The Social Psychology of Groups
Groups
 Groups can be any interaction involving more
 than one person
   Two friends are a group
   Families are a group
   Communities are a group
   Community organizations form when a group of
   people come together to act in a shared interest or
   common cause
 People are considered a group if they themselves
 are bound to one another in some way


                  Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                  Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Group Processes Perspective
 Social Psychologists
   study group behavior
   Have different theories and perspectives of how to
   approach the study of group behavior
     Group Procecesses is one of those perspectives

 The Group Processes perspectives explores how
 basic social processes operate in group contexts
   Sociologists study the processes that occur in
    groups
   Psychologists are interested in the groups
    themselves

                    Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                    Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Studying Processes
 Certain basic social processes tend to play out in
  group contexts, in both small and large groups
 The main processes studied in the group
  processes perspective include:
   Power
   Status
   Justice
   Legitimacy




                  Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                  Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Power
 According to Max Weber, power is the ability to
  control people, even over their objections
 Power exists in the context of our relationships
  with others
   To have power, there must be someone to have
    power over
   The types of groups in which power processes
    operate vary in size




                   Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                   Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Power
 Power does not come from the nature of the
 individual, but rather their position in a social
 hierarchy
   Although personal character likely plays a large role
    in one attaining a position of power, the power
    emanates from the position itself
   Examples include the President, business
    executives, and religious leaders
 The power found in social positions originates in
 social agreements pertaining to the position itself
   Formal rules
   Social norms
                   Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                   Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Power
 In most group contexts the sources of power are
 more subtle
   Examples include power relationships in marriages
   and friendship groups




                  Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                  Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Status
 Status is a person‘s standing in a group or society
  based on prestige and respect
 Status only exists in relation to others
 Status involves social comparisons in groups




                  Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                  Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Status
 Research consistently supports the idea that,
 when groups get together to complete tasks,
 status hierarchies form
   Those who are higher in the status hierarchy tend to
   talk more and get more credit for their contributions




                  Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                  Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Justice
 Justice is a group process that
 involves social comparisons of
 fairness or equity
   For example, if someone feels
    they are unfairly paid, it is based
    on a comparison to others in a
    group (whether it be a single
    department, company, or society
    as a whole)
   Justice perceptions are
    perceptions that members of a
    group are not being treated fairly

                    Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                    Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Justice
 Research has found that our justice perceptions
  tend to have a self-serving bias
 For example, in justice perceptions pertaining to
  wages:
   We compare ourselves to similar others, however
    we tend to seek comparisons that will give the
    highest value to the amount we think we should
    earn
   We are more likely to perceive an injustice if we feel
    underpaid than if we feel overpaid
   Therefore, we tend to apply different criteria to what
    is considered ‗fair‘ compensation
     Equal pay distribution
     Equitable pay distribution
                      Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                      Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Legitimacy
 The sense that an existing social arrangement is
  the way that things should be
 Social arrangements that are viewed as
  illegitimate can result in a number of undermining
  social outcomes
   Revolutions or political coups
   Protests
   Work stoppages or ‗slow downs‘
   Other forms of resistance




                   Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                   Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Group Structures
 The effect of a group on its members depends, in
 part, on how the group is configured
   Size
   Function
   Goals
   Et cetera
Group Size
 Small groups are defined as groups of two or more
 individuals, whose members are able to engage in
 direct, face-to-face interactions
   Usually between 2 and 20 people
   It is generally difficult for personal relationships to
    develop in groups of more than 20
   Larger groups are often ―broken up‖ into smaller groups
    to facilitate interpersonal relationships




                      Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                      Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Dyads and Triads
                                     Dyads
                                         Groups of two people
                                         Limited to a single relationship
                                     Triads
                                         Groups of three people
                                         The third person creates two
                                         additional relationships, compared to a
                                         dyad


 Adding a person to a group increases the number of
  relationships and decreases intimacy levels in the
  group
 The effects of group size on group members‘
  thoughts, feelings, and behaviors occur above and
  beyond the specific individuals involved in the group


                    Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                    Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Does the Size of a Group Matter?



     Dyad                         Triad                 Larger groups
-more intimate – share       - May have one            -less intimate
deepest secrets              dominant member
                                                       Group can survive if
-Requires full attention     - One person can          some members leave
and cooperation of both      temporarily withdraw
                                                       -Less intense & more
-Intense & unstable          -more stable than Dyads   stable (because one
(because if one member                                 member of the group
of the group leaves, the                               may leave and the group
group will cease to exist)                             will continue to exist)
Types of Groups
 Social psychologists distinguish between three
 broad types of groups, which are configured in
 different ways and serve different purposes
   Primary groups
   Secondary groups
   Reference groups




                 Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                 Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Primary Groups




 friends, family, military units, or peer
 groups
  People we are close to and interact with regularly
  Social groups that have face-to-face contact and
   emotional ties among their members
  Tend to serve more emotional needs
Community

Secondary groups                             organizatio
                                                 ns

  People we affiliate with to achieve similar goals or
   needs
  Co-workers or teammates
  Tend to serve more instrumental needs
Reference groups
  People we do not necessarily know personally, but
  look to as a source of standards and identity
   provide standards for judging our attitudes or behaviors


  There can be some overlap between Reference
  groups and primary or secondary groups




                    Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology:
                    Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
Group traits
 Group structure - In addition to size, groups also
  vary based on their function, goals, etc.
 They can also vary based on
   How long the group remains together
   The requirements of membership in the group
     You have specific ―requirements‖ for selecting your friends
     Going to the store makes you part of the group of people in
      the store. The only requirement is being there at the same
      time.
   The norms that exist in the group
     Norms are the rules that govern society‘s behaviors
Group vs. Collective Behavior




 Collective behavior refers to the action or behavior
  of people in groups or crowds
There are 3 Types of Actions
 Conforming
   Following prevailing norms
 Deviant
   behavior that violates the norms of a group
 Collective Behavior
   Neither conforming nor deviant
   Norms are absent or unclear or contradict each
   other
Collective Behavior
 Characterized by a group of people who
  bypass the usual norms governing their
  behavior and do something unusual
 It is a broad term and covers a wide range of
  acts
 Emerges in ―spontaneous‖ way




                           Henslin, J. (2008). Sociology: A Down-to-Earth Approach (9th Ed.).
                           Pearson, Boston
Types of Collective Behavior
 Social Movements
 Crowds
 Riots
 Rumors
 Panic
 Fads & Fashions
How is Collective Behavior
different from Group Behavior?
Collective Behavior      Group Behavior
 Limited & short-term    Remain together
  social interaction      longer
 No clear social
  boundaries, anyone      Membership is more
  can be a member of      selective or limited
  the collective            Eg., groups of friends,
                            colleagues,
 Generates weak and        organizations
 unconventional norms     Stronger and more
Underlying Causes of Collective Behavior

 • Collective behavior usually involves the
  underlying conditions in the larger society.
  • Strain - occurs when one aspect of society is no
    longer in balance with other aspects.
  • Relative Deprivation - a gap between one‘s
    desired level of need satisfaction and one‘s actual
    level of need satisfaction.
  • Grievances - discontent with the existing
    distribution of resources.
Social Movements
Overview
     Social Movements are a type of Collective
      Behavior
  Types of Actions
     Collective Behavior is a type of Action
1. Conforming
2. Deviant
3. Collective
   Behavior               Collective
                          Behaviors
                    1.   Social
                         Movements
                    2.   Crowds             Examples of Social
                    3.   Riots                   Movements
                    4.   Rumors        1. Labor movement
                    5.   Panic         2. Women‘s movement
                    6.   Fads &        3. Populist movement
                         Fashions      4. Civil rights movement
                                       5. Anti-war movement
                                       6. Welfare rights movement
                                       7. Gay rights movement
Social Movements
• Social Movements are a collective activity
 that expresses a high level of concern about
 some issues.
 • People who participate are those who feel strongly
   enough about the issue to act.
   • Persons involved engage in a
     variety of activities;
     • signing petitions
     • Boycotts
     • Marches
     • Rallies
     • campaigns
To Change or to Resist Change

  People engage in social movements either to
  bring about change or to resist change.
    A civil rights march vs. protesting a nuclear
    plant in your town
Development of a Social Movement
 For a movement to appear, people must perceive
  their discontent as the result of controllable forces
  external to themselves.
 Preconditions include:
   People must experience strain or deprivation.
   People must believe they have a right to satisfy
    their unmet needs.
   People must believe that satisfaction cannot be
    achieved through established channels.
Development of a Social Movement

• Ideology and Framing
   As individuals interact, an ideology must emerge that
    justifies collective activity.
   Ideologies are often developed by movement
    participants as the movement grows.
      Once social movement groups have identified and
       committed to ideological positions, they must
       articulate and present their ideas to others in order
       to win support, gain members, and gather
       resources.
Recruitment
 The development and continuing existence of
 any movement depends on recruitment —the
 process of attracting supporters.

   Recruitment depends on three catalysts; ideology,
   identity, and existing social networks.

   Sometimes entire categories of people are
   recruited all at once (members of a minority group,
   a religious order, or a work or professional group.)
                             or a
                         Community
                         Organization
Stages of Social Movements
                                                                      A community
                                                                      organization
                                                                      might be part
                                                                          of a
                                                                      ―movement.
                                                                       movement.


             A
        community
       organization
       might be the
         start of a
       movement.                                                                                                                                           You don’t
                                                                                                                                                            need to
                                                                                                                                                           know the
                                                                                                                                                           stages for
                                                                                                                                                           the exam

References: Graph from Wikipedia on social movements and is based on Blumer, Herbert G. 1969. "Collective Behavior." In Alfred McClung Lee, ed., Principles of Sociology. Third
Edition. New York: Barnes and Noble Books, pp. 65-121; Mauss, Armand L. 1975. Social Problems as Social Movements. Philadelphia: Lippincott; and Tilly, Charles. 1978. From
Mobilization to Revolution. Reading, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley, 1978.

Groups and Social Movements

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Groups  Groups canbe any interaction involving more than one person  Two friends are a group  Families are a group  Communities are a group  Community organizations form when a group of people come together to act in a shared interest or common cause  People are considered a group if they themselves are bound to one another in some way Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 3.
    Group Processes Perspective Social Psychologists  study group behavior  Have different theories and perspectives of how to approach the study of group behavior  Group Procecesses is one of those perspectives  The Group Processes perspectives explores how basic social processes operate in group contexts  Sociologists study the processes that occur in groups  Psychologists are interested in the groups themselves Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 4.
    Studying Processes  Certainbasic social processes tend to play out in group contexts, in both small and large groups  The main processes studied in the group processes perspective include:  Power  Status  Justice  Legitimacy Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 5.
    Power  According toMax Weber, power is the ability to control people, even over their objections  Power exists in the context of our relationships with others  To have power, there must be someone to have power over  The types of groups in which power processes operate vary in size Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 6.
    Power  Power doesnot come from the nature of the individual, but rather their position in a social hierarchy  Although personal character likely plays a large role in one attaining a position of power, the power emanates from the position itself  Examples include the President, business executives, and religious leaders  The power found in social positions originates in social agreements pertaining to the position itself  Formal rules  Social norms Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 7.
    Power  In mostgroup contexts the sources of power are more subtle  Examples include power relationships in marriages and friendship groups Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 8.
    Status  Status isa person‘s standing in a group or society based on prestige and respect  Status only exists in relation to others  Status involves social comparisons in groups Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 9.
    Status  Research consistentlysupports the idea that, when groups get together to complete tasks, status hierarchies form  Those who are higher in the status hierarchy tend to talk more and get more credit for their contributions Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 10.
    Justice  Justice isa group process that involves social comparisons of fairness or equity  For example, if someone feels they are unfairly paid, it is based on a comparison to others in a group (whether it be a single department, company, or society as a whole)  Justice perceptions are perceptions that members of a group are not being treated fairly Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 11.
    Justice  Research hasfound that our justice perceptions tend to have a self-serving bias  For example, in justice perceptions pertaining to wages:  We compare ourselves to similar others, however we tend to seek comparisons that will give the highest value to the amount we think we should earn  We are more likely to perceive an injustice if we feel underpaid than if we feel overpaid  Therefore, we tend to apply different criteria to what is considered ‗fair‘ compensation  Equal pay distribution  Equitable pay distribution Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 12.
    Legitimacy  The sensethat an existing social arrangement is the way that things should be  Social arrangements that are viewed as illegitimate can result in a number of undermining social outcomes  Revolutions or political coups  Protests  Work stoppages or ‗slow downs‘  Other forms of resistance Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 13.
    Group Structures  Theeffect of a group on its members depends, in part, on how the group is configured  Size  Function  Goals  Et cetera
  • 14.
    Group Size  Smallgroups are defined as groups of two or more individuals, whose members are able to engage in direct, face-to-face interactions  Usually between 2 and 20 people  It is generally difficult for personal relationships to develop in groups of more than 20  Larger groups are often ―broken up‖ into smaller groups to facilitate interpersonal relationships Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 15.
    Dyads and Triads Dyads Groups of two people Limited to a single relationship Triads Groups of three people The third person creates two additional relationships, compared to a dyad  Adding a person to a group increases the number of relationships and decreases intimacy levels in the group  The effects of group size on group members‘ thoughts, feelings, and behaviors occur above and beyond the specific individuals involved in the group Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 16.
    Does the Sizeof a Group Matter? Dyad Triad Larger groups -more intimate – share - May have one -less intimate deepest secrets dominant member Group can survive if -Requires full attention - One person can some members leave and cooperation of both temporarily withdraw -Less intense & more -Intense & unstable -more stable than Dyads stable (because one (because if one member member of the group of the group leaves, the may leave and the group group will cease to exist) will continue to exist)
  • 17.
    Types of Groups Social psychologists distinguish between three broad types of groups, which are configured in different ways and serve different purposes  Primary groups  Secondary groups  Reference groups Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 18.
    Primary Groups  friends,family, military units, or peer groups  People we are close to and interact with regularly  Social groups that have face-to-face contact and emotional ties among their members  Tend to serve more emotional needs
  • 19.
    Community Secondary groups organizatio ns  People we affiliate with to achieve similar goals or needs  Co-workers or teammates  Tend to serve more instrumental needs
  • 20.
    Reference groups People we do not necessarily know personally, but look to as a source of standards and identity  provide standards for judging our attitudes or behaviors  There can be some overlap between Reference groups and primary or secondary groups Rohall, David E., Milkie, Melissa A., and Lucas, Jeffrey W. (2010). Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (2nd Ed.)
  • 21.
    Group traits  Groupstructure - In addition to size, groups also vary based on their function, goals, etc.  They can also vary based on  How long the group remains together  The requirements of membership in the group  You have specific ―requirements‖ for selecting your friends  Going to the store makes you part of the group of people in the store. The only requirement is being there at the same time.  The norms that exist in the group  Norms are the rules that govern society‘s behaviors
  • 22.
    Group vs. CollectiveBehavior  Collective behavior refers to the action or behavior of people in groups or crowds
  • 23.
    There are 3Types of Actions  Conforming  Following prevailing norms  Deviant  behavior that violates the norms of a group  Collective Behavior  Neither conforming nor deviant  Norms are absent or unclear or contradict each other
  • 24.
    Collective Behavior  Characterizedby a group of people who bypass the usual norms governing their behavior and do something unusual  It is a broad term and covers a wide range of acts  Emerges in ―spontaneous‖ way Henslin, J. (2008). Sociology: A Down-to-Earth Approach (9th Ed.). Pearson, Boston
  • 25.
    Types of CollectiveBehavior  Social Movements  Crowds  Riots  Rumors  Panic  Fads & Fashions
  • 26.
    How is CollectiveBehavior different from Group Behavior? Collective Behavior Group Behavior  Limited & short-term  Remain together social interaction longer  No clear social boundaries, anyone  Membership is more can be a member of selective or limited the collective  Eg., groups of friends, colleagues,  Generates weak and organizations unconventional norms  Stronger and more
  • 27.
    Underlying Causes ofCollective Behavior • Collective behavior usually involves the underlying conditions in the larger society. • Strain - occurs when one aspect of society is no longer in balance with other aspects. • Relative Deprivation - a gap between one‘s desired level of need satisfaction and one‘s actual level of need satisfaction. • Grievances - discontent with the existing distribution of resources.
  • 28.
  • 29.
    Overview  Social Movements are a type of Collective Behavior Types of Actions  Collective Behavior is a type of Action 1. Conforming 2. Deviant 3. Collective Behavior Collective Behaviors 1. Social Movements 2. Crowds Examples of Social 3. Riots Movements 4. Rumors 1. Labor movement 5. Panic 2. Women‘s movement 6. Fads & 3. Populist movement Fashions 4. Civil rights movement 5. Anti-war movement 6. Welfare rights movement 7. Gay rights movement
  • 30.
    Social Movements • SocialMovements are a collective activity that expresses a high level of concern about some issues. • People who participate are those who feel strongly enough about the issue to act. • Persons involved engage in a variety of activities; • signing petitions • Boycotts • Marches • Rallies • campaigns
  • 31.
    To Change orto Resist Change  People engage in social movements either to bring about change or to resist change.  A civil rights march vs. protesting a nuclear plant in your town
  • 32.
    Development of aSocial Movement  For a movement to appear, people must perceive their discontent as the result of controllable forces external to themselves.  Preconditions include:  People must experience strain or deprivation.  People must believe they have a right to satisfy their unmet needs.  People must believe that satisfaction cannot be achieved through established channels.
  • 33.
    Development of aSocial Movement • Ideology and Framing  As individuals interact, an ideology must emerge that justifies collective activity.  Ideologies are often developed by movement participants as the movement grows.  Once social movement groups have identified and committed to ideological positions, they must articulate and present their ideas to others in order to win support, gain members, and gather resources.
  • 34.
    Recruitment  The developmentand continuing existence of any movement depends on recruitment —the process of attracting supporters.  Recruitment depends on three catalysts; ideology, identity, and existing social networks.  Sometimes entire categories of people are recruited all at once (members of a minority group, a religious order, or a work or professional group.) or a Community Organization
  • 35.
    Stages of SocialMovements A community organization might be part of a ―movement. movement. A community organization might be the start of a movement. You don’t need to know the stages for the exam References: Graph from Wikipedia on social movements and is based on Blumer, Herbert G. 1969. "Collective Behavior." In Alfred McClung Lee, ed., Principles of Sociology. Third Edition. New York: Barnes and Noble Books, pp. 65-121; Mauss, Armand L. 1975. Social Problems as Social Movements. Philadelphia: Lippincott; and Tilly, Charles. 1978. From Mobilization to Revolution. Reading, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley, 1978.

Editor's Notes

  • #17 Simmel
  • #19 What are some other examples of Primary groups?What groups do you belong to?Are they open to anyone?Are there specific membership requirements? Initiations?