Delivering Climate Compatible
  Development - Sam Bickersteth,CDKN




GWP Consulting Partners Meeting.
Stockholm August 2012
Climate Compatible Development

                                                           Climate compatible
                                                           development:
                                                           Development that minimises the
                                                           harm caused by climate impacts,
                                                           while maximising the many
                                                           human development
                                                           opportunities presented by a low
                                                           emissions, more resilient, future




Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                 2
What’s the problem and why is it difficult to
  solve?




         http://www.climateactiontracker.org/


Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org   3
Water and CCD




    Opportunities…
    and threats

Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org   4
IPCC SREX: implications for water sector

• A changing climate leads to changes in frequency, intensity, spatial extent
and duration of weather and climate events
• Extreme events such as floods and droughts will have a direct impact on
water resources now and in the future
•Frequency of heavy rainfall events likely to increase 4 fold and extreme hot
days 10 fold by end of century.
• Populations exposed to water-related hazards – e.g. flooding, coastal
inundation – are already significant and likely to increase
• Changes in the climate could seriously affect water management systems,
such as water storage and treatment plants, and supply systems
• Climate change adaptation and DRM likely to require transformational
changes in processes and institutions
• This will involve taking a more holistic approach – e.g. integrating water
management with urban planning and design, and into policies on land use


Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                        5
Slow onset economic transformation




Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org   6
Extreme events – global exposure to floods;
av. physical exposure in 1000 capita/year




Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org   7
Storage deficit or harnessed hydrology


             Country                                       Reservoir storage (m3/cap)

             Ethiopia                                      38

             India                                         262

             South Africa                                  687

             China                                         2486

             North America                                 5961


                                                                         Grey and Sadoff, 2006


Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                         8
How to structure a responce
                               Changes in institutions and institutional
                               capacity to respond to CCD needs and
                                              demands
                                                                           Changes in co-
                                                                           ordination,
    Changes in the
                                                                           collaboration and
understanding and
                                                                           mobilisation amongst
   commitment of
                                                                           key CCD
   decision makers
                                                                           stakeholders
around CCD issues

                                               Changes in the
                                                 quality of life
      Changes in                               for people most                Changes in the
quality relevance                               challenged by                 ability of decision
  and usability of                               the effects of               makers to leverage
 CCD evidence                                                                 and channel CCD
                                               climate change                 resources
             base
                                                                              strategically




 Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                           9
Integrating adaptation and DRM
approaches for a changing climate




Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org   10
What is needed to deliver CCD?
                     National                                                      International
Incentive and        •   Climate Change Act                                        • New post-Kyoto international targets
                     •   Independent Climate Change Commission                     • International cap and trade
Regulatory           •   Low carbon transmission plan or roadmap                   • International carbon tax
Framework            •   National cap and trade                                    • International standards for fuel efficiency
                     •   Carbon tax                                                  and emissions
                     •   Portfolio regulation of energy companies                  • Extend emissions targets to aviation and
                     •   Targeted tax incentives for private sector R&D              shipping
                     •   Regulate emissions from vehicles                          • Regulate trade (e.g. in forest products)
                     •   Regulate other emissions                                  • New international treaties on water
                     •   Strengthen forest law to reduce deforestation               sharing
                     •   Strengthen planning laws on housing design and location
                     •   Decoupling utility profits from gross sales

Public               •   Increase R&D budget                                       •   Fund N-S technology transfer
                     •   AMCs for renewable technologies                           •   Fund S-S cooperation
Expenditure          •   Subsidise retro-fitting of buildings                      •   Extend scope of CDM
                     •   Subsidise new technologies (e.g. CCS)                     •   Regional risk facilities
                     •   Subsidise renewables at domestic level
                     •   Provide subsidies to offset fuel poverty
                     •   Extend social protection for vulnerable groups
                     •   Invest in strengthening critical infrastructure
                     •   Invest in new infrastructure
                     •   Subsidise insurance mechanisms
                     •   Cut traditional fuel subsidies
                     •   Improved extension and entrepreneurial education
                     •   Education and consumer benchmarking

Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                                                           11
Water and CCD

Opportunities                                              Threats
• Re-double efforts to extend and                          • The 1st line of defence against
  sustain water & sanitation                                 climate variability and change, but
  services                                                   investment still lags
• Invest in multipurpose storage                           • Green hydropower and irrigation,
  and conveyance – the hydraulic                             but for whom, and at what cost?
  platform
• Invest in water resources                                • Start now, or repeat the mistakes
  assessment and management –                                of HICs and MICs
  the information and institutional
  platform



Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                      12
Kenya’s Climate Change Action
Plan
• CDKN is supporting a cross government effort to coordinate and deliver a National Climate
  Change Action Plan. The plan is broken down into 8 components.
• The Action Plan is gaining traction with enhanced visibility at a national level, with the
  National Social and Economic Research Council recognising its importance.
• The process has fostered closer working between the Ministry of Environment and the
  Ministry of Planning.

                                                                                                             (1) Long term vision and direction of low carbon and climate-resilient growth pathway




                                                     (9) Coordination of Action Plan delivery as a whole
                                                                                                                                       (2) Regulatory and policy framework




                                                                                                               (3) Adaptation planning and actions              (4) Mitigation planning and actions




                                                                                                                      (5) Technology         (6)            (7) Capacity
                                                                                                           Enablers




                                                                                                                          transfer,    Performance &         building &
                                                                                                                                                                                  (8) Finance
                                                                                                                        research &         benefit           knowledge
                                                                                                                       development     measurements         management




Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                                                                                                                          13
Rwanda: Fonerwa
Building on the newly adopted Green Growth and Climate Resilience Strategy,
CDKN has supported the Government of Rwanda to develop a national climate
change and environment fund.


The purpose of the fund is to:
• ensure sustainable financing is accessible to
  support environmental sustainability,
  resilience to climate change and green
  growth.
• be the primary mechanism through which
  Rwanda accesses, programmes, disburses
  and monitors international and national extra-
  budgetary climate and environment finance.
Funds will be distributed to Government, private
sector, civil society and communities to implement
a range of projects.

Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                      14
Economic impact assessment of climate change
in Nepal

 CDKN is working with the government of Nepal to address one of the key objectives of
 their National Climate Change Policy: assessment of losses and benefits from climate
 change in various geographical areas and development sectors by 2013.



The project aims to provide:

• estimates of the impacts and economic costs and
  benefits of climate change for the agricultural and
  water sectors followed by,
• a ranking of climate compatible development policy
  options in these sectors, according to their
  economic efficiency, to help the Government to
  strategically consider options for climate
  compatible development pathways.



       http://cdkn.org/project/economic-impact-assessment-of-climate-change-in-nepal/

Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                15
Carbon and water footprinting in Andean
cities
 CDKN are in the process of planning a project aimed at reducing the vulnerability to
 climate change of urban and peri-urban areas of three Andean capital cities (La Paz, Lima
 and Quito).

                                                           Key objectives of the project will be to

                                                           • Promote local government action on climate
                                                             change mitigation and adaptation through the
                                                             assessment of the carbon footprint and water
                                                             footprint of local government operations.

                                                           • Develop participative methodologies
                                                             appropriate to local conditions and assess the
                                                             carbon footprint and water footprint of the
                                                             cities of La Paz, Quito and Lima.

                                                           These assessments will form part of an action
                                                           plan for adaptation and mitigation.



Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                                      16
Developing Tools
Framework for Water Security and Climate Resilient Development




Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org   17
Integrating Tools
Water and Climate Development Programme




Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org   18
CCD: what have we learnt?
•     Leaders putting CCD at the top of their agenda
•     Building resilience and response to disasters is an entry point.
•     Development benefits of “Low emissions” growth key to narrative
•     Integrating CCD into existing multi-stakeholder national
      development and poverty reduction planning processes critical
•     Donor coordination and sharing of learning to address
      knowledge gaps and build country ownership
•     Countries prioritising allocation of finance to fund implementation
      of CCD strategies
•     National CCD action is occurring without global agreement – but
      a global deal and Green Climate Fund will accelerate and scale
      action
Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                 19
www.cdkn.org
This document is an output from a project funded by the UK Department for International Development (DFID) for the
benefit of developing countries. However, the views expressed and information contained in it are not necessarily those
of or endorsed by DFID, which can accept no responsibility for such views or information or for any reliance placed on
them. This publication has been prepared for general guidance on matters of interest only, and does not constitute
professional advice. You should not act upon the information contained in this publication without obtaining specific
professional advice. No representation or warranty (express or implied) is given as to the accuracy or completeness of
the information contained in this publication, and, to the extent permitted by law, the Climate and Development
Knowledge Network’s members, the UK Department for International Development (‘DFID’), their advisors and the
authors and distributors of this publication do not accept or assume any liability, responsibility or duty of care for any
consequences of you or anyone else acting, or refraining to act, in reliance on the information contained in this
publication or for any decision based on it.
Copyright © 2010, Climate and Development Knowledge Network. All rights reserved.
Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org                                                                     20

Delivering climate compatible development by Sam Bickersteth

  • 1.
    Delivering Climate Compatible Development - Sam Bickersteth,CDKN GWP Consulting Partners Meeting. Stockholm August 2012
  • 2.
    Climate Compatible Development Climate compatible development: Development that minimises the harm caused by climate impacts, while maximising the many human development opportunities presented by a low emissions, more resilient, future Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 2
  • 3.
    What’s the problemand why is it difficult to solve? http://www.climateactiontracker.org/ Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 3
  • 4.
    Water and CCD Opportunities… and threats Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 4
  • 5.
    IPCC SREX: implicationsfor water sector • A changing climate leads to changes in frequency, intensity, spatial extent and duration of weather and climate events • Extreme events such as floods and droughts will have a direct impact on water resources now and in the future •Frequency of heavy rainfall events likely to increase 4 fold and extreme hot days 10 fold by end of century. • Populations exposed to water-related hazards – e.g. flooding, coastal inundation – are already significant and likely to increase • Changes in the climate could seriously affect water management systems, such as water storage and treatment plants, and supply systems • Climate change adaptation and DRM likely to require transformational changes in processes and institutions • This will involve taking a more holistic approach – e.g. integrating water management with urban planning and design, and into policies on land use Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 5
  • 6.
    Slow onset economictransformation Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 6
  • 7.
    Extreme events –global exposure to floods; av. physical exposure in 1000 capita/year Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 7
  • 8.
    Storage deficit orharnessed hydrology Country Reservoir storage (m3/cap) Ethiopia 38 India 262 South Africa 687 China 2486 North America 5961 Grey and Sadoff, 2006 Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 8
  • 9.
    How to structurea responce Changes in institutions and institutional capacity to respond to CCD needs and demands Changes in co- ordination, Changes in the collaboration and understanding and mobilisation amongst commitment of key CCD decision makers stakeholders around CCD issues Changes in the quality of life Changes in for people most Changes in the quality relevance challenged by ability of decision and usability of the effects of makers to leverage CCD evidence and channel CCD climate change resources base strategically Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 9
  • 10.
    Integrating adaptation andDRM approaches for a changing climate Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 10
  • 11.
    What is neededto deliver CCD? National International Incentive and • Climate Change Act • New post-Kyoto international targets • Independent Climate Change Commission • International cap and trade Regulatory • Low carbon transmission plan or roadmap • International carbon tax Framework • National cap and trade • International standards for fuel efficiency • Carbon tax and emissions • Portfolio regulation of energy companies • Extend emissions targets to aviation and • Targeted tax incentives for private sector R&D shipping • Regulate emissions from vehicles • Regulate trade (e.g. in forest products) • Regulate other emissions • New international treaties on water • Strengthen forest law to reduce deforestation sharing • Strengthen planning laws on housing design and location • Decoupling utility profits from gross sales Public • Increase R&D budget • Fund N-S technology transfer • AMCs for renewable technologies • Fund S-S cooperation Expenditure • Subsidise retro-fitting of buildings • Extend scope of CDM • Subsidise new technologies (e.g. CCS) • Regional risk facilities • Subsidise renewables at domestic level • Provide subsidies to offset fuel poverty • Extend social protection for vulnerable groups • Invest in strengthening critical infrastructure • Invest in new infrastructure • Subsidise insurance mechanisms • Cut traditional fuel subsidies • Improved extension and entrepreneurial education • Education and consumer benchmarking Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 11
  • 12.
    Water and CCD Opportunities Threats • Re-double efforts to extend and • The 1st line of defence against sustain water & sanitation climate variability and change, but services investment still lags • Invest in multipurpose storage • Green hydropower and irrigation, and conveyance – the hydraulic but for whom, and at what cost? platform • Invest in water resources • Start now, or repeat the mistakes assessment and management – of HICs and MICs the information and institutional platform Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 12
  • 13.
    Kenya’s Climate ChangeAction Plan • CDKN is supporting a cross government effort to coordinate and deliver a National Climate Change Action Plan. The plan is broken down into 8 components. • The Action Plan is gaining traction with enhanced visibility at a national level, with the National Social and Economic Research Council recognising its importance. • The process has fostered closer working between the Ministry of Environment and the Ministry of Planning. (1) Long term vision and direction of low carbon and climate-resilient growth pathway (9) Coordination of Action Plan delivery as a whole (2) Regulatory and policy framework (3) Adaptation planning and actions (4) Mitigation planning and actions (5) Technology (6) (7) Capacity Enablers transfer, Performance & building & (8) Finance research & benefit knowledge development measurements management Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 13
  • 14.
    Rwanda: Fonerwa Building onthe newly adopted Green Growth and Climate Resilience Strategy, CDKN has supported the Government of Rwanda to develop a national climate change and environment fund. The purpose of the fund is to: • ensure sustainable financing is accessible to support environmental sustainability, resilience to climate change and green growth. • be the primary mechanism through which Rwanda accesses, programmes, disburses and monitors international and national extra- budgetary climate and environment finance. Funds will be distributed to Government, private sector, civil society and communities to implement a range of projects. Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 14
  • 15.
    Economic impact assessmentof climate change in Nepal CDKN is working with the government of Nepal to address one of the key objectives of their National Climate Change Policy: assessment of losses and benefits from climate change in various geographical areas and development sectors by 2013. The project aims to provide: • estimates of the impacts and economic costs and benefits of climate change for the agricultural and water sectors followed by, • a ranking of climate compatible development policy options in these sectors, according to their economic efficiency, to help the Government to strategically consider options for climate compatible development pathways. http://cdkn.org/project/economic-impact-assessment-of-climate-change-in-nepal/ Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 15
  • 16.
    Carbon and waterfootprinting in Andean cities CDKN are in the process of planning a project aimed at reducing the vulnerability to climate change of urban and peri-urban areas of three Andean capital cities (La Paz, Lima and Quito). Key objectives of the project will be to • Promote local government action on climate change mitigation and adaptation through the assessment of the carbon footprint and water footprint of local government operations. • Develop participative methodologies appropriate to local conditions and assess the carbon footprint and water footprint of the cities of La Paz, Quito and Lima. These assessments will form part of an action plan for adaptation and mitigation. Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 16
  • 17.
    Developing Tools Framework forWater Security and Climate Resilient Development Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 17
  • 18.
    Integrating Tools Water andClimate Development Programme Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 18
  • 19.
    CCD: what havewe learnt? • Leaders putting CCD at the top of their agenda • Building resilience and response to disasters is an entry point. • Development benefits of “Low emissions” growth key to narrative • Integrating CCD into existing multi-stakeholder national development and poverty reduction planning processes critical • Donor coordination and sharing of learning to address knowledge gaps and build country ownership • Countries prioritising allocation of finance to fund implementation of CCD strategies • National CCD action is occurring without global agreement – but a global deal and Green Climate Fund will accelerate and scale action Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 19
  • 20.
    www.cdkn.org This document isan output from a project funded by the UK Department for International Development (DFID) for the benefit of developing countries. However, the views expressed and information contained in it are not necessarily those of or endorsed by DFID, which can accept no responsibility for such views or information or for any reliance placed on them. This publication has been prepared for general guidance on matters of interest only, and does not constitute professional advice. You should not act upon the information contained in this publication without obtaining specific professional advice. No representation or warranty (express or implied) is given as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this publication, and, to the extent permitted by law, the Climate and Development Knowledge Network’s members, the UK Department for International Development (‘DFID’), their advisors and the authors and distributors of this publication do not accept or assume any liability, responsibility or duty of care for any consequences of you or anyone else acting, or refraining to act, in reliance on the information contained in this publication or for any decision based on it. Copyright © 2010, Climate and Development Knowledge Network. All rights reserved. Climate and Development Knowledge Network | www.cdkn.org 20

Editor's Notes

  • #5 What of water & CCD? Pictures from Ethiopia illustrate some of the opportunities and challenges aheadFrom (1) reducing dependence on vulnerable, unhealthy water sources, to (2) increasing irrigation and soil/water conservation (reducing dependence on increasingly volatile, rainfed agric), and (3) investing in multipurpose infrastructure for green energy, irrigation and flood control – dams get the headlines, but water storage to buffer rainfall variability can work at many scales. Note: obvious point - dams are contentious. The point here is that there is now a pretty widespread consensus that SSA needs to invest in its hydraulic infrastructure of storage and conveyance – see next slide. And develop – carefully – its groundwater resources which offer a ‘natural’ buffer against climate variability and change. Improving water security is essential for development and poverty reduction.Extreme climate events increase the cost and ease of improving water security, making it increasingly important to integrate water security and climate resilience into development planning.Importance of integrated planning processes for water, energy and food security that take account of climate change
  • #8 WATER – NB assuming constant hazard
  • #9 Built storage (reservoirs). Makes an important point re vulnerability to climate variability & change, though misses the natural storage provided by groundwater.
  • #10 All TA projects need to align to this. And this is what success looks like – how do we measure these?
  • #11 READABLE?
  • #13 In a little more detail, our current understanding of opportunities and threats:Why water & sanitation? Because extending and sustaining water & sanitation services is a precondition for tacking poverty. And because tackling poverty is central to both development and building resilience to CC. The good news: the international development target for halving the number of people without access to safe water (MDG 7) has been met, 5 years before the 2015 deadline. The bad news (threats): the global figures are skewed by rapid progress in India and China; SSA continues to lag, and financing to sustain existing services and extend access is insufficient (UNICEF/WHO Joint Monitoring Programme, 2012; UN Water Global Analysis and Assessment of Sanitation and Drinking Water, 2012). In SSA – the most vulnerable to CC – we know that investment in water storage and conveyance is a priority. Why? Because countries like Ethiopia (previous slide) have water, but the water is distributed unevenly in space and time. Unmitigated hydrological variability is estimated to cost Ethiopia roughly one-third of its growth potential (World Bank, 2006). Building a hydraulic platform is essential…and we know that Africa harnesses only around 5-7% of its hydropower potential (green energy), and less on irrigation. But, we also know that ‘green’ in a carbon sense is not necessarily ‘inclusive’, ‘pro-poor’ or sustainable in the roundHence the need to invest in an equivalent institutional platform of water resources management to ensure that tradeoffs and risks are accounted for, and to ensure that new infrastructure simultaneously delivers improved livelihoods, equity and environmental sustainability. Investment in water resources management is long overdue, and depends on much better information on resource conditions and trends. Note the need to avoid the mistakes of higher and middle income countries (HICs, MICs) and their ‘capture and control’ approach to water resources development….climate resilience at huge environmental and social cost
  • #18 CDKN supported GWP and AMCOW to develop the Framework for Water Security and Climate Resilient DevelopmentStrategic Framework: Launched at Africa Water Week in MayTechnical Background Document: Launched tomorrow at WWW5 Policy BriefsCapacity Development StrategyFramework will be presented by Alex in more detail, but at a high level it recommends activities at different stages of planning and investment cycles, for different decision-makers (central ministries, line ministries, local government, transboundary bodies, civil society), to develop no/low regrets investment decisions to achieve water security and climate resilience. Highlight that CDKN is a “happy donor”, we benefit from GWPs wide networks across Africa, their engagement style, the technical expertise they bring and we have great working relationships at an operational level
  • #19 Plethora of tools existEssential that they are embedded in long term planning approaches. Integration in government decision making processesThe Framework fits into the wider WACDEP programme, which is a crucial factor to its useAndrew will introduce WACDEP in full, but briefly, it aims to:integrate water security and climate resilience in development planning processes, using the Framework as the underlying tool to do sodevelop partnerships and capacity of institutions and stakeholders to build resilience to climate change through better water managementdevelop “no regret” financing and investment strategies for water security and climate change adaptation CDKN are very pleased to be providing on going support to the programme, and in particular in the capacity building work package. This work is currently under procurement and will commence in October Aims to strengthen the institutional capacity of African planning departments in ministries, local government and broader to apply the Framework to their real life programmes and projects. The output will be enhanced institutional capacity to develop water-related development decisions, plans and investment strategies that are no/low regrets