A 21-year-old male presents to the emergency department with midline cervical pain after falling headfirst into a shallow pool while wrestling with friends. On examination, he has mild midline cervical tenderness without neurological deficits. Radiographs reveal a compression fracture of C1 with splitting of the lateral masses, indicative of an unstable Jefferson fracture from an axial blow to the head. The patient requires cervical spine immobilization, orthopedic consultation, and treatment with a halo or skeletal traction and possible cervical fusion due to the instability of the fracture.