Our Disappearing Sandspit:
Current and Projected Changes
to the Barrier Spit at St. Mary’s-by-the-Sea
July 13, 2021
Overview
• Areas of Erosion
• Changes Over Time
• Projected Future Changes
• Areas Most Affected by Changes
• Habitat Restoration & Destruction - 1950’s
to Present
• ACCA Actions & Responses
• Next Steps
Aerial Views of Lower Ash Creek Video Courtesy of Barry Hyman
Simulated View of Lower Ash Creek in 2036
Sand Spit 2011
Sand Spit 2021
Sand Spit Changes
Scientific Analysis Commissioned by ACCA 2021
Bryan Quinn, RLA, One Nature & Steven Danzer, Ph.D.
• 2006-2016 loss of 60 linear feet
• Predicted to disappear by 2036
• Stable from 17th Century until 1950’s
• Loss of sand deposits due to Fairfield’s jetty
and dredging for marina
• DEEP allows Fairfield to take sand from
dredging and put on Jennings Beach
• 2019 dredging caused tremendous erosion
Sand Spit 2006-2016
60 Foot Linear Retreat of 4’ High Edge of Sand Spit Over 10 Year Period
Great Marsh Island Changes
Scientific Analysis Commissioned by ACCA 2021
Bryan Quinn, RLA, One Nature & Steven Danzer, Ph.D.
• Long-term loss of approximately 25,000 SF of
intertidal marsh (aerial geographic analysis, 1991 vs.
2020)
• May be due to increased wave action caused by
reduction in size of barrier spit
1909 Great Marsh Island
(Palmquist, 1955)
1951 Aerial View
View of Great Marsh Island (Palmquist, 1955)
1976 Aerial View
Jetty and Marina Built, Dredging of Channel
2019 Aerial View
Photo by Geoffrey Steadman, 2019
2036 Projected Aerial View
Photoshop edits by Gail Robinson of original aerial photo by Geoffrey Steadman
Flood Zone and Storm Surge Maps
Ash Creek 2036
• 194 Black Rock homes at risk
based on flood surge map
• No attenuation of wave action,
erosion of land, water pushed
further inland
• Destruction of spartina and rest of
marshlands which acts as sponge,
more flooding
Reclaimed Marsh Land
What Led to This Problem?
• Filling in wetlands and building on reclaimed land
• Fairfield’s marina, jetty, & dredging since 1950’s
• Natural events, such as Irene & Sandy
• Rising sea levels from global warming – marsh land
grows higher, but can’t keep up with the pace
What Can We Change?
• Filling in wetlands and building on reclaimed land
• Fairfield’s marina, jetty, & dredging since 1950’s
• Natural events, such as Irene & Sandy
• Rising sea levels – marsh land grows higher, but
can’t keep up with the pace
Fairfield’s Dredging
• DEEP 10 year permit allows Fairfield to take sand from
dredging activities on the spit and put it on Jennings Beach
• Granted in 2007 and 2014
• ACCA had requested in 2013 that the DEEP permit require
the sand to be put back on the sand spit to no avail
• 2019 dredging caused tremendous erosion
Sand Spit – Dredging 2019
Alarming Amount of Erosion from Fairfield’s Dredging in 2019
Habitat Restoration & Destruction in
Ash Creek - 1950’s to Present
Town Boundary Changed in 1954
Major Dredging 1957 & 1967
• Channel excavated to 70’
wide and 10’ deep at low tide
in 1967
• Jetty caught the sand that
would have come to Black
Rock’s beach and retained it
in Fairfield
• Fairfield used sand from
dredging for Jennings Beach
Staged Dredging 2007-2008
• Heavy equipment used to dredge channel from sand spit to
save money
• Flattened dunes, destroyed vegetation
Dr. Orson’s Recommendations - 2008
Habitat Restoration – 2008-2009
Dredging 2010
Bridgeport’s “Beach Clean Up” 2011
June 24 & 28
Bridgeport’s “Beach Clean Up” 2011
BEFORE - September 2010 AFTER – June 28, 2011
Irene - August 2011
Irene – August 2011
Assessment
September 2011
Habitat Restoration - October 2011
On 10/6/11 the City planted:
300 containers of American
Beach Grass
50 Beach Plum shrubs
50 Sand Cherry shrubs
50 Staghorn Sumac bushes
Under order from the DEEP
Habitat Restoration Plan - 2011
Park Master Plan- 2011
Ash Creek Master Plan 2012
86 page scientific analysis &
recommendations by Bryan
Quinn, RLA of One Nature
and Steve Danzer, Ph.D.
Sandy 2012
Before
After
Dredging - 2013
Detailed Plan for
Habitat Restoration - 2014
Detailed Plan for
Habitat Restoration - 2014
Meeting w. Bridgeport & Fairfield -
2014
Dredging - 2019
Dredging Trends
2007 4,500 cubic yards
2013 22,000 cubic yards
2019 32,000 cubic yards
Action Steps
• Dredging should be scaled back. We don’t need deeper
and wider dredging for bigger boats.
• Sand should be put back on the sandspit when Fairfield
dredges
• Fairfield and Bridgeport should use federal funds for
habitat restoration of the sandspit and use the habitat
restoration plan from 2014 (updated version)
• Ten year dredging permit is too long, five year dredging
permit – reevaluate dredging based on health of tidal
estuary
Who We Have Contacted
TWO KEY PLAYERS:
• Bill Hurley, Fairfield Dept. of Engineering – in
charge of dredging
• Sue Bailey, DEEP – approves dredging permit
STAKEHOLDER:
• David Brandt, Aspetuck Land Trust – owns
half of Great Marsh Island – July 21
FAIRFIELD:
• First Selectwoman Brenda Kupchick, First
Selectwoman Fairfield
• Fairfield Conservation Commission – getting
on next agenda
• Fairfield Shellfish Commission
BRIDGEPORT:
• Steve Hladun, Bridgeport Parks Dept.
• Bridgeport Parks Commission –getting on
next agenda
• Scott Burns, City Council & NRZ
• Matt McCarthy, City Council
• Mayor Ganim, Mayor of Bridgeport
• Jon Uriquidi, City of Bridgeport Engineering
• Joe Gresko, City of Bridgeport
• Dan Roach, Mayor’s Office
STATE:
• Steve Stafstrom, State Representative
Who You Can Contact
Need to put pressure on DEEP, Fairfield, and Bridgeport
Send e-mails to people on handout
Thank you!

Our Disappearing Sandspit

  • 1.
    Our Disappearing Sandspit: Currentand Projected Changes to the Barrier Spit at St. Mary’s-by-the-Sea July 13, 2021
  • 2.
    Overview • Areas ofErosion • Changes Over Time • Projected Future Changes • Areas Most Affected by Changes • Habitat Restoration & Destruction - 1950’s to Present • ACCA Actions & Responses • Next Steps
  • 3.
    Aerial Views ofLower Ash Creek Video Courtesy of Barry Hyman
  • 4.
    Simulated View ofLower Ash Creek in 2036
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Sand Spit Changes ScientificAnalysis Commissioned by ACCA 2021 Bryan Quinn, RLA, One Nature & Steven Danzer, Ph.D. • 2006-2016 loss of 60 linear feet • Predicted to disappear by 2036 • Stable from 17th Century until 1950’s • Loss of sand deposits due to Fairfield’s jetty and dredging for marina • DEEP allows Fairfield to take sand from dredging and put on Jennings Beach • 2019 dredging caused tremendous erosion
  • 8.
    Sand Spit 2006-2016 60Foot Linear Retreat of 4’ High Edge of Sand Spit Over 10 Year Period
  • 9.
    Great Marsh IslandChanges Scientific Analysis Commissioned by ACCA 2021 Bryan Quinn, RLA, One Nature & Steven Danzer, Ph.D. • Long-term loss of approximately 25,000 SF of intertidal marsh (aerial geographic analysis, 1991 vs. 2020) • May be due to increased wave action caused by reduction in size of barrier spit
  • 10.
    1909 Great MarshIsland (Palmquist, 1955)
  • 11.
    1951 Aerial View Viewof Great Marsh Island (Palmquist, 1955)
  • 12.
    1976 Aerial View Jettyand Marina Built, Dredging of Channel
  • 13.
    2019 Aerial View Photoby Geoffrey Steadman, 2019
  • 14.
    2036 Projected AerialView Photoshop edits by Gail Robinson of original aerial photo by Geoffrey Steadman
  • 15.
    Flood Zone andStorm Surge Maps
  • 16.
    Ash Creek 2036 •194 Black Rock homes at risk based on flood surge map • No attenuation of wave action, erosion of land, water pushed further inland • Destruction of spartina and rest of marshlands which acts as sponge, more flooding
  • 17.
  • 18.
    What Led toThis Problem? • Filling in wetlands and building on reclaimed land • Fairfield’s marina, jetty, & dredging since 1950’s • Natural events, such as Irene & Sandy • Rising sea levels from global warming – marsh land grows higher, but can’t keep up with the pace
  • 19.
    What Can WeChange? • Filling in wetlands and building on reclaimed land • Fairfield’s marina, jetty, & dredging since 1950’s • Natural events, such as Irene & Sandy • Rising sea levels – marsh land grows higher, but can’t keep up with the pace
  • 20.
    Fairfield’s Dredging • DEEP10 year permit allows Fairfield to take sand from dredging activities on the spit and put it on Jennings Beach • Granted in 2007 and 2014 • ACCA had requested in 2013 that the DEEP permit require the sand to be put back on the sand spit to no avail • 2019 dredging caused tremendous erosion
  • 21.
    Sand Spit –Dredging 2019 Alarming Amount of Erosion from Fairfield’s Dredging in 2019
  • 22.
    Habitat Restoration &Destruction in Ash Creek - 1950’s to Present
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Major Dredging 1957& 1967 • Channel excavated to 70’ wide and 10’ deep at low tide in 1967 • Jetty caught the sand that would have come to Black Rock’s beach and retained it in Fairfield • Fairfield used sand from dredging for Jennings Beach
  • 25.
    Staged Dredging 2007-2008 •Heavy equipment used to dredge channel from sand spit to save money • Flattened dunes, destroyed vegetation
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
    Bridgeport’s “Beach CleanUp” 2011 June 24 & 28
  • 30.
    Bridgeport’s “Beach CleanUp” 2011 BEFORE - September 2010 AFTER – June 28, 2011
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
    Habitat Restoration -October 2011 On 10/6/11 the City planted: 300 containers of American Beach Grass 50 Beach Plum shrubs 50 Sand Cherry shrubs 50 Staghorn Sumac bushes Under order from the DEEP
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
    Ash Creek MasterPlan 2012 86 page scientific analysis & recommendations by Bryan Quinn, RLA of One Nature and Steve Danzer, Ph.D.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
    Detailed Plan for HabitatRestoration - 2014
  • 41.
    Detailed Plan for HabitatRestoration - 2014
  • 42.
    Meeting w. Bridgeport& Fairfield - 2014
  • 43.
  • 44.
    Dredging Trends 2007 4,500cubic yards 2013 22,000 cubic yards 2019 32,000 cubic yards
  • 45.
    Action Steps • Dredgingshould be scaled back. We don’t need deeper and wider dredging for bigger boats. • Sand should be put back on the sandspit when Fairfield dredges • Fairfield and Bridgeport should use federal funds for habitat restoration of the sandspit and use the habitat restoration plan from 2014 (updated version) • Ten year dredging permit is too long, five year dredging permit – reevaluate dredging based on health of tidal estuary
  • 46.
    Who We HaveContacted TWO KEY PLAYERS: • Bill Hurley, Fairfield Dept. of Engineering – in charge of dredging • Sue Bailey, DEEP – approves dredging permit STAKEHOLDER: • David Brandt, Aspetuck Land Trust – owns half of Great Marsh Island – July 21 FAIRFIELD: • First Selectwoman Brenda Kupchick, First Selectwoman Fairfield • Fairfield Conservation Commission – getting on next agenda • Fairfield Shellfish Commission BRIDGEPORT: • Steve Hladun, Bridgeport Parks Dept. • Bridgeport Parks Commission –getting on next agenda • Scott Burns, City Council & NRZ • Matt McCarthy, City Council • Mayor Ganim, Mayor of Bridgeport • Jon Uriquidi, City of Bridgeport Engineering • Joe Gresko, City of Bridgeport • Dan Roach, Mayor’s Office STATE: • Steve Stafstrom, State Representative
  • 47.
    Who You CanContact Need to put pressure on DEEP, Fairfield, and Bridgeport Send e-mails to people on handout Thank you!