This presentation discusses the difference between Microsoft Project and Primavera,their capabilities in managing project and overall project performance monitoring and controlling.

1. Importance of Microsoft Project and
Primavera In Construction Industry
November 03, 2015

2. Questions ?
CEPT
UNIVERSITY
Why Microsoft Project and Primavera ?
Why PMS ?
Planners only make schedules
Microsoft Project or Primavera ?
Microsoft Project cannot handle Complex Projects
Potential Used ?

3. Contents… CEPT
UNIVERSITY
 Project Management Challenges
 Market Penetration
 Project planning:
 PDM network
 Assign Resources and Cost
 Baseline the plan
 Project review:
 Identify resource over-allocations
 Level if necessary
 Project Execution:
 Generate Reports
 Project Monitoring and Tracking:
 Update Baseline plan
 Compare Actual against Baseline
 Re-plan and Re-Baseline
 Earned Value Concept
 Difference between MSP and
Primavera
 Microsoft Project or Primavera?

4. Work Performance Data/Info/Reports
CEPT
UNIVERSITY
PM Plan
The document which
describes how the
project will be
documented, monitored
and controlled
WPD
Physical work
completion, start and
finish dates, change
requests, actual costs,
actual duration etc.
WPI
Status of deliverables,
status for change requests,
forecasted estimates to
complete
WPR
Status
reports,memos,justifications,
recommendations

5. Project Management Challenges CEPT
UNIVERSITY
Geographic dispersion
Overbooked or
Unutilized
Resources
Project Scope Changes
Unnecessary Paperwork

6. Market Penetration CEPT
UNIVERSITY
Middle East United States
Source: The use of project management software in construction industry of Southeast Europe
Mladen Vukomanović, Mladen Radujković, Zlata Dolaček Alduk

7. Project Planning CEPT
UNIVERSITY
Schedule
Baseline is
established to
control actual
project
performance

8. Project Planning: PDM Network CEPT
UNIVERSITY

9. Project Planning : PDM Network CEPT
UNIVERSITY

10. Project Review: Assigning resources and Cost
CEPT
UNIVERSITY

11. Project Review: Levelling Resources CEPT
UNIVERSITY

12. Managing Floats in MS-Project and Primavera
CEPT
UNIVERSITY

13. Managing Floats in MS-Project and Primavera
CEPT
UNIVERSITY

14. Managing Floats in MS-Project and Primavera
CEPT
UNIVERSITY

15. Managing Floats in MS-Project and Primavera
CEPT
UNIVERSITY

16. Project Tracking: Setup Baseline CEPT
UNIVERSITY
Go to: Project/Set baseline to set a
baseline for your project
A Baseline is essentially a snapshot of your
project schedule, it should be captured once
your schedule is complete.
So that you can compare your original plan
with the current progress.

17. Project Monitoring & Tracking: Tracking Gantt
CEPT
UNIVERSITY

18. CEPT
UNIVERSITYEarned Value Analysis
55000
49000
56000
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000 Jan-03
Feb-03
Mar-03
Apr-03
May-03
Jun-03
Jul-03
Aug-03
Sep-03
Oct-03
Nov-03
Dec-03
BCWS
BCWP
ACWP
Cost Variance: 55,000-56,0000 = -1000 INR (Cost-Overrun)
Schedule Variance: 49,000 – 55,000 = -6000 INR (Behind Schedule)

19. Project Monitoring & Tracking: EVA CEPT
UNIVERSITY

20. Project Execution: Reports CEPT
UNIVERSITY
Microsoft Project-2013 Primavera-P6

21. Primavera P6 Dashboard
CEPT
UNIVERSIT
Y

23. MS-Project or Primavera? Decision Matrix
CEPT
UNIVERSITY
Source: https://precisionschedulingconsultants.co
Factor MS-Project Primavera
Small & medium building project (<200 activities)
Program-level analysis or simultaneous multiple project analysis
Multiple user interface (more than one person updating/tracking the
schedule)
Construction schedule oversight and detailed analysis
Non-construction projects / simple schedules
Basic bar charts or timelines for display in MS PowerPoint™ presentation
System Integration (BIM,ERP)
Licensing Cost
User friendly , Beginner use, planning and scheduling
Recommended
Note: These decisions are based on professional opinion that were derived from years
and $billions worth of construction scheduling experience.
Not-Recommended

24. MICROSOFT PROJECT PRIMAVERA
Simple and user friendly Detailed and complex
Allows user to make Macros and Switches
with the help of VBA language
Macros , complex formulas cannot be made
in Primavera
Limited Baselines (Only 11) Unlimited baselines
Project Tracking with multiple projects at
same time is not possible.
Project Tracking with multiple projects at
same time is possible.
Multiple activity relationship not possible It is possible to have a FF as well as SS
relationship between two activities.
Relatively low cost of installation and
maintenance.
High installation and maintenance cost
Appealing appearance Needs configuration to make it appealing.

25. Difference a decade makes (MS-Project) CEPT
UNIVERSITY

26. Difference a decade makes….
1994 2000 2003 2006 2010
P3-V1 for
Windows
P3 (V-02)
incorporated
EPS
P6- PrimaVision
web based
platform is
released
Incorporates
Risk
management
Enterprise
Project
Portfolio is
released
CEPT
UNIVERSITY

27. The Competition—Endless……
Thank You For Your Attention….
Questions?