Feed in value chains




               Shirley Tarawali
FAP Symposium on Feed in Smallholder Systems
                                               1
  Luang Prabang, Laos, 18-19 November 2010
Key issue
Past feed research “supply focused”
Feed in VC context – different approach:
  – Demand for livestock commodity – feed as an
    element of value chain
  – Feed value chains intersecting with livestock
    (?and crop) commodity value chains




                                                2
We know: its complex


Inputs and                                                  Consumers
                Production     Processing    Marketing
  services


                                Biomass
             Feed
                       Breed

              Health
                                            Land
                                                    Water

                                              GhG
                        Number of
                        animals
                                                                  3
We know: context and livestock
          commodity matter
Crop livestock systems – majority of livestock
 commodities in developing countries
Production efficiency....shift from feed for
 maintenance to productivity




                                           4
Priority value chains           Small ruminants:
-Market opportunities            Ethiopia, Mali
-Opportunities for engagement
-Constraints- resolvable
-Momentum/experience




          Dairy: Nicaragua,                    Pigs: Vietnam,
           Tanzania, India
                                                  Uganda
We know: changing commodity
              demand influences feed dimensions
Feed source                                  Feed type
                             Own farm
                                             Natural grazing
                                             Planted pastures
                             Community       Other planted forages
                                             Crop residues
                             Market          Crop by products
                                             Other by products
                                             Grains
                             Policy          Roots and tubers
                                             Mineral etc supplements
                                             Balanced concentrates



                 Opportunities to increase feed:
         Produce more --- Utilize better --- Import
                                                                 6
South Asia rain fed dairy                     Source of feed (%DM)
                                                  Natural grazing
                                                  Planted pastures
                                                  Planted forages
                                                  Crop residues
                                                  Crop by-products
                                                  Other by-products
                                                  Grains
                                                  Roots & tubers
                                                  Mineral/vit suppl
                   2010                           Balanced concentrates




                                       2030
                            Own farm
                   Community
             Market

                                                                    7
Gaps
How to prioritise and target feed based
 investments in R4D in commodity value
 chains?
                       Institutions and
                            policies




        Technologies                  Innovation and
                                        knowledge
                                                       8

Feed in value chains

  • 1.
    Feed in valuechains Shirley Tarawali FAP Symposium on Feed in Smallholder Systems 1 Luang Prabang, Laos, 18-19 November 2010
  • 2.
    Key issue Past feedresearch “supply focused” Feed in VC context – different approach: – Demand for livestock commodity – feed as an element of value chain – Feed value chains intersecting with livestock (?and crop) commodity value chains 2
  • 3.
    We know: itscomplex Inputs and Consumers Production Processing Marketing services Biomass Feed Breed Health Land Water GhG Number of animals 3
  • 4.
    We know: contextand livestock commodity matter Crop livestock systems – majority of livestock commodities in developing countries Production efficiency....shift from feed for maintenance to productivity 4
  • 5.
    Priority value chains Small ruminants: -Market opportunities Ethiopia, Mali -Opportunities for engagement -Constraints- resolvable -Momentum/experience Dairy: Nicaragua, Pigs: Vietnam, Tanzania, India Uganda
  • 6.
    We know: changingcommodity demand influences feed dimensions Feed source Feed type Own farm Natural grazing Planted pastures Community Other planted forages Crop residues Market Crop by products Other by products Grains Policy Roots and tubers Mineral etc supplements Balanced concentrates Opportunities to increase feed: Produce more --- Utilize better --- Import 6
  • 7.
    South Asia rainfed dairy Source of feed (%DM) Natural grazing Planted pastures Planted forages Crop residues Crop by-products Other by-products Grains Roots & tubers Mineral/vit suppl 2010 Balanced concentrates 2030 Own farm Community Market 7
  • 8.
    Gaps How to prioritiseand target feed based investments in R4D in commodity value chains? Institutions and policies Technologies Innovation and knowledge 8

Editor's Notes

  • #4 Some more bubbles to illustrate: Feed is a key component of productivity which determines market participation for smallholders. But there are complex interactions and trade offs – at the biophysical level with the environment (and relationship of this to for example numbers of animals required to address demand), feed demand impacts on land and water, interactions with breed and health of animals, and with competing demands for biomass. Likewise, beyond this, the implications of meeting feed demand require service and knowledge inputs, and may have equity implications. Policies and regulations can impact feed availability and the ability of smallholders to access and use feed. Beyond such issues are a complex set of drivers......
  • #7 These issues can be translated into dimensions that relate to institutions and policies (including changing public and private sector roles); knowledge and innovation; as well as technologies themselves
  • #8 Diagram to illustrate impacts of intensification on aspects of previous slide......... With intensification:Least market oriented:All feeds sourced at household levelMost market oriented:Feed sourced off farmConsiderable impact of policies; public/private sector interactionsFeeds less variable/diverse