The speaker achieved the maximum grade of merit for their pitch. They maintained eye contact and kept their PowerPoint simple to allow more explanation to the panel. While their ideas were good, their first idea needed more backstory and their second idea would be difficult to film. The panel preferred the first idea as easier to develop and film. Feedback included reorganizing the presentation to show ideas before discussing characters and techniques. The speaker will take forward their first idea, changing it slightly based on the panel's feedback.