Inclusive tech, (how) is that
possible?
Marion Mulder
Inclusive tech, (how) is that possible?
• Is inclusive tech possible? Spoiler alert: YES (but its hard work)
• What do I mean when I talk about inclusive tech? I’ll take you
along on my journey of exploration
• That ‘thing’ about biological and genetics aspects; what’s going
on? why is that? Symptoms & underlying causes. In short: Bias
and by Binary Thinking
• Opportunities & Possible Solutions
Future Maker
Creating a world I want to live in
Equality for all
Taking away hurdles
How do I try to do that?
Activism
Talks
conversation
Digital
Transformation
work on digital strategies and
implementations of solutions
Inclusive Tech
Technology that benefits everyone
Privilege:
So what could possibly go wrong, right?
Some examples of where it did not go
quite right….
Sales of helmet in
Asia (of US brand)
were low…
Turns out the
average head size
in the database was
not diverse enough
Image source: Che-Wei Wang – mindful algorithms: the new role of the designer in generative design - TNW conference 2018
Some examples of where it did not go
quite right….
Automatic translations also changes gender
Some examples of where it did not go
quite right….
Google’s image classifier
wrongly assigned black
people
Some examples of where it did not go
quite right….
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/11/21/science/artificial-intelligence-fake-people-faces.html
Because we can, should we?
Source: Virginia Dignum – UMEA University
Because we can, should we?
How correct is the data really?
Because we can, should we?
Criminal face detection AI
Source: Juriaan van Diggelen - TNO
Contributing to the effect on society
Documentary on Netflix on modern day
slavery in the US judicial system.
As a consequence of the Law & Order
Business Model
Addictive technology
Addictive technology
On October 25, 2017, Saudi Arabia
granted citizenship to Sophia Robot.
In August 2019, in a positive and long-overdue development, the
authorities announced major reforms to the discriminatory male
guardianship system. Among other things, these allowed women
aged over 21 to apply for and obtain a passport and travel without
the permission of a male guardian; women aged over 18 to
register the birth of a newborn child, the death of a relative and
their own marriage or divorce, as well as to apply for and obtain a
family record; and women to act as the head of a household.
12/11/2019 “Saudi Arabia just declared
homosexuality, feminism and atheism
as ‘extremism’
It’s a girl….
I’m sorry, I don’t understand…..
Google’s speech-recognition software was
70% more likely to
recognise male speech than female speech
2016 Rachel Tatman,
linguistics at the University of Washington
So what’s causing it,
and what can we do?
In short:
Bias based on (binary view on) biological aspects
Why Biology Matters
There are reasons why biology
matters in technology (design),
think for example of a smart
phone generally not fitting
women’s hands, or medicine
behaving differently for men an
women due to hormones.
But in many cases we should ask
ourselves “should we? really?”
And at the same time we should
ask ourselves is this really a
gender thing or is this just a
‘people with smaller hands thing’
or a ‘people with uteruses/
specific hormone behaviour
thing’?
Why Biology Matters
There are reasons why biology
matters in technology (design),
think for example of a smart
phone generally not fitting
women’s hands, or medicine
behaving differently for men an
women due to hormones.
But in many cases we should ask
ourselves “should we? really?”
And at the same time we should
ask ourselves is this really a
gender thing or is this just a
‘people with smaller hands thing’
or a ‘people with uteruses/
specific hormone behaviour
thing’?
PS: gender =/= women!
It is the entire spectrum of
men – women.
Meet ‘default man’
skinny white dude 1,75m hight
Why Biology Matters
There are reasons why biology
matters in technology (design),
think for example of a smart
phone generally not fitting
women’s hands, or medicine
behaving differently for men an
women due to hormones.
But in many cases we should ask
ourselves “should we? really?”
And at the same time we should
ask ourselves is this really a
gender thing or is this just a
‘people with smaller hands thing’
or a ‘people with uteruses/
specific hormone behaviour
thing’?
PS: gender =/= women!
It is the entire spectrum of
men – women.
Meet ‘default man’
skinny white dude 1,75m hight
Dealing with human Bias
• Bias: expectations derived from experience
regularities in the world. Knowing what
programmer means, including that most are male.
• Stereotypes: biases based on regularities we do
not wish to persist.
Knowing that (most) programmes are male.
• Prejudice: action on stereotypes.
Hiring only male programmers.
Bias, stereotypes, prejudice;
discrimination potentially being programmed into the future
Source: Joanna Bryson at AI Summit - Caliskan, Bryson &Narayanan 2017
Ada Lovelace
Live isn’t binary
M U L D I M E D I A
• The problem with binary is that there’s
usually a hierarchy in ‘m; one is better
that the other:
man/woman, white/black, abled/disabled,
in a relationship/single, straight/gay, left
brain/ right brain, economy/environment,
us/them, etc.
• What if we started looking at the world
from a non-binary perspective and more
as a spectrums?
How we view the world isn’t static
yesterday ≠ today ≠ tomorrow
So if we DO collect data or use historical
data sets……
Just because
we can,
should we?
What is the by-catch/ what are side
effects?
Just because
we can,
should we?
What is the by-catch/ what are side
effects?
(How) is this
helping
Human Kind
in a sustainable
way?
Design & TEST Human in the Loop
systems
• Consult non-technical experts and resources
• Involve diverse groups in your design, data
gathering, testing
• Transparency (explainable) of your decision
making and algorithms
• Analyze –synthetize –evaluate -repeat
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1T8jGIG2bvbQtE7fLWLSRrmC9yYwMeBuf/view
https://theodi.org/article/data-ethics-canvas/
Access & Accessibility
Is what you are making available to everyone?
Should this ‘problem’ actually be solved by (this) technology?
AmazonBasics
voice-controlled
microwave oven
Access & Accessibility
Is what you are making available to everyone?
Should this ‘problem’ actually be solved by (this) technology?
Access & Accessibility
Be the face of the
change you want to see
join a community
Lets create the
future together!

Inclusive tech, (how) is that possible?

  • 1.
    Inclusive tech, (how)is that possible? Marion Mulder
  • 2.
    Inclusive tech, (how)is that possible? • Is inclusive tech possible? Spoiler alert: YES (but its hard work) • What do I mean when I talk about inclusive tech? I’ll take you along on my journey of exploration • That ‘thing’ about biological and genetics aspects; what’s going on? why is that? Symptoms & underlying causes. In short: Bias and by Binary Thinking • Opportunities & Possible Solutions
  • 3.
    Future Maker Creating aworld I want to live in
  • 4.
  • 5.
    How do Itry to do that?
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Digital Transformation work on digitalstrategies and implementations of solutions
  • 9.
    Inclusive Tech Technology thatbenefits everyone Privilege:
  • 10.
    So what couldpossibly go wrong, right?
  • 11.
    Some examples ofwhere it did not go quite right…. Sales of helmet in Asia (of US brand) were low… Turns out the average head size in the database was not diverse enough Image source: Che-Wei Wang – mindful algorithms: the new role of the designer in generative design - TNW conference 2018
  • 12.
    Some examples ofwhere it did not go quite right…. Automatic translations also changes gender
  • 13.
    Some examples ofwhere it did not go quite right…. Google’s image classifier wrongly assigned black people
  • 14.
    Some examples ofwhere it did not go quite right….
  • 16.
  • 20.
    Source: Virginia Dignum– UMEA University Because we can, should we? How correct is the data really?
  • 21.
    Because we can,should we? Criminal face detection AI Source: Juriaan van Diggelen - TNO
  • 22.
    Contributing to theeffect on society Documentary on Netflix on modern day slavery in the US judicial system. As a consequence of the Law & Order Business Model
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
    On October 25,2017, Saudi Arabia granted citizenship to Sophia Robot. In August 2019, in a positive and long-overdue development, the authorities announced major reforms to the discriminatory male guardianship system. Among other things, these allowed women aged over 21 to apply for and obtain a passport and travel without the permission of a male guardian; women aged over 18 to register the birth of a newborn child, the death of a relative and their own marriage or divorce, as well as to apply for and obtain a family record; and women to act as the head of a household. 12/11/2019 “Saudi Arabia just declared homosexuality, feminism and atheism as ‘extremism’ It’s a girl….
  • 27.
    I’m sorry, Idon’t understand….. Google’s speech-recognition software was 70% more likely to recognise male speech than female speech 2016 Rachel Tatman, linguistics at the University of Washington
  • 28.
    So what’s causingit, and what can we do? In short: Bias based on (binary view on) biological aspects
  • 29.
    Why Biology Matters Thereare reasons why biology matters in technology (design), think for example of a smart phone generally not fitting women’s hands, or medicine behaving differently for men an women due to hormones. But in many cases we should ask ourselves “should we? really?” And at the same time we should ask ourselves is this really a gender thing or is this just a ‘people with smaller hands thing’ or a ‘people with uteruses/ specific hormone behaviour thing’?
  • 30.
    Why Biology Matters Thereare reasons why biology matters in technology (design), think for example of a smart phone generally not fitting women’s hands, or medicine behaving differently for men an women due to hormones. But in many cases we should ask ourselves “should we? really?” And at the same time we should ask ourselves is this really a gender thing or is this just a ‘people with smaller hands thing’ or a ‘people with uteruses/ specific hormone behaviour thing’? PS: gender =/= women! It is the entire spectrum of men – women. Meet ‘default man’ skinny white dude 1,75m hight
  • 31.
    Why Biology Matters Thereare reasons why biology matters in technology (design), think for example of a smart phone generally not fitting women’s hands, or medicine behaving differently for men an women due to hormones. But in many cases we should ask ourselves “should we? really?” And at the same time we should ask ourselves is this really a gender thing or is this just a ‘people with smaller hands thing’ or a ‘people with uteruses/ specific hormone behaviour thing’? PS: gender =/= women! It is the entire spectrum of men – women. Meet ‘default man’ skinny white dude 1,75m hight
  • 32.
    Dealing with humanBias • Bias: expectations derived from experience regularities in the world. Knowing what programmer means, including that most are male. • Stereotypes: biases based on regularities we do not wish to persist. Knowing that (most) programmes are male. • Prejudice: action on stereotypes. Hiring only male programmers. Bias, stereotypes, prejudice; discrimination potentially being programmed into the future Source: Joanna Bryson at AI Summit - Caliskan, Bryson &Narayanan 2017 Ada Lovelace
  • 33.
    Live isn’t binary MU L D I M E D I A • The problem with binary is that there’s usually a hierarchy in ‘m; one is better that the other: man/woman, white/black, abled/disabled, in a relationship/single, straight/gay, left brain/ right brain, economy/environment, us/them, etc. • What if we started looking at the world from a non-binary perspective and more as a spectrums?
  • 34.
    How we viewthe world isn’t static yesterday ≠ today ≠ tomorrow
  • 35.
    So if weDO collect data or use historical data sets……
  • 36.
    Just because we can, shouldwe? What is the by-catch/ what are side effects?
  • 37.
    Just because we can, shouldwe? What is the by-catch/ what are side effects? (How) is this helping Human Kind in a sustainable way?
  • 38.
    Design & TESTHuman in the Loop systems • Consult non-technical experts and resources • Involve diverse groups in your design, data gathering, testing • Transparency (explainable) of your decision making and algorithms • Analyze –synthetize –evaluate -repeat
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
    Access & Accessibility Iswhat you are making available to everyone? Should this ‘problem’ actually be solved by (this) technology? AmazonBasics voice-controlled microwave oven
  • 42.
    Access & Accessibility Iswhat you are making available to everyone? Should this ‘problem’ actually be solved by (this) technology?
  • 43.
  • 44.
    Be the faceof the change you want to see join a community
  • 45.