HAPPY MOO HAPPY YOU!
CASE ANALYSIS:
NATUREVIEW FARM
• Founded and manufactured in Cabot, Vermont
• Plain vanilla flavor of 8-oz and 32-oz packaging initially
• Less than $100,000 revenue earned
• Revenue of the company grew from $100,000 to $13 million
• FRUIT AT THE BOTTOM developed in productive size of 8-oz
• Introduced various flavours in different sizes
• Multipack yogurt products for children
1989
1999
2000
The FOUR P’s
• PRODUCT
• PRICE
• PLACE
• PROMOTION
PRODUCT
• RECEPIE USED ARE NATURAL INGREDIENTS
• AVERAGE SHELF LIFE OF NATUREVIEW FARM’S YOGURT IS 50 DAYS
• SPEICAL PROCESS GAVE YOGURT A SMOOTH TEXTURE
• USED MILK FROM COW UNTREATED WITH ARTIFICIAL GROWTH
HORMONE
PRICE
NATURAL FOOD
CHANNELS
MANUFACTUR
ING COST
AVERAGE RETAIL
PRICE
TOTAL COST
8-oz CUP $0.31 $0.88 $1.19
32-oz CUP $0.99 $3.19 $4.18
4-oz CUP MULTIPACK $1.15 $3.35 $4.50
SUPERMARKET
CHANNEL
MANUFACTU
RING COST
AVERAGE RETAIL
PRICE
TOTAL COST
8-oz CUP $0.31 $0.74 $1.05
32-oz CUP $0.99 $2.70 $3.69
4-oz CUP MULTIPACK $1.15 $2.85 $4.00
A f f o r d a b l e A c c o r d i n g T o I t ’ s C h a n n e l
PLACE
SUPERMARKET
CHANNELS
MARGIN
MANUFACTURER -
DISTRIBUTOR 15%
RETAILER 27%
CONSUMER -
NATURAL FOOD CHANNELS MARGIN
MANUFACTURER -
NATURAL FOOD WHOLESALER 7%
NATURAL FOOD DISTRIBUTOR 9%
RETAILER 35%
CONSUMER -
PLACE
PROMOTION
• It’s natural flavor with high quality and great taste growth in the national distribution and
natural food channels
• Low cost guerilla marketing
MANUFACTURER
NATURAL FOOD WHOLESALER
NATURAL FOOD DISTRIBUTOR
RETAILER
CONSUMER
NATURAL FOOD CHANNEL
Typical natural food wholesaler margin was 7%,distributor margin was 9%,and retailer margin
was 35%
SUPERMARKET CHANNEL
MANUFACTURER
DISTRIBUTOR
RETAILER
CUSTOMER
A typical distributor margin in this channel was 15% and typical retailer margin was 27%.Hence with
respect to the natural food stores, prices tended to be lower here.
1
2 3
WITH MOST IMPORATANT OBJECTIVE BEING TO MEET THE DESIRED REVENUE
GENERATION, FOLLOWING MARKET SURVEY RESULTS ARE TO BE CONSIDERED:
SUPERMARKET SOLD 97% OF ALL THE YOGURT CONSUMED AND
NATURAL FOOD STORE SOLD THE BALANCE.
AMONG 100% OF THE U.S. POPULATION,
 ORAGNIC PRODUCT WAS CONSUMED BY 40 % OF THE POPULATION
 AMONG ORGANIC PRODUCT USERS,70% ARE YOGURT CONSUMERS
 SIXTY-SEVEN PERCENT OF U.S. HOUSEHOLDS INDICATED THAT PRICE WAS A
BARRIER TO THEIR PURCHASE OF ORGANIC PRODUCTS
 58% EXPRESSED THAT THEY WOULD BUY MORE ORGANIC PRODUCT IF THEY
WERE LESS EXPENSIVE.
 FORTY-SIX PERCENT OF ORGANIC FOOD CONSUMERS BOUGHT ORGANIC
PRODUCTS AT A SUPERMARKET, 25% AT A SMALL HEALTH FOODS STORE,
AND 29% AT A NATURAL FOODS SUPERMARKET
MARKET SURVEY
OPTION 1
(MOST STRONGLY ADVOCATED BY WALTER BELLINI,PRESIDENT OF SALES)
TO EXPAND 6 SKU’s OF THE 8-oz PRODUCT LINE INTO ONE OR
TWO SELECTED SUPERMARKET CHANNEL REGION
 Supermarket retailer would likely authorize only one organic product brand. The
first brand to enter the channel would have a significant advantage.
 8 ounce cup represented the largest dollar and unit share of refrigerated yogurt
market.
 Other natural food brand had successfully expanded their distribution into the
supermarket channel out of which two of them have increased revenue by over
200% within two years of entering supermarket.
OPTION 2
TO EXPAND 4 SKU’S OF THE 32-oz SIZE
NATIONALLY
 32-OZ CUPS CURRENTLY GENERATED AN ABOVE AVERAGE GROSS PROFIT
MARGIN FOR NATUREVIEW(43.6% VS 36% FOR 8-oz PRODUCT LINE)
 NATUREVIEW FARM HAD A STRONG COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE BECAUSE
OF THE PRODUCTS LONGER SHELF LIFE
 32-OZ. SIZE WAS PROMOTED ONLY TWICE A YEAR,HENCE LESSER PROMOTIONA
EXPENSES
(ADVOCATED BY JACK GOTTLIEB, VICE PRESIDENT OF OPERATIONS)
OPTION 3
TO INTRODUCE TWO SKUS OF A CHILDREN’S MULTI-PACK INTO THE NATURAL FOODS CHANNEL
 EXPANSION INTO THE SUPERMARKET CHANNEL COULD POTENTIALLY AFFECT STRONG RELATIONSHIPS WITH
THE LEADING NATURAL FOODS CHANNEL RETAILERS RELATIONSHIPS.
 NATUREVIEW FARM’S ALL-NATURAL INGREDIENTS WOULD PROVIDE THE PERFECT POSITIONING FROM WHICH
TO LAUNCH ITS OWN CHILDREN’S MULTI-PACK PRODUCT OFFERING INTO THEIR CORE SALES CHANNEL
 THE FINANCIAL POTENTIAL WAS VERY ATTRACTIVE. THE PROJECTED TOTAL YEARLY REVENUE FOR THE TWO
MULTIPACK SKUS WOULD BE APPROXIMATELY 10% OF THE NATURAL FOODS CHANNEL CATEGORY DOLLAR
SALES, AND THE ESTIMATED POTENTIAL INCREMENTAL UNIT VOLUME AT 1.8 MILLION.
 THE NATURAL FOODS CHANNEL WAS GROWING ALMOST SEVEN TIMES FASTER THAN THE SUPERMARKET
CHANNEL, AND NATUREVIEW WAS DEVELOPING SEVERAL NEW PRODUCTS THAT COULD FURTHER BOOST
SALES PERFORMANCE IN THIS HIGHLY SUCCESSFUL CHANNEL.
( advocated by Walker’s colleague Kelly Riley, the assistant marketing director)
CONSIDERING THE UNIT SALES AND HENCE FINDING THE REVENUE
PROJECTION, WE CAN SEE THAT REVENUE FOR THE OPTIONS ARE(YEAR
2001)
OPTION UNIT SALES
OPTION 1 42,000,000
OPTION 2 5,500,000
OPTION 3 2,070,000
REVENUE
44,080,000
27,850,000
19,934,500
NET PROFIT
27,247,200
21,397,600
17,130,637
OPTION 1 IS THE BEST OPTION!
 EASIER IMPLEMENTION AS IT’S A REGIONAL DISTRIBUTION
 WITH MORE COMPETITORS MOVING INTO THE SUPERMARKET,THIS RISK IS NECESSARY ELSE A HUGE
OPPORTUNITY MIGHT BE MISSED
 ITS LONG TERM ADVANTAGES ARE HIGH IF PROPERLY IMPLEMENTED AND SUCCESSFUL.
 EXPOSURE TO MORE RANGE OF CUSTOMERS
 IT EXCEEDS THE REVENUE OBJECTIVE
CREATED BY PUJYA PANDEY,JSS NOIDA
During a marketing internship under
Prof. SAMEER MATHUR,IIM LUCKNOW.

NATUREVIEW FARM

  • 1.
    HAPPY MOO HAPPYYOU! CASE ANALYSIS: NATUREVIEW FARM
  • 2.
    • Founded andmanufactured in Cabot, Vermont • Plain vanilla flavor of 8-oz and 32-oz packaging initially • Less than $100,000 revenue earned • Revenue of the company grew from $100,000 to $13 million • FRUIT AT THE BOTTOM developed in productive size of 8-oz • Introduced various flavours in different sizes • Multipack yogurt products for children 1989 1999 2000
  • 3.
    The FOUR P’s •PRODUCT • PRICE • PLACE • PROMOTION
  • 4.
    PRODUCT • RECEPIE USEDARE NATURAL INGREDIENTS • AVERAGE SHELF LIFE OF NATUREVIEW FARM’S YOGURT IS 50 DAYS • SPEICAL PROCESS GAVE YOGURT A SMOOTH TEXTURE • USED MILK FROM COW UNTREATED WITH ARTIFICIAL GROWTH HORMONE
  • 5.
    PRICE NATURAL FOOD CHANNELS MANUFACTUR ING COST AVERAGERETAIL PRICE TOTAL COST 8-oz CUP $0.31 $0.88 $1.19 32-oz CUP $0.99 $3.19 $4.18 4-oz CUP MULTIPACK $1.15 $3.35 $4.50 SUPERMARKET CHANNEL MANUFACTU RING COST AVERAGE RETAIL PRICE TOTAL COST 8-oz CUP $0.31 $0.74 $1.05 32-oz CUP $0.99 $2.70 $3.69 4-oz CUP MULTIPACK $1.15 $2.85 $4.00 A f f o r d a b l e A c c o r d i n g T o I t ’ s C h a n n e l
  • 6.
    PLACE SUPERMARKET CHANNELS MARGIN MANUFACTURER - DISTRIBUTOR 15% RETAILER27% CONSUMER - NATURAL FOOD CHANNELS MARGIN MANUFACTURER - NATURAL FOOD WHOLESALER 7% NATURAL FOOD DISTRIBUTOR 9% RETAILER 35% CONSUMER - PLACE
  • 7.
    PROMOTION • It’s naturalflavor with high quality and great taste growth in the national distribution and natural food channels • Low cost guerilla marketing
  • 8.
    MANUFACTURER NATURAL FOOD WHOLESALER NATURALFOOD DISTRIBUTOR RETAILER CONSUMER NATURAL FOOD CHANNEL Typical natural food wholesaler margin was 7%,distributor margin was 9%,and retailer margin was 35%
  • 9.
    SUPERMARKET CHANNEL MANUFACTURER DISTRIBUTOR RETAILER CUSTOMER A typicaldistributor margin in this channel was 15% and typical retailer margin was 27%.Hence with respect to the natural food stores, prices tended to be lower here.
  • 10.
  • 11.
    WITH MOST IMPORATANTOBJECTIVE BEING TO MEET THE DESIRED REVENUE GENERATION, FOLLOWING MARKET SURVEY RESULTS ARE TO BE CONSIDERED: SUPERMARKET SOLD 97% OF ALL THE YOGURT CONSUMED AND NATURAL FOOD STORE SOLD THE BALANCE. AMONG 100% OF THE U.S. POPULATION,  ORAGNIC PRODUCT WAS CONSUMED BY 40 % OF THE POPULATION  AMONG ORGANIC PRODUCT USERS,70% ARE YOGURT CONSUMERS  SIXTY-SEVEN PERCENT OF U.S. HOUSEHOLDS INDICATED THAT PRICE WAS A BARRIER TO THEIR PURCHASE OF ORGANIC PRODUCTS  58% EXPRESSED THAT THEY WOULD BUY MORE ORGANIC PRODUCT IF THEY WERE LESS EXPENSIVE.  FORTY-SIX PERCENT OF ORGANIC FOOD CONSUMERS BOUGHT ORGANIC PRODUCTS AT A SUPERMARKET, 25% AT A SMALL HEALTH FOODS STORE, AND 29% AT A NATURAL FOODS SUPERMARKET MARKET SURVEY
  • 12.
    OPTION 1 (MOST STRONGLYADVOCATED BY WALTER BELLINI,PRESIDENT OF SALES) TO EXPAND 6 SKU’s OF THE 8-oz PRODUCT LINE INTO ONE OR TWO SELECTED SUPERMARKET CHANNEL REGION  Supermarket retailer would likely authorize only one organic product brand. The first brand to enter the channel would have a significant advantage.  8 ounce cup represented the largest dollar and unit share of refrigerated yogurt market.  Other natural food brand had successfully expanded their distribution into the supermarket channel out of which two of them have increased revenue by over 200% within two years of entering supermarket.
  • 13.
    OPTION 2 TO EXPAND4 SKU’S OF THE 32-oz SIZE NATIONALLY  32-OZ CUPS CURRENTLY GENERATED AN ABOVE AVERAGE GROSS PROFIT MARGIN FOR NATUREVIEW(43.6% VS 36% FOR 8-oz PRODUCT LINE)  NATUREVIEW FARM HAD A STRONG COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE BECAUSE OF THE PRODUCTS LONGER SHELF LIFE  32-OZ. SIZE WAS PROMOTED ONLY TWICE A YEAR,HENCE LESSER PROMOTIONA EXPENSES (ADVOCATED BY JACK GOTTLIEB, VICE PRESIDENT OF OPERATIONS)
  • 14.
    OPTION 3 TO INTRODUCETWO SKUS OF A CHILDREN’S MULTI-PACK INTO THE NATURAL FOODS CHANNEL  EXPANSION INTO THE SUPERMARKET CHANNEL COULD POTENTIALLY AFFECT STRONG RELATIONSHIPS WITH THE LEADING NATURAL FOODS CHANNEL RETAILERS RELATIONSHIPS.  NATUREVIEW FARM’S ALL-NATURAL INGREDIENTS WOULD PROVIDE THE PERFECT POSITIONING FROM WHICH TO LAUNCH ITS OWN CHILDREN’S MULTI-PACK PRODUCT OFFERING INTO THEIR CORE SALES CHANNEL  THE FINANCIAL POTENTIAL WAS VERY ATTRACTIVE. THE PROJECTED TOTAL YEARLY REVENUE FOR THE TWO MULTIPACK SKUS WOULD BE APPROXIMATELY 10% OF THE NATURAL FOODS CHANNEL CATEGORY DOLLAR SALES, AND THE ESTIMATED POTENTIAL INCREMENTAL UNIT VOLUME AT 1.8 MILLION.  THE NATURAL FOODS CHANNEL WAS GROWING ALMOST SEVEN TIMES FASTER THAN THE SUPERMARKET CHANNEL, AND NATUREVIEW WAS DEVELOPING SEVERAL NEW PRODUCTS THAT COULD FURTHER BOOST SALES PERFORMANCE IN THIS HIGHLY SUCCESSFUL CHANNEL. ( advocated by Walker’s colleague Kelly Riley, the assistant marketing director)
  • 16.
    CONSIDERING THE UNITSALES AND HENCE FINDING THE REVENUE PROJECTION, WE CAN SEE THAT REVENUE FOR THE OPTIONS ARE(YEAR 2001) OPTION UNIT SALES OPTION 1 42,000,000 OPTION 2 5,500,000 OPTION 3 2,070,000 REVENUE 44,080,000 27,850,000 19,934,500 NET PROFIT 27,247,200 21,397,600 17,130,637
  • 17.
    OPTION 1 ISTHE BEST OPTION!  EASIER IMPLEMENTION AS IT’S A REGIONAL DISTRIBUTION  WITH MORE COMPETITORS MOVING INTO THE SUPERMARKET,THIS RISK IS NECESSARY ELSE A HUGE OPPORTUNITY MIGHT BE MISSED  ITS LONG TERM ADVANTAGES ARE HIGH IF PROPERLY IMPLEMENTED AND SUCCESSFUL.  EXPOSURE TO MORE RANGE OF CUSTOMERS  IT EXCEEDS THE REVENUE OBJECTIVE
  • 18.
    CREATED BY PUJYAPANDEY,JSS NOIDA During a marketing internship under Prof. SAMEER MATHUR,IIM LUCKNOW.