Opportunity validation
•
0 likes•118 views
The document discusses frameworks for validating business opportunities, including Porter's Five Forces analysis and the 7+1 framework. It focuses on analyzing sectors like telecom and consumer goods using these models. Key aspects of opportunity validation covered include evaluating the market size, customer needs, competitive landscape, management team, and ensuring the opportunity has positive present value, is timely, and can be implemented and scaled efficiently.
Recommended
More Related Content
What's hot
What's hot (20)
Similar to Opportunity validation
Similar to Opportunity validation (20)
More from Sublaxmi Gupta
More from Sublaxmi Gupta (20)
Recently uploaded
Recently uploaded (20)
Opportunity validation
- 1. © Archana Veerabahu Business Design Session 2 Opportunity Validation
- 2. © Archana Veerabahu A quick recap of Sector Analysis
- 3. © Archana Veerabahu 2 competing standards • GICS – Global Industrial Classification Standard – S&P, MSCI • ICB – Industrial Classification Benchmark – Dow Jones, FTSE 11Sectors
- 4. © Archana Veerabahu 5 steps to sector analysis Basic understanding Porter’s 5 forces Industry life cycle Growth drivers and roadblocks Does the sector interest you?
- 5. © Archana Veerabahu Source: ibef Telecom Telecom Mobile Fixed Line Internet Services
- 6. © Archana Veerabahu Industry growth Source: ibef Telecom
- 7. © Archana Veerabahu Porter’s Five Forces Analysis Threat of substitutes Bargaining power of buyers Bargaining power of suppliers Competitive rivalry Threat of new entrants Economies of Scale Capital Costs Government Policies Access to Distribution Availability of Substitutes Buyer concentration vs Firm concentration Brand Loyalty Product Differentiation Product Differentiation Differentiation of Inputs on Quality Threat of Backward Integration Switching costs of Buyers Number of Competitors Relative Size of Competitors Industry Growth Rate Brand Loyalty Number of Substitutes Buyer propensity to substitute Switching cost for Firms to substitute Telecom
- 8. © Archana Veerabahu Porter’s Five Forces Analysis Threat of substitutes Bargaining power of buyers Bargaining power of suppliers Competitive rivalry Threat of new entrants Economies of Scale Capital Costs Government Policies Access to Distribution Availability of Substitutes Buyer concentration vs Firm concentration Brand Loyalty Product Differentiation Product Differentiation Differentiation of Inputs on Quality Threat of Backward Integration Switching costs of Buyers Number of Competitors Relative Size of Competitors Industry Growth Rate Brand Loyalty Number of Substitutes Buyer propensity to substitute Switching cost for Firms to substitute Telecom
- 9. © Archana Veerabahu Let’s try a different sector
- 10. © Archana Veerabahu Consumer Goods Consumer Goods Food and beverages Household and personal care Healthcare Source: ibef
- 11. © Archana Veerabahu Industry highlights
- 12. © Archana Veerabahu Per capita income trend
- 13. © Archana Veerabahu Source: ibef Consumer Goods
- 14. © Archana Veerabahu Porter’s Five Forces Analysis Threat of substitutes Bargaining power of buyers Bargaining power of suppliers Competitive rivalry Threat of new entrants Economies of Scale Capital Costs Government Policies Access to Distribution Availability of Substitutes Buyer concentration vs Firm concentration Brand Loyalty Product Differentiation Product Differentiation Differentiation of Inputs on Quality Threat of Backward Integration Switching costs of Buyers Number of Competitors Relative Size of Competitors Industry Growth Rate Brand Loyalty Number of Substitutes Buyer propensity to substitute Switching cost for Firms to substitute Consumer Goods
- 15. © Archana Veerabahu Porter’s Five Forces Analysis Threat of substitutes Bargaining power of buyers Bargaining power of suppliers Competitive rivalry Threat of new entrants Economies of Scale Capital Costs Government Policies Access to Distribution Availability of Substitutes Buyer concentration vs Firm concentration Brand Loyalty Product Differentiation Product Differentiation Differentiation of Inputs on Quality Threat of Backward Integration Switching costs of Buyers Number of Competitors Relative Size of Competitors Industry Growth Rate Brand Loyalty Number of Substitutes Buyer propensity to substitute Switching cost for Firms to substitute Consumer Goods
- 16. © Archana Veerabahu Industry Value Chain Raw materials Intermediate goods Manufacturing Marketing/Sales After-sales service Opportunity Identification
- 17. © Archana Veerabahu Opportunity Validation Pre-reqs: • Familiarity with the chosen industry • Clarity of idea READY TO BE TESTED What?
- 18. © Archana Veerabahu Who do you want to be?
- 19. © Archana Veerabahu Typical startup journey Discover opportunities Pursue the best opportunity Validate the chosen opportunity
- 20. © Archana Veerabahu OUTSIDE - IMPACTS Opportunity Uncertainty Team Strategy Investment Deal Exit Dr. Steven Kaplan
- 21. © Archana Veerabahu Opportunity Does it have IMPACTS? Idea •What is the idea / industry ? Market •Is the target market large enough to support substantial growth / valuation? Positive Present Value •Why does the opportunity generate a positive present value? What is unique? Acceptance • Will customers in that market accept / buy this new product / service? Competition • Why won't the value be competed away? Time • Why is this a good time to enter? Speed • How quickly can this be implemented?
- 22. © Archana Veerabahu Positive Present Value • Why does the opportunity generate a positive present value? • What is unique? • What is differentiating? • Why will you make money? • How will you make money? IMPACTS
- 23. © Archana Veerabahu Acceptance • Will customers in that market accept / buy this new product / service? • How does the customer spend the day • Why will they buy your product / service? • What do they buy now? • Why do they buy what they do now? • Why will they switch from their current product? • How will you get to the customers? – Direct Salesforce – Resellers – Distributors – How much of each? How quickly? • Advertising – How much will it cost? – How will you retain customers? – How much will it cost? IMPACTS
- 24. © Archana Veerabahu IMPACTS Competition •Why won't the value be competed away? •What will existing competitors do? •What will other new entrants do? •How will you respond? Time •Why is this a good time to enter? •Why hasn't the opportunity been taken already? Speed •How quickly can this be implemented? Good opportunities have positive IMPACTS If the opportunity does not have IMPACTS, then it should not be pursued
- 25. © Archana Veerabahu OUTSIDE • What are major uncertainties? – Market size – Customer acceptance – Customer approach – Competition – Management team • Potential real options – Which uncertainties can be managed so that outcome is more likely to be favorable? – Choice of initial customers – Choice of investors – How do the answers affect the opportunity? Uncertainties
- 26. © Archana Veerabahu OUTSIDE • Can management team implement opportunity? – How does previous experience relate to opportunity? – How “hungry” is the management team? • If management pieces are missing – What pieces are missing? – What type of person will you look for to fill them? – How will you find that person? • For VCs, a good team and a good opportunity are necessities Team Is strategy consistent with opportunity, uncertainty, team, and exit? Strategy
- 27. © Archana Veerabahu OUTSIDE • Cash flow requirements – What is the volume of cash required – How frequently is the injection of cash required – Are there any uncertainties in future cash flows • Does deal structure provide appropriate incentives? – Is the deal priced attractively ? – Do key individuals have incentives to do deal? – Do key individuals have incentives to make deal work? – Does deal structure provide / ensure appropriate governance? – Does deal structure help manage the uncertainties? • Can investors exit the deal? How? Investment Deal Exit If an investment does not pass the OUTSIDE tests, leave it outside
- 28. © Archana Veerabahu An alternative approach 7+1 framework by Dr. Patrick Berbon Multiple frameworks exist to validate any business opportunity Each PE/VC firm has a proprietary framework that they use to evaluate ventures 1. Large pain point 2. Superior solution 3. Profitable model Target Opportunity 4. Team 5. Timing 6. Scalability 7. Capital Efficiency
- 29. © Archana Veerabahu 1. Large Pain point
- 30. © Archana Veerabahu 1. Large Pain point Are you addressing a clear pain point? Who are the customers feeling that pain? How painful is the pain point? Are you addressing a conscious pain ? How is the pain point addressed today? Is the addressable market size above 1 billion dollars? Is the market growing over 30% a year?
- 31. © Archana Veerabahu 2. A superior solution to the particular pain point
- 32. © Archana Veerabahu 2. A superior solution to the particular pain point What is your solution? Does your solution solve the pain point? How is your solution 10 times better in at least one dimension than your competitors’? Is your solution beyond proof of concept? Can your solution become the market leader?
- 33. © Archana Veerabahu 3. A profitable model
- 34. © Archana Veerabahu 3. A profitable model What is your Business Model? What is your competitive advantage? How will you receive monopoly profit’? What is your Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) and Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC)? How do you reach the customers?
- 35. © Archana Veerabahu 4. A stellar team
- 36. © Archana Veerabahu 4. A stellar team Who are the founders? Have they achieved something hard before? Have they achieved something hard together before? Who is in the board of advisors ? Is this really what you want to do? What are the skills of the team? Does the team have an entrepreneurial spirit?
- 37. © Archana Veerabahu 5. An answer to “Why now?”
- 38. © Archana Veerabahu 5. An answer to “Why now?” What has changed in the last quarters or years to justify that now is the right time to invest in this project Was this business model not applicable before?
- 39. © Archana Veerabahu 6. Scalability A characteristic of a system that describes its capability to perform under an increased or expanding workload. A system that scales well will be able to maintain or even increase its level of efficiency when tested by larger operational demands
- 40. © Archana Veerabahu 6. Scalability Is my production scalable? Is my marketing scalable? Is my distribution scalable? Is my workforce scalable?
- 41. © Archana Veerabahu 6. Capital Efficiency ROI!
- 42. © Archana Veerabahu 7. Capital Efficiency What return on capital can an investor expect from your project? Can you become cash-flow positive with a small amount of money?
- 43. © Archana Veerabahu Horse or jockey? • Some VCs believe company’s product and market are key • Bet on the horse • Others believe that VC investment is about management, management, management. • Bet on the jockey
- 44. © Archana Veerabahu What will you do? That’s the real question!