Nationalism is an infantile disease.  It is the measles of mankind.   Albert Einstein
Soviet Union foreign policy is a puzzle  inside a riddle wrapped in an enigma,  and the key is Russian nationalism. Winston Churchill
 
A private man, however successful in his own dealing, if his country perish is involved in her destruction; but if he be an unprosperous citizen of a prosperous city, he is much more likely to recover.  Seeing, then, that States can bear the misfortunes of individuals, but individuals cannot bear the misfortunes of States, let us all stand by our country.   Thucydides
Nationalism A2 Govt. and Politics Unit 5B 5 March 2009
Nation versus  state
A state is a sovereign, political power over a given territory (which may be multinational). A nation (a much more recent concept that that of the state) is a cultural entity, a collection of people with a shared sense of common heritage.
Nationalism
States
Nations
UK State Northern Irish nation Scottish nation English nation Welsh nation
Nation state
A Nation state is when the common cultural group equates with a sovereign political unit.
The methods of most nationalist groups include: Unification Secession Irredentism The replacement of a foreign leadership by an indigenous one.
Nationalism is often perceived as a single doctrine that can attach itself to almost any wider political ideology, such as liberalism, conservatism, fascism and even socialism. It is therefore one of the most flexible of all modern political tenets.
Liberal nationalism
 
What is Liberal nationalism? It regards nations in the same way as liberal theory regards individuals; they are moral entities deserving of freedom, autonomy and self-determination.
Self-determination
Internationalism
Our true nationality is mankind. H.G Wells
Liberal individualism verses nationalist collectivism
Liberal nationalism Peaceful Constitutional Progressive Reformist Seeking self-determination and popular sovereignty.
Liberalism  is ambivalent about nationalism
Elie Kedourie
Liberalism  is not compatible with expansionist nationalism
'national ideal'
Paradox
Conservative nationalism
What is Conservative nationalism? From the 19 th  century onwards, conservatives came to support nationalism because its emphasis on common culture, history and tradition corresponded well with conservative values.
 
 
The flag and monarchy
Old maids on bicycles and cricketers playing on the village green. John Major
Conservative nationalism Traditional Organic Static Emphasising cultural heritage, social stability and the primacy of the state over the individual.
Conservatism fears  cultural diversity
Germany  end of  19th century
Conservative nationalism
Chauvinist nationalism
 
What is Chauvinist nationalism? It is expansionist, aggressive, militarist and  ethnocentric , justifying the nation’s right to impose its control and culture upon other ‘inferior’ nations and states through war and conquest.
 
Age  of  Empire
 
'Jingoism'
Examples of chauvinist nationalism
All within the state, nothing outside the state, nothing against the state.   Benito Mussolini
Chauvinist nationalism Expansionist Militarist Aggressive Ethnocentric Sometimes tending to racism Main example is fascism.
Integral nationalism
Pan-Slavism
 
Fascism
Anti-colonial nationalism
 
What is anti-colonial nationalism? It is found mainly in less economically developed countries seeking freedom from capitalist, imperial rule and economic modernisation.
Communism and Nationalism
Examples of anti-colonial nationalism
Anti-colonial nationalism Anti-imperialist Usually in less developed countries Often revolutionary and socialist in character Seeking economic modernisation Maybe peaceful or violent.
Religious Fundamentalism
Nationalism – progressive or reactionary? Liberal and anti-colonial nationalisms are seen as broadly progressive, rational, liberating and reformist or revolutionary. Conservative and chauvinist nationalisms are seen broadly  as static, reactionary, irrational, illiberal or oppressive. Chauvinist nationalism, especially, is seen as inherently expansionist, violent and destructive. All forms may exhibit negative traits to some degrees.
Political  and Cultural Nationalism
What is Political nationalism? It is defined by the principle of self-determination, whether it is expressed by the desire for some measure of autonomy, in the form of devolution or federalism, or in the fully developed form of sovereign statehood. This is the most common of the two kinds of nationalism. It may be liberal, Communist, chauvinist, expansionist or anti-colonial.
 
What is Cultural nationalism? It is associated with the defence of a nation’s cultural heritage, without any strong desire for political autonomy  It places primary emphasis on the regeneration of the nation as a distinctive civilisation, rather than as a discrete political community.  It often leans to conservatism. Cultural nationalism may also seek to defend or strengthen a national religion. Cultural nationalism may sometimes develop into political nationalism.
Overview of nationalism National identity has at least 3 dimensions: cultural, political and psychological. The concept of nationalism originated in late 18 th  century Europe, with the French Revolution and industrialisation. Cultural nationalism differs from political nationalism. Many writers regard nations as ‘invented traditions’ or ‘imagined communities’. Many states, such as the UK and the USA, are multinational or multicultural. Nationalism may or may not overlap with racism.
'chameleon ideology'
 

Nationalism overview - Unit 5B Other Ideological Traditions

  • 1.
    Nationalism is aninfantile disease. It is the measles of mankind. Albert Einstein
  • 2.
    Soviet Union foreignpolicy is a puzzle inside a riddle wrapped in an enigma, and the key is Russian nationalism. Winston Churchill
  • 3.
  • 4.
    A private man,however successful in his own dealing, if his country perish is involved in her destruction; but if he be an unprosperous citizen of a prosperous city, he is much more likely to recover.  Seeing, then, that States can bear the misfortunes of individuals, but individuals cannot bear the misfortunes of States, let us all stand by our country.  Thucydides
  • 5.
    Nationalism A2 Govt.and Politics Unit 5B 5 March 2009
  • 6.
  • 7.
    A state isa sovereign, political power over a given territory (which may be multinational). A nation (a much more recent concept that that of the state) is a cultural entity, a collection of people with a shared sense of common heritage.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
    UK State NorthernIrish nation Scottish nation English nation Welsh nation
  • 12.
  • 13.
    A Nation stateis when the common cultural group equates with a sovereign political unit.
  • 14.
    The methods ofmost nationalist groups include: Unification Secession Irredentism The replacement of a foreign leadership by an indigenous one.
  • 15.
    Nationalism is oftenperceived as a single doctrine that can attach itself to almost any wider political ideology, such as liberalism, conservatism, fascism and even socialism. It is therefore one of the most flexible of all modern political tenets.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
    What is Liberalnationalism? It regards nations in the same way as liberal theory regards individuals; they are moral entities deserving of freedom, autonomy and self-determination.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Our true nationalityis mankind. H.G Wells
  • 22.
    Liberal individualism versesnationalist collectivism
  • 23.
    Liberal nationalism PeacefulConstitutional Progressive Reformist Seeking self-determination and popular sovereignty.
  • 24.
    Liberalism isambivalent about nationalism
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Liberalism isnot compatible with expansionist nationalism
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
    What is Conservativenationalism? From the 19 th century onwards, conservatives came to support nationalism because its emphasis on common culture, history and tradition corresponded well with conservative values.
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
    The flag andmonarchy
  • 34.
    Old maids onbicycles and cricketers playing on the village green. John Major
  • 35.
    Conservative nationalism TraditionalOrganic Static Emphasising cultural heritage, social stability and the primacy of the state over the individual.
  • 36.
    Conservatism fears cultural diversity
  • 37.
    Germany endof 19th century
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
    What is Chauvinistnationalism? It is expansionist, aggressive, militarist and ethnocentric , justifying the nation’s right to impose its control and culture upon other ‘inferior’ nations and states through war and conquest.
  • 42.
  • 43.
    Age of Empire
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47.
    All within thestate, nothing outside the state, nothing against the state. Benito Mussolini
  • 48.
    Chauvinist nationalism ExpansionistMilitarist Aggressive Ethnocentric Sometimes tending to racism Main example is fascism.
  • 49.
  • 50.
  • 51.
  • 52.
  • 53.
  • 54.
  • 55.
    What is anti-colonialnationalism? It is found mainly in less economically developed countries seeking freedom from capitalist, imperial rule and economic modernisation.
  • 56.
  • 57.
  • 58.
    Anti-colonial nationalism Anti-imperialistUsually in less developed countries Often revolutionary and socialist in character Seeking economic modernisation Maybe peaceful or violent.
  • 59.
  • 60.
    Nationalism – progressiveor reactionary? Liberal and anti-colonial nationalisms are seen as broadly progressive, rational, liberating and reformist or revolutionary. Conservative and chauvinist nationalisms are seen broadly as static, reactionary, irrational, illiberal or oppressive. Chauvinist nationalism, especially, is seen as inherently expansionist, violent and destructive. All forms may exhibit negative traits to some degrees.
  • 61.
    Political andCultural Nationalism
  • 62.
    What is Politicalnationalism? It is defined by the principle of self-determination, whether it is expressed by the desire for some measure of autonomy, in the form of devolution or federalism, or in the fully developed form of sovereign statehood. This is the most common of the two kinds of nationalism. It may be liberal, Communist, chauvinist, expansionist or anti-colonial.
  • 63.
  • 64.
    What is Culturalnationalism? It is associated with the defence of a nation’s cultural heritage, without any strong desire for political autonomy It places primary emphasis on the regeneration of the nation as a distinctive civilisation, rather than as a discrete political community. It often leans to conservatism. Cultural nationalism may also seek to defend or strengthen a national religion. Cultural nationalism may sometimes develop into political nationalism.
  • 65.
    Overview of nationalismNational identity has at least 3 dimensions: cultural, political and psychological. The concept of nationalism originated in late 18 th century Europe, with the French Revolution and industrialisation. Cultural nationalism differs from political nationalism. Many writers regard nations as ‘invented traditions’ or ‘imagined communities’. Many states, such as the UK and the USA, are multinational or multicultural. Nationalism may or may not overlap with racism.
  • 66.
  • 67.