The document discusses the tension between militarism and artistry in German intellectual history from 1815-1930. It explores the influence of romanticism, nationalism, liberalism, and volkisch ideology on German thought during this period and examines how these philosophies related to militarism on one side and expressionist anti-war art on the other. It also provides historical context on figures and movements that grappled with this dichotomy such as Friedrich, Wagner, Langbehn and the Wandervogel youth movement.
5. Militarism vs the Artist’s Way
• Romanticism • Expressionism
• Nationalism • Anti-war art
• Liberalism • Kino
• Völkisch Ideology • Neue Sachlichkeit
• Racism
• Jugendbewegung
27. Romanticism
tended toward the irrational & emotional
rationalism had been discredited, 1789-94
“the heart, not the head”
28. Romanticism
tended toward the irrational & emotional
rationalism had been discredited, 1789-94
“the heart, not the head”
pantheism, search for roots in nature
29. Romanticism
tended toward the irrational & emotional
rationalism had been discredited, 1789-94
“the heart, not the head”
pantheism, search for roots in nature
mysticism
31. Friedrich Schlegel
(1772-1829)
• poet, philologist, historian
• search for the Ursprache
• Über die Sprache u. Weisheit der
Indier (1808) “...beauty,
antiquity & philosophical
clarity of Sanscrit”
• “...a new masterful race....”
• by 1819--the Aryan myth
35. Frankenstein; or the
Modern Prometheus
(1818)
written by Mary Shelley, age 19
a warning against the “over-
reaching” of modern man in the
Industrial Revolution
40. Johann Gottlieb Fichte
(1762-1814)
idealist philosopher
“bridge” between Kant & Hegel
“father of German nationalism”
Addresses to the German Nation,
1807-1808
anti-Semite
41. 19th c. Multinational States
Russia--Poles, Ukrainians, Balts, Germans, Georgians &c
Habsburg Empire--Magyars, Czechs, Poles, South Slavs &c
Britain--Irish, Scots, Welsh, colonial subjects &c
44. Ancient Germans Rediscovered
von Ranke & the modern
discipline of history wie es
eigentlich gewesen
Kleist’s Hermannsschlacht,
(1808)
Felix Dahn, Kampf um Rom,
1867
runes, solar occultism, Norse
deities -- revived public
interest
56. Niebelungenlied
the German Iliad ?
Wagner’s Ring Cycle
Fritz Lang silent film
Sci Fi Channel, 2004
http://omacl.org/
Nibelungenlied/
adventure2.html
57. Guido von List (1848-1919)
Viennese journalist, alpinist,
rower, novelist
occultist, mystic & volkish
Pan German
Runic Revivalism,
millinarianism & Runosophy
58. Runic Circle of the Armanen Futharkh
a cataract operation in 1902
11 months of temp blindness
a vision revealing The Secret of
the Runes (1908)
G. v List Society
“Tarnhari” (crook & swindler)
publishes Swastika Letter,Leipzig
59. Tarnhari (Ernst Lauterer)
letter to List, 1911
posed as reincarnated
chieftain of prehistoric tribe
confirms List’s speculations
established publishing
houses
ties to Dietrich Eckart,
Hitler’s mentor
60. Jörg Lanz von Liebenfels
(1874-1954)
middle class Viennese
Cistercian, 1893-99
theozoologist, anti-Semite,
occultist, new Templar
Ostara, 1905
claimed to be a precursor
of Nazi ideology
61. ... the widespread interest among certain sections of
German and Austrian society for all manners of
health cures, revelations, reassurances, and
techniques of self-realization in troubled times.
62. ... the widespread interest among certain sections of
German and Austrian society for all manners of
health cures, revelations, reassurances, and
techniques of self-realization in troubled times.
Nicholas Goodrick-Clark
63. Want more on this topic?
a source I found after the
reading list went to press
originally published in 1985
scholarly, not a Nazi
exploitation book
Publ library has 2 copies
75. Völkisch Ideology
“Chap 1. From Romanticism to the Volk” -- Mosse
Industrial Revolution > alienation (Entseelung)
76. Völkisch Ideology
“Chap 1. From Romanticism to the Volk” -- Mosse
Industrial Revolution > alienation (Entseelung)
search for “rootedness” in Nature
77. Völkisch Ideology
“Chap 1. From Romanticism to the Volk” -- Mosse
Industrial Revolution > alienation (Entseelung)
search for “rootedness” in Nature
Volkskunde or Cultural Anthropology
78. Wilhelm Heinrich Riehl (1823-97)
journalist, novelist, folklorist
Land und Leute (Land & People)
v. 1 of 4(1854)
“modernity is nature contrived by
man and thus devoid of that
genuiness to which living nature
alone gives meaning.”
the Jew’s Volk was without
territory, i.e. “rootless”
79. Theodor Fontane (1819-1898)
novelist & poet
many works of historical
fiction
Wanderungen durch die
Mark Brandenburg
(1862-1882, 5 vols.)
“required reading for the
Jugendbewegung” --
Mosse
80. Hermann Löns (1866-28 Sept 1914)
originator of the Heimat
novel
The Wehrwolf (1910)
“accepted the rapine &
pillage of Thirty Years War
as ‘normal’ “ --Mosse
81. Paul Anton de Lagarde (1827-1891)
scripture scholar, orientalist
taught at a Berlin Gymnasium
founder, völkische Bewegung
virulent anti-Semite
Deutsche Schriften (1878-81)
85. Lagarde’s Spiritual Ideas
“Germanism lies not within the blood but in the character”
quest for a German faith to replace materialism
Christianity has become stifled by laws, traditions, & practices
86. Lagarde’s Spiritual Ideas
“Germanism lies not within the blood but in the character”
quest for a German faith to replace materialism
Christianity has become stifled by laws, traditions, & practices
search for “original Christianity”
87. Lagarde’s Spiritual Ideas
“Germanism lies not within the blood but in the character”
quest for a German faith to replace materialism
Christianity has become stifled by laws, traditions, & practices
search for “original Christianity”
apostles were Christ’s Volk, the Kingdom of God
88. Lagarde’s Spiritual Ideas
“Germanism lies not within the blood but in the character”
quest for a German faith to replace materialism
Christianity has become stifled by laws, traditions, & practices
search for “original Christianity”
apostles were Christ’s Volk, the Kingdom of God
nostalgia for the Middle Ages
90. Julius Langbehn (1851-1907)
vol, age 19, Franco-
War, 2nd Lt in reserve
sought PhD art history
theosophist, mystic,
Swedenborgian
Rembrandt as Educator,
1890
convinced anti-Semite
91. Racism
notions of ethnic superiority are quite old
18th century classification of peoples
scientific racism emerged in the 19th century
Gobineau’s Inequality of the Human Races (1853)
Galton’s Hereditary Genius (1870)
92. Aristotle’s Politics, 4th c BCE
“Some from the hour of their birth are destined
to be masters; others, slaves.” Politics, bk i
natural masters--”those who possess reason to a
high degree” = most Greeks
natural slaves--”those who can apprehend reason,
but cannot originate it” =most barbarians, i.e.
non-Greeks
93. Carolus Linnaeus [Karl Linne](1707-78)
father of modern taxonomy
subcategories of homo sapiens--Americanus, Asiaticus,
Africanus, & Europeanus
unilinealism or polygenesis?
94. Craniometry and Physical Anthropology
Phrenology was a pseudo science
attempting to describe human
character by the shape of the
skull
It ushered in a host of bogus
theories such as racial
intelligence from cranial capacity
(Morton)
Nott's and Gliddon's Indigenous races of
the earth (1857) used misleading
imagery to suggest that quot;Negroesquot;
ranked between whites and
chimpanzees.
95.
96. Charles Darwin (1809-1882)
Origin of Species (1859) --no
mention of man
Descent of Man (1871) --not a
racist viewpoint
but popularizers create:
Social Darwinism
97. Social Darwinism
“evolution” + “natural
selection” > “survival of the
fittest”--Herbert Spencer
(1864)
Francis Galton > “eugenics”
98. Jugendbewegung
There were many German
youth organizations but most
famous were the
Wandervögeln. Begun as a
hiking club at the end of the
19th century, they grew to
tens of thousands before the
war, hundreds of thousands
after it.
99. Hugo Höppener, Fidus (1868-1948)
• favorite artist of the
Wandervögeln
• subscribed to the beliefs:
romanticism, revolt
against modernity, “back
to nature” vegetarianism,
nudism, sun worship,
theosophy, idealized
peasant life
100. Early Works
1900
Wandervögels Abschied (Farewell) (Vegetarian Restaurant)
101. In search of Volkstum
Pictured here with his
Munich Art Academy
professor in 1887. He
gave him the name,
Fidus, for serving a
brief jail term for
nudity. Both were
Naturmenschen.
102. Lichtgebet (Light Prayer) 1913
His most famous work was displayed on
adolescent walls before World War I, just
as Raven or Johnny Depp might be today.
The youthful Nordic sun worshiper forms
the “life rune” (Y) with his arms.
106. Otto
Dix
eager volunteer in 1914
fought in the Somme, 1916
seriously wounded several times
Iron Cross (EK) 2nd class
“Self Portrait as Target” 1915
suffered recurring nightmares
113. Peter Gay, Weimar Culture; the Outsider as
Insider. (1968)
• Weimar style predates the Weimar Republic
• cosmopolitan, Futurist
• Dada born during the war in Zurich
• post-war Paris
• finally, Berlin
114. • “most insistent question revolved around the need for man’s
renewal”
• “most urgent and practically insoluble by:
1. disappearance of God
2. threat of the machine”
3. the incurable stupidity of the upper classes
4. & the helpless philistinism of the bourgeoisie
from the introduction, pp 5-7
115. play > opera >
film > DVD
•Georg Büchner, 1837
•Alban Berg, 1925 “Wozzek”
•Werner Herzog, 1979
128. “The Good Soldier Schweik”
A sort of Catch 22 set in the Austrian
army during WW I. Hasek was him-
self a Czech veteran. The story has
become a classic anti-war, anti-
authority fable.
130. Hintergrund (Backdrop)
Piscator’s adaptation of “Schweik”
called for a painted cloth backdrop
which was rolled behind the players
Grosz was chosen to execute it
this climactic panel caused an
uproar
the caption read “Shut your trap
and soldier on!!”
Grosz was tried for blasphemy
141. Kino
new at the end of the 19th century
rapid pre-war growth
German film industry nationalized for the war
German cinema became a world leader in the
“golden ‘20s”
144. Dr. Mabuse the Gambler
(1922)
evil genius, hypnotist, master
of disguises
metaphor for the stock
market “swindlers”
145. Die Nibelungen
(1922-24)
Lang, no Wagnerian, reverts to
the original text. Technically
innovative, drenched in volkish
romantic nationalism, Hitler &
Goebbels loved it!
147. Siegfried Kracauer scorned this
film by Fritz Lang. Too superficial
treatment of class issues for his
Social Democrat ideology.
But the masses loved it!
UFA Babelsberg Studios
Reichsmark 7 million
1927
150. The Blue Angel (1930)
first major German sound
film
launched Marlene Dietrich
international success
banned by Nazis after 1933
151. M
(1931)
Lang’s first sound film. Peter
Lorre as the child murderer is
burdened by his success. There is
a “league of beggars” like
Brecht’s contemporaneous“Three
Penny Opera”
152.
153.
154. The Testament of Dr.
Mabuse (1933)
• Lang’s 2nd sound film
• Most popular of 3 Mabuse film
series
• Nazis felt Mabuse’s gang was a
metaphor for them!
•Lang emigrates to Hollywood
157. George Grosz
“Republican Automatons”
(1920)
“Their vehement form of
realism distorted appearances
to emphasize the ugly, as
ugliness was the reality these
artists wished to expose.”
161. “Pillars of Society” (1926)
• the officer
• the Lutheran minister
• the industrialist
162. “Pillars of Society” (1926)
• the officer
• the Lutheran minister
• the industrialist
• the journalist
163. “Pillars of Society” (1926)
• the officer
• the Lutheran minister
• the industrialist
• the journalist
• the university Nazi
164. “Pillars of Society” (1926)
• the officer
• the Lutheran minister
• the industrialist
• the journalist
• the university Nazi
all ignoring the building
burning down behind them
170. And now the stage is set for a
rejected artist who had become
a soldier and at the age of 31
discovered a new medium of
expression.
Editor's Notes
Der Deutscher hat zwei seele--Heine
under the Prussian Chancellor, Otto v Bismarck. Dennis Showalter argues that militarism really only took hold after this exhilarating series of events.
However, ever since the father of Frederick the Great, Frederick Wm I, the “Soldier King,” the Prussian Army has been called the school of the nation
Regarded as the greatest general of the 18th century, Fredr the Great, victor of Rossbach & Leuthen, fulfilled his father’s hopes for him.
Prussian militarism came to be a cliche.
• romanticized in the 1920s in a series of silent films
• painting by Anton Graf, the king aged 68, in 1780.
•
. When Wilhelm II became Kaiser in 1888, he felt tremendous pressure to uphold the family and national tradition. His tutor insisted he become a skilled equestrian in spite of his handicap, so that he could lead on the battlefield.
• his campaign to have people call him “Wilhelm the Great” failed
• Kyffhäuser Denkmal on the mountain in where Barbarossa supposedly sleeps
• a current website photo encouraging tourism
• note the date stamp! People still flock there & put up websites extolling it
• one last loving look! ;-)
On the other hand, German
Kultur
had long maintained that the German
Volk
were a race of
Dichter und Denker
, poets and philosophers. So there was an inherent tension between this ethos of artist and that of the soldier.
•
True enough, there is a branch of the warrior class, the Special Operator, which is creative and individualistic, producing “artists” in the art of war. But in the 18
th
and 19
th
century the connotation of “soldier” was entirely antithetical to this notion. Prussian militarism demanded “blind obedience.”
•
So from the pinnacle of success, the Franco-Prussian War, that led to the German Reich, the stage was set for conflict between the two souls which Heinrich Heine had described.
• an artistic and literary movement beginning in the late 19th c. Fr Rev -->Terror
• anti-IR with its “dark Satanic mills”--Wordsworth
Coalbrookdale by Night
was painted by
Philip James de Loutherbourg
in
1801
. It depicts the Madeley Wood (or Bedlam) Furnaces, which belonged to the
Coalbrookdale
Company from 1776 to 1796. The picture has come to symbolize the birth of the
Industrial Revolution
in
Ironbridge
,
England
. It is held in the collections of the
Science Museum
in
London
.
• musical revolution
• anti-Semite
The
Rütlischwur
is a legendary
oath
of the
Old Swiss Confederacy
• COMPARE TO DAVID’S painting, OATH OF THE HORATII
The oath is notably featured in the
Wilhelm Tell drama
of 1804 by
Friedrich Schiller
.
This story about the oath on the
Rütli
, a meadow above
Lake Lucerne
near
Seelisberg
, is first mentioned in the
White Book of
Sarnen
(
1470
). Its canonical form is that of the 16th century
Chronicon Helveticum
of
Aegidius Tschudi
. According to Tschudi, the three oath-takers (
Eidgenossen
) were
Werner Stauffacher
for
Schwyz
,
Walter Fürst
for
Uri
and Arnold of Melchtal for
Unterwalden
. Tschudi dates the event to 8 November,
1307
. Its historicity is uncorrobated,
• Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus is an 1818 novel written by Mary Shelley at the age of 19, first published anonymously in London, but more often known by the revised third edition of 1831 under her own name. It is a novel infused with some elements of the Gothic novel and the Romantic movement. It was also a warning against the \"over-reaching\" of modern man and the Industrial Revolution, alluded to in the novel's subtitle, The Modern Prometheus.
Romantic nationalism
(also
National Romanticism
,
organic nationalism
,
identity nationalism
) is the form of
nationalism
in which the state derives its political legitimacy as an organic consequence of the unity of those it governs. This includes, depending on the particular manner of practice, the
language
,
race
,
culture
,
religion
and
customs
of the \"
nation
\" in its primal sense of those who were \"born\" within its culture. This form of nationalism arose in reaction to dynastic or imperial
hegemony
, which assessed the legitimacy of the state from the \"top down\", emanating from a monarch or other authority, which justified its existence. Such downward-radiating power might ultimately derive from a god or gods
• Ossian, Beowulf, Sir Walter Scott,
•
\"The Bard\" by
John Martin
: a romantic vision of a single Welsh bard escaping a massacre ordered by
Edward I of England
, intended to destroy Welsh culture
• expel all jews from Ger. citizens only if one managed “to cut off all their heads in one night, and to set new ones on their shoulders, which should contain not a single Jewish idea”
• In 1839, construction was started on a massive statue of Arminius, known as the \"Hermannsdenkmal\", on a hill near Detmold in the Teutoburg Forest; it was completed and dedicated during the early years of the Second German Empire in the wake of the German victory over France in the Franco-Prussian War of 1870–1871. The monument has been a major tourist attraction ever since,
•
Arminius
(also
Armin
,
18 BC
/
17 BC
-
21
AD) was a chieftain of the
Cherusci
who defeated a
Roman army
in the
Battle of the Teutoburg Forest
. His tribal coalition against the
Roman Empire
successfully blocked the efforts of
Germanicus
, nephew of Emperor
Tiberius
, to reconquer the Germanic territories east of the Rhine, although there is debate among historians about the outcome of several inconclusive battles (
Tacitus
, Annals 2.22,
Suetonius
, Caligula 1.4). And although Arminius was ultimately unsuccessful in forging unity among the
Germanic tribes
, his upset victory had a far-reaching effect on the subsequent history of both the ancient Germanic tribes, of the Roman Empire, and ultimately, of Europe.
• 1st Google website for Hermannsdenkmal
• Ernst v Bandel--Fr indemnity helped fund the completion!
• from the German Wiki site
• Nineteenth century philologist Karl Lachmann, Der Nibelunge Noth und die Klage nach der ältesten Überlieferung mit Bezeichnung des Unechten und mit den Abweichungen der gemeinen Lesart (Berlin: Reimer, 1826).
• (Viennese) poet, journalist, writer, businessman and dealer of leather goods, mountaineer, hiker, dramatist, playwright, and rower, but was most notable as an occultist and völkisch author who is seen as one of the most important figures in Germanic revivalism, Germanic mysticism, Runic Revivalism and Runosophy
• The row of 18 so-called \"Armanen runes\", also known as the \"Armanen futharkh\" came to List while in an 11 month state of temporary blindness after a cataract operation on both eyes in 1902. This vision in 1902 allegedly opened what List referred to as his \"inner eye\", via which he claimed the \"Secret of the Runes\" was revealed to him.
• Tarnhari =the concealed lord. During WW I a follower urged him to reveal himself during Ger’s hour of need
• note the Jerusalem Cross on his surplice
• claimed Sicilian birth 2 yrs early of noble parentage--fact Adolf Jos Lanz, son of Johann, suburban Viennese schoolteacher.
• The Occult Roots of Nazism, p.174
This famous painting by Delacrois, “Liberty Leading the People” (28 July 30), commemorated the recent ascendence of Louis Phillippe.
In the 19th century conservatism, personified by Prince Metternich meant opposition to the middle class reformers who wanted to limit the power of monarchs. 19th c.liberalism wanted less democracy than Republicans and certainly were not socialists! Their class interest was bourgeois, i.e., capitalist.
• alienation. Ger “Entseelung” cf Mx “Entseelung des Arbeit”
• pantheism, glorification of natural vs man-made, “Naturmenschen” nudism & hippies
• Ger penchant to theorize, academicise-->speculation
Geography determines the character of a Volk. cf. Lyell & birth of Geology
• “Berlin is the domain of the Jews”
• cities are the “Graben des Deutschtum”
• Fontane became particularly interested in the Mark Brandenburg region. He was especially proud of its past achievements and delighted in the growth of its capital city, Berlin. His fascination with the countryside surrounding Berlin may be seen in his delightfully picturesque Wanderungen durch die Mark Brandenburg (1862-1882, 5 vols.) in which he successfully transposed his former fascination with British historical matters to his native soil.
• Inspired by pre- and post-Christian folklore and history, his most famous novel is Der Wehrwolf (The Warwolf - 1910), an alternately heart-warming and heart-rending chronicle of a North German farming community suffering tragedies and ultimate triumph during the harrowing period of the Thirty Years' War (1618-1648).
At the age of 48 he volunteered for service in the German Army in the
First World War
, and was shot dead during a patrol at
Loivre
in France just three weeks after joining the army. As in some of his writings he showed nationalistic ideas he was later considered by the Nazis as one of their writers - despite the fact that Löns' life style didn't match the Nazi ideals. On request of
Adolf Hitler
Löns was exhumed and reburied in the Lüneburg Heath near the city
Walsrode
.
• a German biblical scholar and orientalist. He also took some part in politics. He belonged to the Prussian Conservative party, and was a violent antisemite. The bitterness which he felt appeared in his writings. His Deutsche Schriften (1878-81) became a nationalist text.
• the Liberals were “their firmest champions”
• e.g. Mx family, Reform movement, c.f.,Cinti & Wise
• rel kept Jews separate, esp after “failure of ‘48”
• PdL “unfamiliar w/ latest devs in [racial] science”
• Eugen Diederichs (coiner of New Romanticism) publicist of PdL “the finest”
• 27 yrs jr to PdL, corresponded, admired, like him academic “gypsy”