IEEE COMSOC PANEL

LTE BACKHAUL CHALLENGES,
SMALL CELLS AND THE
CRITICAL ROLE OF
MICROWAVE

PAUL KENNARD, CTO | AVIAT NETWORKS




                                     1
LTE
                                            (Lon	

                                      	

          g Ter
                                                           m Ev
                                                               oluti
                                    4G	

                           on)	

                                   10x f
                                             aster
                                   QoS,            than
                                                         3G	

                                             Low
                                  All-I           laten
                                        P	

            cy	

                                 Low
                                      Cost
                             	

              	

                       	




3   AVIAT NETWORKS |
?
LESSONS LEARNED #1


CONSTRUCTION
 (not capacity) is key LTE challenge
LTE CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS

                                                 Theore&cal	
  Single	
  User	
  Data	
  Rate	
  	
  
                                                        Down/Up	
  [Mbps]	
  	
  


                                           Close	
                Medium	
                      Far	
  


            10MHz	
                     43	
  /	
  14.4	
         28	
  /	
  9.5	
          14	
  /	
  4.8	
  



    real scenario is 100-150mbps backhaul per 3 sector cellsite
6     AVIAT NETWORKS | 20 AUGUST 2010
AND PROPER PLANNING EASES RING CAPACITY DEMANDS



                       50Mbps           	
           	
     50Mbps


                                 Ring Capacity   300Mbps               Gateway
                                                                       Node

                         	
                                     	
  
                                                                                 100Mbps
        50Mbps
                                                                       50Mbps



                        50Mbps          	
           	
     50Mbps


                 typical overbooking factor for mobile operator = ~3x
                          ring capacity ~100mbps in this case
7   AVIAT NETWORKS |   20 AUGUST 2010
Capacity



 1 Gbit/s




400 Mbit/s




                                            Cell-Site Capacity
100 Mbit/s


                                                                 Time
             Zone of Capacity Growth Maximum Cell-site Capacity



 LTE cannot outstrip microwave capacity to cellsite
BECAUSE MICROWAVE HAS EVOLVED…

Strategy                       Technique

1.  More Spectrum              •  Multiple channels with link aggregation
    (More Hz)                     (incl CCDP) – leverage N+0
                               •  ACM

2.  More Spectral Efficiency   •  Higher modulations (512/1024 QAM, ACM)
  (More Bits per Hz)           •  FEC redundancy

3.  More “Effective”           •  Header optimization / suppression
    Throughput                 •  Payload compression
  (More Data per Bit)          •  Asymmetrical RF



           and is a high capacity transport solution
LESSONS LEARNED #2


MICROWAVE MEETS LTE
CAPACITY NEEDS
even for large rings and multi-cellsite links
FUTURE OF LTE BACKHAUL IS:




                                        Small Cells!!!
11   AVIAT NETWORKS |   FEBRUARY 2012
HOWEVER, SMALL CELLS WILL CHANGE THE BACKHAUL PARADIGM…



                                 1.  More sites
                                   higher cost,
                                   more complexity

                                 2.  Different sites
                                   new technologies

              and construction challenges will get far worse
12   AVIAT NETWORKS |
Wired	
                              Wireless	
  	
                            Wireless	
  	
  
                                     (fiber/cable/dsl)	
                         (LOS)	
                                  (NLOS)	
  

                                                                                                         200+Mbps	
  (shared,	
  may	
  
Capacity	
                 10Gbps	
                                1-­‐2Gbps	
  
                                                                                                         be	
  ok	
  for	
  HSPA)	
  
Site	
  LocaLon	
  /	
     Not	
  available,	
  costly	
           LOS	
  
                                                                                                         Flexible.	
  NLOS	
  
RestricLons	
              install	
                               Parabolic	
  

                                                                   Depends	
  on	
  frequency.	
  	
     Limited	
  for	
  pt-­‐mpt.	
  	
  	
  
Backhaul	
  Distance	
     Long	
  distance	
  but	
  costly	
  
                                                                   Millimeter	
  wave	
  limited	
       Pt-­‐pt	
  ok	
  

Latency	
                  us	
                                    us	
                                  5-­‐10ms	
  (ok	
  for	
  HSPA)	
  
CAPEX	
                    Very	
  high	
                          High	
  (today)	
                     Low	
  
OPEX	
                     Low	
                                   Medium	
                              Medium	
  
                                                                                                         Costly.	
  Unlicensed	
  
Spectrum	
                 N/A	
                                   Available	
  
                                                                                                         opLons	
  very	
  risky	
  




meaning… none of today’s backhaul solutions will suffice
LESSONS LEARNED 3

SMALL CELL NOT SIGNIFICANT MARKET
until backhaul gets cheaper and easier
WHICH MEANS
FUNDAMENTAL INNOVATIONS WILL BE REQUIRED IN
FOUNDATIONAL MICROWAVE TECHNOLOGY…



all in one tiny box...
 including antenna!




15   AVIAT NETWORKS |   FEBRUARY 2012
OTHER NEW APPROACHES WILL NEED TO BE CONSIDERED

                   CACHING               DISTRIBUTED INTELLIGENCE




16   AVIAT NETWORKS |   20 AUGUST 2010
and Microwave Networking solutions will emerge

                                                        Security	
  
                                                                           Redundancy	
  and	
  
                              SynchronizaLon	
  
                                                                             ProtecLon	
  


                                                                                             ACM,	
  RF	
  
                RouLng	
  
                                                                                           opLmizaLons	
  




                                                   Integrated,	
  IP	
                              Others	
  (DPI,	
  
      QoS,	
  Bandwidth	
  
       management	
                                 Microwave	
                                    caching,	
  CDN,	
  
                                                      Pla[orm	
                                         etc)	
  



17    AVIAT NETWORKS |        Microwave                                Dumb Pipe
TO ACHIEVE ALL THIS, WE NEED TO PAY
ATTENTION TO WHAT’S IMPORTANT…




        AMC	
  Pacer	
  –	
  voted	
  worst	
  car	
  of	
  all	
  Lme!
                                                                      	
  
THANK YOU




AVIAT NETWORKS |
20
19 AUGUST 2010

LTE Backhaul Challenges, Small Cells and the Critical Role of Microwave

  • 1.
    IEEE COMSOC PANEL LTEBACKHAUL CHALLENGES, SMALL CELLS AND THE CRITICAL ROLE OF MICROWAVE PAUL KENNARD, CTO | AVIAT NETWORKS 1
  • 3.
    LTE (Lon g Ter m Ev oluti 4G on) 10x f aster QoS, than 3G Low All-I laten P cy Low Cost 3 AVIAT NETWORKS |
  • 4.
  • 5.
    LESSONS LEARNED #1 CONSTRUCTION (not capacity) is key LTE challenge
  • 6.
    LTE CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS Theore&cal  Single  User  Data  Rate     Down/Up  [Mbps]     Close   Medium   Far   10MHz   43  /  14.4   28  /  9.5   14  /  4.8   real scenario is 100-150mbps backhaul per 3 sector cellsite 6 AVIAT NETWORKS | 20 AUGUST 2010
  • 7.
    AND PROPER PLANNINGEASES RING CAPACITY DEMANDS 50Mbps     50Mbps Ring Capacity 300Mbps Gateway Node     100Mbps 50Mbps 50Mbps 50Mbps     50Mbps typical overbooking factor for mobile operator = ~3x ring capacity ~100mbps in this case 7 AVIAT NETWORKS | 20 AUGUST 2010
  • 8.
    Capacity 1 Gbit/s 400Mbit/s Cell-Site Capacity 100 Mbit/s Time Zone of Capacity Growth Maximum Cell-site Capacity LTE cannot outstrip microwave capacity to cellsite
  • 9.
    BECAUSE MICROWAVE HASEVOLVED… Strategy Technique 1.  More Spectrum •  Multiple channels with link aggregation (More Hz) (incl CCDP) – leverage N+0 •  ACM 2.  More Spectral Efficiency •  Higher modulations (512/1024 QAM, ACM) (More Bits per Hz) •  FEC redundancy 3.  More “Effective” •  Header optimization / suppression Throughput •  Payload compression (More Data per Bit) •  Asymmetrical RF and is a high capacity transport solution
  • 10.
    LESSONS LEARNED #2 MICROWAVEMEETS LTE CAPACITY NEEDS even for large rings and multi-cellsite links
  • 11.
    FUTURE OF LTEBACKHAUL IS: Small Cells!!! 11 AVIAT NETWORKS | FEBRUARY 2012
  • 12.
    HOWEVER, SMALL CELLSWILL CHANGE THE BACKHAUL PARADIGM… 1.  More sites higher cost, more complexity 2.  Different sites new technologies and construction challenges will get far worse 12 AVIAT NETWORKS |
  • 13.
    Wired   Wireless     Wireless     (fiber/cable/dsl)   (LOS)   (NLOS)   200+Mbps  (shared,  may   Capacity   10Gbps   1-­‐2Gbps   be  ok  for  HSPA)   Site  LocaLon  /   Not  available,  costly   LOS   Flexible.  NLOS   RestricLons   install   Parabolic   Depends  on  frequency.     Limited  for  pt-­‐mpt.       Backhaul  Distance   Long  distance  but  costly   Millimeter  wave  limited   Pt-­‐pt  ok   Latency   us   us   5-­‐10ms  (ok  for  HSPA)   CAPEX   Very  high   High  (today)   Low   OPEX   Low   Medium   Medium   Costly.  Unlicensed   Spectrum   N/A   Available   opLons  very  risky   meaning… none of today’s backhaul solutions will suffice
  • 14.
    LESSONS LEARNED 3 SMALLCELL NOT SIGNIFICANT MARKET until backhaul gets cheaper and easier
  • 15.
    WHICH MEANS FUNDAMENTAL INNOVATIONSWILL BE REQUIRED IN FOUNDATIONAL MICROWAVE TECHNOLOGY… all in one tiny box... including antenna! 15 AVIAT NETWORKS | FEBRUARY 2012
  • 16.
    OTHER NEW APPROACHESWILL NEED TO BE CONSIDERED CACHING DISTRIBUTED INTELLIGENCE 16 AVIAT NETWORKS | 20 AUGUST 2010
  • 17.
    and Microwave Networkingsolutions will emerge Security   Redundancy  and   SynchronizaLon   ProtecLon   ACM,  RF   RouLng   opLmizaLons   Integrated,  IP   Others  (DPI,   QoS,  Bandwidth   management   Microwave   caching,  CDN,   Pla[orm   etc)   17 AVIAT NETWORKS | Microwave Dumb Pipe
  • 18.
    TO ACHIEVE ALLTHIS, WE NEED TO PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT’S IMPORTANT… AMC  Pacer  –  voted  worst  car  of  all  Lme!  
  • 19.
    THANK YOU AVIAT NETWORKS| 20 19 AUGUST 2010