and anticipated
outcomes
PSU’s story – Steve will discuss PSU’s PM strategy
centered on reliability
Executive takeaways and concluding thoughts
Questions & comments
Agenda
3
Feel Free to Start a Dialogue with Our Presenters
Enter questions in the box at any time; questions will be answered at the end of the presentation
Enter questions
here at any
point during the
webinar
Presentation slides
and webinar
recording will be
sent to each
attendee following
today’s session
4
Questions will be answered at the end of the presentation. If we run out of time, any
remaining questions will be answered after the presentation via follow-up emails.
Introduction
Who We Serve
Robust membership and growing database provides experience and perspective
Partners to the Nation’s Leading Institutions:
• 14 of the Top 20 Colleges*
• 15 of the Top 20 Universities*
• 34 Flagship State Universities
• 13 of the 14 Big 10 Institutions
• 8 of the 12 Ivy Plus Institutions
• 8 of 13 Selective Liberal Arts Colleges
Serving state systems in:
• Alaska
• California
• Florida
• Hawaii
• Maine
• Massachusetts
• Minnesota
• Missouri
• New Hampshire
• New Jersey
• Oregon
• Pennsylvania
• Texas
6
Sightlines Drives a New Conversation
Facilities intelligence toolkit that connects the dots between space, capital, and operating policies
A new conversation around
facilities management…
• Treats physical plant like a core
business
• Uses concepts of endowment
management to contextualize
investment decisions;
• Aligns facilities operations and
capital investment with institutional
mission and finance;
• Uses predictive analysis to focus
on outcomes and not inputs.
• Lets you tell your “facilities story”
as effective as possible.
7
Preventive
Maintenance Strategy,
Implementation, &
Anticipated Outcomes
Brown Campus Profile
> Located in Providence, RI
> 9,100 Students
> 6.8M GSF
> 236 Buildings
> 149 Maintained Acres
> Sightlines Member since 2002
9
> Building Portfolios Grouped by Type:
> Academic Research
> Academic Non-Research
> Biology & Medicine
> Residence Halls
> Athletics
> Student Life
> Admin / Support
> Auxiliary Housing
Brown Campus Profile (cont.)
Maintenance Operations Staffing
Management & Support Staff: 18
Trades Staff: 105
10
Additional Facilities Intelligence Compiled
Campus is older
than peers and
becoming more
complex
19% 17%
6%
26%
23%
22%
52%
36%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
Brown Peer Average
%ofTotalCampusGSF
Campus Age by Category
Under 10 10 to 25 25 to 50 Over 50 Significant needs in building
systems occur over the next
ten years
$0.00
$2.00
$4.00
$6.00
$8.00
$10.00
$12.00
$/GSF
Total Operating Expenses
Daily Service PM Utilities Peer Average
Lower operating expenses, but
performing more work with in-house staff
than peers
12
> Campus NAV 81.65%
> Deferred maintenance need identified at
$462M
> Infrastructure renewal needs $60M annually to
keep backlog from growing
Facts Learned from 2010 Assessment
“Brown needed to increase funding for recurring
capital and needed to focus on Preventive
Maintenance within its operating budget”
11
Statistics at “The Beginning”
2011 (Pre-Strategy)
No. PM+CM completed 14,000
No. RM completed 38,000
% PM+CM labor 25%
% RM labor 75%
In house PM+CM labor $1.5M
Supplies PM+CM $580K
Contract services $1.6M
Dedicated PM staff 0
No. of equipment 5,000
13
Goals:
> Prolong the useful life of equipment
> Lower operating costs associated with
maintaining equipment
> Reduce utility costs and energy
> Reduce unplanned system interruptions
PM Strategy Overview
14
• Co-created a strategy with 133 FM staff and customers using
3 lean principles
• Focus on increasing value, reducing waste, and respecting
people
• Assessed current PM situation including work practices &
systems
• Assessed data systems & sample buildings
• Created building and asset prioritization method
• Generated ideas, assess cost vs. value
• Designed a new PM Program
• Created an implementation approach, including phasing plan,
staffing, and budget
What We Did: The Process
15
PM Strategy by Portfolio
Proposed PM Level of Service
Maint. Levels* Description* PM
Critical Bldg.
Score
Brown Bldg.
Portfolio
Level 1:
Showpiece
Facility
All
recommended
PM is
scheduled and
performed
100% >75
Central Heat
Plant
Academic
Research
Level 2:
Comprehensive
Stewardship
85% of
recommended
PM is
scheduled and
performed
85% 50-74
Academic Non-
Research
Student Life
Level 3:
Managed Care
50-60% of
recommended
PM is
scheduled and
performed
50%-60% 20-49
Admin/Support
Athletics
Dormitory
Level 4:
Reactive
Management
25% or less of
recommended
PM is
scheduled and
performed
<25% <20
Auxiliary
Housing
Portfolio
Critical
Bldg.
Score
Avg.
Acad. Research 77
Student Life 63
Acad. Non-
Research
51
Admin/Support 33
Athletics 23
Dormitory 21
Aux. Housing 8
16
* APPA service levels and descriptions
Brown Values & Desired Outcomes
Identified by Customers and Stakeholders
Customer
Satisfaction!
• Better Planning &
Organization
• Balanced Workflow &
Prioritization
• Improved Communication &
Transparency
17
Planning
Design &
Construction
Gather Data
&
Equipment
Info
Plan PM
Needs
Define PM
Task &
Frequency
Develop
CM WO
Schedule &
Assign Work
Obtain
Materials/
Parts
Do Work
Document
in Famis
Closing &
QA/QC
Organization
Mgmt
Problems 9 13 14 15 8 12 27 58 7 14 5
Ideas 19 8 17 15 2 20 33 55 8 11 3
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Value Stream Mapping of
Preventive & Corrective Maintenance Work Order Processes
Learning to See Problems Together
Identifying Opportunities & Ideas
18
19
> Used to identify waste in maintenance execution
process to help fund the desired PM program
> Identified 57,000 hours of recoverable labor costs
through operational efficiency improvement in these
areas:
Lean Process
Improvement Area Estimated Hours Gained
Asset & Equipment Information 12,528
Standard Work Execution 12,161
PM Strategic & Responsive Scheduling 9,305
Tools/Parts/Materials/Inventory Management 14,568
Management & Communication 8,439
20
PM Budgeting Process
100%
PM Budget
Estimate
Brown University
100% Maintenance
Level
Gross
Square feet
Total
PM Hours
Total
PM Cost
Total
PM Material
Cost
Total
Contract
Services PM
Cost
Total
PM Costs
Cost/GSFT
Academic - Research 643,393 28,755 1,293,989$ 212,877$ 176,435$ 1,683,301$ 2.62
Biomed 694,073 32,701 1,471,545$ 218,311$ 194,572$ 1,884,428$ 2.72
Academic - Non-Research 1,563,481 56,763 2,554,328$ 292,554$ 465,918$ 3,312,800$ 2.12
Student Life 279,275 8,858 398,620$ 91,438$ 100,882$ 590,939$ 2.12
Admin / Support 683,117 14,871 669,198$ 104,205$ 270,700$ 1,044,103$ 1.53
Athletics 440,923 14,406 648,269$ 128,073$ 69,217$ 845,559$ 1.92
Dormitory 1,685,533 29,328 1,319,752$ 176,151$ 372,394$ 1,868,297$ 1.11
Aux. Housing 219,208 6,126 275,676$ 61,184$ 87,441$ 424,301$ 1.94
Central Heating Plant 4,500,000 8,000 360,000$ 24,000$ 160,000$ 544,000$ 0.12
Total 6,209,003 199,808 8,991,377 1,308,791 1,897,559 12,197,727 1.96
$12,197,727199,808
21
Target PM Budget Selected
Brown University
Recommended PM
Program
Gross
Square feet
Future
PM Hours
Future
PM Cost
Future
PM Material
Cost
Future
Contract
Services
PM Cost
Total
PM Costs Cost/GSFT
Academic - Research 643,393 19,266 866,973$ 170,302$ 176,435$ 1,213,709$ 1.89
BioMed 694,073 20,941 942,345$ 208,647$ 185,960$ 1,336,952$ 1.93
Academic - Non Research 1,563,481 32,326 1,454,690$ 291,764$ 465,918$ 2,212,372$ 1.42
Student Life 279,275 5,045 227,014$ 93,042$ 100,882$ 420,937$ 1.51
Admin / Support 683,117 5,978 269,018$ 88,296$ 270,700$ 628,013$ 0.92
Athletics 440,923 4,826 217,170$ 108,277$ 69,217$ 394,664$ 0.90
Dormitory 1,685,533 9,825 442,117$ 113,481$ 297,915$ 853,513$ 0.51
Aux. Housing 219,208 959 43,155$ 37,932$ 71,091$ 152,178$ 0.69
Central Heating Plant 4,500,000 8,000 360,000$ 24,000$ 160,000$ 544,000$ 0.12
Total 6,209,003 107,166 $ 4,822,481 $ 1,135,742 $ 1,798,117 $ 7,756,339 1.25$7,756,339107,166
22
> Seed Money (One time funding)
> Built up a PM reserve over several years of $580K
> New Space Incremental O&M funding (Annual)
> Reoccurring new and renovated space funding
$400K targeted toward Preventive Maintenance
> Recapture of 57,000 hours of labor efficiencies
> PM activities equivalent to 27 FTE’s or $2.5M of PM
PM Program Funding
23
PM Strategy Implementation
2011
› PM Strategy Development
› Lean Process
2012
› PM Strategy Finalized
› Staffing Plan Defined
› Training Program Established
› CMMS Redesign – Phase 1
2013
› CMMS Redesign – Phase 2
› In-House Equipment Data
Collection Pilot
› PM Management Team Created
› PM Staff & Supervisor Additions
2014
› 3rd Party Equipment Data
Collection Pilot
› PM Metrics Design
› Visual Aids Established
› Mobile Application Design
2015
› Visual Aids Pilot
› Mobile Application Pilot
› Master Scheduling
Implementation
› Campus Wide Equipment
Data Collection – Phase 1
24
2016
› Visual Aids Deployed
› Mobile iPad’s Deployed
› Campus Wide Equipment
Data Collection – Phase 2
› PM Metric Deployed
› QA/QC Pilot & Deployed
Current & Future State
2011
(Pre-Strategy)
2015
(Year 4)
< 2019
(Target)
No. PM+CM completed 14,000 32,000 45,000
No. RM completed 38,000 30,000 20,000
% PM+CM labor 25% 52% > 70%
% RM labor 75% 48% < 30%
In house PM+CM labor $1.5M $4.11M $4.85M
Supplies PM+CM $580K $740K $1.15M
Contract services $1.6M $2.0M $1.8M
Dedicated PM staff 0 30 40
No. of equipment 5,000 16,000 >20,000
25
The Team In Action!
26
Reliability Centered
Maintenance
Penn State Campus Profile
> University Park (UP) Campus
Located in State College, PA
> 45,000 Students at UP
> 95,000 Students at all locations
> Sightlines Member since 2002
28
Penn State Campus Profile All Locations
24 distinct locations in Pennsylvania including a major hospital. Each
location is subject to local governance and local support structure.
University Park is almost it’s own city with 2 power plants, it’s own water
supply and filtration plant, sewage treatment plant, 4 substations, etc.
Type UoM University
Park
Campuses Total incl. Hershey
& all other
locations
Land Acres 7,343 3,042 22,539
Paved Roads Miles 35 28 63
Paved Walkways Miles 60 21 71
# of Buildings Each 940 478 1710
Building Area GSF (Millions) 24.6 8.1 32.1
394 Man. & Sup. Staff; 957 TS Employees; 101 Temporary TS Employees
29
> Facility Needs Index (FCNI) Goals:
> Icons (Old Main) 0.15
> Student Space (classrooms, commons, etc.) 0.15
> Education and General Space 0.25
> Infrastructure (parking, roadways, etc.) 0.25
> Utilities 0.15
> Current FCNI’s
0.01-0.05 Excellent, new 18%
0.06-0.15 Good 28%
0.16-0.30 Fair 35%
0.31-0.40 Below average 11%
0.41-0.59 Poor, gut/renovation 6%
0.60-and above Replace 2%
> Current Deferred Renewal Backlog – $1.7B
Penn State Facility Conditions
30
Penn State Age Profile: UP vs. CWC
19% 16%
13%
27%
29%
42%
39%
15%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
UP CWC
%ofTotalCampusGSF
Renovation Age by Category
Less Than 10 10-25 25-50 Over 50
Buildings Under 10
Little work.
“Honeymoon” period.
Low Risk
Buildings 10 to 25
Short life-cycle needs;
primarily space renewal.
Medium Risk
Buildings 25 to 50
Major envelope and mechanical
life cycles come due.
Higher Risk
Buildings over 50
Life cycles of major building
components are past due. Failures are
possible.
Highest risk
68%
57%
31
Penn State Capital Investment Against Target
$0
$50
$100
$150
$200
$250
2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019 2021 2023
Total$inMillions
Annual Stewardship Projection to ‘Keep
Up’ Campus in Current Condition
Asset Reinvestment Projection to Significantly
Reduce Backlog and Modernize Buildings
Blue Bars – Annual Stewardship Capital Investment (Includes MM & SFF Funding)
Yellow Bars – Capital Asset Reinvestment (Includes UFR, DGS, PFI, Gifts)
Blue Line – Annual Stewardship Capital projection to keep up campus in current condition
Yellow Line – Capital Asset Reinvestment Projection to reduce backlog
32
Penn State Loss in Buying Power
-60.0%
-50.0%
-40.0%
-30.0%
-20.0%
-10.0%
0.0%
10.0%
20.0%
Budget Reduction
Industry Inflation
Rate
Cumulative Impact
04-05 05-06 06-07 07-08 08-09 09-10 10-11 11-12 12-13 13-14 14-15
53% over last
ten years
uncompounded
33
Summary of the Challenges
• The challenges are significant and they aren’t going away soon.
• National pressure on affordability = increased pressure on
funding sources.
• Permanent stewardship funding is getting harder to acquire.
• Capital funding doesn’t fully address the gap because much of
it goes to non-priority deferred issues.
• Our annual buying power continues to shrink.
• We need to maximize the use of existing funding to extend the
life of our systems and to improve overall reliability.
We cannot afford to be in the reactive
maintenance business!!!
34
Establish a path toward Reliability focused
Maintenance through Planned, Predictive and
Preventive maintenance
Change the Culture to Focus on Reliability!!
The Answer
35
Change the Culture
Congratulations you oiled 50
bearing sets today!!!!!!
Best way to start a
cultural shift is to
start by changing
what your reward.
36
Why Make this Shift?
Cost for Ineffective Preventive and Predictive Maintenance
for 2 – 40,000 CFM Lab Make-up Air Handlers:
• 2 months down time for one
• 6 months down time for other
• Over $500k direct cost
• Over $1m lost research opportunity
37
Potential Failures – Where to Detect Them?
Cost to repair is
only a portion of
the total cost due
to the failure
38
‘Run to Failure’ Unacceptable in Institutional Settings
While run to
failure is a viable
strategy, it is
rarely acceptable
in Institutional
settings.
39
Operating Actuals: Higher than Average Daily Service Costs
$3.73
$3.13 $3.23
$3.49
$4.31
$3.43
$4.42
$6.10
$5.48
$7.03
$4.03 $3.90
$-
$1.00
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
$5.00
$6.00
$7.00
$8.00
A B C D E F G Penn
State
H I J K
$/GSF
Facilities Operating Budget Actuals
Actual Daily Service $/GSF Peer Avg
*Institutions ordered by backlog
40
Maintenance Performance
Penn State operates with more maintenance staff than most peers
PSU Peers Database
General Repair/
Impression
4.29 3.74 3.84
0
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
120,000
140,000
160,000
180,000
200,000
GSF/FTE
Maintenance Staffing Coverage
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
FTE/Supervisor
Maintenance Supervision
*Ordered by tech rating
41
Planned Maintenance Investment
$0
$1,000,000
$2,000,000
$3,000,000
$4,000,000
$5,000,000
$6,000,000
$7,000,000
$8,000,000
$9,000,000
$10,000,000
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
PMSpending
Planned Maintenance Spending
$0.00
$0.10
$0.20
$0.30
$0.40
$0.50
$0.60
$0.70
$0.80
$0.90
A
B
C
D
E
F
PennState
G
H
I
J
K
$/GSF
PM spending $/GSF
Against Facilities Peers
*Institutions ordered by tech rating
42
Re-Organized to increase focus on preventive
and predictive maintenance programs.
This allows for easier expansion of one area
with simultaneous reduction in another area
Re-organizing Around Preventive and Predictive Maintenance
Manager
Maintenance
Programs
Electrical System
Integrity Programs
Electrical System
Integrity Programs
Electrical System
Integrity Programs
HVAC PM
Hydronic Treatment
Programs
Elevator Program
Maintenance
Maintenance
Programs And
Services
Sr. Manager
Building Services
Area Services 1
Area Services 2
Area Services 3
Area Services 4
Area Services 5
Area Services 6
Plumbing & Metal Fab
HVAC
General Services
Electrical & Electronics
2nd Shift Trades
Weekend Shift Trades
43
Institute Numerous Preventive and Predictive Programs
> Predictive:
> Vibration Analysis
> Thermographic Analysis
> Eddy-Current Testing
> Preventive:
> Custodial Equipment PM
> PMs on all snow removal, landscape, and construction equipment, and all vehicles
> Mechanical room walk thru’s
> Exteriors: Doors and Roofing PMs
> Water softener PMs
> Research Equipment PMs (stills, autoclaves, acid digesters, environmental chambers, etc)
> HV Equipment (filter, belts, lube) & Refrigeration PMs (DX units, process chilled water, etc.)
> Electrical Integrity, EMGs, UPS
> Water Treatment
> Fire extinguishers and Sprinkler Systems, Fire and Smoke Alarm Systems
> Elevator PMs
> Animal Waterers and various farm systems like milking systems, manure removal
> Street Light PMs
> Group Relamping
> Ultrasonic Steam Trap Program
44
> Upgrading our CMMS and aligning our facilities condition analysis to
focus on Assets. This will allow for more informed decision making
> Strengthening the planning and scheduling process
> Adding planners that focus on each of the major disciplines
> Plans will result in job kitting to ensure techs have materials at the site
when they are ready to perform the work.
Strengthen the Planning
45
> Developing new metrics to support the effort and linking metrics directly
to the university and physical plant strategic plans
Develop New Metrics
High-level Objective Child Objective [ 1 ]
Grandchild Objective
Work Execution Management Schedule Optimization Schedule Compliance
MRO_Inventory Management Demand Management Stock-out Management
Work Execution Management Planning Efficiency Planned 2 Unplanned
MRO_Inventory Management Demand Management Service Level Management
Work Execution Management Proactive Work Optimization Proactive Maintenance Compliance
Work Execution Management Proactive Work Optimization Proactive Work Past-due
Reliability Management Asset Reliability Critical Failures
Work Execution Management Planning Efficiency Planning Accuracy
Reliability Management Maintenance Strategy Maintenance Mix
Work Execution Management Schedule Optimization Schedule Break-in Ratio
Work Execution Management Schedule Optimization Backlog Management
MRO_Inventory Management Demand Management PR aging
MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Movement Inventory Aging
MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Movement Inventory Turnover
Reliability Management Asset Reliability M T B F
Reliability Management Asset Reliability M T T R
Reliability Management Maintenance Strategy PM PdM Yield
Reliability Management Asset Reliability Rework
MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Movement Material Transfer Invoicing (MTI)
MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Value Growth Critical Spares Growth
MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Value Growth Non-Critical Spare Growth
MRO_Inventory Management Demand Management Kitting Efficiency
MRO_Inventory Management Warehouse Controls Inventory Adjustments
46
Performed Baseline Wrench Study
Metrics for each Supervisor
Key Activity Type Description
1
Working
Time spent physically performing tasks
2
Travel
Time spent walking/driving to locations
3
Matrl Rec
Time spent gathering materials (i.e.
parts, tools, etc.)
4
Meetings
Time spent in meetings on or off the
jobsite
5
Instruction
Time spent in a learning environment on
or off site in which training takes place
6
Clearance Delay
Time delay due to permission or access
to be granted to perform the work
7
Interference
Time elapsed due to conflicts between
two or more entities on one site (i.e. CM
crew must work around electrical crew)
8
Idle
Downtime due to miscellaneous
occurrences such as mini-breaks, waiting
for glue to dry, etc.
9 Rest Room Time elapsed for rest room visit
10
Break
Time elapsed during break (may include
travel time)
11
Total Time Obs
This is the total time in which an
observation takes place (multiply by the
number of persons observed) (see in
GDM Wrench Time Algorithm)
12
1 Tech Only Time
Time in which only one technician is
working while the other is idle
Activities Studied
47
Expand capacity of staff by capturing $3-6m/yr
in wrench time
Reduce reactive maintenance to less than 20%
Reduce operating cost/SF
Significantly improve overall reliability
Increase overall customer satisfaction
Expected Outcome
48
Executive Takeaways
Paul Armas – Brown University
• It’s critical to have a strategic plan.
• ‘Buy-in’ by both management and the staff is critical. They need to be part
of the process in developing the solutions.
• Metrics must be established and monitored to ensure that goals are met.
Steve Maruszewski – The Pennsylvania State University
• Funding will always be constrained and we need to make the best use of
what we have.
• Planning and Prevention are the key to maximizing the value of available
funding.
• A cultural shift from valuing the extreme to valuing the routine is necessary
for success.
Executive Takeaways
50
Questions?
Please remember to complete the survey after the webinar ends.
Thank you!
Stay Current with Latest Trends and Best Practices
Let us keep you current, visit our Insights page
If you haven’t downloaded
our report, The State of
Facilities in Higher
Education: 2015
Benchmarks, Best
Practices & Trends, please
go to sightlines.com to
download your copy today.
Sign up for our monthly
newsletter
Read our blog, explore our
content
52

More Related Content

What's hot

May 09 -Cable curriculum delivery 2009 v1
May 09 -Cable curriculum delivery 2009 v1May 09 -Cable curriculum delivery 2009 v1
May 09 -Cable curriculum delivery 2009 v1curricsupport
 
Nw admission and enrollment process 11-28-16
Nw admission and enrollment process 11-28-16Nw admission and enrollment process 11-28-16
Nw admission and enrollment process 11-28-16Houston Community College
 
Katarina Thomson and Karl Molden - Turning Course Evaluation into Information
Katarina Thomson and Karl Molden - Turning Course Evaluation into InformationKatarina Thomson and Karl Molden - Turning Course Evaluation into Information
Katarina Thomson and Karl Molden - Turning Course Evaluation into InformationAssociation of University Administrators
 
Acl oct.2015 session hfis_reeves.burt
Acl oct.2015 session hfis_reeves.burtAcl oct.2015 session hfis_reeves.burt
Acl oct.2015 session hfis_reeves.burtRobert Leneway
 
Rolling out institutional technologies
Rolling out institutional technologiesRolling out institutional technologies
Rolling out institutional technologiesJisc
 
Changing the Conversation: Making the Case for Funding Deferred Maintenance [...
Changing the Conversation: Making the Case for Funding Deferred Maintenance [...Changing the Conversation: Making the Case for Funding Deferred Maintenance [...
Changing the Conversation: Making the Case for Funding Deferred Maintenance [...Sightlines
 
Institutional Buy-In - Competency-Based Education
Institutional Buy-In - Competency-Based EducationInstitutional Buy-In - Competency-Based Education
Institutional Buy-In - Competency-Based EducationBecky Lopanec
 
“And never the twain shall meet…” Commercial and academic: quality partnershi...
“And never the twain shall meet…” Commercial and academic: quality partnershi...“And never the twain shall meet…” Commercial and academic: quality partnershi...
“And never the twain shall meet…” Commercial and academic: quality partnershi...Association of University Administrators
 

What's hot (14)

Naac Criterion-III
Naac Criterion-IIINaac Criterion-III
Naac Criterion-III
 
May 09 -Cable curriculum delivery 2009 v1
May 09 -Cable curriculum delivery 2009 v1May 09 -Cable curriculum delivery 2009 v1
May 09 -Cable curriculum delivery 2009 v1
 
Nw admission and enrollment process 11-28-16
Nw admission and enrollment process 11-28-16Nw admission and enrollment process 11-28-16
Nw admission and enrollment process 11-28-16
 
Katarina Thomson and Karl Molden - Turning Course Evaluation into Information
Katarina Thomson and Karl Molden - Turning Course Evaluation into InformationKatarina Thomson and Karl Molden - Turning Course Evaluation into Information
Katarina Thomson and Karl Molden - Turning Course Evaluation into Information
 
Acl oct.2015 session hfis_reeves.burt
Acl oct.2015 session hfis_reeves.burtAcl oct.2015 session hfis_reeves.burt
Acl oct.2015 session hfis_reeves.burt
 
Rolling out institutional technologies
Rolling out institutional technologiesRolling out institutional technologies
Rolling out institutional technologies
 
Changing the Conversation: Making the Case for Funding Deferred Maintenance [...
Changing the Conversation: Making the Case for Funding Deferred Maintenance [...Changing the Conversation: Making the Case for Funding Deferred Maintenance [...
Changing the Conversation: Making the Case for Funding Deferred Maintenance [...
 
Bon secrus college 31 10-18
Bon secrus college 31 10-18Bon secrus college 31 10-18
Bon secrus college 31 10-18
 
IQAC
IQACIQAC
IQAC
 
HE Course and Module Evaluation Conference - Kate Little
HE Course and Module Evaluation Conference - Kate LittleHE Course and Module Evaluation Conference - Kate Little
HE Course and Module Evaluation Conference - Kate Little
 
John Baker and Christopher Sarchet - Trans Europe Express
John Baker and Christopher Sarchet - Trans Europe ExpressJohn Baker and Christopher Sarchet - Trans Europe Express
John Baker and Christopher Sarchet - Trans Europe Express
 
Enhancing the Student Experience through Partnership Working
Enhancing the Student Experience through Partnership Working Enhancing the Student Experience through Partnership Working
Enhancing the Student Experience through Partnership Working
 
Institutional Buy-In - Competency-Based Education
Institutional Buy-In - Competency-Based EducationInstitutional Buy-In - Competency-Based Education
Institutional Buy-In - Competency-Based Education
 
“And never the twain shall meet…” Commercial and academic: quality partnershi...
“And never the twain shall meet…” Commercial and academic: quality partnershi...“And never the twain shall meet…” Commercial and academic: quality partnershi...
“And never the twain shall meet…” Commercial and academic: quality partnershi...
 

Viewers also liked

60 Minutes Per Day Social Media Maintenance Plan
60 Minutes Per Day Social Media Maintenance Plan60 Minutes Per Day Social Media Maintenance Plan
60 Minutes Per Day Social Media Maintenance PlanMarki Lemons Ryhal
 
Computer maintenance work plan
Computer maintenance  work plan Computer maintenance  work plan
Computer maintenance work plan gberk
 
Forklift Planned Maintenance by Toyota Lift of Minnesota
Forklift Planned Maintenance by Toyota Lift of MinnesotaForklift Planned Maintenance by Toyota Lift of Minnesota
Forklift Planned Maintenance by Toyota Lift of MinnesotaForklift Trucks in Minnesota
 
Benefit from a Wilcox Planned Maintenance Program
Benefit from a Wilcox Planned Maintenance ProgramBenefit from a Wilcox Planned Maintenance Program
Benefit from a Wilcox Planned Maintenance ProgramBill Stewart
 
Condition-Based Maintenance: 10 Steps Towards Continuous Improvement
Condition-Based Maintenance: 10 Steps Towards Continuous ImprovementCondition-Based Maintenance: 10 Steps Towards Continuous Improvement
Condition-Based Maintenance: 10 Steps Towards Continuous ImprovementOSIsoft, LLC
 
Batch plant maintenance
Batch plant maintenanceBatch plant maintenance
Batch plant maintenanceDaniia Roxio
 
Key Performance Indicators
Key Performance IndicatorsKey Performance Indicators
Key Performance IndicatorsCIToolkit
 
Planned Maintenance.
Planned Maintenance.Planned Maintenance.
Planned Maintenance.Hal Frohreich
 
Total Quality Management-A Road Map to Corporate Excellence
Total Quality Management-A Road Map to Corporate ExcellenceTotal Quality Management-A Road Map to Corporate Excellence
Total Quality Management-A Road Map to Corporate Excellenceharikrishnanjl
 
Overview of Key Performance Indicators
Overview of Key Performance IndicatorsOverview of Key Performance Indicators
Overview of Key Performance IndicatorsMicheal Axelsen
 
25 KPIs Every Manager Needs To Know
25 KPIs Every Manager Needs To Know25 KPIs Every Manager Needs To Know
25 KPIs Every Manager Needs To KnowBernard Marr
 

Viewers also liked (14)

STEMSeriesPortfolio
STEMSeriesPortfolioSTEMSeriesPortfolio
STEMSeriesPortfolio
 
Plan for major repairs and maintenance work on JCCBI structures
Plan for major repairs and maintenance work on JCCBI structuresPlan for major repairs and maintenance work on JCCBI structures
Plan for major repairs and maintenance work on JCCBI structures
 
60 Minutes Per Day Social Media Maintenance Plan
60 Minutes Per Day Social Media Maintenance Plan60 Minutes Per Day Social Media Maintenance Plan
60 Minutes Per Day Social Media Maintenance Plan
 
Computer maintenance work plan
Computer maintenance  work plan Computer maintenance  work plan
Computer maintenance work plan
 
Forklift Planned Maintenance by Toyota Lift of Minnesota
Forklift Planned Maintenance by Toyota Lift of MinnesotaForklift Planned Maintenance by Toyota Lift of Minnesota
Forklift Planned Maintenance by Toyota Lift of Minnesota
 
Benefit from a Wilcox Planned Maintenance Program
Benefit from a Wilcox Planned Maintenance ProgramBenefit from a Wilcox Planned Maintenance Program
Benefit from a Wilcox Planned Maintenance Program
 
Condition-Based Maintenance: 10 Steps Towards Continuous Improvement
Condition-Based Maintenance: 10 Steps Towards Continuous ImprovementCondition-Based Maintenance: 10 Steps Towards Continuous Improvement
Condition-Based Maintenance: 10 Steps Towards Continuous Improvement
 
A Road Map To Perfect Duplication
A Road Map To Perfect DuplicationA Road Map To Perfect Duplication
A Road Map To Perfect Duplication
 
Batch plant maintenance
Batch plant maintenanceBatch plant maintenance
Batch plant maintenance
 
Key Performance Indicators
Key Performance IndicatorsKey Performance Indicators
Key Performance Indicators
 
Planned Maintenance.
Planned Maintenance.Planned Maintenance.
Planned Maintenance.
 
Total Quality Management-A Road Map to Corporate Excellence
Total Quality Management-A Road Map to Corporate ExcellenceTotal Quality Management-A Road Map to Corporate Excellence
Total Quality Management-A Road Map to Corporate Excellence
 
Overview of Key Performance Indicators
Overview of Key Performance IndicatorsOverview of Key Performance Indicators
Overview of Key Performance Indicators
 
25 KPIs Every Manager Needs To Know
25 KPIs Every Manager Needs To Know25 KPIs Every Manager Needs To Know
25 KPIs Every Manager Needs To Know
 

Similar to Plan More, React Less: Building & Expanding Your Planned Maintenance Program

Leveraging New Analytics to Change the Conversation around Facilities on Campus
Leveraging New Analytics to Change the Conversation around Facilities on Campus Leveraging New Analytics to Change the Conversation around Facilities on Campus
Leveraging New Analytics to Change the Conversation around Facilities on Campus Sightlines
 
Simulation of a University Financial System
Simulation of a University Financial SystemSimulation of a University Financial System
Simulation of a University Financial SystemFletcher Lamkin
 
Is Your Facilities Data Fact, Fiction, or Crap? - Creating Facilities Intelli...
Is Your Facilities Data Fact, Fiction, or Crap? - Creating Facilities Intelli...Is Your Facilities Data Fact, Fiction, or Crap? - Creating Facilities Intelli...
Is Your Facilities Data Fact, Fiction, or Crap? - Creating Facilities Intelli...Sightlines
 
A System-Wide Approach to Driving Process Improvement
A System-Wide Approach to Driving Process ImprovementA System-Wide Approach to Driving Process Improvement
A System-Wide Approach to Driving Process ImprovementKaiNexus
 
From Boiler Room to Board Room: Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Profes...
From Boiler Room to Board Room: Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Profes...From Boiler Room to Board Room: Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Profes...
From Boiler Room to Board Room: Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Profes...Sightlines
 
Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Professionals - APPA 2016
Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Professionals - APPA 2016Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Professionals - APPA 2016
Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Professionals - APPA 2016Sightlines
 
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance - APPA 2015
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance - APPA 2015Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance - APPA 2015
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance - APPA 2015Sightlines
 
The ROI of KaiNexus and the Workout Methodology
The ROI of KaiNexus and the Workout MethodologyThe ROI of KaiNexus and the Workout Methodology
The ROI of KaiNexus and the Workout MethodologyKaiNexus
 
More with Less: Five Strategies for Facilities Success [MAPPA-CAPPA 2017]
More with Less: Five Strategies for Facilities Success [MAPPA-CAPPA 2017]More with Less: Five Strategies for Facilities Success [MAPPA-CAPPA 2017]
More with Less: Five Strategies for Facilities Success [MAPPA-CAPPA 2017]Sightlines
 
MnSCU Bonding Request
MnSCU Bonding RequestMnSCU Bonding Request
MnSCU Bonding RequestMSCSA
 
Developing A Facilities Vision - Savings Summit 2013
Developing A Facilities Vision - Savings Summit 2013Developing A Facilities Vision - Savings Summit 2013
Developing A Facilities Vision - Savings Summit 2013SchoolDude
 
How UMass is reducing its deferred maintenance backlog
How UMass is reducing its deferred maintenance backlogHow UMass is reducing its deferred maintenance backlog
How UMass is reducing its deferred maintenance backlogSightlines
 
7 Essential Questions Highly Effective Facilities Leaders Must Answer_SRAPPA ...
7 Essential Questions Highly Effective Facilities Leaders Must Answer_SRAPPA ...7 Essential Questions Highly Effective Facilities Leaders Must Answer_SRAPPA ...
7 Essential Questions Highly Effective Facilities Leaders Must Answer_SRAPPA ...Sightlines
 
The Hec Story Nov 2011
The Hec Story Nov 2011The Hec Story Nov 2011
The Hec Story Nov 2011Sohail Naqvi
 
Take Control of Your Facilities: Explore the Tools for Aligning Space, Capita...
Take Control of Your Facilities: Explore the Tools for Aligning Space, Capita...Take Control of Your Facilities: Explore the Tools for Aligning Space, Capita...
Take Control of Your Facilities: Explore the Tools for Aligning Space, Capita...Sightlines
 
PEX Award-11-03-13-11-35 -submit
PEX Award-11-03-13-11-35 -submitPEX Award-11-03-13-11-35 -submit
PEX Award-11-03-13-11-35 -submitCarolyn Selin
 
Focusing a Campus Investment Strategy - NCAPPA 2016
Focusing a Campus Investment Strategy - NCAPPA 2016Focusing a Campus Investment Strategy - NCAPPA 2016
Focusing a Campus Investment Strategy - NCAPPA 2016Sightlines
 

Similar to Plan More, React Less: Building & Expanding Your Planned Maintenance Program (20)

Leveraging New Analytics to Change the Conversation around Facilities on Campus
Leveraging New Analytics to Change the Conversation around Facilities on Campus Leveraging New Analytics to Change the Conversation around Facilities on Campus
Leveraging New Analytics to Change the Conversation around Facilities on Campus
 
Simulation of a University Financial System
Simulation of a University Financial SystemSimulation of a University Financial System
Simulation of a University Financial System
 
Is Your Facilities Data Fact, Fiction, or Crap? - Creating Facilities Intelli...
Is Your Facilities Data Fact, Fiction, or Crap? - Creating Facilities Intelli...Is Your Facilities Data Fact, Fiction, or Crap? - Creating Facilities Intelli...
Is Your Facilities Data Fact, Fiction, or Crap? - Creating Facilities Intelli...
 
A System-Wide Approach to Driving Process Improvement
A System-Wide Approach to Driving Process ImprovementA System-Wide Approach to Driving Process Improvement
A System-Wide Approach to Driving Process Improvement
 
November 2017 Directors Meeting
November 2017 Directors MeetingNovember 2017 Directors Meeting
November 2017 Directors Meeting
 
From Boiler Room to Board Room: Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Profes...
From Boiler Room to Board Room: Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Profes...From Boiler Room to Board Room: Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Profes...
From Boiler Room to Board Room: Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Profes...
 
Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Professionals - APPA 2016
Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Professionals - APPA 2016Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Professionals - APPA 2016
Creating Alignment with Non-Facilities Professionals - APPA 2016
 
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance - APPA 2015
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance - APPA 2015Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance - APPA 2015
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance - APPA 2015
 
20150114_presentation_RS_LEAN
20150114_presentation_RS_LEAN20150114_presentation_RS_LEAN
20150114_presentation_RS_LEAN
 
The ROI of KaiNexus and the Workout Methodology
The ROI of KaiNexus and the Workout MethodologyThe ROI of KaiNexus and the Workout Methodology
The ROI of KaiNexus and the Workout Methodology
 
More with Less: Five Strategies for Facilities Success [MAPPA-CAPPA 2017]
More with Less: Five Strategies for Facilities Success [MAPPA-CAPPA 2017]More with Less: Five Strategies for Facilities Success [MAPPA-CAPPA 2017]
More with Less: Five Strategies for Facilities Success [MAPPA-CAPPA 2017]
 
MnSCU Bonding Request
MnSCU Bonding RequestMnSCU Bonding Request
MnSCU Bonding Request
 
Developing A Facilities Vision - Savings Summit 2013
Developing A Facilities Vision - Savings Summit 2013Developing A Facilities Vision - Savings Summit 2013
Developing A Facilities Vision - Savings Summit 2013
 
NHTI About Us
NHTI About UsNHTI About Us
NHTI About Us
 
How UMass is reducing its deferred maintenance backlog
How UMass is reducing its deferred maintenance backlogHow UMass is reducing its deferred maintenance backlog
How UMass is reducing its deferred maintenance backlog
 
7 Essential Questions Highly Effective Facilities Leaders Must Answer_SRAPPA ...
7 Essential Questions Highly Effective Facilities Leaders Must Answer_SRAPPA ...7 Essential Questions Highly Effective Facilities Leaders Must Answer_SRAPPA ...
7 Essential Questions Highly Effective Facilities Leaders Must Answer_SRAPPA ...
 
The Hec Story Nov 2011
The Hec Story Nov 2011The Hec Story Nov 2011
The Hec Story Nov 2011
 
Take Control of Your Facilities: Explore the Tools for Aligning Space, Capita...
Take Control of Your Facilities: Explore the Tools for Aligning Space, Capita...Take Control of Your Facilities: Explore the Tools for Aligning Space, Capita...
Take Control of Your Facilities: Explore the Tools for Aligning Space, Capita...
 
PEX Award-11-03-13-11-35 -submit
PEX Award-11-03-13-11-35 -submitPEX Award-11-03-13-11-35 -submit
PEX Award-11-03-13-11-35 -submit
 
Focusing a Campus Investment Strategy - NCAPPA 2016
Focusing a Campus Investment Strategy - NCAPPA 2016Focusing a Campus Investment Strategy - NCAPPA 2016
Focusing a Campus Investment Strategy - NCAPPA 2016
 

More from Sightlines

State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2017
State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2017State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2017
State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2017Sightlines
 
2017 State of Facilities in Higher Education
2017 State of Facilities in Higher Education2017 State of Facilities in Higher Education
2017 State of Facilities in Higher EducationSightlines
 
Put Your Facilities Data to Work: 5 Steps for Strengthening Your Case on Campus
Put Your Facilities Data to Work: 5 Steps for Strengthening Your Case on CampusPut Your Facilities Data to Work: 5 Steps for Strengthening Your Case on Campus
Put Your Facilities Data to Work: 5 Steps for Strengthening Your Case on CampusSightlines
 
Developing the Capital Plan is Only Half the Battle [ERAPPA 2017]
Developing the Capital Plan is Only Half the Battle [ERAPPA 2017]Developing the Capital Plan is Only Half the Battle [ERAPPA 2017]
Developing the Capital Plan is Only Half the Battle [ERAPPA 2017]Sightlines
 
The State of Housing Facilities: Trends & Best Practices [ACUHO-i/APPA 2017]
The State of Housing Facilities: Trends & Best Practices [ACUHO-i/APPA 2017]The State of Housing Facilities: Trends & Best Practices [ACUHO-i/APPA 2017]
The State of Housing Facilities: Trends & Best Practices [ACUHO-i/APPA 2017]Sightlines
 
Doing More with Less: Solutions for Managing Facilities on a Limited Budget
Doing More with Less: Solutions for Managing Facilities on a Limited BudgetDoing More with Less: Solutions for Managing Facilities on a Limited Budget
Doing More with Less: Solutions for Managing Facilities on a Limited BudgetSightlines
 
Making the Case for Campus Sustainability
Making the Case for Campus SustainabilityMaking the Case for Campus Sustainability
Making the Case for Campus SustainabilitySightlines
 
Planning for the Future: Adapting Facilities to Tomorrow's Needs
Planning for the Future: Adapting Facilities to Tomorrow's NeedsPlanning for the Future: Adapting Facilities to Tomorrow's Needs
Planning for the Future: Adapting Facilities to Tomorrow's NeedsSightlines
 
The State of Facilities: Preventing Your Biggest Asset from Becoming Your Big...
The State of Facilities: Preventing Your Biggest Asset from Becoming Your Big...The State of Facilities: Preventing Your Biggest Asset from Becoming Your Big...
The State of Facilities: Preventing Your Biggest Asset from Becoming Your Big...Sightlines
 
Exploring the State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2016
Exploring the State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2016Exploring the State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2016
Exploring the State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2016Sightlines
 
2016 State of Facilities in Higher Education
2016 State of Facilities in Higher Education2016 State of Facilities in Higher Education
2016 State of Facilities in Higher EducationSightlines
 
When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It: Rutgers & Sightlines ERAPPA 201...
When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It: Rutgers & Sightlines ERAPPA 201...When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It: Rutgers & Sightlines ERAPPA 201...
When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It: Rutgers & Sightlines ERAPPA 201...Sightlines
 
Prepping for the President: Planning Rutgers' 250th Commencement
Prepping for the President: Planning Rutgers' 250th CommencementPrepping for the President: Planning Rutgers' 250th Commencement
Prepping for the President: Planning Rutgers' 250th CommencementSightlines
 
The State of Facilities at Midwestern Institutions
The State of Facilities at Midwestern InstitutionsThe State of Facilities at Midwestern Institutions
The State of Facilities at Midwestern InstitutionsSightlines
 
Sightlines Membership Update - The Value of Integration with Gordian
Sightlines Membership Update - The Value of Integration with GordianSightlines Membership Update - The Value of Integration with Gordian
Sightlines Membership Update - The Value of Integration with GordianSightlines
 
Data & Sustainability: How the Right Data Creates Success
Data & Sustainability: How the Right Data Creates SuccessData & Sustainability: How the Right Data Creates Success
Data & Sustainability: How the Right Data Creates SuccessSightlines
 
Taming Deferred Maintenance Before the Roof Caves In (2016 Sightlines NACUBO ...
Taming Deferred Maintenance Before the Roof Caves In (2016 Sightlines NACUBO ...Taming Deferred Maintenance Before the Roof Caves In (2016 Sightlines NACUBO ...
Taming Deferred Maintenance Before the Roof Caves In (2016 Sightlines NACUBO ...Sightlines
 
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance: From Game Plan to Master Plan
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance: From Game Plan to Master PlanDon't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance: From Game Plan to Master Plan
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance: From Game Plan to Master PlanSightlines
 
The State of Facilities at Eastern Region Institutions JUNE16
The State of Facilities at Eastern Region Institutions JUNE16The State of Facilities at Eastern Region Institutions JUNE16
The State of Facilities at Eastern Region Institutions JUNE16Sightlines
 
The State of Facilities at Pacific Coast Institutions May2016
The State of Facilities at Pacific Coast Institutions May2016The State of Facilities at Pacific Coast Institutions May2016
The State of Facilities at Pacific Coast Institutions May2016Sightlines
 

More from Sightlines (20)

State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2017
State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2017State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2017
State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2017
 
2017 State of Facilities in Higher Education
2017 State of Facilities in Higher Education2017 State of Facilities in Higher Education
2017 State of Facilities in Higher Education
 
Put Your Facilities Data to Work: 5 Steps for Strengthening Your Case on Campus
Put Your Facilities Data to Work: 5 Steps for Strengthening Your Case on CampusPut Your Facilities Data to Work: 5 Steps for Strengthening Your Case on Campus
Put Your Facilities Data to Work: 5 Steps for Strengthening Your Case on Campus
 
Developing the Capital Plan is Only Half the Battle [ERAPPA 2017]
Developing the Capital Plan is Only Half the Battle [ERAPPA 2017]Developing the Capital Plan is Only Half the Battle [ERAPPA 2017]
Developing the Capital Plan is Only Half the Battle [ERAPPA 2017]
 
The State of Housing Facilities: Trends & Best Practices [ACUHO-i/APPA 2017]
The State of Housing Facilities: Trends & Best Practices [ACUHO-i/APPA 2017]The State of Housing Facilities: Trends & Best Practices [ACUHO-i/APPA 2017]
The State of Housing Facilities: Trends & Best Practices [ACUHO-i/APPA 2017]
 
Doing More with Less: Solutions for Managing Facilities on a Limited Budget
Doing More with Less: Solutions for Managing Facilities on a Limited BudgetDoing More with Less: Solutions for Managing Facilities on a Limited Budget
Doing More with Less: Solutions for Managing Facilities on a Limited Budget
 
Making the Case for Campus Sustainability
Making the Case for Campus SustainabilityMaking the Case for Campus Sustainability
Making the Case for Campus Sustainability
 
Planning for the Future: Adapting Facilities to Tomorrow's Needs
Planning for the Future: Adapting Facilities to Tomorrow's NeedsPlanning for the Future: Adapting Facilities to Tomorrow's Needs
Planning for the Future: Adapting Facilities to Tomorrow's Needs
 
The State of Facilities: Preventing Your Biggest Asset from Becoming Your Big...
The State of Facilities: Preventing Your Biggest Asset from Becoming Your Big...The State of Facilities: Preventing Your Biggest Asset from Becoming Your Big...
The State of Facilities: Preventing Your Biggest Asset from Becoming Your Big...
 
Exploring the State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2016
Exploring the State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2016Exploring the State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2016
Exploring the State of Sustainability in Higher Education 2016
 
2016 State of Facilities in Higher Education
2016 State of Facilities in Higher Education2016 State of Facilities in Higher Education
2016 State of Facilities in Higher Education
 
When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It: Rutgers & Sightlines ERAPPA 201...
When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It: Rutgers & Sightlines ERAPPA 201...When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It: Rutgers & Sightlines ERAPPA 201...
When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It: Rutgers & Sightlines ERAPPA 201...
 
Prepping for the President: Planning Rutgers' 250th Commencement
Prepping for the President: Planning Rutgers' 250th CommencementPrepping for the President: Planning Rutgers' 250th Commencement
Prepping for the President: Planning Rutgers' 250th Commencement
 
The State of Facilities at Midwestern Institutions
The State of Facilities at Midwestern InstitutionsThe State of Facilities at Midwestern Institutions
The State of Facilities at Midwestern Institutions
 
Sightlines Membership Update - The Value of Integration with Gordian
Sightlines Membership Update - The Value of Integration with GordianSightlines Membership Update - The Value of Integration with Gordian
Sightlines Membership Update - The Value of Integration with Gordian
 
Data & Sustainability: How the Right Data Creates Success
Data & Sustainability: How the Right Data Creates SuccessData & Sustainability: How the Right Data Creates Success
Data & Sustainability: How the Right Data Creates Success
 
Taming Deferred Maintenance Before the Roof Caves In (2016 Sightlines NACUBO ...
Taming Deferred Maintenance Before the Roof Caves In (2016 Sightlines NACUBO ...Taming Deferred Maintenance Before the Roof Caves In (2016 Sightlines NACUBO ...
Taming Deferred Maintenance Before the Roof Caves In (2016 Sightlines NACUBO ...
 
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance: From Game Plan to Master Plan
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance: From Game Plan to Master PlanDon't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance: From Game Plan to Master Plan
Don't Leave Your Facilities Needs to Chance: From Game Plan to Master Plan
 
The State of Facilities at Eastern Region Institutions JUNE16
The State of Facilities at Eastern Region Institutions JUNE16The State of Facilities at Eastern Region Institutions JUNE16
The State of Facilities at Eastern Region Institutions JUNE16
 
The State of Facilities at Pacific Coast Institutions May2016
The State of Facilities at Pacific Coast Institutions May2016The State of Facilities at Pacific Coast Institutions May2016
The State of Facilities at Pacific Coast Institutions May2016
 

Recently uploaded

Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3JemimahLaneBuaron
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxheathfieldcps1
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityGeoBlogs
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxNirmalaLoungPoorunde1
 
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website AppURLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website AppCeline George
 
mini mental status format.docx
mini    mental       status     format.docxmini    mental       status     format.docx
mini mental status format.docxPoojaSen20
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfSoniaTolstoy
 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)eniolaolutunde
 
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdfQucHHunhnh
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformChameera Dedduwage
 
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactPECB
 
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphThiyagu K
 
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...Marc Dusseiller Dusjagr
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdfQucHHunhnh
 
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpinStudent login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpinRaunakKeshri1
 
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991RKavithamani
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfchloefrazer622
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
 
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website AppURLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
URLs and Routing in the Odoo 17 Website App
 
mini mental status format.docx
mini    mental       status     format.docxmini    mental       status     format.docx
mini mental status format.docx
 
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
 
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
 
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
 
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
 
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
 
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpinStudent login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
 
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
 
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSDStaff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
 

Plan More, React Less: Building & Expanding Your Planned Maintenance Program

  • 1. Wheaton College (MA) Whitworth University Widener University Wilkes University Williams College Worcester Polytechnic Institute Worcester State College Wright State University Xavier University Yeshiva University Youngstown State University Plan More, React Less Building and Expanding Your Planned Maintenance Program Sightlines Webinar w/ Steve Maruszewski of Penn State University & Paul Armas of Brown University April 27, 2016
  • 2. Today’s Presenters > Kevan Will; Account Manager, Sightlines > 9+ years of tenure at Sightlines > Has worked with over 100 campuses in 27 states > Sightlines Operational Lead for The Pennsylvania State University’s University Park Campus & 20 Commonwealth Campuses > Graduated from Gettysburg College with a BA in Management > Paul Armas; Director of Maintenance Operations, Brown University > 6 years of tenure at Brown University > Proudest Accomplishments @ Brown: > Cultivated a culture in Facilities Management of Continuous Improvement > Aligning facilities operations with capital renewal investments and identifying operational inefficiencies that improve the effectiveness of service initiatives > Steve Maruszewski; Associate Vice President for Physical Plant, The Pennsylvania State University > 20 years of tenure at The Pennsylvania State University > Proudest Accomplishments @ Penn State: > Sustainability Efforts including Co-chairing the Development of Penn State’s Sustainability Strategic Plan and achieving APPA’s national Award for Sustainability in Higher Education. > Leading a physical plant staff of incredibly talented individuals 2
  • 3. Introduction to Sightlines and our database Brown’s story – Paul will share Brown’s PM implementation/execution strategy and anticipated outcomes PSU’s story – Steve will discuss PSU’s PM strategy centered on reliability Executive takeaways and concluding thoughts Questions & comments Agenda 3
  • 4. Feel Free to Start a Dialogue with Our Presenters Enter questions in the box at any time; questions will be answered at the end of the presentation Enter questions here at any point during the webinar Presentation slides and webinar recording will be sent to each attendee following today’s session 4 Questions will be answered at the end of the presentation. If we run out of time, any remaining questions will be answered after the presentation via follow-up emails.
  • 6. Who We Serve Robust membership and growing database provides experience and perspective Partners to the Nation’s Leading Institutions: • 14 of the Top 20 Colleges* • 15 of the Top 20 Universities* • 34 Flagship State Universities • 13 of the 14 Big 10 Institutions • 8 of the 12 Ivy Plus Institutions • 8 of 13 Selective Liberal Arts Colleges Serving state systems in: • Alaska • California • Florida • Hawaii • Maine • Massachusetts • Minnesota • Missouri • New Hampshire • New Jersey • Oregon • Pennsylvania • Texas 6
  • 7. Sightlines Drives a New Conversation Facilities intelligence toolkit that connects the dots between space, capital, and operating policies A new conversation around facilities management… • Treats physical plant like a core business • Uses concepts of endowment management to contextualize investment decisions; • Aligns facilities operations and capital investment with institutional mission and finance; • Uses predictive analysis to focus on outcomes and not inputs. • Lets you tell your “facilities story” as effective as possible. 7
  • 9. Brown Campus Profile > Located in Providence, RI > 9,100 Students > 6.8M GSF > 236 Buildings > 149 Maintained Acres > Sightlines Member since 2002 9
  • 10. > Building Portfolios Grouped by Type: > Academic Research > Academic Non-Research > Biology & Medicine > Residence Halls > Athletics > Student Life > Admin / Support > Auxiliary Housing Brown Campus Profile (cont.) Maintenance Operations Staffing Management & Support Staff: 18 Trades Staff: 105 10
  • 11. Additional Facilities Intelligence Compiled Campus is older than peers and becoming more complex 19% 17% 6% 26% 23% 22% 52% 36% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Brown Peer Average %ofTotalCampusGSF Campus Age by Category Under 10 10 to 25 25 to 50 Over 50 Significant needs in building systems occur over the next ten years $0.00 $2.00 $4.00 $6.00 $8.00 $10.00 $12.00 $/GSF Total Operating Expenses Daily Service PM Utilities Peer Average Lower operating expenses, but performing more work with in-house staff than peers 12
  • 12. > Campus NAV 81.65% > Deferred maintenance need identified at $462M > Infrastructure renewal needs $60M annually to keep backlog from growing Facts Learned from 2010 Assessment “Brown needed to increase funding for recurring capital and needed to focus on Preventive Maintenance within its operating budget” 11
  • 13. Statistics at “The Beginning” 2011 (Pre-Strategy) No. PM+CM completed 14,000 No. RM completed 38,000 % PM+CM labor 25% % RM labor 75% In house PM+CM labor $1.5M Supplies PM+CM $580K Contract services $1.6M Dedicated PM staff 0 No. of equipment 5,000 13
  • 14. Goals: > Prolong the useful life of equipment > Lower operating costs associated with maintaining equipment > Reduce utility costs and energy > Reduce unplanned system interruptions PM Strategy Overview 14
  • 15. • Co-created a strategy with 133 FM staff and customers using 3 lean principles • Focus on increasing value, reducing waste, and respecting people • Assessed current PM situation including work practices & systems • Assessed data systems & sample buildings • Created building and asset prioritization method • Generated ideas, assess cost vs. value • Designed a new PM Program • Created an implementation approach, including phasing plan, staffing, and budget What We Did: The Process 15
  • 16. PM Strategy by Portfolio Proposed PM Level of Service Maint. Levels* Description* PM Critical Bldg. Score Brown Bldg. Portfolio Level 1: Showpiece Facility All recommended PM is scheduled and performed 100% >75 Central Heat Plant Academic Research Level 2: Comprehensive Stewardship 85% of recommended PM is scheduled and performed 85% 50-74 Academic Non- Research Student Life Level 3: Managed Care 50-60% of recommended PM is scheduled and performed 50%-60% 20-49 Admin/Support Athletics Dormitory Level 4: Reactive Management 25% or less of recommended PM is scheduled and performed <25% <20 Auxiliary Housing Portfolio Critical Bldg. Score Avg. Acad. Research 77 Student Life 63 Acad. Non- Research 51 Admin/Support 33 Athletics 23 Dormitory 21 Aux. Housing 8 16 * APPA service levels and descriptions
  • 17. Brown Values & Desired Outcomes Identified by Customers and Stakeholders Customer Satisfaction! • Better Planning & Organization • Balanced Workflow & Prioritization • Improved Communication & Transparency 17
  • 18. Planning Design & Construction Gather Data & Equipment Info Plan PM Needs Define PM Task & Frequency Develop CM WO Schedule & Assign Work Obtain Materials/ Parts Do Work Document in Famis Closing & QA/QC Organization Mgmt Problems 9 13 14 15 8 12 27 58 7 14 5 Ideas 19 8 17 15 2 20 33 55 8 11 3 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Value Stream Mapping of Preventive & Corrective Maintenance Work Order Processes Learning to See Problems Together Identifying Opportunities & Ideas 18
  • 19. 19
  • 20. > Used to identify waste in maintenance execution process to help fund the desired PM program > Identified 57,000 hours of recoverable labor costs through operational efficiency improvement in these areas: Lean Process Improvement Area Estimated Hours Gained Asset & Equipment Information 12,528 Standard Work Execution 12,161 PM Strategic & Responsive Scheduling 9,305 Tools/Parts/Materials/Inventory Management 14,568 Management & Communication 8,439 20
  • 21. PM Budgeting Process 100% PM Budget Estimate Brown University 100% Maintenance Level Gross Square feet Total PM Hours Total PM Cost Total PM Material Cost Total Contract Services PM Cost Total PM Costs Cost/GSFT Academic - Research 643,393 28,755 1,293,989$ 212,877$ 176,435$ 1,683,301$ 2.62 Biomed 694,073 32,701 1,471,545$ 218,311$ 194,572$ 1,884,428$ 2.72 Academic - Non-Research 1,563,481 56,763 2,554,328$ 292,554$ 465,918$ 3,312,800$ 2.12 Student Life 279,275 8,858 398,620$ 91,438$ 100,882$ 590,939$ 2.12 Admin / Support 683,117 14,871 669,198$ 104,205$ 270,700$ 1,044,103$ 1.53 Athletics 440,923 14,406 648,269$ 128,073$ 69,217$ 845,559$ 1.92 Dormitory 1,685,533 29,328 1,319,752$ 176,151$ 372,394$ 1,868,297$ 1.11 Aux. Housing 219,208 6,126 275,676$ 61,184$ 87,441$ 424,301$ 1.94 Central Heating Plant 4,500,000 8,000 360,000$ 24,000$ 160,000$ 544,000$ 0.12 Total 6,209,003 199,808 8,991,377 1,308,791 1,897,559 12,197,727 1.96 $12,197,727199,808 21
  • 22. Target PM Budget Selected Brown University Recommended PM Program Gross Square feet Future PM Hours Future PM Cost Future PM Material Cost Future Contract Services PM Cost Total PM Costs Cost/GSFT Academic - Research 643,393 19,266 866,973$ 170,302$ 176,435$ 1,213,709$ 1.89 BioMed 694,073 20,941 942,345$ 208,647$ 185,960$ 1,336,952$ 1.93 Academic - Non Research 1,563,481 32,326 1,454,690$ 291,764$ 465,918$ 2,212,372$ 1.42 Student Life 279,275 5,045 227,014$ 93,042$ 100,882$ 420,937$ 1.51 Admin / Support 683,117 5,978 269,018$ 88,296$ 270,700$ 628,013$ 0.92 Athletics 440,923 4,826 217,170$ 108,277$ 69,217$ 394,664$ 0.90 Dormitory 1,685,533 9,825 442,117$ 113,481$ 297,915$ 853,513$ 0.51 Aux. Housing 219,208 959 43,155$ 37,932$ 71,091$ 152,178$ 0.69 Central Heating Plant 4,500,000 8,000 360,000$ 24,000$ 160,000$ 544,000$ 0.12 Total 6,209,003 107,166 $ 4,822,481 $ 1,135,742 $ 1,798,117 $ 7,756,339 1.25$7,756,339107,166 22
  • 23. > Seed Money (One time funding) > Built up a PM reserve over several years of $580K > New Space Incremental O&M funding (Annual) > Reoccurring new and renovated space funding $400K targeted toward Preventive Maintenance > Recapture of 57,000 hours of labor efficiencies > PM activities equivalent to 27 FTE’s or $2.5M of PM PM Program Funding 23
  • 24. PM Strategy Implementation 2011 › PM Strategy Development › Lean Process 2012 › PM Strategy Finalized › Staffing Plan Defined › Training Program Established › CMMS Redesign – Phase 1 2013 › CMMS Redesign – Phase 2 › In-House Equipment Data Collection Pilot › PM Management Team Created › PM Staff & Supervisor Additions 2014 › 3rd Party Equipment Data Collection Pilot › PM Metrics Design › Visual Aids Established › Mobile Application Design 2015 › Visual Aids Pilot › Mobile Application Pilot › Master Scheduling Implementation › Campus Wide Equipment Data Collection – Phase 1 24 2016 › Visual Aids Deployed › Mobile iPad’s Deployed › Campus Wide Equipment Data Collection – Phase 2 › PM Metric Deployed › QA/QC Pilot & Deployed
  • 25. Current & Future State 2011 (Pre-Strategy) 2015 (Year 4) < 2019 (Target) No. PM+CM completed 14,000 32,000 45,000 No. RM completed 38,000 30,000 20,000 % PM+CM labor 25% 52% > 70% % RM labor 75% 48% < 30% In house PM+CM labor $1.5M $4.11M $4.85M Supplies PM+CM $580K $740K $1.15M Contract services $1.6M $2.0M $1.8M Dedicated PM staff 0 30 40 No. of equipment 5,000 16,000 >20,000 25
  • 26. The Team In Action! 26
  • 28. Penn State Campus Profile > University Park (UP) Campus Located in State College, PA > 45,000 Students at UP > 95,000 Students at all locations > Sightlines Member since 2002 28
  • 29. Penn State Campus Profile All Locations 24 distinct locations in Pennsylvania including a major hospital. Each location is subject to local governance and local support structure. University Park is almost it’s own city with 2 power plants, it’s own water supply and filtration plant, sewage treatment plant, 4 substations, etc. Type UoM University Park Campuses Total incl. Hershey & all other locations Land Acres 7,343 3,042 22,539 Paved Roads Miles 35 28 63 Paved Walkways Miles 60 21 71 # of Buildings Each 940 478 1710 Building Area GSF (Millions) 24.6 8.1 32.1 394 Man. & Sup. Staff; 957 TS Employees; 101 Temporary TS Employees 29
  • 30. > Facility Needs Index (FCNI) Goals: > Icons (Old Main) 0.15 > Student Space (classrooms, commons, etc.) 0.15 > Education and General Space 0.25 > Infrastructure (parking, roadways, etc.) 0.25 > Utilities 0.15 > Current FCNI’s 0.01-0.05 Excellent, new 18% 0.06-0.15 Good 28% 0.16-0.30 Fair 35% 0.31-0.40 Below average 11% 0.41-0.59 Poor, gut/renovation 6% 0.60-and above Replace 2% > Current Deferred Renewal Backlog – $1.7B Penn State Facility Conditions 30
  • 31. Penn State Age Profile: UP vs. CWC 19% 16% 13% 27% 29% 42% 39% 15% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% UP CWC %ofTotalCampusGSF Renovation Age by Category Less Than 10 10-25 25-50 Over 50 Buildings Under 10 Little work. “Honeymoon” period. Low Risk Buildings 10 to 25 Short life-cycle needs; primarily space renewal. Medium Risk Buildings 25 to 50 Major envelope and mechanical life cycles come due. Higher Risk Buildings over 50 Life cycles of major building components are past due. Failures are possible. Highest risk 68% 57% 31
  • 32. Penn State Capital Investment Against Target $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019 2021 2023 Total$inMillions Annual Stewardship Projection to ‘Keep Up’ Campus in Current Condition Asset Reinvestment Projection to Significantly Reduce Backlog and Modernize Buildings Blue Bars – Annual Stewardship Capital Investment (Includes MM & SFF Funding) Yellow Bars – Capital Asset Reinvestment (Includes UFR, DGS, PFI, Gifts) Blue Line – Annual Stewardship Capital projection to keep up campus in current condition Yellow Line – Capital Asset Reinvestment Projection to reduce backlog 32
  • 33. Penn State Loss in Buying Power -60.0% -50.0% -40.0% -30.0% -20.0% -10.0% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% Budget Reduction Industry Inflation Rate Cumulative Impact 04-05 05-06 06-07 07-08 08-09 09-10 10-11 11-12 12-13 13-14 14-15 53% over last ten years uncompounded 33
  • 34. Summary of the Challenges • The challenges are significant and they aren’t going away soon. • National pressure on affordability = increased pressure on funding sources. • Permanent stewardship funding is getting harder to acquire. • Capital funding doesn’t fully address the gap because much of it goes to non-priority deferred issues. • Our annual buying power continues to shrink. • We need to maximize the use of existing funding to extend the life of our systems and to improve overall reliability. We cannot afford to be in the reactive maintenance business!!! 34
  • 35. Establish a path toward Reliability focused Maintenance through Planned, Predictive and Preventive maintenance Change the Culture to Focus on Reliability!! The Answer 35
  • 36. Change the Culture Congratulations you oiled 50 bearing sets today!!!!!! Best way to start a cultural shift is to start by changing what your reward. 36
  • 37. Why Make this Shift? Cost for Ineffective Preventive and Predictive Maintenance for 2 – 40,000 CFM Lab Make-up Air Handlers: • 2 months down time for one • 6 months down time for other • Over $500k direct cost • Over $1m lost research opportunity 37
  • 38. Potential Failures – Where to Detect Them? Cost to repair is only a portion of the total cost due to the failure 38
  • 39. ‘Run to Failure’ Unacceptable in Institutional Settings While run to failure is a viable strategy, it is rarely acceptable in Institutional settings. 39
  • 40. Operating Actuals: Higher than Average Daily Service Costs $3.73 $3.13 $3.23 $3.49 $4.31 $3.43 $4.42 $6.10 $5.48 $7.03 $4.03 $3.90 $- $1.00 $2.00 $3.00 $4.00 $5.00 $6.00 $7.00 $8.00 A B C D E F G Penn State H I J K $/GSF Facilities Operating Budget Actuals Actual Daily Service $/GSF Peer Avg *Institutions ordered by backlog 40
  • 41. Maintenance Performance Penn State operates with more maintenance staff than most peers PSU Peers Database General Repair/ Impression 4.29 3.74 3.84 0 20,000 40,000 60,000 80,000 100,000 120,000 140,000 160,000 180,000 200,000 GSF/FTE Maintenance Staffing Coverage 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 FTE/Supervisor Maintenance Supervision *Ordered by tech rating 41
  • 42. Planned Maintenance Investment $0 $1,000,000 $2,000,000 $3,000,000 $4,000,000 $5,000,000 $6,000,000 $7,000,000 $8,000,000 $9,000,000 $10,000,000 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 PMSpending Planned Maintenance Spending $0.00 $0.10 $0.20 $0.30 $0.40 $0.50 $0.60 $0.70 $0.80 $0.90 A B C D E F PennState G H I J K $/GSF PM spending $/GSF Against Facilities Peers *Institutions ordered by tech rating 42
  • 43. Re-Organized to increase focus on preventive and predictive maintenance programs. This allows for easier expansion of one area with simultaneous reduction in another area Re-organizing Around Preventive and Predictive Maintenance Manager Maintenance Programs Electrical System Integrity Programs Electrical System Integrity Programs Electrical System Integrity Programs HVAC PM Hydronic Treatment Programs Elevator Program Maintenance Maintenance Programs And Services Sr. Manager Building Services Area Services 1 Area Services 2 Area Services 3 Area Services 4 Area Services 5 Area Services 6 Plumbing & Metal Fab HVAC General Services Electrical & Electronics 2nd Shift Trades Weekend Shift Trades 43
  • 44. Institute Numerous Preventive and Predictive Programs > Predictive: > Vibration Analysis > Thermographic Analysis > Eddy-Current Testing > Preventive: > Custodial Equipment PM > PMs on all snow removal, landscape, and construction equipment, and all vehicles > Mechanical room walk thru’s > Exteriors: Doors and Roofing PMs > Water softener PMs > Research Equipment PMs (stills, autoclaves, acid digesters, environmental chambers, etc) > HV Equipment (filter, belts, lube) & Refrigeration PMs (DX units, process chilled water, etc.) > Electrical Integrity, EMGs, UPS > Water Treatment > Fire extinguishers and Sprinkler Systems, Fire and Smoke Alarm Systems > Elevator PMs > Animal Waterers and various farm systems like milking systems, manure removal > Street Light PMs > Group Relamping > Ultrasonic Steam Trap Program 44
  • 45. > Upgrading our CMMS and aligning our facilities condition analysis to focus on Assets. This will allow for more informed decision making > Strengthening the planning and scheduling process > Adding planners that focus on each of the major disciplines > Plans will result in job kitting to ensure techs have materials at the site when they are ready to perform the work. Strengthen the Planning 45
  • 46. > Developing new metrics to support the effort and linking metrics directly to the university and physical plant strategic plans Develop New Metrics High-level Objective Child Objective [ 1 ] Grandchild Objective Work Execution Management Schedule Optimization Schedule Compliance MRO_Inventory Management Demand Management Stock-out Management Work Execution Management Planning Efficiency Planned 2 Unplanned MRO_Inventory Management Demand Management Service Level Management Work Execution Management Proactive Work Optimization Proactive Maintenance Compliance Work Execution Management Proactive Work Optimization Proactive Work Past-due Reliability Management Asset Reliability Critical Failures Work Execution Management Planning Efficiency Planning Accuracy Reliability Management Maintenance Strategy Maintenance Mix Work Execution Management Schedule Optimization Schedule Break-in Ratio Work Execution Management Schedule Optimization Backlog Management MRO_Inventory Management Demand Management PR aging MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Movement Inventory Aging MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Movement Inventory Turnover Reliability Management Asset Reliability M T B F Reliability Management Asset Reliability M T T R Reliability Management Maintenance Strategy PM PdM Yield Reliability Management Asset Reliability Rework MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Movement Material Transfer Invoicing (MTI) MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Value Growth Critical Spares Growth MRO_Inventory Management Inventory Value Growth Non-Critical Spare Growth MRO_Inventory Management Demand Management Kitting Efficiency MRO_Inventory Management Warehouse Controls Inventory Adjustments 46
  • 47. Performed Baseline Wrench Study Metrics for each Supervisor Key Activity Type Description 1 Working Time spent physically performing tasks 2 Travel Time spent walking/driving to locations 3 Matrl Rec Time spent gathering materials (i.e. parts, tools, etc.) 4 Meetings Time spent in meetings on or off the jobsite 5 Instruction Time spent in a learning environment on or off site in which training takes place 6 Clearance Delay Time delay due to permission or access to be granted to perform the work 7 Interference Time elapsed due to conflicts between two or more entities on one site (i.e. CM crew must work around electrical crew) 8 Idle Downtime due to miscellaneous occurrences such as mini-breaks, waiting for glue to dry, etc. 9 Rest Room Time elapsed for rest room visit 10 Break Time elapsed during break (may include travel time) 11 Total Time Obs This is the total time in which an observation takes place (multiply by the number of persons observed) (see in GDM Wrench Time Algorithm) 12 1 Tech Only Time Time in which only one technician is working while the other is idle Activities Studied 47
  • 48. Expand capacity of staff by capturing $3-6m/yr in wrench time Reduce reactive maintenance to less than 20% Reduce operating cost/SF Significantly improve overall reliability Increase overall customer satisfaction Expected Outcome 48
  • 50. Paul Armas – Brown University • It’s critical to have a strategic plan. • ‘Buy-in’ by both management and the staff is critical. They need to be part of the process in developing the solutions. • Metrics must be established and monitored to ensure that goals are met. Steve Maruszewski – The Pennsylvania State University • Funding will always be constrained and we need to make the best use of what we have. • Planning and Prevention are the key to maximizing the value of available funding. • A cultural shift from valuing the extreme to valuing the routine is necessary for success. Executive Takeaways 50
  • 51. Questions? Please remember to complete the survey after the webinar ends. Thank you!
  • 52. Stay Current with Latest Trends and Best Practices Let us keep you current, visit our Insights page If you haven’t downloaded our report, The State of Facilities in Higher Education: 2015 Benchmarks, Best Practices & Trends, please go to sightlines.com to download your copy today. Sign up for our monthly newsletter Read our blog, explore our content 52