Food and Nutrition Security in Africa seminar in Helsinki 16 June 2014, Agricultural marketing and the use of mobile phones: Results from Ghana and Uganda, Nicholas Minot, IFPRI
Similar to Food and Nutrition Security in Africa, Agricultural marketing and the use of mobile phones: Results from Ghana and Uganda, Nicholas Minot (20)
Engler and Prantl system of classification in plant taxonomy
Food and Nutrition Security in Africa, Agricultural marketing and the use of mobile phones: Results from Ghana and Uganda, Nicholas Minot
1. INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE
Agricultural marketing and the use of
mobile phones: Results from Ghana and
Uganda
Nicholas Minot
Senior Research Fellow, IFPRI
Presented at the FoodAfrica Mid-term Conference
University of Helsinki, Helsinki, 16 June 2014
2. 2
Overview of WP6 “ICT and market access”
Overall objective: Measure the impact of using SMS to improve access
to agricultural market information and other agricultural information
Methods
Baseline surveys
• Ghana: 1290 households in northern Ghana
• Uganda: 1440 households in Western, Central, and Eastern regions
Interventions
• Ghana: Esoko provides agricultural market information, weather info, and
extension info via SMS to random sub-sample of interviewed farmers
• Uganda: FIT-Uganda provides agricultural market info, weather, and extension
info via SMS to random sub-sample of surveyed farmers
Endline surveys
• Ghana: Scheduled for 2014
• Uganda: Scheduled for early 2015
3. 3
Methods: Collaborating institutions
MTT Economics branch
• Participation in all phases, particularly in planning, analysis, and interpretation
• Gender analysis of household survey data
ICRAF
• Assistance in dissemination strategy
• WP7 Innovative extension approaches
ISSER (Ghana)
• Implementation of household surveys in Ghana
Esoko (Ghana)
• Provision of agricultural price information via SMS to selected beneficiaries
FIT-Uganda
• Provision of agricultural price information to selected beneficiaries
4. 4
Comparison
Ghana Uganda
Population 25 million 36 million
Share urban 48% 13%
GNI per capita US$ 1,410 US$ 510
Life expectancy 64 years 54 years
Agricultural exports Cocoa, cashew nut Coffee, tea
Staple foods Cassava, maize, yams Plantains, maize, cassava,
sweet potatoes
Data collection Oct-Dec 2011 Dec 2012-Feb 2013
Regional coverage All districts in northern
half
8 districts in west, central,
and eastern
Nbr. of villages 130 144
Nbr. of households 1290 1440
5. 5
Agricultural marketing
Who do farmers sell their crops to?
• In both countries, close
to 90% of crop sale
transactions are to
traders
• Most of remainder are
to other farmers and
consumers
• Negligible sales via
cooperatives or directly
to processors,
exporters, or
supermarkets
91 87
5 11
4 2
0 %
20 %
40 %
60 %
80 %
100 %
Ghana Uganda
Type of buyer
Other
Consumer
Trader
6. 6
Agricultural marketing
Where do farmers sell their crops?
• In Uganda, 84% of sales
take place on farm and
at markets (usually in
same village)
• In Ghana, just 25% take
place on farm, 74%
take place in market
(usually outside village)
• May reflect lower
population density in
northern Ghana and/or
smaller mkt surplus
25
84
26
9
48
4
0 %
20 %
40 %
60 %
80 %
100 %
Ghana Uganda
Location of crop sale
Other
Market
elsewhere
Market in
village
Farm
7. 7
Agricultural marketing
What is the role of farmer organizations?
• In both countries,
about 20% are
members of some type
of farmer organization
and about 10% are ag
coop members
• In both countries, less
than 8% of farms have
ever sold through a
cooperative or farmer
organization
2
4
4
7
10
8
19
22
0 10 20 30
Uganda
Ghana
Role of agricultural cooperatives
Member of coop
or farm
organization
Member of ag
coop
Ever sold through
a coop/FO
Sold through a
coop/FO in past
year
8. 8
Agricultural marketing
Most important crops in sales
• In northern Ghana,
yams, groundnuts,
and maize are most
important in terms of
crop revenue
• In Uganda, maize,
coffee, and beans are
most important
• Most “cash crops” are
food crops
• Large share of
“other”
17
39
10
14
19
19
45
37
0 %
10 %
20 %
30 %
40 %
50 %
60 %
70 %
80 %
90 %
100 %
Ghana Uganda
Percent of households by most
important crop in sales
Other
Groundnut
Yams
Coffee
Beans
Maize
9. 9
Agricultural marketing
How much competition?
• In Uganda, 83% of
respondents said they
had a choice of 2 or
more buyers for their
main commercial
crop
• In Ghana, 72% had 2
or more buyers
20
34
16
10
47
29
17
28
0 % 50 % 100 %
Uganda
Ghana
Percentage of households by number of
buyers of main commercialized crop
More than 10
6-10 buyers
2-5 buyers
Just one buyer
10. 1
Agricultural marketing
Reason for selecting buyer
• In both countries,
+85% of respondent
choose buyer by best
price or quick payment
• Debt obligation or
only-one-buyer is the
reason for <8%
• Competition among
traders for main crop
• There may be less
competition for other
crops
68
55
19
30
7
3
3
5
0 % 50 % 100 %
Uganda
Ghana
Percent of household by reason for
selecting buyer
Best price
Immediate
payment
Location
Obligation
Only one
buyer
Other
11. 1
Agricultural marketing
What percentage of crops do farmers sell?
• Fewer farmers with no
sales in Uganda (14%)
than northern Ghana
(28%)
• Median is 38% in
Uganda and 34% in
Ghana
• No clear distinction
between “subsistence”
and “commercial”
farmers; full range
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Cropssalesasapercentageof
valueofcropproduction
Percentage of households
Distribution of farms by share of
production that is sold
Uganda
Ghana
12. 1
Use of mobile phones
Share of farm households owning mobile phones
• Mobile phones are
more widely owned
in Uganda (72%) than
northern Ghana
(62%)
• Although Ghana is a
higher-income
country, northern
Ghana is the poorest
region of the country
72
62
0 20 40 60 80 100
Uganda
Ghana
Percentage of households owning
a mobile phone
13. 1
Use of mobile phones
Share of farm households owning mobile phones
• Female-headed
farmers are less likely
to own a mobile
phone in both
countries
• Also, medium- and
large-scale farmers
are more likely to
own a mobile phone
than small farmers
0 20 40 60 80
Uganda
Ghana
Percentage of households owning
a mobile phone
Female
Male
14. Use of mobile phones
Correlates of mobile phone ownership
• Households owning
mobile phones tend
to have more
members, higher
income, and more
education
• Sex of head of
household is not
significant after
controlling for other
factors
Probit model
Dependent variable = mobile
ownership (1=yes, 0=no)
Ghana Uganda
Household size +++ +++
Farm size
Log of per capita income ++ +++
Female headed household
Age of head of household - - -
Education of head + +++
Head can read
Head can write
15. Use of mobile phones
How are mobile phones used?
• In both countries, no
more than half of
phone owners have
ever sent an SMS text
message
• Roughly one quarter
of owners use their
phone to get ag
market information 28
23
50
42
51
42
0 20 40 60
Uganda
Ghana
Use of mobile phones
(% of households that own a phone)
Know how to
use SMS
Have sent an
SMS
Use phone for
ag market info
16. Use of mobile phones
Do farmers feel well-informed about prices?
• In both countries,
less than half of
farmers fell well
informed about
prices & markets
• Small farmers feel
less informed than
medium or larger
farmers
36
54
27
39
26
34
34
47
0 50 100
Uganda
Ghana
Perception of being well-informed
about prices by farm-size category
(% of households)
Overall
Very small
farms
Small farms
Medium
farms
Large farms
17. Summary
Almost all crop sales are to traders and consumers
• Few farmers sell directly to processors, exporters, or supermarkets
Location of sale varies by country and/or region
• Ugandan farmers sell on farm, while those in northern Ghana sell at markets
Coops & farmer organizations play very minor roles in marketing
• Less than 8% of farmers have ever sold crops through a coop/farmer organization
Markets are more competitive than sometimes portrayed
• More than two-thirds know of at least two buyers willing to buy main crop
• Farmers choose buyer based on best price & terms, not obligation or monopsony
No easy distinction between “subsistence” and “commercial” farmers
• Whole spectrum of farmers with intermediate sales
• Sale of food crops more important than sale of “cash” crops
Most farm households own mobile phones
• More in Uganda than northern Ghana; more among larger, higher-income, and
better educated households
.. but less than one-third of owners get market info by phone
• Provision of agricultural price information to selected beneficiaries
… and most farmers do not feel well-informed about crop prices
• particularly small-scale farmers
18. 1
Conclusions
Ghana and Uganda offer apparently favorable conditions for mobile
phones to improve market information:
• Large majority of farmers have crop sales
• Most farmers sell to traders and have some choice of buyer
• Competition means that negotiation with new information is possible
• Most farmers already have mobile phones
• But few farmers use their phones to get prices and market info
• And less than half of farmers feel well-informed about prices and markets
But only empirical analysis can confirm that market information
delivered via SMS to mobile phones will be useful to farmers