The Rise and Fall of
Walid Aoude | Samantha Kussmann | Vanessa Lee | Marcus Parks | Oleksandr Surkov
agenda
1. History and Company Overview
2. Case Synopsis
3. Key Issues
4. Industry Overview
5. Competitive Landscape
6. Porter’s Five Forces Analysis
7. PEST Analysis
8. SWOT Analysis
9. What if Scenarios
10. Recommendations
11. Risks and Risk Mitigation
12. Suggested Areas of Exploration
13. Current Situation
14. Key Learning Outcomes
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
1865 – Nokia Ab established as a timber company
1922 – industrial conglomerate of Nokia Ab, Suomen
Gummitehdas, Suomen Kaapelitehdas
1967 – merger into Nokia Corporation
1987 – first mobile phone and GSM development in
Europe
1998 – the world’s biggest and leading producer of
mobile phones
2007 – the 5th global brand worth over $33 bln according
to Interbrand
2013 - sold to Microsoft for $7.2 bln
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
history&company
overview
1865
• Timber
1960s
• Rubber
• Cable
• Forestry
• Electronics
• Power Generation
2002
• Mobile Phones
• Multimedia Phones
• Enterprise Solutions
• Networks
2014
• Nokia Networks
• HERE maps
• Nokia Technologies
1865 - 2014
divisional structure
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
history&company
overview
products evolution
1987
• Nokia
Cityman
• €4,500
1992
• Nokia
1011
• €1335
1994
• Nokia
2110
• €703
1996
• Nokia
8110
1998
• Nokia
6160
• €834
1999
• Nokia
7110
• €464
2002
• Nokia
7650
• €185-
411
2003
• Nokia
1616
• €32
2004
• Nokia
7280
• ~€100
2005
• Nokia
8800
• ~€330
2007
• Nokia
6555
• ~€80
2008
• Nokia
E90
• ~€400
2011
• Nokia
801T
• ~€220
2013
• Nokia
Lumia
1020
• ~€400
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
history&company
overview
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
• The case focuses on evolution of over century old Finish communications and
technology corporation, Nokia
• It also provides insight into the role of top management (CEO in particular) in
the performance of the corporation
• This case explores the events and managerial decisions that resulted in
Nokia’s spectacular rise and subsequent fall
• While unraveling some of the techniques behind the corporations key
successes, the case delivers information about the company’s major
downfalls, which led to its eventual collapse and eventually being bought out
by Microsoft at very discounted price
• The case examines Nokia’s biggest successes: their product innovation (in
style and fashion), flexibility, rapid responsiveness to market differences, their
patent portfolio and targeting the low-end market
• The case also examines their biggest faults: in relying too much on
yesterdays success, blinding them from taking advantage of new
opportunities
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
raising industry dynamics and
competition
corporate, organizational &
change management issues
costs & benefits of innovation
and R&D
aggressive business expansion
through mergers and
acquisitions
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
rapidly expanding in developed countries (North
America, Europe, Asia)
dominated by few players with growing competition
from outliers
multiple mobile networks present (GSM, CDMA)
a shift in the industry focus
the emergence of the smartphone
outsourcing of large portions of production and
manufacturing
iOS, Google and Microsoft release operating systems
rapid shortening in product life cycle
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
late 90’s – early 00’s
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
2012 global competition
$881,000,000
$5,730,000,000
$1,820,000,000
$887,000,000
$21,720,000,000
$576,000,000
$62,000,000
MOTOROLA SIEMENS ALCATEL ERICSSON SAMSUNG HTC LG
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
• Lost competitive
position
• Lack of innovation
• Brand identity lost
• Low product
differentiation
Competitive
Rivalry
Threat of New Entry
• Proprietary knowledge
• Software (OS, Apps, …)
• Retaliation from others
• High capital needed
• Brand identity
Buyer
Power
• Consumer volume up
• Rapid changes
• Decreased product
differentiation
• Changing carriers is hard
Supplier
Power
• Hardware components
• Multiple suppliers
• Increased differentiation
in hardware
• Rapid changes
Threat of
Substitution
• Limited phone
substitutions
• Many different phones
• High price performance
value
Porter’s 5 forces
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
Political
• Limited government
support
• Government did not
bail out Nokia in 2013
• European Union (free
trade and single
currency)
Economic
• Finnish economy
recovering
• Increase in mobile
phone market world
wide
• Low interest rates
Social
• World population
becoming more
dependent on mobile
devices
• Social pressures to
manufacture in an
ethical manner
Technological
• Technology changing
rapidly
• 6 to 9 month product
life cycles
• Entry of competitors
with advanced
technologies
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
1. Major mergers and
acquisitions
2. GSM Network control
3. Vast number of patents
4. Large investments in R&D,
manufacturing and
production
5. Major divestment from
non-core business units
6. High quality and tailored
handset designs
1. Small product portfolio for
CDMA network
2. Poor software
development (OS)
3. Minimal focus on American
market
4. Lack of smartphone
development
5. Management conflicts
strengths
weaknesses
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
1. American market – pairing with
service providers
2. Rapidly growing smartphone
market
3. Joint venture with software
developer for OS (Google
Android)
4. Moving in-house production to
outsourced
manufacturing/developing
5. Asian markets – develop/maintain
network dominance (GSM)
6. Decrease product portfolio to
focus on key and rapidly growing
products
7. Increase European market share
1. Major software developers (Apple &
Google & Microsoft)
2. Emerging Asian companies (HTC &
LG & Samsung & Chinese
companies)
3. Rapidly growing tech bubble in USA
(Silicon Valley) – new software
entrants
4. Increasingly globalized economy
creating greater access to other
mobile phone options
5. A shift from standard mobile phones
to smartphones (not industry but the
general public)
6. Japanese development of a local
network (requiring phones for that
specific network)
opportunities
threats
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
best global brands by Interbrand
#98
2014
lookback
alternatives
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
why do you think Nokia has
failed?
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
what were the alternative
strategic decisions of Nokia
management within the last
10 years?
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
• did not keep on pursuing smartphone
technology in early 2000s (they already
designed touchscreen in 2003)
• rejecting outsourcing and ODM model
• blinded by success
• US market specifics
• software (OS) choice
• managerial tensions
• slow reaction to changing market
bad decisions
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
focus on smartphones in
early 2000’s
considering ODM path of
competitors
focus on single open-
source operating system
partner with Microsoft
earlier
change management
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
from today’s perspective
focus on other areas without
reestablishing phones
production/keep receiving royalties
get prepared for later
reestablishment own their own
production/restrict brand name
usage
partnership/board place in the new
devices producer/allow them using
brand name
Nokia has rich expertise in establishing modern networks
experienced and creative tech personnel to pursue IoT and
other latest technologies
royalties for brand name usage as a bonus
try another chance into becoming leading phones manufacturer
"Nokia smartphones are amongst the top five considered
brands for purchase by smartphone buyers" --Nokia,05/2016
still have connections with suppliers/have not been forgotten by
former fans/have tech base
follow ODM/OEM modeland have devices produced by Foxconn
by having presence in top management, Nokia will be able to
control quality and share expertise
Nokia N1 tablet release in 2015 – rather successfulAndroid tablet
available on Asian markets
royalties for brand name usage as a bonus
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
partnership/board place in the
new devices producer/allow
them using brand name
• outsourcing production to keep up with the competition due to lowering production costs
• quality control by taking part in key decisions
the best way for brand reincarnation
by having presence in top management, Nokia will be able to control
quality and share expertise
• pursuing open source OS – Android
• using popular ecosystem
• already tested
Nokia N1 tablet release in 2015 – rather successful Android tablet
available on Asian markets
• although the products won't have Nokia Corp. tag; with proper marketing, consumers will
trust the products more leading to increased brand value
royalties for brand name usage as a bonus
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
• the option requires less investment than
reestablishing Nokia’s own production
• use of Android – familiar and very popular
ecosystem
• investing in market research
• clear positioning of new devices
• marketing campaign to remind consumers about
Nokia
• focus on the loyal markets (India, Asian
countries) in the initial stages
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
invest in market research
researchthe likely demand for
functional phones in the future
workout the strategy for entering
US market
keep on developing 5G
technology & IoT - perspective
market for next generation of
devices
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
current structure
Nokia President
and Chief
Executive
Officer,Rajeev
Suri
Business
Groups
Units
Mobile
Networks
Fixed
Networks
Applications &
Analytics
IP/Optical
Networks
Nokia
Technologies
Chief Financial
Officer
Chief Customer
Operations
Officer
Chief
Innovation &
Operating
Officer
Chief Human
Resources Officer
Chief
Strategy
Officer
Chief
Marketing
Officer
Chief Legal
Officer
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
19
15
29
30
32
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Nokia Market Capitalization 2012 - today
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
Microsoft has just released the latest
Nokia feature phone, with target market
in India. The phone sells for only $37.
The company owns Nokia brand name
until Q4 2016
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
“Nokia signs strategic brand and intellectual
property licensing agreement enabling HMD
global to create new generation of Nokia-
branded mobile phones and tablets”
– Nokia Corporation, 18 May, 2016
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
+
released 2015
Nokia N1 Tablet
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
• aggressive expansion and acquisition of the
companies specializing on supplemental products
(networks, cables, communications) allowed Nokia
to create a market for its products
• sticking to core values is likely to bring success in
the long run
• focus on highly performing company products and
strengths proved to be beneficial for Nokia
• successful utilization of emerging markets in global
economy
• R&D as well as innovation are the engine of any
successful tech company
rise of Nokia
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
• slow decision are very costly in today’s dynamic world
• “vertical business model” is no longer an option on this
market – leading industry players partner with Asian
OEM/ODMs who benefit from enormous economies of
scale
• Nokia missed the key shift in the industry – the role of
software and consumer devices ecosystem
• tensions within company management eliminate the
most valuable resources – time & money. Nokia has
lost focus
• brand value is highly fluctuating dimension, especially
in the 21st century
• North-American CEO didn’t fully understand European
and Asian phone markets and their perception of Nokia
fall of Nokia
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
flashback
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
Thank You
history&company
overview
case synopsis
key issues
industry overview
competition
Porter’s 5 forces
PEST analysis
SWOT
lookback
alternatives
alternative
scenarios
recommendations
risks mitigation
suggestions
2016
key learnings
• http://company.nokia.com/en/our-businesses/nokia-technologies/hello-again
• http://company.nokia.com/en/news/press-releases/2016/05/18/nokia-signs-strategic-brand-and-intellectual-property-licensing-agreement-
enabling-hmd-global-to-create-new-generation-of-nokia-branded-mobile-phones-and-tablets
• http://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2015/06/19/nokia-android-smartphone-2016-confirmed/#35be307d3d13
• http://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2014/04/21/three-vital-signs-of-life-and-death-to-watch-for-as-microsofts-7-5-billion-purchase-of-
nokia-is-finalized/#790e133e30a7
• https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Nokia-fail-to-compete-with-Samsung-Apple-etc-despite-being-the-giant-of-the-mobile-phone-industry
• http://www.rankingthebrands.com/Brand-detail.aspx?brandID=11
• http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-10-03/the-most-valuable-brands-in-america-2000-to-2013
• http://www.cio.com/article/2849223/nokias-n1-android-tablet-is-actually-a-foxconn-tablet.html
• ttp://nokiamuseum.info/category/launching-year/1987/
• http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/nokia-1011-20-years-old-history-mobile-403478
• https://www.amazon.co.uk/Nokia-2100-Grey-SIM-Free/dp/B00009XLN8
• http://company.nokia.com/en/news/media-library/image-gallery/item/nokia-8110-gsm-handportable-1996
• https://www.iretron.com/Cell-Phones/Nokia/Nokia-6160;3332
• https://uk.webuy.com/phones/product.php?mastersku=SNOK7110#.V-hl9skpftQ
• http://www.cnet.com/pictures/nokia-a-long-and-innovative-history-photos/11
• http://www.cellphones.ca/cell-phones/nokia-1616/
• http://latest_mobile_reviews.mobighar.com/nokia_phone_reviews_and_specifications/nokia_7280_old_mobile_phone_full_review_specific
ations.html
• http://www.refurb-phone.com/product/nokia-phone/nokia-8800-mobile-phone/
• http://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_6555-2071.php
• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_E90_Communicator
• http://nokiamuseum.info/nokia-801t/
• https://www.sarchecker.com/smartphone/nokia-lumia-1020/
• http://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_7280-884.php
• https://www.aliexpress.com/price/nokia-7280_price.html
• http://company.nokia.com/en/about-us/our-company/our-structure
• http://mynokiablog.com/2014/04/29/nokias-new-ceo-rajeev-suri-effective-may-1st/
• http://www.huffingtonpost.com/william-morrow/7-proven-ways-to-accelera_b_10042372.html
• https://www.citelighter.com/technology/technology/knowledgecards/technology
• http://www.mobolize.com/can-mobile-networks-keep-up-with-demand/
• https://itunews.itu.int/En/4958-Mobile-broadband-smartphones-apps-fixed-networks.note.aspx
• http://www.optimisationv.com/category/google-analytics
• https://www.sdxcentral.com/articles/news/nokias-post-merger-plan-bodes-well-for-nuage-networks-so-far/2015/10/
• http://www.informationweek.com/it-life/nokia-ozo-virtual-reality-camera-aimed-at-film-pros/d/d-id/1321521
• http://en.uaezoom.com/chief-financial-officer-cfo-salary-in-the-uae/
• http://www.cco-exchange.com/
• https://www.linkedin.com/topic/value-innovation
• http://www.rc-hr.com/contactus.aspx
• http://www.business2community.com/content-marketing/5-key-elements-successful-content-marketing-strategy-0947654
• http://bushmarketing.ca/what-is-the-marketing-funnel/
• http://v-a-l-s.org/
• http://company.nokia.com/en
• https://ycharts.com/companies/NOK/market_cap
web sources

Nokia_Final (1)

  • 1.
    The Rise andFall of Walid Aoude | Samantha Kussmann | Vanessa Lee | Marcus Parks | Oleksandr Surkov
  • 2.
    agenda 1. History andCompany Overview 2. Case Synopsis 3. Key Issues 4. Industry Overview 5. Competitive Landscape 6. Porter’s Five Forces Analysis 7. PEST Analysis 8. SWOT Analysis 9. What if Scenarios 10. Recommendations 11. Risks and Risk Mitigation 12. Suggested Areas of Exploration 13. Current Situation 14. Key Learning Outcomes
  • 3.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings 1865 – Nokia Ab established as a timber company 1922 – industrial conglomerate of Nokia Ab, Suomen Gummitehdas, Suomen Kaapelitehdas 1967 – merger into Nokia Corporation 1987 – first mobile phone and GSM development in Europe 1998 – the world’s biggest and leading producer of mobile phones 2007 – the 5th global brand worth over $33 bln according to Interbrand 2013 - sold to Microsoft for $7.2 bln
  • 4.
    case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings history&company overview 1865 • Timber 1960s • Rubber • Cable • Forestry • Electronics • Power Generation 2002 • Mobile Phones • Multimedia Phones • Enterprise Solutions • Networks 2014 • Nokia Networks • HERE maps • Nokia Technologies 1865 - 2014 divisional structure
  • 5.
    case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings history&company overview products evolution 1987 • Nokia Cityman • €4,500 1992 • Nokia 1011 • €1335 1994 • Nokia 2110 • €703 1996 • Nokia 8110 1998 • Nokia 6160 • €834 1999 • Nokia 7110 • €464 2002 • Nokia 7650 • €185- 411 2003 • Nokia 1616 • €32 2004 • Nokia 7280 • ~€100 2005 • Nokia 8800 • ~€330 2007 • Nokia 6555 • ~€80 2008 • Nokia E90 • ~€400 2011 • Nokia 801T • ~€220 2013 • Nokia Lumia 1020 • ~€400
  • 6.
    case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings history&company overview
  • 7.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings • The case focuses on evolution of over century old Finish communications and technology corporation, Nokia • It also provides insight into the role of top management (CEO in particular) in the performance of the corporation • This case explores the events and managerial decisions that resulted in Nokia’s spectacular rise and subsequent fall • While unraveling some of the techniques behind the corporations key successes, the case delivers information about the company’s major downfalls, which led to its eventual collapse and eventually being bought out by Microsoft at very discounted price • The case examines Nokia’s biggest successes: their product innovation (in style and fashion), flexibility, rapid responsiveness to market differences, their patent portfolio and targeting the low-end market • The case also examines their biggest faults: in relying too much on yesterdays success, blinding them from taking advantage of new opportunities
  • 8.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings raising industry dynamics and competition corporate, organizational & change management issues costs & benefits of innovation and R&D aggressive business expansion through mergers and acquisitions
  • 9.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings rapidly expanding in developed countries (North America, Europe, Asia) dominated by few players with growing competition from outliers multiple mobile networks present (GSM, CDMA) a shift in the industry focus the emergence of the smartphone outsourcing of large portions of production and manufacturing iOS, Google and Microsoft release operating systems rapid shortening in product life cycle
  • 10.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings late 90’s – early 00’s
  • 11.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings 2012 global competition $881,000,000 $5,730,000,000 $1,820,000,000 $887,000,000 $21,720,000,000 $576,000,000 $62,000,000 MOTOROLA SIEMENS ALCATEL ERICSSON SAMSUNG HTC LG
  • 12.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings • Lost competitive position • Lack of innovation • Brand identity lost • Low product differentiation Competitive Rivalry Threat of New Entry • Proprietary knowledge • Software (OS, Apps, …) • Retaliation from others • High capital needed • Brand identity Buyer Power • Consumer volume up • Rapid changes • Decreased product differentiation • Changing carriers is hard Supplier Power • Hardware components • Multiple suppliers • Increased differentiation in hardware • Rapid changes Threat of Substitution • Limited phone substitutions • Many different phones • High price performance value Porter’s 5 forces
  • 13.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings Political • Limited government support • Government did not bail out Nokia in 2013 • European Union (free trade and single currency) Economic • Finnish economy recovering • Increase in mobile phone market world wide • Low interest rates Social • World population becoming more dependent on mobile devices • Social pressures to manufacture in an ethical manner Technological • Technology changing rapidly • 6 to 9 month product life cycles • Entry of competitors with advanced technologies
  • 14.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings 1. Major mergers and acquisitions 2. GSM Network control 3. Vast number of patents 4. Large investments in R&D, manufacturing and production 5. Major divestment from non-core business units 6. High quality and tailored handset designs 1. Small product portfolio for CDMA network 2. Poor software development (OS) 3. Minimal focus on American market 4. Lack of smartphone development 5. Management conflicts strengths weaknesses
  • 15.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings 1. American market – pairing with service providers 2. Rapidly growing smartphone market 3. Joint venture with software developer for OS (Google Android) 4. Moving in-house production to outsourced manufacturing/developing 5. Asian markets – develop/maintain network dominance (GSM) 6. Decrease product portfolio to focus on key and rapidly growing products 7. Increase European market share 1. Major software developers (Apple & Google & Microsoft) 2. Emerging Asian companies (HTC & LG & Samsung & Chinese companies) 3. Rapidly growing tech bubble in USA (Silicon Valley) – new software entrants 4. Increasingly globalized economy creating greater access to other mobile phone options 5. A shift from standard mobile phones to smartphones (not industry but the general public) 6. Japanese development of a local network (requiring phones for that specific network) opportunities threats
  • 16.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings best global brands by Interbrand #98 2014 lookback alternatives
  • 17.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings why do you think Nokia has failed?
  • 18.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings what were the alternative strategic decisions of Nokia management within the last 10 years?
  • 19.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings • did not keep on pursuing smartphone technology in early 2000s (they already designed touchscreen in 2003) • rejecting outsourcing and ODM model • blinded by success • US market specifics • software (OS) choice • managerial tensions • slow reaction to changing market bad decisions
  • 20.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings focus on smartphones in early 2000’s considering ODM path of competitors focus on single open- source operating system partner with Microsoft earlier change management
  • 21.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings from today’s perspective focus on other areas without reestablishing phones production/keep receiving royalties get prepared for later reestablishment own their own production/restrict brand name usage partnership/board place in the new devices producer/allow them using brand name Nokia has rich expertise in establishing modern networks experienced and creative tech personnel to pursue IoT and other latest technologies royalties for brand name usage as a bonus try another chance into becoming leading phones manufacturer "Nokia smartphones are amongst the top five considered brands for purchase by smartphone buyers" --Nokia,05/2016 still have connections with suppliers/have not been forgotten by former fans/have tech base follow ODM/OEM modeland have devices produced by Foxconn by having presence in top management, Nokia will be able to control quality and share expertise Nokia N1 tablet release in 2015 – rather successfulAndroid tablet available on Asian markets royalties for brand name usage as a bonus
  • 22.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings partnership/board place in the new devices producer/allow them using brand name • outsourcing production to keep up with the competition due to lowering production costs • quality control by taking part in key decisions the best way for brand reincarnation by having presence in top management, Nokia will be able to control quality and share expertise • pursuing open source OS – Android • using popular ecosystem • already tested Nokia N1 tablet release in 2015 – rather successful Android tablet available on Asian markets • although the products won't have Nokia Corp. tag; with proper marketing, consumers will trust the products more leading to increased brand value royalties for brand name usage as a bonus
  • 23.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings • the option requires less investment than reestablishing Nokia’s own production • use of Android – familiar and very popular ecosystem • investing in market research • clear positioning of new devices • marketing campaign to remind consumers about Nokia • focus on the loyal markets (India, Asian countries) in the initial stages
  • 24.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings invest in market research researchthe likely demand for functional phones in the future workout the strategy for entering US market keep on developing 5G technology & IoT - perspective market for next generation of devices
  • 25.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings current structure Nokia President and Chief Executive Officer,Rajeev Suri Business Groups Units Mobile Networks Fixed Networks Applications & Analytics IP/Optical Networks Nokia Technologies Chief Financial Officer Chief Customer Operations Officer Chief Innovation & Operating Officer Chief Human Resources Officer Chief Strategy Officer Chief Marketing Officer Chief Legal Officer
  • 26.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings 19 15 29 30 32 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Nokia Market Capitalization 2012 - today
  • 27.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings Microsoft has just released the latest Nokia feature phone, with target market in India. The phone sells for only $37. The company owns Nokia brand name until Q4 2016
  • 28.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings “Nokia signs strategic brand and intellectual property licensing agreement enabling HMD global to create new generation of Nokia- branded mobile phones and tablets” – Nokia Corporation, 18 May, 2016
  • 29.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings + released 2015 Nokia N1 Tablet
  • 30.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings • aggressive expansion and acquisition of the companies specializing on supplemental products (networks, cables, communications) allowed Nokia to create a market for its products • sticking to core values is likely to bring success in the long run • focus on highly performing company products and strengths proved to be beneficial for Nokia • successful utilization of emerging markets in global economy • R&D as well as innovation are the engine of any successful tech company rise of Nokia
  • 31.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings • slow decision are very costly in today’s dynamic world • “vertical business model” is no longer an option on this market – leading industry players partner with Asian OEM/ODMs who benefit from enormous economies of scale • Nokia missed the key shift in the industry – the role of software and consumer devices ecosystem • tensions within company management eliminate the most valuable resources – time & money. Nokia has lost focus • brand value is highly fluctuating dimension, especially in the 21st century • North-American CEO didn’t fully understand European and Asian phone markets and their perception of Nokia fall of Nokia
  • 32.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings flashback
  • 33.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings
  • 34.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings Thank You
  • 35.
    history&company overview case synopsis key issues industryoverview competition Porter’s 5 forces PEST analysis SWOT lookback alternatives alternative scenarios recommendations risks mitigation suggestions 2016 key learnings • http://company.nokia.com/en/our-businesses/nokia-technologies/hello-again • http://company.nokia.com/en/news/press-releases/2016/05/18/nokia-signs-strategic-brand-and-intellectual-property-licensing-agreement- enabling-hmd-global-to-create-new-generation-of-nokia-branded-mobile-phones-and-tablets • http://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2015/06/19/nokia-android-smartphone-2016-confirmed/#35be307d3d13 • http://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2014/04/21/three-vital-signs-of-life-and-death-to-watch-for-as-microsofts-7-5-billion-purchase-of- nokia-is-finalized/#790e133e30a7 • https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Nokia-fail-to-compete-with-Samsung-Apple-etc-despite-being-the-giant-of-the-mobile-phone-industry • http://www.rankingthebrands.com/Brand-detail.aspx?brandID=11 • http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-10-03/the-most-valuable-brands-in-america-2000-to-2013 • http://www.cio.com/article/2849223/nokias-n1-android-tablet-is-actually-a-foxconn-tablet.html • ttp://nokiamuseum.info/category/launching-year/1987/ • http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/nokia-1011-20-years-old-history-mobile-403478 • https://www.amazon.co.uk/Nokia-2100-Grey-SIM-Free/dp/B00009XLN8 • http://company.nokia.com/en/news/media-library/image-gallery/item/nokia-8110-gsm-handportable-1996 • https://www.iretron.com/Cell-Phones/Nokia/Nokia-6160;3332 • https://uk.webuy.com/phones/product.php?mastersku=SNOK7110#.V-hl9skpftQ • http://www.cnet.com/pictures/nokia-a-long-and-innovative-history-photos/11 • http://www.cellphones.ca/cell-phones/nokia-1616/ • http://latest_mobile_reviews.mobighar.com/nokia_phone_reviews_and_specifications/nokia_7280_old_mobile_phone_full_review_specific ations.html • http://www.refurb-phone.com/product/nokia-phone/nokia-8800-mobile-phone/ • http://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_6555-2071.php • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_E90_Communicator • http://nokiamuseum.info/nokia-801t/ • https://www.sarchecker.com/smartphone/nokia-lumia-1020/ • http://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_7280-884.php • https://www.aliexpress.com/price/nokia-7280_price.html • http://company.nokia.com/en/about-us/our-company/our-structure • http://mynokiablog.com/2014/04/29/nokias-new-ceo-rajeev-suri-effective-may-1st/ • http://www.huffingtonpost.com/william-morrow/7-proven-ways-to-accelera_b_10042372.html • https://www.citelighter.com/technology/technology/knowledgecards/technology • http://www.mobolize.com/can-mobile-networks-keep-up-with-demand/ • https://itunews.itu.int/En/4958-Mobile-broadband-smartphones-apps-fixed-networks.note.aspx • http://www.optimisationv.com/category/google-analytics • https://www.sdxcentral.com/articles/news/nokias-post-merger-plan-bodes-well-for-nuage-networks-so-far/2015/10/ • http://www.informationweek.com/it-life/nokia-ozo-virtual-reality-camera-aimed-at-film-pros/d/d-id/1321521 • http://en.uaezoom.com/chief-financial-officer-cfo-salary-in-the-uae/ • http://www.cco-exchange.com/ • https://www.linkedin.com/topic/value-innovation • http://www.rc-hr.com/contactus.aspx • http://www.business2community.com/content-marketing/5-key-elements-successful-content-marketing-strategy-0947654 • http://bushmarketing.ca/what-is-the-marketing-funnel/ • http://v-a-l-s.org/ • http://company.nokia.com/en • https://ycharts.com/companies/NOK/market_cap web sources