This study is the first component of a multi-pronged research study on breaking the cycle of food insecurity in Malawi. Results from other components are to follow, including promoting nutritious value chains and understanding the drivers of food security and resilience. This study examines the impact of a food-based social transfers (MVAC) on household food security, diets, and nutrition status of young children during the lean season in Malawi. This was a quasi-experimental prospective study based on two rounds of a mixed methods surveys study in Zomba district in southern Malawi. Study outcomes include household expenditures and food consumption (7-day recall), child level dietary diversity (24-hour recall) and nutritional status (anthropometric measurements). We follow a mixed methods approach and undertake child and household surveys and assessments as well as in-depth interviews with household members. We estimate program impact by combining propensity score matching (PSM) and difference-in-difference (DID) methods. Qualitative data provides insights into community norms on targeting and sharing that may impact the effectiveness of the transfers.
Food transfers appear to have a protective effect on food security, diets and nutrition status of young children. There was suggestion of a positive effect on micronutrient availability in diets, particularly for iron. At child level, highly significant positive effects were found on dietary diversity and food variety scores, corresponding to increases of 15% and 12% respectively, as well as a positive effect on stunting. But targeting did not appear to be progressive or aligned to MVAC criteria. Furthermore, the coverage of food transfers is extremely low compared to extent of food insecurity. Community norms about targeting and sharing may explain the targeting errors and also may be seen as a response to low coverage.
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Shivpuri_Madhya PradeshPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Balaghat_Madhya PradeshPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Khandwa_Madhya PradeshPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
Ability of Household Food Insecurity Measures to Capture Vulnerability & Resi...TransferProjct
Using evidence from a cash transfer program in Zimbabwe, the presentation covers how quantitative measures can capture vulnerability and resilience at the household level
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Shivpuri_Madhya PradeshPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Balaghat_Madhya PradeshPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Khandwa_Madhya PradeshPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
Ability of Household Food Insecurity Measures to Capture Vulnerability & Resi...TransferProjct
Using evidence from a cash transfer program in Zimbabwe, the presentation covers how quantitative measures can capture vulnerability and resilience at the household level
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Gajapati_OdishaPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Jagatsinghpur_OdishaPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
Exploring the links between household time and food choices in GuatemalaCGIAR
This presentation was given by Jennifer Twyman (CIAT), as part of the Annual Gender Scientific Conference hosted by the CGIAR Collaborative Platform for Gender Research. The event took place on 25-27 September 2018 in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, hosted by the International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI) and co-organized with KIT Royal Tropical Institute.
Read more: http://gender.cgiar.org/gender_events/annual-conference-2018/
Kristin Davis, Guush Berhane, Catherine Mthinda, Ephraim Nkonya
WEBINAR
East Africa Perspectives on the Book: Agricultural Extension – Global Status and Performance in Selected Countries
OCT 28, 2020 - 03:30 PM TO 05:00 PM SAST
Patricia van de Velde
POLICY SEMINAR
Towards Resilient Livelihoods, Food Security, and Nutrition for All: Confronting the Gendered Impacts of COVID-19
Co-Organized by IFPRI, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) and the World Bank
MAR 23, 2021 - 09:30 AM TO 11:00 AM EDT
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Gajapati_OdishaPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
POSHAN District Nutrition Profile_Jagatsinghpur_OdishaPOSHAN
POSHAN District Nutrition Profiles (DNPs) draw on diverse sources of data to compile a set of indicators on the state of nutrition and its cross-sectoral determinants. The profiles are intended to be conversation-starters at the district level and to enable discussions about why undernutrition levels are high, and which factors, at multiple levels, might need to be addressed to improve nutrition.
PLEASE NOTE that POSHAN is regularly tracking data sources as they are released and updating the profiles accordingly.
Exploring the links between household time and food choices in GuatemalaCGIAR
This presentation was given by Jennifer Twyman (CIAT), as part of the Annual Gender Scientific Conference hosted by the CGIAR Collaborative Platform for Gender Research. The event took place on 25-27 September 2018 in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, hosted by the International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI) and co-organized with KIT Royal Tropical Institute.
Read more: http://gender.cgiar.org/gender_events/annual-conference-2018/
Kristin Davis, Guush Berhane, Catherine Mthinda, Ephraim Nkonya
WEBINAR
East Africa Perspectives on the Book: Agricultural Extension – Global Status and Performance in Selected Countries
OCT 28, 2020 - 03:30 PM TO 05:00 PM SAST
Patricia van de Velde
POLICY SEMINAR
Towards Resilient Livelihoods, Food Security, and Nutrition for All: Confronting the Gendered Impacts of COVID-19
Co-Organized by IFPRI, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) and the World Bank
MAR 23, 2021 - 09:30 AM TO 11:00 AM EDT
The presentation was part of the Food Security in India: the Interactions of Climate Change, Economics, Politics and Trade workshop, organized by IFPRI-CUTS on March 11 in New Delhi, India. The project seeks to explore a model for analyzing food security in India through the interactions of climate change, economics, politics and trade.
Effect of Yam-Based Production on Food Security Status of Farm Households in...Agriculture Journal IJOEAR
Abstract— The study assessed the effect of yam-based production on the food security status of farm households in Edo south, Nigeria. Specifically, the objectives of the study were to examine the socio-economic characteristics of the respondents, analyse the contribution of yam-based production to the income profile of the households, estimate their mean per capita daily calorie intake and examine the determinants and the probability of households being food secured.
A multi-stage sampling technique was adopted in selecting 120 farm households from Edo South agro-ecological zone of Edo-State data were collected with the aid of well – structured interview schedule on households socio-economic variables which included sex, age, marital status, level of education, farm size, household size and household income and expenditure profile among others. Data collected were analyzed by appropriate statistical analysis which included frequency counts, percentages, mean, standard deviation, and Logit regression model.
The results showed that 97 males, represented majority of the households with (80.8%) and females 23, represented 19.2%of the house heads. The mean age of household reads was 50 years, of which (92.5%) of them were married, 53% owned houses and 58% had farming experience of 11.20 years the mean household size was estimated as seven persons with a mean farm size of 1.35 hectares. The mean annual household income in the study area was estimated as N 496.850.88 out of which farm income contributed N 62.4307, and off income contributed (37.57%). The mean monthly household expenditure was N 40,934.31 out of which food expenditure accounted for 40 .22%. The results also showed that the area was fairly food -secured with 52.5% being food secured and 47.67 being food insecure with mean per capita calorie intake of 36,okcal and 120.2 kcal respectively.
Finally, the results also revealed that three variables in the logit model were significant in explaining variation in the food security status of the households. These are farm size, form income and off-income. It was recommended that government should provide bigger plot of land for those farmers who are determined to take farming as business.
The abstract should summarize the content of the paper. Try to keep the abstract below 250 words. Do not make references nor display equations in the abstract. The journal will be printed from the same-sized copy prepared by you. Your manuscript should be printed on A4 paper (21.0 cm x 29.7 cm). It is imperative that the margins and style described below be adhered to carefully. This will enable us to keep uniformity in the final printed copies of the Journal. Please keep in mind that the manuscript you prepare will be photographed and printed as it is received. Readability of copy is of paramount importance.
The Effect of State and Local Buffering Mechanisms on Household Food Security...May Cho
Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health. 2012 Jul;43(4):1042-52.
Household food security and buffering mechanisms in Thai and non-Thai households in Nong Loo Sub-district, Sangkhla Buri, Thailand.
Cho MM1, Knowles J, Atwood S.
It is never too soon to start investing. Investing is the smartest way to secure your financial future and to begin letting your money make more money for you. Contrary to what you may think, investing is not only for people who have plenty of spare cash.
Professor Mike Rogers, Head, Bone Therapeutics Group
Garvan Institute of Medical Research. http://www.garvan.org.au/news-events/leaders-in-science-and-society
A/Professor Shane Grey, Head, Transplantation & Immunology, Garvan Institute of Medical Research. http://www.garvan.org.au/news-events/leaders-in-science-and-society
The impact of lean season food transfers on food security, diets and nutritio...IFPRIMaSSP
This study was presented by Dr. Noora-Lisa Aberman (Country Program Manager, International Food Policy Research Institute) at the Agriculture nutrition event on " Improving Food Security, Diets and Nutrition through Multisectoral Action" on 30 May, 2017 at Capital Hotel, Lilongwe
Preliminary results: Malawi Zero Hunger and Malnutrition Strategic ReviewIFPRIMaSSP
This presentation shared preliminary findings from the Malawi Zero Hunger and Malnutrition Strategic Review (ZHMSR), which is a government-led, independent, analytical, and consultative exercise to identify the key challenges Malawi faces in achieving the second Sustainable Development Goal (SDG 2), to "end hunger, achieve food security and improved nutrition, and promote sustainable agriculture" by 2030.
The results were presented at the Lilongwe office of the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) by Dr. Grace Kumchulesi, from the ZHMSR research team. The seminar is part of IFPRI Malawi's Brown Bag Research Seminar series, which allows for presentation of early research results for discussion and feedback.
Using evidence from Ghana's LEAP 1000 program, Transfer Project's Richard de Groot explores whether cash transfers targeted to children in the first 1,000 days of life can improve their nutritional status.
Presented as part of EPRC's What Works for Africa’s Poorest Children conference in Kampala, Uganda in September 2018.
Junk Food Consumption is a Nutrition Problem among Infants and Young Children: Evidence and Program Considerations for Low and Middle Income (LMIC) Countries (MCSP Presentation)
Dr. Pamela Mukaire of the Resources for Improving Birth Outcomes at Liberty University discusses a project in rural Uganda to use the FHI 360 Community-based Management of Acute Malnutrition approach to improve the health of families.
Setting a Path for Improved Health Outcomes RBFRBFHealth
Learning is a critical part of the HRITF RBF portfolio, with all programs benefiting from an embedded impact evaluation and in some cases, complemented by qualitative research components such as process evaluation studies. The presentation discusses the following topics:
1. Using RBF at the community-level to address demand side barriers
This presentation elaborates on the early evidence and the rationale for using RBF at the community level. It will share lessons learned from the implementation of community RBF at country level.
2. Using RBF to Strengthen Quality of Care: Early Lessons
This presentation discusses the broader policy implications of using RBF to strengthen the quality of care. It will explore how Measuring and Paying for the Quality of Care has been operationalized and will highlight the experience of Nigeria. Lastly, it will focus on measuring and Analyzing the Quality of Care from the Impact Evaluation perspective.
SBI Youth for India Fellowship 2016-17 - ANKUR CHHABRAAnkur Chhabra
Health Promotion - Social behaviour change communication and community mobilisation to address the issue of maternal and child malnutrition in Palghar district, Maharashtra
Similar to Impact of food transfers in zomba aberman (20)
This presentation was made by Dr. Francesco Cecchi, Assistant Professor, Development Economics Group, Wageningen University, during IFPRI Malawi brownbag seminar series on 23 November 2022.
Market Access and Quality Upgrading_Dec12_2022.pdfIFPRIMaSSP
This presentation was made by Dr. Tessa Bold, Associate Professor, Institute of International Economic Studies, Stockholm University, during IFPRI Malawi brownbag seminar series on 7 December 2022
The Effect of Extension and Marketing Interventions on Smallholder Farmers: E...IFPRIMaSSP
This presentation was made by Annemie Maertens, Reader in economics, University of Sussex, during the MwAPATA-IFPRI joint seminar series on 9 November 2022
This presentation was made by Ellen Mccullough, Assistant Professor, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, University of Georgia during the MwAPATA-IFPRI Joint seminar series on Wednesday, 19 October 2022
Disentangling food security from subsistence ag malawi t benson_july_2021-minIFPRIMaSSP
This presentation was made during the launch of a book titled "Disentangling Food Security from Subsistence Agriculture in Malawi" by Dr. Todd Benson, IFPRI, at IFPRI Malawi brownbag seminar
A New Method for Crowdsourcing 'Farmgate' PricesIFPRIMaSSP
A New Method for Crowdsourcing Farmgate Prices in Malawi
This Presentation was made during a virtual brown bag seminar at IFPRI Malawi on 23 June 2021. The Presentation was made by Dr. Bob Baulch and Mr. Aubrey Jolex
Does connectivity reduce gender gaps in off-farm employment? Evidence from 12...IFPRIMaSSP
At an IFPRI Malawi virtual brown bag seminar held on 19th May 2021, Dr. Eva-Maria Egger, a UNU-Wider Research Fellow, presented a paper that posed the question “Does Connectivity Reduce Gender Gaps in Off-Farm Employment?”.
Urban proximity, demand for land and land prices in malawi (1)IFPRIMaSSP
African cities are growing rapidly This growth can be attributed to the increase in population from natural births within cities and migration of people from rural areas in search of better job opportunities. The increase in urban population has led to an expansion of urban boundaries into peri-urban and rural areas, And the associated increase in demand for land previously not classified as urban has sped up the development of land markets in Sub-Saharan African (SSA) cities. It is in the context of this trend that a spike in global energy and food prices in 2007 and 2008 led to a sharp – albeit temporary – increase in demand by international investors for rural agricultural land in Africa and beyond, stoking fears of a “land grab.”
Understanding the factors that influence cereal legume adoption amongst small...IFPRIMaSSP
This presentation was made by Dr. Tabitha C. Nindi, a Research Fellow at the Malawi University of Science and Technology (MUST), on the 24th of March 2021.
0x01 - Newton's Third Law: Static vs. Dynamic AbusersOWASP Beja
f you offer a service on the web, odds are that someone will abuse it. Be it an API, a SaaS, a PaaS, or even a static website, someone somewhere will try to figure out a way to use it to their own needs. In this talk we'll compare measures that are effective against static attackers and how to battle a dynamic attacker who adapts to your counter-measures.
About the Speaker
===============
Diogo Sousa, Engineering Manager @ Canonical
An opinionated individual with an interest in cryptography and its intersection with secure software development.
Have you ever wondered how search works while visiting an e-commerce site, internal website, or searching through other types of online resources? Look no further than this informative session on the ways that taxonomies help end-users navigate the internet! Hear from taxonomists and other information professionals who have first-hand experience creating and working with taxonomies that aid in navigation, search, and discovery across a range of disciplines.
Acorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutesIP ServerOne
Introducing Acorn Recovery as a Service, a simple, fast, and secure managed disaster recovery (DRaaS) by IP ServerOne. A DR solution that helps restore your IT infra within minutes.
Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...Orkestra
UIIN Conference, Madrid, 27-29 May 2024
James Wilson, Orkestra and Deusto Business School
Emily Wise, Lund University
Madeline Smith, The Glasgow School of Art
This presentation by Morris Kleiner (University of Minnesota), was made during the discussion “Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations” held at the Working Party No. 2 on Competition and Regulation on 10 June 2024. More papers and presentations on the topic can be found out at oe.cd/crps.
This presentation was uploaded with the author’s consent.
Getting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control Tower
Impact of food transfers in zomba aberman
1. Evidence from a mixed-methods study in Malawi
Aulo Gelli, Noora-Lisa Aberman,
Amy Margolies, Marco Santacroce, Bob Baulch
and Ephraim Chirwa
The impact of lean season food transfers
on food security, diets and nutrition
status
2. Study objectives
• To estimate the impact and targeting of lean
season food transfers (MVAC) on households’
food security and children’s diets and nutrition
• To understand village-level norms on
allocation of food transfers and other
resources that may help explain those results
3. Study sites
• Data was collected
from 60 communities
randomly selected
among a set of
food-insecure villages
in MVAC targeted
region of Zomba
district in southern
Malawi
4. Study methods: Quantitative Data
• Longitudinal study based on two rounds of
surveys undertaken (as part of a cluster
randomized controlled trial of a pre-school
based agriculture and nutrition intervention):
– Baseline survey undertaken in the post-harvest
season (September 2015)
– Follow-up undertaken during the peak lean
season (February 2016) after scale-up of food
transfers
– Rich data set including ~1200 households, over
1,500 children
5. Study methods: Qualitative Data
• Qualitative data is made up of 45 in-depth
time-line interviews in the same communities
in Zomba, with women, men and adolescent
girls (March 2016)
– Translated and transcribed, then thematically
coded
6. Evaluation strategy
• First estimated a probit model to assess the
probability of targeting criteria to predict
program participation
– using range of household and community level
characteristics on sample of MVAC beneficiaries
and non-beneficiaries
• Then we evaluated the impact of MVAC by
combining propensity score matching and
difference in difference (DID) methods
7. Outcomes
• Two levels of outcomes:
1. Alternative measures of household food security
estimated from consumption and expenditure
modules using adult equivalents
2. Measures of diets and
nutrition status of
young children
8. MVAC programme characteristics
• Eligibility criteria for MVAC food assistance
included households headed by women, the
elderly or children, or households including
orphans, the chronically ill or households that
had lost their main source of income due to
chronic illness
• Household screening criteria also included asset
holdings (including livestock, land and small
durables), participation in other social assistance
programs (including social cash transfers, inputs
subsidy programme and school meals)
9. Food transfers
• Food rations were to be provided to households
on a monthly basis and included maize (50kg),
legumes (10kg) and fortified vegetable oil (1.84 kg)
• At endline, 175 (15%) out of 1,191 households
had received MVAC in the survey population
• Households consuming <1800 calories per capital
per day: 36% at baseline and 46% during lean
season
11. Effects of MVAC Food Transfer
• During the lean season, households in the
sample experienced substantive declines in
household food security
• Compared to control, MVAC food recipients
were better off:
– substantive positive impact on household food
consumption in 7 day recall period
– substantive positive impact on young children’s
diets and nutrition outcomes
12. Treatment effects: Household level
• Substantive positive impact on household
food consumption in 7 day recall period
– Per capita food expenditures + 19% / 35MK pppd
– Daily acquisition of iron +16% / 3.92mg pppd
** p<0.05.
MKw/day
13. Treatment effects: Child level
• Substantive positive impact on young
children’s diets (DDS +15% & FVS +13%)
• And nutrition outcomes: weight-for-height z-
scores (+14%)
Children 36-72m Children 6-59m
***
***
**
*** p<0.01; ** p<0.05.
14. MVAC targeting
• Findings indicate that MVAC targeting criteria are
not good predictors of program participation
• Data on MVAC participation also suggests that
~20% of most food secure households (by
quintile) received transfers
• Positive effects on food expenditures and
children’s diets are concentrated among the
poorer households
• SCTP recipients appear to be excluded from
receiving MVAC food
18. Resilience and Coping: tracking the
ups and downs
• Ups and downs: major life events cause
shocks, as well as annual lean season shock
• All households face dietary shifts during the
lean season, decreasing amount of food or
shifting to less preferred (though not always
less nutrient-dense) foods
– Few manage lean season without negative coping
(diets, schooling, assets)
19. Social norms, targeting & favoritism
• Village heads play a significant role in determining who
received MVAC and other social support programs.
– Primarily through control over beneficiary selection, also
through decrees about sharing
• Villages vary in terms of perceptions of extent of
consultation in the targeting process
• Perceptions of the extent (and definition) of favoritism also
varies
• Some complaints about chief intervention, e.g., inclusion
errors (favoritism) and forced sharing, but frequently this is
viewed as unavoidable and part of village norms
• Beyond some complaints about chief intervention, the
primary complaint about targeting is “not enough benefit”
related to feeling that “everyone should get something”
20. Social norms and sharing
• About half the time sharing is dictated by the chief. When
it’s not, HHs decide to share on their own due to kinship
obligations, social pressure, and hope for reciprocation
(often described as a moral or humanitarian requirement).
• Some people complained about forced sharing and
community pressure to share. No one complained about
sharing with relatives => social requirement.
• Sharing is required even if targeted recipient is objectively
poorer than those with whom they share (relative wealth
does not seem to be considered in sharing decisions)
• Sharing norms related to cash transfers may be different
=> possibly less sharing, fear of tracking
21. Female MVAC recipients in Zomba in favor of forced sharing:
Interviewer: Did you think this sharing was beneficial?
Respondent 1: Yes, it was beneficial because it could be
you next year not in the program, and your friends
would help you. But the owners of the program say not
to share, this only happens in the village to just help
each other.
Interviewer: Alright. Was the sharing fair?
Respondent 2: I can say that on this side of the village
it was fair. Because this village has two tribes; those
from the chief and those not related to the chief…So if
they need 8 people then they will take 4 from each
side.
22. Female MVAC recipients in Zomba unhappy with targeting and
forced sharing:
I: So what criteria were they using to select beneficiaries?
R: They were choosing people who had nothing to eat…But at
times they recorded names of people who had food but those
who lacked food were also being skipped…As per village level
problems, the chief said, “This maize should be shared amongst
you. You will see how you can share.” So people could share two
[households] per bag…
Male non-recipients in Zomba describing the unfair targeting processes:
R: I should just give an example of a certain year, where I was
really touched [hurt] in my heart. I received a coupon that I
should be receiving maize. After three months I discovered that
somebody was using my coupon to get my maize. Somebody
with a higher position in the village. The person came and
offered me 12 kilograms, and I said all the people were
receiving 25 kilograms, why should I get 12? No I cannot accept
that, you will consider me the next time.
23. Conclusions: Effects of MVAC
• Quantitative data suggests that MVAC food
transfers are effective in protecting food
security and nutrition status during the lean
season.
–Evidence of protective impact on household
food consumption, and on dietary diversity (of
3-6yr olds) and weight for height z-scores of
young children (0-5yrs)
24. Conclusions: Targeting and Coverage
• Targeting and coverage of MVAC:
– Overall coverage of transfers was low in the survey
population (~15% of HH)
– Data on targeting criteria are not good predictors of
program participation
– Evidence suggests that ~20% of the most food secure
households received transfers
• Effects on food expenditures and diets are greater for
poorer households (better targeting=>more efficient)
• Data also shows that those receiving SCTP are
excluded from receiving MVAC, even though SCTP
recipients should be among the poorest and most
food insecure.
25. Conclusions: Sharing and Favoritism
• Insufficient public social support reinforces high
dependence on kinship networks and community
support
• Favoritism in community-based targeting seen as
unavoidable (villagers cannot contest/ it’s chief’s
prerogative)
• A more objective targeting system (e.g., UBR)
could improve targeting to some extent, but
pressure to reallocate once transfer arrive in the
village are likely to remain
26. Policy Implications
• Putting in place a targeting system separate from village politics
and norms would likely increase impact. But how?
• Most people face dietary shocks each year: suggesting that
other social support mechanisms (productive and protective)
must be scaled up to meet the current need.
• However, all program targeting mechanisms must consider
sharing & reallocation.
• Possible approaches:
– Increased village-level transparency about targeting criteria
– Parallel village-level institutions to assist/monitor targeting, distinct from
village governing structures could bypass village norms and politics
– Whole village targeting, when feasible
– Universal (vulnerable sub-group) targeting, as in Ntchisi, to all families
with under-fives, or to all elderly
• Educating villagers on good local governance practices, may slowly
begin to alter norms that yield exclusion and inclusion errors, but
weak social support system reinforces these practices.
27. Open Questions
• Next round of data collection ongoing
• Will examine any effects of MVAC on stunting.
• Will explore village head’s perceptions of
favoritism and their role in targeting.
• Are targeting errors due to sharing or
targeting process?
• Do sharing norms differ for different types of
programs/transfers? (e.g. cash)?
34. MVAC targeting
0.000.250.500.751.00
0.00 0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00
Inclusion of Non-Vulnerable (1 - Specificity)
Area under ROC curve = 0.4957
Households with Female, Child or Elderly Head or Orphans
Editor's Notes
Value minimum ~11,500 Kwacha/month (~20USD)
36% of households (at baseline in September) and 46% (during lean season) are estimated to be consuming less than 1800 calories per capita per day (individual equivalents based on consumption data)
19 and 16 percent increase from baseline, respectively.
35MK difference in per capita food consumption compared to control group / 3.92mg per capita increase in iron compared to control group
Percentage increases from baseline: DDS 15, FVS 13 and weight for height 14
Impact compared to control group: DDS .79 / FVS .86 / WFH .26
Low weight for height reflects recent undernutrition, very low is called wasting which reflects recent acute and sever undernutrition.
Dividing up the sample into 5 groups according to wellbeing, the bars depict the percent of the group receiving MVAC. Approx 23% in the poorest, least food secure group, and approx. 20% in the wealthiest most food secure group.
Disaggregating treatment effects by sub-groups is difficult as sample sizes in the treatment group are relatively small. However, when disaggregating the analysis of treatment effects by poverty status, the evidence suggests that the effects on per capita food expenditure and on child diet diversity are concentrated in households that are poor (table 7).
groups serve as a distinct parallel institution to that of the home, governed by constitutions and by-laws, that do enable them to push the boundaries of community gender norms, although both are embedded in the same community.
A ROC curve shows the ability of a diagnostic test to distinguish correctly between two states or conditions, in this case receiving MVAC or not receiving MVAC. To better capture the cumulative nature of MVAC targeting based on a number of criteria, we tested the extent to which these four criteria (whether separately or combined) predict MVAC participation.
Perfect prediction would show the ROC curve aligned to the upper left corner but this ROC curve shows that households WITH female heads, child heads, elderly heads, and/or orphans, are just as likely as those without those characteristics to receive MVAC.