2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
Mainstreaming DRR into Development n Recovery: Experience sharing
1. Mainstreaming DRR into Development &
Recovery:
Experience sharing
BSDMA, Patna; 2 December 2015
Sudhir Kumar
DRR and Recovery Specialist
2. Chennai Foods Nov 2015
•246.5 mm rains in 24 hrs
•169 deaths
•Rs. 8481 cr. damage
--------------
Phailin Cyclone Oct 2013
•220 kms/hr wind speed
•44 deaths
•Rs. 8902 cr damage & loss
----------------
• 452.4 mm rain in Nov 1976
• 650 to 27 water bodies
• Phoenix mall sits on a
lake-bed in Velachery.
Orissa Super Cyclone of
1999 led to app.10,000
deaths
Source: DNA Source: CNN
Management improved
Risk remained
3.
4.
5.
6. Global discourse
Yokohama
Strategy 1994
UNISDR formed, 2000
Relief
Act
DRR through
CCA, 4AMCDRR,
2010 SFDRR
GAR (Report)
Regional Framework and National DM Acts
HFA 2005-15
1990 1999 2006 2011 2015
1st
World Climate Conf.
1979
IPCC formed, 1988
Rio Earth
Summit, 1992
GEF, UNFCC, 1994
4th
Assessment
Report, IPCC, 2007
SREX, IPCC, 2012
Kyoto Protocol, 1997
SDG
Adaptation Fund, 2007
7. Climate, Disaster and Development
Modified and Adapted from IPCC SREX, 2012
Geological
Hazards
8.
9. Mainstreaming
• Integration?
• Institutionalization?
• A ‘process’… to make
it a ‘normal process’
• Not an one off
exercise… but rather
continuous
• Not an end in itself…
rather a strategic
approach
9
Main stream
Side stream
10. Approach
Step 1
•Understand the elements of
development planning
Step 3
•By superimposing the DRR
and CCA framework on the
Development planning
framework identify
– Policy/Strategy
– Plan
– Projects
– Budgeting
– M&E
Step 2
•Understand the elements of DRR
and CCA framework
11. Development Planning Framework, Philippines
Budgeting
Project Implementation,
Monitoring and Evaluation
Project Evaluation &
Development
Vision
Investment Program
Planning Environment
Land Use & Physical Framework
Physical Resources/
Transport
Economic Activity
Population
Income &
Services
Development Issues, Goals,
Objectives/Targets
Strategies and PPAs
Source: NEDA, Philippines
12. Mainstreaming Framework, Philippines
Budgeting
Project Implementation,
Monitoring and Evaluation
Project Evaluation &
Development
Vision
Investment
Program
Planning Environment
Land Use & Physical Framework
Physical Resources/
Transport
Economic Activity
Population
Income &
Services
Development Issues, Goals,
Objectives/Targets
Strategies and PPAs
Risk Estimation
Risk Evaluation
Hazard Characterization/
Frequency Analysis
Consequence Analysis
Disaster Risk Assessment Development Planning
Source: NEDA, Philippines
15. Background
• One of the 20 most hazard-prone
countries in the world
• Entire country lies in a high earthquake
intensity belt and ranks 11th
in the world
in terms of vulnerability
• Highly prone to floods and
between1971-2008, more than 2500
floods cases reported
• Drought, Landslides, Epidemic, Fires,
etc
• Consistent warming and rise in the
Max temp of 0.04- 0.06C/ yr observed
Source : Oxfam , Nepal
17. Understand Risk: Hazard Assessment
• Earthquake ( 500 years, 250 years, 100
years & 50 years return Period)
• Floods (Inundation for 500 years, 100
years, 50 years, 25 years and 10 years
Return Period)
• Landslide (Precipitation and earthquake
induced landslides)
• Drought (Pre, during, post Monsoon and
Winter)
• Epidemics (Diseases and Outbreak)
18. Understand Risk: Climate Data Portal
• Analysis of climatological /
meteorological, geographical and
projection data
• Easy accessing historical station data,
• Projected future climate change
scenarios for:
Assessing impacts and
vulnerability in climate sensitive
sectors such as agriculture, water
resources, energy, health, etc.
19. DRR/CCA inclusion in Priority Ministry
• National Planning Commission
• Ministry of Home Affairs
• Ministry of Federal Affairs and Local Development
• Ministry of Urban Development
• Ministry of Irrigation
• Ministry of Forest and Soil Conservation
• Ministry of Science, Technology and Environment
• Ministry of Education
• 3 Pilot districts in 3 regions of Nepal
21. DRR in Local Development Planning
District
Development
Planning Steps
Activities under the
Planning Step
DRR/CCA Considerations
District
Development
Committee (Pre-
planning
workshop
• The DDC inform all key
district level stakeholders
about policies, objectives,
programmes, as well as
resources, activities of the
Sectoral ministries, and
the amount that can be
budgeted for each VDC.
• How to fill out project
request forms for the
settlement level is taught.
• Policy statement discussion
and dissemination should
include DRM/CRM issues
• The impact of recent disaster
on different sectors and
vulnerable groups in recent
past especially in the district
should be discussed
• Directives to VDC and
Municipalities to include
DRM/CRM considerations in
22. Capacity building
NASC: National Administrative Staff College ; LDTA: Local Development Training Academy; BTR&TC: Building Technology Research and
Training Center; CTE&VT: Council for Technical Education and Vocational Training; APFTC: Armed Police Force Training Center
23. Initial success
• LDTA adapted training into local context and
implementing
• Latrine design revised in a few districts under
reducing Open defecation program
• Box bridge design revised to allow unhindered
flow of water
25. Hazards in Myanmar
• Coastal regions are exposed to cyclones,
storm surges and tsunamis.
• Rainfall-induced flooding: A recurring
phenomenon across the country.
• Whole country at risk from earthquakes,
droughts and fires
• Hilly regions exposed to landslide risks
• Rainy days has reduced significantly in
last few decades
• In 2008, Cyclone Nargis led to death/
(missing) of more than 120,00 people
• Huge floods in mid-2015 in central
Myanmar
27. Key intervention: DRR/CCA Mainstreaming
• National Course on Mainstreaming
DRR/CCA steered by Planning Dept and
Relief and Resettlement Dept
• Included into existing planning training
programs
• DRR &CCA chapter/section in the 20-Year
Development Plan (draft)
• Risk consideration inclusion into provincial
Development Planning on pilot basis
• Capacity building on DRM &CRM inclusion
at sub-national levels (Townships)
28. Initial success
• Training course on Development Planning
includes session on DRR mainstreaming
• Selected schools in lower Myanmar raised
foundation to avoid floods
31. Background : Gujarat Earthquake 2001
….that too in the wake of two consecutive years of drought.
• One of the worst earthquakes in
the history of Gujarat
• Over 1 crore people affected
• 13,805 lives lost and 167,000
persons injured
• More than 10 lakh houses damaged
or destroyed
32. Steps involved in Housing Reconstruction
Damage Assessment
3-member team, 5 categories [G-1 to G-5]
Rubble Removal
Individual/Contractor ; Guideline for Debris Disposal
Temporary/Intermediate Shelter
Repair/Reconstruction of Houses Rubble Removal
Owner-driven/Public-private partnership
33. Housing Reconstruction
• Owner driven: led by owner
• PPP: Model for engagement of NGOs
• Multi-hazard reconstruction
• 20 model houses with seismic features
• Material assistance provided through Material
banks
• Insurance for 10 years
• Masons and Engineering training
• Masons Certification program
• Financial assistance in 3 installment to ensure
quality
• 3 party audit process
35. Success
• Considered to be a model recovery and
reconstruction program and was awarded UN
Sasakawa Award
• Masons certification program integrated into
development phase
36.
37. Take away
• Mainstreaming DRR is challenging and a
long-haul intervention
• DRR Agency is only a facilitator while
Planning, Finance, Public works, Education,
Heath, etc. to lead
• Convergence of DRR, CCA and Development
• Risk information of usable scale is important
• National/Sub-national training institutions
key for sustainability
• Demand driven DRR to complement supply-
driven DRR