SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
Oral Histories as Building Blocks for New Theoretical Models: Individual Agency, Gendered Experiences and Critical Junctures in Women’s Pathways into STEM Faculty Careers Jordana Hoegh Dept. of Sociology, ADVANCE Research Team Dr. Alice L. Pawley School of Engineering Education, ADVANCE Research Director
Main points Existing theoretical models and their limits Ways oral histories may be used to address those limits A case study to demonstrate the potential of oral history data to generate new theoretical models
Why women’s pathways into STEM faculty careers? To understand women’s attrition rates from the path to STEM faculty careers Women increasingly earn STEM doctorates but their representation among STEM faculty has not experienced a relative increase
What are the current theoretical models? Leaky Pipeline People drop out or “leak” at particular points from the career path pipeline to STEM faculty Chilly Climate Environment is so unpleasant that some people leave
What are the limits? Leaky pipeline assumptions: A passive actor One path to STEM faculty The path is unidirectional Chilly climate assumptions: Women perceive the climate negatively They leave because of a negative climate
How might oral history methods expound these limits? Give voice to participants Perceptions of climate will emerge naturally Career pathway patterns will emerge naturally Account for individual agency of actors Shed light on decision-making processes critical junctures
What are oral history methods? Semi-structured in-person interviews Broad, open-ended, guiding questions Begin with childhood experiences continuing chronologically through significant life events Participants to choose which experiences to share
What are the advantages of oral histories? Build good rapport Interactive process encourages participants to reveal information that surveys or other research methods cannot capture  Uncover individual perceptions and decision-making processes Identify why one path was chosen over another
Demonstrating the theory-building potential of oral histories I will use a case study from a set of oral history data collected as part of a NSF-funded ADVANCE grant research project aimed at improving the career success of women STEM faculty Examine the relationship between gendered experiences and career decision-making in the context of a critical juncture
Sandy: An Exemplar Case Study Critical Juncture:  Contemplating leaving graduate school for an industry job.   Gendered Experience: Male mentors and an all male research team Individual Agency: Choosing to stay the course
Theory-building Potential From the case study: Explore the role of positive and negative mentors in the career paths of women in STEM doctoral graduate programs Explore the ways careers are “facilitated” or “obstructed” Oral history data as building blocks: an idea generator from the ground up
Acknowledgements Thank you to study participants! Thanks to those who helped with participant invitations. This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. HRD 0811194.  (Any opinions, findings and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.) Questions?
Questions?

More Related Content

What's hot

Learning analytics – Challenges, paradoxes and opportunities for mega open di...
Learning analytics – Challenges, paradoxes and opportunities for mega open di...Learning analytics – Challenges, paradoxes and opportunities for mega open di...
Learning analytics – Challenges, paradoxes and opportunities for mega open di...
Sharon Slade
 
Transitioning from School to Work: Preparing Evaluation Students and New Eval...
Transitioning from School to Work: Preparing Evaluation Students and New Eval...Transitioning from School to Work: Preparing Evaluation Students and New Eval...
Transitioning from School to Work: Preparing Evaluation Students and New Eval...
Washington Evaluators
 
CRI - Teaching Through Research - Melissa McCartney - Assessment
CRI - Teaching Through Research - Melissa McCartney - AssessmentCRI - Teaching Through Research - Melissa McCartney - Assessment
CRI - Teaching Through Research - Melissa McCartney - Assessment
LeadershipProgram
 
Exploring Gender Differences in the Benefits of Undergraduate Research Experi...
Exploring Gender Differences in the Benefits of Undergraduate Research Experi...Exploring Gender Differences in the Benefits of Undergraduate Research Experi...
Exploring Gender Differences in the Benefits of Undergraduate Research Experi...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 

What's hot (20)

Research in the scholarship of teaching
Research in the scholarship of teachingResearch in the scholarship of teaching
Research in the scholarship of teaching
 
Case study
Case studyCase study
Case study
 
Eportfolios: Three Implementations
Eportfolios: Three ImplementationsEportfolios: Three Implementations
Eportfolios: Three Implementations
 
Learning analytics – Challenges, paradoxes and opportunities for mega open di...
Learning analytics – Challenges, paradoxes and opportunities for mega open di...Learning analytics – Challenges, paradoxes and opportunities for mega open di...
Learning analytics – Challenges, paradoxes and opportunities for mega open di...
 
Ohio Campus Compact & Walsh University offer Service-Learning Research Workshop
Ohio Campus Compact & Walsh University offer Service-Learning Research WorkshopOhio Campus Compact & Walsh University offer Service-Learning Research Workshop
Ohio Campus Compact & Walsh University offer Service-Learning Research Workshop
 
Hard VS Harder Science: University Characteristics that Support Interdiscipli...
Hard VS Harder Science: University Characteristics that Support Interdiscipli...Hard VS Harder Science: University Characteristics that Support Interdiscipli...
Hard VS Harder Science: University Characteristics that Support Interdiscipli...
 
AERA 2010: A Steady State
AERA 2010: A Steady StateAERA 2010: A Steady State
AERA 2010: A Steady State
 
Transitioning from School to Work: Preparing Evaluation Students and New Eval...
Transitioning from School to Work: Preparing Evaluation Students and New Eval...Transitioning from School to Work: Preparing Evaluation Students and New Eval...
Transitioning from School to Work: Preparing Evaluation Students and New Eval...
 
Strengths based approach to ph d retentioncompletion
Strengths based approach to ph d retentioncompletionStrengths based approach to ph d retentioncompletion
Strengths based approach to ph d retentioncompletion
 
What makes for an academic career?
What makes for an academic career?What makes for an academic career?
What makes for an academic career?
 
DC Consortium Student Conference 1.0
DC Consortium Student Conference 1.0DC Consortium Student Conference 1.0
DC Consortium Student Conference 1.0
 
CRI - Teaching Through Research - Melissa McCartney - Assessment
CRI - Teaching Through Research - Melissa McCartney - AssessmentCRI - Teaching Through Research - Melissa McCartney - Assessment
CRI - Teaching Through Research - Melissa McCartney - Assessment
 
Partnerships for Transformative Change in Challenging Political Contexts w/ D...
Partnerships for Transformative Change in Challenging Political Contexts w/ D...Partnerships for Transformative Change in Challenging Political Contexts w/ D...
Partnerships for Transformative Change in Challenging Political Contexts w/ D...
 
Activating prior knowledge (real life examples) with recording-sd
Activating prior knowledge (real life examples) with recording-sdActivating prior knowledge (real life examples) with recording-sd
Activating prior knowledge (real life examples) with recording-sd
 
Making sense of feedback
Making sense of feedbackMaking sense of feedback
Making sense of feedback
 
Gender balance Research Funders
Gender balance Research FundersGender balance Research Funders
Gender balance Research Funders
 
Research in the Wild
Research in the WildResearch in the Wild
Research in the Wild
 
Exploring Gender Differences in the Benefits of Undergraduate Research Experi...
Exploring Gender Differences in the Benefits of Undergraduate Research Experi...Exploring Gender Differences in the Benefits of Undergraduate Research Experi...
Exploring Gender Differences in the Benefits of Undergraduate Research Experi...
 
Analytics: From Data to Decisions
Analytics: From Data to DecisionsAnalytics: From Data to Decisions
Analytics: From Data to Decisions
 
Education in parapsychology pa 2014
Education in parapsychology pa 2014Education in parapsychology pa 2014
Education in parapsychology pa 2014
 

Viewers also liked

Gender and STEM Research Symposium Opening Presentation
Gender and STEM Research Symposium Opening PresentationGender and STEM Research Symposium Opening Presentation
Gender and STEM Research Symposium Opening Presentation
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Improving Checkout on the Mobile Web
Improving Checkout on the Mobile WebImproving Checkout on the Mobile Web
Improving Checkout on the Mobile Web
TheFind
 

Viewers also liked (18)

Gender and STEM Research Symposium Opening Presentation
Gender and STEM Research Symposium Opening PresentationGender and STEM Research Symposium Opening Presentation
Gender and STEM Research Symposium Opening Presentation
 
Uber Geeky Keynote Trix
Uber Geeky Keynote TrixUber Geeky Keynote Trix
Uber Geeky Keynote Trix
 
Work Sample: Webinar on Healthy Lifestyle
Work Sample: Webinar on Healthy LifestyleWork Sample: Webinar on Healthy Lifestyle
Work Sample: Webinar on Healthy Lifestyle
 
Facebook,Youtube, Twitter: Oh My (Keynote Presentation)
Facebook,Youtube, Twitter: Oh My (Keynote Presentation)Facebook,Youtube, Twitter: Oh My (Keynote Presentation)
Facebook,Youtube, Twitter: Oh My (Keynote Presentation)
 
Improving Checkout on the Mobile Web
Improving Checkout on the Mobile WebImproving Checkout on the Mobile Web
Improving Checkout on the Mobile Web
 
Uber Presentation
Uber PresentationUber Presentation
Uber Presentation
 
Co working
Co workingCo working
Co working
 
Uber
UberUber
Uber
 
RobotUX: A Framework for Human-Robot Interactions
RobotUX: A Framework for Human-Robot InteractionsRobotUX: A Framework for Human-Robot Interactions
RobotUX: A Framework for Human-Robot Interactions
 
The Evolution of Airbnb's Frontend
The Evolution of Airbnb's FrontendThe Evolution of Airbnb's Frontend
The Evolution of Airbnb's Frontend
 
All You Need Is TDD (Português)
All You Need Is TDD (Português)All You Need Is TDD (Português)
All You Need Is TDD (Português)
 
Social e conteúdo preditivo: como antever reações de usuários e diminuir risc...
Social e conteúdo preditivo: como antever reações de usuários e diminuir risc...Social e conteúdo preditivo: como antever reações de usuários e diminuir risc...
Social e conteúdo preditivo: como antever reações de usuários e diminuir risc...
 
Airbnb
AirbnbAirbnb
Airbnb
 
Uber's Business Model
Uber's Business ModelUber's Business Model
Uber's Business Model
 
Foursquare's 1st Pitch Deck
Foursquare's 1st Pitch DeckFoursquare's 1st Pitch Deck
Foursquare's 1st Pitch Deck
 
Mixpanel - Our pitch deck that we used to raise $65M
Mixpanel - Our pitch deck that we used to raise $65MMixpanel - Our pitch deck that we used to raise $65M
Mixpanel - Our pitch deck that we used to raise $65M
 
AirBnB Pitch Deck
AirBnB Pitch Deck AirBnB Pitch Deck
AirBnB Pitch Deck
 
SEOmoz Pitch Deck July 2011
SEOmoz Pitch Deck July 2011SEOmoz Pitch Deck July 2011
SEOmoz Pitch Deck July 2011
 

Similar to Oral Histories as Building Blocks for New Theoretical Models: Individual Agency, Gendered Experiences, and Critical Junctures in Women’s Pathways into STEM Faculty Careers. By Jordana Hoegh

Three theoretical approaches to gender: Implications for creating effective p...
Three theoretical approaches to gender: Implications for creating effective p...Three theoretical approaches to gender: Implications for creating effective p...
Three theoretical approaches to gender: Implications for creating effective p...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
ASEE16 - An Analysis of Female Engineering Students - Abstract
ASEE16 - An Analysis of Female Engineering Students - AbstractASEE16 - An Analysis of Female Engineering Students - Abstract
ASEE16 - An Analysis of Female Engineering Students - Abstract
Ali Anderson
 
Empowerment, Women & Exception Academic Success at UKZN
Empowerment, Women & Exception Academic Success at UKZNEmpowerment, Women & Exception Academic Success at UKZN
Empowerment, Women & Exception Academic Success at UKZN
Terry S
 
Christopher Allen Final Dissertation
Christopher Allen Final DissertationChristopher Allen Final Dissertation
Christopher Allen Final Dissertation
Christopher Allen
 
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained DiscourseGender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Sandra Conway
 
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained DiscourseGender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Sandra Conway
 

Similar to Oral Histories as Building Blocks for New Theoretical Models: Individual Agency, Gendered Experiences, and Critical Junctures in Women’s Pathways into STEM Faculty Careers. By Jordana Hoegh (20)

Gender inequities in science careers
Gender inequities in science careersGender inequities in science careers
Gender inequities in science careers
 
Gender and research funding in a Norwegian context
Gender and research funding in a Norwegian contextGender and research funding in a Norwegian context
Gender and research funding in a Norwegian context
 
Three theoretical approaches to gender: Implications for creating effective p...
Three theoretical approaches to gender: Implications for creating effective p...Three theoretical approaches to gender: Implications for creating effective p...
Three theoretical approaches to gender: Implications for creating effective p...
 
"What are the challenges that female researchers face? What kind of support i...
"What are the challenges that female researchers face? What kind of support i..."What are the challenges that female researchers face? What kind of support i...
"What are the challenges that female researchers face? What kind of support i...
 
ICWES15 - The Outcomes of 19 Institutional Transformation Efforts to ADVANCE ...
ICWES15 - The Outcomes of 19 Institutional Transformation Efforts to ADVANCE ...ICWES15 - The Outcomes of 19 Institutional Transformation Efforts to ADVANCE ...
ICWES15 - The Outcomes of 19 Institutional Transformation Efforts to ADVANCE ...
 
Linda wilson jones (done) focus
Linda wilson jones (done) focusLinda wilson jones (done) focus
Linda wilson jones (done) focus
 
Holistic Review in Graduate Admissions: What we need to Know
Holistic Review in Graduate Admissions: What we need to KnowHolistic Review in Graduate Admissions: What we need to Know
Holistic Review in Graduate Admissions: What we need to Know
 
ASEE16 - An Analysis of Female Engineering Students - Abstract
ASEE16 - An Analysis of Female Engineering Students - AbstractASEE16 - An Analysis of Female Engineering Students - Abstract
ASEE16 - An Analysis of Female Engineering Students - Abstract
 
WE16 - The State of Women in Engineering
WE16 - The State of Women in EngineeringWE16 - The State of Women in Engineering
WE16 - The State of Women in Engineering
 
MPACE Poster
MPACE PosterMPACE Poster
MPACE Poster
 
Women in Science: Challenges at the Intersection of Gender, Race & Culture
Women in Science: Challenges at the Intersection of Gender, Race & CultureWomen in Science: Challenges at the Intersection of Gender, Race & Culture
Women in Science: Challenges at the Intersection of Gender, Race & Culture
 
Research.ppt
Research.pptResearch.ppt
Research.ppt
 
Empowerment, Women & Exception Academic Success at UKZN
Empowerment, Women & Exception Academic Success at UKZNEmpowerment, Women & Exception Academic Success at UKZN
Empowerment, Women & Exception Academic Success at UKZN
 
Christopher Allen Final Dissertation
Christopher Allen Final DissertationChristopher Allen Final Dissertation
Christopher Allen Final Dissertation
 
Why so few?
Why so few?Why so few?
Why so few?
 
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained DiscourseGender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
 
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained DiscourseGender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
Gender and Race in Leadership Preparation: A Constrained Discourse
 
Design- Based Research: New Research Paradigm
Design- Based Research: New Research Paradigm Design- Based Research: New Research Paradigm
Design- Based Research: New Research Paradigm
 
Pairs Talk 22 Jan 08 Jane Seale
Pairs Talk 22 Jan 08 Jane SealePairs Talk 22 Jan 08 Jane Seale
Pairs Talk 22 Jan 08 Jane Seale
 
Wilson jones, linda graduate females focus v6 n1 2011
Wilson jones, linda graduate females focus v6 n1 2011Wilson jones, linda graduate females focus v6 n1 2011
Wilson jones, linda graduate females focus v6 n1 2011
 

More from ADVANCE-Purdue

Career Motivations of Freshman Engineering and Non-Engineering Students: A Ge...
Career Motivations of Freshman Engineering and Non-Engineering Students: A Ge...Career Motivations of Freshman Engineering and Non-Engineering Students: A Ge...
Career Motivations of Freshman Engineering and Non-Engineering Students: A Ge...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Choosing STEM careers: The Dialectical Discourses of 21st century Indian women
Choosing STEM careers:  The Dialectical Discourses of 21st century Indian womenChoosing STEM careers:  The Dialectical Discourses of 21st century Indian women
Choosing STEM careers: The Dialectical Discourses of 21st century Indian women
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Cultural negotiations of Indian women in U.S. engineering classrooms
Cultural negotiations of Indian women in U.S. engineering classroomsCultural negotiations of Indian women in U.S. engineering classrooms
Cultural negotiations of Indian women in U.S. engineering classrooms
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Gender Differences in Digital Literacy Games: Efficacy, Strategies, Experienc...
Gender Differences in Digital Literacy Games: Efficacy, Strategies, Experienc...Gender Differences in Digital Literacy Games: Efficacy, Strategies, Experienc...
Gender Differences in Digital Literacy Games: Efficacy, Strategies, Experienc...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Engaging under-represented populations in agricultural research
Engaging under-represented populations in agricultural researchEngaging under-represented populations in agricultural research
Engaging under-represented populations in agricultural research
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Role of Social Cognitive Variables on Agricultural and Science Career Interes...
Role of Social Cognitive Variables on Agricultural and Science Career Interes...Role of Social Cognitive Variables on Agricultural and Science Career Interes...
Role of Social Cognitive Variables on Agricultural and Science Career Interes...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Gender Equity and Slow Adopters: Changing Academic Culture via "Leadership D...
Gender Equity and Slow Adopters:  Changing Academic Culture via "Leadership D...Gender Equity and Slow Adopters:  Changing Academic Culture via "Leadership D...
Gender Equity and Slow Adopters: Changing Academic Culture via "Leadership D...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Institutional Ethnography as a Method to Understand the Career and Parental L...
Institutional Ethnography as a Method to Understand the Career and Parental L...Institutional Ethnography as a Method to Understand the Career and Parental L...
Institutional Ethnography as a Method to Understand the Career and Parental L...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
2011 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
2011 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program2011 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
2011 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Attracting Underrepresented Minorities through Contextualized Learning Experi...
Attracting Underrepresented Minorities through Contextualized Learning Experi...Attracting Underrepresented Minorities through Contextualized Learning Experi...
Attracting Underrepresented Minorities through Contextualized Learning Experi...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Technology Education and Educational Technology – Two Fields, Very Different ...
Technology Education and Educational Technology – Two Fields, Very Different ...Technology Education and Educational Technology – Two Fields, Very Different ...
Technology Education and Educational Technology – Two Fields, Very Different ...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Understanding Women's Career Choices in Chemistry. By Megan Grunert and Georg...
Understanding Women's Career Choices in Chemistry. By Megan Grunert and Georg...Understanding Women's Career Choices in Chemistry. By Megan Grunert and Georg...
Understanding Women's Career Choices in Chemistry. By Megan Grunert and Georg...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Gender and Race: Workplace Benefits and Job Satisfaction of the American Work...
Gender and Race: Workplace Benefits and Job Satisfaction of the American Work...Gender and Race: Workplace Benefits and Job Satisfaction of the American Work...
Gender and Race: Workplace Benefits and Job Satisfaction of the American Work...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Work and Family: Gender and Program Compari...
Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Work and Family: Gender and Program Compari...Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Work and Family: Gender and Program Compari...
Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Work and Family: Gender and Program Compari...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
Chartering Factors that may contribute to Gender Differences in Spatial Abili...
Chartering Factors that may contribute to Gender Differences in Spatial Abili...Chartering Factors that may contribute to Gender Differences in Spatial Abili...
Chartering Factors that may contribute to Gender Differences in Spatial Abili...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 
What science and engineering means: Discourses of young children across the w...
What science and engineering means: Discourses of young children across the w...What science and engineering means: Discourses of young children across the w...
What science and engineering means: Discourses of young children across the w...
ADVANCE-Purdue
 

More from ADVANCE-Purdue (18)

Career Motivations of Freshman Engineering and Non-Engineering Students: A Ge...
Career Motivations of Freshman Engineering and Non-Engineering Students: A Ge...Career Motivations of Freshman Engineering and Non-Engineering Students: A Ge...
Career Motivations of Freshman Engineering and Non-Engineering Students: A Ge...
 
Choosing STEM careers: The Dialectical Discourses of 21st century Indian women
Choosing STEM careers:  The Dialectical Discourses of 21st century Indian womenChoosing STEM careers:  The Dialectical Discourses of 21st century Indian women
Choosing STEM careers: The Dialectical Discourses of 21st century Indian women
 
Cultural negotiations of Indian women in U.S. engineering classrooms
Cultural negotiations of Indian women in U.S. engineering classroomsCultural negotiations of Indian women in U.S. engineering classrooms
Cultural negotiations of Indian women in U.S. engineering classrooms
 
Gender Differences in Digital Literacy Games: Efficacy, Strategies, Experienc...
Gender Differences in Digital Literacy Games: Efficacy, Strategies, Experienc...Gender Differences in Digital Literacy Games: Efficacy, Strategies, Experienc...
Gender Differences in Digital Literacy Games: Efficacy, Strategies, Experienc...
 
Engaging under-represented populations in agricultural research
Engaging under-represented populations in agricultural researchEngaging under-represented populations in agricultural research
Engaging under-represented populations in agricultural research
 
Role of Social Cognitive Variables on Agricultural and Science Career Interes...
Role of Social Cognitive Variables on Agricultural and Science Career Interes...Role of Social Cognitive Variables on Agricultural and Science Career Interes...
Role of Social Cognitive Variables on Agricultural and Science Career Interes...
 
Gender Equity and Slow Adopters: Changing Academic Culture via "Leadership D...
Gender Equity and Slow Adopters:  Changing Academic Culture via "Leadership D...Gender Equity and Slow Adopters:  Changing Academic Culture via "Leadership D...
Gender Equity and Slow Adopters: Changing Academic Culture via "Leadership D...
 
Institutional Ethnography as a Method to Understand the Career and Parental L...
Institutional Ethnography as a Method to Understand the Career and Parental L...Institutional Ethnography as a Method to Understand the Career and Parental L...
Institutional Ethnography as a Method to Understand the Career and Parental L...
 
2011 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
2011 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program2011 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
2011 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
 
Race, Gender, and Institutional Differences in Engineering Persistence. By Ma...
Race, Gender, and Institutional Differences in Engineering Persistence. By Ma...Race, Gender, and Institutional Differences in Engineering Persistence. By Ma...
Race, Gender, and Institutional Differences in Engineering Persistence. By Ma...
 
Attracting Underrepresented Minorities through Contextualized Learning Experi...
Attracting Underrepresented Minorities through Contextualized Learning Experi...Attracting Underrepresented Minorities through Contextualized Learning Experi...
Attracting Underrepresented Minorities through Contextualized Learning Experi...
 
Technology Education and Educational Technology – Two Fields, Very Different ...
Technology Education and Educational Technology – Two Fields, Very Different ...Technology Education and Educational Technology – Two Fields, Very Different ...
Technology Education and Educational Technology – Two Fields, Very Different ...
 
Understanding Women's Career Choices in Chemistry. By Megan Grunert and Georg...
Understanding Women's Career Choices in Chemistry. By Megan Grunert and Georg...Understanding Women's Career Choices in Chemistry. By Megan Grunert and Georg...
Understanding Women's Career Choices in Chemistry. By Megan Grunert and Georg...
 
2010 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
2010 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program2010 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
2010 Gender and STEM Research Symposium Program
 
Gender and Race: Workplace Benefits and Job Satisfaction of the American Work...
Gender and Race: Workplace Benefits and Job Satisfaction of the American Work...Gender and Race: Workplace Benefits and Job Satisfaction of the American Work...
Gender and Race: Workplace Benefits and Job Satisfaction of the American Work...
 
Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Work and Family: Gender and Program Compari...
Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Work and Family: Gender and Program Compari...Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Work and Family: Gender and Program Compari...
Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Work and Family: Gender and Program Compari...
 
Chartering Factors that may contribute to Gender Differences in Spatial Abili...
Chartering Factors that may contribute to Gender Differences in Spatial Abili...Chartering Factors that may contribute to Gender Differences in Spatial Abili...
Chartering Factors that may contribute to Gender Differences in Spatial Abili...
 
What science and engineering means: Discourses of young children across the w...
What science and engineering means: Discourses of young children across the w...What science and engineering means: Discourses of young children across the w...
What science and engineering means: Discourses of young children across the w...
 

Recently uploaded

會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽
會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽
會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽
中 央社
 
SURVEY I created for uni project research
SURVEY I created for uni project researchSURVEY I created for uni project research
SURVEY I created for uni project research
CaitlinCummins3
 
MSc Ag Genetics & Plant Breeding: Insights from Previous Year JNKVV Entrance ...
MSc Ag Genetics & Plant Breeding: Insights from Previous Year JNKVV Entrance ...MSc Ag Genetics & Plant Breeding: Insights from Previous Year JNKVV Entrance ...
MSc Ag Genetics & Plant Breeding: Insights from Previous Year JNKVV Entrance ...
Krashi Coaching
 

Recently uploaded (20)

會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽
會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽
會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽會考英聽
 
diagnosting testing bsc 2nd sem.pptx....
diagnosting testing bsc 2nd sem.pptx....diagnosting testing bsc 2nd sem.pptx....
diagnosting testing bsc 2nd sem.pptx....
 
philosophy and it's principles based on the life
philosophy and it's principles based on the lifephilosophy and it's principles based on the life
philosophy and it's principles based on the life
 
MOOD STABLIZERS DRUGS.pptx
MOOD     STABLIZERS           DRUGS.pptxMOOD     STABLIZERS           DRUGS.pptx
MOOD STABLIZERS DRUGS.pptx
 
TỔNG HỢP HƠN 100 ĐỀ THI THỬ TỐT NGHIỆP THPT TOÁN 2024 - TỪ CÁC TRƯỜNG, TRƯỜNG...
TỔNG HỢP HƠN 100 ĐỀ THI THỬ TỐT NGHIỆP THPT TOÁN 2024 - TỪ CÁC TRƯỜNG, TRƯỜNG...TỔNG HỢP HƠN 100 ĐỀ THI THỬ TỐT NGHIỆP THPT TOÁN 2024 - TỪ CÁC TRƯỜNG, TRƯỜNG...
TỔNG HỢP HƠN 100 ĐỀ THI THỬ TỐT NGHIỆP THPT TOÁN 2024 - TỪ CÁC TRƯỜNG, TRƯỜNG...
 
How To Create Editable Tree View in Odoo 17
How To Create Editable Tree View in Odoo 17How To Create Editable Tree View in Odoo 17
How To Create Editable Tree View in Odoo 17
 
ANTI PARKISON DRUGS.pptx
ANTI         PARKISON          DRUGS.pptxANTI         PARKISON          DRUGS.pptx
ANTI PARKISON DRUGS.pptx
 
Improved Approval Flow in Odoo 17 Studio App
Improved Approval Flow in Odoo 17 Studio AppImproved Approval Flow in Odoo 17 Studio App
Improved Approval Flow in Odoo 17 Studio App
 
Dementia (Alzheimer & vasular dementia).
Dementia (Alzheimer & vasular dementia).Dementia (Alzheimer & vasular dementia).
Dementia (Alzheimer & vasular dementia).
 
IPL Online Quiz by Pragya; Question Set.
IPL Online Quiz by Pragya; Question Set.IPL Online Quiz by Pragya; Question Set.
IPL Online Quiz by Pragya; Question Set.
 
SURVEY I created for uni project research
SURVEY I created for uni project researchSURVEY I created for uni project research
SURVEY I created for uni project research
 
Exploring Gemini AI and Integration with MuleSoft | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #45
Exploring Gemini AI and Integration with MuleSoft | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #45Exploring Gemini AI and Integration with MuleSoft | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #45
Exploring Gemini AI and Integration with MuleSoft | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #45
 
MSc Ag Genetics & Plant Breeding: Insights from Previous Year JNKVV Entrance ...
MSc Ag Genetics & Plant Breeding: Insights from Previous Year JNKVV Entrance ...MSc Ag Genetics & Plant Breeding: Insights from Previous Year JNKVV Entrance ...
MSc Ag Genetics & Plant Breeding: Insights from Previous Year JNKVV Entrance ...
 
Championnat de France de Tennis de table/
Championnat de France de Tennis de table/Championnat de France de Tennis de table/
Championnat de France de Tennis de table/
 
“O BEIJO” EM ARTE .
“O BEIJO” EM ARTE                       .“O BEIJO” EM ARTE                       .
“O BEIJO” EM ARTE .
 
Major project report on Tata Motors and its marketing strategies
Major project report on Tata Motors and its marketing strategiesMajor project report on Tata Motors and its marketing strategies
Major project report on Tata Motors and its marketing strategies
 
PSYPACT- Practicing Over State Lines May 2024.pptx
PSYPACT- Practicing Over State Lines May 2024.pptxPSYPACT- Practicing Over State Lines May 2024.pptx
PSYPACT- Practicing Over State Lines May 2024.pptx
 
Including Mental Health Support in Project Delivery, 14 May.pdf
Including Mental Health Support in Project Delivery, 14 May.pdfIncluding Mental Health Support in Project Delivery, 14 May.pdf
Including Mental Health Support in Project Delivery, 14 May.pdf
 
How to Manage Closest Location in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Closest Location in Odoo 17 InventoryHow to Manage Closest Location in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Closest Location in Odoo 17 Inventory
 
Đề tieng anh thpt 2024 danh cho cac ban hoc sinh
Đề tieng anh thpt 2024 danh cho cac ban hoc sinhĐề tieng anh thpt 2024 danh cho cac ban hoc sinh
Đề tieng anh thpt 2024 danh cho cac ban hoc sinh
 

Oral Histories as Building Blocks for New Theoretical Models: Individual Agency, Gendered Experiences, and Critical Junctures in Women’s Pathways into STEM Faculty Careers. By Jordana Hoegh

  • 1. Oral Histories as Building Blocks for New Theoretical Models: Individual Agency, Gendered Experiences and Critical Junctures in Women’s Pathways into STEM Faculty Careers Jordana Hoegh Dept. of Sociology, ADVANCE Research Team Dr. Alice L. Pawley School of Engineering Education, ADVANCE Research Director
  • 2. Main points Existing theoretical models and their limits Ways oral histories may be used to address those limits A case study to demonstrate the potential of oral history data to generate new theoretical models
  • 3. Why women’s pathways into STEM faculty careers? To understand women’s attrition rates from the path to STEM faculty careers Women increasingly earn STEM doctorates but their representation among STEM faculty has not experienced a relative increase
  • 4. What are the current theoretical models? Leaky Pipeline People drop out or “leak” at particular points from the career path pipeline to STEM faculty Chilly Climate Environment is so unpleasant that some people leave
  • 5. What are the limits? Leaky pipeline assumptions: A passive actor One path to STEM faculty The path is unidirectional Chilly climate assumptions: Women perceive the climate negatively They leave because of a negative climate
  • 6. How might oral history methods expound these limits? Give voice to participants Perceptions of climate will emerge naturally Career pathway patterns will emerge naturally Account for individual agency of actors Shed light on decision-making processes critical junctures
  • 7. What are oral history methods? Semi-structured in-person interviews Broad, open-ended, guiding questions Begin with childhood experiences continuing chronologically through significant life events Participants to choose which experiences to share
  • 8. What are the advantages of oral histories? Build good rapport Interactive process encourages participants to reveal information that surveys or other research methods cannot capture Uncover individual perceptions and decision-making processes Identify why one path was chosen over another
  • 9. Demonstrating the theory-building potential of oral histories I will use a case study from a set of oral history data collected as part of a NSF-funded ADVANCE grant research project aimed at improving the career success of women STEM faculty Examine the relationship between gendered experiences and career decision-making in the context of a critical juncture
  • 10. Sandy: An Exemplar Case Study Critical Juncture: Contemplating leaving graduate school for an industry job. Gendered Experience: Male mentors and an all male research team Individual Agency: Choosing to stay the course
  • 11. Theory-building Potential From the case study: Explore the role of positive and negative mentors in the career paths of women in STEM doctoral graduate programs Explore the ways careers are “facilitated” or “obstructed” Oral history data as building blocks: an idea generator from the ground up
  • 12. Acknowledgements Thank you to study participants! Thanks to those who helped with participant invitations. This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. HRD 0811194. (Any opinions, findings and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.) Questions?

Editor's Notes

  1. Today I’m going to talk about how oral histories may be used as building blocks for developing new theoretical modes for understanding women’s persistent underrepresentation among STEM faculty.I will use a case study to illustrate this by examining individual agency, gendered experiences and critical junctures in women’s pathways into STEM faculty careersAnd I want to note that Dr. Alice Pawley has directed the course of this resarch.
  2. Today I’m going to discuss existing theoretical models used to understand women’s persistent underrepresentation among STEM faculty.I will demonstrate the ways oral history methods may be used to address some of those limits.And, I will use a case study from oral history data to demonstrate the potential to of oral history data in generating new theoretical models that will shed light on women’s underrepresentation among STEM faculty
  3. So, why are we focusing on women’s pathways into STEM faculty careers?To better understand women’s attrition rates from the pathways to STEM facultyWomen increasingly earn STEM doctorates but their representation among STEM faculty has not experienced a relative increaseWomen’s attrition rates from the career pathway to STEM faculty spike after doctoral receipt and before applying for tenure-track faculty positions as well as before earning tenure (National Academies 2009 report)So there’s a need for understanding these trends.
  4. Before I talk about what the current theoretical models are, I want to address why we need theoretical models.Theoretical models enable us to better understand and patterns of particular phenomenon. Understanding such patterns may lead to solutions to particular problems or phenomenon.Leaky pipeline and chilly climate are two frequently used theoretical models to explain women’s underrepresentation among STEM faculty.Leaky pipeline likens the academic career path to a pipeline where potential engineers and scientists enter the pipeline and move through the pipeline completing milestones along the way to becoming academic faculty. People drop out or “leak” at particular points from the career path pipeline to STEM facultyChilly climate contends that the working atmosphere for women is so unpleasant that they leave the career track to STEM faculty altogether
  5. While leaky pipeline and chilly climate theoretical models help us understand the phenomenon of women’s persistent underrepresentation among STEM faculty, they have some limits.The leaky pipeline metaphor assumes a passive actor that is pushed along through the pipeline. Individual agency, which is an individual’s ability to actively make choices, is not considered in the leaky pipeline theoretical model.Also, the pipeline assumes that the pathway to STEM faculty careers is unidirectional and has only one standard sequence and timing. As such it does not account for people who leave the pipeline for a period of time and then later reenter it. Chilly climate assumes that women perceive a negative climate and that they leave because of it. While this certainly represents the experiences of many women, it is only one piece of a larger puzzle. Chilly climate is also limited in its explanatory power as it addresses only one reason that women might leave the career path to STEM faculty.So chilly climate does not account for other reasons that women might leave, like being recruited to higher paying industry jobs, or leaving for family, or health reasons.
  6. So, how might oral history methods expound the limits of leaky pipeline and chilly climate theories?Oral histories give participants voice by putting them the driver’s seat, so to speak. They enable participants to discuss what they feel is important about their career pathways rather researcher imposing their ideas about what is important.This will allow perceptions of chilly climate as well as patterns in career pathways to emerge naturally, if at all.Also, oral histories account for the individual agency of actors, which is particularly important when examining the decision-making processes at critical junctures along the pathway to STEM careers.
  7. So, what are oral history methods? Oral histories are a means of capturing the totality of one’s life experiences. Interviewers guide oral histories by asking participants about particular topics pertinent to the study purpose. Interviewers are active listeners and offer probes only as necessary. So, oral histories are semi-structured, in-person interviews with broak, open-ended guiding questions.They often begin with childhood experiences and continue chronologically through significant life events.Because participants choose which experiences to share, themes emerge naturally 
  8. So, what are the advantages of oral histories?In effective oral histories, interviewers build good rapport with participants and uniquely encourage participants to divulge information they would not otherwise divulge on a survey or even in a phone interview. Oral histories methods uniquely allow researchers to examine individual perceptions and personal decision-making processes. As participants detail critical points in their life paths, they talk about why they chose one path over another. If participants do not divulge the rationale for their choices, the interviewer may probe for additional explanations. Because of the conversational nature of oral histories, researchers may easily tap into the dynamics of decision-making thought processes.
  9. So, to demonstrate the theory-building potential of oral histories, I will use a case study for a set of oral history data collected as part of a NSF-funded ADVANCE grant research project aimed at improving the career success of women STEM faculty.I will examine the relationship between gendered experiences and career decision-making in the context of a critical juncture in the career pathway of a women STEM faculty member.
  10. I am going to talk about the case of Sandy, which is a pseudonym, who is a STEM faculty member.While in graduate school, Sandy contemplated leaving graduate school for an industry job. She was the only female on a team of 10 or so graduate student researchers. ~ humiliation in the lab~ bad mentor advising her to pursue another career path because she was not talented enough to make it~ no comraderie among fellow grad students on the research team~ She was considering leaving grad school and looked into several job opportunities in the private sector~ Now, she also had another research appointment with another professor who I dubb as “good mentor”~ good mentor pursuaded her to continue through graduate school because she has the talent to create a fruitful and successful research career~ Sandy quit working for bad professor and continued through graduate schoolShe admits that if it weren’t for good mentor, she would likely have left grad school for an industry careerAs she told her story she said that bad mentor “obstructed her” while good mentor “facilitated her” in her careerSandy’s gendered experience both negatively and positively influenced Sandy.…the bad mentor caused her to doubt her abilities and even her career path as she considered other career options…the good mentor reassured her that she is qualified, talented and capable of an academic research career. Sandy’s story highlights the significant role of mentors in the pathway to STEM faculty careers. Her story also makes use of the terms “obstructed” and “facilitated”.These ideas are the beginnings of theory development. Interestingly Sandy talks about they ways her mentors “obstructed” or “facilitated” her in passive terms. This could reflect her view of herself as a passive agent being moved along the career pathway, much like the pipeline metaphor.Or, it could be a nuance of retrospective reflection.Finally, Sandy’s story highlights a critical juncture where she actively chose to stay on the pathway to STEM faculty where others may have fallen from the career path. Her gendered experience with her male mentors and all male research team placed her in critical juncture where she considered an alternate career path but actively chose to stay the course.
  11. From this case study, there is theory-building potential in exploring the role of positive and negative mentors in in the career paths of women in STEM doctoral graduate programsThere is also potential to explore the ways women view their careers as “facilitated” or “obstructed” by othersThese ideas are the building blocks for generating new theories from the ground up. These theories are important because they may inform the educational experiences, recruitment hiring, and retention of women into STEM faculty careers.